Science topic

Public Space - Science topic

Explore the latest questions and answers in Public Space, and find Public Space experts.
Questions related to Public Space
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
2 answers
My research plan: First, via literature review and on-site investigation, summarize public space elements. Then, learn from literature that place attachment theory has two factors: place dependence (shallow-level, emphasizing visual and functional use) and place identity (deep-level, emphasizing related historical, cultural, and personal experiences). Hypothesize that through questionnaire to collect data and statistical analysis, a positive correlation can be found between public space elements and place dependence, and that public space elements' perception can indirectly impact place identity via place dependence, affecting place attachment level. Third, aim to study the correlation; encode and quantify public space elements as can't directly research on quantitative data (affected by many factors). Fourth, conduct correlation analysis between public space elements' quantitative data and people's perception data to analyze the relationship, and by optimizing the design, enhance people's place attachment level.
Relevant answer
The best way is to conduct surveys using Likert scales because you're dealing with opinions, not scientific data. You then analyse the surveys using non parametric tests, such as Chi square. That's much simpler and more accurate :)
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
10 answers
I'm looking for illustrations of public space, public interaction, and public life in films. Which are the most interesting to look at? Thank you!
Relevant answer
I think you might be interested in the audiovisual work "La Vuelta" 2013 by Juan Fernando Herrán who has explored the urban interstices on a local scale in the most emblematic areas of Medellín: the communes and marginal neighborhoods. In his work, he shows a peculiarity of public space in sectors where the use of motorcycles and the alleys between houses and stairs became sculptures of the lives of the inhabitants.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
2 answers
Cities compete with each other in a globalised environment. How does this affect the design of urban space and the community?
Relevant answer
Answer
The design of tourism-focused public spaces can have various impacts on local communities, both positive and negative. Here are some ways in which it can affect them:
  1. Economic Impact: Well-designed tourism-focused public spaces can stimulate economic activity by attracting visitors, leading to increased spending in local businesses such as restaurants, shops, and accommodations. This can create jobs and generate revenue for the local community.
  2. Cultural Exchange: Tourism-focused public spaces provide opportunities for cultural exchange between locals and visitors. They can showcase local traditions, arts, and crafts, allowing residents to share their heritage with tourists and vice versa. This cultural exchange can foster mutual understanding and appreciation.
  3. Community Identity: The design of public spaces can reflect the identity and values of the local community. By incorporating elements of local history, architecture, and culture, these spaces can strengthen community pride and identity. However, if the design overly caters to tourists and neglects local preferences, it may lead to resentment or loss of identity among residents.
  4. Social Interaction: Well-designed public spaces can serve as gathering places for both locals and tourists, fostering social interaction and community cohesion. They provide opportunities for people to meet, socialize, and participate in collective activities, contributing to a sense of belonging and connectedness.
  5. Environmental Impact: The design of tourism-focused public spaces can have environmental implications, particularly in terms of resource use, waste generation, and ecological conservation. Sustainable design practices, such as green infrastructure, energy-efficient lighting, and waste management systems, can minimize negative environmental impacts and promote long-term sustainability.
  6. Infrastructure Development: The development of tourism-focused public spaces often requires infrastructure investments, such as transportation, utilities, and amenities. While this can improve the quality of life for residents by providing better access to services and facilities, it may also lead to gentrification, displacement, or unequal distribution of resources if not managed properly.
  7. Overcrowding and Congestion: Popular tourism-focused public spaces may experience overcrowding and congestion, especially during peak tourist seasons. This can put pressure on local infrastructure, increase traffic congestion, and disrupt the daily lives of residents. Proper management strategies, such as crowd control measures and visitor management plans, are necessary to mitigate these issues.
Overall, the design of tourism-focused public spaces can significantly influence the well-being, economy, and social fabric of local communities. It is essential to consider the needs, preferences, and concerns of residents while planning and designing these spaces to ensure that they benefit both locals and visitors alike.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
2 answers
Does anyone know about literature concerning this questions or wants to share thoughts?
Relevant answer
Answer
There are two words in the question that, in my experience, do not go together. They are "artistic" and "feminism." What I have found and observed is that when a work has a two purposes, one of them usually dominates the other. So a focus on "feminism", say, will likely result in the "artistic" elements being dominated. This is a general principle in my view. That is, list any two or more objectives and this principle is at work.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
3 answers
Hello fellow researchers and innovators
At the moment I am working for a small / medium Norwegian municipality. There we want to develop a method, which enables us to make climate positive decisions when planning, building and maintaining urban public spaces w/ and w/o greenery.
This municipality is suffering rural migration, which means, the economics isn't the best. So we need to find / work out our own solutions instead of buying.
In addition to that, most of the software and calculators I have come across are developed for "buildings", hard materials for housing constructions, but in urban public places w/ greenery vegetation can account for CO2-sinks.
I feel the benefits of plants are far too often forgotten.
Do any of you have possible "links" to interesting webpages, or perhaps and even better, do any of you have an Excel-sheet which one could use to calculate this?
You know, perhaps someone has already done this job and worked out how to give factors and benefits and measurements into a calculation matrix, which then could work out a weighing up of a variety of design-elements...?
Your name would of course be mentioned and the research / product would be given your credits / copyright...
Cheers,
Berit
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Volodymyr Durmanov
Thank you for you quick reply.
I agree that a mere literary study will not suffice.
I am aware that there are a handful of software types that calculate the carbon emissions of (building) materials. These have come to use in some projects in the municipality, where colleagues managed to reconstruct one of the main roads in such a way that the who project was (nearly) carbon neutral.
But, as mentioned, there seem to be no coordinating tool for urban places that also includes vegetation and soils.
I was however hoping that someone out there in the big world of researchers that some had already tried to merge the different tools and their outcomes in a kind of user-friendly matrix of some sort, f.eks. in an Excel-sheet-matrix... something that we could test in our project that is supposed to start these days.
Meaning as well, that we cannot wait until next year. Not sure if I can go as far as to start a research project.
Sorry!
But thank you for you quick reply!
Greetings from Norway!
Berit
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
2 answers
Good morning, if you are living in Cairo,Egypt can you take part in this questionnaire by answering it , it is for my master thesis topic “ sociability challenges in public spaces in the era of industry 4.0”
You can answer in arabic or english format
Relevant answer
Answer
In recent years, the rise of Industry 4.0 has revolutionized various sectors and transformed the way we live, work, and interact with technology. The term "Industry 4.0" refers to the fourth industrial revolution, characterized by the integration of cyber-physical systems, the Internet of Things (IoT), automation, artificial intelligence (AI), and other advanced technologies. As these innovations continue to shape our world, it is crucial to examine their impact on people's everyday lives.
1. Smart Homes and Connected Devices:
Industry 4.0 has brought about the advent of smart homes, where interconnected devices and appliances enhance convenience, comfort, and efficiency. From voice-controlled virtual assistants to intelligent thermostats, these technologies enable seamless automation and control of various household tasks. Individuals can now remotely manage their home security, lighting, temperature, and entertainment systems, leading to increased energy efficiency and enhanced quality of life.
2. Personalized Healthcare:
The convergence of Industry 4.0 and healthcare has yielded significant advancements in personalized medicine and patient care. Wearable devices and sensors equipped with IoT capabilities can collect real-time health data, enabling individuals to monitor their fitness levels, heart rate, sleep patterns, and more. Additionally, AI-powered algorithms can analyze this data to provide personalized recommendations, facilitating proactive healthcare management and early detection of potential health issues.
3. Smart Transportation and Mobility:
Industry 4.0 has also revolutionized the transportation sector, paving the way for smart and sustainable mobility solutions. Electric vehicles, connected cars, and autonomous driving technologies are becoming increasingly prevalent, promoting energy efficiency, reducing emissions, and enhancing road safety. Moreover, real-time traffic information, route optimization, and ride-sharing applications are improving urban mobility and transforming the way people commute.
4. Smart Manufacturing and Workplaces:
Industry 4.0 has had a profound impact on the manufacturing industry, leading to the development of smart factories and intelligent automation systems. Advanced robotics, machine learning, and IoT technologies have increased productivity, precision, and safety in manufacturing processes. Human workers collaborate with intelligent machines, focusing on complex tasks that require creativity and problem-solving skills. This shift has the potential to enhance job satisfaction and empower workers with new skills for the digital era.
5. Digital Education and Skill Development:
As Industry 4.0 advances, the need for digital skills has become paramount. Online learning platforms, virtual classrooms, and educational apps are transforming the traditional education system. These technologies provide accessible and flexible learning opportunities, enabling individuals to acquire new skills and adapt to the evolving job market. Lifelong learning has become crucial to keep up with the rapid pace of technological advancements brought about by Industry 4.0.
The impact of Industry 4.0 on people's everyday lives is far-reaching, revolutionizing various aspects such as homes, healthcare, transportation, manufacturing, and education. As technology continues to evolve, it is vital to embrace its potential while addressing challenges such as data security, privacy concerns, and the digital divide. By leveraging the opportunities presented by Industry 4.0, individuals can enjoy enhanced convenience, efficiency, and quality of life while adapting to the demands of the digital age.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
1 answer
Dear Colleagues,
We are glad to inform you that I am currently serving as the guest editor for the Special Issue
"Public Spaces: Socioeconomic Challenges"
We would like to invite you to submit a paper to our special issue: https://www.mdpi.com/journal/land/special_issues/QUY7LS4BII
Please contact the Section Managing Editor kristie.shen@mdpi.com if you have any questions. An article processing charge (APC) of CHF 2200 currently applies to all accepted papers. The submission deadline is 3 July 2023. But if you need more time, you can feel free to contact us.
You may find the instructions for the manuscript preparation at https://www.mdpi.com/journal/land/instructions
The manuscripts can be uploaded at
For us to plan this last phase of this project, we kindly ask you to let us know of your possible interest in participating within the next two weeks. Thank you for your interest and we look forward to hear from you,
Teresa de Noronha
Relevant answer
Answer
I would love to contribute
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
Dear Academics and Researchers,
My friend and I are working on a research paper regarding 'walkability and environmental characteristics in historic sites' through the case study of Naqsh-e Jahan Square in Isfahan.
The city has been facing inactivity due to interruption in the historical site's identity and unforeseen inconvenience resulting from changing street use, something that authorities were unaware of. In this context, we would like to conduct a survey to illustrate how the elements of public spaces could contribute to walkability development and social inclusion.
We have divided the questionnaire into three parts. Feel free to complete whichever you would think is more related to your area of research: Quality-of-place and Accessibility in Historic Sites: https://lnkd.in/eruS8sDW Equity, Affordability and Comfortability in Walkability: https://lnkd.in/eZ9x54-F Architectural and Built Environment Details' impacts on Walkability: https://lnkd.in/efxseu7G Each questionnaire should take you about 15 minutes. We would sincerely appreciate it if you could take the time to complete this survey kindly. Thank you very much for your time and efforts in advance.
Relevant answer
Answer
with respect, it has been a mega-city(I refer to the link below), counting crossing of course has been done. Also, asking people for many reasons are necessary,for place making, behavioral attitude, the reasons to come, cultural identity, the symbols, even old bazaar show that its geometry was collective space but new bazaar has nothing to . Sorry but we have two kinds of questionnaire.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
2 answers
As tourism grows and tourists come to dominate public spaces, the value/use of those spaces to native-born populations is shifting. This is a rather new topic for me, but looking for resources that will address the changes and how the status of localities shifts as they are rendered public for tourists but of limited use/access by native born. Thanks!
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Jeff
You probably already know Walter Little's work but it is very much on that topic, eg his book: Little, Walter E. Mayas in the Marketplace: Tourism, Globalization, and Cultural Identity. University of Texas Press, 2010.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
14 answers
Our scape is currently overwhelmed with physical structures that act as obstructive forces towards humanity-oriented progress. The globalised format of our cities has dominated its roots on other aspects of architecture, including education. Hence, in some schools, architectural education follows this emerging imagery of the market, and not the other way around. This has led to a critical phenomenon of poor development of architectural pedagogy, i.e. lack of individual and collective creativity.
Do you think that architectural schools should shift its methodology towards not building anymore? Should they focus more on creating open spaces and flexible structures?
Relevant answer
Answer
Anwaar, you want everything and thats nice, only impossible. Academy must have priorities and not a bit of everything. Sorry
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
6 answers
When I embarked on this journey of exploring more on exploring the condition and status of gender equity and equality in architecture, or public spaces, or urban design, I found very little literature is available. Would be great to discuss on this topic. I have started to get an impression perhaps this topic is irrelevant or not trending at all. But I have strong feeling that has an importance, but very little research has been done on this. Would be great if you know of some documents or share some light on this.
Relevant answer
Answer
Designing Gender Sensitive Public Spaces – Cidco Smartcity (niua.org)
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
How does activities and agè affect the people who visit the green public spaces
Relevant answer
Answer
Adults seem to prefer clean and secure environment. Places where there's less noise and congestion. I think older people turn to prefer natural environment and to get closer to nature. Younger people seem to prefer sporting facilities and playing fields. They use these spaces mostly for playing and for training/ exercising.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
We study safety and satisfaction within public spaces in relation to light within different day intervals and within different environment sets.
We decided to split the questionnaire into six small ones, each consisting of 10 questions maximum, and this is the second one.
This survey aims to understand the correlation between lighting at different times of the day, activities in public space, and users' sense of safety within an environment rich with green color in the form of Shrubs.
We will be grateful if you fill this one, it will take around 5 mins only.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you 🙏🏻
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
11 answers
I will be grateful if you fill this Questionnaire, it will take around 5 mins only.
Relevant answer
الاضاءة والتهوية الجيدة من اهم العناصر لنجاح المناطق الحضرية الخضراء والمفتوحة
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
'Sound level' perceptions in Neighborhoods & public spaces. Requesting to fill in the Survey google form & contribute your inputs. Greatly appreciate!
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you much, Appreciate time taken. Yes, I agree on that.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
24 answers
Hi, I'm looking for documentation concerning how public spaces have changed since the pandemic. I'm interested in repositories, databases, review articles, media sources etc. Thank you very much!
Relevant answer
Answer
hope you find this article helpful:
Kind regards,
Yelena
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
9 answers
Dear researchers we are trying to explore the urban designers’ understanding(s) of gender-sensitive urban design.
What do designers focus on when they develop public open space design/planning?
some examples are: participatory processes engaging women and gender minorities, meeting the needs of women in the design, involving women and underrepresented groups in key decisions.
What do you think is the most relevant literature on the topic?
Relevant answer
Answer
I have an urban design perspective on this.
(1) The akcnowledgement of different experiences of public spaces (not just on a gender-basis). Gender-blind urban design follows standards, historically embedded patterns and conventions when it comes to deciding what kind of affordances should they place in space and how space should be configured. Gender-sensitive does not take this for granted and explores different needs. We ask questions like if and why a social variable predicts presence, use, comfort in public space. The resulting design offers variety, something to do for everyone. For example, in the CEE region, it is common to place football or basketball pitches in parks for children. In a Viennese park, the designers mapped the sports children like, and decided to also deploy a volleyball court, because girls would otherwise just not go out and play (as much).
(2) Public space harrassment is one of the textbook categories for gender-driven aggressions, so safety and perceived safety in public spaces is one of those determinants of "different experiences" that is emphasized during (good) design. I am actually in the middle of a research to develop a method to quantify perceived safety using visual graph analysis. But it doesn't have to be analytic, visibility, eyes-on-the-street, public life, and lighting are things designers can work with.
(3) On the level off affordances, there are also lifestyles, habits and routines associated with a gender, which should be designed in a way not to obstruct the other genders from doing them. Gender-blind example would be diaper changing stations in women's restrooms only.
Bottomline: urban design is very much a profession that reuses and rearranges patterns of spatial culture, which are subtle, small, but persistent ways to make certain behaviours more easy or difficult. Gender-sensitivity - for me - is one of the approaches that challenge passing on these patterns uncritically, and argues that we should stop and engage with our user groups first.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
9 answers
Dear Honorable Researcher
Greetings and Best Regards;
The present questionnaire aims to assess the effect of the Covid-19 virus on the public realm of residential neighborhoods from the evaluation point of view of experts (Architecture, Landscape Architecture, Urban Design and Urban Planning) according to the components of social capital; Therefore, you, dear researcher, are requested to help us in advancing the correct goals of this research by answering the questions that have been raised in this regard, in addition to applying your professional and valuable opinions. This project is being implemented with the support of the Research Deputy of Apadana Institute of Higher Education In Shiraz, Iran.
Please follow the link to answer the questions (https://survey.porsline.ir/s/MPHz138)
Relevant answer
Answer
The impact of the SARS-CoV-2 (Covid-19) coronavirus pandemic on the public sphere of housing estates is correlated with the effectiveness and efficiency of management of housing cooperatives' authorities or the local government of residents of a given housing estate. Another important determinant of anti-pandemic safety in housing estates is the level of applied basic rules of hygiene, cleanliness of public places, including, for example, staircases and other parts of common multi-family buildings and the public space of a housing estate, the standards of safety management related to municipal waste, sewage and water supply management. . This issue is related to the level of quality of services provided by municipal institutions and enterprises dealing with waste management, sewage systems and water supply systems, which should ensure a high level of treatment of water supplied to housing estates and ensure a high level of anti-pandemic safety. In addition, an important issue is also the level of awareness of the inhabitants of the housing estate regarding the standards of applying procedures and principles of public safety, including anti-pandemic safety, culture of citizens in respect of compliance with new anti-pandemic restrictions, the level of social trust in local and central authorities and institutions, the level of social solidarity and between the generations of inhabitants of a given housing estate, etc.
Best wishes,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
28 answers
My research field involves environment-person relations and I am looking for examples from around the world of public spaces that were designed to meet the containment measures of COVID-19, more specifically the social distance. I look for projects that have already been effectively implemented. If you know any, please contact me. Thanks in advance
Relevant answer
Answer
Public spaces that have been designed and implemented to meet the measures to curb the development of the SARS-CoV-2 (Covid-19) coronavirus pandemic include primarily those public sectors and public institutions that, as part of public goods, offer a certain level of provision for society. and the standard of public safety. These public sectors include health care institutions (preparation of infectious wards in hospitals), education (e-learning), public offices and local government units (e-government and services for citizens via the Internet), law enforcement and public administration services (anti-pandemic procedures, quick introduced principles of social distancing, remote work, wearing protective masks), waterworks operated by municipal enterprises controlled by local government units (anti-pandemic water treatment in waterworks), financial institutions (development of electronic and mobile banking, online settlements and payments), culture (introduced lockdowns and the provision of cultural services via the Internet), trade and business of commercially operating economic entities (development of e-commerce, the possibility of making purchases on the Internet), etc. Of course, in individual countries, the level of preparation of public institutions for demia is varied. The issue of the aforementioned differentiation is correlated primarily with the level of the country's development, including the level of institutional and socio-economic development, equipping public institutions and economic entities with modern technologies used to improve public safety systems, including anti-pandemic safety, crisis management and pandemic risk, etc.
Best regards,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
3 answers
Hi everyone,
I want to ask a (not so) quick question about ecosystem services economics, urban planning, sustainable water drainage and cost-benefit analysis.
Whenever comparing different scenarii of urban greening or urban planning, in a cost-benefit anaysis (CBA), opportunity costs have to be integrated to represent the whole array of costs associated with a plan. The definition by Buchanan (1992) is good enough here : "Opportunity cost is the evaluation placed on the most highly valued of the rejected alternatives or opportunities", which is to say, it is the value that is sacrificed in any choice in a decision making situation. This cost is usually valued as the highest benefits that could have been produced by a choice, but that was forgone by the actual choice.
Now, when the subjects of a CBA, that is, the scenarii, are firm or private indivdual investments, the notion of opportunity cost is pretty thorough : it is the net revenue from the best forgone investment. And that's it.
However when dealing with urban planning, as with many other real world economics, it becomes trickier. The opportunity cost of using urban space is almost exclusively represented in the literature with land or real estate prices. The underlying hypothesis there is that construction would always be the next best profitable option for urban land, and that land prices are its best reflection. Fair enough, although it may debatable, as not all the alternatives of land use for a given land have a clear net benefit flow, far from it. Who knows, perhaps, at times, the next most profitable option for public welfare would be represented by the net flow of ecosystem services generated by a natural conservation option ?..
Anyhow, what if we are valuating water drainage systems scenarios ? Small urban green bioswales alongside the roads, designed for managing sustainably rainwater and stormwater ? It does not really eats up property lands, but rather public space, streets and sidewalks. What about linear street parking spaces, if those are to be converted for creating urban parks and whatnot. Real estate prices would not be a fitting approximation for the lost foregone best benefit in these situations, it seems to me.
I have not found any alternatives in the literature for taking into account the opportunity costs of open or public space. Do you have any insights on this matter ? Any literature on geographic economics or urban economics modelling that deals differently with this ?
Many thanks for any contribution
Relevant answer
Answer
Very good question. The opportunity costs of using public space for greening depends on situations and countries.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
6 answers
I'm looking for research and studies using Goffman's theory to approach contemporary urban life (including issues of new technologies, AI, urban safety, extremism, epidemics etc…). Obliged to anyone who can point me to relevant materials. Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
GENERALIZATION OF EPIDEMIC THEORY. AN APPLICATION TO THE TRANSMISSION OF IDEAS
W GOFFMAN, V A NEWILL
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
9 answers
As a rule, actions focused on making an urbanized area smarter are at the same time actions to improve the quality of life (comfort) of the inhabitants of such an area. This statement also includes - in my opinion - the problem of creating the most appropriate acoustic climate in a smart city, or rather in its components. I am intentionally not talking about noise reduction: being in absolute silence is one of the more sophisticated tortures. The comfortable living space is "acoustically varied": we expect a rather quiet space for rest (sleep) at night, but accept a more noisy dining and entertainment space, of course with restrictions on the night time, ie usually between 10.00 PM and 6.00 AM. However, in publications on acoustic phenomena in public space, I did not find too many studies on Smart City acoustics. Do you know such studies or studies?
Relevant answer
Answer
I am intensely looking for it, but up to now, my efforts are unsuccessful. Therefore, I am also intensely looking for people who know something or who intend to engage in this area of problems.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
11 answers
Hi Kind helpers,
For my industrial design thesis, I'm working on a concentrated solar energy (>CPV) construction, to be integrated in urban areas/buildings (glass roofs, with integrated Fresnel lens).
The construction would be applied in large public spaces (shopping malls, trainstations etc.). In the case of this CPV construction, the PV/solar panel, is hung inside, and is never exposed to exterior dirt/soil/bird droppings. While there's some literature on exterior soiling of PV and optics, I'm having a hard time estimating how much of an impact dust can have on the efficiency of PV in larger interior spaces.
Is there a specific 'estimation method' that I can use, to estimate how much dust will fall per surface area (& height?), based on the volume of a place and maybe how many people pass through per x amount of time? Would love to hear if there's a good way to do this, without actually experimenting. Related literature is also very welcome of course.
Thanks in advance.
Relevant answer
because the dust deposition on the glass surface of your modules is coming from interior contamination, then I think it is hard to give the rate of deposition of dust on the glass surface. You need to make experimental investigations. In order to speed up the experiment you can suck the air by a pump and let it pass through a filter. The you measure the pumped air and weigh the trapped duct from which you can estimate the the thickness of the deposited layer under free fall conditions.
Best wishes
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
My research field focuses on environment-user relations and I look for studies that compare the user's perception of prohibition and guidance signs. I mean, in COVID-19 times, I would like to understand if the environment that uses prohibition signs becomes more hostile in some way. Thank you very much in advance!
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you so much for your contribution, Mark! It's great to meet you here, I had the pleasure of meeting you at the IAPS event last year. I will research studies with this approach. Recently I found some studies that deal with the development of negative feelings in environments that only provide restrictions through signaling. And some of them declare the effectiveness of prohibitive signs in places where other people are breaking the rules they impose.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
10 answers
Hello! Currently I am working on a research about different methodologies of urban public spaces evaluation/their impact assessment. The only comprehensive projects with explicit measurement instructions I could find were established in the US.
Do you know any documents/brochures of this type formulated by state agencies/private agencies in other countries? (there is an example attached below)
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Daria,
I primer on methods used universally focused on social aspects is Gehl & Svarre 2013
which is also referred to in the guidebook you linked to. While published in the US it relies on research from all over the word.
If you are interested in cultural differences, a recent paper that may be of interest is
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
5 answers
  • What are the processes through which public spaces evolve, and how does planning and other forms of regulation interact with them?
  • How should rights and responsibilities for public spaces be safeguarded over the long term?
  • How can the global prepare to live with pandemic potentiality, specifically when it comes to their rural and impoverished communities?
Relevant answer
Answer
Public space takes its importance from activities that take place .. so, in order to evolve a public space we need to:
First, making a public space that suits the citizen' desires .
Make it an open access space by placing it in secure and open area ( hear we are talking about physical, visual and psychological accessibility to that space)..
Involving citizens in building that space and getting care of it and with time it will takes sens and signification by creating what is called a "place attachement" as mr amine Moulay said ..
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
12 answers
Hi All,
I want to raise the following issue related to the innovation performance of the business, especially the problem with reporting research and innovation activities to national statistical offices and public incentives to increasing the level of data gathered in this field.
We call this phenomenon “Hidden innovation” – the good examples exist. Still, there is no official information about them in public space and official statistics, which is a problem in at least the following directions: 1) lack of awareness about “good practices” and missing opportunities for their dissemination; and 2) underestimated positions of the national economy within the framework of different international classifications and indices; 3) lack of evidence-based policies in the field of research and innovation and stemming from this inefficient public investment and unaddressed market and system failers.
It will be exciting and fruitful if you can share national practices in this area and what is most important – workable decisions for making innovative business more responsible in reporting data concerning their research and innovation activities.
Relevant answer
Affirmative
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
3 answers
A research group is conducting a study across several cultures to investigate insights about issues in the environment of school-age children (6-12). The purpose is to explore practitioners' feedback and insights into how urban form in children environment is configured and assembled to fit their daily life in public spaces. Your answers to the following survey are much appreciated to the entire questions that might take less than 5 minutes.
Relevant answer
An interesting research d. Formella... I was happy to complete the form... All the best for this project!
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
7 answers
A research group is conducting a study across several cultures to investigate insights about issues in the environment of school-age children (6-12). The purpose is to explore practitioners' feedback and insights into how urban form in children environment is configured and assembled to fit their daily life in public spaces. Your answers to the following survey are much appreciated to the entire questions that might take less than 5 minutes.
Thank you
Relevant answer
Answer
You may take benefit from the above article...
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
3 answers
Public exposure to mobile phones is enhanced by microwave reflection in enclosed spaces. such as elevators, and perhaps public transportation and cars, as well. What then is the risk to the brain of “passive exposure” to mobile phone microwaves?
Relevant answer
Good Answer M. Cooper
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
5 answers
In crowded public spaces there is a high risk of droplet transmission. Seeing the scarcity of the masks what should we do. In media lot of messages going on for it and against it. What to follow?
Relevant answer
Answer
as recommended, only sick people should wear masks.physiology of breathing can only force greater respiratory resistance in healthy people as well as result in a decrease in the filter's filtration values
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
7 answers
I am an urban design specialist with an emerging interest in "Smart Cities" concept and use of ICTs in the related fields (e.g. public spaces, urban planning, urban management, ...).
I wanted to know if there are some specific applications and Computer Software which can be helpful in learning and acting in this area (e.g. built environments, modeling, traffic analyse, ... ).
I would be grateful for any upcoming help and suggestion.
Relevant answer
Answer
2) Dublin smart dashboard -- http://dublindashboard.ie/pages/index
3) the Bee Smart City database has lots of digital and smart city solutions --- https://www.beesmart.city/index
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
9 answers
Social exclusion is a process by which certain groups are systematically disadvantaged because they are discriminated against on the basis of their ethnicity, race, religion, sexual orientation, caste, descent, gender, age, disability, HIV status, migrant status or where they live.
Relevant answer
Answer
Well, the question asked is very generic and social exclusion covers wide range of variables that affect that specific community/group being discriminate both economically (job opportunities and freedom to do business etc) and socially (anxiety, stress, depression). Since the question asked is related to public space and services, yes it does affect the mindset of specific group being discriminated and it could be an intentional (state sponsored) act or unintentionally (by general public). The issue highlighted is prevailing in both developed and developing countries. The situation is worst in developing or under-developed regions where economy also play an important role. In worst cases, this discrimination results into hatred, anti-state retaliation and anarchy in the society. For explanation I want to refer to some examples and wish to include China, India and Pakistan.
The recent revocation of special status of Kashmir in India (as explained in article 370 of Indian constitution) and introduction of Muslim discriminated citizenship bill is damaging Indian economy to large extent. Both state and Muslim community have different narratives but you may consider it in your study.
About China, Uighur Muslims camps in Xinjiang, province is another example. ( https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-50511063 )
In Pakistan, after 9/11 when the initially known Mujahideen forces (trained and armed during soviet's Afghan invasion) later called Taliban with movement known as TTP (Tehrik e Taliban Pakistan) majorly consist of Pashtoon/Paktoon ethnic group widely populated in Afghan-Pakistan border areas were started being discriminate in other part of country, such as in news papers their cartoons were published to indirectly sent the message that this complete ethnic group is actually Taliban (Taliban is generalized to be pastoons) that is totally wrong. Anyway, this group is not considered an ethnic minority but again their movements were restricted in many part of Pakistan due to potential terrorist attack although recently security situation improves. ( https://www.dw.com/en/pashtuns-rise-up-against-war-taliban-and-pakistani-military/a-43309299 )
Another ethnic minority group called "Hazara" situated in Baluchistan province of Pakistan is being discriminate and even mass murdered since past few years due to their religious believe and ethnicity. The people of this community cannot use normal transport inside Quetta and other part of province. Public transporters don't allow them inside their buses due to potential threat of any terrorist attack. They directly excuse by referring, we cannot put the life of other passengers on risk. There movement is limited and they cannot do business in open market as recently most of the businessman from this community is targeted and killed. In past ten years about 100,000 members of this community migrated to Australia, Europe etc to seek asylum. The complete area is surrounded by security forces for past 6-7 years and its hard to say either the presence of security forces for this long period is for the protection or ... For more details, you may refer to
The above mentioned analysis is my personnel opinion and I apologize if it hurts sentiment of any specific group/community. I am not sure if I answered the question asked appropriately.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
5 answers
For developing the model of my PhD thesis about "urban happiness in public spaces", I would like to recognize the best system dynamic methods. I sincerely looking for the recommendation.
Relevant answer
Answer
This link is kind of the reverse of happiness but can give some ideas
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
3 answers
One of the European Union's integration goals is to create a common European public space. Today, the most effective public sphere is national public sphere. In the context of the European Union, have we moved from national public spaces to European public spaces? Can such a European public sphere be moved? Is this a realistic target?
Relevant answer
Answer
Massimo Airoldi .... how about adding your own views also?
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
I m trying to simulate an open space in EP for evaluating the effect of different shades for cooling public spaces. One such option is putting radiant cooling on the floor. But can we simulate these and come up with a solution?
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
7 answers
Looking for getting some information about revitalizing public spaces in Sadr City and adjacent urban areas.
Relevant answer
Answer
Please see the following article
Best Regards Nizar R. J. Dalfi
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
18 answers
I'm doing a research on public spaces which I'm trying to understand the way of life in cities in past days, their presence in public spaces, their uses of public spaces and different spaces they used and I'm wondering if there is a method to study this?
Relevant answer
Answer
Start with "Critique of Everyday Life" by Henri Lefebvre.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
1 answer
Can any one help me on how to make a questionnaire to determining the effect of physical and social factors to place attachment?
#place_attachment
#public_space
#physical_factors
#social_factors
Relevant answer
Answer
I can tell you that your questionnaire depends first of all on your research's objectives, and on indicators based on your hypothesis. If you make a good conceptualization of your hypothesis I guarantee you that you would have a perfect questionnaire about your field study
Greetings
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
6 answers
Defining street vending as a art, and making it perform at public space gives essence of identity and belonging. Also, it leaves sense of adjustments in sustaining their art of living.
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with Mamun Rashid and doubt, if the image that is displayed at the start of this discussion has been produced by street sellers. It does not necessarily mean that the locations they occupy are not used by others, but those who do graffiti. If this is correct then they street sellers and the graffiti provide the background of photographic art.....
  • asked a question related to Public Space
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
Urban codes have a profound influence on urban form, affecting the design and placement of buildings, streets and public spaces. Historically, their use has helped create some of our best-loved urban environments, while recent advances in coding have been a growing focus of attention, particularly in Britain and North America. However, the full potential for the role of codes has yet to be realized.
In Stephen Marshall's book - Urban Coding and Planning - the nature and scope of coding are investigated; its purposes; the types of environments it creates; and, perhaps more importantly, its relation to urban planning.
The purpose of this question is to bring this discussion of how zoning codes affect the urban form. Can you help with something?
Relevant answer
Answer
Bryan Higgins
, thank you for answer. While perhaps less familiar than the examples of our OECD counterparts, the planning and development strategies employed by this Brazilian city over the past decades are equally noteworthy. At its core, Curitiba exemplifies how the integration of land use planning, transportation infrastructure, and environmental sustainability efforts can enable a city to meet the needs of its expanding population and mitigate the negative effects of urban growth. As such, both its innovations and the foundational principles underlying them are deeply relevant to expanding metropolises worldwide. It highlights innovations in Curitiba, Brazil that have been successful in alleviating the interrelated problems of urban growth: sprawl, environmental degradation, and economic inequality.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
3 answers
Is the place’s distinctive character reflected in the way it is laid out and landscaped?
Relevant answer
Answer
Istanbul is a tremendously interesting city to visit. However I’m not sure that the question makes sense to me. Istanbul has different areas built at different times and with different characters. It does not seem to be one coherent whole. That’s part of its charm surely?
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
6 answers
In most Mexican cities, public administrations use street furniture as propaganda, painting with the color of their political party every change of government. In terms of urban landscape, these behaviors do not create conditions of quality of public space, identity and attachment to the place by the inhabitants
Relevant answer
Answer
n Poland, nothing like this happens.
It is a democratic country and the regulations from 2015 regulate the issues of advertising in public space
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
Hello,
in 2008 after my epidemiological thesis in biology/ethnomedicine I started the development of the FCMapper. About 2010 I started studying fine arts and worked in the field of Art&Science since then. 2018 I got a one year stipend from the state of Carinthia for developing FCM as an artistc method.
In which kind of fields do you plan to work with FCM in this project? Which kind of scientists and experts will be involved into this project?
It would be great to contribute to a bigger project to bring FCM out of academia - into museums and also public space.
Kind regards, Michael
Relevant answer
Answer
cool idea Michael! Allow me to brainstorm a little bit .....
Think of a 3d installation in a museum for example that visualises in real time the satisfation of the visitors. The visitors fill online satisfaction surveys and the 3d installation adapts its form and geometry with respect the FCM outcomes.
Serafeim
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
3 answers
I am carrying on a research related to Latin America Public Space. I would like to kindly ask if you could help me with any updated references/authors that discuss about:
- changes on local scale of public spaces (IN LATIN AMERICA CITIES), taking into account the physical (how the materiality has changed), social (how the subjects have using it), and political (how the subjects have claims over them and from them) dimensions.
Thank you all in advance
Relevant answer
Answer
Cheers!
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
10 answers
I started to do a new work about gender justice in Iranian urban public spaces. I like to cooperate with another researcher in other countries to compare Iranian cities results and the other countries cities results. Please contact me, if you are interested.
Relevant answer
Answer
This is a very important topic especially for the cities of developing countries. Cities of these countries are cities of men. They lack sidewalks, sitting places and toilets. It is very important that the urban design is from the point of view of a woman. Thank you.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
1 answer
Cataloging frogs calls are a robust method of collecting data for bullfrog immigration, but they don't work year round, are subjective and need dedicated volunteers. eDNA needs specialists and resources. The early methods of airguns for sample collecting are unlikely to be approved for urban public spaces.
Fyke nets have promise, but permission to deploy them is not a given, plus costs, maintenance and perceived impact on ecosystem are problems.
Is there any method that is virtually free, quick and easy? Wondering if there is any experience of identification of species via photographs of individuals like they do for whales?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello,
You can ID individuals based on patterns, and there are softwares that help, but it is quite species dependent. It should work pretty well with the spots on the ventral side for bullfrogs though. The paper below give some recommendations on what works and what is better avoided.
For free methods, I still recommend call monitoring, it works quite well for population dymanics:
Best,
Amael
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
6 answers
I am looking for real or evacuation drill data set for validation purpose. If anyone can help or share data.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Tarapada,
under the following link you can find data archive with a variety of experimental trajectory data from pedestrian experiments made by the Research Center Jülich (Germany). The data can be used for further research, as long you name the source of the data.
I hope you find something useful.
Regards Helmut
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
3 answers
Public space is a gathering place for various activities and each user can change at any time. Meanwhile, the comfort of space and place is one of the important things, not only about visual comfort but also thermal comfort.
How do you meet thermal comfort in a public space? whereas, thermal comfort is very subjective. Can we ignore that subjectivity?
Relevant answer
Answer
@ Harimi Djamila
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
5 answers
Thank you for participating in our survey of playable city, gamifiying Urban Public Spaces. By gamfiying the city and public urban places, we mean to create a joyful and playable city for all generations not only children or young people.
The survey is voluntary – you do not need to do it. However, by carefully and accurately completing this
survey you will help others provide the platform for developing cities livable place for everyone. So,If you prefer, you can complete. Please fill this quick survey and let us know your thoughts (your answers will be anonymous).
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi,
You may look at these references.
Best,
Dhirgham
- WHITZMAN, CAROLYN, MEGAN WORTHINGTON, and DANA MIZRACHI. "The Journey and the Destination Matter: Child-Friendly Cities and Children's Right to the City." Built Environment (1978-) 36, no. 4 (2010): 474-86.
- Angell, Robert Cooley. "Moral Integration and Interpersonal Integration." American Journal of Sociology 57, no. 1 (1951): 88-91.
- Hrostowski, Susan. "Diversity in Aging America: Making Our Communities Aging Friendly." Race, Gender & Class 17, no. 3/4 (2010): 307-13.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
5 answers
I am Ian Daniel Garife, a 5th - year BS Architecture student from the Philippines. I am currently researching a study on the feasibility of A Proposed Agri-Urban Food Park. The study delves into Recreating Public Realms as Multi-Use Destinations through Placemaking.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Garife,
Here are some relevant works including the authors; you may check them out. Also, Michael Southworth, a professor at University of California Berkeley, is one of the experts in this area (https://vcresearch.berkeley.edu/faculty/michael-southworth).
Best,
1- Robert G. Shibley, Lynda H. Schneekloth and Bradshaw Hovey (2003) Constituting the Public Realm of a Region: Placemaking in the Bi-National Niagaras.
2- Hector Fernando Burga (2008) Traditions of Placemaking and Fundamentalisms of Practice: The New Urbanism in the Context of Globalization.
3- Robert G. Shibly (1998) The Complete New Urbanism and the Partial Practices of Placemaking.
4- Dolores Hayden (1988) Placemaking, Preservation and Urban History
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
2 answers
It is widely argued that the contemporary city is becoming an increasingly hostile environment for homeless people. As basic street survival strategies are criminalised and public space ‘purified’ of those whose spoiled identities threaten to taint fellow members of the public, city authorities seem to have turned from a position of neglect to more
obviously punitive measures designed to contain and control homeless people. Less widely acknowledged but equally prevalent, however, is a parallel rise in the care system; evident in the growing number of shelters rooms, kitchens and many other services for homeless people. These spaces of care springing up in theinterstices of a revanchist city, act as important sources of material
resource and refuge for a highly stigmatised group. However, what for one person may operate as a space of care might, for another, be experienced as a space of fear, shame and further stigmatization. Do these spaces help people to get out of the homelessness ?
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with much of what you have said and the previous answer. This is a systemic issue. Shelters and soup kitchens are vital when homelessness is rampant but they don't solve it. Better access to housing, welfare benefits and mental health services, for example, do help solve it. In the UK in the late 80s and early 90s there was a homelessness crisis due to benefit cuts. This was partially solved by investing in intensive outreach and housing services. Now these have been disinvested and benefits cut again and homelessness is spiralling again. This is a choice we make politically and economically as a sociaty and this must be recognised and policy must address it systematically rather than just leaving it to soup kitchen charities great though they are.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
5 answers
Public space is essential in the daily life of the homeless. Waldron (1991) underlines that the traditional complementarity between the use of private space and the use of public space, which works correctly for the domiciled, fails completely in the case of homeless people. In other words, homeless people do not only live public space like the rest of the “normal” people, rather they live in public space, having, by definition, no private space (homes) and no alternative but to be and live their lives in public. Hence, public space becomes a home, a place where homeless people tend to settle, more or less temporarily. It is a place where everyday life can be managed and a place where survival resources can be found. Private and public life cannot be separated: both are located in the public space. Walking through the streets of the city it is quite common to see marginalized people sitting or resting under the arcades, begging or wandering in general. In particular, in the course of my research into the use of the city spaces I have discovered a whole world belonging to homeless people with its own spaces, rhythms, times, relationships and survival strategies. Living on the streets forces the homeless to make choices continuously, as anyone would do in their daily life. However, it is not something done in a casual way; we can discern a strong rationality in the process, and such rationality is based on the reality of the individual’s situation. The reality of living on the street defines the choices of the homeless person and affects every moment of his day and his entire life. Could we say that urban public space forces the homeless to adopt particular behaviours? And so that a the urban space is not only the place where they spend most of their day, but it is also a mechanism which contributes towards shaping an homeless identity?
Relevant answer
Answer
Since 2015, and in cooperation with the Faculty of art of Université du Québec à Montréal (UQAM), artistic activities has been offered to homeless men on this particular theme of: how I see my city, and how I live in it.
The workshops, span over 12 weeks and are organised by a professional artist. The men each have a cell phone or a camera and they walk throughout the city taking pictures and recording sounds that will be later used to elaborate a short video of 4-5 minutes. In the process, they visits museums or artists' studios to see what professional contemporary artists have produced on the subject.
This whole process brings a lot of change in their vision of the city and of their place in the city.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
I am trying to understand if and how planners can help empower migrants by intervening on the built form. I am familiar with works by, for example, Jeffrey Hou and Fran Tonkiss. I wonder if someone wrote more specifically about how immigrants use a city's public spaces and what interventions might be done to facilitate self-empowerment. Thank you!
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Maria,
Have a look at:
-The biopolitics of otherness: undocumented foreigners and racial discrimination in French public debate
-Gender, Visibility and Public Space in Refugee Claims on the Basis of Sexual Orientation
-Rethinking urban parks: Public space and cultural diversity
-Negotiating public space: Strategies and styles of migrant female domestic workers in Singapore
-Contesting the public realm: Struggles over public space in Los Angeles
Hope these help.
Best,
Aryan
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
How could space and its individual and social representations questions the problem of sustainable human development ? In a context of permanently mutating space, how can we state the ability to make society ? Could social appropriation of environment quality and sustainable co-management of living spaces be analytically modelled ? Is it possible to interrogate the socio-environmental strategies of daily territories appropriation ? How can user values of public spaces constitute a transfiguration of reality in the field of landscape experience ?
Relevant answer
Modeling human actions to mitigate the effects of drought, floods, or rising sea level, etc., arising from climate change or from other natural or human factors is possible where human reaction indicators are identifiable. E.g. If human reaction x has been proven scientifically as a mitigation measure against environmental factor y, call it rising temperature due to climate change, then x becomes the applicable measure to adopt under similar circumstances.
Prof. Orach-Meza
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
9 answers
What in your opinion are the key reasons why so many locations are hard to navigate? Why does wayfinding design so often fail to work effectively?
This is an open ended question as I am keen on any and all opinions.
If you are in an airport why did you get lost and how could it have been solved? In a urban area, on a bay trail, in a sports stadium/ What wayfinding problems did you experience?
Relevant answer
Answer
I've been to almost 20 countries and I must say that infrastructure is affected by the different sociocultural conventions. Another way to look at it is that the differences in landscapes between different lands/countries compel the residents to devise their methods of navigation, be it pedestrian or vehicular. You also need to consider the time and effort different people invest in getting to know a previously unfamiliar environment and their inherent expertise or effectiveness with navigation strategy use (see my papers). All these factors contribute to individual differences in spatial navigaiton, that is, what may be easy for one person (due to greater cognitive flexibility, adaptability, or effective strategy use, etc.) may come across as complex for another. 
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
2 answers
Pillars are the vertical or near vertical supports of a car's window area or greenhous.
Relevant answer
Answer
Some cars use an Aluminum Sub Frame,
and actually the B-Pillar is the post behind the front door and between doors on 4 door models, on 4-door models they have a c-pillar that supports the rear window, the A-pillar supports the front windshield
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
Bikesharing is currently rather hot in China because of the emergence of a new form bikesharing program, namely non-docking bikesharing. It is called Mobike of Ofo, two of most wide-accepted bikesharing program. More and more people tend to ride the bikesharing for commuting, shopping, entertainment, exercise, et al. There is no docking station, which is different from the tradional bikesharing before. As they are avaiable around us easily, commuters can ride it to their workplace directly or regard it as a transfer mode. Based on this assumption, will this new form of bikesharing mitigate the urban traffic congestion in the future? I hold a positive attitude.
Relevant answer
Answer
This is an interesting and challenging question. Many factors may make these shared mobility solutions positively/negatively impact urban traffic. How many bikes were shared? How are these shared bikes managed at intersections, links, etc.? Sufficient bike lanes/roads? Imagining a city without car but just bikes, is it perfect? Perhaps there will be bike traffic congestion:)  All in all, one answer cannot fit for all cities' conditions.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
5 answers
I am designing a crowd sourced, regional air pollution profile study, where I want to obtain personal exposures for about 300 participants. Looking for a device similar to AirBeam but under $100. 
Relevant answer
Answer
forget the 2 previous answers
tests in  peer-reviewed publication
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
5 answers
I am investigating the relationship between old and new (modern, functional, luminous) university campuses and the way they shape thought, especially for students.
Relevant answer
Answer
The university’s complex environment with diverse organizational sub-cultures and traditions has raised concerns. Students are more focused on modern facilities and take cognizance and adopt campus practices such as energy,  use public transportation,  and actively involved in recreational facilities.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
Community usually has a perception of crime, dangerous, fear of contaminated soil or horrible feel towards abandoned brownfield site. How uses of technology can improve the community perception and encourage uses of the abandoned space?
Relevant answer
Answer
Using for example before and after renderings of brownfields... as well as case studies in which these spaces have been successfully converted into new landscapes, as is the case of Duisburg Nord, Millenium Park, Gas Works Park, etc. etc...
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
14 answers
Phenomenology malls
Foundations of development stimuli
Relevant answer
Answer
Yes, Navid, these spaces are inevitable, and most people use and enjoy them. I suppose I'm unusually traditional. I don't even own a mobile phone!
Do you think it is possible to strengthen traditional commercial spaces and patterns of production/distribution so that they might counter some of the more nocive effects of the large corporate model that has consolidated itself throughout much of the world?
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
6 answers
Are there cities that have applied something similar?
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
15 answers
This beach front space is in the city area, and the building of such a hotel will offer many job opportunities to many locals. At present unemployment is very high in the country. This 15-story hotel would be the highest in the country and by extension in the city, but its height will not block the vision of any other building in the city.
They are some hotels a distant away also on the beach that are less than 7-stories, but this venture will bring much foreign exchange to the country. It will as well bring a greater level of aesthetics to the area as many buildings in the said world heritage site are become derelict. The city really needs a face lift at this moment.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Angela,
As the type of World Heritage site hasn't been noted, it is difficult to provide a full justification to the question. Lets say that the site is an urban world heritage site. UNESCO haven't provided any recommendations or documents which discuss the impacts of high rise buildings in urban landscapes, which therefore initiates the first problem regarding what is and what isn't allowed provided by the international advisory bodies, as there is no clear guidelines and each case is different depending on the city. The second issue is in regards to the human/heritage dilemma, as the number one stakeholder here would be the local communities. Is it the right thing to do to prevent a regenerative scheme into the local area to preserve the historic buildings of the city (which you commented on was in need of a facelift). The situation sounds like it does require some regenerative scheme to the urban area, however it does need to be an organic development, and one which negotiates between preserving the historic landscape, but also understanding that urban areas require change benefit the communities and prevent a form of museumification. 
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
8 answers
Through my research in Middle-East, in multiple occasions I have encountered the confusion around the ownership of the 'public' space and the way it is perceived! The language clearly differentiates between social space and public space as the former mostly refers to social relations and social production of space and latter embraces the public space as the space of political and body politics (Arendt / Habermas). Now I am wondering how the notion of public space can be divorced from public-private dichotomy and what would be its implication?
Relevant answer
Answer
As noted by others above many authors go beyond a simple public-private dichotomy. To the literature mentioned earlier I would add  Dovey, K. (2016) Urban Design Thinking: A Conceptual Toolkit, London: Bloomsbury. pp.153-158. The chapter on privatisation provides a simple but powerful framework for thinking about these issues by distinguishing between access and control (i.e. ownership) of space. Thus there are hybrid/quasi-public conditions where a space can be accessed by the public but is privately controlled (i.e. shopping malls) or be publicly controlled yet have highly restricted access (i.e. military compounds).
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
1 answer
I'm interested in the relationship between the development of sports complexes which occupy the space.
Relevant answer
Answer
I think two aspects of sports geography may be interesting. First, how is the location determined? Second, how can we conduct a cost-benefit analysis?  Especially, it might be challenging to estimate the benefits of a sports complex.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
18 answers
We will continue talking for a long time about the Crisis, many have forgotten its origins and seems that they haven’t learned about its consequences. As an architect I must say that one of its main causes has been a bad management of the city. This amnesia, that seems it has been incrusted in the brains of the ones in charge of giving solutions, has provoked, as a slab falling over the polis, that the “supposed anti-crisis” policies that have been and are being adopted are merely economical with devastating and dramatic consequences for the citizens, without understanding that the wound of this hemorrhage will not heal if one of its causes is not investigated, analyzed and cauterized, I’m referring to the notion of City and to the condition of public space as an exemplary result of the aggrupation of citizens, politicians, in the Aristotelian sense of politics.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear José,
I think the biggest difficulty about a definition of what is public space relates to the generally undiscussed status of the analogy/metaphor/metonymy between public space as a political configuration and public space as a physical dimension in cities.
Some French scholars have tried to explore this interstice between, let's say, Habermas and "la place": They might be useful for your reflection.
Jacques Lévy:
Louis Quéré:
Etienne Tassin:
Bassand and Joye:
Chartier and Baker:
For a critical view on the history of the concept and of its chaotic uses, see also F. Tomas:
Best regards
d.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
8 answers
I am researching about public space size, access, localization and distribution, and I need to know how are these critery in other countrys. Or someone can help me with suggestions papers with these informations? Thanks
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Izabel,
This may not be exactly what you are looking for, but in my 20-year-long study of institution and home I developed a territorial gradient (see attached diagrams). The gradient, the first diagram, delineates the domain, the number of people potentially using the space (perhaps the most important factor), the approximate size, typical term of occupancy,  typical responsible entity, typical type of control necessary, and typical access. 
Since I was applying the gradient to residential buildings, the second and third diagrams are more applied. For the second, I placed different types of residential buildings on the scale as one way of exploring degrees of institutionality.  The third combines this and other studies I did, especially space syntax to develop a gradient of institutionality. This is described in my book Institution and Home: Architecture as a Cultural Medium (Techne Press, 2006), (see also my article online "Institutional Space, Domestic Space, and Power Relations: Revisiting territoriality with space syntax")
With best wishes,
Julia
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
25 answers
Pace of urbanization and thus forming really wide public spaces is very different from historic as well as geographical point of view. In any case this process means that a number of people whose cognitive and communicative habits are adopted to the close milieus where one is personally acquainted with everyone (or with the majority of those people) one has to deal with - have to accommodate oneselves to the milieus where lots of "the others" are to be looked at as abstracted agents. The pace of this accommodation - in both personal and generational perspectives - supposes different strategies both on the side of those passing through this process as well as those already urbanized ones who have to deal with the newcomers. Thus the question.
Relevant answer
Answer
The answer to the first question: There is never downshifting because I believe that we take the kampung spirit with us when we migrate to the city. Malaysians are very attached to their roots. I must tell you about our 'balik kampung' phenomenon whereby our capital city is literally deserted during major festivals such as Eid, Chinese New Year and Deepavali and school holidays. During these holidays, everyone 'balik kampung' i.e. leave the city to go back to their kampungs for a few days. If you can imagine, Extreme Christmas at least 4 times a year (we have 2 Eids). So, there is never a question of downshifting because kampung is deeply entrenched in our psyches.
The answer to the second question: If I'm allowed to generalise, my answer would be "yes". Especially if the newcomers bring their 'kampung' attitude to the city. For instance, kampungfolks are not used to living in high rise buildings, and some will do things like throwing rubbish from their balcony or put excessive plant pots in the corridor (kampung folks like to garden). However, I think town people are becoming more receptive to kampung folks these days, especially when we have an influx of foreign immigrants/workers who bring their own 'kampung' culture to Malaysia! :)
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
9 answers
I am looking at inclusive collective spaces as strategic projects acting as catalysts against the spatial segregation of the city. But I not sure that my concept of public space is conceived in the same way in South Africa.
My case study is Cape Town, but I think that I need to undestand better the public space meaning in the South African context.
Available for any additional information.
Relevant answer
Answer
Miriam,
Useful Links
UN-Habitat: Global Toolkit for Public Space
Project for Public Spaces
Open Streets Cape Town
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
I'm currently researching materials to read for my thesis, the idea is to find a connection between socialisation of migrants and locals in public spaces' contexts to foster their integration. 
Relevant answer
Answer
SPENER, David. Transitional bilingual education and the socialization of immigrants. Harvard Educational Review, 1988, vol. 58, no 2, p. 133-154.
ROMERO, Mary. Racial profiling and immigration law enforcement: Rounding up of usual suspects in the Latino community. Critical Sociology, 2006, vol. 32, no 2-3, p. 447-473.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
10 answers
I am pulling together a research proposal on the topic above and would like to know what you think are the key ideas and examples regarding children and open space in cities, in relation to environmental, societal and economic concerns? It's a very wide subject I know, but the final piece will be reflecting that.
Thanks!
Relevant answer
Answer
Children are playful and quite inventive.while designing for child friendly public realm would effectively mean more safe spaces.
I recommend the links below 
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
6 answers
There are too many studies about how to improve the public space, but what happens when there are too many governmental actors working without coordination, plans or goals? Thanks for your help!
Relevant answer
Answer
I would highly recommend McDermott's book on education.
McDermott, K. A. (2011). High-stakes reform: The politics of educational accountability. Georgetown University Press.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
13 answers
Can anyone help me on how to put together an effective questionnaire for gathering information on determining the level of place attachment in urban public spaces of Isfahan?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Joseph,
I want to include Place Attatchment in the Phd project I am working on. There is a Spanish group of researchers that have developed a scale to measure Place Attatchment and Place Identification throug a short list of likert items.
I think it could be useful for you. I copy here references of their work.
Good luck.
Hernández, B., Carmen Hidalgo, M., Salazar-Laplace, M. E., & Hess, S. (2007). Place attachment and place identity in natives and non-natives. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 27(4), 310–319. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2007.06.003
Ruiz, C., & Hernández, B. (2014). Emotions and coping strategies during an episode of volcanic activity and their relations to place attachment. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 38, 279–287. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2014.03.008
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
15 answers
In investigating what works best in making public spaces for people living in high urban spaces in the asian developing world (thailand, vietnam, indonesia),there needs to be indication that users of different backgrounds have positive experiences with the space and other users different to their own social backgrounds. Methods of gathering opinion from an individual(in an interview) is a challenge as more likely in this South East Asian culture, people often refer to themselves to be part of a group/community themselves than as individual, or reluctant to share as one. Conducting focus groups however, poses a different challenge as one voice may influence the rest-this could influence the outcome of a study itself.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Najah, colleagues and I have developed a mixed methods tool for assessing collective resilience; it combines a quant survey with qual data collection focusing on the individual's experience of the collective. Might be of use?
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
19 answers
I am looking for studies on the built environment and public spaces using observation as a primary method.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Leila,
I am replying you because I have worked in professional and academic terms on the impact of observation within the built space of some Italian historic centres.
Actually, observation was one of the many indicators that I used to assess the 'suitability to transformation' of each building.
There are few papers that I published with my former supervisor within the Politecnico di Milano University (Milan, Italy).
In case you are interested, please check this presentation (http://paolillo.professor.polimi.it/files/Ricerca/Ppt%20paper%20Santander2003.pdf) and take a look at some of the paper I uploaded in my ResearchGate profile.
Basically, we used ArcGis extensions to develop DTM (Digital Terrain Model) and DEM (Digital Elevation Model), to use Viewshed extensions. Actually, our most recent publications are based on the use of many tools, like the Viewshed, the VGA, and other approaches.
Please let me know what do you think about the experiences illustrated in those papers (especially the one about the city of Cremona and the one on the city of Como).
In case you find them of your interest, please let me know.
Good luck with your studies and work.
Cheers,
Umberto
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
11 answers
My research is focused on the public space in the intravilan of the countryside. Its topic is the phenomenon of rurality, the rural character as a value associated with the form of environment of rural settlements.
The objective is to find, evaluate and describe the basic attributes and relations in space which co-create rurality, and to do it in such a way so that these findings could eventually be used in practice - e. g. in the intravilan's public space design in order to strengthen the rural features of the environment.
Relevant answer
Answer
I have published a paper on the conservation of New Gourna Village in Egypt, which has been designed by the Egyptian architect Hassan Fathy, as well as another paper on the sustainable conservation of a traditional living community in the USA which is Taos Pueblo. I think both properties can be considered examples of rural settlements that might be relevant to your work. Through these two papers I discussed an approach to analyze the heritage values that these properties might enjoy and how to evaluate their authenticity. I hope that these two papers might be relevant to your work.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
12 answers
I have done a study of a group of women to see how they are related to their environment (in the city) through their everyday lives in the city and its public spaces. I am wondering if there is any specific categorization of everyday life which can be analysed in terms of people's interaction with place in the city.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Roja, 
I would look at the interrelations and assemblages between body, space (materiality), others, meanings and strategies. I observe urban experience from a daily mobility point of view and more than classifying spaces, I try to understand the relations between these different aspects of daily experience.  I hope this helps. 
Regards, Paola
  • asked a question related to Public Space
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
13 answers
I am currently preparing for a dissertation about the relationship between open space design and urban tourism, and how open space stimulates tourism industry.
Are there any recommended journals or books for literature review and references? Can anybody help?
Relevant answer
Answer
Either you depend on subjective or objective indicators or both together. The aims and question of your research will determine the methodology that you may use to investigateyour indicators. For example you may depend sociological or psychological methods to get your subjective indicators.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
1 answer
Around the Government Hill of Hong Kong, there are plenty of landscaped areas being designed for public access, while citizen used to use these spaces for morning exercise.
Relevant answer
Hello .
As architect ,I honestly think that the administrative buildings should be due located out side the public area especially the pedestrian zones due to these governments building are official and secured zones and also being used within the day's hours  and then be empty within the night's ,so the green , open landscapes are not used at all.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
9 answers
I am conducting research on women's experience of fear of crime in public spaces. I will compare foreign literature to my findings, however, I cannot assume that there is an existing fear of crime, so I am stuck with how do I ask if there is a fear of crime without directly asking it. Thank you so much.
Relevant answer
Answer
I would ask about the issue of crime more generally first in your research setting. If you are using in-depth interviews then this should open the conversation up to more how they feel about crime in the area, et cetera. 
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
8 answers
I am trying to measure the effectiveness of CCTV cameras. I am now working on a study designing to look at the relationship between the use of CCTV cameras and perceived fear of crime.
I am specifically looking for a SEM study to measure the effectiveness of CCTV cameras and the influence of this on the perceptions of the public regarding the fear of crime.
Thanks in advance for your inquires
Relevant answer
Answer
I don’t think that you will find such a measure of the effectiveness of CCTVs ready at hand, but I will follow this question to see what materializes.
The effectiveness of CCTV lies mainly in
(1) the deterrent effect they have,
(2) the evidence they provide for post-event investigation and prosecution, and
(3) the immediate alert they can provide during a crime for timely intervention by police.
The threat of investigation and prosecution (2), and the threat of immediate stopping intervention (3) naturally motivate deterrence (1). But post-event investigation and prosecution of course provides no stopping force other than deterrence during the moments of a crime. If the CCTVs are not supervised attentively at all times, moreover, then stopping intervention (3) becomes very unlikely. It is a matter more of chance than of design in security measures.
So the main effectiveness of CCTV for immediate, timely protective security is deterrence (1). And a measure of CCTV effectiveness has to include a measure of deterrent effect. This is obviously problematic.
There has been some work on quantitative measures of deterrence in connection with deterrence through “target shifting”, when protective measures at one site bias criminals toward other sites, demonstrating a significant “force multiplier” effect of deterrence (1) when timely intervention (3) is the foremost justification for surveillance at high-security events, but this may not apply to CCTV generally, when crimes are impulsive, opportunistic, and carried out with little prior planning, and when attentive supervision of CCTV is rare.
It appears, moreover, that you ultimately want a measure of the comfort that comes to the general public from the effectiveness they subjectively attribute to each of the three mechanisms above. This subjective appreciation by the general public may of course differ significantly from the “true” effectiveness that would be more objectively be attributed to each of the three mechanisms by an analysis of the statistics of criminal inclinations and behaviour, with and without CCTV. Thus an objective measure of CCTV effectiveness may not actually serve your purpose.
Subdividing effectiveness into its three different modes acting simultaneously, and drawing a clear distinction between subjective and objective measures of effectiveness for each mode, may help progress toward an answer.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
10 answers
Hello all,
I am looking for books or articles that focus on the development of traditional European public spaces in relation to religious and political ideologies.
It seems evident that most of the traditional public spaces in European cities were created with political and/or religious buildings as the primary focal points.  In many cities, these two functions overlapped.
In the United States, our public spaces are continuously criticized in relation to these traditional European public spaces, though there is also a strong resistance to keep religious ideology separate from the public realm.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Tyler , the link below maybe useful starting point, it is about Religion, Power, and Politics...regards
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
1 answer
A case study will be a shopping mall/centre
Relevant answer
Answer
 Hello Niven,
This very subject was one of my undergraduate research projects. That was many years ago but the few times I have been recently things have not changed much.
It was observational research and if I still have the paper I will send it to you. I remember three types of behaviors depending on location. In a mall, romantic, social, and rudeness. In the universities lunch building (fast food establishments were), what I termed, social, "semi social", technology causing engagement disengagement) and of course romantic.
Last the post office. In the states this is where we find long lines of people. I noticed three types of behaviors, the stoic, friendly and social, and arrogant(fidgety, impatient, pushing, and closeness).
One other behavior I noticed was space had a lot to do with behavior, the more confined the less social and more of the stoic.
Hope this helps,
Douglas
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
11 answers
Currently, high speed of technological development can bring “the whole world” into your own houses which results in lacking of interaction with social and natural environment in their surroundings and impacting negatively on human health.
The relationship between human wellbeing and public spaces is an interesting topic. I am basically focusing on design of of integration between leisure and cultural activities in urban design, especially considering it in design of natural and cultural parks.
I am seeking proper information that whether the above achievement can lead public parks to become meaningful existences in urban design and develop well-being lifestyle.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Hazel
Even for a Master's thesis it would be helpful to know if your degree is in urban design or landscape architecture.
I suggest you narrow your focus to a particular kind of open green space within an urban context, as there are many different kinds and they perform differently for the people who inhabit their surroundings than for those who actually go into them and use them.
Open green space can be as different as Central Park  and Grammercy Park in New York.  
Central park was designed to resemble a natural landscape and is of immense size in order to accommodate automotive traffic, equestrian traffic, pedestrians, skiing and skating in winter, jogging, croquet, lawn bowls and boating in summer, organised sport like baseball football and foot races, dog walking, music concerts, botanical gardening, restaurants, etc.  It also contains infrastructure:  a reservoir for the city drinking water system, a weather observation station, channelled and depressed through-roads for cross town vehicular traffic, an art museum, a music pavilion, and a zoo. Mt Sinai Hospital was located at the edge of Central Park in the days before antibiotics, so that the fresh air around the park would benefit tuberculosis patients.  
Grammercy Park in New york, is a small traditional landscape garden in the middle of a residential square and is both fenced off and gated so that only residents of the square can use it, usually not more than a few at a time.
You can see that the health benefits differ depending on the size of the park and the use to which it is put.  You can also see that the way the park is engaged by the people living next to it will be hugely different: some people on Fifth Avenue or Central Park West in New York never enter the park at all but just look at a distant view it from their windows, and this may have health benefits in itself.  Grammercy Park residents probably don't even bother looking at the garden in the middle of the square, which isn't very impressive, but only 'use' it by entering it for an exclusive private stroll, which itself is a form of exercise.  Finally, Central Park has a huge catchment of users, with people coming from all over the New York metropolitan area as well as all over the world just to be there, whereas no one can use Grammercy park unless they are a guest of a resident.
Central Park and Grammercy Park are two extremes, and you could probably write your thesis just on them without even visiting them because they are so well known and documented.
You will know of similar examples around Melbourne.  Pick a size range that you can cover, perhaps the smaller the better, so you can make sufficient detailed observations with the time allowed.  If you are doing this as a research topic, you may wish to document users or interview them, as well as making inquiries among those who have designed and maintained the park about their objectives in doing so.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
6 answers
The monitoring of public spaces is a very sensitive issue as it entails the tracking and observing of people captured by a deployed network of video cameras. The monitoring may be dealt with at different levels of detail, depending on the type of technology employed, with regards to the dimensions of the monitored area, the topology of the sensor network, its location and the purpose of monitoring (security, crowd management, service delivery, etc.)
In particular face detection techniques joined with geotagging GPS Devices act as a distributed sensor node able to detect the identity, location, social connections, and more of any other person he encounters in public environment. In security surveillance perspective these ICT technologies are quite useful, but according to personal privacy the risk for abuse in such a system is substantial.
Relevant answer
Answer
Everyone has something to hide.  No one walks the streets naked, or goes to the toilet in the open street, or discusses their intimate health issues in a loud voice so that strangers around them can listen in.  If I walk down the street talking to my friend about personal matters and a stranger walks behind me listening in, most people would regard this as unwelcome.  Privacy is a universal aspect of human society.  Privacy is necessary for psychological well-being.  The desire for privacy does not indicate that someone has done something wrong and has something to hide.  Where people do not feel their privacy is sufficient, they experience a range of psychological issues.
We must recognise that different cultures have different levels of personal privacy, and that people inside any one culture have prefer different levels of privacy.  What constitutes "misuse" of personal data therefore varies from culture to culture and person to person.  It is therefore difficult to determine a single standard for all people in a pluralist society.  For some, the knowledge that unknown agencies are compiling unknown data about them is itself upsetting, irrespective of what it is used for.  It represents a possible threat, and that is sufficient to upset them.
We must also recognise that people abuse systems.  The mere existence of such pervasive tracking guarrantees it will be misused.  Criminal sanctions will not prevent such misuse.  We know NSA staff have used internet survelliance to track old girlfriends, for example.  Sanctions may deter a few, but mostly it will be used to punish people after the abuse has happened.  Criminals never committ crimes expecting to be caught.  In addition, with online services the way they are, the bigger danger is that misuse will be impossible to detect.  If I fail to get a job because my employer had illegal access to personal information about me, how would I know, or be able to prove it.
It is not automatic that such pervasive tracking would improve police efficiency.  The influx of huge amounts of additional data could just as easily confuse and overload police.  If we wanted to get real efficiency, we should all be wearing personal gps trackers all the time.  It would then be simple to determine that someone had broken into a house and robbed it.  If you don't like the idea of wearing a device which reports your location to your government all the time, then you shouldn't like the idea of pervasive survellience, because the only difference is the technology being used - wearing it vs placing it in the street.
The fact that privacy is not considered important by people is not really relevant.  This is a technically complex area, and most people simply don't know what's going on.  In addition, most fail to realise the potential consequences of misuse.
As to whether pervasive survelliance represents an improvement to the quality of life, it depends much on your definition.  For some, reduction in crime and improved chances to prevent terrorist attacks are more important than personal privacy.  However, the degree of risk reduction for the individual, whose personal chance of being a victim of crime or terrorism is statistically tiny, may be very low. However, many people value their independance from government and privacy more and are prepared to accept a slight increase in risk if it means preserving their privacy.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
7 answers
Are there any new studies on the desirability of urban public spaces from the perspective of specific groups, women and girls?
Relevant answer
Answer
One of the most common uses of Geographic Information Systems (GIS) corresponds to the selection of the most suitable place or places to locate any public facilities. Among the existing methods for this purpose are highlighted Multicriteria evaluation, Optimum Location and Location-allocation.
Some references: 
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
9 answers
Public spaces, such as parks, are created to discourage discrimination of social hierarchy, and to be shared by all races, genders and backgrounds.
What is the best way to mitigate arising issues in adjacent private spaces?
Relevant answer
Answer
I think to answer your question you need to expand on this.....What is the best way to mitigate arising issues in adjacent private spaces?
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
29 answers
I am interested in any new studies that detail on how urban form interacts with the way in which users of public spaces engage in activities and, particularly, the profile of these users and how the activities were categorized. I have read the "classics" on this and was wondering whether any new research has been performed on this, either from an urban planning or environmental psychology perspective. Thank you for any ideas.
Relevant answer
Answer
You can look at the recent dissertation by Xiaolu Zhou (2014), from the University of Illinois, who looked at how urban form was related to modes of active transportation. If you can't find it easily, email me off line and I'll send a copy to you (wcsulliv@illinois.edu). Xiaolu is now an Assistant Professor of Geography at the University of Southern Georgia.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
3 answers
I am focusing on the context of Hong Kong. In cramped living environment, social space hard to be obtained in private living area, so people need to find "compensation" for social space in semi-public or public, but in those areas, privacy would be hard to control by the users, and it would affect the social quality. So is there any existing architectural solution? example from other countries?
Relevant answer
Answer
Often cramped and privacy actually go together because they simply have to. I have encountered activites that aimed at solve problems of that kind, however not that many architectural solutions. I would look for Japanese experinces in the field.I look forward to what you come up with.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
7 answers
What are the impacts to urban residents?
Relevant answer
Answer
You should look into the work of CY Jim (http://geog.hku.hk/staff_FT_Jim.html). He's a world expert and local to Hong Kong. Check out his publication list (from the webpage above) and I'm certain you'll find relevant papers.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
"Past present and future of public space" is an Italian project. It aims to explore new dimensions of public realm and to discuss results of research activities, through a multidisciplinary approach, on public space and related topics, comparing theories and projects with advisors and correspondents from different contexts.
The international conference will take place in Bologna on June 25/27, 2014.
Deadline for abstract proposals: December 20, 2013.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Usama, sorry but we are not accepting abstract proposals anymore. We received more abstracts than we expected, the topic seems to be very appealing for many scholars, so I guess I will promote something similar (conference, seminar, journal issue) in the future. Thank you for your interest!
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
19 answers
Museums are buildings that are considered boring and dull by a majority of people. So I intend to analyse on why are they perceived to be so dull and what role does colors and textures play there? Furthermore, how usage of different colors and textures can make that place more interesting and gives it a 'Sense of Place'. I would here, like to analyse how young generation is majorly affected by it and what forces would drive the perception of a museum as an interesting place to be.
Relevant answer
Answer
Wikipedia Defines Museum as-
“A museum is an institution that cares for (conserves) a collection of artifacts and other objects of scientific, artistic, cultural, or historical importance and makes them available for public viewing through exhibits that may be permanent or temporary”.
The definition totally indicates that the museum always serves as an open classroom, providing the ideal environment for children’s, Youngsters and Senior citizens also to see, touch, and experience the ‘Art’. As children grow, so will the Museum grow and continue to progress for generations to come.
It means that, we can hope that coming centuries, Museum’s will definitely serve as a new “Learning Center” for the community, where people can freely contribute in education, creation, entertainment, and communication. Besides the texture and color affections on the users or viewers behavior in a museum building can be taken in consideration as a part of Management or representation of an art, and definitely has a crucial role in attracting the viewers to watch it.
Finally, through its supportive commitment with community the Museum will attempt to explore and generate completely new activities as an art museum in future.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
7 answers
As we are all aware, wayfinding process is derived from a sequence of decision making. One's desired destination is processed in relation to the spatial factors and environment present within a space. The aim of of this question is to understand how effectively the wayfinding & orientation is performed.
Relevant answer
Answer
Suppose you are a mother planning your shopping trip and you have diferent places to stop between leaving clothes in the laundry, buying groceries, lunch, picking your 2 years old son in the nursery, etc.? the way you plan your trip is specificly related to parking facilities, the volumes you hare carring, the fresh products you are buying, the time you have to pick the child, etc. so in the same journey you have very clear destinations (nursery and laundry), less specific ( supermarket) and even less (lunch).
Another aspect that we haven't talked so far is the narrative function of wayfinding systems. The functional side is a "emotionally cold" piece of information based on easy reading, culturally neutral and universally comprensible... other systems, even besides interaction, can adapt to your needs, add value to your trip by giving you relevant information... that type of systems is being tried in turist locations but can be used anywhere...
Yes, I think we have a more or less desired destination depending on the rational/pleasure and free time trip we are doing but even in those cases we allow ourselves some moments free of constraints to explore. We need that variety even in the simples of the journeys.
regards Niven
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
There are unlimited spatial provisions in public buildings. Each of them are different in size, shape, colour, aesthetics etc. There are also shopping outlets, public furniture, bins, plants, art, etc. that have been allocated spaces when designing public buildings. My aim is to understand how the user's react to these spatial factors.
Relevant answer
Thanks Sherine, these link were very useful and helped a lot to more understand about mall and its development.
My research question investigates about how we react to the spatial factors within a mall!!! It will explain the behaviour of shoppers in relation to the variation of these spaces within an enclosed public building..
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
4 answers
Any calculating method or standard? According to the density of population or size of urban area?
Relevant answer
Answer
By parkland, do you mean green-spaces for active and passive recreation? If you do, this is a tricky matter. Most cities rely on some measure of green area per resident, or per 1,000 residents. Peter Harnik from the US non-profit - Trust for Public Land has done some work reviewing the level of green-space provision in cities in the USA. Most cities around the world have some form of enshrined standard in their planning ordinances, codes or supporting legislation. These standards typically have two forms: (i) an amount measure (ii) a proximity or accessibility measure. For example, 20 hectares of parkland per 1,000 residents and all residents will be able to access a park within 400 metres of their house. Seldom have these standards been met - usually for reasons associated with the historical provision of parkland, the function of urban land markets, histories of ethno-racial oppression and the decisions of local councils about what land, how much and where will be accepted for parks - oftentimes motivated by financial and maintenance concerns. You can access my review of the literature here: http://www98.griffith.edu.au/dspace/bitstream/handle/10072/34502/62968_1.pdf?sequence=1
You can also see my paper in Progress in Human Geography that talks about the environmental justice and political ecology perspectives of green-space provision: http://phg.sagepub.com/content/33/6/743.abstractules and a paper I wrote for practitioners in CITYgreen: https://www.academia.edu/3130290/Greenspace_planning_problems_with_standards_lessons_from_research_and_best_practices
More recently, the public health literature has led a challenge to standards, pointing to the fact that distance measures of proximity are quite arbitrary, and do not reflect barriers that are real or perceived. Moreover, people perceive distances differently to actual distances. And the distance that most people are prepared to walk to a park has declines markedly over the past 3 - 4 decades, as overweight and obesity have increased. Finally, park standards seldom recognise the need for diverse facilities in parks, the need for park programming and park activities, and rarely account for changing recreation needs as the socio-demographic composition of populations change.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
3 answers
If so, which factors have caused the change?
Relevant answer
Answer
I believe television and video games have changed the landscape significantly over the last two decades. Children are making the switch from actual playgrounds to virtual playgrounds. The fact that schools seem intent on testing children as early as kindergarten has fueled the removal of play from the school day of most children. (We can't count physical education class as play because such organized activities don't generate the same level of creativity as child's play.) I believe we are beginning to see the consequences in increases in obesity and type II diabetes in children, also with a decrease in creativity and critical thinking skills.
  • asked a question related to Public Space
Question
6 answers
For a contrast study between Europe and USA 1960-2012...Thank you!
Relevant answer
Answer
Bo-sin Tang, and Siu-wai Wong, (2008) A longitudinal study of open space zoning and development in Hong Kong. Landscape and Urban Planning. 87, 258-268.