Science topic

Team Performance - Science topic

Explore the latest questions and answers in Team Performance, and find Team Performance experts.
Questions related to Team Performance
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
Hi everyone,
I am a third-year university student in the Netherlands, and for one of my classes, I need to write a literature review. I'm currently unsure if the gap I have identified is viable for my research.
I have chosen a quantitative approach, and since we, as students, do not have many resources, we have been advised to use questionnaires for data collection. Given the limited research time of one month, my sample size will be around 100-120 respondents.
The overarching theme of my research is team dynamics, and I have decided to focus on cultural diversity as a factor affecting team performance. My research question is: "How do individuals perceive the impact of cultural diversity on their team’s efficiency and overall performance?"
From the literature I have read so far, I noticed that studies usually analyze the impact of cultural diversity by looking at entire teams as a whole, drawing conclusions based on team-level data. However, due to my time and resource constraints, my questionnaire will collect data from individuals in different teams. This means my research will focus primarily on individuals' perceptions of how cultural diversity influences team performance.
Considering this, I believe there might be a potential gap in existing research: the lack of studies that examine the impact of cultural diversity on team performance from the perspective of individual team members, rather than looking at entire teams collectively.
Do you think this is a good literature gap to focus on, or does it seem too stretched? After all, teams are comprised of individuals and their opinions on the impact of cultural diversity on team performance should also be understood.
Thanks in advance,
Bianca
Relevant answer
Answer
Yes
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
2 answers
How to measure and analyze the impact of timeouts on team performance during and after the timeout
Relevant answer
Answer
Very difficult to do, as there must be a measurable impact of timeouts on a results--a hypothesized cause and effect relationship. Timeouts are not normally distributed, and there are many other variables at play. My experience is the research is very limited.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
4 answers
I am currently developing a team-level assessment of Psychological Safety (PS) that will be used by companies in an applied setting.
Specifically, the assessment will be a standard self-report Likert scale, with ~80 items spread across ~10 subscales. Teams will use this assessment to determine their PS levels and identify which intervention actions to take. There is also indications that our clients intend to use this assessment in an evaluative manner to judge managerial performance, and make team assignment decisions. This assessment will be administered, scored, and results reported via software, with no direct contact with me or other individuals with expertise in assessment administration or psychometrics.
I hope to establish between-industry norms for the assessment. The main push for these norms is forthcoming government regulations that will require companies to report assessment results regarding their performance relative to other companies in their industry.
Locating research on norms for team-level assessments is what has been surprisingly difficult.
I have spent days fruitlessly doing a literature search to locate specifics regarding sample size for establishing these norms. It seems the field is self-aware that most guidelines for norms are so vague they border on useless. However, I have been able to find some specific suggestions - that a minimum of N = 100 - 150 is required (e.g., Tett, Pieper, Wadlington, Davies, & Anderson, 2009; Gaddis, Foster, & Lemming, 2015).
However, all this research has been aimed at individual-level assessments. So it is unclear how this translate to team-level context. Do I need N = 150 teams within each industry? Or N = 150 individuals across a diversity of teams from a variety of companies within each industry? Is there a minimum number of teams and companies I should shoot for?
I understand that these things are more complex than a simple number (e.g., diversity and representativeness of sample is more important than the N, the importance of using of randomization and stratification in our sampling approach, etc.). But I am still hoping for a number or range of N that will at least give me a basic framework I can use to interpret and guide our sampling approach.
If someone could provide recommendations regarding a team N, that would be wonderful. Equally (if not more) appreciated would be citations that discuss assessment norming for team-level assessments.
Thank you for anything you can offer!
Relevant answer
Dear, depending on the specified budget and the required accuracy, as well as other conditions for selecting samples ..... Greetings
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
12 answers
I am looking for validated/standardized group problem solving tasks for evaluating team collaboration performance in controlled laboratory settings. My goal is to identify tasks that can solved in teams to compare teams performing under different manipulation conditions. Any hint is welcome! 
(please add reference to existing studies or reviews, if any)
Relevant answer
Answer
I found this document "A conceptual framework for designing and conducting groupware evaluations". I hope it helps you
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
4 answers
Dear community, for my master thesis I am researching how cultural diversity impacts team performance in cross-cultural alliances. do you have any suggestions on which scale I can use to measure this variable?
Relevant answer
Answer
Cultural diversity looks at various traditions and cultural norms practice and values setting
Take for example west Africa and East Africa are all Africans but there is difference in cultural diversity
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
In his book Black Swan, Taleb (2010) believes that the human mind is subject to many blind spots, illusions and biases and that: “The right strategy for inventors and entrepreneurs is to rely less on detailed plans and to focus as much as possible on creative thinking and recognizing opportunities when they arise. Excessive attention to what we know results in yet another similar weakness: we tend to learn the details instead of adopting general laws.” Resistance to change has long been cited as one of the key reasons why companies do not adapt to change on time. One of the approaches is exercise "How to destroy a company". Employees and stakeholders can be divided into groups to find the most effective ways to destroy a company. Lisa Bodell, founder and CEO of the company “Futurethink”, uses simple techniques to help organizations embrace change and increase their ability to innovate, such as Google, Novartis, and HBO: “The first time the HBO team performed this exercise, it created three tactics that a top competitor could use to destroy HBO. The American mining company regularly conducts this exercise in order to protect itself from both competitive and market forces.” Modern management has always existed for “best practices”. In trainings, managers use role models to encourage and direct change. New researches suggest a method better than the previous one. Scientists from the Kellogg School of Management in the USA conducted a series of experiments, and in one such experiment managers were gathered in small teams to create unusual creative purposes for a cardboard box. Before the brainstorming, half of the group was given the task to share the unpleasant stories from the past six months, and the other half was given the task to share the stories they are proud of. According to the results of the experiment, the teams that shared unpleasant stories generated 26 percent more ideas than the groups that shared proud stories.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you very much for your valuable overview. Yes, human being is complex in his/her nature. There are many challanges in front of us to learn more about specific behavior. Best regards
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
Dear RG Members,
I am doing a study at a team-level from a software services organization collecting data by surveying the team lead and the members. My independent variables (IVs) are individual-behavior oriented and the survey data was collected using a 7-point likert scale. In addition to the IVs, I also collected perception of team performance from the survey members on 7-point likert scale.
Using the survey data, I used regression analysis to check if my IVs are leading to my DV (team performance) and I was able to confirm my Hypotheses.
Now, I would like to do supplemental testing and I was planning to use the actual revenue data at project level and use that as DV instead of the team performance perception measure obtained from the survey.
For this, I am planning to use the actual annual revenue of the project from Year 1 and Year 2 and get the difference in them. I am converting the increase/drop in revenue in terms of % growth / de-growth from year 1 to year 2 and use this Percentage difference as my financial performance variable and use this directly in the regression (after standardizing). Since this is actual project revenue data, I am assuming that this is primary data and not secondary/panel data.
Can someone please let me know if there is a precedence to this and if so, can you please point me to the correct references?
Thanks in advance.
Relevant answer
Answer
Rosner Fundamentals of Biostatistics covers almost everything in regression for most major models. You should be able to find the correct method there. Pay attention to the dependant variable, the most important thing in choice of model. I believe it is available in the z-library. Best wishes, David Booth
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
43 answers
As an academic or professional leader with an academic career, what is the appropriate leadership style to lead your team in the light of the global epidemic, quarantine and remote leadership?
Please it is very important to give your opinion
Relevant answer
Answer
Be a visionary leader
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
Hi,
I'm a master's student and I'm studying software development teams as my thesis. My research is quantitative and I need to measure my variables which are social/Organizational Behavior concepts. One of my four variables is team effectiveness. I have determined means of measuring other variables but so far I had no luck finding a suitable method by reviewing the literature. I'm using a structured questionnaire as my method of data gathering, so for each variable, I have included questions from a previously accepted and well-cited research. As for team effectiveness, I've also been looking for a survey-based scale that suits a software development team which is a knowledge work team, and is also usable for a mass variety of teams as I'm going to need to gather data for more than 40 different and probably diverse teams across my country.
It might be because I'm not searching correctly or enough, however, I'll be more than happy if anyone could recommend anything to me.
Thanks a lot
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
I wonder what it means if persons are emotionally, personally or culturally similar or incompatible, for example, in social relations or in work.
Relevant answer
Answer
Cultural incompatibility in fact is cultural diversity. I suppose you have doubts if the question is correctly defined. Yes, Your question is quite correct. Cultural diversity in schools f.ex., needs increasing of intercultural sensitivity widely known as intercultural competence (IC) or intercultural communication competence (ICC). That includes personal, emotional and even more categorical attributes needed for successful interaction between teachers or between teachers and students. If persons are culturally incompatible, that means they need training in areas such ethnocentrism, ethnorelativism, communication, global competence...
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
27 answers
Motivation and The Candle Problem
by Rhoads on August 13, 2013 in Motivation
Our world continues to move faster and is increasing in complexity. So what’s the best way to motivate people to think creatively and solve complex problems in a shorter amount of time? Let’s take a look at a study that examines this question.
“The Candle Problem” was conducted by Professor Duncker in 1945. Individuals are led into a room that has a table sitting against the wall. On it is a box of thumbtacks, some matches, and a candle. They are asked to attach a lit candle to the wall in a way that the wax won’t drip onto the table and to do this as fast as they can.
Many who attempted the test tried creative methods but were unsuccessful. Some took a tack and tried to pin the candle to the wall…but that wouldn’t work.
Others lit a match and melted the wax on the side of the candle and then tried to stick it to the wall …but, that wouldn’t work either.
Some, figured out that the real solution was to empty the box of tacks then tack it to the wall and place the lit candle in it.
Professor Duncker realized that people have difficulty in solving a problem when one element has a fixed function that must be altered. In this case, the problem solver has to be able to realize that the box is not just a container for the tacks, but that it can also be used to hold the candle on the wall.
To demonstrate this point, he repeated The Candle Problem again with new participants, but this time he placed the tacks next to the empty box. This time the problem solvers could see that the box’s function was not directly tied to holding the thumbtacks. As a result, virtually all the participants were able to solve the problem with relative ease.
The Candle Problem becomes even more intriguing when you add a monetary reward to the task which is exactly what a professor of psychology, Sam Glucksberg did in 1962.
Glucksberg took a set of new participants and split them into two groups. He told the first group that “the person to complete the problem the fastest will receive $150, and if you are in the top 25% of fastest times you’ll receive $40 (values adjusted for 2013 value).” To the other group he did not offer a monetary reward, but still asked them to solve the problem as fast as they could.
Then he split those groups up and half of each group faced the problem with the tacks placed outside of the box, and the other half faced the problem in the more complex way with the tacks placed in the box.
You’d expect that those who were given the incentive of money would solve the problem faster and in fact that is true when the tacks were out of the box. More of the participants in the group that was incentivized by money solved the problem and with faster times than the other group.
However this was not the case when the problem was given in the more complex way with the tacks placed inside of the box. In this case, those who were not incented by money performed better than those who were offered money.
Glucksberg found that adding the variable of competition for a monetary reward creates levels of stress that shuts down the creative thinking and problem solving areas of the brain.
This finding can have huge implications on the reward model that many organizations use today. Many organizations use an “if – then” motivation model, meaning if you do this, then you get that. While directly tying financial incentives in an “if – then” format to simple tasks can be effective, tying financial incentives in this format to complex tasks that require creative thinking will actually have a negative impact on performance.
This viewpoint was popularized by Daniel Pink in his book Drive where he unpacks the concept of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. The main premise of his book is that you when you hire people to do complex and creative work, you need to motivate them with autonomy, mastery, and purpose rather than the carrot of a financial reward. Pink is clear to point out that money is still very important…however for this type of work, organizations should pay their employees very well and not tie it directly to the result of their creative work because that would only decrease their performance.
So if you lead a team or are trying to figure out how to motivate people to do something, think about the type of task that is being completed and if it complex and requires creative thinking, understand that using money as a reward for performance on this type of work will actually decrease the quality of the work you are trying to incite.
Sources:
Drive, by Daniel Pink
The Cornell Daily Sun, “Solve this Problem, Receive $20”, by Steven Zhang
The Candle Problem – Wikipedia
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear @Şeyda Bostancı To me, motivation equals to inspiration plus directed action towards the aim. If anybody is accustomed to disclosing his aim before others, research has revealed that the person gradually loses his motivation towards his aim.
Best regards, AKC
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
4 answers
Hello!
I believe, that we, the researchers in social and human sciences are a bit like the Moliere’s Monsieur Jourdain who found out (with the help of the teacher) that he spoke in prose. Today we speak of certain types of proses, e.g. behavioral, liberal, etc., as it is the universal language of today's social and human science. The language we use is geared with the research we do.
I believe, the language from D. Kahneman "Thinking fast and slow" has made us use psychological & behavioral prose, and consequently psychological & behavioral interpretations and the units of analyses in our research.
That's why I start working on the project "Creating fast and slow" which aims at showing that the creativity of interdisciplinary teams is based not on how do particular members think but on how are the assignments formulated: (1) creating fast, the assignments that expect a direct solution of the formulated problem (2) creating slow, the assignments that allow redefining the problem and to solve another problem than the initial one. I believe that improperly solving a fast creativity assignment instead of the slow creativity assignments is a relevant research problem here.
Origins
In 2018, we carried out one semester-long workshop on innovations, where students were working on briefs supplied by firms from one of the technological parks. The briefs contained the problems to be solved. The students proposed solutions and got feedback from the authors of the briefs (the sponsor users were the holders of the study). We saw that (1) only one team reformulated the initially formulated problem after one semester of work on it (2) the presented solutions got feedback but no one was tested in a real-life environment anyway. We understand now that (1) the whole above project should be redesigned and (2) the problem of improperly solving a fast creativity assignment instead of the slow creativity assignments should be investigated also outside the university projects' reality.
Could you point any scientific sources or anecdotal evidence (failures? achievements?), where the teams solved the fast creating type assignment, where they should work on the slow creating type assignment? Have you seen any research on such a problem?
Relevant answer
Answer
Let me think about it.
Kahneman (2011) suggests that "quick thinking" (system 1) is flawed and is located in the (un)consciousness of the individual subject. Turner and Cochrane (1993) suggest that the team working method may be well or poorly defined.
I am suggesting that "creating fast" (1) is not a flawed method, but fits a limited group of problems, and (2) is located in team assignment formulation practices. I would also say that "creating, fast and slow" relates to what goals are available in the teamwork project (containing reformulations of the initial assignment) rather than dependent on the clarity of the goal.
That's why I believe that the CF&S project can contribute to the literature.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
4 answers
Dear Concern,
Kindly guide me regarding the step by step process of data aggregation in Mplus/SPSS. (Pls answer as per your expertise in any of the mentioned statistical software).
I have collected data from two sources; team members and team leaders. During the survey, leaders were given questionnaires for variables, and one among them was the team-level variable (group norm). Regarding this, I am not sure about its aggregation and further hypotheses testing.
It would be kind of you if your understanding of this query (data aggregation) can help me proceed with my data analysis and interpretation.
Thanks in anticipation!
Regards,
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks, respectable(s); Amlan Haque and Kelvyn Jones!
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
I'm looking for the 5-item scale to measure team performance developed by Hackman.
Multiple sources have linked the article below, but the article itself does not show any scale.
Hackman, J.R. (1987),“The design of work teams”, in Lorsch, J.W. (Ed.),Handbook of OrganizationalBehavior, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, pp. 315-342.
Where can I find the scale?
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
Dear professors/researchers,
My name is Nicola Bombonato, currently enrolled in the Msc in Marketing Management at Bocconi University (Milan, Italy), nice to meet you!
I am looking for some academic literature regarding sales team performance, since I want to develop a research thesis in this field. In particular I am interested in analysing the effect of the group dimension and its impact on the sales team performance.
Do you have any academic articles to suggest?
Thanks in advance for your help.
Kind Regards
Nicola
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
5 answers
I am trying to find out the relationship between emotional intelligence and work relationship among individual employees. There seems a lot of research done on the job performance, team performance, leadership of course and marketing performance as well. However, there seems not much work done on the relationship between emotional intelligence and work relationship among individual employees. Your thoughts will be highly appreciated.
Relevant answer
Answer
Emotional Intelligence influences work relationships and also work performance while also provides work satisfaction,
While, Emotional intelligence seems good for workplace, but I think EI in personal relationships must be used restrictively,
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
I'm preparing for a management research and analysis exam and in it we have to devise a hypothetical research study to solve an organisational problem.
My independent variables in the example I'm completing are communication frequency, trust levels within team, and number of team members. My dependent variable is team performance.
If I wanted to suggest trust had a moderation effect on the relationship between communication and team performance, what steps would I have to go through/data analysis techniques would I use, and what kind of results would I expect to see if there was a moderation effect on the relationship? It doesn't need to be too in depth, and it might be worth noting I'm using a longitudinal research design with questionnaires as my data collection method.
Many thanks.
Relevant answer
Answer
Deat researcher
As for the choice of the questionnaire method for data collection, it is a valid one. The questionnaire should be structured, preferably a Likert scale type. The assessment of the moderating effects in your research model requires the use of multi-group analysis. You may want to assess the unconstrained model against the constrained models that show the effects of your moderating variables.
Kind regards
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
32 answers
How to make a high international research collaboration?
What are the criteria of the good research team?
Relevant answer
Answer
How to make a high international research collaboration?
Following factors can be considered:
  1. Find the research team with common research interest - best place to start is through searching from RG member list
  2. Build up the rapport & trust - it can be via sharing of common interests, artifacts contribution from each parties, challenges and future plans etc.
  3. Arrange & agree on the protocol & logistics - when trust is built / comfort level is affirmed, research collaboration protocol needs to be discussed & agreed e.g. how to collaborate, what is the stake / contribution from each party, what are the recognition points, commitment to ground rules (especially during conflict management), research process & manuscript writing & publishing order etc. Logistics e.g. when & where to meet, virtual meeting across different time zones, deliverable deadlines, project schedule management (if required) are also important.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
60 answers
Research needs appropriate and accurate data collection.
For the research team with data collectors, should they be invited to join the authorship?
Relevant answer
Answer
Data collection is also a essential criteria of the research as one of the key factor, with proper data and good knowledge with data input and data munching, a good research could be boosted. So it is to identified what has been the limit of the data collectors task and due acknowledgement need to be provided.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
5 answers
If you are the principal investigator and notice conflict of interest between two of your coauthors, how would you manage it?
Relevant answer
Answer
Let me tell you a suggestion. If I were you I would adopt the nominal group technique for them. You should inform them that you realized there is a conflict which block the work and the project is in danger. Asked each of them to find out the way how do she/he can change her/his job to help finishing the project. After that they can give some other aspects to each other what would be welcomed. Of course when you sit them together to discuss the proposals you need a moderator, a mediator is better. You can do it! Good luck!
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
17 answers
I am working on a research for Master thesis in Management. My field of research is focused on self-managing teams, but I have not defined the final topic yet. I am thinking of analyzing some characteristics which are common for both traditional and self-managing teams, by reviewing theoretical and empirical findings. Field research using questionnaires are to be considered, too.
Therefore, your help in providing with the relevant information on the common characteristics for these two types of teams and the instruments which were used to measure (in case there is any), would be highly appreciated.
Thank you in advance for your support!
Cordially,
Besnik
Relevant answer
Answer
Middelkoop mentions socio-technical systems as the origins of self-managed teams. The idea of leaderless teams was first introduced by Lewin and used by the Tavistock people during World War 2. I can recommend that you read an article by Trist who promoted that approach strongly.
You can find the article in the link. The same text was used in Volume 2 of the Tavistock Anthology of 1990.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
12 answers
I am working on a research for Master thesis in Management. My field of research is focused on self-managing teams, and after a long and deep review of literature and some recommendations from some researchers, I came up with some ideas about analyzing the outputs of self-managing teams in context of 'job satisfaction' and 'performance' ('innovation' is also a facet to be considered).
Therefore, I would highly appreciate your efforts to give me some better orientations in the most popular instruments, surveys or questionnaires which have previously been used to give a metric measurement to the above-mentioned facets of the teams (self-managing teams).
Thank you in advance for your support!
Cordially,
Besnik
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
11 answers
actually I am looking for team performance measurement scale employed by Marianne van Woerkom & Marcel Croon,2009 (
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
4 answers
Hello all, I am attempting to propose a meta-analysis study to identify the most vital (best and/or most popular) factors to evaluate team performance.
Several studies I'm planing to code in the meta-analysis include correlation values ( e.g. Tau or P) and rankings of what respondents think are the most important factors.
I plan to use the 'Comprehensive Meta-Analysis' software, which gives the following formats to input data: https://www.meta-analysis.com/pages/formats.php
I have also included two screenshots that show example data I plan to utilize from studies that will be coded in the meta-analysis.
To identify the most vital factors to evaluate team performance, what calculations or rankings can I utilize as input? Which one of these effect size calculations would be the most proper route to take: https://www.meta-analysis.com/pages/formats.php
I've considered looking at performance output that have the highest correlation values, but I'm not sure that high average correlation values signify the importance of an output factor. Another idea is to take the frequency that a performance output is measured (e.g. efficiency was measured in 70 out of 100 studies)
Any advice or input would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you,
Ramy
Relevant answer
Answer
You can use some advanced statistical techniques to better evaluate and measure your data. To this end, you need first to create multiple regression models and then use some techniques to estimate the variations in the independent variables. PCA (principle component analysis) technique can show you the impact of every single independent variable on the dependent variable., which enable you to reduce the dimensionality of your problem You can also try to assume some hypothesis testing to prove that your outcomes are statistically significant. ANOVA (analysis of variance) can also be involved in the analysis.
Try to look at these techniques (at least) and enjoy the analysis.
Good luck
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
9 answers
Human multitasking is our ability to do more than one task at the same time.
Is this theme applicable in your research field?
Will you consider running parallel research projects by the same researcher or research team a type of multitasking?
Please Share your thoughts and reflection..
Relevant answer
Answer
A researcher should always have multiple research projects in "the pipeline." While open is under review you can be writing the manuscript for another and collecting data for a third. It is not a good idea to wait until a paper is published to begin planning the next.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
2 answers
I am currently working on the research that tries to identify and examine the relationship between deep-level diversity of entrepreneurial teams and their ability to generate business ideas. The recent studies show that team heterogeneity affects the team performance including creative processes such as ideation. As we daily and practically work with our young entrepreneurs at our faculty we are curious how the composition of the teams affects their creativity during the process of idea generation for their projects/and or start-ups. We have noticed that cooperation in a team affects positively the team atmosphere and their willingness to share information and knowledge and consequently, their creativity performance in a team. However, we have noticed also a lot of conflicts in the teams where not all of them where negatively affecting ideation processes. Some conflicts, cognitive/task conflicts where indeed stimulating the process of idea generation. Nevertheless, not all teams cooperate at the same level and not all of the teams have only tasks conflicts as some enter into the relationship conflicts that block many processes in a team. We are therefore, curious how and why team diversity affects creativity performance and how and why cooperation and conflict can mediate the relation. It would help us to monitor and improve creative processes of our entrepreneurial teams.
I would be grateful for any info, insights from researchers that have already worked in that area and would like to share their findings or opinions and viewpoints.
Relevant answer
Hello Monica.
I have worked with some activities and exercises focused on the promotion of cooperation within teams, promoting the awarness on power relations. We have done it through some board games.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
11 answers
Dear all,
I have had to close off a quantitative survey which is part of a study, due to the fact that no more participants could be found.
The problem is; the total amount of participants is now only 11, plus 3 incomplete ones (explained further down).
The study consists of quantitative surveys sent out to company leaders as well as to 1 of their team members.
Both questionnaires have around 60 question items, with five-point Likert scale options (certainly don't agree, don't agree, neutral, agree and certainly agree).
Questions were subdivided into seperate groups, of which;
Leaders AND team members received the same questions on the leader's leadership approach plus also questions on team performance.
Leaders received additional 4 open end questions
Team members received additional closed questions on team dynamics
The goal of the study is to show correlations between the leadership style of leaders and team performance. Additionally also taking into account team dynamics.
Long story short; I now have 11 companies of which both a leader and a team member completed the survey. 3 companies only returned 1 copy, completed by the leader (which could be used as well, although these don't have a second perspective to verify the situation in those companies)
The next step was to statistically analyse the data to show correlations, but I am fairly certain that none of these calculations will result in significant findings due to the very low population sample. So what options are there to still use this data in a relatively meaningful way?
  • Conduct statistical analysis anyways, and mention that none of the results are significant, yet can be seen as suggestions for potentially existing correlations?
  • Merely present results in a visual manner and make broad assumptions?
  • Apply a different analytical tool?
Thank you for reading all the way through, I would very much like to know what your thoughts on this issue are!
Relevant answer
Answer
A sample size of 11 is inadequate for correlation because of very low statistical power and imprecision in the estimate of the correlation between your two variables in the population you are studying. I see two possibilities. First, 11 and 14 are enough subjects to estimate and compare means, perhaps with a t-test. Does it make sense to compare leaders and followers on any of your variables? Second, you could treat this as a qualitative study and content analyze the open-ended responses. Perhaps there are some useful insights in those answers.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
I am working on teams performing in extreme environment
Relevant answer
Answer
Team Performance in Extreme Environments focuses on extreme environment as one in which teams are exposed to high risk rate and large change in environmental.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
10 answers
I have reached out to the two possible contacts that I have, which have not been fruitful. I have also reached out to my LinkedIn and Twitter network to try to identify an organization to participate in my team-level research, but I still have not had any luck. I have been offering to provide a consulting service to help with personnel or leadership decision making in exchange for the participation. I have also stated whom the PhD-holding supervisor the project. Please let me know any suggestions you have, or if you have access to a large organization that may be willing to participate in team cohesion research.
Thanks,
M. Justin Miller, M.S.
Relevant answer
Answer
...a pretty random suggestion but as someone who works in health care there are likely to be lots of hospitals who fit the bill. While health services managers are not necessarily particularly research literate and no t all organisations are research active, the idea of research is not alien to them. I think it's well worth a try. Twitter and Linkedin well worth a try but i suspect a direct phone call or (failing that) email) to a senior person is likely to be more productive. Do a bit of background research to get the names before you start.
Don't expect people to be impressed by you, a PhD or your supervisor (if they are that's a bonus) but work on piquing their interest in what you are actually researching.
Good luck
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
4 answers
I am working on a project called "Diversity and Team Performance: Evidence from Indian Premier League." There might be some endogeneity in the team diversity as the players are not randomly assigned to the teams. I am sure that, the endogeneity issue here must be minimum. However, the referee will definitely ask for it when publishing. So, I  am looking for a good Instrumental Variable (IV). Anyone have any idea about it?
By the way, i tried the 2009 problem of not playing Pakistan players. But the change is very small. And if it is, it might have affected 2009 and to minimum 2010 season. I am looking forward to your suggestion. 
Relevant answer
Answer
Perhaps one possible IV could be the auction price of the players/budget of the teams.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
14 answers
Hi, I am attempting to study an intervention program. I need certain measurements to see if the intervention was effective. I want something that measures attitude towards teamwork, negative/positive thinking, and attitude towards productivity. I found other measurements for other constructs I'm measuring, but these are the only ones I am having trouble measuring. I have ideas for alternatives, but I would just like to see if anyone had ideas or knew of any measurement tools. Thank you so much.
Relevant answer
Answer
I am not sure if just measuring attitude  towards teamwork will provide the expected productivity gains?
There are many additional factors that influence productivity in team work. Some are people related, personal side of team work. Some are technical-oriented or related. Others are management style or management strategies-deployed. 
A lot depends upon a set of strategies or styles chosen or deployed during a teamwork. Such as on a project, how work-tasks are distributed or how work-tasks are assigned among the selected team-players.  
The following paper outlines some of those aspects.. Take a look... 
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
4 answers
There are multiple measurements of team performance and individual creativity. Does anyone know a good measurement tool for codesign performance or collaborative creativity in design?
Relevant answer
Answer
Some of the teams in a project with which I am involved are also trying to tackle this issue. You might take a look at the project website to see if there is anything useful for your work:
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
I have searched Scholar, Google, and various databases; naturally I came across several nonverbal annotation manuals, yet none focus specifically on natural leader-follower interaction occurring in real-life organizational settings (e.g. supervisor-led staff meetings, day-to-day work floor interactions).
I am asking the ResearchGate community in the hope that someone could point me in the right direction!
Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you Ian and Camille for you helpful suggestions!
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
6 answers
Salam,
   i am doing my research on teamwork quality and team performance and currently facing problem whether to insert control variable or not in my research and what can be possible control variables for my research. My unit of anlaysis is individuals in the team i-e team leaders and team members. my variable of TWQ are communication, cohesion, coordination of expertise, trust, value diversity and mutual support and dependent variable is team performance.
Can anyone please help me out on this problem because i am not understanding is very well because the papers i have read not included the control variables but they also did not provide any justification to it.
Looking forward to hear answers shortly and will really appreciate it.
Regards,
Eman.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Eman,
Agreed with Rafael on using gender & age as potential control variables.  Others might include education level, team size, duration the team get together etc.  But before you use any of the above suggested, perhaps you need to perform rigorous literature review on more journal articles especially those include control variables similar to your research constructs i.e. team performance & team work quality etc.  Reason being later in your writeup you can defend to the article reviewer / thesis examiner that your control variables selection was based on rigorous literature review / article precedents.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
Scrum is widely used in the software industry today for the execution of projects. Measuring the performance of Scrum teams is the biggest challenge that most organizations face today. Scrum requires a simple and quick way to measure the performance of the team. Many methods are found, but they may affect the agility of the development process.
Relevant answer
Answer
You can also take a look at the "agile fluency model" with a star like rating:
It can be used not only for Scrum teams and also include the surrounding of teams (for example the product management layer)
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
10 answers
HI, I am MS Student and currently trying to do my Thesis in Project Management.
 My Topic is "The Influence of Teamwork Quality on project performance in  Environment Developmental Projects" but i cannot find any research article which can relate these two variables. I have my base paper which is "Teamwork Quality on project performance in IT projects" and also I have literature review on IT Projects Performance and Teamwork Quality. Is it possible that i can generalize this literature review for environmental projects? is it possible to do research on topic which i am trying to do? I am new to research please do help me if anyone can. I will be very happy to hear from everyone.
Regards,
Eman.
Relevant answer
Answer
A paper on teamwork in environmental projects is attached. It may help you and give some directions to move ahead. 
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
16 answers
I am doing a litterature review on collective learning processes that would predict different kind of performance in a team. I want to check that I'm not missing something I wouldn't have thought of by asking you this question !
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello Raphael, I mainly studied a particular aspect of this question, linked to international / intercultural dimension. Maybe you are interested in these papers:
Bartel-Radic, A. (2006). "Intercultural Learning in Global Teams." Management International Review 46(6): 1-31.
(main result concerning your topic: diversity within the team is the main factor permitting collective intercultural learning.)
Bartel-Radic, A. (2013). "'Estrangeirismo' and Flexibility: Intercultural Learning in Brazilian MNCs." Management International 17(4): 239-253.
(main result concerning your topic: collective learning process differ accross cultures - here the case of Brazil is detailed).
Good luck with your research - I'm looking forward to the results!
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
10 answers
Several papers have been published related to culture or subculture. However how can the culture or subculture of a project team be characterised? Looking forward for any oppinion and/or publication in this topic.
Relevant answer
You might find this recent Springer publication of interest (although it looks at the specifis of managing diversity in the area of ICT projects): http://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-81-322-2151-7_2 
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
9 answers
Often Management by Objective comes ahead about when we talk about setting goals during the performance appraisal process. But MBO might not suitable in all kinds of circumstances and organizations. 
Relevant answer
Answer
@ Faris Alshubiri - thank you for such a relevant article.. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology is a heard-about journal. cheers!
@Zeynep Aksehirli - i agree with your perspective but MBO is not effective in some organizations (esp govt) considering their structure and nature of work. My quest is another PA tool or combination of tools that does the work of  intrinsically' motivating employees as MBO does. Thank you for your effort and opinion :)
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
4 answers
I'm planning a project proposal and would like to see a few a papers in my chosen area.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Mr. Jones,
I would suggest these references:
Dirks, K.T. (2000). Trust in leadership and team performance: Evidence from NCAA
basketball. Journal of Applied Psychology, 85 (66) 1004-1012.
Morgan, P. B., Fletcher, D., & Sarkar, M. (2013). Defining and characterizing team resilience in elite sport. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 14(4), 549-559.
I recommend also (http://breakingmuscle.com/sports-psychology/athletic-resilience-coaching-athletes-to-success-after-mistakes.) It's simple but interesting, I think that can help your question.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
6 answers
Globalisation and cross-border movement of labor has given rise to workforces where differences in nationalities, cultures, traditions, customs, religions, languages, economies and social structures play a crucial role while flexible labor policies provide organisations with access to global talent. In addition, the large movement of populations from East to West due to continuing wars as well as the existing European strategies of protecting immigrants strengthens the existence and spread of multicultural workplaces. Thus, it is evident that the need for multicultural awareness and sensitivity becomes imperative. To this vein, how a multicultural team performs within an Organisation and in its relationships with other organisations, their groups and teams is of great value.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you Arhan for your answer. Actually Hofstede's model is included in my literature review and partly I have integrated some parts in the model I am proposing. I was just wondering whether there was a newer model, more "applicable" like the one I am proposing, and in parallel a model that helps organisations to benchmark their capabilities of managing multicultural issues within them. Thanks a lot for your contribution.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
6 answers
I need to assess the ability to engage in complex activities or projects demanding an interdisciplinary approach.
I’m using the word “competency” to involve a three or at least a two dimensional construct regarding:
-       Knowledge to recognize different but specialized fields of work, research and study of different disciplines.
-       Attitude towards the contribution of different disciplines for complex problems solving and respect for their particular knowledge and practices.
-       And probably some skills component involving Team Work (?).
Relevant answer
Answer
There seems to be many more frameworks out there already.  I searched under these terms together: "interdisciplinary measurement of skills abilities"
Search Results
[PDF]Developing a Measure of Interdisciplinary Competence for ...
American Society for Engineering Education
limitations; 5) interdisciplinary evaluation; 6) ability to find common ground; .... The interdisciplinary competence measure was developed as part of a study ...
Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Social Sciences
Georgeta Raţă, ‎Hasan Arslan, ‎Patricia-Luciana Runcan - 2014 - ‎Social Science
When measuring fit, subjective direct fit measures were used in which ... or job demands with their knowledge, skills, abilities and resources, was measured with ...
[PDF]Career skill measurement for researchers - Eurodoc
framework, as well as those engaged in interdisciplinary research. ... Measurement of skills through a yearly evaluation ... doctoral work to show the ability to.
[PDF]21st Century Competencies - Hewlett Foundation
William and Flora Hewlett Foundation
by D Finegold - ‎Cited by 22 - ‎Related articles
An Interdisciplinary Literature Review ... interpersonal skills, ability to execute, information processing, and capacity for change/learning. .... The literature on measurement of competencies within firms is being reviewed in a related paper by ...
[PDF]Integrating the disciplines: Successful interdisciplinary ...
University of Melbourne
by C Golding - ‎2009 - ‎Related articles
“knowledgeable across disciplines” with the ability to “examine critically, synthesise and evaluate knowledge .... logic or critical thinking subject would teach these interdisciplinary skills and then apply them in ..... and how to measure this.
Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Learning to Read: ...
Kathy Hall, ‎Usha Goswami, ‎Colin Harrison - 2010 - ‎Education
Each child completed a range of assessments including: general ability ... memory, word reading, reading comprehension, and measures of integration and ...
[PDF]Interdisciplinary Education at Liberal Arts Institutions - The ...
The Evergreen State College
by D Rhoten - ‎Cited by 19 - ‎Related articles
ability to make fundamental decisions and judgments'” (Huber and Hutchings, .... measure these as student outcomes alongside those of liberal arts learning?
Interdisciplinary Thinking and Four Cognitive Abilities
serc.carleton.edu › ... › Why Teach with an Interdisciplinary Approach?
Sep 2, 2010 - Interdisciplinary teaching is a demanding enterprise. ... identifies four cognitive abilities (i.e., brain-based skills and mental processes that ... Mathematical and Statistical Models · Measurement and Uncertainty · Models · Peer ...
Interdisciplinary Elementary Physical Education
Theresa Purcell Cone, ‎Peter H. Werner, ‎Stephen Leonard Cone - 2009 - ‎Education
1 measure and record their performances on scoring sheets; and diagram their performances on ... Children who have more advanced measuring abilities may use more accurate ... Work with the classroom teacher on measurement skills.
Interdisciplinary Behavior and Social Sciences: ...
Ford Lumban Gaol - 2015 - ‎Business & Economics
Proceedings of the 3rd International Congress on Interdisciplinary Behavior and ... (2002) defines entrepreneurship competence as entrepreneurs' total ability to ... the measurement of environmental effect on business (Covin and Slevin, 1989; ...
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
7 answers
How to improve and examine user acceptance and adoption towards new integrated IT systems (i.e. PLM) and identify areas of improvements from a change management perspective?
Relevant answer
Answer
I think IT is shaping into other new and advanced Internet-cloud-based, web-based technologies. 
The following key note paper examines new tends in emerging technologies like  web-enabled PLM,  Knowledge-based Engineering and Internet of things.
It also identified areas of improvements from usage and management perspectives and their impacts on productivity and efficiency..
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
I am trying to find the ways and means that already exist to measure or calculate a team member's (individual) performance in greening projects. Are there any KPI, metrics, or frameworks that exist for easy calculation?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Allet Joelle,
Look the paper in attached, maybe can help you!
edit: my mistake,I have not seen greening projects. I don't know. Is it reeally green it? Some software developers in greening it projects? 
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
13 answers
I want to do research on corporate governance and firm performance. In this regard, I want to find a new dimension. Does any one have any idea about it?
Relevant answer
Answer
You may want to take a look at the paper by Parsa, Chong & Isimoya
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
1 answer
...
Relevant answer
Answer
If you're looking for an overall performance indicator, perhaps the win/loss record of a team would be appropriate (or number of goals, etc.). Questionnaires tend to measure constructs that are more specific such as particular beliefs, values, tendencies, or behaviors. Most questionnaires measure constructs on the individual level rather than on the team level.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
4 answers
I am planning to conduct research on competitive state and team performance under different level of the competitive situation. Since DDD (Aptima) has been accredited in some articles, I would appreciate if somebody could recommend me some other similar (and free-of-charge) instrument.
Relevant answer
Answer
The SYMLOG (Systematic Multi-level Observation of Groups) Consulting Group provides a useful methodology for analyzing team performance, although you have to be certified to use it. See: http://www.symlog.com and attachment.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
1 answer
When  there is time pressure in team work,  individual employees are  more likely to focus their attention on issues related to task. Am looking for scales that can be used to measure individual responses to time pressure in teams
Relevant answer
Answer
Attention Control scale is a self reported 20 item questionnaire ... I am not sure if it'd be useful but I think you can see it. This questionnaire measures two items attention focus and attention shifting (it's main use is in psychopathology but may be it's relevant???)
Forgive me if it's irrelevant!
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
5 answers
I am researching the topic cultural diversity: does it impact on team performance and what challenges if any does it pose in organisations?
Relevant answer
Answer
  • Cultural diversity does have impact on team performance. DadFar and Gustavsson (1992) suggest that, there seems to be a general agreement that if cultural diversity is managed well, it can be an asset to perform, and if it is overlooked or mismanaged, it may diminish the performance.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
3 answers
Attributes, methods or existing models or suggestions for evaluating development teams free software.
Relevant answer
Answer
Octavio: Thank you for your ideas. I´m taking into account these elements in my research . The third side that you mention is very important to me.
Jaharkanti: Yes, is very important that the members of the team have capacities and abilities for obtain the best results in the project. So what I have seen in several articles that I have reviewed.
Best regards to both.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
14 answers
We want to find a good index to evaluate organisational training focusing on: psychological safety, openness, trust, feedback, communication of best behavior and areas of improvement in production and services, feedback on individual- and team action plans, follow up by supervisor.
We have looked at Wilson, Lizzio & al, 1997, and Kuvaas & Dysvik, 2008, and want something more spesific to evaluate the training external consultancy firms deliver to an organisation. Do you know of relevant indexes we can use?
Relevant answer
Answer
I really like Isabel's response. The arithmetic index might give you a single measure of degree of success, but it would not be very useful for feedback. The goal of training like this is always to help people change behaviors, so feedback on how much key behaviors are changing (or not) and information about factors that are impeding or facilitating change will be most useful. Nifty little indices may be useful for keeping score, but nothing beats behavioral feedback for helping people take action to improve.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
16 answers
I'm interested in how to create safe spaces for team members to share stories about failure since we often learn more from failure than success. Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
You should distinguish between doing something wrong under a correct hypothesis (failure) and doing something right under a wrong hypothesis (negative result). I assume you mean sharing negative results, not failures.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
20 answers
I want to know the characteristics that can I use to differentiate between team and group.
Relevant answer
Answer
Team has task, target, goal and aim.
Group is a mass along with uniform mind set.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
7 answers
Currently only  looking at  measures of team mental workload. (no physiological or primary/secondary task measures)
The focus will be on the distributed team - the master, pilot, tugmasters and port control. . 
Looking for measure that would be fairly easy to use in simulator and real world studies of workload involved in ship navigation.  
The aim is to be able to measure changes to workload if, for example, a procedure is changed, new device is introduced, crewing levels change. 
Relevant answer
Answer
I have good results with using the very simple but valid ISA metric by tab Lamoureux.
For references, see:
this last one is in fact:
Lamoureux, Tab. “The influence of aircraft proximity data on the subjective mental workload of controllers in the air traffic control task”. Ergonomics 42, no. 11 (1999), doi: 10.1080/001401399184839.
I asked Tab (in 1999!) approval to use this simple metric, he consulted his boss and was able to allow me to do so.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
4 answers
Emotional Intelligence in Work group / Teams.
Relevant answer
Answer
Based on my research, knowledge, education, and experience, I say absolutely, but I respect that there are some who would disagree based on intention. The foundation for my response is what is found rooted in Transformational Leadership with the applied concept that no matter what role you hold within a team or organization (whether as leader, peer, or follower [Maxwell, J, 2006]) having an acute awareness of others will only benefit the overall objective. An article I think you would find helpful (Tucker, Turner, Barling, Reid, & Elving, n.d.) states, "looking beyond self-interest for the good of the relationship, thus embodying many elements of transformational leadership (i.e., inspirational motivation, idealized influence, intellectual stimulation, and individualized consideration; Bass, 1998)” (p. 196). The notion is that when success is determined as a synergetic group element, not merely personal gain, it requires a considerable degree of attention to others emotional responses to situations, operational tempo, and your own behaviors and decisions.
Those that would oppose my view, may state that too much attention to emotion and personal effects would detract from goal accomplishment, but that is only if TOO much attention is averted away from the task. A healthy balance of both goal defining and the application of emotional intelligence and/or awareness is the recipe for genuine success. How I define "genuine success" is accomplishing a goal without sacrificing the well-being of those around you (teammates, customers, community, etc.).
There are several concepts within leadership that address the awareness of emotional valance, such as the aforementioned plus servant leadership. I'd quote all they say regarding the matter, but it would not do any justice especially if you are looking at the application within a specific area you are working. Hopefully this is a good start. I'm excited to see what others may have to say.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
20 answers
National culture can have a profound effect on team performance. For example aircraft accident rates are much higher for high power distance, low individualist aircrews than for low power distance, high individualist aircrews (even when adjusted for GNP-per-capita); a further example - team performance capabilities at tasks requiring various levels of creativity, from highly original ideas to modest process and product improvements, vary considerably across cultures. The Japanese are unmatched at process improvement.
During my research, I have found little in the literature on team skill sets that is of relevance to culture, and have had to develop a task/skill set of my own, which I use for 'default' culture-based assessments. Users rate the various tasks/skills in this set in terms of their importance to their proposed or actual team's performance. Clearly, the key skills/tasks of an aircrew 'team' are different to those of a research team.
I do not want to bias any discussion towards my own ideas, but I provide the following examples for clarification.
(1) National culture affects the speed of communication between team members,
(2) National culture affects the willingness of team members to contribute ideas.
As a final comment, the tools that I am building are not intended to provide the basis for any form of selection. They are primarily intended to highlight certain issues that may arise if culture is not taken into account when designing systems or operating procedures. These tools have been validated to some extent against data collected on accident rates, industrial & commercial team performances, etc.
Relevant answer
Answer
Your question is complex . It is like a Russian Puppet : it contains many internal/implicit questions.
What follows is not a game. It leads to a serious issue – Be patient
Has anyone come across (or developed) a team task/skill taxonomy (or set) that can be used to assess cultural aspects of team performance? A very puzzling question !
This question supposes that many prerequisites have been clarified, and not just this one : . What taxonomy is most appropriate & what for?
Has anyone come across a way to assess cultural aspects of team performance? i.e. What method to assess & what tools to assess those cultural aspects that might be relevant?
Then on the one hand :
Has anyone come across a way to assess team performance? i.e. What does it mean to assess team performance, having in mind its relation with culture…? Or What is the method to assess team performance? or What are the criteria to assess team performance ?
Has anyone come across “team performance”? i.e. What is team performance? Or What do we call “team performance”? What team?
Has anyone come across what a team is or what kind of a team is to be considered?
And on the other hand, for each of the three above questions:
Has anyone come across cultural aspects of team performance? i.e. How does culture interfere with team performance? Both inside & ouside views? How to identify both the relevant cultural “aspects” and their action mechanisms?
And also :
Do these questions address existing teams that are to be observed by an “entomologist”? –i.e. External observer
Do these questions address teams still to be created or further developed? Combined insider’s view (the actors themselves) & External observer’s view
So what? What then?
1 Your definition of Culture :” The term “culture” relates to the values, assumptions, preferences,beliefs, rituals, knowledge, skills, and behaviors that are shared at the level of the social group (or society).”
In other words, all what the individual has absorbed since he was born & converted into his self. Of course, all what we “learn”, we learn it from other people or from direct encounter with earthy reality. So, what we learn is always “cultural”. Scientists enjoy building up classifications : of course, what we learn when we were 6 months old or 5 years old might be more deeply buried inside ourselves than what we “learn “ at 15 or 50 !. But some encounters at 20 or 40 can also be decisive. We are Biological-cultural beings. We are historical beings. What we are here & now is the position on our trajectory or rather our network. We always act in the present. Some civilisations distinguish the “present” & the “imaginary” : the present is what triggers our immediate micro actions ( it involves the current situation & memories of similar situations- e.g. 20 years ago- that are relevant here & now; the imaginary is what is not relevant here & now in the past or the future : it can be an event that occurred yesterday or 10 years ago. In mid-Empire Egyptian, everything happened in the present: future & past were not embedded in the verbal form, but well, whether the action was under way or stopped – terminated, suspended, or not started yet- Past & future were indicated in a subtle way, similar to an interrogation mark
So culture is everything we make use of when facing a new situation. Well, not quite : there are the “productive” things, i.e. the one that belong to the material world, data, information, knowledge, science, technology … : this can be modeled & transformed into prescriptions; we just have to carry them on. But a new situation is also life, movement, changes ; to a large extent they are determined, but not pre-determined. So, what will really happen.=?? We have to rely, not on theory, mathematics or reductionist concepts, but on ourselves, or habits & experience. The ones that seemed to be most effective according to our past & the ones of people who are close to us & whom we trust. And also, on our capacity to find ways & means to survive in case our initial decision is wrong ….
A computer scientist attempted to design an expert system in pneumology. So, he carefully observed the behavior/ criteria of a top-physician. Then in order to make his system more robust, he wanted to combine what he had learned with a new observation : that of another expert physician. Complete failure : why? The first physician was more “aggressive” & the second one more “contemplative”; but each of them knew how to act in case his initial decision led to a failure. Mixing both approaches leads to chaos. MIT developed an expert system for a renal intensive care unit together with the best physicians of the Mass General Hospital. Then, they wanted the expert system be tested in the Mass Gen Hospital ( the “authors”), in a general I C U, & in a post surgical ICU. The system was rejected by everybody !!! the people in the Mass Gen Hosp ( “ we know more than what we told you : we told you what we can describe with our language, our concepts, …. Not our feelings of experienced professionals; in the general ICU : no ! if we apply the advices of the expert system & if something goes wrong , what do we do? We prefer to call a human referent: he will have the expertise to react & will have the “legal” responsibility; the post op unit : if things seem a bit abnormal, we immediately transfer the patient to a top ICU)
2- the definition of performance
I have no experience of aircrafts ! Only of the design of computer / telecom systems to support ICU & Anesthesia teams. Also creating & managing international R/D projects in Europe dealing with the new IT in medicine at large
In our Western world, we design what should be an ideal team, an ideal project, an ideal something, …. and we act to make it pass in the facts. ( actually , we repeat again & again the old myth of the « creation » : God wanted to build the Universe & did it ; we just try to do the same thing – with a lot of success as far as science & technology is concerned) We know that this team/project consists of people and machines. People ,-pilot, driver, physician, patient, sportsman, manager, …. You name them- do not limit themselves to their reason, their knowledge, know how, technical expertise or technical skills: this is their “production” dimension. It can be analyzed, reduced to schemes, to algorithms … The life / living being dimensions as well as the “external” circumstances cannot be modelled. Although we keep striving again & again. Is it more effective to keep trying or use an other approach. My view point). In addition, culture can be observed from two different points
To be practical :
A__you describe bipolar cultural dimensions – actually three of them, for all practical purposes, from Hofstede – Why ? because he is well-known and referred to by many people – full stop ; not because he is the best one – And then, you show that there is clear correlation between them & crisis management.
Why not turn things upside down.
When we had to design automatic systems for ICU’s (Intensive Care Units) we addressed three major topics =
1. The normative : data, information flows, alogorithms, sensors, …. The rôles of the people= what ought to be done
2. The practical : what was really done ( physician have two patient records : the official one; shared with the other professionals, on the computers; & their personal ones : “the patient is lying; he is drunk; he is fooling his family; he is hiding something, …. “ ; similarly, nurse exchange “confidential” notes on the patients, the physicians, whom to trust, …. ) We need to know that in order to make the automatic system more effective – to compensate for the human weaknesses
3. The crises/breakdowns : everything goes wrong = what to do
As we are not Anglo-Saxon, the priority is not the normative ( see the paper of Dawson , Cambridge) but the breakdowns : everything has to be organized from them.
B__Why not start describing/observing what is a catastrophy? What ought to be done? How to organize the automatic system accordingly? How to train the people as if breakdowns were just normal events : no reason to panic. In this respect, the impact of culture is minimized. And instead of checking whether Hofstede or Trompenaars dimensions are relevant and to what extent, just identify the qualities that people & the equipment need most to successfully manage a breakdown.
This being said, individuals are not equal. And some will learn faster than others and be more effective & more efficient.
So, understanding their cultural background is most important – as in dramatic situations, behaviours learned during childhood will be prominent !
BUT WHAT IS CULTURE ?
When I got interested in Culture as an issue worth considering ( +/- 1987-1990), I faced two approaches :
- That of Hofstede, Trompenaars, … = purely descripitive; you smile often, you talk a lot, … OK: you are put in class 1; you want to act on your own … OK, class 2; the past is important for you, class 3…. And so on : you prefer white wine or beer , a contract is just a piece of paper, ….class 4 … Important if you want to leanr a rôle : how to do business with a Japanese, a Chinese or a Frenchman
- That of Charles Hampden-Turner just when he began to work with Fons Trompenaars ( The Seven Cultures of Capitalism; later, he stopped trying to understand …) , Emmanel Todd ( INED, Paris), or to a certain extent, Steve Toulmin, & many others about “time”, also, H Maturana, Montaigne, & people who recently became interested in empathy …. = what are the roots of Culture, what is culture as seen from the inside of the individual; the way he behaves in society – i.e. the view point of Hofstede … - is another story
I have of course chosen the second viewpoint. Culture is what gives more “thickness” to your present. It has to be continuously elaborated. It has to evolve. But this implies that you are fully aware of what you have to “conserve” in order to remain yourselves.
But this an other story.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
5 answers
I am interested in understanding to what extent cultural diversity in the workplace impacts productivity and performance.
Relevant answer
Answer
Definately consider hierarchical linear modelling. I did a study within a business context, yet did not have enough upper level groups (one needs at least 20 to perform this test). However, it would make your analysis stronger if you consider the fact, that your teams might be nested in a specific school, or corporation.
Check out the following paper:
'Commitment across Cultures: A Meta-Analytical Approach' by Fischer, Ronald and Mansell, Angela; Journal of International Business Studies,2009, Journal of International Business Studies, Volume 40, Issue 8, pp. 1339 - 1358
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
5 answers
Which metrics would you use?
Relevant answer
Answer
Andrea: Thanks for your clarification question.
Yes, it could be a "good" collaboration when the discussions contribute towards the advancement of the stated goals. Meaning, it must be adding values to ideas or discussions in some way or other. Just having an equitable repartition of the speech time and of the gestuality is essential but not sufficient.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
1 answer
What in your view would be strategies to assess team adaptability as an outcome qualitatively?
Is it possible to assess "team adaptive performance" statically in point of time as an outcome variable through interviews? If so could someone please shed some light on what would the appropriate items be to evaluate this construct. As till now mostly adaptive cycles are used, which suggest "team adaptive performance" develops over time
Thank You
Relevant answer
Answer
Small group research and experiments are a lost art. As such, I would begin looking for research in the 1950's through the present as it should loop around. For example, initial findings demonstrating that romantic attraction was based on variables including the effect of physical attractiveness and during social interaction between individuals during experiments involving social interaction between 1950 and 1970 (Berscheid & Walster, 1974). Nevertheless, years of subsequent research had departed from this important observation which Luo and Zhang (2009) believed were due to effects of isolated testing for social phenomena. Unfortunately, the study of small groups appears to have suffered the same fate (Fine, 2004).
Around the 1950’s, Sherif began developed a scientific model for studying small groups which yielded significant findings about the mechanisms underlying social interaction (Sherif, Harvey, White, Hood, & Sherif, 1954/1961). His procedure including bringing the theories and findings of several disciplines, such as anthropology and sociology, and integrating them with psychology in order to create a scientifically credible method to support his research (Sherif et al., 1954/1961). Using the method often cited as necessary to create a valid theory in scientific disciplines such as the biological sciences (Stanovich, 2010), Sherif built his theories on social behaviors using hypothesis testing, operationalized definitions, and subjective and objective measurements (Fine, 2004; Sherif et al., 1954/1961). This was important because it added a methodological structure that some believed lacking in psychology by making replication possible in the event others wanted to test the validity of his results (Stanovich, 2010). Nevertheless, these findings seems to have been lost in time (Fine, 2004).
After reading the article about why strategies to decrease intergroup tension were not being seen in real-life situations, despite the validity of each of the four means the researchers had explained had been elicited and verified in scientific studies, I thought of the attractiveness principle as well as all the studies on substance abuse (Cohen & Insko, 2008; Longabaugh, 2007; Luo & Zhang, 2009). While the fate of the attraction seems to be on the right track with the help of Kenny’s social research model and the importance of dyads and groups, the outlook for substance abuse studies seems less bright (Groh, Jason, & Keys, 2008; Luo & Zhang, 2009; Willenbring, 2010). For example, the interactions described by Sherif et al. (1954/1961) appear to explain why groups, such as Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), are correlated to improved treatment outcome even though individual treatment programs based on single elements isolated from AA and proven effective in experiments fail to produce the same results (Willenbring, 2010). And yet, more research using the same basic model based on individuals and independent variables continues along with the poor treatment models being used today (Groh et al., 2008). Hopefully, researchers like Luo and Zhang (2009) will realize that treatment always involves some interaction between the individual with alcoholism and the treatment provider and more often than not, a lot of group therapy, in order to create more effective interventions (Groh et al., 2008).
References
Berscheid, E., & Walster, E. (1974). Physical attractiveness. In L. Berkowitz (Ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology Elsevier Science.
Cohen, T. R., & Insko, C. A. (2008). War and peace: possible approaches to reducing intergroup conflict. Perspectives on Psychological Science (Wiley-Blackwell), 3(2), 87-93.
Fine, G. A. (2004). Forgotten classic: The robbers cave experiment. Sociological Forum, 19(4), 663-666. doi: 10.1007/s11206-004-0704-7
Groh, D. R., Jason, L. A., & Keys, C. B. (2008). Social network variables in alcoholics anonymous: a literature review. Clinical Psychology Review, 28(3), 430-450.
Longabaugh, R. (2007). The search for mechanisms of change in behavioral treatments for alcohol use disorders: A commentary. Alcoholism, Clinical And Experimental Research, 31(10 Suppl), 21s-32s.
Luo, S., & Zhang, G. (2009). What leads to romantic attraction: Similarity, reciprocity, security, or beauty? Evidence from a speed-dating study. Joural of personality, 77(4), 933-963.
Sherif, M., Harvey, O. J., White, B. J., Hood, W. R., & Sherif, C. W. (1954/1961). Integrating field work and laboratory in small group research. Intergroup Conflict and Cooperation: The Robbers Cave Experiment. Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press. Retrieved from http://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Sherif/chap1.htm.
Stanovich, K. E. (2010). How to think straight about psychology (9th ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
Willenbring, M. L. (2010). The past and future of research on treatment of alcohol
dependence. Alcohol Research & Health, 33(1-2), 55-63.
  • asked a question related to Team Performance
Question
4 answers
How can team spirit be helpful in upgrading the level of research output?
Relevant answer
Answer
@ Mpefe Ketlhapile: I am glad to hear from you that you have an agreement with the statement given by Sridhar reflecting appealing relevance to my query.