K. Irvine's research while affiliated with NCI-Frederick and other places

The use of anti-idiotypic antibodies as immunogens represents one potential approach to active specific immunotherapy of cancer. Two panels of syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies were generated. One panel was directed against mAb CC49 and the other to mAb COL-1. mAb CC49 recognizes the pancarcinoma antigen (Ag), tumor-associated glycoprotein-72 (TAG-72), and mAb COL-1 recognizes carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA). Seven anti-idiotypic (AI) antibodies (Ab2) designated AI49-1-7 were generated that recognize the variable region of mAb CC49. These mAb were shown to inhibit the interaction of mAb CC49 (Ab1) with TAG-72 (Ag). Five anti-idiotypic antibodies designated CAI-1-5 were also generated to the anti-CEA mAb, COL-1 (Ab1). These Ab2 were shown to inhibit the interaction between COL-1 (Ab1) and CEA (Ag). Immunization of mice, rats, and rabbits with Ab2 directed against CC49 or COL-1 could not elicit specific Ab3 humoral immune responses, i.e., antibody selectively reactive with their respective target antigens. However, immunization of mice with the CC49 anti-idiotypic antibody (Ab2), designated AI49-3, could induce a delayed-type hypersensitivity response (DTH) specific for tumor cells that express TAG-72. Similarly, immunization of mice with an anti-idiotypic antibody directed against COL-1, designated CAI-1, could induce specific DTH cell-mediated immune responses to murine tumor cells that express human CEA on their surface. These results thus demonstrate that while some anti-idiotype mAb may not be potent immunogens in eliciting Ab3 humoral responses, they are capable of eliciting specific cellular immune responses against human carcinoma-associated antigens. This type of mAb may ultimately be useful in active immunotherapy protocols for human carcinoma.

One potential target for active specific immunotherapy of gastrointestinal carcinomas and many lung and breast carcinomas is carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA). We have reported on the development of a CEA recombinant vaccinia virus construct [designated rV(NYC)-CEA]. The efficacy of the rV(NYC)-CEA vaccine was determined in immunologically intact mice with the use of a syngeneic murine colon carcinoma that had been transduced with the human CEA gene. Nontransduced tumors were used as controls. Using this model, the rV(NYC)-CEA was shown to both protect mice against the challenge of CEA-transduced tumor cells and reduce or eliminate the growth of established tumors. In this study, using the same tumor model system, purified CEA and an anti-idiotype antibody, CAI-1 (capable of inducing anti-CEA T cell responses) were compared to rV(NYC)-CEA for their ability to prevent and treat CEA expressing tumors. immunization of mice with three doses of purified CEA (25 μg/dose) emulsified in Freund's adjuvants could prevent the growth of CEA-transduced tumors but was not effective in the treatment of established tumors. Immunization of mice with three doses of anti-idiotype antibody CAI-1 coupled to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) and emulsified in Freund's adjuvants was not efficient in preventing the growth of transplanted tumors. Immunization of mice with purified CEA induced potent CEA-specific humoral responses accompanied by weak delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) and in vitro proliferative responses. On the other hand, immunization of mice with rV(NYC)-CEA appeared to induce more potent T cell immunity, especially DTH and cytolytic T lymphocyte responses, than immunization with purified CEA alone. Although direct comparisons between purified proteins and an infectious agent are not possible, these data suggest that the CEA recombinant vaccinia virus may be superior to purified CEA or an anti-idiotype antibody bearing the image of a CEA T cell epitope as a primary immunogen for antitumor activity.

We have previously reported the development of a recombinant vaccinia virus vaccine expressing the human carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) gene, designated rV(NYC)-CEA. This construct has been shown to elicit specific anti-CEA immune responses and an antitumor effect in a murine tumor model. In the studies reported here, the safety and immunogenicity of this recombinant vaccinia virus were evaluated in a rhesus monkey model. Human CEA is a M(r) 180,000 glycoprotein expressed in approximately 90% of gastrointestinal carcinomas and in some breast and non-small cell lung carcinomas. This family also includes normal cross-reacting antigen (NCA). Rhesus monkeys, like humans, have some NCA on the surface of their granulocytes. Eight monkeys were immunized 3 or 4 times by skin scarification with the recombinant CEA vaccine and four monkeys received wild-type vaccinia virus as control. After three vaccinations, all rV(NYC)-CEA-vaccinated animals exhibited a strong anti-CEA antibody response as measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The functional ability of these antibodies to mediate lysis of a CEA-bearing tumor cell was demonstrated using human effector cells. This response could be enhanced by interleukin 2. Cellular immunity to CEA was measured by delayed-type hypersensitivity upon intradermal challenge with purified CEA. Only those animals receiving the recombinant vaccine displayed significant anti-CEA responses. Furthermore, peripheral blood mononuclear cells from immunized monkeys were found to proliferate in response to CEA stimulation. All vaccinated monkeys developed local skin irritation at the site of the vaccination, regional lymphadenopathy, and low-grade fevers after immunization. Following immunization with rV(NYC)-CEA, the response was consistent with the usual constitutional symptoms seen with human smallpox virus immunization. Blood counts, differentials, and hepatic and renal chemistries remained normal in all animals throughout the study and for up to 1 year following the primary vaccination. No evidence of immunological cross-reactivity to NCA was found by either a fall in the granulocyte count or analyses for anti-NCA antibodies. Thus, the rV(NYC)-CEA vaccine appears to be safe in rhesus monkeys. The administration of a CEA recombinant vaccine to rhesus monkeys induces both a humoral and a cell-mediated immune response directed against human CEA.

Human carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) is a 180-kd glycoprotein expressed in human colorectal, gastric, pancreatic, breast, and non-small-cell lung carcinomas. Previous studies have demonstrated enhanced immune responses to other antigens presented with vaccinia virus proteins via a recombinant vaccinia virus construct. In addition, we have developed a recombinant CEA-vaccinia virus construct, designated rV(WR)-CEA, and have demonstrated humoral anti-CEA responses in mice after immunization with that virus. The goals of this study were (a) to construct a recombinant CEA-vaccinia vaccine in a less virulent vaccinia strain that is potentially safe and effective for treatment of patients whose tumors express CEA and (b) to evaluate the ability of the recombinant CEA-vaccinia vaccine to prevent and reverse tumor growth in mice and to elicit cell-mediated and humoral anti-CEA immune responses. Using the New York City strain of vaccinia virus, which is used in smallpox vaccination and is more attenuated for humans than rV(WR), we derived a recombinant CEA-vaccinia construct, designated rV(NYC)-CEA. The ability of this construct to induce antitumor immunity was evaluated in mice receiving subcutaneous injections of murine colon adenocarcinoma cells expressing the human CEA gene. Administration of rV(NYC)-CEA in mice induced strong anti-CEA antibody responses, as well as CEA-specific cell-mediated responses, including delayed-type hypersensitivity, lymphoproliferative, and cytotoxic responses. Vaccination of mice with the rV(NYC)-CEA rendered them resistant to the growth of subsequently transplanted CEA-expressing tumors. Moreover, when mice were vaccinated 7 days after tumor cell injection, tumor growth was either greatly reduced or eliminated. No toxic effects were observed in any of the mice. These studies demonstrate that antitumor activity can be induced with the use of a recombinant CEA-vaccinia virus construct derived from an attenuated vaccinia strain, and they reveal the range of cell-mediated and humoral responses induced by this recombinant vaccine.