ArticlePDF Available

Cross-reactions of sera from dogs infected with Angiostrongylus vasorum in commercially available Dirofilaria immitis test kits

Authors:

Abstract

Background Dirofilaria immitis and Angiostrongylus vasorum are both important potentially fatal canine nematodes with overlapping endemic areas, especially in Europe. The preadult and adult stages of both species are living in the Arteria pulmonalis and the right heart, and diagnostically detectable circulating parasite antigens have been demonstrated for both species. For the detection of D. immitis infections, a variety of commercial tests have been developed, however, they have not been evaluated for cross-reactions against circulating antigens of A. vasorum. Methods In this study, potential cross-reactions of sera from 16 dogs, which were experimentally infected with A. vasorum and which had circulating antigens as confirmed by a species-specific ELISA, were evaluated for the detection of A. vasorum antigen in six commercially available D. immitis test kits. Results In three fast tests (Witness® Dirofilaria, SensPERT® Canine Heartworm, SNAP® 4Dx® Plus), all sera were negative. One fast membrane ELISA (SNAP® HTWM RT Test) was positive with four sera (25%), and one serum delivered a non-valid result twice. In the PetChek® HTWM PF Test, depending on the interpretation protocol, 5 or 8 dogs (31.2 – 50%) were positive. With the DiroCHEK®-ELISA, a single A. vasorum-infected dog (6.2%) tested positive. Conclusions Due to potential cross-reactions with A. vasorum in commercially available test kits for the detection of D. immitis antigen, the simultaneous use of highly specific diagnostic methods for the differentiation of these two canine heart worms is recommended.
R E S E A R C H Open Access
Cross-reactions of sera from dogs infected with
Angiostrongylus vasorum in commercially
available Dirofilaria immitis test kits
Manuela Schnyder
*
and Peter Deplazes
Abstract
Background: Dirofilaria immitis and Angiostrongylus vasorum are both important potentially fatal canine nematodes
with overlapping endemic areas, especially in Europe. The preadult and adult stages of both species are living in
the Arteria pulmonalis and the right heart, and diagnostically detectable circulating parasite antigens have been
demonstrated for both species. For the detection of D. immitis infections, a variety of commercial tests have been
developed, however, they have not been evaluated for cross-reactions against circulating antigens of A. vasorum.
Methods: In this study, potential cross-reactions of sera from 16 dogs, which were experimentally infected with A.
vasorum and which had circulating antigens as confirmed by a species-specific ELISA, were evaluated for the
detection of A. vasorum antigen in six commercially available D. immitis test kits.
Results: In three fast tests (Witness
W
Dirofilaria, SensPERT
W
Canine Heartworm, SNAP
W
4Dx
W
Plus), all sera were
negative. One fast membrane ELISA (SNAP
W
HTWM RT Test) was positive with four sera (25%), and one serum
delivered a non-valid result twice. In the PetChek
W
HTWM PF Test, depending on the interpretation protocol, 5 or 8
dogs (31.2 50%) were positive. With the DiroCHEK
W
-ELISA, a single A. vasorum-infected dog (6.2%) tested positive.
Conclusions: Due to potential cross-reactions with A. vasorum in commercially available test kits for the detection
of D. immitis antigen, the simultaneous use of highly specific diagnostic methods for the differentiation of these
two canine heart worms is recommended.
Keywords: Angiostrongylus vasorum,Dirofilaria immitis, Antigen detection, Cross-reactions, Dogs
Background
The adult stages of Dirofilaria immitis, a filarial nema-
tode, and Angiostrongylus vasorum, a metastrongylid
nematode, are both localized in the Arteria pulmonalis
and the right heart of their definitive hosts. Dogs, foxes
and some other carnivores are the definitive hosts of
both parasites, while Culicidae and Gastropoda are the
intermediate hosts of D. immitis and A. vasorum,
respectively.
In Europe, D. immitis is present in coastal Mediterra-
nean areas with expansion northwards, while in North
America the parasite has expanded from the south-
eastern coastal areas northwards and westwards [1] up
to Canada [2]. A. vasorum was diagnosed for the first
time in France in 1913 [3], but it is only recently that
this parasite has regained attention within the veterinary
community [4,5]. Its presence has been increasingly
reported from several new areas in and outside Europe
(reviewed in [6]). Reports of an increasing number of
cases of canine angiostrongylosis, as well as the develop-
ment of new diagnostic tools such as ELISAs [7-10] or
biomolecular techniques [11,12] may have contributed
and also incentivised epidemiological studies, confirming
the presence of this parasite in dogs, foxes and snails
throughout Europe. The Atlantic provinces of New-
foundland and Labrador are the only regions actually
affected by A. vasorum in North America, with a poten-
tial for expansion to further regions [4,13,14]. Overlap-
ping areas in large parts of southern Europe with the
presence of both A. vasorum and D. immitis have there-
fore to be accounted for. Furthermore, in non-endemic
* Correspondence: manuela.schnyder@uzh.ch
Institute of Parasitology, Vetsuisse Faculty, Winterthurerstrasse 266a, 8057,
Zürich, Switzerland
© 2012 Schnyder and Deplazes; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use,
distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Schnyder and Deplazes Parasites & Vectors 2012, 5:258
http://www.parasitesandvectors.com/content/5/1/258
areas of D. immitis, this agent has to be considered
based on anamnestic information (travelling with pet
dogs or imports) and differentiated from A. vasorum
infections.
Fatal clinical consequences of D. immitis infection are
usually prevented by the monthly use of macrocyclic lac-
tones in known endemic areas [15-17], and treatment of
dirofilariosis is based on the intramuscular application of
the arsenic derivate melarsomine [18] and/or, alterna-
tively, by eliminating the endosymbiont Wolbachia with
doxycycline supported by administration of macrocyclic
lactones [19]. Dogs infected with A. vasorum, instead,
are treated using macrocyclic lactones such as moxidec-
tin [20] or milbemycin-oxime [13], or applying fenben-
dazole [21]. Prophylactic treatment (with macrocyclic
lactones) against potentially fatal canine angiostrongylo-
sis is, as for dirofilariosis, recommended in highly en-
demic and well known areas [20].
The currently used diagnostic laboratory methods for
the detection of these parasites are divergent. The diag-
nosis of D. immitis is based on the detection of microfil-
ariae or circulating antigens released by mature adult
female worms into the blood circulation, both being de-
tectable starting from 6 months after infection [18]. A
variety of tests have been developed for the detection of
circulating antigens, employing lateral flow immuno-
chromatographic techniques, membrane ELISAs or con-
ventional ELISAs [22-24]. Test evaluations showed that
the sensitivity of heartworm antigen tests depends on
the worm burden, and the sex and age of the parasites
[24-28], while the specificity of the kits is regularly indi-
cated to be very high, between 95% and 100%
[23,25,26,29,30]. However, only occasionally were poten-
tial cross-reactions evaluated in animals with natural or
experimental infections with other helminths, mainly
against other filarial nematodes such as Dipetalonema
reconditum [22,31] or Dirofilaria repens, indicating that
modern test kits may overcome cross-reactions detected
in previously developed test kits for these parasites
[32,33], and, rarely, against intestinal parasites such as
Ancylostoma caninum and Trichuris spp. [22,34]. The
most current diagnostic method for detection of A.
vasorum infections in dogs is the isolation of first stage
larvae (L1) from faecal samples, which are produced by
the parasites approximately 67 weeks after infection.
Larval migration techniques such as the Baermann-
Wetzel method [35] are commonly adopted. Further-
more, ELISAs for the detection of antibodies against A.
vasorum have been described [7,9], and, recently, tests
for the detection of circulating antigen of A. vasorum
have been developed. These latter ones have been evalu-
ated for cross-reactions against Crenosoma vulpis [8,10]
and also against intestinal parasites (Toxocara canis,
Ancylostoma caninum) and, importantly, against D.
immitis [8], showing a high specificity (94-100%).
Due to their common localization within the definitive
hosts, their considerable size and particularly the well
documented production of circulating antigens [31,36],
it was argued that antigens of A. vasorum and D. immitis
may share epitopes responsible for potential cross-
reactions in antigen detection tests. This hypothesis has
been confirmed during the development of the ELISA
for the detection of circulating antigen for A. vasorum
[8].
The aim of the study was to evaluate potential cross-
reactions of sera from dogs experimentally infected with
A. vasorum in six different commercially available tests
for the detection of D. immitis antigen.
Methods
A total of 16 sera from dogs experimentally inocu-
lated with 200 third stage larvae (L3) of A. vasorum
were obtained during previously performed studies
[20,37]. Infection of dogs was confirmed by positive
Baermann-Wetzel analyses [35], by the detection of
circulating A. vasorum antigen [8] and by the pres-
ence of adult worms at necropsy adopting an estab-
lished method of reverse lung perfusion [20]. The
day of sample collection (between 55 and 356, mean
101) after inoculation (dpi) and the number of
detected parasites at necropsy are shown in Table 1.
Worm burdens varied between 10 and 170 adult parasites,
with a mean of 66 worms per dog. Dirofilaria immitis
infection was excluded based on the fact that the dogs
were living in a non-endemic area under controlled ex-
perimental conditions, and at necropsy.
All tests were performed blinded with an identity
code from 1 to 16, by veterinarians (fast tests) or by
experienced laboratory technicians from the IPZ
(ELISAs).
All sera were non-haemolytic, stored at 20°C and
tested within 1140 months after collection. The follow-
ing test kits were used, adopting the manufacturers in-
struction and within the indicated expiry dates:
1) Witness
W
Dirofilaria, lateral flow (Synbiotics, San
Diego, USA)
2) SensPERT
W
Canine Heartworm, lateral flow (VetAll
Laboratories, Kyunggi-Do, South Korea)
3) SNAP
W
HTWM RT, membrane ELISA (IDEXX
Laboratories, Westbrook, USA)
4) SNAP
W
4Dx
W
Plus, membrane ELISA (IDEXX
Laboratories, Westbrook, USA)
5) Petchek
W
HTWM PF Antigen Test , ELISA (IDEXX,
Westbrook, USA)
6) DiroCHEK
W
, ELISA (Synbiotics San Diego, USA)
Schnyder and Deplazes Parasites & Vectors 2012, 5:258 Page 2 of 5
http://www.parasitesandvectors.com/content/5/1/258
Results
Single test results are shown in Table 1. All tests, with
one exception (see Tab. 1, dog Av 8) fulfilled the criteria
for test validity based on the results of positive and/or
negative controls.
The ELISA for the detection of circulating A. vasorum
antigen was highly positive for all experimentally
infected dogs, with absorbance values (optical density
read at 405 nm, OD) varying between 0.263 and 2.007
(cut-off value: 0.159, as previously described [8]), with a
mean of 1.096.
In three fast tests (Witness
W
, SensPERT
W
,SNAP
W
4Dx
W
Plus) all sera resulted negative, while in one fast
membrane ELISA (SNAP
W
HTWM RT) four A. vasorum
infected dogs were positive for D. immitis antigen, and
one serum delivered a non-valid result twice. In the
PetChek
W
-ELISA two methods for interpretation were
adopted: following the instruction for veterinary practi-
tioners based on eye detection, 5 dogs resulted positive
for D. immitis infection, while following the instructions
under laboratory conditions with OD measurements, a
total of 8 dogs were seropositive. With the DiroCHEK
W
-
ELISA, a single A. vasorum infected dog was D. immitis
seropositive. With one exception (76 dpi), all cross-
reactions were observed in dogs infected with A.
vasorum for more than 90 days, with worm burdens
varying from 10170.
Discussion
This study provides evidence of false positive reactions
in D. immitis antigen detection kits with sera of dogs
infected with A. vasorum. The two ELISAs for D. immi-
tis detection (PetChek
W
and DiroCHEK
W
) and the mem-
brane ELISA SNAP
W
HTWM RT showed single cross-
reactions against A. vasorum, which had not been con-
sidered so far. In contrast, the adopted ELISA for the de-
tection of circulating A. vasorum antigen has been
developed evaluating different monoclonal antibodies,
which had been selectively chosen based on their ab-
sence of cross-reactivity against D. immitis circulating
antigens, resulting in an overall high specificity [8].
Table 1 Comparative results of 16 sera from dogs experimentally inoculated with Angiostrongylus vasorum (Av) tested
with 6 different diagnostic kits for the detection of D. immitis antigen and with an ELISA for detection of A. vasorum
circulating antigen [8]
Dog-ID Days post
inoculation
(dpi)
Worm
burden
(n)
A. vasorum
antigen detection
(optical density)
1
Diagnostic test kits for the detection of Dirofilaria immitis antigen
Witness
W
SensPERT
W
SNAP
W
HTWM RT
2
SNAP
W
4Dx
W
Plus
PetChek
W
(veterinary
practice
conditions)
3
PetChek
W
(laboratory
conditions)
3
DiroCHEK
W
Av 1 55 49 1.484 neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg.
Av 2 55 54 1.825 neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg.
Av 3 55 106 1.743 neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg.
Av 4 55 129 1.400 neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg.
Av 5 55 134 1.485 neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. pos. neg.
Av 6 59 57 0.567 neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg.
Av 7 59 98 0.657 neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg.
Av 8 76 32 0.263 neg. neg. not valid neg. low pos. pos. pos.
Av 9 76 42 0.520 neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg.
Av 10 76 68 1.007 neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. pos. neg.
Av 11 90 13 0.879 neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. pos. neg.
Av 12 90 30 1.069 neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg. neg.
Av 13
4
91 10 1.264 neg. neg. low pos. neg. low pos. pos. neg.
Av 14
4
91 170 1.396 neg. neg. low pos. neg. low pos. pos. neg.
Av 15 286 36 2.007 neg. neg. low pos. neg. pos. pos. neg.
Av 16 356 24 1.357 neg. neg. low pos. neg. pos. pos. neg.
1
: optical density values read at 405 nm.
2
: SNAP
W
HTWM RT test differentiates between low positive (low pos.) and positive results.
3
: The interpretation of PetChek
W
results can be done under an In-clinic-protocol based on subjective colour evaluation or under the Laboratory protocolby
measuring the optical densities at 650 nm and a cut-off calculation based on positive and negative controls.
4
: dog Av 13 and Av 14 were inoculated with 50 and 500 L3, respectively.
neg.: negative.
pos.: positive.
Schnyder and Deplazes Parasites & Vectors 2012, 5:258 Page 3 of 5
http://www.parasitesandvectors.com/content/5/1/258
Generally, D. immitis antigen tests are considered to
be more sensitive than microfilariae concentration meth-
ods or other procedures [38]. In particular, the ELISA
technology has been shown to be more sensitive than
lateral flow immunochromatography [26] for the diagno-
sis of heartworm infected dogs. Reasons for the occur-
rence of false negative results with sera of D. immitis
positive dogs have been discussed in previously per-
formed studies evaluating different D. immitis test kits.
Low worm burden and low number of female worms
have been shown to reduce sensitivity of the tests
[25,26,39]. However, increased sensitivity may be
coupled with lower specificity and, importantly, with po-
tential cross-reactions against A. vasorum. An unknown
number of dogs with travel anamnesis and testing posi-
tive for circulating heartworm antigen may have falsely
been diagnosed positive due to A. vasorum cross-reac-
tions, and erroneously treated with melarsomine and/or
macrocyclic lactones. Therefore, serological results for
D. immitis should be confirmed or excluded by add-
itional diagnostic tests (Knotts test for microfilariae of
D. immitis, or serology or Baermann migration test for
L1 of A. vasorum) or diagnostic imaging frequently deli-
vering pathognomonic findings for heart dirofilariosis
[40,41] or angiostrongylosis [42,43].
Conclusions
In this study we confirmed that sera of dogs infected
with A. vasorum cross-react in commercially available
test kits for the detection of circulating D. immitis anti-
gen. The simultaneous use of highly specific diagnostic
tools is recommended for epidemiological studies where
both heart worm species occur or for individual dogs
with a suspected heart worm infection.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authorscontributions
MS participated in the design of the study, collected the samples, carried out
the diagnostic assays and drafted the manuscript. PD conceived the study
and implemented the draft of the manuscript. Both authors have read and
approved the final manuscript.
Acknowledgements
Authors sincerely thank Christine Sperlich and Vera Kaspar for technical
assistance, Dr. Jeongmi Kim (VetAll Laboratories, Korea) for the free provision
of the test kits and IDEXX Laboratories for providing of SNAP
W
4Dx
W
Plus
test kits.
Received: 26 September 2012 Accepted: 8 November 2012
Published: 13 November 2012
References
1. Theis JH: Public health aspects of dirofilariasis in the United States. Vet
Parasitol 2005, 133(23):157180.
2. Villeneuve A, Goring J, Marcotte L, Overvelde S: Seroprevalence of Borrelia
burgdorferi, Anaplasma phagocytophilum, Ehrlichia canis, and Dirofilaria
immitis among dogs in Canada. Can Vet J 2011, 52(5):527530.
3. Capdebielle H: Embolie cérébrale produit par Strongylus vasorum.Rev Vét
1911, 36(68):144147.
4. Conboy GA: Canine angiostrongylosis: the French heartworm:
an emerging threat in North America. Vet Parasitol 2011,
176(4):382389.
5. Traversa D, Di Cesare A, Conboy G: Canine and feline cardiopulmonary
parasitic nematodes in Europe: emerging and underestimated. Parasit
Vectors 2010, 3:62.
6. Koch J, Willesen JL: Canine pulmonary angiostrongylosis: An update. Vet J
2009, 179(3):348359.
7. Cury MC, Lima WS, Vitor RWA: Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay
(ELISA) for the diagnosis of Angiostrongylus vasorum (Baillet, 1866)
infection in dogs. Revue Méd Vét 1996, 147(7):525530.
8. Schnyder M, Tanner I, Webster P, Barutzki D, Deplazes P: An ELISA for
sensitive and specific detection of circulating antigen of Angiostrongylus
vasorum in serum samples of naturally and experimentally infected
dogs. Vet Parasitol 2011, 179:152158.
9. Schucan A, Schnyder M, Tanner I, Barutzki D, Traversa D, Deplazes P:
Detection of specific antibodies in dogs infected with Angiostrongylus
vasorum.Vet Parasitol 2012, 185:216224.
10. Verzberger-Epshtein I, Markham RJ, Sheppard JA, Stryhn H, Whitney H,
Conboy GA: Serologic detection of Angiostrongylus vasorum infection in
dogs. Vet Parasitol 2008, 151(1):5360.
11. Al-Sabi MN, Deplazes P, Webster P, Willesen JL, Davidson RK, Kapel CM: PCR
detection of Angiostrongylus vasorum in faecal samples of dogs and
foxes. Parasitol Res 2010, 107:135140.
12. Jefferies R, Morgan ER, Shaw SE: A SYBR green real-time PCR assay for the
detection of the nematode Angiostrongylus vasorum in definitive and
intermediate hosts. Vet Parasitol 2009, 166(12):112118.
13. Conboy G: Natural infections of Crenosoma vulpis and Angiostrongylus
vasorum in dogs in Atlantic Canada and their treatment with
milbemycin oxime. Vet Rec 2004, 155(1):1618.
14. Morgan ER, Jefferies R, Krajewski M, Ward P, Shaw SE: Canine pulmonary
angiostrongylosis: the influence of climate on parasite distribution.
Parasitol Int 2009, 58(4):406410.
15. Arther RG, Bowman DD, Slone RL, Travis LE: Imidacloprid plus moxidectin
topical solution for the prevention of heartworm disease (Dirofiloria
immitis) in dogs. Parasitol Res 2005, 97(Suppl 1):S76S80.
16. Clemence RG, Sarasola P, Genchi C, Smith DG, Shanks DJ, Jernigan AD,
Rowan TG: Efficacy of selamectin in the prevention of adult heartworm
(Dirofilaria immitis) infection in dogs in northern Italy. Vet Parasitol 2000,
91(34):251258.
17. Genchi C, Rossi L, Cardini G, Kramer LH, Venco L, Casiraghi M, Genchi M,
Agostini A: Full season efficacy of moxidectin microsphere sustained
release formulation for the prevention of heartworm (Dirofilaria immitis)
infection in dogs. Vet Parasitol 2002, 110(12):8591.
18. McCall JW, Genchi C, Kramer LH, Guerrero J, Venco L: Heartworm disease
in animals and humans. Adv Parasitol 2008, 66:193285.
19. Bazzocchi C, Mortarino M, Grandi G, Kramer LH, Genchi C, Bandi C,
Genchi M, Sacchi L, McCall JW: Combined ivermectin and doxycycline
treatment has microfilaricidal and adulticidal activity against
Dirofilaria immitis in experimentally infected dogs. Int J Parasitol 2008,
38(12):14011410.
20. Schnyder M, Fahrion A, Ossent P, Kohler L, Webster P, Heine J, Deplazes P:
Larvicidal effect of imidacloprid/moxidectin spot-on solution in dogs
experimentally inoculated with Angiostrongylus vasorum.Vet Parasitol
2009, 166:326332.
21. Willesen JL, Kristensen AT, Jensen AL, Heine J, Koch J: Efficacy and safety of
imidacloprid/moxidectin spot-on solution and fenbendazole in the
treatment of dogs naturally infected with Angiostrongylus vasorum
(Baillet, 1866). Vet Parasitol 2007, 147(34):258264.
22. Gillis JM, Smith RD, Todd KS Jr: Diagnostic criteria for an enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay for occult heartworm disease: standardization of
the test system in naturally exposed dogs. Am J Vet Res 1984,
45(11):22892292.
23. Atwell RB, Sheridan AB, Baldock FC: An evaluation of the Dirochek test
for detection of Dirofilaria immitis antigen in dogs. Austr Vet J 1988,
65(5):161162.
24. Lee AC, Bowman DD, Lucio-Forster A, Beall MJ, Liotta JL, Dillon R:
Evaluation of a new in-clinic method for the detection of canine
heartworm antigen. Vet Parasitol 2011, 177(34):387391.
Schnyder and Deplazes Parasites & Vectors 2012, 5:258 Page 4 of 5
http://www.parasitesandvectors.com/content/5/1/258
25. Atkins CE: Comparison of results of three commercial heartworm antigen
test kits in dogs with low heartworm burdens. J Am Vet Med Ass 2003,
222(9):12211223.
26. Courtney CH, Zeng Q: Comparison of heartworm antigen test kit
performance in dogs having low heartworm burdens. Vet Parasitol 2001,
96(4):317322.
27. Martini M, Capelli G, Poglayen G, Bertotti F, Turilli C: The validity of some
haematological and ELISA methods for the diagnosis of canine
heartworm disease. Vet Res Commun 1996, 20(4):331339.
28. Rawlings CA, Tonelli Q, Lewis RE, Duncan JR: Semiquantitative test for
Dirofilaria immitis as a predictor of thromboembolic complications
associated with heartworm treatment in dogs. Am J Vet Res 1993,
54(6):914919.
29. Levine SE, Mossler JA, Woodard BH: Dirofilaria immitis: a zoonosis of
clinical concern. South Med J 1980, 73(6):749750.
30. Martini M, Poglayen G, Capelli G, Roda R: Diagnosis of canine filariosis:
relative sensitivity and specificity of some haematological techniques.
Angew Parasitol 1991, 32(3):133136.
31. Weil GJ, Malane MS, Powers KG: Detection of circulating parasite antigens
in canine dirofilariasis by counterimmunoelectrophoresis. AmJTrop Med
Hyg 1984, 33(3):425430.
32. Di Sacco B: Valutazioni comparative e problemi nell'uso di diversi kit
diagnostici per la filariosi. Veterinaria 1993, 7(2):2027.
33. Pantchev N, Etzold M, Daugschies A, Dyachenko V: Diagnosis of imported
canine filarial infections in Germany 20082010. Parasitol Res 2011,
109(Suppl 1):S61S76.
34. Brunner CJ, Hendrix CM, Blagburn BL, Hanrahan LA: Comparison of
serologic tests for detection of antigen in canine heartworm infections.
J Am Vet Med Ass 1988, 192(10):14231427.
35. Eckert J, Friedhoff KT, Zahner H, Deplazes P (Eds): Lehrbuch der Parasitologie
für die Tiermedizin. 2nd edition. Stuttgart: Enke Verlag; 2008.
36. Ehrenberg JP, Tamashiro WK, Scott AL: Dirofilaria immitis: identification
and characterization of circulating parasite antigens. Exp Parasitol 1987,
63(2):205214.
37. Schnyder M, Fahrion A, Riond B, Ossent P, Webster P, Kranjc A, Glaus T,
Deplazes P: Clinical, laboratory and pathological findings in dogs
experimentally infected with Angiostrongylus vasorum.Parasitol Res 2010,
107:14711480.
38. Vezzani D, Fontanarrosa MF, Eiras DF: Are antigen test kits efficient for
detecting heartworm-infected dogs at the southern distribution limit of
the parasite in South America? Preliminary results. Res Vet Sci 2008,
85(1):113115.
39. Klotins KC, Martin SW, Bonnett BN, Peregrine AS: Canine heartworm testing
in Canada: are we being effective? Can Vet J 2000, 41(12):929937.
40. Lonsky JM, Thrall DE, Lewis RE: Thoracic radiographic abnormalities in
200 dogs with heartworm-induced cor pulmonale. Vet Radiol 1983,
24:120123.
41. Badertscher RR, Losonsky JM, Paul AJ, Kneller SK: Two-dimensional
echocardiography for diagnosis of dirofilariasis in nine dogs. J Am Vet
Med Ass 1988, 193(7):843846.
42. Dennler M, Makara M, Kranjc A, Schnyder M, Ossent P, Deplazes P, Ohlerth
S, Glaus TM: Thoracic computed tomography findings in dogs
experimentally infected with Angiostrongylus vasorum.Vet Radiol
Ultrasound 2011, 52(3):289294.
43. Kranjc A, Schnyder M, Dennler M, Fahrion A, Makara M, Ossent P, Morgan J,
Deplazes P, Glaus TM: Pulmonary artery thrombosis in experimental
Angiostrongylus vasorum infection does not result in pulmonary
hypertension and echocardiographic right ventricular changes. J Vet Int
Med 2010, 24:855862.
doi:10.1186/1756-3305-5-258
Cite this article as: Schnyder and Deplazes: Cross-reactions of sera from
dogs infected with Angiostrongylus vasorum in commercially available
Dirofilaria immitis test kits. Parasites & Vectors 2012 5:258.
Submit your next manuscript to BioMed Central
and take full advantage of:
Convenient online submission
Thorough peer review
No space constraints or color figure charges
Immediate publication on acceptance
Inclusion in PubMed, CAS, Scopus and Google Scholar
Research which is freely available for redistribution
Submit your manuscript at
www.biomedcentral.com/submit
Schnyder and Deplazes Parasites & Vectors 2012, 5:258 Page 5 of 5
http://www.parasitesandvectors.com/content/5/1/258
... These samples were identified in Arkansas (n = 4), Arizona (n = 2), Massachusetts (n = 4), Minnesota (n = 2), New Hampshire (n = 1), Nevada (n = 9), Ohio (n = 4), and Oregon (n = 1), representing 0.5% of the total samples tested. False-positive results are reported in wildlife species infected with other nematodes belonging to the Dirofilaria genus and in samples without heat treatment [6,8,[29][30][31][32]. Heat treatment is unlikely to induce cross-reactions, according to one study which used positive samples from dogs confirmed by necropsy [9]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: Heartworm disease (HWD) is a vector-borne disease caused by the filarial nematode Dirofilaria immitis. Low antigen levels caused by immune complex formation preclude HWD diagnosis. Heat treatment is an immune complex dissociation technique used to enhance antigen detection. Only a few studies have reported the benefits of heat treatment in nationwide surveys. Methods: To investigate the impact of heat treatment on the seroprevalence of HWD in companion dogs in the USA, serum samples (n = 3253) were analyzed for D. immitis antigen (DiroCHEK®, Zoetis) without and with heat treatment of the samples. Results: Compared to sera without heat treatment, heat treatment significantly increased overall prevalence from 3.8% (123/3253) to 7.3% (237/3253) (p < 10−4), expanding antigen detection from 32 to 39 of the 48 states and Washington District of Columbia included in this study. Conclusions: This study represents the largest nationwide survey of HW antigen detection in dogs in the US applying heat treatment to canine sera. The heat treatment used herein has the advantage of requiring a low volume of serum, making it optimal for use in routine diagnosis. Heat treatment should be used routinely by reference laboratories and veterinary clinics in patients with a negative initial test.
... It is important to remember that the Knott's test allows to estimate microfilariaemia, to evaluate, in association with antigen test, the presence of occult infections of D. immitis and to identify the different species of circulating microfilariae (e.g., D. immitis, D. repens, Acanthocheilonema reconditum). Furthermore, reliance on the antigen test alone may give false positive results due to potential cross-reactivity of enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and immunochromatographic tests for D. immitis with other filarial nematodes such as D. repens, Angiostrongylus vasorum and Spirocerca lupi (Schnyder and Deplazes, 2012;Aroch et al., 2015). In the clinical practice, the Knott's test has excellent sensitivity (Ciuca et al., 2020), but it has an operator-dependent specificity as reported in European guidelines (ESCCAP, 2019). ...
... Because false-positive antigen test results are uncommon, a positive result generally indicates a current infection (Snyder et al. 2000). However, test kits for dogs have potential cross-reactions with Angiostrongylus vasorum and Spirocerca lupi (Schnyder and Deplazes, 2012;Aroch et al., 2015). The current status of the lung worm and the esophageal worm in cats in Thailand is unknown, so that cross-reactivity between D. immitis and other feline nematodes in commercially available antigen test kits is not clearly explained. ...
... It is important to remember that the Knott's test allows to estimate microfilariaemia, to evaluate, in association with antigen test, the presence of occult infections of D. immitis and to identify the different species of circulating microfilariae (e.g., D. immitis, D. repens, Acanthocheilonema reconditum). Furthermore, reliance on the antigen test alone may give false positive results due to potential cross-reactivity of enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and immunochromatographic tests for D. immitis with other filarial nematodes such as D. repens, Angiostrongylus vasorum and Spirocerca lupi (Schnyder and Deplazes, 2012;Aroch et al., 2015). In the clinical practice, the Knott's test has excellent sensitivity (Ciuca et al., 2020), but it has an operator-dependent specificity as reported in European guidelines (ESCCAP, 2019). ...
... Moreover, all dogs were previously tested for Leishmania (before this study) and none of them resulted positive. However, to exclude possible crossreactions with Angiostrongylus vasorum to the antigenic test of D. immitis, which has been reported (22), all dogs in this study were tested for A. vasorum antigen, but the result was negative. ...
Article
Full-text available
In southern Italy, the number of autochthonous cases of Dirofilaria immitis in dogs has increased considerably. This also occurs in the Campania region, particularly in coastal areas, where infections with D. immitis and Dirofilaria repens have been reported more frequently. Therefore the aim of the present study was to better investigate the occurrence of Dirofilaria spp. in a local dog shelter in Castel Volturno (Campania region, southern Italy). Briefly, a total of 260 blood samples were analysed for identification of microfilariae (mff) and detection of Dirofilaria immitis antigen. Dogs were classified according to their age (1–3 years; 4–6 years; 7–11 years; > 11 years) and length of stay in the shelter at the time of sampling (dogs that entered in the shelter in the last 4 months; dogs housed in the shelter for more than 4 months up to 2 years; dogs housed for more than 2 years). The modified Knott’s test revealed that 195 dogs (75.0%) were positive for circulating mff of Dirofilaria spp. Specifically, 104/260 (40.0%) dogs were positive for D. immitis and 91/260 (35.0%) were positive for D. repens. In addition, 72/260 (27.7%) dogs had both D. immitis and D. repens mff. Antigen testing revealed that 78/260 (30.0%) dogs were positive for D. immitis. However, 26/104 (25.0%) of the dogs with D. immitis mff were antigen-negative. The overall k concordance between the modified Knott’s test and the antigenic test was ≤0.2 (poor) (p = 0.000). The results of the logistic regression model showed a significant association between Dirofilaria exposure and the period of time the dogs had spent in the shelter at the time of sampling. Dogs housed in the shelter for 4 months (group 1) and between 4 months and 2 years (group 2) had higher Dirofilaria positivity than dogs in group 3 (housed for more than 2 years) (80.4% vs. 79.6% vs. 62.4%, respectively). Moreover, male dogs and older dogs (between 7 and 11 years of age) were more likely to be infected with Dirofilaria spp.
... This method is known to be sensitive for screening a population of apparently healthy dogs or for confirming a clinically suspected D. immitis infection presenting a sensitivity greater than 90% in dogs infected with one adult female worm and 100% in dogs infected with more than one adult female Henry et al., 2018;Laidoud et al., 2019;Panarese et al., 2020). Although these are highly specific and sensitive for D. immitis, recent work has demonstrated limitations in specificity due to cross-reactions with D. repens or Angiostrongylus vasorum (Schnyder and Deplazes, 2012;Venco et al., 2017;Alho et al., 2018). In these cases, diagnosis depends on examining the microfilariae, usually applying a modified Knott test and PCR. ...
Article
Dirofilariasis is a vector-borne disease frequent in many countries. Not only infected dogs, but also cats and wild canids (including wolves and foxes), represent important sources of infection for mosquitoes, which are the pathogen vectors. The disease is endemic in Mediterranean countries with increasing incidence in Italy, France, Greece and Spain, but limited epidemiological data is available from Portugal regarding its distribution and impact. Aiming to clarify this, canine whole blood samples (n = 244) from the north of Portugal were tested for Dirofilaria spp. antigens by use of a commercial rapid immunomigration test. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and the modified Knott test were also used to assess the presence of microfilariae. Results were also compared to assess the performance of each test used. Of the 244 animals tested, 118 (48.4%) were positive for Dirofilaria immitis (heartworm) in the serological adult worm rapid antigen detection test, and 36 (14.8%) had circulating microfilariae, identified as D. immitis. A combined positivity of 51.6 % (126/244) was found. Results indicate that the risk of exposure to D. immitis in dogs is high in this region of Portugal, and that prophylaxis against the parasite is advisable to decrease the occurrence of canine infection and disease. The present study highlights the diagnostic value of serological and molecular tests in determining the prevalence of D. immitis.
... Cross-reactivity between D. immitis and Acanthocheilonema species such as A. reconditum and A. odendhali was previously described [30,31]. Additionally, shared epitopes are reported between D. immitis and other nematode species such as Toxocara canis and Angiostrongylus vasorum [30,[32][33][34]. Our findings underline the need for new biomarkers for rapid diagnostic tests that could detect not only D. immitis, but also other filarial species. ...
Article
Full-text available
Different nematodes affect canines, however Acanthocheilonema reconditum was considered mostly a non-pathogenic parasite. Climate change, animal migration, and other factors transformed the dynamics of vector-borne diseases, including filariasis. Since 2016, a sudden increase in the number of dogs with microfilaremia was reported by different veterinary centers in Cali, southwest Colombia. The objective of this study was to molecularly identify the etiologic agent of this filariasis outbreak detected in this city, using PCR–RFLP and evaluating dogs’ clinical signs. From 2018–2019, canine filariasis cases were prospectively evaluated after a microscopic test, recruiting 82 cases and 43 healthy controls from 2971 samples. Acanthocheilonema reconditum (Nematoda, Onchocercidae) was identified in 61.3% of the cases (49/82) by PCR–RFLP. Sanger sequencing of the 5.8S ribosomal RNA gene and internal transcribed spacer-2 fragment was additionally performed on seven cases, confirming A. reconditum in all of them. The filariasis cases are statistically associated with male dogs who have clinical signs of anemia, low levels of hemoglobin and hematocrit (p < 0.0001), and high levels of plasma proteins (p < 0.001). This emerging canine disease constitutes an important public health concern among veterinarians and active surveillance is advised to explore its zoonotic potential.
Book
GUIDE OF MAIN INFECTIOUS DISEASES TRANSMITTED FROM NON-HUMAN ANIMALS TO HUMANS – DIROFILARIOSIS IN HUMANS AND ANIMALS
Article
Full-text available
In order to evaluate the prevalence of heartworm disease in the SouthEast of Romania, we collected blood from 40 dogs from a shelter in Galati, which were examined by several methods for the Dirofilaria immitis and Dirofilaria repenes microfilariae identification, and for the detection of Dirofilaria immitis antigen respectively. Eleven dogs were positive for microfilariae (27.5%), of which 3/11 were co-infections and only 1/40 had D. repens microfilariae detected. Following serological test, D. immitis antigen was detected in 30% of the investigated serum samples (12/40). The high prevalence of heartworm disease requires continuous monitoring of symptomatic dogs, but also of the asymptomatic ones from shelters or of those from veterinary clinics in endemic areas. Furthermore, the mosquito populations control in endemic areas is mandatory.
Article
Parasitic diseases are considered to be a cause of oxidative stress which leads to oxidative damage of various molecules including DNA. This can result in mutations, replication errors, and genome instability. Therefore, aim of this study was to measure DNA damage induced by Dirofilaria immitis in the single cells such as dogs' leukocytes using the comet assay. Also, we monitored the effects of antiparasitic treatment on mitigation of sensitivity to DNA damage in leukocytes treated with H2O2 using the in vivo and ex vivo comet assay. The whole blood samples from 34 dogs from Serbia were used, both males and females, from one to 13 years old, both pure and mixed-breeds. A rapid immunochromatographic test (Antigen Rapid Heartworm Ag 2.0 Test Kit, Bionote, Minnesota, USA) was used for the detection of D. immitis antigens. The modified Knott's test and PCR were used in the aim of detecting D. immitis microfilariae in dogs' blood, and evaluating the number of circulating microfilariae during the treatment. The genotoxicity evaluation showed that D. immitis infection resulted in DNA damage in naturally infected dogs, with the highest DNA damage occurring in the group of dogs with severe clinical signs. Treatment with ivermectin and doxycycline decreased DNA damage in leukocytes of dogs in all groups, as the intensity of infection decreased due to applied therapy. Ex vivo comet assay results showed that leukocytes exhibited decreased sensitivity to H2O2-induced DNA damage during treatment. The results of the modified Knott's test and PCR in our study showed that treatment with ivermectin and doxycycline was successful in decreasing the average number of microfilariae during the time and at the end eliminating them from the dogs' blood.
Article
Full-text available
The seropositivity of dogs to Borrelia burgdorferi, Anaplasma phagocytophilum, and Ehrlichia canis antibodies, and Dirofilaria immitis antigen was assessed in Canada. Borrelia burgdorferi had the highest seroprevalence, while that of Dirofilaria immitis has not changed significantly in the past 20 y. The risk for these vector-borne infectious agents in Canadian dogs is low but widespread with foci of higher prevalence.
Article
Full-text available
Filarial infections of dogs are attracting attention across Europe because of the risk of spread into previously non-endemic areas (e.g. Dirofilaria repens with Culicidae as vectors) and as emerging zoonotic agents. The occurrence of filarial infections in German dogs has been analysed based on 8,545 samples collected either from imported animals or following travel into endemic regions. All samples were tested by means of modified Knott's test and heartworm antigen assay within the period 2008 - 2010. Heartworm antigen was detected in 127 samples (1.49 %; 95 % CI: 1.25 - 1.77 %), but only 38 dogs also had microfilariae in their blood samples. On the other hand, 125 animals (1.46 %; 95 % CI: 1.23 - 1.74 %) were only positive in the Knott's test. For discrimination by means of PCR and sequencing a total of 73 blood samples as well as two samples of adult worms were included, which have been sent by veterinarians during 2008 - 2010. A mono-infection caused by D. repens was detected in 35 cases, while D. immitis was proven in 15 samples, with 6 of these showing a combination of D. immitis and D. repens. Imported Dipetalonema dracunculoides (transmitted by Rhipicephalus sanguineus or Hippobosca longipennis) or Acanthocheilonema reconditum (fleas and lice serve as intermediate hosts) infections were diagnosed in 24 cases and in a single sample a co-infection of A. reconditum and D. repens was evident. D. repens was the most common filarial infection imported and it was introduced into Germany from eleven European countries. Slovenia and Hungary are reported for the first time as endemic for D. repens and A. reconditum, respectively. Furthermore this study reports, to the best of our knowledge, for the first time import of D. dracunculoides from the Canary Islands, A. reconditum from Majorca, D. immitis from Corfu and a co-infection of D. repens and A. reconditum from Spain as well as mixed infections of D. repens and D. immitis from Corfu, Sardinia and Bulgaria. Co-infections with other arthropod-borne infections as well as therapeutical follow-up were also considered. Selamectin (as spot-on formulation) was not able to clear microfilaraemia in dogs infected with either D. repens, A. reconditum or D. dracunculoides, whereas a topical moxidectin/imidacloprid formulation was able to eliminate microfilariae in one dog infected with A. reconditum.
Article
Two groups of seven crossbred dogs were inoculated, respectively, with 50 and 100 larvae/kg of body weight of Angiostrongylus vasorum. For 5 months, blood was collected to obtain serum for use in ELISA tests. ELISA detected specific antibodies anti-A. vasorum, from 14th day post-infection.
Article
Thoracic radiographs of 200 dogs with spontaneously occurring heartworm disease were reviewed. Radiographs of 28 dogs (14%) were normal. In the remaining 172 dogs various combinations of cardiopulmonary abnormalties were found. The most frequently observed combination, noted in 61 of 200 dogs, was right ventricular, main pulmonary, and right cranial lobar pulmonary artery enlargemetn. Dogs with severe increse of one parameter generally had severe increase of the other two parameters also. One hundred five of the 200 dogs had a right cranial lobar pulmonary artery of normal size. Thus, right cranial lobar pulmonary artery size, when normal, is not a sensitive indicator of the absence of heartworm disease. There was a statistically significant positive relation between the size of the caudal vena cava and that of the right ventricle.
Article
Canine angiostrongylosis, caused by the nematode Angiostrongylus vasorum, is an emerging cardiopulmonary disease in Europe which can be fatal if left untreated. We determined the diagnostic value of the specific detection of antibodies against A. vasorum adult somatic antigen, adult excretory/secretory (E/S) antigen and first stage larvae (L1) somatic antigen in ELISAs. Also, A. vasorum adult somatic antigen purified by monoclonal antibodies (mAb) was evaluated in a sandwich-ELISA. Among the crude antigens, the best sensitivities when testing 21 naturally infected dogs were obtained using adult E/S and somatic antigen (85.7% and 76.2%, respectively), which were comparable with the results of the sandwich-ELISA based on mAb-purified antigens (81%). The ELISA performed with L1 antigen had the lowest sensitivity (42.9%). In experimentally inoculated dogs, the sensitivities ranged from 97.7% to 100% with all test settings. The specificity was 98.8% (92.5-99.9%, 95% CI) with all ELISAs using sera of 82 randomly selected dogs. Cross-reactions using adult somatic, adult E/S and L1 somatic antigen were observed in sera of dogs infected with Crenosoma vulpis, Dirofilaria immitis, Dirofilaria repens, and Eucoleus aerophilus. In contrast, using the mAb-purified antigens, the cross-reactions were minimal. Depending on the antigens used, specific antibodies were detected starting between 13 and 21 days post experimental inoculation (dpi), and at latest between 35 and 48 dpi, thus before or around the onset of patency. The serological follow-up of four A. vasorum-infected dogs after anthelmintic treatment at 88 dpi showed a decrease of antibody levels after drug administration, and the animals became seronegative 2-9 weeks later. Two untreated dogs remained seropositive. In four dogs treated 4 dpi, virtually no antibody-reaction was detectable, with the exception of the ELISA performed with L1 antigen. The early detection of specific antibodies against A. vasorum by ELISA represents a valid alternative for a reliable diagnosis and for follow-up investigations after anthelmintic treatment.
Article
To characterize the computed tomography (CT) features of thoracic lesions caused by infection with Angiostrongylus vasorum, pre- and postcontrast CT was performed in six experimentally infected Beagles 13 weeks postinoculation and in four of these 9 weeks postchemotherapy. Findings were compared with survey radiographs and necropsy findings. A multicentric bronchoalveolar pattern more pronounced at the lung periphery was present radiographically. On CT, the predominant abnormality underlying this alveolar pattern was multiple large nodules merging to areas of consolidation, and containing air bronchograms of varying extent. These nodular changes corresponded to histopathologic granulomata, consisting mainly of macrophages, multinucleated giant cells, and lymphocytes that had accumulated around larvae and eggs. Morphologically, no bronchial changes were observed on CT or histologically. Quantitatively, however, on CT there was evidence of bronchial thickening at 13 weeks postinoculation and mild very peripheral bronchiectasia 9 weeks postchemotherapy. Regional lymph nodes were enlarged after infection, and smaller after treatment. On postcontrast CT, several suspicious intraluminal filling defects suggestive of thrombosis were found; however, the tortuosity of some pulmonary arteries seen radiographically was not present in CT images. After treatment, the consolidations and large nodules had almost completely disappeared. A remaining radiographic interstitial pattern was characterized on CT as ground-glass opacifications, subpleural interstitial thickening, subpleural lines, and interface signs. These interstitial changes reflected fibrosis as documented histopathologically. CT allowed very detailed and accurate characterization of pulmonary parenchymal lesions, bronchi, and lymphnodes and closely reflected histopathological changes.
Article
Canine angiostrongylosis is an emerging cardiopulmonary disease in Europe which can be fatal if left untreated. We developed a sandwich-ELISA based on a monoclonal antibody (mAb Av 56/1/2) and on polyclonal rabbit antibodies directed against Angiostrongylus vasorum adult excretory/secretory - antigen for the detection of circulating serum antigen of A. vasorum. The sensitivity of the test was 95.7% (78.1-99.9, 95% CI) as determined with sera of 23 dogs naturally infected with A. vasorum. The specificity was 94.0% (83.5-98.7, 95% CI) using 50 dog sera (control group) submitted for reasons other than parasitic infections. Potential cross-reactions were investigated with sera of a group of totally 61 dogs with proven infections with Dirofilaria immitis (n=23), Crenosoma vulpis (n=14), Ancylostoma caninum (n=4) or Toxocara canis (n=20). No significant difference was observed concerning the proportion of positive reactions between the control group and the group with proven helminth infections other than A. vasorum. In experimentally inoculated dogs with proven worm burdens of A. vasorum, the proportion of seropositive dogs increased over the first 3 months of infection, starting from 35 days post inoculation (dpi) which was before the onset of larval excretion. Ten weeks post inoculation, 98.6% of the dogs were seropositive, and circulating antigen persisted in two dogs with long-term follow-up over 286 and 356 days, respectively. In contrast, in dogs with a single treatment with imidacloprid/moxidectin at four or 32 dpi, no circulating antigen was observed, while in dogs treated at 88-92 dpi, OD values decreased within 13-34 days. The specific detection of circulating A. vasorum antigen by ELISA represents a valid alternative for reliable diagnosis and for follow-up investigations after anthelmintic treatment. Moreover, the test can be used for mass screening in large epidemiological investigations.
Article
Angiostrongylus vasorum, French heartworm, is a metastrongloid parasite found in the pulmonary arteries and right ventricle of wild and domestic canids and various other animals. The natural definitive hosts are species of foxes. The geographic distribution of the parasite includes various countries of Europe, Africa, South America, and North America. Angiostrongylosis is considered an emerging disease in dogs in Europe. In North America, autochthonous A. vasorum infection occurs only in the Canadian province of Newfoundland-Labrador. Computer modeling suggests there is a high probability that A. vasorum will spread to other parts of North America and will likely become endemic in the eastern half of the continent and in the states and provinces along the western coast. Animals acquire infection by the ingestion of gastropod or frog intermediate hosts that carry the infective 3rd-stage larvae. Frogs can also serve as paratenic hosts. Definitive antemortem diagnosis is by detection of L(1) in feces, sputum, or bronchoalveolar lavage samples. Baermann fecal examination is the most reliable method for fecal detection. However, false negative results can occur due to the typical erratic/sporadic fecal larval shedding pattern of A. vasorum. Recently, promising new methods for A. vasorum infection diagnosis have been reported involving polymerase chain reaction of blood and fecal samples and a sandwich ELISA for detection of circulating worm excretory/secretory antigen. Current treatment options include moxidectin, milbemycin oxime, and fenbendazole.