Content uploaded by Guido Pastorino
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Guido Pastorino on Mar 19, 2014
Content may be subject to copyright.
431
THE GENUS SPHENIA TURTON, 1822 (BIVALVIA: MYIDAE)
FROM SHALLOW WATERS OF ARGENTINA
Guido Pastorino* & Maria Bagur
Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales, Av. Angel Gallardo 470 3° piso lab. 80 C1405DJR,
Buenos Aires, Argentina
INTRODUCTION
The genus Sphenia was first reported in
southern South America by Pilsbry (1899), who
described Sphenia hatcheri from shallow Pa-
tagonian waters. Later, Castellanos (1965) pub-
lished a short note with comments on the type
material of this species, studied by the late J.
J. Parodiz at the Academy of Natural Sciences
of Philadelphia, USA. Finally, in her catalogue
of marine mollusks from Buenos Aires province
(1970: 279), Castellanos mentioned Mar del
Plata (38°S) as the farthest north distribution of
this species. Coan (1999) published a detailed
review of the Pacic species of Sphenia, includ-
ing some interesting data about two Atlantic
species, S. hatcheri and S. fragilis. Scarabino
& Zaffaroni (2004) and Scarabino et al. (2006)
briey reported and discussed the distribution
of these species in Uruguayan waters.
After an exhaustive study of the intertidal
endolithic fauna of bivalves from Buenos Aires
province, Argentina, new ndings of speci-
mens of Sphenia allow the reillustration and
comparison of these species. In addition, new
distributional ranges are provided.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Specimens collected from the intertidal sedi-
mentary rock shoal, close to Santa Elena, Bue-
nos Aires province, Argentina (37°51’8.81”S,
57°30’21.65”W), were the core of material
studied. Additionally, all the specimens housed
at the collections of the Museo Argentino de
Ciencias Naturales “Bernardino Rivadavia”,
Buenos Aires (MACN), and Museo de La Plata,
Argentina (MLP) were studied. Scanning elec-
tron microscope images were produced with a
Philips XL30 at the MACN. Most photographs
were taken using a digital camera. All images
were digitally processed with the appropriate
software.
MALACOLOGIA, 2011, 54(1-2): 431-435
*Corresponding author: gpastorino@macn.gov.ar
SYSTEMATICS
Sphenia fragilis
(H. Adams & A. Adams, 1854)
Figures 1–8
Synonyms: (complete list in Coan, 1999)
Tyleria fragilis H. Adams & A. Adams, 1854:
418.
Sphenia hatcheri. Castellanos, 1970: 279 (non
Pilsbry, 1899, partim); Figueiras & Sicardi,
1970: 22, pl. 7, g. 103 (non Pilsbry, 1899).
Corbula iheringiana Pilsbry, 1897: 295, pl. 7,
gs. 24–26; Castellanos 1970: 270.
Sphenia fragilis. Coan, 1999: 105, gs. 2–6, 18,
24; Scarabino et al., 2006: 161; Mikkelsen &
Bieler, 2008: 378, g.
Material Examined: (sp. = complete speci-
mens, otherwise specified). 37°51’8.81”S,
57°30’21.65”W, Santa Elena, Buenos Aires,
16 sp., intertidal (MACN-In 38283); Mar del
Plata, Buenos Aires, 1 sp. (MACN-In 10757);
Miramar, 1 sp. (MACN 8451-15); Miramar, 2
sp. (MACN-In 8451); Miramar, Buenos Aires,
1 sp. (MACN-In 29511); Miramar, 1 left valve
(MLP 2365-2); Río Quequén, Buenos Aires, 3
sp. (MACN-In 29514); Puerto Quequén, 1 sp.
(MACN-In 19552); 41°12’S–62°54’W, 1 sp., 1
left valve, in 27.4 m depth (MACN-In 20652);
Puerto Militar, Buenos Aires, in 30 m depth, 2
sp. (MACN-In 11142).
Remarks: The specimens studied showed a
considerable variation in shell shape because
of the constraints imposed by their nestling
habit and consequent dependence on the
substrata where the animal grows. Figures 1–5
illustrate specimens in which the height and
length of, right and left valves, are the most
variable feature. The chondrophore, as it was
pointed out by Coan (1999), holds the main
difference between S. fragilis and S. hatcheri.
As it can be seen in Figure 19, the posterior
PASTORINO & BAGUR432
FIGS. 1-8. Sphenia fragilis (H. Adams & A. Adams). FIG. 1: Left valve; FIG. 2: Ventral view of the
same specimen in 1; FIG. 3: Dorsal view of the same specimen in 1; FIG. 4: Left valve; FIG. 5: Left
valve; FIG. 6: Inner view of left valve, tilted to show the chondrophore. Scale bar Figs. 1-5 = 3 mm;
FIG. 7: SEM image of the left valve, right arrow showing a ridge on the anterior margin of chondro-
phore, left arrow showing the posterior ridge of condrophore slightly projected. Scale bar = 200 µm;
FIG. 8: SEM image of right valve showing the hinge area, arrow pointing the anterior cardinal teeth.
Scale bar = 500 µm. All specimens from MACN-In 38283.
SPHENIA IN THE SOUTHWESTERN ATLANTIC 433
FIGS. 9-19. Sphenia hatcheri Pilsbry. FIG. 9: Inner view of right valve; FIG. 10: Outer view of the same
in 9; FIG. 11: Outer view of right valve; FIG. 12: Inner view of the same in 11; FIG. 13: Outer view of
right valve; FIG. 14: Left valve slighly tilted to see the hinge area; FIG. 15: Inner view of the same in 13;
FIG. 16: Inner view of right valve; FIG. 17: Outer view of the same in 16. Scale bar for all specimens
= 1 cm; FIG. 18: Detail of the hinge of right valve; FIG. 19: SEM image of the chondrophore. Scale
bar = 500 µm. All specimens from MACN-In 37986.
PASTORINO & BAGUR434
ridge of the condrophore of S. hatcheri in the
left valve is longer and clearly projecting out of
the ventral edge, whereas in S. fragilis this ridge
is weakly or not projecting (Fig. 7). In addition,
S. fragilis has a distinctive ridge on the anterior
margin of the condrophore (Fig. 7, right arrow).
A larger anterior cardinal tooth in the right valve
of S. hatcheri is another distinguishing feature.
The same tooth is also present in the right valve
of S. fragilis but much smaller and anterior to a
deeply recessed resilifer (Fig. 8, arrow). Also S.
hatcheri is larger than S. fragilis (30.1 mm vs.
12.7 mm according to Coan, 1999).
Coan (1999) cited S. fragilis as occurring
in both eastern Pacic and western Atlantic
oceans. We have studied material from Uru-
guay and Argentina. The distribution range
in both countries covers the entire marine
coast from Uruguay to 41°12’S–62°54’W in
Argentina. Most of the material comes from
the intertidal zone with the exception of two
lots collected at about 30 m depth.
Sphenia fragilis is found usually intertidally
among and under the talus of the Rhodophyta
Corallina ofcinalis. Also, sometimes it is part
of the fauna associated to the byssal laments
of Brachidontes rodriguezii, the most abundant
mytilid forming large banks at the study area.
Living together with S. fragilis is Hiatella meridi-
onalis, another byssate bivalve fairly common
in this habitat; they share the same crevices,
a usual behavior already reported by Yonge
(1951) for Sphenia binghami and Hiatella sp.
from Port Erin, Isle of Man, United Kingdom.
Coan (1999) pointed out the wide distribution
of S. fragilis. This distribution is apparently not
only Recent, as Scarabino & Zaffaroni (2004)
conrmed its presence of S. fragilis in Quater-
nary deposits of Uruguay.
Sphenia hatcheri
Pilsbry, 1899
Figures 9–19
Synonymy: (complete list in Coan, 1999)
Sphenia hatcheri Pilsbry, 1899: 128, pl. 1, g.
5, 6; Carcelles, 1950: 82, pl. 5, g. 94; Car-
celles & Williamson, 1951: 347; Castellanos,
1965: 173–175, pl. 1, gs. 1–8; Castellanos,
1970: 278–279, pl. 25, gs. 9–11 (partim);
Scarabino & Zaffaroni 2004: 11.
Sphenia subequalis Dall, 1908: 422–423; Car-
celles, 1950: 82.
Material Examined: Puerto Deseado, 1 sp.
(MACN-In 17753); 4 km S of Punta Desengaño,
San Julián, Santa Cruz, several valves (MACN-
In 36931); 7.5 km S of San Julián, 1 sp. (MACN-
In 36919); intertidal coast near of Estancia La
Costa, Coyle, Santa Cruz (MACN-In 37986);
Santa Cruz coast between Coyle and Río
Gallegos, 3 sp. (MACN 10125); Santa Cruz,
(MACN-In 29513); Cabo Buen Tiempo, Santa
Cruz, several sp. (MLP 10246); Monte Tigre, S
coast, Río Gallegos, Santa Cruz, 5 left, 1 right
valves (MLP 1681); Monte Tigre, Río Gallegos,
Santa Cruz, 1 sp., 4 left, 2 right valves (MLP
1349); Monte Tigre, Río Gallegos, Santa Cruz,
(MLP 2041); San Sebastián, Tierra del Fuego,
8 sp., 11 left, 9 right valves; (MACN-In 12617);
Punta María, Rio Grande, Tierra del Fuego, 7
sp. (MACN-In 37910); Río del Fuego, Tierra del
Fuego, several sp. (MACN-In 12616); 54°53’S,
68°14’W, Bridges Is., Tierra del Fuego, 1 left,
1 right valves (MLP 12225).
Remarks: According to Coan (1999), based
on Figueiras & Sicardi (1970) and Castellanos
(1970), the distribution in the southwestern At-
lantic is from La Paloma (34°40’S) in Uruguay
to Mar del Plata, in Argentina. Coan (1999)
suggested that these northern records may
represent sporadic recruitment. Along the Pa-
cic coast of South America, S. hatcheri occurs
from Tierra del Fuego to Isla Chiloe in Chile.
We restricted here the distribution on the south-
western Atlantic from Tierra del Fuego to Puerto
Madryn, Golfo Nuevo, Chubut, Argentina, the
latter based on specimens in the ANSP 170466,
reported by Castellanos (1965). No specimens
of S. hatcheri either from Uruguayan or Buenos
Aires province coasts have been found during
our eld work nor in the collections examined.
Those records north of Puerto Madryn cited by
Coan (1999) from the published literature are
here considered as belonging to S. fragilis, as
well as specimens from Mar del Plata, Buenos
Aires province (MACN-In 10757) mentioned
by Castellanos (1970) and repeated by Coan
(1999).
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
E. V. Coan (Palo Alto, California, USA) and
F. Scarabino (MNHNM, Montevideo, Uruguay)
made very useful comments that improved an
early version of the manuscript. L. P. Arribas
kindly helped during eld work. We are grateful
to A. Tablado (MACN-In Buenos Aires, Argen-
tina) and C. Damborenea (MLP) for access to
collections under their care. This work benets
SPHENIA IN THE SOUTHWESTERN ATLANTIC 435
with the criticism of two anonymous reviewers.
It was partially supported by the projects PICT
942 from the National Agency for Scientic
and Technical Promotion, Argentina, and PIP
0732 from the Consejo Nacional de Investiga-
ciones Cientícas y Técnicas (CONICET). We
acknowledge funding by CONICET of Argen-
tina, to which GP belong as a member of the
research carrier and MB as fellow.
LITERATURE CITED
ADAMS, H. & A. ADAMS, 1854, Description of
a new genus of bivalve Mollusca. Annals and
Magazine of Natural History (ser. 2), 14: 418.
CARCELLES, A., 1950, Catálogo de los
moluscos marinos de Patagonia. Anales del
Museo Nahuel Huapi (2 extra nueva serie),
8: 41–100.
CARCELLES, A. & S. WILLIAMSON, 1951, Ca-
tálogo de los moluscos marinos de la provincia
magallánica. Revista del Instituto Nacional de
Investigación de las Ciencias Naturales, Cien-
cias Zoológicas, 2: 225–383.
CASTELLANOS, Z. J. A. de, 1965, Nota sobre
“Sphenia hatcheri” Pilsbry (Moll. Pelecypoda).
Revista del Museo de La Plata (Nueva Serie),
Zoología, 8: 173–175.
CASTELLANOS, Z. J. A. de, 1970, Catálogo de
los moluscos marinos bonaerenses. Anales de
la Comisión de Investigaciones Cientícas de la
Provincia de Buenos Aires, 8: 9–365.
COAN, E. V., 1999, The eastern Pacic species
of Sphenia (Bivalvia: Myidae). The Nautilus,
113: 103–120.
DALL, W. H., 1908, Reports on the Mollusca and
Brachiopoda. Bulletin of the Museum of Com-
parative Zoology, 43: 205–487.
FIGUEIRAS, A. & O. E. SICARDI, 1971, Catálogo
de los moluscos marinos del Uruguay parte 6.
Comunicaciones de la Sociedad Malacológica
del Uruguay, 3: 101–130.
MIKKELSEN, P. M. & R. BIELER, 2008, Seashells
of southern Florida: living marine mollusks of
the Florida keys and adjacent regions. Bivalves.
New Jersey, Princeton University Press, Princ-
eton and Oxford, 503 pp.
PILSBRY, H. A., 1899, Littoral mollusks from Cape
Fairweather, Patagonia. American Journal of
Science (ser. 4), 7: 126–128.
SCARABINO, F. & J. C. ZAFFARONI, 2004, Es-
tatus faunístico de veinte especies de moluscos
citadas para aguas uruguayas. Comunicaciones
Zoológicas, Museo Nacional de Historia Natural
y Antropología, 13: 1–15.
SCARABINO, F., J. C. ZAFFARONI, C. CLAVIJO,
A. CARRANZA & M. NIN, 2006, Bivalvos mari-
nos y estuarinos de la costa uruguaya: faunís-
tica, distribución, taxonomía y conservación. Pp.
157–169, in: R. MenafRa, L. RodRíguez-gaLLego,
f. ScaRabino & d. conde, eds., Bases para la
conservación y el manejo de la costa uruguaya.
Vida Silvestre Uruguay, Montevideo, 668 pp.
TURTON, W., 1822, Conchylia Insularum Britanni-
carum. The shells of the British Islands, system-
atically arranged. Nattali, London, 279 pp.
YONGE, C. M., 1951, Observations on Sphenia
binghami Turton. Journal of the Marine Bio-
logical Association of the United Kingdom, 30:
387–392.
Revised ms. accepted 10 May 2011