Figure 2 - uploaded by Sue O'Connor
Content may be subject to copyright.
Comparison of Timor dog δ 13 C and/or δ 15 N isotopic values with those of prehistoric dogs in the Cook Islands (Craig 2009), Marquesas (West 2007), New Zealand (Leach et al. 2001) and Fiji (Jones and Quinn 2009; Valentin et al. 2006). Isotopic values from Santa Rosa dogs are from ,VÊiÌÊ>°ÊÓ䣣®°Ê*>VwVÊ«}ÊÃÌ«VÊÛ>ÕiÃÊ>ÀiÊ`iÀÛi`ÊvÀÊiÊ>`Ê À>}ÊÓää®]Ê i>Û>Ì wi`ÊiÌÊ>°ÊÓään®]Êi`ÊiÌÊ>°ÊÓää®Ê>`Ê7iÃÌÊÓääÇ®° 

Comparison of Timor dog δ 13 C and/or δ 15 N isotopic values with those of prehistoric dogs in the Cook Islands (Craig 2009), Marquesas (West 2007), New Zealand (Leach et al. 2001) and Fiji (Jones and Quinn 2009; Valentin et al. 2006). Isotopic values from Santa Rosa dogs are from ,VÊiÌÊ>°ÊÓ䣣®°Ê*>VwVÊ«}ÊÃÌ«VÊÛ>ÕiÃÊ>ÀiÊ`iÀÛi`ÊvÀÊiÊ>`Ê À>}ÊÓää®]Ê i>Û>Ì wi`ÊiÌÊ>°ÊÓään®]Êi`ÊiÌÊ>°ÊÓää®Ê>`Ê7iÃÌÊÓääÇ®° 

Source publication
Article
Full-text available
The domestic dog (Canis familiaris) is considered to be the oldest domesticated animal in the world. It arrived in Island Southeast Asia and Australia-New Guinea relatively late in the Holocene, though the timing and means of its dispersal remain unclear. We report a dog burial from Timor-Leste dated to ~3000 cal. BP. Morphometric analysis demonstr...

Contexts in source publication

Context 1
... to that of recent South Asia and Southeast Asia pariah populations, which Gonzalez (2012) divided into four types (dingo, sight hound, broad head dog and village dog). Measurements of dog remains from Neolithic levels in Niah Cave in Borneo indicate these animals had a body size smaller than the average village dog (Clutton- Brock 1959; Medway 1959). Further west, in east Java, Storm (2001) examined an incomplete skull from Hoekgrott Cave, which could represent either a large village dog, or a smaller dingo-type pariah; this specimen was tentatively dated to 2655±60 BP. In Timor, dog remains from Uai Bobo 1 (1400 BP) and Bui Ceri Uato (0–2500 BP) were described by Gollan (1982) as representing two types, one similar to the village dog, and the other larger and more dingo-like. In the east of Timor-Leste, adjacent to Lake Ira Laloro (~334 m asl), are two caves in uplifted limestone known as Matja Kuru 1 (MK1) and Matja Kura 2 (MK2). These are located approximately 9 km from the current coastline, with entrances facing south over the large freshwater lake (Figure 1). MK2 is one of several sites excavated locally which contain marine resources dating to the Pleistocene (Spriggs et al. 2003). A 1 x 1 m test pit yielded well-preserved faunal remains throughout the sequence, including abundant remains of giant rats, reptiles and freshwater turtles, from layers dating to ~36,000–30,000 cal. BP. Evidence for use of the coastal environment includes a broad range of marine shellfish, fish and turtle, which are most abundant in the earliest occupation phase. The earliest date obtained was ~36,000 cal. BP on marine shell from Spit 47, though bedrock was not reached during excavation and it is likely that older occupation deposits are present. Dates from higher in the sequence cluster into two periods: 13,000–9500 cal. BP and >3500 cal. BP. It thus appears that the deposit accumulated episodically, with an early occupation phase prior to 30,000 years ago, followed by a second occupation phase in the terminal Pleistocene-early Holocene, and a final phase in the mid- to late Holocene. MK2 currently has no evidence for human use between ~30,000 BP and 13,000 BP, the time coinciding with the Last Glacial Maximum (O’Connor and Aplin 2007; Veth et al. 2005). During excavation a dog skeleton was found in Spits 26–25 of MK2, with these remains appearing to have been interred in a pit dug from overlying levels. Pottery was present in small quantities in Spits 19–12, with most ceramics occurring in Spits 11–8. Two pot sherds in Spits 26–25 were found with the dog bone, indicating displacement of pottery from ceramic levels during digging of the burial pit. Two samples from the dog bones were prepared at the Waikato Radiocarbon Laboratory, with AMS determinations run at the Rafter Radiocarbon Laboratory on graphite targets processed by the reduction of CO with Zn in a reaction catalysed by iron 2 powder at a temperature of ~575oC. The first age determination was made on bone (L. humerus distal+midshaft) gelatin in 2003 and gave a conventional radiocarbon age (CRA) of 2967±58 BP (Wk-10051). However, the C:N ratio was 3.87 (carbon% 39.4, nitrogen% 11.87), indicating potentially poor sample quality. A new sample of ultrafiltered gelatin (L. femur prox+midshaft) was analysed in 2012 and produced a slightly younger CRA of 2867±26 BP (Wk-34931). The C:N ratio of 3.34 indicates good bone preservation (cf. Ambrose and Norr 1993:404; van Klinken 1999) and the sample produced an age of 2921–3075 cal. BP (Calib 6.1.0, two sigma, p =0.95). 13 C and/or 15 N isotopic values from bone protein are regularly used as quantitative measures of different dietary protein sources for humans and animals (Allen and Craig 2009; Field et al. 2009; Richards et al. 2009; Valentin et al. 2010). Carbon isotopes are generally considered to have a linear relationship between marine and terrestrial food sources. Stable nitrogen isotopes indicate the trophic level of an organism and have been used to determine the amounts of animal versus plant protein (Schoeninger and DeNiro 1984). On Nukuoro Atoll, Davidson (1992) dated two dog bones which had 13 C values of -15.4 and -12.5, suggesting a significant marine component in their diets. Two prehistoric dogs from New Zealand with values of 13 C values of -17.6 and -17.1 and 15 N values of 11.3 and 14.3 also consumed some marine foods (Leach et al. 2001:50). In contrast, Santa Rosa Island dogs of the late Holocene Chumash people, who relied exclusively on hunting and gathering wild foods (Rick et al. 2011), subsisted almost entirely on marine resources ( 13 C mean -1.5±0.8‰ and 15 N mean 17.9±0.5‰). The Timor dog has a 13 C value of -19.47 and a 15 N value of 9.70 (Wk-34931), which suggests a terrestrial diet similar to that of Pacific pigs, but having less marine food compared to some dogs from the Cook Islands and Marquesas, which also appear to show a difference in the trophic level of marine foods consumed (Figure 2). Several attempts were made to extract aDNA from the Timor dog remains. Both teeth (incisor, M 1 ) and bone samples (rib fragment) were processed but, while in relatively good condition macroscopically, none were well-preserved with respect to aDNA. After multiple attempts using the bone and tooth samples we amplified a very small fragment of the mitochondrial d-loop, spanning approximately 84 base pairs from site 15536–15628 (based on complete mtDNA genome reported in Bjornerfeldt et al. 2006). Over this very short region the Timor dog sequence is identical to those of Asian and Asian-derived breeds. Further analyses will focus on the 100 base pairs following site 15628 to determine whether the Timor dog has the point mutations found in dingoes and New Guinea singing dogs (Savolainen et al. 2004). The dog burial comprised 125 bone fragments, representing 92 skeletal elements. The bone was well preserved with little sign of weathering, staining, trampling, burning or gnawing. There is a high incidence of incipient breakage lines that have not developed into cracks; these likely represent the combined effects of the weight of sedimentary overburden and natural decay. The most commonly observed taphonomic feature was recent bone fragmentation which probably occurred post-excavation during transport of the MK2 assemblage to Australia. No cut marks, indicating removal of meat or skinning, were observed on any bones, and the element representation is consistent with the deliberate burial of a complete dog. Age and physical condition of the dog were evaluated using data related to epiphysial fusion, tooth eruption, pulp cavity size and limb bone thickness. The pulp cavity of the canine was assessed against previously published criteria (Kershaw et al. 2005; Knowlton and Whittemore 2001), and indicates an individual of three to four years of age. Tooth wear was, however, minimal, with dentition presenting well-defined cusps, perhaps reflecting a non-abrasive diet. The specimen was male, based on the presence of a complete os penis. Muscle attachments on the limb bones and the occipital region were deep and well-developed. A degree of pathological development was detected on some lumbar vertebrae, with slight deformation of the spinous processes. Such anomalies can be caused by early extensive muscular growth or by repetitive pack carrying/pulling. The only other anomaly was a supernumerary nutrient foramen in the left tibia. Cause of death was not evident, and the overall condition of the skeleton suggests a well fed and healthy animal. In summary, the skeletal data indicates that the Timor dog was an adult male that lived for three to four years, in which time the animal did not experience severe nutritional shortages; there is no skeletal evidence for severe trauma or disease. We have attempted to reconstruct the size and weight of the Timor dog using formulas developed by Anderson et al. (1985), Clark (1997), Hamblin (1984) and Wing (1978), which are based on measurements of length and diameter of limb bones, atlas and mandible. We also examined the degree of teeth crowding, which can help to identify wild from domesticated canids, following Davis and Valla (1978; but see Ovodov et al. 2011). Results suggest the Timor canine was a small to medium- sized dog with a body weight of 8–10 kg and a shoulder height of 39 cm (Table 1). In comparison with modern breeds, it is similar in height to a basenji, but the low body weight reflects a more gracile animal as suggested by the narrow diameter of limb bone mid-shafts. The value of the dental overlap index is 0.67, which indicates a slight degree of teeth crowding within the domesticated ...
Context 2
... Timor dog has a 13 C value of -19.47 and a 15 N value of 9.70 (Wk-34931), which suggests a terrestrial diet similar to that of Pacific pigs, but having less marine food compared to some dogs from the Cook Islands and Marquesas, which also appear to show a difference in the trophic level of marine foods consumed (Figure 2). ...

Citations

... Timor-Leste is known for the earliest appearance of pelagic fishing worldwide , the earliest production of shell fishhooks in SE Asia , the earliest use of ochred shell beads and pendants in SE Asia (Langley et al., 2016a), and at site of Matja Kuru 2 itself, the earliest hafted osseous projectile (O'Connor et al. 2014) and dog burial in SE Asia (Gonzalez et al., 2013). Analyses of the lithic assemblages from sites in Timor-Leste and across Wallacea more generally (the 347,000 km 2 region comprised of >1600 islands in an intervisible island chain (Norman et al., 2018) stretching between Sunda in the west and Sahul in the east) have emphasized long-term continuity and a virtually unchanging lithic technology over the last 50-40,000 years. ...
... Piper (2017) argues that pigs were introduced to ISEA between 4000 and 3500 years BP. The oldest known dog remains on Timor are from Matja Kuru 2 in Lautem District to the east and are dated to ca. 3000 years BP (Gonzalez et al. 2013). While evidence for subsistence activities at Hatu Saur (e.g., faunal remains) declines in the last 800 years (phase 3), it is interesting to note that the stone artifacts remain relatively high during this period. ...
Article
During the Holocene, Wallacea saw dramatic sociocultural changes during the Pre-ceramic, Neolithic, Metal-age, and Colonial periods, as well as climatic and associated environmental changes that affected the landscapes and ecologies of islands. These environmental and cultural processes appear to have influenced human socioeconomic adaptations throughout the archipelago. Here, we present new anthropological and archaeological data demonstrating the effects of these processes. Excavations at the cave site of Hatu Saur on the north coast of Timor-Leste have revealed a deep archaeological sequence that dates from ca. 10,500 years until the present. The site contains extensive assemblages of faunal remains, as well as stone artifacts, revealing settlement patterns that were influenced by sea level change and estuarine infilling after 7 ka. The sequence encompasses the beginning of the Neolithic in Timor-Leste, some 3500 years ago, and the period from ca. 700 years ago when outside influences, including Chinese and Makassar traders and Dutch and Portuguese colonization, greatly affected the indigenous culture and economy on the island of Timor, reflected in the material culture remains from Hatu Saur. The archaeological findings complement related anthropological research in the region that highlights unique local mythologies of settlement origins and their contested histories.
... A dog burial recovered from Square D Spit 25-26 was directly dated to 2921-3075 cal. BP (González et al., 2013) and remains the earliest evidence for the arrival of dog east of the Wallace Line (Greig et al., 2018). ...
... The cultural material recovered in the 2001 excavation includes marine shell beads, ochre, a dog burial dated to ca. 3 ka cal BP, and a stone-lined cooking oven dated to ca. 9 ka cal BP (O'Connor, 2010(O'Connor, , 2015González et al., 2013;Langley and O'Connor, 2019). A bone artefact, interpreted as the haft end of a projectile point, was documented in the Pleistocene levels (O'Connor et al., 2014). ...
... Two dingo burials studied by Gollan (1982) indeed had marine fish remains, presumably originating via human fishing, preserved in their stomachs. Marine and aquatic resources are frequently identified as important food bases for the management of prehistoric dogs in contexts outside Australia (Clark, 1997;Gonzalez et al., 2013;Losey et al., 2013;Perri et al., 2019). The general abundance of faunal resources in these environments may have also furnished an attractive base of scavengeable discard material within and around Aboriginal occupational sites that lessened the impetus for tame dingoes to stray far from the camp for self-foraged sustenance (particularly while raising pups). ...
Article
Full-text available
The historically known relationship of interspecies companionship between Aboriginal foraging communities in Australia and free-ranging dingoes provides a model for understanding the human-canid relations that gave rise to the first domesticated dogs. Here, we propose that a broadly similar relationship might have developed early in time between wild-living wolves and mobile groups of foragers in Late Pleistocene Eurasia, with hunter-gatherers routinely raiding wild wolf dens for pre-weaned pups, which were socialized to humans and kept in camp as tamed companions (“pets”). We outline a model in which captive wolf pups that reverted to the wild to breed when they were sexually mature established their territories in the vicinity of foraging communities — in a “liminal” ecological zone between humans and truly wild-living wolves. Many (or most) of the wolf pups humans took from the wilderness to rear in camp may have derived from these liminal dens where the breeding pairs had been under indirect human selection for tameness over many generations. This highlights the importance of the large seasonal hunting/aggregation camps associated with mammoth kill-sites in Gravettian/Epigravettian central Europe. Large numbers of foragers gathered regularly at these locations during the wild wolf birthing season. We infer that if a pattern of this kind occurred over long periods of time then there might have been a pronounced effect on genetic variation in free-ranging wolves that denned and whelped in the liminal zones in the vicinity of these human seasonal aggregation sites. The argument is not that wolves were domesticated in central Europe. Rather, it is this pattern of hunter-gatherers who caught and reared wild wolf pups gathering seasonally in large numbers that might have been the catalyst for the early changes leading to the first domesticated dogs — whether in western Eurasia or further afield.
... A dog burial recovered from Square D Spit 25-26 was directly dated to 2921-3075 cal. BP (González et al., 2013) and remains the earliest evidence for the arrival of dog east of the Wallace Line (Greig et al., 2018). ...
... The earliest archaeological evidence for dogs is the dog burial in Matja Kuru 2 in Timor-Leste which is dated to ca. 3000 cal. BP (2867±26 BP, Wk-34931; Gonzalez et al. 2013). Thus 3500 years is a maximum age for the dog paintings, but they may have been painted any time since then. ...
Article
Full-text available
We report 40 recently discovered rock art sites from Kisar Island in eastern Indonesia and investigate the commonalities between this art and painted art in other islands of Indonesia and in Timor-Leste. Predominantly painted, the art can be broadly divided into three categories: 1) small figurative motifs including humans, animals, boats and items of material culture, 2) a range of geometrics, both curvilinear and rectilinear, and 3) hand and arm stencils. On the ba-sis of geological features and weathering we suggest that the Kisar paintings span a consider-able period of time, from the Pleistocene through to the Indonesian historic period. We argue that the oldest paintings in the Kisar repertoire are some of the red pigment hand and arm stencils. The small figurative motifs such as the anthropomorphs and some of the geometrics are remarkably similar to those featured in the rock art assemblages of nearby Timor-Leste, and at a number of locations throughout eastern Indonesia. One site with an engraved motif carved into a stalagmite formation was also recorded.
... Moreover, the archaeological survey that led to this study was informed by a desire for increased knowledge of the faunal history of the region, and in large part spurred by the need, identified by Ken Aplin, for increased sampling of natural and archaeological records, especially of rodents, on Pantar. Ken Aplin had a deep and enduring interest in archaeology and throughout his career made major contributions to our understanding of human subsistence practices, hunting technology, and faunal succession resulting from environmental change in the Wallacean islands (e.g., Aplin & Helgen, 2010;O'Connor & Aplin, 2007;O'Connor et al., 2013). This site report honours Ken Aplin's contribution to the archaeology of this region. ...
... The dog tooth in spit 14 (layer 7), associated with a date of c. 1305-1187 cal. BP is not unanticipated, considering dog remains have been recovered from Matja Kuru 2 in Timor-Leste at c. 3000 BP (Gonzalez et al., 2013). Domesticated pigs are thought to have entered ISEA between 4-3 ka (Dobney et al., 2008). ...
Article
Full-text available
The archaeological record of Wallacea remains exceptionally fragmentary. This is especially the case for late Holocene human occupation of the region when lifestyle and culture in marginal island environments is relatively unknown. Here we report on the archaeology of Jareng Bori rockshelter, a Metal-Age site spanning c. 1800 cal. BP up to the late historic period and situated on the eastern coast of Pantar Island in the Lesser Sunda Islands of eastern Indonesia. We use osteoarchaeological (human and vertebrate remains), invertebrate zooarchaeological (crustacean and molluscan remains), technological (lithics, shell, and pottery) and chemical sourcing (obsidian and metal) datasets to discuss networking, migration, and human subsistence strategies during this recent period of history. While some communities were no doubt living in open village settlements where they were producing pottery, the data indicate that aspects of maritime life-ways continued much as in earlier Pleistocene settlements, with people using rockshelters like Jareng Bori to pursue a range of subsistence activities focused on the shoreline. Shellfishing of rocky and reef intertidal species and fishing for mostly small herbivorous and omnivorous fishes was practised, while domestic animals only appear in the late historic period. Wider regional cultural interactions and networking are epitomized by obsidian exchange, dental modification practices, and pottery decorations, while lithic analyses indicates continuity of stone tool technology up until recent times.
... Dogs are unknown in the Island Southeast Asian and Australian regions prior to the Holocene, although the related Asiatic wild dog or dhole (Cuon alpinus) is native to mainland Asia and islands previously connected to it in the Pleistocene (Iyengar et al., 2005). The most commonly cited date for the initial arrival of dogs in Sahul (the combined landmass of Australia and New Guinea) and surrounding islands is 2886-3068 cal BP from Timor Leste (Gonzalez et al., 2013), contrasting with a slightly earlier arrival of the dingo in Australia around 3210-3361 cal BP 1 , as indicated by a direct radiocarbon date on the oldest known dingo bones from Madura Cave in southeast Western Australia (Balme et al., 2018; see Balme and O'Connor (2016) for a recent review). As dog remains in Micronesia have always been found in archaeological contexts postdating c. 2000 cal BP and are thus considerably later than early remains of dogs in Island Southeast Asia and Melanesia, they will not be discussed further in this paper (e.g. ...
... Both the J3751 and J4083 mandibles are complete, although J4083 appears to exhibit hypodontia, with P 1 missing on both the left and right mandibles. Also included in Table 3 are a limited number of measurements published by Gonzalez et al. (2013) for the Matja Kuru 2 archaeological dog specimen; averaged measurements from two modern village dogs (NBD) held in the ANU Archaeozoology laboratory, collected in the 1960s from West New Britain; and averaged measurements from 28 modern Australian dingoes. ...
... J3751 and J4083 each contain a diastema between P 2 and P 3 , and both diastemas are marginally longer than that of Moiapu 1. The Davis and Valla (1978) tooth crowding index (0.69) for Moiapu 1 is also closer to that of the Matja Kuru 2 dog (0.67) from Timor-Leste (Gonzalez et al., 2013). Both of the modern Queensland Museum PNG specimens, however, produced a tooth crowding index of 0.64, much closer to Davis and Valla's (1978) index for wolves than for dogs. ...
Article
Currently the earliest evidence for dog dispersal into the Greater Australian region and surrounds is found in Australia (Madura Cave 3210–3361 cal BP), New Ireland (Kamgot, c. 3000–3300 cal BP) and Timor-Leste (Matja Kuru 2, 2886–3068 cal BP). Previously, the earliest published dog remains for the large continental island of New Guinea was from Edubu 1 (2314–2700 cal BP) in Caution Bay, south coast of mainland PNG. Here we report on a dog mandible from Moiapu 1, also in Caution Bay. Although the mandible could not be directly dated, good chronostratigraphic resolution indicates that it confidently dates to between 2573 and 2702 cal BP (95% probability). It was found deeply buried in association with Late Lapita cultural materials, and is currently the earliest known dog remain from New Guinea. Biometric measurements on a small sample of archaeological and modern dog remains from the broader region support previously published models (based on genetic results) of multiple dog dispersals into the Pacific region.
... The divergence time of each branch is earlier than the archaeological records (the presence of domesticated dog in SEA from $4,000 BP) (Larson et al. 2012;Jones et al. 2019). One of the earliest archaeological sites with evidence of dogs in the Pacific Islands dates back to $3,000 years ago (Gonzalez et al. 2013), which is consistent with our results. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
The ancestral homeland of Australian dingoes and Pacific dogs is proposed to be in South China. However, the location and timing of their dispersal and relationship to dog domestication is unclear. Here, we sequenced 7,000-to 2,000-year-old complete mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) genomes of 27 ancient canids (one gray wolf and 26 domestic dogs) from the Yellow River and Yangtze River basins (YYRB). These are the first complete ancient mtDNA of Chinese dogs from the cradle of early Chinese civilization. We found that most ancient dogs (18/26) belong to the haplogroup A1b lineage that is found in high frequency in present-day Australian dingoes and precolonial Pacific Island dogs but low frequency in present-day China. Particularly, a 7,000-year-old dog from the Tianluoshan site in Zhejiang province possesses a hap-lotype basal to the entire haplogroup A1b lineage. We propose that A1b lineage dogs were once widely distributed in the YYRB area. Following their dispersal to South China, and then into Southeast Asia, New Guinea and remote Oceania, they were largely replaced by dogs belonging to other lineages in the last 2,000 years in present-day China, especially North China.