Available via license: CC BY-NC 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
RESEARCH
847 November 2013, Vol. 103, No. 11 SAMJ
The practice of hookah pipe smoking is centuries old
and has long been used in India, Pakistan, China and
the Eastern Mediterranean.
[1]
Its use has now permeated
many countries and is becoming a popular social
practice globally, especially among young people.
[1-4]
While the water filter and the fruity flavoured tobacco of hookah may
make it seem innocuous, inhaled smoke contains toxic compounds
such as nicotine, carbon monoxide, formaldehyde, polyaromatic
hydrocarbons, arsenic and lead.
[4,5]
A hookah smoking session is
usually longer in duration and involves exposure to much larger
Hookah pipe smoking among health sciences students
N van der Merwe,
1
BSc, BSocSci (Hons), MSc; T Banoobhai;
1
A Gqweta;
1
A Gwala,
1
BSc (Hons), SPED; T Masiea;
1
M Misra,
1,2
MB ChB, MBA;
V Zweigenthal,
1,2
MB ChB, DTM&H, FCPHM (SA)
1
Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Cape Town, South Africa
2
School of Public Health and Family Medicine, University of Cape Town, South Africa
Corresponding author: N van der Merwe (nicolina.vandermerwe@gmail.com)
Background. Hookah pipe smoking is a social practice and has gained popularity, especially among South African youth. The extent of this
practice among health sciences students, and their knowledge regarding the health risks, are unknown. This is important, as these students
will become future health professionals possibly influencing the practice of individuals and communities.
Objective. To explore the knowledge, attitudes and practices of hookah pipe smoking among students at the Faculty of Health Sciences,
University of Cape Town.
Methods. A cross-sectional study was conducted among undergraduate and postgraduate students. A self-administered questionnaire was
distributed as a hard copy and online survey.
Results. Of 228 participants, 66% had smoked a hookah pipe before, with 18% still smoking. Most began smoking in high school, with 25%
initiating at university. Of the current smokers, 65% smoked occasionally socially, commonly at friends’ houses for 30 - 60 min/session.
A further 11% smoked cigarettes concurrently and 30% added other substances, mainly cannabis, to pipes. Most current hookah smokers
had no interest in quitting (84%). Only 30% of participants had prior health information about hookah pipe smoking. Most knew that it
was harmful (91%), with many not knowing why. A total of 80% of participants perceived that the practice was socially acceptable and 84%
would recommend it to others.
Conclusion. The poor knowledge about the dangers of hookah pipe smoking and the extent of its practice among health sciences students
is alarming. These findings highlight the need for school and university health-promotion campaigns, and for better regulation of hookah
pipe smoking.
S Afr Med J 2013;103(11):847-849. DOI:10.7196/SAMJ.7448
RESEARCH
848 November 2013, Vol. 103, No. 11 SAMJ
volumes of smoke.
[6,7]
Studies investigating the acute and long-term
effects of hookah pipe smoking show that it is a risk factor for lung
cancer, periodontal diseases, cardiovascular disease and adverse
pregnancy outcomes.
[8]
It also poses the risks of transmission of
acute and chronic infections, such as tuberculosis and hepatitis, with
sharing of the hookah pipe mouthpiece.
[6,8]
Thus, while hookah pipes
are commonly perceived to be safer than cigarettes,
[3]
they may be
even be more harmful.
Hookah pipe smoking is a highly social practice occurring on
campus, in the family home, at parties, at a friend’s place, or in
restaurants.
[9]
The influence of peers is a major factor in determining
the initiation of using hookah.
[2]
The South African Tobacco Control
policy prohibits tobacco smoking in public spaces, but policies
specifically prohibiting hookah pipe smoking in public spaces
have not yet been implemented.
[9]
Research shows that knowledge
about the hazards of hookah pipe smoking tend to be limited in
adolescents.
[2,9,10]
Easy social and retail access to both the hookah
and its tobacco, combined with a lack of alternative activities,
[11]
contribute to the popularity of hookah.
In South Africa (SA), the use of hookah pipes among students
is highly prevalent.
[9,11,12]
This has been noted with concern by the
Cancer Association of South Africa (CANSA), resulting in them
approaching the School of Public Health and Family Medicine at the
University of Cape Town (UCT) to conduct a study exploring the
knowledge, attitudes and practices regarding hookah pipe smoking.
The extent of this practice among health sciences students who
will become future health professionals is unknown and they could
impact on the practice of individuals and communities.
Objective
To explore the knowledge, attitudes and practices with regards
to hookah pipe smoking among students at the Faculty of Health
Sciences, UCT.
Methods
A cross-sectional study was conducted in March 2013 among the
3582 undergraduate and postgraduate students registered in 2013. The
minimum sample size was calculated to be 256 based on a 40% smoking
prevalence estimate for the Western Cape
[9]
and a precision of 6%.
A self-administered questionnaire was adapted from a previous
hookah pipe study conducted in the Western Cape. Data were
collected via two methods: distribution of hard-copy questionnaires
on campus, and an online survey.
Hard copies were more likely
to be completed by undergraduates who make the most use of
campus areas, while the online questionnaire served to reach senior
undergraduate students and postgraduates. Informed consent was
obtained prior to participation in the study. The study was approved
by the UCT Human Research Ethics Committee.
Results
Sample
A total of 228 students completed the questionnaire; 111 in hard copy
and 117 online. The majority of participants were female (64%). The
mean age of participants was 21.4 years (standard deviation ±4.38).
Over half were undergraduate medical students (54%); 29% health
and rehabilitation sciences and 9% postgraduate health sciences
students. A further 8% were taking subjects in the faculty towards
degrees registered in other faculties.
Hookah pipe practices
Two-thirds of respondents had smoked a hookah pipe before, even if
only once or twice, while 18% are currently smoking. Of the current
smokers (n=41), the majority smoked occasionally socially (65%).
The most common place for smoking hookah was at friends’ houses
(41%), at home (30%), or in clubs and cafés (21%). A small number
smoked on campus (8%). Most participants smoked with friends
(59%), while some smoked with family (20%). Most participants
(61%) smoked between 30 - 60 min/session.
Almost a third of participants (29%) supplemented hookah
products with other substances, most often cannabis (86%), with a
small number adding alcohol. Methamphetamine (‘tik’) and other
drugs were not added. A minority of those who currently smoke
hookah pipe smoked cigarettes too (11%), most daily (60%).
A minority of students (27%) reported adverse health effects (e.g.
cough, shortness of breath, loss of taste and headaches) that they
attributed to hookah pipe smoking. Most current smokers did not
wish to quit (84%).
Most participants began smoking in high school (67%), while a
quarter (26%) began in university. The majority of participants began
smoking hookah pipes because they ‘just decided to’ (67%), while a
smaller number were recommended to do so by someone else (19%).
For most smokers (55%), parents or partners knew that they were
hookah pipe smokers and most (76%) were accepting of the practice.
Knowledge and attitudes
Only 31% of participants had prior infor mation regarding the
dangers of hookah pipe smoking, with 60% obtaining knowledge
from printed and audiovisual media. Knowledge of the health effects
of hookah pipe smoking, drawn from answers to six questions that
referred to these health effects, was categorised as good (29% of
respondents), average (55%) and poor (16%).
Almost all participants (91%) knew that smoking hookah pipes
was harmful. Responses to an open-ended question about why they
thought hookah pipe smoking was harmful or not are shown in Fig. 1.
The majority had a permissive attitude towards hookah pipe
smoking, with 80% believed it to be socially acceptable, and 84%
were willing to recommend it to others. Contrary to this, the majority
of individuals (74%) believed the practice should be subject to legal
regulation.
Discussion
While it was encouraging that most of the sampled students were
not currently hookah pipe smokers, the majority had tried it at least
once, suggesting an ease of accessibility and acceptability of the
practice. Of those smoking, a third smoked on a regular basis, in
contrast to other SA research indicating that the majority of hookah
pipe smokers smoke daily.
[9]
The social element of hookah smoking is
significant, and peer pressure is a major factor in initiating usage,
[2]
and the majority of participants started smoking in high school and
university, with peers. It is concerning that hookah pipe smoking is
permissible in families, as there are high levels of acceptance and
practice among family members.
Hookah bars, cafés and restaurants are social places for hookah
smoking.
[9]
However, selection of smokers’ or friends’ homes were
more common among the sample. In contrast to the findings of
a study done at another local university where a large proportion
of students smoked hookah on campus,
[9]
few students smoked on
campus in our survey. This may be attributable to the strict policies
on any tobacco products on UCT campus.
Although the number of concurrent cigarette users may be higher
than that of exclusive users of hookah,
[9]
we found that only 11%
smoked cigarettes and hookah concurrently.
Nearly a third of hookah smokers in the current sample
supplemented their hookah products with cannabis, which suggests
RESEARCH
849 November 2013, Vol. 103, No. 11 SAMJ
that this practice could provide an
opportunity for the use of narcotics, thus
increasing associated risks.
Only a small number of hookah pipe
smokers noticed any health effects attributable
to their smoking, which suggests that the
effects are not readily apparent. Thus, the
practice is seemingly innocuous, concealing
the serious long-term consequences.
[6-8]
Knowledge and attitudes
Most students had only an average level
of knowledge of the risks associated with
hookah pipe smoking, indicating a need for
education on the topic. Important to consider,
is that a large number of participants had
not received any health information about
hookah pipe smoking previously.
While most could identify that hookah
pipe smoking was harmful, many gave
incorrect reasons, indicating a knowledge
gap. Some perceived hookah pipe smoking
to be less harmful than cigarette smoking,
suggesting that hookah is perceived as a safer
alternative. However, previous studies have
suggested that hookah pipe and cigarette
smoking share similar health risks, with
more carbon monoxide, similar nicotine
and more smoke exposure during a session
of hookah
pipe smoking.
[6,7]
It is concerning
that the health effects of hookah pipe
smoking are unclear.
Most students had permissive attitudes
towards hookah pipe smoking, believing it
to be socially acceptable and that they could
easily access hookah pipe products. However,
not as many would recommend it to others
and the majority believed that the practice
should be subject to stricter regulation.
Currently, while the South African Tobacco
Control policy prohibits tobacco smoking
in public spaces, such prohibition does not
explicitly extend to hookah pipe smoking.
[9]
Study limitations
Limitations of the current study include
possible response and recall bias in
questionnaire responses, as well as selection
bias. Hard copies were distributed to students
in the social areas of the campus, which
may influence the composition of the sample
despite an online questionnaire being
available to all health sciences students to
counteract this effect. The current study
neither explored reasons why those who no
longer smoked hookah pipe had stopped,
nor the temporality of cigarette smoking
on hookah pipe smoking. This would have
been useful in the interpretation of attitudes
towards the practice.
Conclusion
The current study was conducted among a
subset of SA’s future health professionals.
Their poor knowledge about the dangers
of hookah pipe smoking, coupled with the
extent of its practice is alarming. Permissive
attitudes toward the practice, the young age
of first experimentation in high school and
at university, together with low exposure
to information about hookah smoking
highlights the need for school and university
health-promotion campaigns, as well as for
the better regulation of hookah pipe smoking
and awareness campaigns at a national level.
Acknowledgements. e authors thank CANSA
and the Faculty of Health Sciences, UCT, for
support throughout this research, as well as the
students who participated in the research.
References
1. Maziak, W, Ward, KD, Afifi Soweid, RA, Eissenberg, T.
Tobacco smoking using a waterpipe: A re-emerging strain in
a global epidemic. Tob Control 2004;13(4):327-333. [http://
dx.doi.org/10.1136/tc.2004.008169]
2. Tobacco FreeU Organisation, The Bacchus Network.
Reducing Hookah Use: A Public Health Challenge for
the 21st Century. Denver: The Bacchus Network, 2011.
http://www.tobaccofreeu.org/pdf/HookahWhitePaper.pdf
(accessed 6 March 2013).
3. Amin, TT, Amr, MAM, Zaza, BO, Suleman, W. Harm
perception, attitudes and predictors of waterpipe (shisha)
smoking among secondary school adolescents in Al-Hassa,
Saudi Arabia. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev 2010;11(2):293-301.
4. Martinasek, MP, McDermott, RJ, Martini, L. Waterpipe
(hookah) tobacco smoking among youth. Curr Probl Pediatr
Adolesc Health Care 2011;41(2):34-57. [http://dx.doi.
org/10.1016/j.cppeds.2010.10.001]
5. Nakkash, R, Khalil, J. Health warning labelling practices on
narghile (shisha, hookah) waterpipe tobacco products and
related accessories. Tob Control 2010;19(13):235-239. [http://
dx.doi.org/10.1136/tc.2009.031773]
6. Maziak, W. The waterpipe: An emerging global risk for
cancer. Cancer Epidemiol 2012;37(1):1-4. [http://dx.doi.
org/10.1016/j.canep.2012.10.013]
7. Cobb, CO, Sahmarani, K, Eissenberg, T, Shihadeh, A. Acute
toxicant exposure and cardiac autonomic dysfunction
from smoking a single narghile waterpipe with tobacco
and with a ‘healthy’ tobacco-free alternative. Toxicol
Lett 2012;215(1):70-75. [http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
toxlet.2012.09.026]
8. Akl, EA, Gaddam, S, Gunukula, SK, Honeine, R, Abou
Jaoude, P, Irani, J. The effects of waterpipe tobacco smoking
on health outcomes: A systematic review. Int J Epidemiol
2010;39(3):834-857. [http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ije/dyq054]
9. Daniels, KE, Roman, NV. A descriptive study of the
perceptions and behaviors of waterpipe use by university
students in the Western Cape, South Africa. Tob Induc Dis
2013;11(1):4. [http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1617-9625-11-4]
10. Anjum, Q, Ahmed, F, Ashfaq, T. Knowledge, attitude and
perception of water pipe smoking (shisha) among adolescents
aged 14-19 years. J Pak Med Assoc 2008;58(6):312-317.
11. Combrink, A, Irwin, N, Laudin, G, Naidoo, K, Plagerson,
S, Mathee, A. High prevalence of hookah smoking among
secondary school students in a disadvantaged community in
Johannesburg. S Afr Med J 2010;100(5):297-299.
12. Senkubuge, F, Ayo-Yusuf, OA, Louwagie, GMC, Okuyemi,
KS. Water pipe and smokeless tobacco use among medical
students in South Africa. Nicotine Tob Res 2011;14(6):755-
760. [http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ntr/ntr211]
Accepted 5 September 2013.
0
5
15
30
35
Frequency, %
20
Causes illness/
damages lungs
Contains harmful
substances
Addictive
Not addictive
Equally as harmful
as cigarettes
Less harmful than
cigarettes
Heard it was bad via
media
Did not know
25
10
Response
Fig. 1. Responses to open-ended question about why hookah pipe smoking was harmful or not (N=206).