Science topics: PhilosophyEthicsVirtues
Science topic

Virtues - Science topic

Character traits that are considered to be morally praiseworthy. (Bioethics Thesaurus)
Questions related to Virtues
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
5 answers
The concept of fasting and intermittent fasting has spiritual roots. However sceintific literature suggsts fasting helps in healing the body by virtue of autophagy and helps in clearing infections , dead cells etc. Further discussion on topic is requested
Relevant answer
Answer
I think this needs scientific experiment and medical proof to see whether it works or not.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
7 answers
In most cases survey research involves covering a wide geographic bound and/or a large number of population study. And due to the high cost and considerable time of coverage provision is made for the use of samples in the study. To guide appropriate sample selection, a good understanding of the principles of sampling techniques and sampling procedures becomes crucial. Basically there are two methods of sampling, which are the probability and non-probability methods. The probability method has four sampling techniques - simple random, systematic, stratified and cluster. The non-probability method numerous sampling techniques, among which are purposive, quota, snowballing, convenient etc. The emerging questions are: What are these sampling methods or techniques designed for? To sample study population or study location? A careful study of these sampling techniques and procedures reveals that they are designed MAINLY FOR SAMPLING OF STUDY POPULATION or the set of people to be studied. THE SAMPLING TECHNIQUES ARE NEVER DESIGNED FOR SAMPLING OF STUDY LOCATION, NO MATTER HOW LARGE THE GEOGRAPHIC SPREAD OR BOUND IS, there is NO PROVISION FOR SAMPLING AREAS AS STUDY LOCATION By default, an area or a social system becomes a study location by virtue of the existence of the social phenomenon to be studied in the area. Where it is invariably impossible to cover the entire geographic bound, it is not the locations (such as communities, counties, local government areas, or states) to be sampled but the people that make up the study population across the locations. CLUSTER SAMPLING TECHNIQUE provides the right procedure for this. If you are to conduct a survey study on post traumatic effects of COVID-19 in Nigeria or the US, how will handle the geographic spread of the study? Let's have your take! hashtag#SocialScienceResearchHints hashtag#Survey hashtag#Studylocation hashtag#SamplingTechniques hashtag#SamplingProcedures hashtag#ClusterSamplingTechnique
Relevant answer
Answer
Okanlade Lawal-Adebowale -
I am not completely certain as to what you are asking, but perhaps you might have an interest in small area estimation (SAE), or small area prediction, i.e. design-based or model-based.  Design-based cluster sampling can help you sample for a broad area when travel is a problem. It is less efficient (meaning variance is relatively high for a given sample size) but can be more convenient and less expensive. But SAE may help give results for smaller geographic regions possibly by employing a model-assisted or a model-based approach. Borrowing strength from neighboring geographic regions may be helpful. J.N.K. Rao and others have done some sophisticated work in this area (SAE).  (You can find some more elementary comments on this in a conference paper I wrote in 2022:
A big problem with design-based (probability-of-selection-based) sampling is nonresponse. One often uses modeling to handle nonresponse and at some point you may as well use a model-based (prediction-based) procedure overall. You might be interested in knowing that the new chair of the Survey Research Methods Section of the American Statistical Association (ASA), who I believe is also an Assistant Chief Statistician of Canada, has expressed desire to find how to move forward with survey sampling in the future. I commented on two short articles he wrote for Amstat News, a magazine of the ASA:
January 2025:
Survey Research Methods Section Looks Ahead with Sights on Nonresponse | Amstat News:
February 2025:
Surveys Here to Stay | Amstat News:
Best wishes - Jim Knaub
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
11 answers
According to epistemic virtue theory, a purpose-driven mindset, diligence, cognitive resilience, and related personality traits are considered intellectual values. These psycho-moral virtues, as existential weights, fill the emptiness of a nihilistic life, bringing an empowering sense of joy, inner strength, and unwavering determination. In your perspective, what are intellectual values?
Relevant answer
Answer
Those who are intrigued by this sidebar on Wernher von Braun might take a look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wernher_von_Braun in order to get a sense of the complexity of the case as regards intellectual and moral virtues and values.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
4 answers
Suppose there is a phosphate group with P attached to 4 groups-
-O-R, -O-R', -O, =O (Last two differs by the bond type: single and double bond)
The P is sp3 hybridised and would be chiral if all 4 groups attached to it are different. Are -O (single bond) and =O (double bond) considered to be different groups by virtue of their difference in bond type?
Relevant answer
Answer
In this case, there would be a resonance between the two-oxygen atoms attached to the phosphate group which leads to the presence of a plane of symmetry, and due to this plane of symmetry, the molecule should be achiral.
For surety, I would suggest you synthesize such molecules and test chiral polarity.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
11 answers
Doctoral Research on the topic of Happiness and Virtue in Ancient Philosophy
Relevant answer
Answer
Please read the chapter on happiness in the book published at cost on Amazon: "Life Examined: Lessons in Buddhist Philosophy." There you will find the difference between pleasure and happiness explained; the futility of the pursuit of sensual pleasures; and what true happiness is. Please check out: https://www.buddhismdemystified.org/ Let me know what you think:)
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
15 answers
using book 1 and 2 of Nicomachean Ethics, do u think virtue is essential to happiness?
Relevant answer
Answer
You wrote: "Having or truly having happiness: Sometimes a person might believe they possess happiness, but in reality, it may be an illusion, stemming from a dangerously low level of self-awareness and moral capabilities."
True, people can be deluded about being happy. But being happy doesn't require a belief that one is happy. One can have a happy childhood after all. For sure, a state of happiness achieved through living in accordance with virtue has added value. But that is a contingent feature, not a necessary condition. (Nor is it a sufficient condition for happiness.)
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
8 answers
Can emotional intelligence be considered a form of moral virtue, and if so, how does it contribute to ethical decision-making and virtuous behavior?
Relevant answer
Answer
Exactly.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
3 answers
Other than the widely discussed trolley problem,
Relevant answer
Answer
You can go back to the example of Covid19 and find countless cases when doctors had to make a sound decision to save a life and risk another. The general rule was to save the youngest and sacrifice the eldest when there was an ethical dilemma of who to save first. I think that this decision was mostly utilitarian as it sought to protect the right to life of those who would bring more pleasurable consequences to the world (in terms of productivity) than the elderly. It was not deontological because the categorical imperative of justice would suggest that all lives needed to be saved equally. Also, it was not virtue-based because virtue ethics cannot imagine solutions to such ethical dilemmas. Finally, other criteria might have changed the parameters of whose life to save. Take the example of an elderly person who is your father or a Nobel prize winner; could the doctors sacrifice him for a younger delinquent person? I congratulate you on this interesting question though.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
2 answers
The following is based on the words of the man, the historical Buddha; nothing typically thought of as religion is involved. I believe you may find it helpful.
"[ When one ] has clearly seen with correct wisdom as it really is, this dependent origination and these dependently arisen phenomenon, it is impossible that he will run back to the past thinking: 'Did I exist in the past? What was I in the past? How was I in the past?' OR that he will run forward into the future, thinking: 'Will I exist in the future? Will I not exist in the future? What will I be in the future? How will I be in the future? Having been what, what will I become in the future?' OR that he will now be inwardly confused about the present thus: 'Do I exist? Do I not exist? What am I? How am I? This being -- where has it come from, and where will it go?' ..."
"... the Dhamma [(the Way)] has ... been well-expounded ..., elucidated, disclosed, revealed, stripped of patchwork, this is enough for ... [one ] who has gone forth out of faith to arouse his energy thus: 'Willingly, let only my skin, sinews, and bones remain, and let the flesh and blood dry up in my body, but I will not relax my energy so long as I have not attained what can be attained by manly strength, by manly energy, by manly exertion'..."
"... Considering your own good, ..., it is enough to strive for the goal with diligence; considering the good of others, it is enough to strive for the goal with diligence; considering the good of both, it is enough to strive for the goal with diligence."
"Do not think about past, future, or present existence. To be fortunate upon death: You have, in life, through intentional actions earned merit (& generated & changed/created kamma). And, thus to be so fortunate, in life: you have engaged in what you have to do ..." “ [He who] understands as they really are the gratification, the danger, and the escape in the case of the 5 faculties [(the 'senses')], then he is called a stream-enterer, no longer bound to the nether world.”
"... [He is] “liberated by non-clinging”, “one whose taints are destroyed”, “one who has done what had to be done ... reached his goal.” “... utterly destroyed the fetters of existence, [become] one completely liberated "
"Through dispassion [his mind] is liberated. When it is liberated there comes the knowledge: 'It's liberated.' He understands: 'Destroying birth, the holy life has been lived, what had to be done has been done, there is no more for this state of being.'"
----------------
" (1)–(2) the purpose and benefit of wholesome virtuous behavior is non-regret; (3) the purpose and benefit of non-regret is joy; (4) the purpose and benefit of joy is rapture; (5) the purpose and benefit of rapture is tranquility; (6) the purpose and benefit of tranquility is pleasure; (7) the purpose and benefit of pleasure is concentration; (8) the purpose and benefit of concentration is the knowledge and vision of things as they really are; (9) the purpose and benefit of the knowledge and vision of things as they really are is disenchantment and dispassion; and (10) the purpose and benefit of disenchantment and dispassion is the knowledge and vision of liberation. Thus,..., wholesome virtuous behavior progressively leads to the foremost.”
---------------
“Ignorance is the forerunner in the entry upon unwholesome states, with shamelessness and fearlessness of wrongdoing following along.”
“For an unwise person immersed in ignorance, wrong view springs up. For one of wrong view, wrong intention springs up. For one of wrong intention, wrong speech speech springs up.”
“... wrong speech, wrong action ... wrong action, wrong livelihood ... wrong livelihood, wrong effort ,... wrong effort, wrong mindfulness, ... wrong mindfulness, wrong concentration.”
“... There is feeling with wrong view as a condition, also feeling with right view as condition ... feeling with wrong concentration as condition and feeling with right concentration as condition. There is feeling with desire as condition, also feeling with thought as condition, also feeling with perception as condition.
... when desire has subsided, and perception has subsided, there is also feeling with that as condition. There is effort for the as-yet-unattained; when that stage has been reached, there is also feeling with that as condition.”
“... true knowledge is the forerunner in the entry upon wholesome states, with a sense of shame and fear of wrongdoing following along ... true knowledge, right view; right view, right intention; ..., right speech; ..., right action; ..., right livelihood; ... , right effort; ..., right mindfulness; ..., right concentration.”
" [(One in training on the Path)] generates desire for the non-arising of unarisen evil, unwholesome states; he makes an effort, arouses energy, applies his mind, and strives. He generates desire for the abandoning of evil, arisen unwholesome states. ... He generates desire for the arising of wholesome states. He generates desire for the maintenance of arisen wholesome states, for their non-decay, increase, expansion,and fulfillment by development; he makes an effort, aroused energy, applies his mind and strives.”
“ ... whatever wholesome states there are, they are rooted in diligence, converge upon diligence, and diligence is declared to be chief among them..”
“Whatever strenuous deeds are done, [they] are all done based upon the earth, established upon the earth, so too, based upon virtue, established upon virtue.”
--------------------
For a comprehensive (and realistic/naturalistic and rational) summary of all the words of the historical Buddha (the Pali Canon), see: https://mynichecomp.com .
Relevant answer
Answer
Great ! Good. Thanks.
After 3.5 years, it is good to finally have an answer.
Thanks again.
Best wishes, Brad Jesness
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
2 answers
Should we start using “The appropriate role in the appropriate place at the right time” or “NEW” instead of “The right person in the right place at the right time.?” by Thomas B. Holman?
-------------
The saying “the right person in the right place at the right time.” is considered the biggest deception in all scientific, humanitarian, and religious fields worldwide.
I suggest replacing it with “the appropriate role in the appropriate place at the right time.” not only for the person but also for legal parties, such as organizations, countries, political parties, writers, researchers, high positions, innovators, politicians, famous people, thinkers, philosophers, clerics, and professional roles.
Consider this saying and its application against all divine and artificial laws. How?
And why?
An application of God’s law on earth, one of the essential roles of man (human rights) in life is to apply what God has revealed to His prophets and messengers of laws and rulings that are applicable in every time and place, and among his tasks is also to ensure their application and care by establishing borders, spreading virtues, and commanding Virtue and forbidding evil.
The laws (Judaism, Christianity, Islam) contributed to establishing awareness of human freedom and his right to a free and dignified life, and liberating him from all restrictions, as these laws of one source made man the orbit of the universe and the source of honor in his human capacity.
That is why the roles you play or represent are significant. Forget your personality anywhere: in your home. In faiths and all fields, roles are part of the system.
Unfortunately, most human beings have mastered evil roles in various ways through their actions, and we will show those roles and their performers through tradition, history, science, and knowledge.
Good roles are not well-known by most people. We will do our best to draw them and clarify their application from the sources of heavenly sciences and doctrines and the reasons for our failure to know them, not for criticism but for treatment and return to good roles and away from devilish and evil roles.
.
We will reveal the evil roles and show how to perform the good roles with examples and evidence, and we will allow you to participate in many discussions, dialogues, and live broadcasts, God willing.
Next Questions?
[1]
Why “the appropriate role in the appropriate place at the right time.”?
[2]
How to apply the “NEW” saying per each concept?
[3]
Suggestion: Looking forward to generating a group on LinkedIn and Platforms on many social media. What do you think?
Relevant answer
Answer
Steven Davis: I think you misunderstand the question.
First: The question has nothing to do with any Actor or Legal Party records in healthcare or taxation, among others.
Second: All Actors and Legal Parties are not robots; they are the center of everything in society. We are talking about the role anyone or any legal party plays only in some of their lives.
Third: When anyone gets evaluated or assessed should be based on the role anyone plays rather than on his personality, which is problematic.
Example: if anyone is acting the role (Father) and doing it well or poorly. We end up with two roles: Good Father and Bad Father, and the result will be completely different.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
4 answers
i was looking at Virtue approach, Common good approach
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with the comments made by Denis above. Perhaps they can best be encompassed by the approach of casuistry which is iterative/analogous. It is case-based moral reasoning based on principlism and legalism. This approach works well within the framework of an organisation.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
1 answer
Hello
I am looking for a translation of the 24 character strengths and virtues as defined by the VIA-IS in Ukranian language
Best regards
T. Hendriks
Relevant answer
Answer
Perhaps looking in the World Wide Web or by an Ukranian colleague.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
3 answers
In some countries, capital profits are exempted by virtue of a presumption from the tax legislator, bearing in mind that the income tax law does not provide for their exemption. Is it permissible to bypass the law and rely on the presumption of the legislator?
Relevant answer
Answer
In Canada and Australia for sure. 😢
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
4 answers
Regarding the advances in this theory which stresses the practice of environmental virtues and flourishing, how can it offer workable solutions in case of ethical dilemmas (such as the necessity to build a dam to save people's lives and the necessity to keep biodiversity in the targeted bioregion)?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Abdelhafid Jabri,
The level of environmental ethics depends on society-wide pro-environmental awareness. The formation of society-wide pro-environmental awareness is an important factor in the formation of people's habits in the field of nature protection, protection of the planet's climate and biosphere, protection of the biodiversity of natural ecosystems. If the business and political spheres slow down the processes of pro-environmental transformation of the economy, including pro-environmental transformation of the energy sector, development of renewable and emission-free sources of energy, then the key role in this issue, including in the issue of shaping the general social pro-environmental awareness is played by non-governmental organisations, grassroots social movements, science institutions and environmentally conscious citizens. Therefore, due to the accelerating process of global warming, the importance of NGOs, grassroots social movements in shaping ethical, pro-environmental attitudes of citizens is steadily increasing. Environmental ethics is a concept closely related to the issue of the environmental social responsibility of economic entities, including companies, businesses, corporations, etc., whose activities affect the environment and the planet's climate in specific, including often negative, ways. This happens when certain economic entities, noticing the increase of general social awareness of customers in order to improve their image, add pro-environmental issues, sustainable development, green economy, implementation of eco-innovations etc. to their company mission and development strategy. Then, in advertising campaigns, they present their product and service offerings and their corporate mission as green, sustainable, pro-environmental, closed loop economy, etc. If this is factually correct, then the specific economic entity is acting in an environmentally ethical manner and complying with the principles of social environmental responsibility. In view of the above, the issue of the general social environmental awareness of citizens and the social environmental responsibility of businesses and institutions are important factors in the smooth implementation of a pro-environmental transformation of the economy in order to build a sustainable, green, zero-carbon, zero-growth economy and a closed loop economy. How quickly and efficiently this pro-environmental transformation of the economy is carried out, on the other hand, is a key determinant of the possibility of slowing down the progressive process of global warming and reducing the scale of any future climate catastrophe.
Best regards,
Dariusz
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
5 answers
Philosophers of science typically recognize two kinds of values in scientific practice: (1) epistemic (or theoretical, or cognitive) virtues, like accuracy, testability, empirical support, etc, and (2) ethical (or social, or regulative) norms, like justice, egalitarianism, openness, etc. Of course, the strict separation of these categories is open to disagreement.
Are there values or norms (of either kind) that are unique to mathematics? Rigour (or provability) is one possibility; computability is another. Can you think of others? Do values play the same kind of role in math as in the natural sciences?
Relevant answer
Answer
Elegance and parsimony are mathematical virtues. They seem to be aesthetic, rather than ethical or straightforwardly epistemic. However, aesthetics can be an aid to cognition.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
3 answers
I find VIA as an instrument is great! I would want to utilize it my surveys. In addition to that, I also want to measure Confucian virtues such as “harmony”. So I am looking for a validated instrument on the Confucian virtues. Please help!
Thank you!
Yan
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Ms. Huo
I am not with CMCQ, but the value would seem to be indicated in Reflections on Things at Hand. Believe that it relates to the Doctrine of the Mean, so the measure is how moderate something is (simplistically)
Hope that helps!
Cheers
Rob
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
10 answers
Usually, literature is analysed by means of textual methods (textual analysis). As I am about to start analysing my selected novels for PhD using a philosophical theory, this question came to my mind.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Abdelhafid Jabri , you could borrow appraoches from the social sciences (which are usually not applied to literary works but rather newspaper articles or interview data).
You could either pick methods of qualitative content analysis, where you would develop a coding sheme based on your philosophical theory and then fine-tune it inductively on your data, see, e.g.,
Software, that supports you nicely for such endevors would be MAXQDA or NVivo.
Or, if you want to treat your theory as relatively fixed, you test it in a purely deductive way and thus develop the coding scheme completely beforehand based on your theory and then apply quantitative content analysis to your novels.
This here is the go-to introduction to the quantitative approach:
Software supporting such an approach are the 'classical' statistics tools such as SPSS (or it's free dupe PSPP), STATA or R (if you want to go pro and start programming for your project).
Here's a nice example, where R was applied to analyzing not novels with philosophical theory but at least philosophical texts themselves. It might give you a good idea of what is possible with R:
Anyway, good luck with your project!
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
4 answers
Algorithm to Nourish Soul
Step 1: Prepare a list of soul objects of you. Select
a sample of your neighborhood of relations as
judgment set.
Step 2: Classify the list in step 1 in to two spaces
Virtue Space and Vice Space
Step 3: Select the proper measure order to get
meaningful result and α = 0.6, β=0.1
Step 4: Use email/whatsapp/letter/etc commu-
nication to collect feedback and use the equation
of judgment [1] to find the Soul status of Virtue
Space and Vice Space at time T.
Step 5: Check whether the soul process shows
that you are in (i) R(β–Hell),(ii)not in R(β –Hell) ,
(iii)R(α –Heaven) or (iv) not in R(α –Heaven).
Step 6: If you are in R(α –Heaven) and not in
R(β –Hell) , α = α + 0.1, β= β - 0.01
Step 7: Improve your positive soul objects, con-
trol and reduce your negative soul objects.
Step 8: If α > 1 and β < 0 go to step 10.
Step 9: T= T+ (n days), n €N. Allow change in
sample of neighborhood of relations.Go to step 4.
Step 10: Stop
Reference : Attached
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Rafiee,
Thanks. I tested among my colleagues . I needed improvement always.For that I tried to develop an Android Application Soul Analyst. Just a rough work.
I wish to sell this to Pope Vatican Italy. He can then control Soul Status of Priests under him all over the world.
Can any one help me for that?
All ideas were got published in my credit as Articles. I hope that will upgrade the Christian Community .
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
11 answers
This question is inspired in the article of yesterday by John Horvat II https://www.returntoorder.org/2014/07/saint-thomas-say-immigration-2/?pkg=rtoe0886
In looking at the debate over immigration, it is almost automatically assumed that the Church’s position is one of unconditional charity toward those who enter the nation, legally or illegally.
However, is this the case? What does the Bible say about immigration? What do Church doctors and theologians say? Above all, what does the greatest of doctors, Saint Thomas Aquinas, say about immigration? Does his opinion offer some insights to the burning issues now shaking the nation and blurring the national borders?
Saint Thomas: “Man’s relations with foreigners are twofold: peaceful, and hostile: and in directing both kinds of relation the Law contained suitable precepts.”
Commentary: In making this affirmation, Saint Thomas affirms that not all immigrants are equal. Every nation has the right to decide which immigrants are beneficial, that is, “peaceful,” to the common good. As a matter of self-defense, the State can reject those criminal elements, traitors, enemies and others who it deems harmful or “hostile” to its citizens.
The second thing he affirms is that the manner of dealing with immigration is determined by law in the cases of both beneficial and “hostile” immigration. The State has the right and duty to apply its law.
Saint Thomas: “For the Jews were offered three opportunities of peaceful relations with foreigners. First, when foreigners passed through their land as travelers. Secondly, when they came to dwell in their land as newcomers. And in both these respects the Law made kind provision in its precepts: for it is written (Exodus 22:21): ’Thou shalt not molest a stranger [advenam]’; and again (Exodus 22:9): ’Thou shalt not molest a stranger [peregrino].’”
Commentary: Here Saint Thomas acknowledges the fact that others will want to come to visit or even stay in the land for some time. Such foreigners deserved to be treated with charity, respect and courtesy, which is due to any human of good will. In these cases, the law can and should protect foreigners from being badly treated or molested.
Saint Thomas: “Thirdly, when any foreigners wished to be admitted entirely to their fellowship and mode of worship. With regard to these a certain order was observed. For they were not at once admitted to citizenship: just as it was law with some nations that no one was deemed a citizen except after two or three generations, as the Philosopher says (Polit. iii, 1).”
Commentary: Saint Thomas recognizes that there will be those who will want to stay and become citizens of the lands they visit. However, he sets as the first condition for acceptance a desire to integrate fully into what would today be considered the culture and life of the nation.
A second condition is that the granting of citizenship would not be immediate. The integration process takes time. People need to adapt themselves to the nation. He quotes the philosopher Aristotle as saying this process was once deemed to take two or three generations. Saint Thomas himself does not give a time frame for this integration, but he does admit that it can take a long time.
Saint Thomas: “The reason for this was that if foreigners were allowed to meddle with the affairs of a nation as soon as they settled down in its midst, many dangers might occur, since the foreigners not yet having the common good firmly at heart might attempt something hurtful to the people.”
Commentary: The common sense of Saint Thomas is certainly not politically correct but it is logical. The theologian notes that living in a nation is a complex thing. It takes time to know the issues affecting the nation. Those familiar with the long history of their nation are in the best position to make the long-term decisions about its future. It is harmful and unjust to put the future of a place in the hands of those recently arrived, who, although through no fault of their own, have little idea of what is happening or has happened in the nation. Such a policy could lead to the destruction of the nation.
As an illustration of this point, Saint Thomas later notes that the Jewish people did not treat all nations equally since those nations closer to them were more quickly integrated into the population than those who were not as close. Some hostile peoples were not to be admitted at all into full fellowship due to their enmity toward the Jewish people.
Saint Thomas: “Nevertheless it was possible by dispensation for a man to be admitted to citizenship on account of some act of virtue: thus it is related (Judith 14:6) that Achior, the captain of the children of Ammon, ‘was joined to the people of Israel, with all the succession of his kindred.’”
Commentary: That is to say, the rules were not rigid. There were exceptions that were granted based on the circumstances. However, such exceptions were not arbitrary but always had in mind the common good. The example of Achior describes the citizenship bestowed upon the captain and his children for the good services rendered to the nation.
* * *
These are some of the thoughts of Saint Thomas Aquinas on the matter of immigration based on biblical principles. It is clear that immigration must have two things in mind: the first is the nation’s unity; and the second is the common good.
Immigration should have as its goal integration, not disintegration or segregation. The immigrant should not only desire to assume the benefits but the responsibilities of joining into the full fellowship of the nation. By becoming a citizen, a person becomes part of a broad family over the long term and not a shareholder in a joint stock company seeking only short-term self-interest.
Secondly, Saint Thomas teaches that immigration must have in mind the common good; it cannot destroy or overwhelm a nation.
This explains why so many Americans experience uneasiness caused by massive and disproportional immigration. Such policy artificially introduces a situation that destroys common points of unity and overwhelms the ability of a society to absorb new elements organically into a unified culture. The common good is no longer considered.
A proportional immigration has always been a healthy development in a society since it injects new life and qualities into a social body. But when it loses that proportion and undermines the purpose of the State, it threatens the well-being of the nation.
When this happens, the nation would do well to follow the advice of Saint Thomas Aquinas and biblical principles. The nation must practice justice and charity towards all, including foreigners, but it must above all safeguard the common good and its unity, without which no country can long endure.
Relevant answer
Answer
En tiempos de Santo Tomás de Aquino la gente viajaba pero no tanto como ahora y cuando se hacía era por motivos de trabajo o motivos serios. Actualmente la gente viaja para conocer, hacer turismo, intentar una vida mejor aunque muy raramente se logre todo lo que se busca.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
1 answer
I need articles of them
Relevant answer
Answer
James F. Childress has written about race, racism, and structural injustice in 2021. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/epub/10.1080/15265161.2021.1877011?needAccess=true
Tom L Beauchamp is the author of the "the philosophical dimension" chapter in the book "Psychiatric Ethics". (Fifth edition published 2021).
Best regards
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
16 answers
Currently writing a paper on the Euthyphro Dilemma, discussing the origins of morality, metaethical and normative positions without God, and then revisiting the ED for Virtue Ethics. Could it be the case that the virtuous act is virtuous because the virtuous agent does it, or does the virtuous agent do it because it is virtuous? Really appreciate anyone's insight! Many thanks.
Relevant answer
Answer
The virtuous agent is one who tends to act in accordance with virtue, but a virtuous agent is not perfect and can make mistakes or even occasionally succumb to temptation. Virtue is the prior notion.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
33 answers
Is it reason, intelligence, superior nature, rights, or something else?
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
92 answers
Even tigers and lions kill just to survive. Lions kill other lions' cubs just because of "the egoistic gen". However, we kill - yearly (!) - hundreds and hundreds million of animals just for our food (and we most likely are successors of fruits-eating animals, as, e.g., also Pan paniscus are) and for mere entertainment (so called "hunting" - the same predators' "virtue" ) and simply disgusting pleasure (furs). We are keeping them in frightening conditions in meantime. (As if they were not living soul persons just as we all are?) And we kill them for nothing in millions just under suspection of slightest endangering for our own health:
In early November, the Danish government announced a plan to slaughter 15 million mink due to emerging fears of the COVID-19 mutation, which could be transmitted from these animals to humans. At a press conference held on November 4, Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen announced that twelve people had contracted the mutant virus and added that mink are "considered a threat to public health".
15 mln vs. 12 - isn't it a clear evidence of presumption of Homo sapiens sapiens
to be actually the most predatory (and beyond compare measure EXTRAORDINARY) of species of whole the Multiverse, therefore?
Photo from:
Dania. Władze wybiły norki. Teraz ich truchła wychodzą z ziemi (wprost.pl)
Relevant answer
Animals kill other animals just to feed themselves and nothing else, so why shouldn't we be like them?
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
17 answers
Why or why not?
Relevant answer
Answer
Am in line with Aparna Sathya Murthy
Pim Janse brought an important 'gap' into the discussion, if we move from the micro-level or personal action to the macro-evel of political decisions.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
11 answers
Hi all,
I am interested in collecting the positive psychology scales and questionnaires established in physical activity, exercise and sport settings. I mean here by positive psychology subjective experience variables (i.e., flourishing, well-being, happiness, courage, gratitude, passion, ...etc.) or strengths and virtues.
Thanks for your help.
All my best
Marei
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
2 answers
Aristotle, the great Greek philosopher, says virtue is the middle ground of two vices!
But if it is, then there must be twice the virtues, vices
Relevant answer
Answer
Philadelphia, PA
Dear Davar,
Apparently you mean that according to Aristotle, there must be two vices we could name for any given virtue?
Is that about right? If so, I see no problem or "challenge." There are many ways to lack the virtues. Right?
H.G. Callaway
---you wrote---
Aristotle, the great Greek philosopher, says virtue is the middle ground of two vices!
But if it is, then there must be twice the virtues, vices
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
14 answers
At all times someone argues againist another on virtues and evils in ethics, then what parts of ethics are there? Actually the virtues and evils of mankind is controlled by some rullers, or by rationality of mankind? Who is the Creator?
Relevant answer
Answer
Stanley, I don't attach permanent value status to types of acts. Good and evil are opposites, but it doesn't follow that a type of act that is good on one occasion must also be good on another. So for example, some instances of charity may be good, others not. Sometimes uncompromising toughness is morally called for rather than charity or benevolence. But particular instances of types of acts don't change their value. If it indeed was morally right to have done X at time t, then it remains so. (If I was mistaken about its having been morally right to do X at time t, that it is a different matter. Beliefs can be revised but not truth.)
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
5 answers
Is it ever possible to deduce the attributes of a thing by virtue of it being a member of a group, when those attributes are not actually part of the definition of the group?
Consider this conditional syllogism:
1. All horses are red.
2. Jenny is a horse.
Therefore, Jenny is red.
Can this ever be valid unless redness is part of the definition of ‘horse’? And if it is part of the definition, then the conclusion is merely a restatement of part of “Jenny is a horse.” If redness is not part of the definition, then the argument becomes either an inference or an equivocation. It seems to me that all groups exist only by definition, and its members can have no necessary attributes other than those we assign to them by definition. If we define a 'calcium atom' as an atom that has 20 protons, then we can’t “deduce” anything about any particular member of the group 'calcium atoms' other than that it has 20 protons. We can infer that it also has 20 electrons, but we can’t deduce it unless we also make the number of electrons part of the definition as well. But is a tautology really a deduction?
Relevant answer
Answer
This is simply deductive logic
Logic does not care about truth, any statement afirming something has another which denys it.
So the the statement that all horses are red is just part of the starting point. All we care about is if the deduction is correct.
As a deduction it is correct. It is not a tautology.
If you have a set with property P, then a proper subset of this set also has property P. That is all a sylogism does.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
3 answers
Please explain me. What are RMSD L.B. and RMSD U.B. ?
How to predict which is the better binding site for a ligand on a protein.
Please also explain me what is the virtue respective of delta G.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
6 answers
  • In recent years, particular interest is given to halophytes as bioactive molecules tanks unexplored. Is halophytes plants have medicinal virtues?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Abderrahim,
Some halophytes have medicinal properties - some of them are proven, while others are assumed, especially in halophytic species of a genus that has non-halophytic members with pharmacological properties (ex., Plantago, Inula genera - have many medicinal species, non-halophytic, but also halophytes species). There are many published lists with such species. However, you may consult: https://www.sussex.ac.uk/affiliates/halophytes/ for further documentation.
Best regards,
Marius
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
4 answers
A central aspect in precision medicine is the finding of biomarkers. But biomarkers can fall into very vague definition. High blood pressure, Low Hemoglobin and presence of PCA are specific biomarkers for hypertension, anemia and prostate cancer. High body is an alarming biomarker, but it can be a sign of many things, from a physiological reaction to the prelude of a fatal convulsion.
Thus some criteria must exist to discern about the virtues of a biomarker as a herald of a specific condition.
Thanks
Jose Luis Hernandez Caceres
Relevant answer
Answer
The clinical aspect can be found in an article by Mark J. Pletcher.
Pletcher, Mark J and Michael Pignone. “Evaluating the clinical utility of a biomarker: a review of methods for estimating health impact” Circulation vol. 123,10 (2011): 1116-24.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
10 answers
Happiness based on virtues and natural law rather than egoistical happiness seems to leave a longer lasting happiness yet many people practice narcissistic happiness. What is your take on this issue?
Relevant answer
Answer
Der Wangeci
You ask the following: Do you agree or disagree that Moral behavior is necessary for happiness otherwise it is an irrational observance?
As I see it, moral behavior is absolutely necessary for happiness. If this were not the case, then moral behavior would be irrrational observance. By its very nature, moral behavior is others-oriented behavior, that is, behavior concerned with another's welfare and well-being. As I psychologist, I think that, unless one is a psychopath, no one can be happy if s/he behaves immoraly toward others. To behave morally means not to treat others unfairly according to Lawrence Kohlberg's theory of moral development and an ethic of justice, and not to turn away from someone in need according to Caroll Giligan's theory of an ethic of care and responsibility.
I use to say that for an individual to be happy s/he should live in peace and harmony with himself/herself, with the others, and even with the universe. It is difficult, may be impossible, to live in peace with ourselves if, for example, we do not do what we think it should be done. It is difficult, may be impossible, to live in peace with the others, if, for example, we do not pay due attention to their legitimate needs and desires. It is difficult, may be impossible, to live in peace with the universe if, for example, we pollute water, air, and the soil.
Best regards,
Orlando
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
3 answers
This question will be used in my graduation thesis.
Relevant answer
Answer
You really do need perseverance and persistence-the more you research a problem the more tunnels you see to go down to light up; the more crevices and cracks you see in the tunnels to investigate.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
20 answers
There are many virtues in spiritual thinking, which nevertheless serves a psychological purpose, but religious ideas and thinking occupy another area of cognitive processes that seems distinctive from both, and yet fulfills psychological needs, cognitive, and philosophical needs-that is provides a shared worldview.
Relevant answer
Answer
Religious control of behaviour exhibits different psyche responses to focusing upon an object, solid or abstract for spiritual effect. The former concerns conforming, communal conditions and control. These too can be religious values.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
8 answers
What do you think is the best response that the hedonist can give to the problem? Is this response adequate?
Relevant answer
Answer
Interesting question and looking forward to read answers and I go with Ayad.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
9 answers
Why or why wouldn't you find the psychological egoist's explanation plausible?
Relevant answer
Answer
An egoist will look and treat an altruist wrong. Egoist and altruist , if not diametrically opposite personalities, are completely in different spectrum of behaviors and therefore their value systems and truth to them are completely different.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
30 answers
Why or why not?
Relevant answer
Answer
The fact is that society considers " immoral " if you behave contrary to the human nature.
Morality needs sanction of the society in which you live. When majority groups in the community prohibit certain acts because they are contrary to the human nature, such acts become immoral in the eyes of community and even in the eyes of law.
Morality is following ethical path in the direction of natural law. Positive or natural justice is administered by man.Natural law is also termed as divine law or Law of Reasons. If you behave contrary to the 'morality' "'good reasons"' don't exist to prove your own case. The conventional law is any rule or system of rules agreed upon by persons for the regulation of their conduct towards each other
It is always immoral to behave contrary to human nature.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
35 answers
Why might someone believe that it is? What challenges does such a view face?
Relevant answer
Answer
From the very beginning of the society religion has played very important part in upholding of the morality. It is the group behavior and therefore it has remarkable influence on the society to behave morally.
The pillars on which the LAW is founded are natural justice and positive morality.
Positive morality is rules of conduct approved by public opinion of any community. They are the rules maintained and enforced in that community.
Thus there is a necessity to have Community with some principles based on morality which emerges from religious beliefs.
Aristotle has said that universal law consists of those unwritten rules which are recognized among the group of people- the society. Such groups and morality principles are all on account of religion- people are afraid of almighty God and to earn credit from him they are motivated to be moral. They have the fear that they will be otherwise driven out.
Natural law which is observed equally in all nations is established on divine prudence is changeable by the tacit consent of people.
When no law was existing, Common law was in force. What is right and what is wrong was based on the belief that if you do right God will be pleased else He will punish you. Thus the origin of morality is found in the religious communities.
I therefore feel religion is necessary in order to motivate people to behave morally.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
22 answers
Why or why not?
Relevant answer
Answer
Killing for mercy is difficult to differentiate from murder; for killing is synonymous with taking life or homicidal. The difference could be if there is an authentic intention to take the life of a fellow who suffers and for mercy it ends this suffering.
On the other hand, in murder, an intention to harm is inferred, to deliberately kill with a perverse intention; where whoever is killed is not suffering and could suffer at the time of the murder.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
6 answers
Why or why not?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello,
Unlike consequentialist theories which maintain that the moral rightness or wrongness of an act is entirely a function of its consequences , a non-consequentialist theory of value judges the rightness or wrongness of an action based on properties intrinsic to the action, not on its consequences. Considering your question, I think I am not an act non-consequentialist. Siding with the utilitarian stance, I believe that our life experiences should guarantee human utility (i.e., happiness). I always tend to assess my moral decisions and actions based the consequences they evoke. Therefore, if the consequences are good, then I consider the action is right , and if they are bad , then the act is totally impermissible.
Best regards,
R. Bira
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
51 answers
For a research study about virtues of medical professional. I ask your collaboration to a question of unique answer to elect. Click the link below. Thank you.
Para un estudio de investigación sobre virtudes del profesional médico, te pido tu colaboración a una pregunta de respuesta única a elegir. Pulsa el enlace o link debajo. Muchas gracias.
Relevant answer
Answer
I did it.
Regards
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
38 answers
The Christian tradition has always emphasized prudence, courage, temperance, justice (the four classical virtues), faith, hope, and love (the three theological virtues).
Relevant answer
Answer
Justice...the fair and equal treatment of all the things in nature and the respect for their legal right of existence is the most powerful virtue to motivate humans in protecting the very environment that pivots our life sustainance.
Dickson Adom
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
9 answers
Often the objections raised to claims of getting power from permanent magnets are accompanied by the argument “How one can get an output without an input?”. When it is said so normally we meant to say “see we are not giving it any input”. But isn’t it the same with hydroelectric power? The water had a potential energy by virtue of the gravitational force that pulls it. Likewise magnet is also pulled by another magnet. So if we had a fluid of tiny magnets being pulled by a large magnet, power can be produced from the kinetic energy of mass of magnetic fluid. Then the question that should be asked is: Is there sufficient magnetic energy stored in the system that can be converted into some other useful form?
Relevant answer
Answer
You can dissolve a permanent magnet
in acid, then the energy stored in
it is set free as heat. It is not
very much, as you can guess from the
energy it takes to make steel
magnetic.
Regards,
Joachim
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
15 answers
I've been wondering since a few months ago what do you think is the most important virtue a scientific should have or develop to make impactant or good research? I supose there are a few critical features a scientific cannot rid off before, during and after they start making research for the very first time.
Thanks for answering.
Relevant answer
Answer
Scientific ethics
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
8 answers
I would like to have your views on individualism: what it means, how it shows, and where it comes from. Is it a virtue to be emulated or a vice to be shunned? Is it a healthy trait, or a malady? How does it affect relationships in faith-based communities and/or families? Your responses and contributions of supporting sources will be highly appreciated.
Relevant answer
Answer
Being morally virtuous (as Aristotle explains it) involves having a disposition to behave in the right manner and at the mean between extremes of deficiency and excess, which are vices. In that sense, individualism per se is neither a vice nor a virtue. However, acting individualistically may be either vicious or virtuous, depending on one's motives and particular circumstances. 
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
5 answers
Is it based on utility, desert, virtue, liberty, or something else?
Relevant answer
Answer
Yes. It's the pro-property line throughout history.
Proudhon said otherwise "la propriété c'est le vol" in a zero sum game that you can only own by depriving others from owning, sometimes causing famine and death (Irish potato famine, years of wheat speculation preceding French revolution).
There was food in Ireland, it was owned by some, and needed by others.
What is allowed to be owned?
Humans, no, or rather not any more, George Washington owned slaves... The cities of Bristol, Liverpool, Nantes made fortunes from this inhumane trade. 
Where do you put the limit?
In some countries public transport is privately owned potentially overpriced, and what could seem to be private transport by car depends heavily on public subsidy (roads and bridges). In others public transport is owned by state companies and underpriced, and roads may have tolls. 
Of course this drives towards more collective means of transport and less Carbon oxides release (electrical trains, trams, etc) or more (fossil fuel vehicles). 
Nobody commented on my line of data ownership. 
Ok I'll add habeas corpus, which is mistakenly believed as everyone owns their body, whereas the meaning was in old England that a suspect could be seized by a court depending on the king to be tried, instead of the local court where he or she had been taken to initially. This resulted statistically in fairer judgment. Law applied with more independence, corruption and arbitrary judgement was counterbalanced. The consequence was that you tended to own your body, because the king could seize it... 
One could also ask the question of education and property. Can you buy education, should you be able to, and if your parents - not you- have no money, should you be made to "pay", be punished for your parents to lack money? 
There is a worldwide divide on this: education dominantly state-run vs education dominantly private. 200km apart, the rule can be almost free universities vs 22 000 GBP or 9000 GBP/year, in Europe. 
Can you buy and own education? 
Or is it acquired by study, hard intellectual work, and the cost of the teaching is covered by government? 
Some countries with dominance of private university education import well-trained people in the medical professions, from countries where such studies are funded by the tax payer. Maybe Proudhon would say again that "la propriété c'est le vol". Hijacking rare resource from those who have funded its development. OPM, other people's money. 
Well the seemingly simple definition of ownership has made us travel through human right, microeconomics, macroeconomics.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
18 answers
How can we differentiate virtues and values or are they same in meaning. Please provide some examples. 
Relevant answer
Answer
Opatha, H. H.D.N.P., and Teong, L. K., (2014)  point out that a virtue is a good habit and a good attribute that is useful for a person him/herself and other persons.  Solomon (1999) states that virtue is an essential aspect of an individual. Solomon (1999) further states that the concept of virtues provides the conceptual linkage between an individual and his/her society. Opatha (2010) mentions that the virtues do not vary according to race, nationality, religion, culture or any other classification since they are universally accepted moral principles. On the other hand values may not be universally accepted beliefs or ideals. Values may vary according to race, nationality, religion, culture or any other classification. According to Opatha (2010) this is the main difference between virtues and values.
Opatha (2010) writes:
“In order to excel in a particular field, country or organization a person must possess a good personal character, in addition to the enhancement of technical competence relevant to the particular field. A good personal character is of utmost importance.”
Opatha (2010) further writes that:
“Absence of virtues results in the absence of a good personal character. Possession of virtues contributes to a good personal character, which leads to good personal quality. Good qualities or habits which do not harm a person are virtues. These are advantageous and favorable for self-development, others’ development and institutional development.”
References
Solomon, R.C. (1999), A better way to think about business, New York: Oxford University Press.
Opatha, H.H.D.N.P (2010), Personal Quality, University of Sri Jayewardenepura.
Opatha, H. H.D.N.P., and Teong, L. K., (2014). Enhancing your personal Q. Sintok; Universiti Utara Malaysia, UUM Press.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
8 answers
I am interested in measuring citizenship behavior of residents of a particular society (City or a country for that matter). In literature 'organization citizenship behavior- OCB has drawn much attention. I found 3 sub-scales of OCB to be 'helping others', 'sportsmanship' and 'civic virtue' widely validated in different cultural contexts. Can we extrapolate this scale to measure citizenship behavior of a large social group, not confined by organizational settings, for example residents of a town? Or is there any alternate measurement scale available to gauge the general citizenship behavior of citizens.
Please guide.
Thanks.
Salman.
Relevant answer
Answer
One other comment, the older Middletown studies of the Lynds looked at citizen behavhor and concluded that they were divided by class and race and occupational status.  Its too old but still maybe a good reference to see how you would do it differently 80 years later.
  • asked a question related to Virtues
Question
27 answers
I am working on a lecture on the plague and compassion. Historical evidence suggests that theme of the wholesale abandonment of the sick and dying in plague literature and art is not accurate. This opens up the question of how compassion can overcome extreme fear. It is easy to account for the desertion of loved ones because of fear.  But how does one account for the many medical professionals of the time, religious, and loved ones who ministered to the sick and dying in the plague.  Is compassion a learned and cultivated virtue or genetic trait?  What influence does the social order or disorder have on its expression?   Thanks for your thoughts. Ross             
Relevant answer
Answer
Compassion is probably a combination of genetics and cultivated virtue. A problem in the medieval times is that they did not understand the cause of the plague, and it took time to identify effective means to contain and limit the disease. People may have used different strategies to cope with and overcome their fear. Today we know the cause of epidemics and know reasonably well how to protect ourselves against them. This helps overcoming the fear. In the medieval times, people may have had other reasons to believe that they would not be affected by the plague, or they may have have had religious reasons, and put their fate in the hands of God. Another example is the tuberculosis hospitals, where compassionate people were helping out despite having a great risk of becoming infected themselves. Some people survived the disease or were immune, and they could help those who got the disease.
An analogy from our times is how the recent Ebola outbreak in West Africa was handled. Many doctors have volunteered to help out, despite having a risk of being infected themselves.