The glazed flat plate solar collector has reflective properties so that not all heat energy can be absorbed, but has the ability to trap heat. While the unglazed flat plate solar collector, solar irradiation directly overrides the absorber plate surface (no reflection), but the heat energy absorbed is easily released because this collector has no cover.
This study aims to compare the performance of glazed and unglazed flat plate solar collectors in the same weather conditions for various sun positions, flow rates, and inlet temperatures as well as analyze the performance of glazed and unglazed flat plate solar collector combinations in generating hot air for grain drying applications. This research was conducted in three stages, namely, uniformity testing by looking at the outlet temperature of the two collector types, the ratio of collector efficiency in several conditions which included two levels of water flow rate (1.8 and 3 liters/minute), two inlet temperature levels (40 and 55 °C) and three positions of solar radiation (08.00-09.00, 11.30-12.30 and 15.00-16.00) as well as testing a combination of collector systems with variations in water flow rates through glazed and unglazed flat plate solar collector for air heating.
Performance testing of solar collectors shows that in general glazed flat plate solar collector has better efficiency compared to unglazed flat plate solar collector.The highest efficiency in glazed flat plate solar collector was 64% and unglazed flat plate solar collector was 53% with a flow rate of 3 liters/minute and inlet temperature of 40°C. The inlet temperature of 40°C with a flow rate of 3 liters/minute gives a range of efficiency values of glazed flat plate solar collector of 32-64%, unglazed flat plate solar collector is 26-53% while for inlet temperature of 40°C with a flow rate of 1.8 liters/minute the efficiency range of glazed flat plate solar collector was 33-50% and unglazed flat plate solar collector was 26-38%. Furthermore, for inlet temperature of 55°C with a flow rate of 3 liters/minute, the range of glazed flat plate solar collector efficiency values of 6-37% and unglazed flat plate solar collector was 2-20%, while for flow rate of 1.8 liters per minute the efficiency range of glazed flat plate solar collector of 0-33% and unglazed flat plate solar collector of 0-24%. At noon, in general, the efficiency of solar collectors is greater, where the efficiency of glazed flat plate solar collector is 33-64%, while unglazed flat plate solar collector is 20-53%. In the morning and evening, the highest efficiency of glazed flat plate solar collector was only 40% and unglazed flat plate solar collector was 32%. Cost per Watt (useful energy) depends on the inlet temperature and flow rate used ranging from Rp 5,310/W to Rp 20,268/W. In general, these costs are higher for unglazed flat plate solar collector except for the inlet temperature of 40°C and at the same flow rate of 3 liters/minute, namely glazed flat plate solar collector of Rp 5,310/W and unglazed flat plate solar collector of Rp 5,570/W. The collector combination system has worked well in meeting the needs of drying air for grain dryers. In sunny conditions and during the charging and discharging process, the efficiency of the solar collector remains positive. The best combination of collectors is obtained from the treatment of low initial water temperature (33-35°C) with a flow rate of 4 liters/minute on the unglazed flat plate solar collector inlet and 10 liters/minute on the unglazed flat plate solar collector inlet-glazed flat plate solar collector with an efficiency value of 59.58%. The high initial water temperature treatment (48 -52°C) was able to dry the grain at 745.62kg and at the initial low-temperature treatment it was able (33 -35°C) to dry the grain drying 538.01kg (availability of heat energy for 8 hours).
Keywords: heat energy, flow rate, glazed and unglazed solar collector, solar collector effiency, solar irradiation.