ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

The aim of this paper is to present a real-time interaction system for ancient artifacts digitally restored in a virtual environment. Using commercial hardware and open source software, Augmented Reality versions of archaeological artifacts are experienced on mobile devices both in a real outdoor site as well as an indoor museum. The case study for this project is represented by two artifacts of Syracuse, Italy, a statue and an altar, dated back to Hellenistic time. Virtual replicas of the two artifacts were produced applying different techniques. Later the two projects became part of the same research plan aimed to virtually rebuild the most significant artistic and architectural features of Hellenistic Syracuse. Besides the simple production of 3D models, via laserscanning and 3D modelling, a digital process of visual improvement of the statue was preliminary carried out based on photographic documentation of some archetypes. The commercial framework for mobile devices, ARToolworks, has been used for developing Augmented Reality applications. Using a pattern that is recognized by the device, the virtual model is shown as it is in the real world. The novelty of this work is that graduate students in virtual archaeology and non computer programmers such as museum staff, could benefit of this work and implement such a system.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Augmented Perception of the Past -
The Case of Hellenistic Syracuse
Filippo Stanco1, Davide Tanasi2, Giovanni Gallo1, Matteo Buffa1, Beatrice Basile3
1University of Catania, Dipartimento di Matematica e Informatica,
Viale A. Doria, 6 - 95125 Catania, Italy
Email: {fstanco, gallo}@dmi.unict.it
2Arcadia University, The College of Global Studies - AUMCAS,
Palazzo Ardizzone, via Roma, 124 - 96100 Siracusa, Italy
Email: tanasid@arcadia.edu
3Servizio Museo Archeologico Regionale Paolo Orsi di Siracusa,
Viale Teocrito, 66 - 96100 Siracusa, Italy
Email: museo.arche.orsi@regione.sicilia.it
Abstract The aim of this paper is to present a real-time
interaction system for ancient artifacts digitally restored in a
virtual environment. Using commercial hardware and open
source software, Augmented Reality versions of archaeologi-
cal artifacts are experienced on mobile devices both in a real
outdoor site as well as an indoor museum. The case study
for this project is represented by two artifacts of Syracuse,
Italy, a statue and an altar, dated back to Hellenistic time.
Virtual replicas of the two artifacts were produced applying
different techniques. Later the two projects became part of
the same research plan aimed to virtually rebuild the most
significant artistic and architectural features of Hellenistic
Syracuse. Besides the simple production of 3D models, via
laserscanning and 3D modelling, a digital process of visual
improvement of the statue was preliminary carried out based
on photographic documentation of some archetypes. The
commercial framework for mobile devices, ARToolworks,
has been used for developing Augmented Reality applica-
tions. Using a pattern that is recognized by the device, the
virtual model is shown as it is in the real world. The novelty
of this work is that graduate students in virtual archaeology
and non computer programmers such as museum staff,
could benefit of this work and implement such a system.
Index Terms Augmented reality, Laser scanning, 3D Mod-
elling, Real time interaction, Virtual heritage
I. INTRODUCTION
In the last fifty years, the growing use of computer
applications has become a main feature of archaeological
research [1]. It can now influence interpretation proce-
dures and revolutionize the language and contents of the
study of the past.
From its first definition by Reilly in 1990 [2], virtual
archaeology (VA) was intended as the use of digital recon-
struction in archaeology. Recently, new communicative
approaches to archaeological contents through the use of
This paper is based on “Augmented perception of the past. The case
of the Telamon from the Greek theater of Syracuse,” by F. Stanco,
D. Tanasi, M. Buffa, B. Basile, which appeared in the Proceedings of
International Workshop on Multimedia for Cultural Heritage (MM4CH
2011) May 3, 2011, Modena (Italy).
interactive strategies have been added [3]. 3D modeling is
especially very useful for the identification, monitoring,
conservation, restoration, and promotion of archaeological
artefacts. In this context, 3D computer graphics can
support archaeology and politics of cultural heritage by
offering scholars a “sixth sense” for understanding the
traces of the past, as it allows us to experience it [4].
3D documentation of extant archaeological remains or
building elements is an important part of collecting the
necessary data for a virtual archaeology project. New
developments facilitate this phase of documentation, in-
cluding the obtaining of correct measurements and ground
plans from photography, through the use of readily-
available equipment. This is important in restoring archae-
ological remains when older phases are reconstructed in
a virtual way. The original state, the restored state, and
eventual in–between states can be recorded easily through
photo–modeling technique [5].
In this paper a project of virtual archaeology focusing
on two artefacts of Hellenistic Syracuse (3rd century
BC) is presented. The two artifacts are a statue of a
Telamon (Fig. 1) held at the Archaeological Museum
of Syracuse and the altar of Hieron II (Fig. 2), to
which probably the Telamon belonged, located in the
western suburb of the city, in the so called ancient district
of Neapolis. Virtual replicas of the two artifacts were
produced applying different techniques as parts of two
originally separated projects and with diverse goals: to
monitor the degradation of the statue and to provide a
more accurate reconstruction of the altar, that is an unicum
without comparisons in the ancient Mediterranean. Later
the two projects became part of the same research plan
aimed to virtually rebuild the most significant buildings
of Hellenistic Syracuse.
II. THE AR CHE OMATI CA PROJ ECT
A state of the art experience in the field of digital
archaeology is represented by Archeomatica Project [6],
JOURNAL OF MULTIMEDIA, VOL. 7, NO. 2, MAY 2012
211
© 2012 ACADEMY PUBLISHER
doi:10.4304/jmm.7.2.211-216
(a) (b)
Figure 1. (a) Telamon in a photograph of 1927; (b) Telamon in a recent
photo.
Figure 2. Altar of Hieron II from the West. Red arrow indicates the
feet currently preserved of one Telamon.
[7], a research program started out in late 2007 at the Im-
age Processing Lab [8] of the University of Catania. The
main aim of the project is to produce automatic systems
of recognition and classification of graphic data, such as
figurative pottery decoration, through the use of computer
vision and pattern recognition techniques, and to develop
virtual models of ancient artefacts with a high degree of
accuracy using data from excavation, through application
of laser scanner and 3D modeling techniques managed
with open source software. This cognitive process is
based on peer-to-peer exchange of knowledge between
experts of computer science and archaeology working side
by side. A further goal of this research program is to
train graduate students as communication consultants for
virtual archaeology projects, giving them the opportunity
of attending stages with public institutions and of devel-
oping individual projects aimed to promotion of cultural
heritage. At the same time, through seminars and practical
workshops, the staff of museums and archaeological parks
are trained in the use of software and hardware solutions
for dealing with their work of knowledge dissemination.
III. VIS UAL IMPROVEMENT:TH E TELAMON
The first case study is represented by a Late Classical
Greek statue of a Telamon [9] coming from the south-
western district of the ancient Syracuse, named Neapolis,
where important public building as the theather and the
altar of Hieron II are located. This statue, currently on
display at the Archaeological Museum of Syracuse, is
made out of local calcarenite plastered with a mix of
marble dust and sand, and it is representing a satyr
version of the titan, with typical hairy legs and pointed
ears. Due to the materials used, the statue is subject
to cyclical degradation and even the restoration attempts
seem unsuccessful, as can be observed in Fig. 1. A virtual
copy of the statue can be used to monitor the degradation
and to present the statue in a new way.
The technique of 3D digital restoration of archaeo-
logical objects is perhaps the most common trend in
interdisciplinary projects related to the interpretation and
dissemination of archaeological knowledge. This is be-
cause of the potential that 3D has in subtracting the
archaeological goods from the destructive effects of at-
mospheric agents, of pollution, of time, and, in some
cases, of natural disasters and wars. The high–definition
3D laser scanner is an instrument that collects 3D data
from a given surface or object in a systematic, automated
manner, at a relatively high rate, in near real time using a
laser ray to establish the surface coordinates. Over the last
decade, this technology has been applied to archaeological
research to construct geometric models with different
characteristics [10]. Most archaeological work has been
carried out to digitize objects of an intermediate size, such
as settlement structures, statues, and vessels. The most
recent projects have been focused on modeling structures
during the excavation of archaeological sites, either of one
limited zone [11] or the complete ensemble [12]. These
studies have been carried out from the ground surface or
using helicopters and airplanes [13].
The possibility of obtaining a virtual, exact replica of
reality in a limited amount of time makes the laser scan-
ning method ideal for studies of 3D digital restoration,
where the virtual recomposition of fragmented elements,
both physically and narratively, is fundamental [14]. In
this field, the Archeomatica Project team of researchers
has proposed integrating the Blender–based 3D model-
ing [15] and image–based 3D modeling with the laser
scanning technique, in order to solve the problems of
possible data voids connected with complex scanning. The
laser scanner used is the compact and handy Next Engine
[16], and it is very versatile especially when the objects
to be scanned are placed in restricted spaces or cannot
be removed. It is an optical triangulation scanner that
offers a high degree of precision, allowing the creation
of good three-dimensional models of real subjects. Since
the Telamon was very large, a tripod was used with the
scanner in manual mode. For the alignment process the
software Meshlab [17] was used. It is rather suitable for
this kind of work offering a wide range of specific filters
to manipulate and improve data acquired in the previous
212
JOURNAL OF MULTIMEDIA, VOL. 7, NO. 2, MAY 2012
© 2012 ACADEMY PUBLISHER
(a) (b)
Figure 3. (a) Statue of Telamon, from Syracuse Museum; (b) 3D model
of the statue obtained with laser scanning technique.
Figure 4. Restoration analysis in virtual environment of the Telamon
acquired with laser scanning technique.
phase.
After filling gaps and data voids of 3D models (Fig.
3(b)), dark blotches and salt encrustations were removed
from the surfaces of the models. One detached ear was
fixed in its original position and the missing half part of
the body was replaced by a mirror of the preserved one.
In this way the overall appearance was optimized (Fig.
4).
IV. ARCHAEOLOGICAL 3D M ODELING:THE ALTAR
As clarified above, the second monument we worked
on is strictly connected with the Telamon. The altar of
Hieron II (Fig. 2) was built between 270 and 215 BC,
by the will of Hieron II, king of Syracuse at the time
[18]. Only its foundations,cut in the bedrock, remain. The
superstructure was made of calcareous limestone blocks
and was almost completely dismantled and re-used in the
Spanish fortifications of the 16th century. On the north
and south ends of the front, two symmetrically-placed
ramps gave access to the central platform where animal
sacrifices took place. Each ramp was preceded by an
entrance: at least the northern entrance was flanked by
two Telamons. On the right side, the feet of one statue
are still visible. Besides two attempts of reconstructing it
carried out by artists aiming to give general idea of this
impressive structure, no further recostructions have been
suggested until now (Fig. 5).
To test scholars’ hypothesis about the altar and its
use, an archaeological 3d modelling analysis has been
(a) (b)
Figure 5. Artistic reconstructions of the altar of Hieron II.
(a) (b)
Figure 6. (a) Virtual reconstruction of the altar; (b) 3D model of the
Telamon placed in its hypothetical position in the virtual reconstruction
of the altar.
carried out. Archaeological 3D modeling is basically the
recreation of landscapes, architecture, and objects by
digital means based upon the current state of the salvaged
monuments integrated with the data coming from his-
torical and archaeological researches using software for
developing 3D models [19], without the application of
reverse engineering methodology.
The archaeological 3D modeling is not just a simple
cognitive tool to reproduce virtually aspects of the past
to improve the knowledge and the comprehension. It
is also, above all, a methodology of recording all the
archaeological data in a much more complete way than
the traditional photography and drawing. It is a kind of
virtual benchmark of the archaeologists’ theories where
the hypothesis is tested and corrected in order to produce
a truthful image of something buried by time. A kind
of “solid modeling to illustrate the monument” becoming
“solid modeling to analyze the monument” [20]. For this
reason, the privileged application field for this technique is
the prehistoric archaeological research, where, the scarcity
of iconographical sources and the poor state of conserva-
tion of the findings, makes extremely complex both the
process of decoding the information and of transmitting
the knowledge to the public. For reconstructing the altar
the vectorialized plan was imported into Blender [15] and
completed with elements deriving from iconographical
fonts of contemporary architecture. Afterwards, the walls
were extruded, thus realistically imitating the original
building technique observed in the remaining rows of
blocks. The texture used is procedural but modified and
optimized in order to recall the Syracusan limestone,
mainly used for the Greek buildings of the city (Fig. 6).
V. AUGMENT ED RE A LI TY
Virtual reality allows the 3D visualization of concepts,
objects, or spaces and their contextualization through the
creation of a visual framework in which data is displayed.
VR also enables interaction with data organized in 3D,
JOURNAL OF MULTIMEDIA, VOL. 7, NO. 2, MAY 2012
213
© 2012 ACADEMY PUBLISHER
facilitating the interaction between operator, data, and
information in order to enhance the sensorial perception
[21]. It creates a virtual space that is a replica of the
real space, where the information about every feature
that constituted the different moments of life of the real
space are “translated” into 3D data. The two crucial
points of every project of VR are the selection of the
information (pictures, drawings, geometrical measures)
and the choice of which facets of the original object’s
nature must be captured and reconstructed. “Visual com-
puter models should make clear their sources and the
criteria on which they are based” [22]. In order to
understand archaeological systems, much more than a vi-
sually “realistic” geometric model is needed. “Dynamism
and interaction” are essential. A dynamic model is a
model that changes in position, size, material properties,
lighting, and viewing specification. If those changes are
not static but respond to user input, we enter into the
proper world of virtual reality, whose key feature is
real-time (RT) interaction. Here real-time means that the
computer is able to detect input and modify the virtual
world “instantaneously” at user commands. By selectively
transforming an object, that is, by interpolating shape
transformations, archaeologists may be able to form an
object hypothesis more quickly [23]. One field where
the scholars in archaeology and computer science are
recently getting involved is augmented reality (AR) where
the simultaneous visualization of virtual data and the real
world is performed [24]–[27]. One of the objectives of AR
is to bring the computer out of the desktop environment
and into the world of non professional users dealing with
3D applications. In contrast to VR, where the user is
immersed in the world of the computer, AR incorporates
the computer into the reality of the user. He can then
interact with the real world in a natural way, with the
computer providing information and assistance. It is then
a combination of the real scene viewed by the user and
a virtual scene generated by the computer that augments
the scene with additional information. The virtual world
acts as an interface, which may not be used if it provides
the same experience as face-to-face communication. AR
enables users to go “beyond being there” and enhance the
experience in order to achieve both the full interpretation
of the traces of the past and the development of the best
tool for the dissemination of their message [28].
VI. EX P ER IME NTAL RES ULTS
Final goal of our research project about Hellenistic
Syracuse is to give an augmented reality experience to
the visitors of the Archaeological Museum and of the
Neapolis Archaeological Park, aimed to revive virtually
both the Telamon and the altar as they were on common
mobile devices. In this preliminary phase of our work
we just focused on the case study of the Telamon. The
environment developed provides new ways of information
access at the Museum in a user-friendly way through
the use of 3D-visualization on mobile devices [29], [30].
We have chosen as our device a common mobile Apple
Figure 7. The AR applied to the Telamon. The mobile phone gives the
statue model when the pattern is found by the camera.
Iphone, with the commercial framework ARToolworks
which provides an high level programming tool for devel-
oping AR. Once the three-dimensional statue is obtained,
it is necessary to adapt it to the hardware limitations
imposed by the device. The graphical engine inside the
mobile device is able to handle three-dimensional en-
vironments without loss of data and without any delay
within a certain threshold. This limit has a maximum of
seven million polygons per second. However, the statue
is composed of thirty-nine million polygons and must
necessarily be reduced to fit within the limitations of the
device, without compromising the aspect of the statue.
For this operation, a filter contained in Meshlab software
[17] called “Quadric Edge Collapse Decimation” has been
used. This filter has been applied many times by halving
the number of faces each time. This is preferable than
making only one application of this filter with a single
drastic decimation with bad results in terms of quality
and shape of the final object.
ARToolworks is based on ARToolkit [31], an open
source library for Augmented Reality that allows many
easy-to-use functions of Computer Vision to be used for
AR, the openGL library for high performance graphics
and the rendering process. It gives the possibility to
create Augmented Reality applications on any mobile
device using a high level programming environment that
allows the developer to set and manipulate the Video
Tracking process and three-dimensional overlapping in
a few simple steps without having to delve into the
world of deep programming and the theory of Computer
Vision. In fact we have chosen this tool because the
aim of this paper is to allow the development of a new
way interaction between visitors and cultural heritage in
museums or archeological sites, through the use of a very
common hardware as a mobile device. ARToolworks is
integrated in Xcode, an Apple Integrated Development
Environment; it uses only API approved by Apple and any
application is “App-Store” compatible. Using a pattern
that is recognized by the device, a three-dimensional
model is associated with the pattern and the virtual model
is shown like it is in the real world (Figs. 7 and 8).
214
JOURNAL OF MULTIMEDIA, VOL. 7, NO. 2, MAY 2012
© 2012 ACADEMY PUBLISHER
(a) (b)
Figure 8. The augmented reality in the Museum. (a) the user in the
Museum; (b) the display shows the restored version of the Telamon
where the left arm is reconstructed.
VII. CONCLUSION
The encouraging results of the application of AR to
archaeological evidence has demonstrated that it is pos-
sible to use another “sense” to decrypt the traces of the
past: the three-dimensional recreation of ancient life and
visual images are extremely effective in explaining the
past because they allow us to experience it.
The potential of this approach in the future could be
enhanced by investing much more in the five fundamental
elements of an AR environment, namely virtuality (ob-
jects that don’t exist in the real world can be viewed and
examined), augmentation (real objects can be augmented
by virtual annotations), cooperation (multiple users can
see each other and cooperate in a natural way), indepen-
dence (each user controls his own independent viewpoint),
and individuality (displayed data can be different for each
viewer) [32].
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Many thanks to Giuseppe Sammatrice who worked on
the production of the 3D models.
REFERENCES
[1] E. B. W. Zubrow, Digital Archaeology. A Historical con-
text. T. L. Evans, P. Daly (eds.), Digital Archaeology.
Bridging Method and Theory, Routledge, London, 2006.
[2] P. Reilly, Towards a virtual archaeology. K. Lockyear,
S. Rahtz (eds.), Computer Applications and Quantitative
Methods in Archaeology 1990, BAR International Series
565, Oxford, 1990.
[3] F. Stanco and D. Tanasi, “Experiencing the past: Computer
graphics in archaeology,” in Digital Imaging for Cultural
Heritage. CRC Press, 2011, pp. 1–37.
[4] S. Moser, Archaeological Representation. The virtual Con-
ventions for Constructing Knowledge about the Past. I.
Hodder (ed.), Archaeological Theory Today, Polity Press,
Malden, 2005.
[5] D. Pletinckx, “Virtual archaeology as an integrated preser-
vation method,” in Arqueologica 2.0, Proceedings of 1st
International Meeting on Graphic Archaeology and Infor-
matics, Cultural Heritage and Innovation”, Seville 17-20
June 2009, 2009, pp. 51–55.
[6] http://www.archeomatica.unict.it.
[7] F. Stanco, S. Battiato, and G. Gallo, “Digital imaging for
cultural heritage preservation. analysis and reconstruction
of ancient artworks.” CRC Press, 2011.
[8] http://iplab.dmi.unict.it.
[9] G. Libertini, “Il regio museo archeologico di siracusa.” La
Libreria dello Stato, Roma, 1929.
[10] W. Boeheler, “Comparison of 3D laser scanning and other
3D measurement techniques,” in M. Baltsavias, A. Gruen,
L. Van Gool, M. Pateraki (eds.), Recording, Modeling and
Visualization of Cultural Heritage, London, Taylor and
Francis, pp. 89–100.
[11] M. Doneus and W. Neubauer, Laser scanners for 3D doc-
umentation of stratigraphic excavations. M. Baltsavias,
A. Gruen, L. Van Gool, M. Pateraki (eds.), Recording,
Modeling and Visualization of Cultural Heritage, London,
Taylor and Francis, 2006.
[12] T. Gaisecker, Pinchango Alto. 3D archaeology documen-
tation using the hybrid 3D laser scan system of RIEGL.
M. Baltsavias, A. Gruen, L. Van Gool, M. Pateraki (eds.),
Recording, Modeling and Visualization of Cultural Her-
itage, London, Taylor and Francis, 2006.
[13] M. Doneus, C. Brieseb, M. Feraa, U. Fornwagnera,
M. Griebla, M. Jannera, and M. C. Zingerlea, “Docu-
mentation and analysis of archaeological sites using aerial
reconnaissance and airborne laser scanning,” in A. Geor-
gopoulos, N. Agriantonis (eds.), AntiCIPAting the Future
of the Cultural Past, Proceedings of the XXI International
CIPA Symposium, 2007, pp. 1–6.
[14] K. Cain, C. Sobieralski, and P. Martinez, “Reconstruct-
ing a colossus of Ramesses II from laser scan data,”
in SIGGRAPH ’03: ACM SIGGRAPH 2003 Sketches &
Applications. New York, NY, USA: ACM, 2003.
[15] http://www.blender.org.
[16] http://www.nextengine.com.
[17] http://meshlab.sourceforge.net/.
[18] R. Evans, “Syracuse in antiquity. Unisa Press, Pretoria,
2009.
[19] D. Margounakis, Virtual Reconstructions in Archaeology.
D. Politis ed., E-Learning Methodologies and Computer
Applications in Archaeology, 2008.
[20] P. Reilly, Three dimensional modelling and primary ar-
chaeological data. P. Reilly, S. Rahtz (eds.), Archaeology
and the Information Age. A global perspective, 1992.
[21] S. Hermon and L. Kalisperis, “Between the real and the
virtual: 3D visualization in the cultural heritage domain -
expectations and prospects,” in Arqueologica 2.0, Proceed-
ings of 1st International Meeting on Graphic Archaeology
and Informatics, Cultural Heritage and Innovation, June
2009, pp. 99–103.
[22] F. Niccolucci, “Virtual archaology: an introduction,” in F.
Niccolucci (ed.), Virtual Archaeology, Proceedings of the
VAST Euroconference, Arezzo 24-25 November 2000, BAR
I.S. 1075, Oxford, Archaeopress, 2002, pp. 3–6.
[23] J. Barcel ´
o, “Virtual reality for archaeological explanation
beyond ”picturesque” reconstruction,Archeologia e Cal-
colatori, vol. 12, pp. 221–244, 2001.
[24] P. Milgram and S. Yin, “An augmented reality based tele-
operation interface for unstructured environments,” in ANS
7th Meeting on Robotics and Remote Systems, Augusta,
1997, pp. 101–123.
[25] N. Magnenat-Thalmann and G. Papagiannakis, Virtual
worlds and augmented reality in cultural heritage applica-
tions. M. Baltsavias, A. Gruen, L. Van Gool, M. Pateraki
(eds.), Recording, Modeling and Visualization of Cultural
Heritage, London, Taylor and Francis.
[26] M. Zollner, J. Keil, H. Wust, and D. Pletinckx, “An
augmented reality presentation system for remote cultural
heritage sites,” in Proceedings of the 10th International
Symposium on Virtual Reality, Archaeology and Cultural
Heritage VAST.
[27] B. Ramic-Brkic, Z. Karkin, A. Sadzak, D. Selimovic, and
S. Rizvic, “Augmented real-time enviroment of the church
of the holy trinity in mostar,” in Proceedings of the 10th
International Symposium on Virtual Reality, Archaeology
and Cultural Heritage VAST.
JOURNAL OF MULTIMEDIA, VOL. 7, NO. 2, MAY 2012
215
© 2012 ACADEMY PUBLISHER
[28] M. Billinghurst and H. Kato, “Collaborative mixed real-
ity. Proceedings of the First International Symposium
on Mixed Reality (ISMR ’99). Mixed Reality - Merging
Real and Virtual Worlds, Berlin, Springer Verlag, 1999,
pp. 261–284.
[29] V. Vlahakis, N. Ioannidis, J. Karigiannis, M. Tsotros,
M. Gounaris, D. Stricker, T. Gleue, P. Daehne, and
L. Almeida, “Archeoguide: Challenges and solutions of
a personalized augmented reality guide for archaeological
sites,” IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, vol. 22,
no. 5, pp. 52–60, 2002.
[30] D. Stricker, A. Pagani, and M. Zoellner, “In-situ visual-
ization for cultural heritage sites using novel, augmented
reality technologies,” in Arqueologica 2.0, Proceedings of
1st International Meeting on Graphic Archaeology and
Informatics, Cultural Heritage and Innovation, June 2009,
pp. 141–145.
[31] http://www.hitl.washington.edu/artoolkit/.
[32] D. Schmalsteig, A. Fujrmann, Z. SZalavari, M. Gervautz,
and E. Studierstube, “An environment for collaboration in
augmented reality,” in CVE ’96 Workshop Proceedings,
Nottingham, September 1996.
Filippo Stanco is an Assistant Professor with the Department of
Mathematics and Computer Science, University of Catania. He
coordinates the “Archeomatica Project” to develop new digital
tools for the archaeological research and preservation of cultural
heritage. His research interests include digital restoration, zoom-
ing, super-resolution, artifacts removal, interpolation, texture,
and GIS. Dr. Stanco has been an organizer and associate editor
of several conferences and symposiums, and he is a reviewer
for several international journals.
Davide Tanasi is Adjunct Professor of Archaeology and Ancient
History with Arcadia University - The College of Global Studies
(AUMCAS). He is co-director of the Archeomatica Project
(IPLab, University of Catania) aimed to develop new digital
tools for archaeological research and the preservation of cultural
heritage.
Giovanni Gallo is a Full Professor of Computer Graphics and
Computer Vision at Catania University where he coordinates a
research group on image processing and graphics applied to
medicine, archaeology, and data visualization. Prof. Gallo is
also a member of the faculty of “Accademia di Belle Arti”
of Catania and coordinates several interdisciplinary projects
involving art and technologies. He is president of the Italian
chapter of Eurographics for 2009-2012.
Matteo Buffa is a Master Degree student. He is involved in
several projects of IPLab at University of Catania. His interests
lie in the areas of Computer Graphics and Computer Vision with
application in the Cultural Heritage.
Beatrice Basile is the Director of the Archaeological Museum
“Paolo Orsi” of Syracuse, Italy.
216
JOURNAL OF MULTIMEDIA, VOL. 7, NO. 2, MAY 2012
© 2012 ACADEMY PUBLISHER
... In this respect, we know that many museums have already used 3D scanning and modelling techniques to create virtual tours of their attractions [1], which could thus also be enjoyed through apps or websites. Not only that but in [14,13] we see how virtual reality can even allow users to interact with museum attractions or reproductions of ancient artefacts through mobile devices. Usually, virtual visits rely on technologies that make use of 3D techniques, VR (virtual reality) or AR (augmented reality). ...
... Then this information are processed in order to build digital 3-D models of the scanned elements. Nowadays, 3-D scanning devices play a key role in many research field and applications such as: cultural heritage preservation and documentation, industrial, prosthetics and medicine prototyping, etc. [5]- [12]- [20]- [21]- [22]- [23]- [17]- [8]. Since these devices works by employing many different technologies and their cost change in a wide price range, it is important to select the best solution for your own applications. ...
Article
Full-text available
Surface reconstruction of objects using photogrammetry and terrestrial laser scanning systems (TLS) has been a topic for research for many decades, especially for culture heritage data recording. Recently, many advances into these systems are now available in the market, which give the availability of collecting a huge number of geo-referenced 3-D points covering any object surface. Due to speed and efficiency of data acquisition by means of terrestrial laser scanners, researchers and designers can select the reliable technique, depending on their application, that can be complete to give good results for the complex surfaces such as heritage objects. As Grand Egyptian Museum (GEM), located nearby the Giza Pyramids, is set to open by 2020, which considered as the largest museum from its type all over the world, with a huge area covered about a half million m2. GEM is proposed to be a unique museum all over the world for presenting a huge number from old history Egyptian artifacts. Consequently, there is a vital need for building a huge digital database containing complete information for this large number of artifacts. Mobile applications are presently at the primacy of documenting historical and archaeological sites. The current paper examine the methodological framework adopted for one high copy of Pharaonic artifacts, namely Offering Carrier, using hand held laser scanning and convert the results to a mobile application.
... The former application is usually more accurate in representation, because in the indoor environment it is easier to associate the artefact with a marker that assists the AR system's orientation. For example, Stanco et al. (2012) and White et al. (2014) designed AR systems to visualise statues based on markers on paper. Gherardini et al. (2018) used the rectangular base of a damaged lion statue as the marker to find the viewer's position and visualise the missing parts of the statue. ...
... The former application is usually more accurate in representation, because in the indoor environment it is easier to associate the artefact with a marker that assists the AR system's orientation. For example, Stanco et al. (2012) and White et al. (2014) designed AR systems to visualise statues based on markers on paper. Gherardini et al. (2018) used the rectangular base of a damaged lion statue as the marker to find the viewer's position and visualise the missing parts of the statue. ...
... Moreover, the results indicate that digital upgradeable archives with 3D models is an important alternative to traditional graphic and photographic documentation (Sangregorio et al., 2008). Another important project involves the development of Augmented Reality versions of archaeological artifacts from Syracuse, Italy and testing on mobile devices (Stanco, Tanasi, Gallo, Buffa, & Basile, 2012). The novelty of the proposed work lies on involving non -technical staff in the philosophy and use of virtual archaeology. ...
Chapter
This chapter enlightens how Industry 4.0 is gradually implemented in Cultural Industry. Even though Industry 4.0 started from manufacturing, it soon expanded to less technologically consuming industries, such as the Cultural, creating new opportunities especially in the field of Virtual Reality and Augmented Reality technologies. Taking into account existing research on Industry 4.0 and its main technologies and existing research and projects on Cultural Heritage's aspects related with the 4th Industrial Revolution, the chapter investigates how Industry 4.0 is implemented into Cultural Sector from a technological point of view, but moreover to investigate its potential role.
... In recent years, AR has grown in popularity among scholars and practitioners in fields such as archaeology, particularly in the virtual rebuilding of historical sites (Fritz, Susperregui, & Linaza, 2005), cultural heritage and tourism Graham, Zook, & Boulton, 2013;Jung, Chung, & Leue, 2015;Stanco, Tanasi, Gallo, Buffa, & Basile, 2016). This is incorporated into the recently emerged conception of cultural heritage tourism, no longer regarded as an elitist practice but rather as a dynamic and social interaction among visitors, the local community and institutions (Amakawa & Westin, 2018;Chipa, 2012, p. 142). ...
Article
In recent years, cutting-edge information and communication technologies (ICTs) have been implemented at different scales in order to improve tourists’ experiences of cultural heritage. In particular, advanced technologies combining augmented reality can offer a deeply immersive visitor’s experience aiming both at providing multifaceted information about the site and enhancing the attractiveness of a tourist destination at the different scales. Thus, the study aims at critically scrutinising the intersection of AR and tourist practices through the analysis of tourism destination stakeholders’ perceived value of AR solutions. The aim is to understand how it is crucial to take into account stakeholders’ perceptions about cutting-edge technology development, apart from providing practical implications for industry practitioners and local institutional actors. From the methodological standpoint, the article is based on a multi-method approach encompassing field-work observation, in addition to a stakeholder and case study approach, aiming at evaluating internal and external stakeholders’ perceived value through a qualitative perspective based on semi-structured interviews with institutional actors, entrepreneurs, visitors and local community representatives. The results suggested some critical reflections about the inherent elusiveness of technological innovation in the case it is not incorporated in a long-term sustainable vision.
Chapter
In recent years, digital technologies and serious game have widely affected the cultural heritage sector, offering incredible opportunities to enhance the experiential value of heritage assets and improve cultural activities. Due to pandemic and the closure of museums the demand for new digital remote solutions for Cultural Heritage has seen a great increase. Thanks to a collaboration between University of Catania, the Museum of Mineralogy, Petrography and Volcanology and a local SME iInformatica S.r.l a serious game for dissemination of mineralogic and petrographic science was developed. The idea behind the project is to give to all the possibility to learn by doing. Through the simulator, users can assume the role of researchers in mineralogy and petrography and, thus, study the minerals constituting the rocks. Within the game a player can learn how to use a petrographic microscope and how to recognise a rock by analysing the single minerals that constitute it and, therefore, to identify the rock itself.KeywordsCultural HeritageMuseumsMineralogyPetrographySerious Game
Thesis
Full-text available
With 10 million copies sold and 500 million dollars of revenue, the 11th installment of Ubisoft’s Assassin’s Creed series, Assassin’s Creed Odyssey (2018), showed how a videogame based on ancient Greek history and archaeology can make a splash in popular culture and that the distant past can become an extinguishable source of infinite engaging gaming narratives. As pedagogic and research counterparts to videogames of this kind, serious games and archaeogames focusing on Greek and Roman civilizations move from different premises, though aspiring to the same level of success. Serious games, created for a primary purpose other than sole entertainment, have found their way into classrooms and museums to educate students in a variety of disciplines mostly relying on digital storytelling strategies. Archaeogaming, on the other hand, encompasses, among other things, the creation of video games by archaeologists, who create 3D representations of the ancient material culture subject of their study, initially for the purpose of testing hypotheses in simulated environment and later to popularize archaeology and cultural heritage studies, finding a more ‘serious’ use in higher education. This dissertation deals with defining best practices in archaeogaming design and production focusing on two practical examples of re-use of digital archaeological data for the generation of game assets for teaching and public outreach. Both case studies explore the context of Late Roman Sicily on which I conducted most of the experimental work in the preparatory years of this research. The first case study will be the narrative game prototype for the Villa del Casale (Piazza Armerina) in Enna, Sicily, entitled In Ersilia’s Footsteps, featuring Ersilia Caetani-Lovatelli (1840-1925), the first female archaeologist in Italian history. The game, developed in collaboration with the University of Arkansas’ Tesseract and directed by Dr. David Fredrick and Dr. Rhodora Vennarucci, narrative follows her in the exploration of the Late Roman Imperial countryside residence and UNESCO World Heritage site. The game revolves around the use of 3D digitized assets, created employing digital photogrammetry and 3D laser-scanning to capture the archaeological site, that significantly contributed to increase the realism of the game environment influencing the game creation process towards telling stories of real historic characters in real historic places. The second game, Building by the River, is an a building and experimental archaeogame, aimed at both contextualized elements from the archaeological site as well as the ability aid researchers in understanding the relationship between space and flow in the Late Roman villa of Caddeddi on the Tellaro river (Noto). More specifically, it seeks to explore how the Villa di Caddeddi may have looked and how the rooms functioned during its time as an operating rural villa in the late 4th Century CE. Giving players the ability to pick from a list of 3D digitized assets of actual archaeological materials found both on site and in similar Sicilian Roman villas, the game seeks to engage with playful building and experimentation as seen in other popular digital game titles, like Sims 4, Subnautica, and Minecraft. The on-going work at adding assets to use in the game as well as learn more about the nature and history of the Villa di Caddeddi is discussed in terms of the second-life of digital data, archaeological interpretation, and investigation of spatial use by ancient Romans in their elite rural homes. These assets, in both In Ersilia’s Footsteps and Building by the River, represent at the same time an example in best practices in reusing 3D data, since, once used to achieve research goals, they are repurposed and in combination with an original narrative and a user-friendly interface and mechanics they become the core of an engaging and exciting exploration game. Ultimately, the experimental work, the new data gathered and the production of two original media research tools have proven to be a strategic decision to advance the digital scholarship agenda on Roman archaeology of Sicily and to trace a path for incorporating archaeogaming as a methodological approach into a research framework. The ability to re-use scientific data for the purpose of public outreach, education, and research allows for archaeologists to address pseudoscience and dangerous representations of the field. As such, the need to provide assets for games can be served through the second life of 3D digital archaeological materials.
Article
Full-text available
The global competitiveness of the Malaysian tourism sector has been deteriorating recently. The declining national trend has been reflected at the UNESCO World Historical Cities of Melaka and Georgetown where tourism is on a decline. Paving the way of realising Tourism 4.0, many cultural heritage sites are now integrating augmented reality technology into tourism offerings to enrich tourist experience. However, AR mobile applications failed easily even though the early adoption rate is high. With an aim to ensure a successful implementation of AR mobile applications, factors affecting users' intention to use the technology continuously should be examined. Ideally, developing AR for tourism does not only aim to provide enhanced tourist experience, the ultimate goal is to ensure the tourist destinations continue to be a preferred choice among the travellers. This paper discusses the theoretical foundation for developing a framework for AR mobile application success and world heritage sites sustainability. The research objectives are threefold. Firstly, based on the Expectation-Confirmation Model, this study envisions to examine the relationships among confirmation, perceived usefulness, experiential satisfaction and continuance intention to use AR mobile application. Secondly, by adapting the Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology 2, this study aims to examine the determinants of tourists' experiential satisfaction and continuance intention in using the AR mobile application. Lastly, in the light of the Balance Theory, this study intents to examine the relationships among tourists' experiential satisfaction in using the AR mobile application, attitude and behavioural intention toward the destination. An interview was conducted to gain early insights of the research framework before a survey which will conducted after the Covid-19 pandemic when tourism sector resumes to normal. The early findings of the study are deliberated in this paper.
Article
Full-text available
The paper discusses two uses of 3D Visualization and Virtual Reality (hereafter VR) of Cultural Heritage (CH) assets: a less used one, in the archaeological / historical research and a more frequent one, as a communication medium in CH museums. While technological effort has been mainly invested in improving the “accuracy” of VR (determined as how truthfully it reproduces the “CH reality”), issues related to scientific requirements, (data transparency, separation between “real” and “virtual”, etc.), are largely neglected, or at least not directly related to the 3D outcome, which may explain why, after more than twenty years of producing VR models, they are still rarely used in the archaeological research. The paper will present a proposal for developing VR tools as such as to be meaningful CH research tools as well as a methodology for designing VR outcomes to be used as a communication medium in CH museums.
Article
Full-text available
This paper focuses on virtual archaeology as a scientific activity, that complies with the London Charter, as a sustainable activity, that complies with the UNESCO Charter on the Preservation of Digital Heritage, and as an integration activity to structure and preserve all related information.
Article
Full-text available
Mobile Augmented Reality is an ideal technology for presenting information in an attractive, comprehensive and personalized way to visitors of cultural heritage sites. One of the pioneer projects in this area was certainly the European project ArcheoGuide (IST-1999-11306) which developed and evaluated Augmented Reality (AR) at a very early stage. Many progresses have been done since then, and novel devices and algorithms offer novel possibilities and functionalities. In this paper we present current research work and discuss different approaches of Mobile AR for cultural heritage. Since this area is very large we focus on the visual aspects of such technologies, namely tracking and computer vision, as well as visualization.
Article
Full-text available
Virtual Reality (VR) appears a natural medium for computer supported collaborative work (CSCW). However immersive Virtual Reality separates the user from the real world and their traditional tools . An alternative approach is through Mixed Reality (MR), the overlaying of virtual objects on the real world. This allows users to see each other and the real world at the same time as the virtual images, facilitating a high bandwidth of communication between users and intuitive manipulation of the virtual information. We review MR techniques for developing CSCW interfaces and describe lessons learned from developing a variety of collaborative Mixed Reality interfaces. Our recent work involves the use of computer vision techniques for accurate MR registration. We describe this and identify areas for future research.
Article
Full-text available
For the last 4 years, an area covering 700 km2 along the river Leitha 30 km southeast of Vienna has been investigated in two research projects. This paper presents the preliminary results and tries to demonstrate the potential of an integrated approach using aerial reconnaissance, targeted field walking, and ALS, and shows the high-quality information that can be gathered using new photogrammetric techniques applicable even in forested areas. It is argued that only an integration of different prospection methods will enable effective heritage management.
Chapter
Contents Chapter 1: Introduction: A Review Of Contemporary Theoretical Debates In Archaeology Ian Hodder Chapter 2: Behavioral Archaeology: Towards A New Synthesis Vincent Michael LaMotta and Michael Brian Schiffer Chapter 3: Evolutionary Archaeology Robert Leonard Chapter 4: Archaeological Theory and Theories Of Cognitive Evolution, Steven Mithen Chapter 5: Symbol Before Concept: Material Engagement and The Early Development Of Society Colin Renfrew Chapter 6: Agency, The Duality Of Structure and The Problem Of The Archaeological Record John Barrett Chapter 7: Archaeologies Of Place and Landscape Julian Thomas Chapter 8: Archaeologies Of Identity Lynn Meskell Chapter 9: American Material Culture In Mind, Thought And Deed Anne Yentsch and Mary Beaudry Chapter 10: Post-Colonial Archaeology: Issues Of Culture, Identity And Knowledge Chris Gosden Chapter 11: Archaeological Representation: The Visual Conventions For Constructing Knowledge About The Past Stephanie Moser Chapter 12: Culture Archaeology: The Dispersion Of A Discipline and Its Objects Mike Shanks
Chapter
This chapter analyzes the computational methods used for recreating virtual worlds from the past. Terms, like photogrammetry, rendering and digital elevation models, are introduced and explained. The collaboration between archaeologists and computer graphics designers has to offer a lot to the wide spreading of cultural heritage by using innovative and appealing 3D technologies. In Section 1, several possible applications of virtual reconstructions in archaeology are discussed. Section 2 presents the methods and techniques for recreating a virtual world, while Section 3 mentions some examples and related work on the field from literature. Purchase this chapter to continue reading all 11 pages >
Conference Paper
Doneus, M., Neubauer, W., 2006. Laser scanners for 3D documentation of stratigraphic excavations, in: Baltsavias, E., Gruen, A., van Gool, L., Pateraki, M. (Eds.), Recording, modeling and visualization of cultural heritage. Proceedings of the International Workshop, Centro Stefano Franscini, Monte Verita, Ascona, Switzerland, May 22-27, 2005. Taylor & Francis, London, pp. 193–203.
Article
Museums often lack the possibility to present archaeological or cultural heritage sites in a realistic and interesting way. Thus are proposing a new way to show augmented reality applications of cultural heritage sites at remote places like museums. In the exhibition space large wall-filling photographs of the real site are superimposed with interactive contextual annotations like 3D reconstructions, images and movies. Therefore we are using two different hardware setups for visualization: Standard UMPCs and a custom made revolving display. The setup has been installed and tested at SIGGRAPH 2008, Allard Pierson Museum in Amsterdam and CeBIT 2009. Museum visitors could experience Forum Romanum and Satricum in an informative and intuitive way by pointing the video see through devices on different areas of the photographs. The result is a more realistic and entertaining way for presenting cultural heritage sites in museums. Furthermore our solution is less expensive than comparable installations regarding content and hardware.