To clarify the feasibility of BFRP (basalt fiber reinforced plastics) anchors instead of steel anchors in the seismic application of slopes under different vibration strengths, a series of shaking table tests were carried out to strengthen the slope using BFRP anchors and steel anchors, respectively. By studying the dynamic response recorded in the slope model and the observed experimental phenomena, the acceleration dynamic response and displacement spectrum dynamic response of the two slope models were analyzed. The test results show that the deformation stage of the slope reinforced by the two types of anchors is basically the same during the test, that is, elastic, plastic (potential sliding surface and plastic strengthening), and failure stages, respectively. The slope is in the elastic stage before the 0.2 g seismic wave, and it gradually enters the plastic stage after the 0.4 g seismic wave. However, the peak acceleration and displacement of the slope reinforced by steel anchors are greater than those of the slope reinforced by BFRP anchors under the same working conditions of seismic waves. In addition, we found that the acceleration response spectrum distribution curve of each measuring point in the short period has an obvious amplification effect along the elevation, and its predominant period has a forward migration phenomenon with the increase of the height of the measuring point, which also indicates that the higher frequency seismic wave has a greater impact on the top of the slope. The BFRP anchors, as a kind of flexible structure supporting slope, can effectively reduce the impact of seismic waves on the slope and attenuate seismic waves to a certain extent compared with steel anchors. Furthermore, the BFRP anchors can be deformed in coordination with the slope, which can improve the overall working performance of the slope, especially limit the dynamic response of the middle and lower slopes. These results can provide a theoretical guide for the seismic design of BFRP anchors for high slopes.
1. Introduction
In the actual anchoring engineering, the conventional prestressed anchor shows a good antiseismic effect in low seismic intensity, which can limit the deformation of the rock mass and improve the stability of the slope [1, 2]. However, the anchored rock mass deforms greatly under the strong earthquake condition, and it is generally difficult for the conventional prestressed anchors to continue limiting their deformation. In addition, the steel anchor is easily broken owing to its insufficient deformability or overload under the action of instantaneous impact load, causing slope instability and failure [3–5]. Furthermore, some corrosive chemicals in the groundwater and the slope body often cause aging, damage, or destruction of the conventional prestressed anchor tendon, which leads to the phenomenon of overall instability and destruction of the anchored slope. Although technical measures such as hot-dip galvanizing on the surface, epoxy coating, anchor bracket, and grouting slurry mixed with preservatives can be adopted in the anchoring engineering, the problem has not been fundamentally solved [6]. With the continuous improvement of infrastructure, the demand for steel bars is increasing. However, the iron ore resources used to produce steel bars are gradually being depleted. Therefore, a nonmetallic anchor should be adopted instead of the steel anchor for geotechnical anchoring engineering. The new material of basalt fiber-reinforced plastics (BFRP) is gradually used to replace the traditional reinforced anchor because it can fully utilize its relatively high tensile strength and low elastic modulus. In addition, the BFRP anchor has the advantages of good stress transfer characteristics, antiseismic and corrosion performance, which can better adapt to the deformation of the slope, effectively solve the corrosion problem of anchor in the slope; and has obvious antiseismic effect of the slope [5]. Basalt fibers are gradually gaining domestic acceptance owing to their advantages of environmental protection, corrosion resistance, high strength, light weight, fatigue resistance, good adhesion to the grouting body, thermal expansion coefficient similar to concrete, and tensile strength retention rate equivalent to steel bars.
Many researchers have done much scientific research on the mechanical properties, bond strength with cement mortar, and anchoring performance, and have obtained a lot of valuable results [7, 8]. In previous studies, scholars have carried out a lot of research on the basic physical and mechanical properties of FRP rebars [9–13]. In their conclusions, the main factors that affect the degree of corrosion of FRP bars are temperature, humidity, salt solution, acid-base environment, ultraviolet intensity, etc., and it was found that the corrosion of FRP tendons is usually formed by the deterioration of the fiber or the matrix interface. Generally, basalt fiber has better resistance in acidic environment than alkaline environment [14, 15]. Some researchers [16, 17] have conducted comparative studies on the corrosion resistance of BFRP, GFRP, and CFRP rebars, and considered that the corrosion resistance and durability of BFRP rebars are better than those of GFRP and CFRP rebars. Furthermore, Urbanski et al. [18] and Zhang et al. [19] studied the ductility, deformability, ultimate stress, and damage mechanism of BFRP-reinforced structures and compared with traditional steel-reinforced structures, indicating that BFRP-reinforced structures have certain advantages.
In recent decades, BFRP rebars are mostly used to reinforce concrete beams and supports [20, 21]. Yuan et al. [22] studied the influence of the bond performance between the BFRP sheet and concrete, and proposed a bond strength model considering the influence of strain energy and BFRP bond area. Liu et al. [23] studied the bond behavior between BFRP reinforcement and recycled aggregate concrete (RAC) by the orthogonal test method, and proposed the influence of RAC strength grade, volume content, and length of chopped basalt fiber on the bond stress slip constitutive relationship. Nerilli and Vairob [24] studied the failure mode of the BFRP-bar-reinforced concrete support through the push–pull double-shear test of BFRP concrete specimens, and analyzed in detail the strain mode and the bond-slip relationship between BFRP and concrete interface.
Owing to the mature performance and technology of BFRP rebars, it is gradually used in slope reinforcement engineering. Lei et al. [25] and Liu [26] carried out experiments to analyze the soil slopes supported by nonprestressed BFRP and FRP bolts, respectively, and proposed relevant values and recommended design parameters for the soil slopes supported by BFRP bolts. Jin et al. [27] and Ho et al. [28], respectively, proposed the use of GFRP and FRP to reinforce the slope, and the reinforcement effect was evaluated through numerical theory and experiment. Furthermore, Huang et al. [29, 30], and Kim and Lee [31] established models to predict the effect of slope reinforced by new composite materials, and the experimental results showed that the proposed prediction model achieved high prediction accuracy.
In the past, scholars’ studies on BFRP mainly focused on its physical and chemical properties, bonding properties with concrete, and slope reinforcement. Despite many studies, dynamic response of BFRP-reinforced slopes under seismic loadings is mainly based on theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, and in some cases, the engineering practice for antiseismic design in reinforcing the slopes is still largely based on experience. Furthermore, the use of large-scale model tests to study the dynamic response characteristics of BFRP anchors in slope reinforcement engineering under earthquake action is still lacking. Therefore, to clarify the reinforcement effect of BFRP anchor cables in the protection of high slopes in high-intensity earthquake areas, the large-scale shaking table test was used to study the dynamic response characteristics and the failure mode of the slope strengthened by BFRP anchor (cable) + frame structure. Meanwhile, the effect of the slope strengthened by BFRP was compared with that of traditional reinforced anchor (cable) + frame structure. The study results help us to better understand the dynamic response characteristics of BFRP-reinforced slopes and provide a scientific basis for the dynamic rational design of BFRP anchor cables to reinforce high slopes.
2. Shaking Table Test Design
2.1. Project Overview
In this study, the fully weathered basalt slope of the Xiangshui River (K5 + 620∼K5 + 700) on the Gongdong expressway was selected as the experimental prototype. The geological disaster point along the Gongdong expressway and the location of the Xiangshui river slope are shown in Figure 1.