Science topics: Methodology
Science method

Methodology - Science method

Methodology are emergent methodologies in soft and hard sciences
Questions related to Methodology
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
5 answers
Hi everyone...my question is that ...
How to put one variable as dependent variable in Johansen cointegration test, if all variables in the model can be endogenous. And how to identify the cointegrating relationship among them, because if I have (for example) 5 variables in the model and I am putting each variable as a dependent variable then each will give a different cointegrating relationship..so how to identify the exact relationship among these 5 variables and how to select the dependent variable.
Relevant answer
Answer
Using the Johansen Cointegration Test to Interpret the Results:
1. The EViews output contains two statistics: the Trace Statistic and the Max-Eigen Statistic.
2. The rejection criterion is set at 0.05.
3. An asterisk (*) denotes rejection of the null hypothesis.
4. If the probability value is less than or equal to 0.05, reject the null hypothesis.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
37 answers
I believe that I have found an elementary proof for Fermat's Last Theorem , and it is in the process of submitting to journal for publication.Hence I can't provide my proof completely now. However , I can outline my methodology in this thread.
Relevant answer
My best wishes Dear Dr. P. N. Seetharaman !....I wish the best in your progress!
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
13 answers
Hello,
What do you consider to be the best methodological handbooks (covering both quali & quanti) for beginning researchers in the humanities and social sciences?
The views of doctoral students are particularly welcome :)
Many thanks in advance for your help!
Relevant answer
Answer
Isabelle Skakni A good rule of thumb to follow when selecting whether to employ qualitative or quantitative data is: quantitative analysis is preferable if you want to confirm or test something (a theory or hypothesis) and If you want to understand anything, use qualitative research (concepts, thoughts, experiences)
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
37 answers
The original meaning of the word "theory" comes close to "view", or even "world view". As such it has already been used by the ancient Greek philosophers, e.g. Aristoteles or Plato. Over the centuries, its meaning has become more and more precise, culminating in a well-defined logical notion of the correspondence between a part of the (outer) real world and the (inner) symbolic world we use to think about or describe it.
In more popular parlance, Wikipedia summarizes it in the statement: "A theory is a rational type of abstract thinking about a phenomenon or the results of such thinking." *) Of course, what is meant with "phenomenon" (also an ancient Greek word) is typically left unspecified: it may be a very specific class of objects or events, or it may be something as big as our universe (as in "cosmological theory").
Over the years, I have observed a gradual inflation of the technical term "theory" as defined and used in scientific methodology. The (dualistic) notion of a correspondence between the real world on the one hand and the media we use to reflect about the latter (thought, language, ...) on the other hand seems to have been lost during the rise of empirical research with its strong emphasis on "phenomena" instead of "thoughts".
The result is that the technical term "theory" appears to have also lost its well-defined meaning of a bridge between our outer world "as we observe it" and our inner world "as we reason about it". For instance:
  • In a recent paper (2021), the author (a well-known expert in a subfield of social science) promises to offer a theory (sic!) of a particular "phenomenon" in his subfield. As I am also much interested in the kind of phenomena he is doing research about, I of course hoped to find - at least - a worked-out theoretical model of those phenomena.
  • Far out! Besides a simple flow-chart of (some of) the processes involved, what he presented was a large collection of more or less confirmed "empirical facts" together with simple "interpretations" (mostly re-wordings) and pointers to possible or plausible relationships.
  • I didn't find any sign of the hallmarks of a good theory: a worked-out theoretical model of those phenomena, on the basis of which I (or someone else) could reason about those phenomena, look for inconsistencies between assumptions and facts, derive crucial hypothesis to be tested, etc.: !
My questions to you:
  • What are your experiences with this type of inflated use of the word "theory" in scientific research?
  • Do you believe that there is a difference in this respect between social sciences and natural sciences?
  • How can we bring the "empirical approach" and the "theoretical approach" together, again?
________________________________________
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Paul Hubert Vossen My area of ​​work is the philosophy of science, but I am a sociologist, so I am familiar with arguments from both disciplinary fields. It is common in the social sciences to use the word "phenomenon" to refer to a social, public and objective fact (it is a common way of referring to a social fact, not necessarily strange) and not to anything mental.
That is, unlike philosophy, where "phenomenon" is often used to refer to something given or that occurs in consciousness, with more or less Kantian meanings, social scientists use the word to refer to a characteristic of social reality, which they consider to be objective and self-existent (independently of any human mind); that is to say, "phenomenon" is not a word that replaces "thought", but rather a "social fact".
On the other hand, while I agree that in the social sciences there are vagueness, imprecision, neologisms and inconsistencies, it seems that in their claim for a model is the idea that the theories of the social sciences should be similar to those of the natural sciences. This position has been called "naturalism" and together with the thesis that social and natural sciences must use the same methods (called "methodological monism") are part of a long and deep epistemological debate about the demarcation between the two types of scientific disciplines and about the scientific status of the social sciences.
In the social sciences, too, the word theory is used as a synonym for hypothesis or hypothesis accepted as knowledge, about a fact or a type of fact, but although this does not occur in physics, it also happens in the biological sciences: for example, theories about why the dinosaurs or the Mayan civilization became extinct, or why elephants periodically approach their cemeteries, which are very far from the conceptions that consider them as interpreted calculations.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
looking for new methodologies
Relevant answer
Answer
Odilbek Mamatqosimov It's the Quadrant Method - For stationary animals like plants, or very small and slow-moving organisms, plots called quadrats can be used to estimate population size and density. Within the habitat, each quadrat marks off an area of the same size—typically a square area.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
13 answers
A mere superficial perusal of the research results can be potentially misleading in the context of the ever-growing research complexities. There is a pressing need of an enhanced transparency alongside lucidity in the research findings representation.
Relevant answer
Answer
A pandemic perspective to the debate by Dr Pranav Ish is indeed noteworthy.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
18 answers
Hi,
Yesterday, I received a response of one mine paper with the concept of "major revisions". The paper is about engineering education and m-learning (a methodology). There are 20 points that the reviewers indicate me, some of them are basically impossible to address because are focused on the methodology that was made. Even for the paper that is a methodology, they indicate me to make a review as a "systematic literature review" employing PRISMA criteria and stuff like that.
PD: The paper was presented of a Q1 journal of education (Springer).
So, my questions are: How to deal with major revisions in a paper?, How to address the comments of the reviewers?, and How to make the revisions of the paper consistenly?
Thanks in advance for your help.
Best regards,
Jonathan
Relevant answer
Answer
Try to address those comments as much as possible. For the ones that you think are impossible, you may provide rebuttal to the editor explaining your opinion.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
Hi everyone,
I am experiencing trouble on measuring correlation on my dissertation study.
In two questions, I have asked my respondents "How many times have you been to ..." and "How familiar are you with the music at ...".
I am trying to establish the relationship between those who have frequented a store most often and if they are the same people who expressed their high familiarity with the music. They are the same group of respondents. Will a one-sample T test on SPSS be sufficient to test this relationship?
Hope to get all of your expertise on this!!
Relevant answer
Answer
Assuming your two questions yield categorical data on the same respondents, you could go for Pearson Chi-Square. You might check out the following for insights into carrying out Pearson Chi-Square on SPSS.
Lund Research Ltd. (2018). Chi-Square test for association using SPSS statistics. SPSS Statistics Tutorials and Statistical Guides | Laerd Statistics. https://statistics.laerd.com/spss-tutorials/chi-square-test-for-association-using-spss-statistics.php
Good luck,
  • asked a question related to Methodology
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
Hello everybody
my question is a methodological one: I would like to evaluate CXCL8 at intracellular levels. I have already evaluated CXCL8 levels in cells culture supernatants after 24 hours culture. My purpose is to understand if in those cells where CXCL8 is not secrete, it is maybe stored ad a protein at intracellular levels, thus if CXCL8mRNA is translated to a protein but not secreted in cell culture supernatant. I have no possibility to perform western blot, is it possible to assay it by ELISA? Could anyone suggest me the correct methodological approach?
Thankyou very much
Francesca
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with Fatemeh Khozaei
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
Any research projects or literature that you know about how to improve rural infrastructure in West Africa?
I'm looking for methodologies and case studies for interventions around, housing, WaSH, energy inclusion, Water Harvesting, Food Security, etc.
Have you designed/implemented/evaluated any projects using participatory methodologies with the communities? do you have any concrete examples?
Relevant answer
Answer
Water Security is one of the most (if not the most) nagging issues in water-scarce countries. Examples for sustainable development in the arid region are given in the following discussions:
(2) Adaptation and Resilience to Climate Change: "Temporal Paradox" versus "Chronology Protection Conjecture". (researchgate.net)
(2) On Water Scarcity Indicators (researchgate.net)
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
6 answers
I am conducting a methodological systematic review with will include both partial and full economic evaluations involving a certain treatment.
A number of checklists have been developed to guide the methodological quality assessment of economic evaluation studies, mostly full economic evaluation studies. For partial economic evaluations, I only found guidance to critically assess cost of illness studies and budget impact analysis. Do you know any tool, checklist or guideline to assess the methodological quality of cost analysis studies (comparing only the costs of two alternatives)?
Relevant answer
Answer
Try Cochrane - they have check lists for most systematic reviews.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
72 answers
Qualitative research has its rigor and method. It is a valid methodological strategy, which means that research can be carried out using qualitative methodology. However, it is not always given the recognition it deserves. Why?
Relevant answer
Answer
I think that it is qualitative or quantitative, the important thing is that the investigation lives. I don't know about other cases, but for me, it's super important, I can't conceive of my day without trying to learn a little more
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
5 answers
Dear research community,
i am looking for methodological papers (or a scientific approach) or best practice paper that utilize the same methodology. Due to page limitations we are not able to conduct a literature review. However, our intent is to rely on well-known journal only papers in our discipline and analyze them for a specific aspect, thus conducting only a backward search based on these papers to create a body of literature. By doing so, we want to reach a sufficient rigour without conducting and documenting a completely new literature review.
I am not sure if a metastudy is something like what we want to do but a metastudy is rather abour a quantitative analysis of the literature.
If our approach is realistic and applicable i would be happy for every suggestion how to do it. Any methodological paper on such an approach or any best practice paper would help.
Thank you a lot in advance.
BR
Dimitri
Relevant answer
Answer
yes sure, easy to find so many
just type your title and search especially for surveys
google scholar will help you to easily find and access.
All the best
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
2 answers
How can I find the Matlab file along with the data of this research
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
Methodology about the agriculture extension methods and strategies its for my thesis proposal.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello Mofida,
Selecting the appropriate agriculture extension method will provide you with an idea of whether to choose quantitative, qualitative, or mixed-method research. For instance, if it is a group approach, mixed-method would be appropriate.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
9 answers
Good day
I am busy with my methodology Chapter for my doctoral thesis. There are quite a lot of contradictions and different interpretations of the concepts constructivism, constructionism and social constructionism and other combinations.
I have read many articles and book chapters already about these concepts, but still struggles to understand the differences. To name a few: Ackermann (2001), Crotty (1998), Gergen, Guba and Lincoln (1994) and Schwandt (1998; 2000).
Can someone point me in the right direction please?
Regards
Johann Pieterse
Relevant answer
Answer
While social constructionism focuses on the objects produced by a group's social interactions, social constructivism focuses on an individual's learning as a result of his or her interactions in a group.
The major distinction between the two theories is the emphasis that each places on experiences and social interactions. The emphasis in constructivism is on personal experiences in creating knowledge, but in social constructivism the emphasis is on social interactions and culture.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
10 answers
I have a question about normalisation of results on composite indicator.
I am not sure is it methodologically sound to normalise result on a composite indicator?
The situation is as follows.
I have a composite indicator of civic competence and for getting composite score different scales with respective weighting are used.
My dilemma is this: should every scale be normalised and then composite indicator score calculated or it is alright to normalise only results on composite indicator?
Thanks everyone in advance
Ivan
Relevant answer
Answer
Creating a z score will result in a mean of zero and a SD of 1, but skewness will still be there and one skewed input variable (or indeed one with outliers) can have a big effect on the composite variable. You may be happy with this; if not then you could do a transformation that produces a more symmetric distribution and has mean of zero and SD of 1 - see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rankit and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normal_probability_plot
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
I am doing a reliability analysis of a motivation questionnaire on a sample of athletes in different sports. I do the reliability analysis in order to check the reliability of the translation of the questionnaire into another language.
Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
The most common way to assess reliability with a single point in time is with coefficient alpha.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
6 answers
Good Day!
I am now conducting a quantitative study utilizing a descriptive correlational methodology. I am also employing an Independent Variable and Dependent Variable with a Moderating Variable as the third variable. Can you assist me to determine what statistical treatment is essential to investigate the correlation of the IV towards the DV with the intervention of the MV?
Thank you very much!
Relevant answer
Answer
As mentioned by David L Morgan , the moderated effect can be tested in a regression model by including a product term (moderator*IV) in the regression equation. This is called moderated regression analysis.
Mathematically, a moderated regression equation for one IV and one moderator variable looks like this:
Y = b0 + b1*X + b2*Z + b3*X*Z + error
where Y = dependent variable, X = independent variable, Z = moderator variable, and b0, b1, b2, and b3 indicate constant regression coefficients. In order to test for moderation, you multiply the X and Z variables to obtain a product term (X*Z), for example, by using the COMPUTE command in SPSS. The product term X*Z gets added to your model as an additional "predictor." The moderator Z can be binary (a 0-1 coded dummy variable) or continuous (metrical/interval scale). In case of continuous X and Z, it is often useful to center X and Z before computing the product term to facilitate the interpretation of the results (in particular when the uncentered X and Z have no meaningful zero points).
The coefficient b3 for the interaction (product) term allows you to examine whether there is an interaction (moderator) effect. The null hypothesis H0 for the interaction effect is H0: b3 = 0. That is, when b3 = 0 in the population, there is no moderation (interaction) effect. When b3 is significantly different from zero, this null hypothesis can be rejected.
For details, see Aiken and West (1991):
Aiken, L. S., & West, S. G. (1991). Multiple regression: Testing and interpreting interactions. Sage Publications, Inc.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
13 answers
Dear all,
I would like to discuss with you your experiences with conducting MGCFA with ordinal variables with WLSMV estimator in Mplus. I came across a problem in my analyzes and I do not know how to solve it.
If I test all levels of equivalence together with the command MODEL = CONFIGURAL METRIC SCALAR, I will get different results than if I test each level separately. Does anyone have experience with this? The same procedure with continuous variables and ML estimator works.
Thank you very much for your answers and discussion.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Radka Hanzlová,
In addition to the helpful comments from Christian and Rainer, I would recommend that you:
For discussions around measurement invariance with ordered-categorigcal variables using WLSMV have a look at:
1. Millsap et al., 2004. Assessing factorial invariance in ordered-categorical measures
2. Liu et al., 2017. Testing measurement invariance in longitudinal data with ordered-categorical measures
For discussions around empty response options (zero cells) have a look at:
1. Rutkowski et al., 2019. Collapsing categorical variables and measurement invariance.
2. Savalei, Victoria 2011. What to do about zero frequency cells when estimating polychoric correlations.
Hope this helps!
Best,
Darun
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
1 answer
Dear members,
As a part of cognitive research, i am looking for an animal model to test attention and focus either through phenotypic or objective assessment (direct assessment).
Through much of lit survey I am unable find direct methodology.
Suggestions in this regard are highly helpful to my research.
Relevant answer
Dear Nehru Sai suresh Chalichem
Open field is a good apparatus for mice to test attention, learning and other similar parameters. I add some example.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
6 answers
...and that a correlation can't be ruled out (but obviously would have to be studied again with a larger sample size, ironing out any other methodological constraints?)
Thank you very much for any thoughts, I appreciate it!
Relevant answer
Answer
Exactly rightly responded. But please keep in mind , low correlation speaks of irrelevance of hypothesis , the identified factors do not influence each other....
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
1 answer
Is ammonium nitrate compatible with HTPB? How to evolve a better curing methodology for this system?
Relevant answer
Answer
On thermal decomposition, frequently used oxidizers such as AP and AN yield significant oxygen concentrations. Hydrocarbon-based polymers such as HTPB, CTPB, and PBAN are utilized as fuel. To get a high specific impulse, large oxidizer concentrations are often utilized.
Best Regards
Dr. Fatemeh Khozaei
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
2 answers
Hi, are there some ideas for research (especially data and methodology) considering an investigation of the relationship between ESG information about company and its management quality? Thanks in advance!
Relevant answer
Answer
ESG, or Environmental, Social, and Governance, is a program that identifies and measures the effect of an organization's policies and processes linked to environmental sustainability and social standards.
ESG concerns and related megatrends, such as natural resource depletion (e.g., drinkable water shortage) and shifting demographics (e.g., the economic ascent of pro-sustainability millennials), are important to investment risk and return across asset classes.
Best Regards
Dr. Fatemeh Khozaei
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
Hello everyone,
I am in the third year of Computer Science and my project is about social robots, I am doing the proposal, ethics form, and literature review about the social robot. The question above is in the ethics form.
Relevant answer
Answer
Methods used in the study should be standard and validated. The methods should be replicated in other studies too and produce almost similar results
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
5 answers
For ArcGIS users, if I'm creating a polygon from adjacent features, the polygon is not created unless the features are 100% adjacent. Is there a methodology to identify where is the gap location between them?
Relevant answer
Answer
السلام عليكم ست امال
نحب نستفيد عن كيفية استخراج الفجوه من خلال الاجابات المضافه
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
I am a master degree student in engineering management, this survey is conducted to see what methodologies are commonly used by project managers in managing projects in our digital age.
I would ask you to fill this form to help me in my study.
Thanks in advance
Relevant answer
Answer
The overarching goal of project management technique is to standardize, structure, and organize work practices. This helps to concentrate all initiatives in the same direction and enables us to replicate successful elements while learning from failures, resulting in a continual improvement process.
Good Luck, All the Best.
Best Regards
Dr. Fatemeh Khozaei
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
1 answer
I found this L18-John array in SAS-JMP software which is not a typical Taguchi array.
Anyone know where this L18-John methodology come from ? any reference literature ?
Thanks a lot
Run1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Run2 1 1 2 2 3 2 2 2
Run3 1 1 3 3 2 3 3 3
Run4 1 2 1 2 2 2 3 1
Run5 1 2 2 3 1 3 1 2
Run6 1 2 3 1 3 1 2 3
Run7 1 3 1 3 3 2 1 3
Run8 1 3 2 1 2 3 2 1
Run9 1 3 3 2 1 1 3 2
Run10 2 1 1 3 2 1 2 2
Run11 2 1 2 1 1 2 3 3
Run12 2 1 3 2 3 3 1 1
Run13 2 2 1 1 3 3 3 2
Run14 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 3
Run15 2 2 3 3 1 2 2 1
Run16 2 3 1 2 1 3 2 3
Run17 2 3 2 3 3 1 3 1
Run18 2 3 3 1 2 2 1 2
Relevant answer
Answer
Repeat the attached Google search for full details. Best wishes, David Booth
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
46 answers
Hi everyone,
My study conceptual framework includes four latent variables. the QUESTION is, Can I use two or more theories my study as "Underpinning Theory/ies"?
Relevant answer
Answer
Yes, you can. However, the need for each framework should be justified.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
2 answers
Greetings everyone,
I am developing a formulation based on poloxamer (15% - 20%) in phosphate buffer. I used some methodologies from the literature to obtain the DSC profile, but I didn't get any satisfactory results (the attached image).
Methodology: PL hydrogels (35 mg) were placed in sealed aluminum pans and submitted to three successive thermal cycles of heating-cooling from 0 °C to 50 °C at a rate of 5 °C/min, using a TA Instruments (USA) Q200 DSC apparatus. An empty pan was used as reference. All analyzes were performed in triplicate and thermograms represented by heat flux (kJ·mol−1 ) versus temperature (°C).
I even used two different equipment and had similar results, far from what is expected (Tg of approximately 30ºC). Could anyone give me any thoughts on this?
Cheers!
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Matheus!
The hydrogel (Poloxamer diluted in phosphate buffer) does not show glass transition; instead, there is the micellization temperature, which is the temperature in which the poloxamer self-assembly into micelles. In most of your compositions, this is the peak you observe in the third graph over 10-30 °C.
If you want to see the gelation temperature, I recommend you perform a rheology analysis, fixing the frequency, varying the temperature, and recording elastic and viscous moduli.
As far as I know, the glass transition is only observed in dried poloxamer. The hydrogel does not show glass transition below 100 °C, which is the maximum temperature you can work since you have water in the hydrogels. So then, only the dried poloxamer pellets show glass transition due to the degree of freedom of PEO-PPO-PEO chains.
I hope I have helped you.
Best regards,
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
What will be the best approaches to get information about forest tenure system, issues related to forest tenure of an area to get scientific base result .
Relevant answer
Answer
Unsettled districts usually have indigenous residents and more recently settled residents. Discussions on location with these people can produce a wealth of local knowledge to encourage co-operation and avoid tenure issues. there may also be unofficial small scale forest tenure systems in place that could be accommodated.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
2 answers
what are the possible methodologies used in the design and analysis of a cut slope
Relevant answer
Answer
The phrase "cut scores" gets used differently in different disciplines, so it would be useful to create a new discussion where you define what you mean. For example, in education it is often using subject matter experts or by comparing the test on which you want to make the cut scores with some other test (e.g., ).
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
2 answers
Dear All,
Is there any standard methodology to account for the size effect phenomenon observed in materials such as concrete other than ASTM C1683?
Best Regards,
Hamed
Relevant answer
Answer
Lorenzo Del Giudice Many thanks for your reply. If i'm not mistaken, the procedure put forward by Professor Bažant is mostly applicable to flexure-induced tension not direct tension. I was wondering if the procedure can be modified to apply it to direct tension.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
1 answer
I am looking for a methodology for histolocalization of copper in plant tissues (other than Phen green SK). I found articles where hematoxylin were used but in animal tissues, and another author mentions Toluidine blue O for histochemical aalyses, but he does not cite the source. Somebody could help me?
Relevant answer
Answer
Toluidine blue O is a polychromatic dye, which means it may stain various components of the cell wall in different colors5,6. Toluidine blue O is most commonly used to detect pectin and lignin5,6.
Best Regards
Dr. Fatemeh Khozaei
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
6 answers
I am try to classify chest x-ray images but the dataset available is in grayscale. Please specify some methodologies to convert the whole datastore of grayscale images into RGB.
Thanks
Relevant answer
Answer
to convert rgb image ([h, w, 3]) to grayscale image ([h, w]) you need to duplicate the gray_image 3 times over the rgb channels:
rgb_image = zeros(h, w, 3)
for i=1:3
rgb_image[:, :, i] = gray_image
end
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
Working on application for goniometer mounted beam that will be fixed at one end. Material likely to be low CTE material (invar) or steel. Need to reduce weight by way of cellular holes in web. Is there a methodology to optimize this design. Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you @MoinUlHaq
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
33 answers
Dear all!
I hope you had a wonderful weekend. At the moment Im in the later stages of planning a hopefully good quantitative article in entrepreneurship. I will use connections in the industry (to do the dirty work of actually convincing people to participate )where Im active and my question is, what do you deem to be an acceptable sample size for a questionnaire about decision making, connecting into other areas?
It is a relatively small business community in our country so sample size can not be 1000, if yes there must be a discussion about expanding the geographical area.I know what the literature says but what is your experience regarding minimum sample size in different level journals. No need to say Im a qualitative researcher seeking to make an excursion into enemy territory :-)
Thank you so much for your input in advance.
Best wishes Henrik
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Henrik,
For such quantitative size of survey as You want the best thing is to use Paniott formula. Please, take a glance on Paniott formula on Google.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
10 answers
We are working on climate action at the local level and we wonder if you can share papers of methodologies in order to measure the progress of local climate action.
Many thanks
Relevant answer
Answer
Good day sir.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
2 answers
If someone know some methodologys of control doses. It would be great if you share it.
Relevant answer
Answer
I can't answer your question because it is not related with my research interest.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
10 answers
Hello everyone,
I am aiming to write a PHD proposal of 1000 words. The research is described by the supervisor. That means, research questions, aim, and instruments are well defined by the supervisor.
I developed an introduction along with a brief literature review. I also refined the aim to specific objectives and outlined the reseaech methodology.
My questions are:
1- Should I paraphrase the research questions and research significance defined by the supervisor in my proposal?
2- In view of words limitation, what are the the sections that should be given more attention?
Thank you so much
Relevant answer
Answer
With ref to my previous thread I would request you to publish one or two papers in standard J. in the field of your specialisation . This will help you in writing your synopsis very clearly .
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
16 answers
I've been asked to give feedback on a study that used a survey with the option for comments in each question. Some participants decided to share additional observations and thoughts for some questions. I've found that these additional comments carry rich qualitative data so I'm suggesting they analyze them and integrate them into the results (since they're currently not).
However, I'm not sure how to justify this methodologically (or even if it's appropriate). Even though these comments add insightful information about the participant's perceptions, they only account for a portion of them.
Options I'm currently considering:
(1) Use a common theme analysis for the qualitative data and relabel the study from quantitative to mixed-methods.
(2) Still define it as quantitative, but mention that some qualitative data was gathered as optional comments and analysed as well (would this be methodologically correct?).
(3) Do not use the qualitative data for the results, since it doesn't come from all participants.
Any thoughts?
Thank you very much in advance!
Relevant answer
Answer
Of course, they should be added and used (qualitatively) -- it's data, and respondents felt a need to add them, so we should report them. Since the researcher did not ask for comments, it doesn't make sense to call it a mixed method study. It's a quant study with supplemental comments. You add a section to the report describing qualitatively, what was said, including areas of convergence and divergence if the sample is large enough, and with some representative verbatims in any case. You should also include the % of respondents who added comments, for context.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
15 answers
I am looking for methods to analyze participants perception on future outcomes collected through a survey followed by qualitative data collected through focus groups. How do I combine data from these two sources and conduct a mixed methodology (Qualitative + Quantitative)? Is there any other better approach than the mixed methodology?
Thank you in advance for reading my inquiry.
Relevant answer
Answer
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
What about if I need to measure soil moisture directly at the field comparing summer and winter reading at arid area in (sandy soil ) in Acacia forests?
what type of instrument is recommended? and what is the simple Methodology for that ?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Rabie,
Hereby, I send you two papers published in 2021 describing two different methods in measuring soil moisture.
Good luck.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
Is it feasible to calculate "impact of socio-demographic factors on willingness to pay and trust" at the same time through a survey?
Relevant answer
Answer
In fact, the question needs to be framed a bit differently. How can we model the variation in two dependent variables through a single model?
Additionally, the measurement of variables is possible through survey design?
I would answer the second question first. Survey design is one of the most prevalent research design. The overuse of the method has attracted the attention of academicians who have pointed to different issues. We can improve the quality of survey by applying the remedial procedures suggested by Podsakoff (Link: https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2003-08045-010). The answer to the first question is the use of MANOVA. There is one cleavage to be taken care of. Both the dependent variables to be used must have a reasonable level of correlation between them. You can use the following book to master MANOVA: Introduction to Statistics and SPSS in Psychology.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
1 answer
Dear all,
i have to develop a Medium voltage cable pulling test procedure for providing tests at customer facilities.
I wonder if you could help me to find some suitable examples.
Description:
Pulll test is required to cable installation method without damage.
Test is to verify the following:
  • mechanical integrity (no elongations)
  • calculated pulling forces
  • electrical parameters are not damaged during pulling operation
  • the cable can be installed at required lengths.
Procedure shall include the following:
  • test purpose
  • test methodology
  • test measurements
  • test meaesurements criteria
  • required measurement equipment.
Thans a lot for your help.
Relevant answer
Answer
Basically, To perform the test, one end of a wire is fed into the gripping attachment, while the other end is secured to a fixed point. The tester then pulls the wire at a gradual pace, increasing the force until the wire breaks or the terminal is removed.
Best Regards
Dr. Fatemeh Khozaei
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
5 answers
I just looked up one of my publications on RG and noticed a new section ("Methods"), just after the abstract – and I'm really curious as to why the method suggested is "diagnosis", rather than "qualitive methods", "interviews" or "depth-hermeneutics", which are more relevant to my paper:
It seems there is an automated process behind it from RG perhaps drawing on certain concepts from the abstract ("top methods in this publication") – "diagnosis" in my case. I think we should be able to override/edit this automation, as the current function is misleading, in my view. It would be really usfeul if this new methods function WORKED and we could use it to profile our methods and link to other research based on similar methodologies!
Relevant answer
Answer
I wonder if our students on the professional doctorate in social work course could do something with this theme, particularly around child protection, parenting and the breast - I think it would be fascinating.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
9 answers
I've recently written and submitted a literature review that provides a narrative synthesis of 30 studies, half of which are quantitative (using various methods) and half qualitative. I make clear in the introduction that part of the value of the review is in bringing together a wide range of studies that look at the same issue from a range of disciplinary perspectives, using a variety of methods.
On review, one of the reviewers has suggested that I combine the findings in a meta-analysis. Is this even feasible given that the review covers both quantitative and qualitative papers? If so, what methodology would I use? (I'm aware of the Timulak papers on qualitative meta-analysis, but am not aware of anything that enables you to combine quan and qual). The methods of the included studies range from discrete choice analyses to quantitative content analyses, to semi-structured interviews, to ethnography. Surely much of the value of each study would be lost if they were somehow pulled together in a meta-analysis?
Would I be justified in rejecting this suggestion and reiterating that the review provides a narrative synthesis of a range of study types?
Thanks.
Relevant answer
Hello
In my opinion, you have to review MIXED METHODOLOGY:
Best regards
Ph.D. Ingrid del Valle Garcia Carreño
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
We would like to share some details about a methodology (designing Q-Sorts in Q-methodology) which should be available as quickly as possible. We are considering registering a pre-print version in an open repository. But it seems that sometimes journals don't accept these articles as originals. We would appreciate tips and considerations from colleagues, in particular with experience in this field. Thank you!
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks for all the great tips, St Schulz ! We will surely look them up also for other cases in the future! Best regards
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
1 answer
I am planning on using the QIAamp PowerFecal Pro DNA Kit on my samples, however, I am looking into alternative methodologies on effective ways to potentially extract DNA using lab resources when kits are not accessible. I want to look at microbial gut bacteria in the 16S gene. Thanks
Relevant answer
Answer
You can always go for phenol-choloroform method. But kits are designed for a fast and easier/safer extraction process, which might not be the same for you if you use the traditional kit-less methods.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
6 answers
Hello everyone,
In my research I will be assessing the relationship between a number of psychological variables , the issue I am having is that I could not find a suitable tool to measure one of the variables and I had to design a one myself and I am a bit worried as I will measure the other variables using well established tools. I have never come across a study using both existing and self-developed tools and I am afraid this will undermine the methodological rigor of my research.
Relevant answer
Answer
Royce Willis has given you could advice. In addition, you might consider pre-testing your newly created measure. One possible technique for doing that pre-testing is through cognitive interviews (Willis, 2004).
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
2 answers
I am PhD research student at a university in Scotland. I am in my first year with background in Materials and Metallurgy. I want to go into simulation particularly MD. My proposal research is on precision machining of SiC/Si (diamond turning to be specific). The first stage is building models of workpiece and tool. I have tried to create workpiece model using Atomsk but I still have sum difficult to replace the substituted atoms with the properties of the original atom after creating Types for LAMMPS. I have not yet known how to create the tool. SUMMARY: I am new in MD simulation, I need someone that can guide me through this first stage, and if possible further assistance will be appreciated. I have read the methodology and procedure of MD theoretically, but need how to use tools to create the atomistic models before writing LAMMPS script. Meanwhile, I can not afford material studio being commercially available.
Relevant answer
Answer
@Hadi. It is true but I need Material Studio to model the tool and combine it with workpiece. Is any means of getting Material studio or similar software that can be used. That is model I am talking about.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
I am looking for some methodological advise on if this survey has to be completed independently or if it can be completed with the support of a researcher? And how this should be reported?
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
5 answers
Any literature or findings, datasets and methodologies on this related topic please share and discuss with me
Relevant answer
Answer
i found another interesting story as well. may be useful.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
hello folks , i m doing my masters and i am having many difficulties in choosing current topic with systematic review methodology. any one here to help?
Relevant answer
Answer
1. We usually conduct SR with either qualitative or qualitative studies
2. See equator network for data extraction and reporting format
"Systematic reviews/Meta-analyses/Reviews/HTA/Overviews | Study Designs | The EQUATOR Network" https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines-study-design/systematic-reviews-and-meta-analyses/?post_type=eq_guidelines
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
Dear experts,
I am a PhD student and going to write a methodological paper. But I would like to know what is the best structure/ design for such kind of papers: as the research itself is a methodology developing. Could you advise any good examples of such papers.
Kind regards,
Valerija Kozlova
Relevant answer
Answer
Always welcome Mam.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
9 answers
Studying on Scrum and XP
Relevant answer
Answer
There are several ways to measure the success of IT projects. projects meet objectives within time and budget, delivered features, and the quality of the delivered product. There are other indicators such as productivity of developers and number of detected bugs. More information can be found in this paper where the focus is qualitative analysis.
good luck
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
2 answers
Does anyone know a reliable methodology to estimate the initial values of theta1 (or A) and theta2 (or B) in a non-linear model? For example,
a = (A+Bx/hc)(hc/x-Eg)
How to reliably estimate the initial values of "A", "B" ?
i am using Origin Pro and Minitab.
Relevant answer
Answer
All the values of regressions coefficiants are generated from best fit software used .http://demonstrations.wolfram.com/ChoosingInitialParameterValuesForNonlinearRegression/
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
14 answers
We have published several articles to strengthen the methodology of Action Research.
From those associated with doctoral programs (PhD, DBA, Ed.D., D.S.Sc, etc.), it would be useful to know whether or not Action Research is included in your curriculum.
If it is, details about what is taught and how is it taught would be greatly appreciated.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear researchers
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
1 answer
Dear experts,
I have a reaction that happens in a Petri dish, and as the reaction progress it will generates beautiful patterns as attached herewith. I am wondering is there any way to print the observed patterns by using some polymer materials or any other methodology.
Looking forward to hear from you.
Note: The reaction is oscillatory Belousov-Zhabotinksy reaction.
Relevant answer
Answer
Extrusion 3D Printing of Polymeric Materials with Advanced Properties
Zhen Jiang, Broden Diggle, Ming Li Tan, Jekaterina Viktorova, Christopher W Bennett, Luke A. Connal,
First published: 05 August 2020
Abstract 3D printing is a rapidly growing technology that has an enormous potential to impact a wide range of industries such as engineering, art, education, medicine, and aerospace. The flexibility in design provided by this technique offers many opportunities for manufacturing sophisticated 3D devices. The most widely utilized method is an extrusion-based solid-freeform fabrication approach, which is an extremely attractive additive manufacturing technology in both academic and industrial research communities. This method is versatile, with the ability to print a range of dimensions, multimaterial, and multifunctional 3D structures. It is also a very affordable technique in prototyping. However, the lack of variety in printable polymers with advanced material properties becomes the main bottleneck in further development of this technology. Herein, a comprehensive review is provided, focusing on material design strategies to achieve or enhance the 3D printability of a range of polymers including thermoplastics, thermosets, hydrogels, and other polymers by extrusion techniques. Moreover, diverse advanced properties exhibited by such printed polymers, such as mechanical strength, conductance, self-healing, as well as other integrated properties are highlighted. Lastly, the stimuli responsiveness of the 3D printed polymeric materials including shape morphing, degradability, and color changing is also discussed.
Introduction
3D printing, is the conversion of a computer-generated model into a real, physical object. The model is first converted into a series of triangulated coordinates which can be read by a printer and then transformed to a series of sequential layers. A computer-controlled translation stage then moves based on the designed pattern, either in the form of laser optics or an ink based printhead, to fabricate objects one layer at a time. Various 3D printing technologies used in fabricating advanced polymers have been well reviewed and summarized,[23] namely light-based 3D printing[24-26] extrusion-based printing,[27, 28] inkjet 3D printing,[29] and powder bed fusion-based methods.[30] Extrusion-based printing is widely used due to its simple printing mechanism and low-cost of fabrication.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
5 answers
i have some problem in writing statistics data of methodology and results, in fact, i face the challenge which statistics are better to mentioned for receiving accept in a high reputation journal?
Relevant answer
Answer
It's depends on your kind of data. The test statistics should be defined initially. In data analysis we can use recent analysis methods which will be helpful in better interpretation of your results
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
Dear all,
I am in the process of developing an energy behaviour maturity model for organisations in my PhD. So far, I have conducted expert interviews and focus groups on developing factors and maturity level descriptions (for 5 maturity levels against the factors). The structure of the findings so far is given below.
As the final step, I am going to develop the tool further as an assessment tool. Therefore, I am seeking ways of assigning weights for each main factor and sub-factor (Reason: The main factors/subfactors identified seem to have different impact levels for the energy behaviour maturity. Therefore, if I can assign weights that can be reflected in the results of the maturity assessments conduct using this model in the future)
Note: There are no subfactors for some of the main factors. Altogether, under the 3 Areas, 15 main factors and 5 subfactors are available. If required, the 3 areas can also be assigned with weights.
The structure of the current findings is as follows:
Area 1
  • Main factor 1.1
  • subfactor 1.1.1 ------------ Level 1 to Level 5 maturity descriptions against factors
Area 2
  • Main factor 2.1
  • subfactor 2.1.1 ------------ Level 1 to Level 5 maturity descriptions against factors
Area 3
  • Main factor 3.1
  • subfactor 3.1.1 ------------ Level 1 to Level 5 maturity descriptions against factors
I would be grateful if you could provide your thoughts on this matter.
Relevant answer
Answer
You may try with Fuzzy logic theory or multi-grade Fuzzy approach.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
6 answers
Dears,
I'm a spatial planning master student, I'm studying the soundscape in Jordan- Amman, the methodology I will use is varied from a questionnaire (Soundwalk) to a binaural recording, and I'm wondering if you have any recommendation for questions to be asked in the Soundwalk?
Thank You
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello,
Will you conduct noise level measurements at the soundwalk stops? If so, you could ask about the perceived loudness using a scoring method and then correlate the objective and the subjective results.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
The initial use of meta anysis is to compare results from clinical trials.
However, could I use it for data obtained from questionaire.
For instance, the question for dentist would be: ''Do you sterilize your devices regularly?''. I will try to combine responsed from different studies.
Is there any manual or framework on that methodology?
Thanks,
Aleksandar
Relevant answer
Answer
If surveys provide binary answers (yes/no), you can perform a meta-analysis of single proportions using the inverse variance method (with Freeman–Tukey double-arcsine transformation) or a generalized linear mixed model. It is easy to implement in Stata or R, eg. with Metaprop.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
2. if I have 200 respondent for a questionnaire of 25 items included in 4 domains ,on scale score from 0 to 5, so the lowest response will be 0 and the highest will be 125.which scientific way should I follow to make categorizations and why for example into three level (low, moderate or high)or just (weak or strong) or (very low ,low ,moderate, high, very high).
take resilience questionnaire for example highest will be 125
so can we say any score from 0 to 42 he has low level of resilience, from 43 to 84he has medium level of resilience, from 84 to 125 he has low level of resilience
3. that absolutely will be useless if there is categorization in the original questionnaire or not?
Relevant answer
Answer
Again, from a statistical perspective, it is best not to categorize/form groups and to rather use the variable/score as is, taking advantage of its (quasi-) continuous (metrical) scale level. Otherwise, you lose information. There are plenty of statistical procedures available for continuous variables and those are typically more powerful than procedures for categorical/ordinal variables.
Most categorization methods are also rather ad hoc/arbitrary (e.g., median or quartile split). A model-based approach that is less arbitrary is latent profile analysis (LPA), which allows you to identify latent groups based on continuous variables. Often, these groups come out as low, medium, high. However, LPA requires multiple continuous indicator variables.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
1 answer
Since the GRI started to become more famous, a numerous of companies started to publish their sustainability reports, based in those standards.
It is an obligation of the GRI standards that companies present a materiality matrix or framework that embraces, identify and prioritize the issues that are considered material for the company.
Altough the obligation exists, the standards do not establish any methodology that should be pursuit, and one could argue that they even do not evaluate the quality of the methodology used.
That is why i ask, what would be the best methodology for building a materiality matrix or framework?
Relevant answer
Answer
Follow these seven priorities:
  1. Identify internal and external stakeholders.
  2. Conduct some initial stakeholder outreach.
  3. Identify and prioritize what you want to measure.
  4. Design your materiality survey.
  5. Launch your survey and start collecting insights.
  6. Analyze the insights.
  7. Put those insights into action.
Best Regards
Dr. Fatemeh Khozaei
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
It is for my PhD methodology
Relevant answer
Answer
thank you guys
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
2 answers
We want to utilize it on Cal27 cell line (oral SCC) but are unsure of the appropriate dilution ratio and methodology.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you; do you remember the protocol and usage details?
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
1 answer
question regarding cultured hippocampal slices and with the use of ptfe 6well-plate insert, what is the methodology approach to perform chromogenic ihc
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
5 answers
It doesn't matter if it is in English or Spanish.
Relevant answer
Answer
As you are Spanish, I recommend classic manuals, understandable and unless it is Spanish (some, although they say as "Experimental Psychology", are valid for their objectives):
-Psicología Experimental; McGuigan; Ed. TRillas
-Diseño y Cálculo de Tests Estadísticos para Ensayos Clínicos y de Laboratorio; A. González; E.U.E de la Univ. Complutense de Madrid
-INvestigación Científica en CC de la Salud. Polit-Hungler. McGraw-Hill Interamericana
-Psicología Matemática I y II. Julio Seoane et al.Editorial UNED
-Fundamentos de Psicología Matemática.L. Jañez Escalada. Pirámide
-Psicología Matemática. Francis Isidro. Pirámide
-Los clásicos del Prof. Dr. Yela y los Clásicos del Prof. DR. Amón
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
7 answers
Hello Researchers,
Do we have any specific methodology or criteria on how to calculate the utility measures in patients with a worsened outcome in ARDS?
I mean, can we consider their utility score as zero, or something else, while we compare their QoL with those who are survived or died (already zero)?
Do we have any such kind of study for reference? I could find many studies among those who are survived.
Your efforts are much appreciated.
Relevant answer
Answer
-I-
I do not understand the question: IN SURVIVORS OR "IN NON-SURVIVORS WITH ARDS" ... as and as it literally appears, IT MAKES NO SENSE !!!
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
1 answer
What is the exact methodology to find the total number of completely sequenced genomes of a microorganism?
Could anyone please describe the path that should be followed to report accurately the total sequenced strains/genomes?
Relevant answer
Answer
The number of species in the community can be estimated by dividing this “genome” by the average size of a bacterial genome.
Best Regards
Dr. Fatemeh Khozaei
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
With the introduction of the Fourth Industrial Revolution, simultaneous with the outbreak of COVID-19 in 2020, and the globalization of societies and physical settlements, architects find themselves facing a time of uncertainty and major turnovers.
What do you think is the role of architectural education within this unique era? And what are the biggest challenges architectural academics face? Do you think we need to go back in time and adopt from our predecessors' methodologies? Or should we invest in our current progress?
Relevant answer
Answer
The coronavirus brought about a disruption, which also brings about an opportunity to address other much-needed changes at both education and societal level. For future architects to be equipped to face those, a review of the architectural syllabus is needed where equal emphasis is provided on studio just as much as other dimensions. Along with this, it may also be the time to expand the architectural curriculum, merge across disciplines and truly work towards building the future. A future is just as much as beautiful as it is resilient, sustainable, inclusive and safe.
Best Regards
Dr. Fatemeh Khozaei
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
7 answers
I'm designing a new study and looking for a statistician to help me with the statistical methodology. please suggest to me
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you @ chukwudi
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
12 answers
Dear colleagues,
I am currently writing a paper that examines different definitions or different elements of a concept. In the literature review I got a good overview of the topic, but what I couldn't get from it was a comparison model for definitions.
So, I am looking for a model to compare the definitions [Edit] found in the Literature review. The defintions are verbal and do not have empirical data and are not based on empirical data. Discipline is Businss Administration. [/Edit]. No model to evaluate the concept, I found some. My own search has not yielded any useful results for comparison models.
Please, can you help me by either giving me good search terms, textbooks on comparison methodology or something you think can help me with this point?
Kind regards, Sebastian
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks a lot Sajid Iqbal . From a first reading that paper will help me either directly or help to get my Literature research back on track. You saved my submission deadline. :)
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
Plamer index methodolgy
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks you, Zahidul Islam :
As you said, If i had two spp., i.e., Oscillatoria 4, Chlorella 3 etc.
Thus, My Index values 4 + 3 = 7
Does is indicate Lack of pollution as per above index table
( Index values between 0-10 = Lack of organic pollution)
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
6 answers
Actually, we are using commercial (Thermo scientific and monarch) miniprep kits for our plasmid purification and never tried the miraprep.
But anyone has tried miraprep, so could you tell us whether it is efficient over the commercial kit methodology or not?
Here I am attaching the link to the miraprep research paper.
Relevant answer
Answer
Efficiency doesn't really matter for this sort of protocol, if you need more plasmid you just start with more cells or use 2 columns or use a maxi-kit.
I'm assuming that you need the plasmid for something downstream - cloning or expression analysis or whatever. You just need a protocol that will give you a "good enough to work with" amount of plasmid.
Don't get caught up trying to optimize this sort of protocol, especially if you are a Ph.D student. You aren't going to get a thesis chapter out of optimizing a plasmid prep. But you might get one with the data from what you are using the plasmid for.
Good luck!
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
11 answers
I am using the grounded theory methodology and need help to better understand bias and rigour.
How can you ensure rigour in action research?
How can a researcher avoid bias during issue-focused interviews and when doing analysis after??
Relevant answer
Answer
Many of the same guidelines apply to grounded theory as to other methods (like experiments). For example, pre-registration can be useful if you are worried about your bias. We discuss this in our chapter Psychology as a science, What is Science in https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/research-methods-in-psychology/book257083. The authors do not hold the copyright on this (so don't ask), but Sage have it reasonably priced.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
8 answers
I am doing an Impact assessment on an intervention Program among high school students.
I have 4 schools where the intervention was conducted. From those schools I will have the control and the intervention groups.
I am wondering which technique or analysis methodology should I use because it was highlighted that PSM is not a good model.
Please enlighten me.
Relevant answer
Answer
Peterson Machango try DID model or a treatment effect technique
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
1 answer
As part of a research project, I would like to conduct regular height measurements of grass stands in paddocks grazed at high and low grazing density using the Rising Plate Meter. I am aware that grass stands in mob grazed paddocks may reach heights above 50 or 60 cm. However, to this date, I have not found any methodology successfully capturing the dry matter of forage using this method in high stands.
My concern is that some more rigid tall grasses or herbs may cause severe bias since they are not able to represent the density of the grass stand at lower heights.
Could you please point me to research papers, if they exist, or even to alternative methodologies that may be more suited in such as scenario?
Thank you very much in advance!
Relevant answer
Answer
We hd to develop a non-linear calibration equation for a similar method to account for tall, rigid vegetation:
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
5 answers
I'm trying to get a good summary of the main types of architectural research, and the motivations for using each type? any help?
To clearly set up the methodological approach for my new research ...
I rely upon:
(Linking design with research)...
The research as a base for the design
I'm actually trying to use the explanations of the book "Architectural Research Methods" by
Linda Groat and David Wang
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello Nadine Al-bqour,
You can also try to read
'Research Methods for the Architectural Profession' by Ajla Aksamija
publisher: Taylor and Francis
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
Deleted
Relevant answer
Answer
You need to ask your advisor/committee, as they are the ones who will decide if what you do is enough.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
Hello everyone,
I need a simple instruction for modeling of End-of-Life scenarios in GaBi software. I have reviewed every document existed on the internet on this topic but all of them explain the backlog methodology not the modeling procedure. So I kindly ask you rather than referring to documents, tell me if you know a simple workflow in the software for end-of-life modeling. Thank you!
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Shahin, many thanks for posting this interesting technical question on RG. As an inorganic chemist I'm ansolutely not an expert in this field, and personally I never used this software. I assume that you already checked all handbooks and tutorials which are available on the gabi-software.com homepage. In addition to the potentially useful links suggested by Mohamed-Mourad Lafifi please also have a look at the following freely available handbook:
GaBi Manual
This manual is freely available as public full text (see attached pdf file).
It might also be worth having a look at the answers given to the following closely related question which has been asked earlier on RG:
Anybody familiar with End of Life modelling(i.e. recycling) on GaBi?
(6 answers)
I hope this helps. Good luck with your work and best wishes!
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
2 answers
Alternating optimization (AO) has been widely used to solve the (non-convex) problem with several types of variables. People can decouple the original optimization problem into several sub-problems, with each sub-problem contains one type of variable. Solving each sub-problem separately and then optimize different variables alternately. In general, it refers to the methodology named "divided-and-conquer".
Assume that each sub-problem can be optimally solved, how to know whether the obtained solution by AO is global optimal or not?
Relevant answer
Answer
Unless the problem is convex, a local method cannot guarantee global optimality. This is because first- or second-order characterizations of a global minimizer do not exist in the general case.
Now, if you use global methods (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deterministic_global_optimization), you will explore the search space exhaustively (and hopefully implicitly) and you'll be able to prove the global optimality of the solution. This can get pretty difficult to solve, though.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
6 answers
I am working with economics quantitative variables.
One dependent variable (y)
One explanatory variable (x)
One mediator (z)
Among some control variables (a,b)
Please suggest some relavent literature so that I can make sure that time series methodology is not effected by mediation that is
If my variables are of mixed integration then instead of mediation framework can we apply ARDL or relevant time series methodologies?
I need some liturature guide please help me out.
I shall be very grateful for this favor.
Relevant answer
Answer
in quantitative analysis it impossible because data matching problem
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
I am working in a methodology for designing prosthesis. I have read some examples:
  • Hierarchical design models in the mechatronic product development process of synchronous machines
  • Standard Industrial Guideline for Mechatronic Product Design
  • Integrative development of product and production system for mechatronic products
What benefits can this methodology gives.
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
I am a first year PhD student looking to engage with as many different realist researchers as possible as I am trying to make sense of my methodology and methods for my research. I would appreciate any Twitter account recommendations, or any other researchers to follow aside from those in the RAMESES projects (already BRILLIANT materials!). Many thanks in advance for your assistance!
Warmly,
Julie
Relevant answer
Answer
The use of the word "realist" assumes a significant bias on the part of the user of a methodology. A preferable approach would be phenomenological, where individual realities are systematized. Care for individuals requires understanding of individuals.
Sincerely, Kurt
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
please inbox me
Relevant answer
Answer
Thomas Wolke thank you dear
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
7 answers
In practice, Social Work acts from different professional perspectives. For example, the legal case perspective must be methodically related to other case perspectives such as anamnesis and diagnosis within the framework of casework, ideally in a concrete way and with appropriate methodological awareness. It would be conceivable, for example, to subject the results of an introductory anamnesis and diagnosis to subsequent legal monitoring.
Are there scientific concepts or legal requirements for this methodological challenge in your country? Or do you tend to leave the meaningful linking of different case perspectives to the professional actors? What seems to make sense to you?
Relevant answer
Answer
For example Social workers to help solve the vulnerability problems of families
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
6 answers
Hi everyone,
I am trying to optimize my data in FPGA and reduce the data movement between off-chip memory and FPGA. one of the possible techniques is the data reuse methodology. I need a reference, lecture or tutorial to learn about the spatial and temporal reuse techniques. I appreciate any help or guidance from you in advance.
Relevant answer
Answer
I think this is an important question regarding the system design and implementation using FPGAs. The FPFAs contain what is called block ram that can be used as internal memory on the chip. IN case of Memory intensive applications one may an extremal memory. Sure the external memory may take relatively long time to access compared to the block ram which can be made to neighbor the processing block. So, the block ram may function as a cash memory for the local processors. As said before only the data which would be accessed much fewer times can be sent to the off chip memory. It is similar to the cash memory and external memory of the microprocessors.
Best wishes
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
GRADE system is the global standard for rating evidence quality and considering the strength of recommendations in health care. I wanted to know if we can use this tool in systematic reviews that include experimental or laboratory studies or studies that are not directly related to human health, or without human sample units. For example comparing two dental material's characteristics or examining inflammatory related markers in peri-implant crevicular fluid.
Relevant answer
Answer
The Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) Working Group's approach to rating the quality of evidence and strength of recommendations was originally designed for healthcare questions.
In section "2. Framing the health care question" of the GRADE handbook (available here: https://gdt.gradepro.org/app/handbook/handbook.html#h.2uab3znt2cji ), it is clear that the framework is appropriate for research questions that can be adequately captured in the PICO format.
Looking at the domains for rating down study quality (e.g. indirectness, risk of bias, inconsistency, imprecision, and publication bias), its use does not necessarily have to be limited to healthcare or human studies.
A quick internet search will show that the GRADE network has expanded to other content areas (see "Groups and Projects"): https://www.gradeworkinggroup.org/
Here's one study that assessed the use of the framework in animal studies, https://abstracts.cochrane.org/2016-seoul/grade-preclinical-animal-studies-translating-evidence-bench-bedside
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
6 answers
I am trying to test the model in the figures below. That is, a linear relationship between X and Y, with two moderators variables (X and W) in which there is an influence of the joint effects of the two moderators together.
I could use the macro for SPSS called PROCESS, but I am more interested in developing a hierarchical regression with STATA by multiplying the different variables (previously centered).
Has anyone worked with similar models before or recall a similar study I can base to develop the methodological part of this kind of moderation effect correctly?
Thank you un advance.
Relevant answer
Answer
You could refer to Hayes’s (2018) book, referenced below.
Hayes, A. F. (2018). Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis: A regression-based approach (2nded.). Guilford Press. https://www.guilford.com/books/Introduction-to-Mediation-Moderation-and-Conditional-Process-Analysis/Andrew-Hayes/9781462534654
Good luck,
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
It is related to studies researching joint position sense.
Relevant answer
Answer
Ivan Karuc (MINORS) tool or EPOC RoB tool
Good luck
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
My PhD proposal is addressing the emotional expressiveness in Disney films ( the animated films versus their remake counterparts) and how the animated characters show more emotions than the realistic (remake) characters. However, I still could not choose which approach/methodology I should go with.
any advice for such a research?
Relevant answer
Answer
Through the grapevine, I have heard that Japanese anime and similar pictorial art forms being developed in Japan are worthy of scientific study because of their artistic and technological achievements in depicting facial expressions. If you are interested in including a comparative analysis element in your study, then this East Asian approach to emotional expressiveness may be worth researching. It might be interesting to compare and also to contrast facial expressiveness in Disney and some Japanese animated film forms, from both film studies visual arts and psychology of perception cinematic standpoints.
Best wishes,
Nancy Ann Watanabe
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
4 answers
Hello, everybody,
I am looking for recommendations for good methodologies and models for climate scenarios that include ENSO and AMO events for local scales.
Relevant answer
Answer
numerical weather prediction such as WRF model or REGCM Model I think you must try it.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
5 answers
What is the solution use for digestion and dilution of Rice sample.
Relevant answer
Multielemental analysis (including Na and K) could be done by ICP. Prior to that digesti9n with acid(s) should be done.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
3 answers
Dear Friend in RG,
This drawing was created as a part of of a research carried on Drawing therapy at a safe home for COVID Care. Would anybody (specially Psychologist or Drawing Therapist, though everybody is welcome) help me interpreting and analysing (with proper methodology and references) the drawing?
Relevant answer
The “SpO2” reading on a pulse oximeter shows the percentage of oxygen in someone's blood. A normal level of oxygen is usually 95% or higher. Some people with chronic lung disease (Cf COVID's lung effects) or sleep apnea can have normal levels around 90%. If the doctor fears he got the contagion of corona, his measured values are rather normal.
The patient with IV medication has probably COVID. The only one who really can interpret this correct is the one who draw it. The drawer should give an explanation if you want an exact interpretation. The drawing has to be related to the actual situation and from this picture now you can imagine that the Dr fears that he got contagion.
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
5 answers
I'm performing an adsorption experiment but I don't know how to use correctly the filter paper or do the calculations to determine the difference of the retained material. Please, help me
Relevant answer
Answer
This Question which interested me a lot, thank you very much
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
5 answers
How to use this software?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Jalil,
What do you want to know about this software?
I would like to help if I know...
  • asked a question related to Methodology
Question
6 answers
Goodmorning
In a recent qualitative research, we are constructing purposeful sampling, we are thinking to use a specific scale to select a small group of participant. I think that this scale can help us (credibility criterion) is to select the participants that a specific emotional experience. How do you consider this methodological strategy? Uncommon? Should I describe this operation as a mixed method strategy?
Thank you for your attention
Kind regards
Alfonso Santarpia (Université de Sherbrooke, Canada)
Relevant answer
Answer
In mixed methods terminology, this would be a quant --> QUAL design, which unfortunately is not as well known as some of the other combinations in mixed methods research.
If you need a citation for this form of purposive sampling, I devoted a chapter to it my book, Integrating Qualitative and Quantitative Methods.