Science topic

Watershed Management - Science topic

Watershed management is the study of the relevant characteristics of a watershed aimed at the sustainable distribution of its resources and the process of creating and implementing plans, programs, and projects to sustain and enhance watershed functions that affect the plant, animal, and human communities within a watershed boundary
Questions related to Watershed Management
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
4 answers
Imagine you have a field with excessive salt buildup. Assume the volumetric water content is 0.35 cm3 cm-3 and the root zone is 120 cm deep.
If the soil in the field is a clay loam soil with Ks= 5.5 cm per day, b = 5.2, and saturated water content (Theta)=0.5 cm3 cm-3, the hydraulic conductivity followed Campbell’s model, and the flow was under unit gradient conditions (i.e. negligible matric potential gradient), then how long would it take to leach out the salts?
Relevant answer
Answer
The leaching process duration can be estimated using the leaching requirement formula:
t = H/K
where:
- T is the leaching time,
- H is the leaching requirement (difference between initial and desired salt content), and
- K is the hydraulic conductivity.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
I am trying to assess the quantitative impact of climate change on hydrological regime of a semi-arid subbain; and I can not select among different customary models.
please help me based on your knowlege and experience in water resources modeling.
SWAT? SWAT+? WEAP? HEC-HMS? IHACRES? or something else?
Relevant answer
Answer
SWAT is mainly preferred among the models asked in your list. The HEC_HMS model is usually selected for event-based modelings like simulating flood hydrographs or in the design of flood estimation. Since you are simulating for a continuous time period, SWAT is a better choice. It is a widely used model. One can even incorporate management and agricultural practices.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
3 answers
1) What challenges do you/have you encountered in watershed management and planning?
2) Are there processes you feel should be automated?
Share your experiences in watershed management.
Relevant answer
Answer
There are various challenges I faced in research and then as a hydrologist/watershed specialist working for the USForest Service. As with any country or land ownership/management, one must understand the pertinent laws, regulations, goals and intentions, such as Caring for the Land and Serving People. Watershed Management is not the only reseource that managers must consider, so it is best to prescribe or suggest measures with reason and meaning. Reading and interpreting the hydrological and watershed research, and then trying to apply it to the land and resources while still allowing a reasonable degree of activities, while keeping effects as erosion, sediment and water yield changes to acceptable levels is a challenge. For example, mass forest land clearing has been shown to produce high effects, but spacing the harvest areas out and not covering more than 25% of any area seemed to be a reasonable compromise as long as the conditions and streams were stable. Rapid reforestation was expected. Other challenges occur when there are landslides, severe erosion, gullies, road or fill failures, other interconnected land or water uses as mining, domestic drinking water, irrigation, wastes from industry or urban areas, structural designs to consider flooding, fish passage, etc. The list of items and the public or stakeholders involved can be complex and change from area, project, watershed or basin.
You might find a few software that purports to address watershed management, and it might be a helpful start. But depending on country, conditions, ownership, stakeholders, etc., watershed management expectations and plans could change. Most watershed scientists and managers are typically consultants, and not the final decision makers. So prescriptions and plans need to be well based in research, reason, field and resource conditions. Many activities that can affect watershed and water conditions have best management practices (BMPs) or soil and water conservation measures developed to fit conditions.
If you want to take the time to look through the papers and reports, etc. that I uploaded, you will find some examples of the types of issues and projects a watershed specialist might deal with. In my last few decades with the USFS, I lead the local development of automating the RUSLE so it could be applied to forest management estimation of effects of erosion, sediment and more recently water yield changes. The emphasis was the calculations were not real, but could be used to estimate differences in land use options or alternatives. I think I uploaded to Researchgate one of our environmental assessments concerning restoration (removal) efforts of mountain areas planted in error to loblolly pine. As remote sensing through aerial photos, and LiDAR coverage, and availability and digitation of soil maps, contour DEMs, land uses and cover types, geology, hydrologic boundaries, etc., these were instrumental in helping to make appropriate field, road and stream checks.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
3 answers
When carrying out watershed management and planning where do you start? and if so what impact does it have on the overall goal of management and planning?
Relevant answer
Answer
There are various books and papers addressing watershed management or some aspect. A good start at the University level would be taking a few suitable courses land and resource inventory and management including hydrology, soils, geology, vegetation, land uses, etc. Your country, landowners, resource agencies, and communities may have their own ideas or suggested direction. Basically all life to varying degrees depends on the soil, water and air. There is probably no cookbook on how to start, but after some literature review and inventory of conditions, one might proceed. One of our uploaded papers was on the Hydrologic Condition of Indian Creek. It’s not really an example of watershed management, but may give you some idea on some of the factors to assemble. Resource inventories and data assemblage often lead to storing data into a GIS format. How the watershed is managed can affect the water quantity and quality, which in turn can affect the types of resources and uses it can support. Various land uses and associated activities can also influence water, so identifying some best practices and if needed regulations can be helpful to achieve overriding societal goals. But it is not unusual to find conditions of past historical land and resource abuse where watershed conditions are poor or less than desired. Reestablishing acceptable watershed conditions is sometimes difficult and costly to achieve. That is why developing a watershed management plan can be very important to identify current conditions and help determine if protection, constrained management (rules, regulations, BMPs, etc.) and/or improvement measures are needed. As suggested by Dr. Singh, assembling stakeholders for involvement is preferable, but one should also consider in areas of critical water supply and a past history of water use and land ownership, one may need to work to diffuse issues with appropriate meeting management skills.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
2 answers
Does the slope factor (SF) and reference dose values (RFD) for different metals remain constant when assessing the risks of heavy metals in water, soil, or sediments?
If it is different according to the environment, please provide us with the values ​​of each environment.
Thanks
Azzeddine.
Relevant answer
Answer
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
5 answers
Wildfires have ravaged southwestern United States over the past 12-18 months. The impacts of these fires don't just end with the burnt watershed/areas. The altered soil properties in the watershed will create major hazards in a rainfall event that can impact essential infrastructure and stakeholders in the floodplains. Managers need to make efforts to identify risk zones and allocate resources to mitigate the potential impacts that follows a wildfire event.
Attached here my initial work in this area:
What impacts should one consider from a rainfall event that is preceded by a wildfire event! How can we allocate resources during a pandemic driven economic crunch. I would like hear some thoughts on this.
Relevant answer
Answer
Identifying the bioclimatic regime of the areas under threat to fires is one of the foremost requirements for an efficient forest fire management strategy. These days Google Earth Engine provides one of the fastest ways to prioritize vulnerable areas within the forests. Janaki Sandamali William F. Hansen and others have provided useful information regarding it.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
22 answers
Dears all
I would like to know what are the relationships among watershed health, watershed sustainability and watershed stability!
Please share your experiences with me.
Thanks
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Dr. Douglas Nuttall
Thank you very much for the insightful description.
Regards
Gowhar Meraj
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
27 answers
I am looking for two to three people who want to be co-authors in my paper on the role of watershed organizations in QC.
If interested, let me know!
Thanks in advance.
Relevant answer
Answer
Good call...
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
13 answers
I work in the northeastern USA and I am trying to find options for temperature/level loggers with automated real-time data collection and cloud-based data storage for easy data access. We have a network of sensors in our study watersheds, and data download takes up a lot of time and resources. Anyone have good luck with any sensors and/or data plans that offer cloud-based data access?
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you, Brett Boisjolie, for discussing this issue. Since I live in a Himalayan region, we are still coping up to bring automated data loggers in our hydrological assessments. Usually, the systems we use are stand-alone systems that record data, which field workers manually pick up. However, in downstream areas wherein cellular networks are available, the data is continuously logged and sent to the admin while storing that in the cloud too...
Thanks
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
11 answers
Call for Water Storage solutions and example projects - do you have an unique, resilient or innovative approach to water storage? Please go to our online Water Storage Survey: https://lnkd.in/d8E8349
We are seeking nominations of storage solutions to include in an upcoming World Bank report on Water Storage. The report is intended for developing countries with increasingly complex needs regarding water storage and its management, enhancing Water Security. We are including solutions for the following areas:
  • water storage planning and decision making;
  • groundwater management;
  • planning for integration of green and gray solutions at scale;
  • dam operations;
  • improved urban flood resilience;
  • planning and management to avoid “day-zero” situations of urban water shortages;
  • integration of small-scale storage into irrigation schemes;
  • watershed management to improve downstream dry-season water flows;
  • understanding and minimizing environment and social impacts;
  • among others.
We welcome any storage solutions and example projects - worldwide - that you may wish to nominate. Please go to our online Water Storage Survey: https://lnkd.in/d8E8349
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
12 answers
Anyone holds information regarding the typical hourly distribution of rain events in Australian cities (i.e. rain intensities, hour by hour) is welcome to contact me for a shared research/publication.
Currently, the (insufficient) data that is available for me is daily rain and IDF (intensity–duration–frequency) curves.
Please no comments which refers me to the BOM website :) thanks.
Relevant answer
Answer
look for NASA GPM
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
15 answers
There is no doubt that the access to surface freshwater is an ecosystem service. However, I feel that the many publications on ecosystem services and disservices with respect to the water supply (and water security as a whole) published those past 15 years have created fuzziness when it comes to qualify the 'origin' of this service.
Although mostly seen as a forest-related ecosystem service, the development of the concepts of hydrologic services and watershed services makes me wonder how those three connect together.
For instance, are all hydrologic services dependent on upstream forest health? If so, they logically are all forest services, even of the forest provides other ones, meaning that the diversity of hydrologic services (see Brauman et al. or Martin-Ortega et al.) is basically nested into the diversity of forest services.
However, when it comes to managing forested areas for the provision of surface freshwater, it is likely that options will be scrutinized at the watershed level (i.e., source water protection). Therefore, even if the watershed scale might be used for the management of other services, it means that forest services are nested into watershed services, right? Or are watershed services only relevant for water-related questions?
This classification is really important to establish because it will guide the management of forest disturbances that can impact water and therefore the mitigation of post-disturbance water risks. Forest disturbances create disservices because they can negatively impact the quality, the quantity, and the timing of the supply, but are those disturbances and their consequences forest disservices, hydrologic disservices, or watershed disservices? It would depend on the classification retained.
What are your thoughts on this topic? Do you have references that would help me connect the dots?
Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
all about integration
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
14 answers
Dear Researchers,
I am applying interpolation by kriging method using GIS and interpolation did not cover the whole of area under consideration.
How to do this? Please guide me.
Regards
Naveed
Relevant answer
Answer
Make spatial extent
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
Watershed development structures like Contour Trenches, Contour Bunds, Loose Boulder Structures are built to arrest the run-off and soil erosion. They facilitate the infiltration, which trigger improved soil moisture and water table.
We work on the watershed development in India. I wanted to know the relationship between watershed development structures and soil moisture in following regards:
How does impact of watershed structures on soil moisture vary with the
  1. soil depth?
  2. soil type?
  3. time after the monsoon (rainy) season?
  4. distance from the watershed structure?
Relevant answer
Answer
It's about watershed properties and management practice
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
7 answers
I am looking for data set to develop a flood forecasting system specifically for an agriculture dominated watershed. The requirements include a) fine resolution DEM b) land use type and soil hydrologic group c) hourly/sub-hourly rainfall data for a minimum of 30 years d) hourly/sub-hourly stream flow data and e)demographic details of the area. It would be helpful if you suggest any data repository/experimental watershed for collecting the above mentioned data. I assure you that the services offered will be duly acknowledged.
Relevant answer
Answer
look for NASA aqua and terra
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
5 answers
I am planning to perform hypsometric analysis (Curve) for my study area using DEM image, can anyone kindly let me know the procedure to follow?
To draw Hypsometric Curve and Hypsometric Integral of a watershed 
Relevant answer
Answer
Morpometric analysis
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
10 answers
Due to demands on flood control and water supply in China, many reservoirs and sluices have been constructed in the main streams and tributaries. Most of rivers were losing river's natural hydrological processes, seems like lakes or reservoirs linked together diving by sluices and dams. Our analysis shows that many hydrological stations didn't had any flow even in wet year. So, here is the question: where's the fate of these water?disappeared by evaporation, Irrigation or something else. How can we estimate the amount?
Relevant answer
Answer
in which environment
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
13 answers
We work on watershed development which should actually increase the soil moisture. We are trying to detect the change in soil moisture in a barren land using remote sensing. We want to groundtruth the results. What are the tangible effects of increased soil moisture in barren land (e.g. grass being greener for the longer periods)? We can take narratives of the villagers to explore the impact on these effects of soil moisture.
Relevant answer
Answer
look for GRACE
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
9 answers
For a project I'm looking at the cost and benefits of water retention in the soil versus water retention directly on the land. As of now water authorities create areas for water retention, in order to cope with excess in precipitation or meltwater. Creating and applying these areas will affect agricultural production. Further costs for damage do apply and perhaps buying up land, but how much is that and also purely the process of storing the water on the land. Anyone having thoughts, literature about this? Help is appreciated. Thanks in advance!
Relevant answer
Answer
need agriculture economy
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
15 answers
I research effects of riparian zone on water quality. Have you any idea about this issue?
Relevant answer
Answer
good question
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
16 answers
Hello Dears
I would like to know about the associations related to watershed management in different countries.
It is appreciated if you share your information with me.
Best Regards
Relevant answer
Answer
no
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
what are the band combination for landuse and landcover for watershed management using landsat 8 and landsat5??
Relevant answer
Answer
Just calssify LULC with systematic approch
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
16 answers
thanks in advance.
Relevant answer
Answer
its one
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
16 answers
Can someone help me with different watershed management practices for hilly areas ? Requirement is to have enough water for crop cultivation. I am looking at the hilly areas, any proof of concept or plan available fir India would be really helpful.
Relevant answer
Answer
Spatial anlysis
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
12 answers
Watershed development is the set of practices to impound the flowing rainwater, and thus help it percolate. But the groundwater recharge is also dependent on many other factors like the amount of rainfall, rainfall pattern, topographic slope, soil type, soil thickness, rock type etc. How do we measure the impact of watershed development on the groundwater?
Please do share publications on this topic.
Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
Look for spatial parameters and the groundwater settings
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
4 answers
If you have a source, new book, article or educational booklet, please introduce it. Thanks
Relevant answer
Answer
Best management practice includes all the hyperspatial aspects and socio-economic
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
16 answers
We work on Watershed Development. Soak pit is an important treatment to filter and percolate wastewater (from kitchen, bathroom). In the terrain with black cotton soil and hard rock, water doesn't percolate. In stead it stagnates on ground. Soak pits are also not possible where houses are densely placed, where there is concretization or where there is underground gutter lines.
In such scenarios, what is an alternative treatment to soak pits? Is there any working model for such treatment?
Relevant answer
Answer
long one I think
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
2 answers
The check dams used as torrent control works have some characteristics - in my opinion - which are neither quite those of retention dams (hydraulic structures) nor quite those of retaining walls. So, taking into account their behavior over their period of existence (50 to 100 years), a short period the check dam works as a hydraulic structure subject of hydrostatic/hydrodynamic pressures. Then, after the upstream sector is completely filled with sediments, it works as retaining wall, perodically submited to floods. I put this question because, verifying such a structure using Eurocode 7 I obtain larger dimensions than using the old global factors of safety. And a more than 100 years of experience shows that economically the last approach is better. 
According with the experience and technical regulations in the European countries, are them subject of Eurocode 7 or of some special regulations? 
Relevant answer
Answer
Check dams reduce erosion of the area around the highway. They can be designed also using EC 2 ON CONCRETE STRUCTURES.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
4 answers
It becoming very clear that watershed approach is an effective tool for most development agendas, especially in the rural and agricultural context where almost all conditions are natural. The ever challenging climate change impact is believed to require new approaches in our effort. Re-thinking newer approaches in our watershed management is mandatory. However, knowing the key elements that need rethinking and taking fast actions in watershed management needs integrated effort, fast communication, and updated information.
Relevant answer
Answer
Management of water resources
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
7 answers
Those who are working in the field of watershed management are familiar with land capability classification (LCC). For farm lands, the LCC developed by USDA soil conservation service, mainly based on the ability to produce crops without further deterioration, has been adopted by several countries with or without modifications.
In thickly populated tropical countries, however, biophysical capability of the land alone could not decide the land use pattern. For such countries, a “treatment oriented land capability classification” was published by FAO adopting a flexible view on land use. This is a modification of the original LCC, but it is “treatment-oriented” meaning that land is categorized according to the types of major conservation treatments to be recommended for erosion control.
Is there any country in the world who enacted laws for land use according to LCC? If not, what would be the reasons?
Relevant answer
Answer
In Brazil, each state has regulations about which crops can be planted and where according to agroclimatic zoning principles (coffee examples attached).
They also have laws about amount of land to leave wild but in frontier regions these are often not respected.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
11 answers
We are working on a large scale Watershed Development in Maharashtra, India. We want to evaluate the outcomes of our work after 1 year. I was wondering what should be primary outcome variable. Sample size will depend on that.
Relevant answer
Answer
have a look this important pdf attachment.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
7 answers
Hello Everyone,
I want to use VIC model for permafrost regions to simulate runoff under changing climatic and vegetation cover. Any guide / information may be very supportive and helpful for me. So please share if you have any kind of support / guide /help etc.
Regards
Naveed
Relevant answer
Answer
Interested
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
6 answers
Dear all,
I am currently doing a project that is integrating the GIS and ANN together for watershed management. However I am stucked in how to inputting the files into the neural network.
Please kindly share with me the procedures and your help is highly appreciated!
Relevant answer
Answer
you can read in the files as text (if you dump them as such),
then you can extract shape descriptors, moments etc., and feed them as features to your neural network classifier.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
4 answers
Need to understand the long term changes in the release from upstream storages to the intensively cultivated delta.
Normally flows are from July to Feb months only, over the years flow has reduced to Aug to Jan.
flow data is available for a network of 17 gauging stations in delta. how it can be studied ?
any suggested literature ?
Can i do the analysis in Excel ? if not please suggest some software ?
Relevant answer
Answer
There may be other considerations to include, and check for data availability or possible for development. Changes in rainfall during period of analysis? Changes in land use -- imperveous surfaces increase runoff peaks, reduce base flow. Changes in vegetation type such as pine trees in my vicinity can have ET of 30 inches, hardwoods 20 inches, grasslands 10 inches. Conversion to some species can exert substantial transpiration demand, enough to lower water tables and cause streamflow to decline. Also are there new or increased water uses in watershed, irrigation, wells, demand for water has increased from people, crops, industry, etc. Are gauged streams showing decline or just some of them. Are streams incising or adjusting to change (eroding, degrading, gullying, ditching or canals for drainage, drainage of wetlands). Are upstream releases of stored waters being changed for some reason? Is there increasing water management, storage or retention in dams, ponds? If there are no rainfall, land use, water use, water management or use, stream morphology or other changes, the problem becomes more difficult. It may be a combination of several factors such as those mentioned, producing this change.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
7 answers
Our organization works on Watershed Development. We intend to measure effect of watershed treatments on vegetation and cropping pattern. We plan to use satellite images for the same. NDVI maps can be generated and NDVI statistics can be calculated using satellite images. But is NDVI good enough indicator to detect changes in vegetation? How can one interprete NDVI stats and maps? How can we classify land use using NDVI?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi dear N. Joshi
This old paper (from 1995) summarizes, refers and discusses most of the vegetation indices found in the literature. It presents different existing classifications of indices and proposes to group them in a new classification:
There is other newer reviews about vegetation index:
Hugs. Luís P.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
18 answers
Dear Experts,
As we know that construction of unit hydrograph for a guged locations helps in discharge estimation, especially peak discharge.
I am interested to construct the unit hydrograph of a particular gauging site for which I have multiple rainfall runoff events. In order to construct unit hydrograph what are the criteria for selection of events and how to construct UH from these events. What is it's acceptability, mean how can we validate the constructed UH?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Gebiaw - Good links on the topic. Best wishes
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
4 answers
The watershed management practice is trapping the water along with the sediments, which used to be transferred to the estuary region. These sediments in turn transported to the coasts, the food for that landscape !
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
3 answers
From the watershed and sediment management point of view, which aspects and effective factors of Functional and Structural sediment connectivity should be paid attention?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Robert,
Thank you for your explanation. I agree with your view. But there is one thing which need to be paid attention. Generally we think that functional connectivity is depends on the structural connectivity but I think some sediment transport processes (such as Sediment Storage or Sediment Redistribution) are due to of inconsistency between structural and functional connectivity.
I would like to know what you and other readers think about this matter.
Best wishes,
Saeed
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
2 answers
What are the main differences and similarities between Functional and Structural sediment connectivity?
Can we say they are acting in watersheds independently?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello Saeed,
You can think of 'structural' features as elements that exist in the landscape or environment, even when there is no runoff or sediment transport (i.e. during dry weather). They might include the location and dimensions of patches of bedrock outctop, or patches of plants, or gullies, rills, roads, bunds, etc. 'Functional' connectivity means how the connectivity actually operates when the system is transporting water and sediment. This would clearly depend on things like the length of time rain lasts, how intense the rain is, how wet the soil might already have been when rain began. Structural connectivity in general would only change relatively slowly, but the 'functional' connectivity could change from minute-to-minute or over hours.
Hope this helps,
best wishes
David
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
4 answers
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Firoz,
here is another source with the proceedings of the International Conference on Water Resources of Arid and Semi-Arid Regions of Africa, which took place in 2004:
Also, check out the extensive UNDP material about IWRM, you will find a lot of material on arid regions in there as these tend to be the crucial catchments:
All the best,
Michael
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
15 answers
Availability of rainfall intensity data at micro scale is a big constraint in attempting rainfall-runoff modeling. often we have daily rainfall data . Is it possible to use that time series , to synthetically derive hourly rainfall values . I hope to get educated and invite supportive stuff if any of us have ? 
Relevant answer
Answer
RMC (Random Multiplicative Cascade) model is also an option to disaggregated daily rainfall into hourly rainfall. You can google about it e.g.
I have tested this approach in some of the stations in South India. This approach work reasonable to get the reasonable estimate of distribution at hourly scale.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
4 answers
I am looking for the value of the HDI, that it would be possible to separate USGS gauges to non-urbanized, semi-urbanized and urbanized watersheds based on that. As I am working in the ArcGIS, I need quantitative values for this index.
Relevant answer
Answer
Using watershed metrics like Effective Impervious Area has been successfully used to evaluate stream impairment. This might work well to classify urban, and suburban areas rather than general land cover metrics. Given your background in GIS, I recommend using EIA or similar classifications of the watershed land to develop thresholds. This literature is well developed in past decade. One threshold you could use is 10% EIA that has shown to have a shift in nature of impacts from rural to suburban conditions. Indices like HDI could help but using it to classify the type of land use impact on hydrograph is not straightforward. 
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
2 answers
Hi everyone,
For a global scale project I'm working on right now, I'm wondering if I can use Net Primary Productivity data as a proxy to potential post-fire recovery. My basic thinking here is that pre-fire NPP conditions help post-fire recovery, i.e. facilitates it in the case of high NPP levels, which would mean that existing natural conditions help vegetation to thrive.
Obviously, many other factors condition post-fire recovery, but I'm looking for references that may validate or invalidate this thought. I was not able to find anything so far. Any insights?
Relevant answer
Answer
In issue in your research design is the selection of NPP as the independent variable and recovery as the dependent variable. How are you measuring the NPP (actual, potential) or are you intend to predict NPP? How do you define recovery? Pre-fire biomass, NPP or species (diversity)? Recovery in all three features is by definition fast in pyro-climaxes on the millennium time scale like the Mediterranean biomes (maquis; garigue, fynbos, savanna, steppe) and those on the century timescale (taiga, heath). Further you may consider your time scale.
An issue you may consider in less frequently burning biomes is the whether the pre-fire plant growth is N or P limited as N is removed from the system by fire.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
This is part of my work with a conservation organisation called Rare. We work with local partners who conduct extensive research, including KAP surveys, as part of their social marketing projects promoting behaviour change for sustainable watershed management, in Colombia. We need to cut down on complexity and costs with these surveys.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Alan
I'm not sure whether you are interested in doing household level surveys (although the tool can be adapted beyond that).  If you are, have a look at the tools and support systems for household surveys developed by the Computational Tools Team of the Development Research Group of the World Bank.
The computational tool is named the Computer Assisted Personal Interviewing (CAPI) tool for undertaking household surveys. CAPI tools are part of the World Bank Open Bank, Open Data, Open Knowledge initiative, which has developed analytical tools for applied research by bringing together specialists in high‐level programming, advanced econometrics, and geographic information systems to create appropriate data
gathering and analysis products/tools.
The programme covers a number of areas of support for research, viz.:
 Software for data collection
 Software for automated data analysis
 Software for data dissemination
 Tools for micro‐econometric analysis
The project to develop the CAPI tools was initiated in 2012 as a joint venture collaboration between the World Bank, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, the Living Standards Measurement Study‐Integrated Surveys on Agriculture team and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.
The tool allows an efficient household survey process that provides respondents the option of filling in their own questionnaire for privacy if required.  It also facilitates data analysis and consolidation to a central hub that allows updating of data in an uncomplicated and cost‐effective manner and a relatively simple 'in-house' tool for tracking changes from a baseline and for monitoring and evaluation progress.
Good luck
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
27 answers
I have just one station in the outlet and have monthly rainfall too.
Relevant answer
Answer
Basically if your outlet station records water level on stream per time, and you have stage (level) relationship to discharge in cubic meters per second, calculate the flow by time unit, and add it up for each month, and your total will be in cubic meters for each month.  Your watershed will have a size in square kilometers.  Each sq kilometer is 1 million sq meters.  Divide the monthly cubic meters by the watershed area in square meters, and you will get meters of water yield averaged over the watershed.  You may prefer to report that in cm or mm, and can make the conversion to compare with rain data from your station.  Most of this can easily be done with an excel spreadsheet, and there are various ways to report results on a daily, monthly or annual basis. 
If this is not what you were wanting, perhaps I misunderstood and you may clarify. 
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
10 answers
For example, would the distance of a reforested tree community from a river (i.e. near or far from the bank) or distance from the source of a river (i.e. nearer the source, nearer the mouth or in between) matter when it comes to its effect on how fast the body of water will overflow in a hypothetically intense rainfall event?
Would there be other factors that have to be considered in making decisions such as to where reforestation efforts must be concentrated on first (especially in an extensively denuded watershed)?
I'm looking at the forest in terms of its hydrological importance and effect on the water dynamics of a watershed. Forests can intercept rainfall and help to slow down the flow of water to a receiving body of water such as a river or lake. 
Relevant answer
Answer
It was indeed nice to read apt comments by Dr.Hensen and Dr. Green. Here are some of the observations published in recent publications...
Recent research in forest hydrology points to the fact that the general assumption that more trees equal to more water is based upon our inaccurate understanding of the hydrological cycle in forest ecosystems.   This assumption has so far dominated most forest and water policy. In fact the forest ecosystem is the major user of water. With tree canopies, through interception of precipitation and evpotranspiration from foliage there is reduction in the groundwater and stream flow. Both natural and manmade forests use more water than most replacement land cover including the agriculture and grazing. This may be translated in the fact that even partial forest removal may result in the increase in the downstream water yields. Although there are some suggestions of the  removal of water-demanding forest cover as a means of preventing or mitigating droughts, especially in semi-arid regions. However, such a policy is been weighed against the consequent loss of the many other services and goods that forests supply. These include erosion control, improved water quality, carbon fixation, reduced salinization, recreation and aesthetic appeal, timber, fuelwood, other forest products, and biodiversity.
It is also well established that partial or complete removal of the tree cover accelerates water discharge, increasing the risk of flood during the rainy season and drought in the dry season. Although forest cover’s importance in regulating hydrological flows has often been overestimated, the impacts of forest cover removal are evident only at the micro-level and in association with short-duration and low intensity rainfall events (which tend to be the most frequent). As rainfall duration or intensity increases and the distance down the watershed and river basin becomes greater, other factors start to override or dwarf the effects experienced close to the deforested area. These factors include the size and morphometry of the basin, what happens in other tributary streams, the direction of the storm path and the intensity and duration of the storm
At the macro-scale, natural processes – rather than land management in the upper watershed – are responsible for flooding. Hence, although there are many good reasons for reforesting watersheds (e.g. reducing soil loss, keeping sediments out of streams, maintaining agricultural production, wildlife habitat), reducing flood risk control is certainly not one of them. Reforestation to prevent or reduce floods is effective at only a local scale of a few hundred hectares. Even on the local scale, much depends on the depth of the soil and the character of the precipitation event. Deep soils can store more water before they become saturated, and deep-rooted trees make the soil mantle more receptive for storing water from a new event. Antecedent rainfall and soil water storage have a great influence on the generation of runoff. Thus, for frequently occurring rainfall events of short duration or low intensity, forested soils may reduce or prevent flash floods locally. For the rarer prolonged or high-intensity storms, however, once the soil layer becomes saturated, water will run off, even where there is full, undisturbed forest cover. On shallow soils, especially steep ones, storage is much less and the watershed is more prone to flash floods; trees or other vegetation or land use can do little to stem the fast subsurface and overland flows.
A publication by FAO and the Center for International Forestry Research (FAO and CIFOR, 2005) has this to say: Although forests can play a certain role in delaying and reducing peak floodwater flows at local levels, scientific evidence clearly indicates that forests cannot stop catastrophic large-scale floods, commonly caused by severe meteorological events …. This in no way diminishes the need for proper management and conservation of upland forests. But it does point toward the critical need for integrated approaches in river-basin management that look beyond simplistic forest-based “solutions”.
Forests’ most significant contribution to the hydrological balance of watershed ecosystems is in maintaining high-quality water. This is achieved through minimizing soil erosion on site, reducing sediment in water bodies (wetlands, ponds and lakes, streams and rivers) and trapping/filtering other water pollutants in the forest litter and underwood. Good forest cover is the most effective land cover for keeping water as sediment-free as possible. Forest is certainly the best cover for drinking-water supply watersheds, because forestry activities involve no use of fertilizer, pesticide and fossil fuel, or outfalls from domestic sewage or industrial processes.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
Any documentation of US watersheds with site number and location map.
Relevant answer
Answer
You might try the USGS Hydrologic unit code website
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
5 answers
Hi, 
I want to download and Process DEM of a Dam watershed. I know only the latitude and longitude of Dam site. I am using this website to get DEM http://srtm.csi.cgiar.org/SELECTION/inputCoord.asp. Kindly guide me among data file and mask file  which file I should process to get DEM. What is the format of DEM file ? Moreover guide me how to locate sub-basins,Meteorological and Hydro-logical Gauging stations within the catchment and outside but nearby the catchment on the DEM. 
Relevant answer
Answer
My expertise is not GIS, but I use it alot.  From your question, I detect you may not have delineated a watershed boundary before.  I would suggest for anyone, even modeler, do it by hand the old fashioned way a few times.  I have done it by hand so many times, the boundaries on topographic maps are easy to pick up, and will give you appreciation of what flow accumulation modeling and boundary determination can and cannot do.  The dam is your hydrologic outlet (low point), and in delineating, you go from dam perpenducular to contours on both sides of the dam to the ridge, then follow the highest ridge that defines water flowing into or out of your watershed.  Your line will intersect top of ridge or mountain, continue through saddles between the highest points.  Doing this by hand may be slow at first, but it is an exercise for understanding.  Infrequently, you may find generally small mistakes in modeling boundaries, that may force a closer look at the stereo pairs as topographic maps are seldom perfect.  We have a researchgate paper from 2015 discussing improved delineation of coastal hydrologic units and streams.  I doubt it will address the GIS process detail you want, but may suggest how difficult this can be in relatively flat terrain with standard topographic map DEMs.  LiDAR DEMs are much better at defining detail -- also 2007 paper discusses other applications for using LiDAR in gully and channel delineation.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
6 answers
What is the optimum buffer for investigation river changes along 80 years by satellite images and aerial photography ?
Relevant answer
Answer
Correct, there is no set meander width and geologic conditions can restrict or enhance meander formation at any point along the valley floor. Valley width is probably an incorrect indicator, depending on the type of physical environment in which the stream resides. A steep gradient would restrict lateral migration and thus meandering, while a low gradient would promote a wide meander belt. However, a stream's valley floor (or floodplain) often represents its entire history to grade, thus there could be relict courses, overflow channels, etc. (see JPG). By rule a stream's meander belt is generally about 15 times the stream's width for moderately at-grade (or near-grade) water courses. One meander area in the attached JPG showing LiDAR data along an upland mature stream, however, has a width 20X that of the stream. If good LiDAR data is available for your study area, that would be best way to more accurately assess the meander width along the stream. This can be used along with historical maps and aerials to determine channel ages if you need to restrict the data to 80 years.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
6 answers
regarding the water rights issue and critical analysis of problems small farmers are suffering from also the social justice aspects of small farmers.
Relevant answer
Answer
There is a good job.
FISRWG – Federal Interagency Stream Restoration Working Group. Stream Corridor Restoration: Principles, Processes, and Practices. Portland: Federal Interagency Stream Restoration Working Group (15 Federal agencies of the US Government). <http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/Internet/FSE_DOCUMENTS/stelprdb1044574.pdf>.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
5 answers
Which part of the sediment particle size is the most important? Clay or silt? why?
Relevant answer
Answer
Since water pollutants are chemical in nature and very minute too, their transfer through sediments will have a lot to do with porosity and drainage. Silt has a porosity of about 25% while clay has a porosity of about 30%, slightly more porous than silt. The higher the porosity the higher its water retention ability and the lower its drainage. It follows that silt has a higher drainage ability compared to clay and is likely to transfer  water pollutants more. As to which one of them being more important, it depends on your point of view. From my point of view, both are important since clay retains more pollutants while silt drains more pollutants.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
15 answers
Hello everyone
Do you have any experiences from watershed management practices that lead to reduce evaporation from water resources?
I need some case studies' results about aforesaid subject or any other related references.
Also, I would like to know which practices have been used in your countries as an appropriate measure to reduce evaporation and increasing water productivity.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello Saeed,
A detailed reply is not possible here but you may get your specific info from following link. 
Water losses specifically from surface could be reduced by mulching on barren surface and reducing the surface area of water ponds.
Subsurface water application may significantly reduce the evaporation losses. The most forgotten part is selection of plant species, we have seen plant recommended for waterlogged area with higher ET were planted in water scares areas :)
Cheers.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
14 answers
Coud I employed RUSLE Model to Estimate soil erosion in monthly scale?
Best Regards
Relevant answer
Answer
yes RUSLE, have capability for monthly soil loss but your all factor r not monthly changeable except R (rainfall) and C (for Vegitation).
And for monthly C you can estimate C from NDVI (monthly), which give u more changes (Monthly based) than the LULC (yearly changes) based,
also u can use this link
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
3 answers
Researchers have used simulated sediment yield at the sub-watershed outlet as a measure to prioritize area for targeting of BMPs. The results of this ranking of sub-watersheds (based on absolute sediment load at their own outlet) may not essentially similar to ranking area based on the sediment yield at watershed outlet.
My goal is sediment yield reduction entering reservoir dam. Therefore, i need prioritization method based on  contribution of sub-watershed on the sediment yield at watershed outlet (or entering reservoir dam).
Do you have any suggestion for my goal (prioritization of sub-watershed based on their share to the sediment load of the watershed outlet using SWAT)?
Relevant answer
Answer
The ideas above are not bad.  I really don't know of the perfect answer.  Roehl  (1964 I think) estimated sediment delivery by watershed size for differing physiographic areas using dam efficiency as an indicator.  In general, his data supports smaller hydrologic units deliver more sediment per unit area than larger units.  The term subwatershed does not mean the he same to everyone, but by that term, I assume you are probably 10-40 thousand acres, maybe 4th to 6th order streams.  If you know or are aware of the Rosgen stream types, braided streams D type are efficient at retaining sediments, and other stream types such as G and F types are normally unstable, and more efficient at both eroding and delivering sediments.  Check out wildlandhydrology.com.  However if the ultimate goal is to reduce sediment, knowing streams or sections that are sediment sinks, aggrading, etc., those may be your friends, even though habitat for fish may be bad.  Streams that are degrading or actively widening to reach stability, those are important to find, along with major sediment sources along roads, landslides, gullies, etc.  Habitat for fish is not that great for these either.  The middle of the road are streams in balance as they have regular access to their floodplain at bankfull flow so their bank erosion is limited, and they are able to store some sediment during over bank flows during floods.  By identifying your most critical problems by stream reach or specific activity, such as roads or urban areas, you can more effectively target your objective.  I am not very familiar with SWAT, but it may include some of the land us and other factors that I would consider.I use RUSLE approach is that I have developed and adjusted for our specific circumstances, vicinity land uses, road types, etc. over the years.  Over the years, I have had mixed feelings about beavers, but I know in many areas of the USA, they were native species, and the early explorers suggest clear and clean waters.  I have seen sediment accumulation, and beaver dam failure.  My guess in lower gradient braided systems with ample rain and rapid vegetation response from beaver eating of riparian vegetation, beavers may be beneficial if sediment reduction is critical.  However, they can also stop up culverts or do other damage if they locate in a the wrong places.  Treatments need to fit the circumstances, and you have the right idea in looking for ways to prioritize your effort or advice.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
5 answers
Models use data to predict weather patterns and floods. Is their a need within the UK to increase rain gauge spacial resolution to 0.5km and a temporal resolution to 1 minute for more accurate and reliable flood predictions? Does soil moisture content need to be monitored?
Relevant answer
Answer
Predicting rain and runoff, flooding is largely based on limited records, and in many instances you are not going everything you want.  Models will typically use all the data you can muster, and be wanting for more.  You need a combination of recording rain guage stations preferred and recording stream gauges and have an absolute minimum of 10 years record for any predictive capability or comparisons with the old data stations, however even 100 years is probably not enough for some things.  Consider the rainfall event we had in October near Charleston, SC.  Using the available data, we had the 1000 year event on the national forest, but as soon as we insert this data into the total and recalibrate, perhaps it may be the 500 year event.  Weather specialists do a reasonable good job now with their data and tools for predicting weather within the next few days, weeks or maybe as far as months, that is pushing it.  However, the predictive tools rely on spatial data, and a lot of it.  In areas with a lot of topographical relief, adding more rainguages can help coverage of individual storms or help locate areas that then to get more rain, but they are not necessarily going to improve prediction but may help with years of data.  Weather patterns shift, the jet stream shifts, you can have wet years, dry years, and individual event severity is dependent on a lot more than a truck load of data.  It is best to model and predict as best as we can, but identify the uncertainty and build infrastructure, homes, etc. accordingly.  If you are in the floodplain, elevate your structure above the 100 year or more elevation, and such as put your garage on the lower level and accept your car may or may not be flooded in your lifetime.  Most people don't have the information at all so that they can consider it as an option. 
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
5 answers
Does anyone have experience using Government Land Office (GLO) survey data in the U.S. to describe watershed history? I have late 1800's records of vegetation associations (upland and riparian species), records of river crossings along the township/section transects that could be used along with aerial photographs to determine changes in stream sinuosity, and in some cases historical records of river widths. Any existing examples or new ideas regarding this research are welcome. Thanks!
Relevant answer
Answer
You should use whatever you can find and have time to interpret.  A local archeologist, geologist, and land surveyor used to interpreting the records may help.  Aerial photos always good, but how much time to you have?  If you can ascertain the types of land use changes and identify any really major ones like land clearing, farming, overgrazing, mining especially hydraulic mining, hydrologic modifications like ditching, old landslides, geology maps of faults, strikes, dips, and other lithological features all add to your end product.  But in most instances, time is not your friend.  Maybe some old timers or former landowners have info too, pictures, etc.  Even surveys by early explorers may sometimes have touched your area of interest.  And the old boundary surveys and in some instances the SCS early soil maps can show streams and other interesting things.  If you are familiar with the US Forest Service, they have publications on watershed and hydrologic assessments you might find useful on the internet.  But the type and level of detail may also depend on your ultimate purpose.  I used to work on the Siskiyou National Forest years ago, and the land records were all microfiche, and time consuming to read.  Although interesting to read, we seldom had time to consider that detail.  However archeologists and historians of today have many tools including GIS and digital filing to store data that we did not have 40 years ago.  Since you mentioned vegetation associations, so there may be botanical records available from botanists or ecologists.  Sometimes ecologists do surveys of the soils and landtypes, burning, vegetation, etc. and come up with their best guess (they don't call it that, probably something like ecological land classification) of what it once was. 
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
Any researcher can suggest me  various methodology related to check Dam mapping from satellite imagery.
Relevant answer
Answer
Unless the dams are pretty big, you need LiDAR.  We have found old dikes in the coastal plain, beaver dams sometimes from LiDAR coverage.  I doubt if satellite imagery is suitable except for the larger dams, which I would not call check dams.  A generality relative to checkdams, the higher the check dam, the more hydrologically unstable it is.  Better to have more frequent low rise check dams for erosion control that the high check dams that are so hydrologically unstable.  You may want a loose rock checkdam for a grade control to stop gullying, but keep them low and make sure the thalweg is low enough or the edges high enough, so that the high flows don't erode around the dam.  In sandy terrain, a 1 foot drop can erode 6 feet deep if the plunge is not rocked and abrupt.  A deep plunge will often lead to failure.  I am unsure that satellite imagery is detailed enough to locate existing ones, but maybe if you don't have a lot of trees or vegetation to hide them like we do. 
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
12 answers
What possible two development projects you may suggest to achieve a sustainable IWRM within the watershed area?
Relevant answer
In my opinion, once identified properly the beneficiaries, ask the population what are they are prepared to do and how much are they ready to pay to achieve a sustainable system in which water reuse is affordable to farmers. Ask the farmers what are their priorities and limitations and why do they need more water and what product are they planned to cultivate before planning an irrigation system. Ask the politicians what are they really want to do to support the new project. And finally, ask the technicians if the solution is reasonable.
Best regards
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
6 answers
Suggest a framework for an adaptive IWRM to coordinate management and development of water resources, land, and environmental resources aimed at maximizing the social and economic benefits without impacts on the ecosystems with x-valley
.
Relevant answer
Answer
Please take a look at the follwing publication: "A Handbook for
Integrated Water Resources Management in Basins" GWP, 2009
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
6 answers
How can watershed management enhance and promote a sustainable IWRM?
Relevant answer
Answer
Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM) is the process of supporting the synchronized development and management of water, land and related natural resources, in order to maximize the resultant economic and social welfare in an equitable manner without compromising the sustainability of the vital ecosystem. IWRM is increasingly gaining importance as the approach to water resources management has shifted from supply driven to demand driven. The concept of IWRM is also influenced by the increasing water scarcity and deterioration of water quality. The world is going through tremendous changes in climate, land use, increase in population, industrialization, etc. This has put a lot of pressure on the availability of water to meet the increasing demands for various purposes. The sustainable management of water can be ensured only through integrated approach with cooperation of various departments and stakeholders. Availability of clean and safe water is a major challenge in many of the Nations. Unsound management of water weakens the development of mankind and adds to the imbalanced distribution of economic welfare. Pollution, depletion of water resources and collapse of ecological functions are of universal, regional and local concern.
The concept of IWRM has gained wide acceptance as a guiding principle in the water sector. The aim is to promote economic and social development by addressing and balancing diverse interests of water users, while simultaneously safeguarding water resources. This is the rationale for the IWRM approach that has now been accepted internationally as the way forward for efficient, equitable and sustainable development and management of the world's limited water resources and for coping with conflicting demands.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
6 answers
I have NetCDF files of CMIP5 scenarios how to find representative row and column of my study area in these NetCDF file
How to find representative row and column of study area in a NetCDF file? If I have netCDF file having Precipitation data in this form 480*260*25 i.e Longitude*latitude*time then how i can extract precipitation data of a specified area?
Relevant answer
Answer
Using ncdump tool would be the most appropriate, as it's made directly by Unidata - the NetCDF format developer. It can eventually dump the data from NetCDF to e.g. txt format, extract file header and so on. Check https://www.unidata.ucar.edu/software/netcdf/docs/netcdf/ncdump.html
If you need to extract the data for your specific area of interest from the global grid file, then try ncks tool http://linux.die.net/man/1/ncks
Both mentioned works for Windows and Unix environment. 
Good luck!
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
9 answers
I am going to add different amendments to soil in order to increase soil water capacity. Can you introduce me some new methods and amendments for this purpose?
Best Regards
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you Dear Hein & Dear Janaka
Regards
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
6 answers
I am working on watershed delineation for my study area. I am using EPA and streamstats tool for watershed delineation. I want to know the details algorithm and limitations for both watershed delineation tool.
Relevant answer
You can use  QGIS software in which have a complement named TauDEM deloloped in Utah State University specifically for hydrology and watershed delineation
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
Recently, I want to apply some low-cost materials like sawdust, rice husk, biochar, coconut shell, clay .... to fabricate an inexpensive equipment to apply for water treatment. Can you suggest some ideas that I can solve this problem? thank you
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you Sir. Abdelazim M Negm. I will look for some documents concerning with this information
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
5 answers
Can anyone provide me with some literature on Watershed management in Himalayan region?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Vinayak, Dr. Chandra Prasad Ghimire defended very good thesis on this topic: Hydrological impacts of reforesting degraded pasture land in the Middle Mountain Zone pof Central Nepal at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam in spring last year. May be this can help you. Best regards       Jan
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
13 answers
What is the relationship between watershed management and control desertification?
In many countries these two subject are separate from each other.
For example, usually in arid and semi-arid countries, the watershed operation was done in the upstream and desertification control operations carried out in downstream areas. Do you think that any kind of watershed management practices is not as a combat desertification?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Dr-Radwan A Al-Weshah
Thank you very much for your attention and cooperation.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
10 answers
Hi, would you write down the formules for flood volume estimation please? especially about applicable with rational method?
Relevant answer
All above discussion is useful. To make things easy, divide your watershed into small subbasins to be able to use the Rational Formula. Route the triangular  flood hydrograph from one outlet to another outlet downstream (e.g., using Muskingum method). The resulting hydrograph shall be trapezoidal shape. Give the time base and shape of hydrograph you can calculate the volume.
Remember to include any other  abstractions if your storm duration is long (greater than 24 hrs)
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
2 answers
If more water is retained in a landscape it will affect soil and air temperature, milders peaks and lows and more - and also different soil biological processes. Looking for cases and evidence..
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Frank
I often wondered about micro- and meso-climatic effects of the purposive lowering of the groundwater table over large farm areas in the Netherlands (especially in spring) as well as converting the Zuiderzee (open to the Atlantic) into the IJsselmeer lake fed by the river Rhine system. Both in the past century. Your best chance to get some data would seem from grassland research in "Wageningen" as the groundwater lowering is aimed at earlier grass growth in spring.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
sustainaibility proceses for "management"
watershed governance 
adoption of watershed management at local scale 
public investment for watershed management
attitude changes at local/politica level
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
19 answers
I found error in watershed delineation in qgis grass plugin. How can I solve this?
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with colleague Sajid recommendation of using GRASS  GIS  and/or, spatial analysis of GIS, and/or  global Mapper for this task  as you will not be only capable of  delineating watershed boundaries of the basin but you will also be able to calculate and analyze the other watershed and drainage parameters.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
1 answer
Terraces are one unique landscape created by human on unfavorable terrians. What are the functions beyound increasing food productions? any leads are appreciated.
Relevant answer
Answer
Great!Great....
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
10 answers
What methods, approaches, models, program and software are applied for watershed health assessment?
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
9 answers
In watershed planning, it is necessary to know local perception about watershed itself. How it is relevant to the whole planning scheme? How to encorporate
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Wilbert,
In my opinion, the most important perception is about pollution of  sources.
In the contexto of "planning", please see:
Nine Minimum Elements to Be Included in a Watershed Plan
Regards,
Vanessa
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
I am developing a phosphorus (P) budget for an agricultural watershed. Chemical fertilizers and organic matters (compost and manure) are the main sources of P in my study site. In addition, the soil of the watershed is characterized as sandy loam. P sorption capacity of manured sandy loam soils is lower than chemical fertilized soils. So, can I conclude like that P coming from organic matters are mainly exported through waterways. Or is there any way to identify which part of P mainly exported from the watershed hydrologically? 
Relevant answer
Answer
The question is a good one and as a chemist I am not happy with any of the responses so far.  Most research relies on measuring molybdate reactive P before/after treatment of soil solutions/ runoff/ flow-through to discriminate between organic and inorganic forms of P in solution. Unless the species are first separated molybdate reactivity is an indiscriminate tool.  And separation itself is complex because much of the P, even if present as phosphate, may in fact be part of suspended colloids. I'm sorry to say that separation followed by measurement is the way to go, but I'm unaware of any authoritative research on the topic, i.e. selective measurement is probably a project in itself. Were I to go there I would use  chromatographic separation with  dual post column detection, e.g. using ICP on one leg and molybdate on the other.  On the ICP leg I would simultaneously measure Fe, Al and C for starters as indices of the forms in which the P may be present.  Good luck!!
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
18 answers
Seeking several papers about runoff production methods and their necessity.
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
Dear Researchers,
I am working with ARCSWAT 2012 using Arcgis 10.2 in 
I faced a problem in second step( Watershed delination)
When I import the DEM map it does'nt work and it shows the message you can see in the attachment.
I would appreciate if you can tell me how can I fix it.
Thank you in advance.
Best Wishes
Farzad
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Farzad,
You need to have full permission on your project folder. Be sure that all your layers has the same geographic projection and that they cover your full area. You also need to change the regional setting in your computer to USA,  I hope this helps.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
6 answers
Does anybody know material suitable for underground civil engineering, like lined rubber sheets, which would be impermeable for tritium (HTO and HT)? We would like to use it to protect leaching and diffusion of tritium produced by secondary hadron cascades from accelerator areas in soil to groundwater in a shallow aquifer surrounding the hot zones.
Relevant answer
I just try to check with zeolites Molecular Sieve beds and so on, but tritium always permeates even rafm steel...
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
4 answers
 I have problems understanding the positive results of treatment conservation of water and soil in an arid region called AIN Chenia Tebessa region in terms of work of art be it the torrential corrections, culverts or mechanized and cereal bench open surfaces.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi freind Intigrated development process in watershed means that the enhancement in soil moisture, crop yield, water table greenery, plantation, income of farm family and happiness sows the positive impact of soil and water conservation activities in the watershed. Thanks
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
9 answers
I am working on evaluation of climate change impacts on two adjacent humid subtropical watersheds . The catchment area of the watersheds are 270 km2  and 153.5 km2. Is it possible to evaluate climate change impacts for the said areas. Which type of climate change models may be used for this study, if anyone know RCPs scenarios and CMIP5 global climate models please share with me
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Muhammad,
In our article "Climate projections for ecologists" we have a section that describes the 3 more commonly used techniques to down-scale a Global Climate Model (GCM). Table 2 (Advantages and Disadvantages of Different Techniques for Rationalizing Global Climate Model Output)  in our article briefly describes these techniques, and statistical down-scaling is one of them.
A key question you may ask when choosing down-scaling techniques is if you need to gain pixel resolution (so the map will 'look' better and match other spatial data you already have), or if in addition of adding the pixels resolution you need climate information (a better climatic presentation at a smaller scale). To give you a quick example, you may have an output from a GCM at 100km pixel, and you may use  stats to get a 100m pixel, but you won't be adding any climatic information to it.  Then, if you needed detailed climatic information the statistical downscaling may not be appropriate method, if you had access to a dynamically down-scaled model, then,that would be the best choice.
The paper I mentioned earlier also present a table with links to all public repositories: Table 3. Overview of Climate Projections Available for Use in Ecological Studies, Based on Different Regionalizing Techniques. You may find this information useful perhaps.
Regards,
Luciana 
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
5 answers
please add your answer in the context of integrated urban water management
Relevant answer
Answer
Check out the following DSS: Mike Basin, WEAP, (Water Situation Assessment Model) WSAM, RIBASIM, Eelbe-DSS!
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
9 answers
I'm very interested in use cases with Arc Hydro and your experiences with it. Do you think it has an added value compared to standard Spatial Analyst analyses?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi,
ArcHydro is fully dependent on ArcGIS, so no stand-alone use. And it's not comparable to Spatial Analyst in any way, as the tools in the latter are quite basic and don't help for hydrology-related studies (while they are okay for basic land system mapping).
As wrote Daniel, you can use HEC-HMS, but many models exist, more or less using ArcHydro or Spatial Analyst to generate inputs or processes. A very popular yet complicated model is SWAT (Soil Water Assessment Tool) that has an ArcGIS extension, but also WEPP, and the list is quite long, for extensions and for stand alone applications as well.
It finally depend if you're interested in process-based (hydrological model) modeling or empirical modeling (ArcHydro).
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
Trying an IPM (NON-GLYPHOSATE!) approach to controlling bermudagrass at the edge of a lake that is stocked for human sport and consumption with hybrid bass. The approach I'm suggesting is stocking with adult triploid grass carp, temporary flooding (during a colder period), and then solarization. Open to other approaches or suggestions, and I'll happily share any results.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks, Sharon! It's looking more and more like a few very large trip crap would be an ideal control, and since the plan is to simply 'sink' a few large dead trees into the lake as cover, that they'd have a secondary food source. I'm a bit concerned about an increase in water turbidity, but that might be relatively easy to balance by adding a few smaller herbivores, if the plankton eaters don't take up the slack.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
9 answers
It would be great if such a data is collected and available for scientists. Even better if it is updated regularly.
Thanks in advance,
Ron
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks Andrew, that's an awesome site.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
7 answers
Dear all,
Assuming that we identified different sources of errors in hydrological modelling. Lets say rainfall is estimated with its error(uncertainty) band, the ET is estimated with its error(uncertainty) band, and other inputs (model parameters) of the model also have been estimated with its errors,  what are the  state of art in propagating all the errors  into the discharge uncertainty.  Unlike the rainfall and ET which is instantaneous each-time step errors, there will also be some initial condition error, that i want to include in the error propagation . So what is the best way to include all of these ? 
Best regards 
Wuletawu 
Relevant answer
Answer
My colleagues Dmitri Kavetski and Mark Thyer have published a lot on this topic - I'd recommend having a look at their Bayesian Total Error Analysis (BATEA) papers (e.g. "Kuczera G, Kavetski D, Franks SW and Thyer M (2006) Towards a Bayesian total error analysis of conceptual rainfall-runoff models: Characterizing model error using storm-dependent parameters, Journal of Hydrology, 331(1-2), pp. 161-177.")
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
13 answers
Most of the time watershed development programs are being executed in participatory mode with farmers. Winning of there trust is very important for success of any such project.What important steps one should take for maintaining transparency in executing watershed development programs.
Relevant answer
Answer
Successful Watershed Governance would be transparent, and include the following attributes.      In the United States governance authorities are split between executive, legislative and judicial branches; and further split between national, state / tribal and municipal institutions.      Watersheds cut across multiple juristictions (Federal, State/Tribal, Municipal), and there are many different regulatory, non-regulatory institutions that can contribute to collectively agreed upon solutions.     Thinking broadly, a good governance process would have the following attributes, in order to achieve the needed collaborative design solutions, that involve a combination of regulatory and voluntary actions
Attributes: :  
1. Participatory, local support and public involvement
2. Emphasis on creating enabling conditions, especially at the local level: To what extent are municipalities playing a role/taking responsibility? How does the volume of local responsibilities affect implementation? Is there a balance between plans and big, bold actions?
3. Systematic/strategic/long term intervention: Is there clear thinking about long term connections and focused effort. Do efforts maintain focus and hold long term views; they do not get stuck/frozen on “what has always been done.”
4. Funding resources for program/projects: Ability to leverage funds, force investment, create financial sustainability.
5. Shared decision making that creates political support: Political support at appropriate levels, which flows from unitarian decision making, shared commitments, eagerness to implement and desire to move forward together.
6. Science plays an important role: Documents conditions and provides policy relevant information. Relationship between fine tuning and justifying policy versus driving policy.
7. Is there clear leadership/champions: Champions create shared ownership of problems, are collaborative, can work across multiple institutions and see issues/hold a big issue, often before the others.
8. Ability to disband/adapt/deal with evolutionary change: Can adaptively deal with new shocks and problems; able to shift to starting things rather than making existing things last without compelling reasons. Balance of resources (financial, human, etc.) between planning and implementation.
9. Includes performance measurements: Looks at both outputs and outcomes. Ability to keep track and be able to report; simple public record keeping.
10. Balance of Power: Power sharing within network and throughout the decision making process
11. Successfully communicate/share information to diverse network affected by issue/program: Role of independent advocacy of the press and its future. Ability to access reports and information.
12. Role of people who coordinate the network: Ongoing coordination that produces action.
13. Focal problems that are shared: Problems that are limited in scope (comprehensive versus strategic), which are important/resonates with constituency and leads to shared solutions. Issues that transcend the tension between synoptic v. strategic – hard to look holistically, more progress with strategic action.
In some cases, when the needed enabling conditions are missing, they need to be intentionally created; e.g. in cases where existing institutions lack sufficient authority and / or capacity to solve issues of common concern.    
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
5 answers
Many studies compared pasture with other cropping systems. In this case, the pastures are always kept without animal. But, if the animal was kept on pasture, soil losses could not be higher because of the compression?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Sarwan Kumar Dubey, I would appreciate if you could send me a copy of this study. You can send in pdf format to jrcesar@usp.br. Thanks
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
7 answers
I feel like people know that wastewater effluent, if it is reclaimed, can be used for many things.  But I don't hear a whole lot about specific uses other than trying to reconvert it to potable water.  So I am curious to know if there are different levels of reclamation that are attempted based on an effluent's intended use.  When most people think about reclaimed wastewater, are they primarily thinking about potable uses, or are there are other possibilities commonly explored?  What are some helpful resources others have used on this topic?
Relevant answer
Answer
Here in Thurston County, WA, USA, there is a study underway to examine potential uses of reclaimed water, potentially even for drinking purposes (see http://www.lottcleanwater.org/reclaimed.htm). The major hurdle so far is how to treat pharmaceutical and related health/household wastes. Hence, the county's land-use regulations presently don't allow recharge of aquifers with reclaimed water in critical areas for fish and wildlife (see http://www.co.thurston.wa.us/planning/planning_commission/agenda/2012-03-07/pc-agenda-20120307-memo-reclaimed-water.pdf). Indeed, aquatic vertebrates are more sensitive to endocrine disruptors than humans, and reclaimed-water usage could deplete streamflows for fishes without flow-restoration considerations.
-Bob Vadas, Jr.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
3 answers
If anybody has done it, can I get it for reference?
Relevant answer
Answer
If I understood by watershed mapping you mean watershed delineation. You will need:
Data
  • DEM - Digital Elevation Model
  • Base Map - Aerial photo or Satellite Image
Software
  • ArcGIS - Licensed
  • Spatial Analyst Extension - Licensed
  • ArcHydro - free tool. this tool analyse the DEM and produce flow accumulation raster, flow direction raster, catchment delineation raster, etc.
  • Hec geoHMS - free tool. It do the same as ArcHydro and prepare your data for HMS model.
  • Or you can use MapWindow GIS - open source program with watershed delineation script included.
Find more on youtube or google by "Delineating watershed using GIS" or "ArcHydro tool".
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
2 answers
Implementation of wells on floodplain to use for crop production.
Relevant answer
Answer
There may be perched aquifer in flood plain area that too seasonal. Test bore is another option for assessing shallow wells.  
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
1 answer
Applying value engineering in watershed measures.
Relevant answer
Answer
I have done some research in applying Value Engineering to concurrent product and process development.
I am not sure if it could apply this to your watershed measures or not. Let me know if you find this applicable to your problem?
Thanks
Brian
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
8 answers
Suggest approaches, techniques, indices, etc. and available research and publications/online resources to help characterize watersheds based on fisheries interests vis-a-vis watershed features for conservation and development.
Relevant answer
Answer
Consider index of biotic integrity, stream temperature/dissolved oxygen baseline and thresholds, and hydrologic characteristics.  Also see the indicators of hydrologic alteration by TNC: https://www.conservationgateway.org/ConservationPractices/Freshwater/EnvironmentalFlows/MethodsandTools/IndicatorsofHydrologicAlteration/Pages/indicators-hydrologic-alt.aspx
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
6 answers
I am doing sensitivity analysis on streamflow variables. I changed the precipitation while unchanging watershed temperature. From the analysis it was found that 7-day minimum  flow is less sensitive than the mean flow ( in most of the watershed), however got reverse results for other watersheds( 2 out of 8). 
Relevant answer
Answer
I am agree with Pooneh and Kenneth, the annual Q7 min is a low flow index. In permanent rivers it could be not influenced by rainfall. Hydrogeological characteristics of the basin regulate the Q7 min value.
Manciola P., Casadei S. "7-Day 10-Yr low flow relationships for ungauged sites in Central Italy". Proceedings of  the Irrigation & Drainage Sessions at Water Forum '92, American Society of Civil Engineering -ASCE-, Baltimora, August 2-6, 1992 (pp. 250-256). Very old !!! But significant.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
4 answers
What should be the best management practice for the Himalayan resources is always a debatable issue. Recently INDIA-CHINA-NEPAL are looking forward to adopting a robust watershed management approach including livelihood (Socioeconomic) improvement, natural resource management, Long term ecological monitoring and access and benefit sharing into the consideration. Kindly suggest some reference/books.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you Srivastava sir thanks a lot...
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
30 answers
I believe sustainable requires the interconnection of ecological with socio economic components of watersheds while integrated management refers only to water resources in relation to socioeconomic alike. is this true?
Relevant answer
Answer
in my opinion sustainable watershed management is the goal while integrated watershed management is the approach. 
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
19 answers
As far as i know the SCS Curve number method is not designed for the runoff estimation in Mountainous/hilly terrain.... If not plz correct me..
Relevant answer
Answer
All the studies we did in Sri Lanka and even in Thailand did not give good results with the SCS curve number method. The Runoff and its peak is not predicted correctly.  Please refer the following publications of ours. Good methods to estimate runoff are given in the paper number 1 given below.
1.Halwatura, D., Najim, M.M.M., 2013. Application of the HEC-HMS model for runoff simulation in a tropical catchment, Environmental Modelling & Software, 46 : 155-162.
2. Najim. M. M. M. Babel M. S. and R. Loof. 2006 AGNPS Model Assessment for a Mixed Forested Watershed in Thailand, ScienceAsia 32(1): 53-61
3. Babel, M.S. Najim, M.M.M. and Loof, R. 2004. Assessment of AGNPS Model for a Watershed in Tropical Environment, Journal of Environmental Engineering of the ASCE, 130(9): 1032 – 1041.
4. D. Halwatura, Najim M.M.M. and N.W.B.A.L Udayanga, 2013. Impacts of Urban Water Management in Attanagalu Oya Basin, In proceeding of: Special session on Urban Water Environment Monitoring & Management, 4th International Conference on Structural Engineering and Construction Management, 2013,, At Kandy Sri Lanka.
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
5 answers
Watershed Management Practices (WMPs) are a set of techniques,
measures, or structural controls that are used to prevent or reduce
the degradation of runoff water quality and/or quantity.
WMps reduce alterations in runoff volumes and are typically
designed based on a peak-flow value, where the discharge for a
certain frequency should not exceed predevelopment conditions.
This criterion is limited in sustaining the health of downstream ecosystems.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Hamzeh,
I just saw a documentary on the link between the health of the Great Barrier Reef corals and the cutting of tropical forest for agriculture in the Northeast of Australia. As Wes has pointed out flow routing can change temperature and chemistry of run-off as well. In the case of of Australia's Northeastern territories, it impacts on the runoff to the Great Barrier Reef. And in that case it is not that much peak flow which is important, but typically Wes' nutrient loads.
The development in the tropical mainland in Australia caused the dying off of part of the corals of the Great Barrier Reef. The main cause for this is that originally almost clear water (that area of Austrlia receives more than 10 meters! of precipitation per year) due to deforestation led to an increase in erosion of the original forest soils (turned into agricultural land). This caused an increase in silt content and sedimentation in the Great Barrier Reef waters as well as strongly increased levels of nutrients from the agricultural areas. Increased settling also induces the same increase in sediment  content and increased levels of nutrients. As a result algae bloomed in the areas of the Great Barrier Reef where the silt and nutrient substances increased due to runoff from areas in the watershed where tropical forest is and has been cut.
Algal bloom caused the death of the corals in the reefs impacted by increased nutrient levels from the mainland areas which had been 'developed'. The algae when strongly growng on the reefs, increase the attenuation of incoming sunlight towards the corals, the effects of this on corals are very well known,... a sudden death so to say.
Knowing that the Great Barrier Reef is also a defense line against floods and storm surges of the Pacific Ocean, the coastal areas face increased flooding risks. Or,... how all these natural systems are coupled in a fragile equilibrium, which can be strongly shifted towards degradation of the Great Barrier Reef corals due to human settlement, forest cutting, agricultural practices and indeed Water Management practices on the tropical mainland. I am sorry to say that humankind is not yet capable of organising its settlements in the way nature has developed the equilibria between its different ecosystems for millions of years.
I don't want put the blame on the Australians here, because all continents on Earth have and are doing exactly the same as the Australians. The difference is that in the Northeast of Australia, settlement is pretty recent, while typically in Africa, Europe and Asia, it is much less recent, with deleterious consequences for many watersheds and the seashores where continental run-off comes to an end.
Have a nice day,
Frank
  • asked a question related to Watershed Management
Question
10 answers
Decreasing trend of inflow is observed in most of Iran's main rivers. 
Analysing decreasing trend of river' inflows: Determining the contribution of each of climate variability, change and upstream consumption.
 
Relevant answer
Answer
A good question. It is important to differentiate the impact of climate variability and climate change in decadal to multi-decadal time scales. In many cases, the decline of runoff might have resulted from both, and human activites. In my opion, we can not detect any signal of climate change in the lonf-term precipitation series for many river basins at present, and the observed trends, if any, might mostly be caused by climatic variability on the decadal and multi-decadal  time sacles, and the recent human consumptions.