Science topic

Public Policy Analysis - Science topic

Explore the latest questions and answers in Public Policy Analysis, and find Public Policy Analysis experts.
Questions related to Public Policy Analysis
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
5 answers
In your opinion, how should a realistically pro-social, pro-family and pro-development socio-economic policy be conducted, i.e. that it is a realistically pro-social, pro-family and pro-development socio-economic policy and not a populist pseudo-economic policy, designed and constructed in such a way that it mainly helps to win successive parliamentary elections for the political party that introduced and implements this policy?
In the country where I operate in terms of socio-economic policy, the PIS government in 2016 introduced the Family 500 Plus programme, i.e. a social programme of financial support for raising children provided to parents or other legal guardians of the children being raised. Similar social programmes of financial support for the upbringing of children operate in highly developed countries in Europe. Thanks to the election promises, which also included the announcement of the introduction of this programme, the PIS party won the parliamentary elections in 2015 and then later also the next parliamentary elections in 2019. I researched this issue at the time and in the articles published at the time I pointed out the key issues that should be taken into account by the government in the introduction of this Family 500 Plus programme so that it is a key element of a real pro-social, pro-family and pro-development social and economic policy and not a populist pseudo-economic policy, including that the key strategic objectives should be achieved. Well, the key strategic objective of the introduction of this programme of social financial support for families bringing up children was to reduce the scale and slow down the progressive change in the demographic structure of society consisting in the successive and exceptionally rapid ageing of the population since the beginning of the 21st century. The effect of this programme was to be a significant increase in the fertility rate.
Unfortunately, this strategic goal has not been realised. In 2021-2022, the birth rate in Poland was the lowest since the end of the mid-20th century. Unfortunately, the Family 500 Plus programme was not implemented reliably, the government did not take into account the results of research conducted by independent economists in designing this programme and in its implementation. What I wrote about several years ago in the aforementioned articles was ignored. Unfortunately, instead of improving this programme, correcting the mistakes made, in May 2023, the government announced the continuation of this programme in the following years without any amendments, but with an increase in the amount paid per child per month from the existing and functioning for 7 years of the same amount of PLN 500 to PLN 800 from January 2024. On the other hand, the next parliamentary elections are to be held in October 2023, which the ruling PIS party is also planning to join. Therefore, in the opinion of citizens, it is obvious that this Family 500 Plus programme has become a programme of mainly populist pseudo-economic policy.
In view of the above, I would like to address the following question to the esteemed community of scientists and researchers:
How, in your opinion, should a realistically pro-social, pro-family and pro-development socio-economic policy be conducted, i.e. that it is a realistically pro-social, pro-family and pro-development socio-economic policy and not a populist pseudo-economic policy, designed and constructed in such a way that it mainly helps to win successive parliamentary elections for the political party that introduced and implements this policy?
How should a real pro-social, pro-family and pro-development socio-economic policy be conducted?
What is your opinion on this issue?
What is your opinion on this subject?
Please respond,
I invite you all to discuss,
Thank you very much,
I will write more on this subject in my book, which I am currently writing. In this monograph, I will include the results of my ongoing research on this issue. I invite you to join me in scientific cooperation on this issue.
Counting on your opinions, on getting to know your personal opinion, on an honest approach to discussions in scientific problems, and not on ready-made answers generated in ChatGPT, I deliberately used the phrase "in your opinion" in the question.
The above text is entirely my own work written by me on the basis of my research.
I have not used other sources or automatic text generation systems such as ChatGPT in writing this text.
Copyright by Dariusz Prokopowicz
Best wishes,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
Relevant answer
Considero que lamentablemente la distribución de la riqueza de un país no son bien dirigidas y esto genera todo tipo de conflictos no solo es educar si no hacer que el pueblo sienta que el Estado piensa y genera acciones importantes para el pueblo ya que se ve tantas cosas que no hacen bien a la sociedad mucha desigualdad social muchos prejuicios sociales y discriminación en todo nivel
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
3 answers
The aim is to establish the relationships between DSS and the decision process, especially related to public policy analysis.
Relevant answer
Answer
Improves efficiency and speed of decision-making activities.
Increases the control, competitiveness and capability of futuristic decision-making of the organization.
Facilitates interpersonal communication.
Encourages learning or training.
Since it is mostly used in non-programmed decisions, it reveals new approaches and sets up new evidences for an unusual decision.
Helps automate managerial processes.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
23 answers
In the situation whereby formulated policy is implemented without general acceptability by the citizens, what will be the outcome of such policy?
Relevant answer
Answer
A responsible government will prioritize citizens' inclusiveness in policy formulation and implementation.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
2 answers
Ongoing peer reviewed scientific research at the US state and federal levels has shown that US tobacco policy has never been punctuated as has been claimed in public policy-oriented punctuated equilibrium theory. Falsifiability is a key feature of scientific research including the testing of scientific current theories. When a current scientific theory is found to be false in whole or part, the proper protocol is to update the scientific theory or even replace it with a new scientific theory (subject to scientific testing). Has this happened in the case of punctuated equilibrium theory related to tobacco policy research and why or why not?
Relevant answer
Answer
Given that who benefits from a subsystem have an interest in maintaining a certain status quo, these systems of limited participation are considered to be highly resistant to change (Cobb & Elder, 1983).
But yes the significance of punctuation is an United States Supreme Court case in the development of American administrative law: FDA v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp in 2000. The Court ruled that the Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act did not give the Food and Drug Administration the authority to regulate tobacco products as "DRUGS".
Regulation of tobacco by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration began in 2009 with the passage of the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act by the United States Congress. With this statute, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) was given the ability to regulate tobacco products.
Sheer label of DRUGS is apparent choice of the buyer and an illustration of punctuation.
Still one perspective of the American Tobacco Industry. A Big Tobacco firm operating across 180 populations, with Net Annual revenues of roughly $8.056 trillion and spending no less than $8.2 billion on advertising is in violation of Section 307 of the US Tariff Act of 1930 ; when leaf cultivation in the exporting country occupies a tremendously vulnerable age group between 6 and 18. A factual deprivation and unfair practice cloaked in cultural distortions that ultimately perpetuate poverty—compels for the abolition of child labour across NTA tobacco contract farming as a structural reform, beginning with PMI.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
3 answers
Is it possible to use the Synthetic Control Method in the firm-level study?
Currently, I am trying to measure the impact of environmental regulation (state-level emission trading scheme) on a firm's green innovation. I have used DID and PSM-DID but want to use SCM with firm-level data, is it applicable? I found most of the paper used state-level data. Expecting your kind opinion in this regard.
Relevant answer
Answer
In principle, you could use it. The reason for the application you mentions has to do with the number of treated units. The SCM can reach situations where the rest of the methods are not adequate (e.g., a single treated unit). This is often the case of state-level policies vs firm-level events (we usually have many observations and treated units in the latter case).
You can have a look at Cunningham's Causal inferente: the mitxtape (https://mixtape.scunning.com/), which can be of some help here.
All the best,
José-Ignacio
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
8 answers
I am just starting to look into what semiotics means to policy studies including electronic/digital government, in terms of its policy, plans, and performance. But the semiotic world is so vast, I need a good advice to enjoy such "brave new world" for me. Please get me informed of any semiotic approach to measuring electronic (digital or any adjective) government (policy or program) performance. Thanks in advance. Younghoon
Relevant answer
Answer
Semiotics is a social or community phenomenon and culture is a sign of a relationship between the government and the community in measuring the performance of local government, it can be approached in the form of text documents or works or regulations that are meaningful for a common goal.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
7 answers
Just getting a gauge from various sides of the community regarding which statistical analysis method is underrated.
Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
Cluster analysis.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
71 answers
In highly developed countries and economically fast developing countries there are analogous processes of changes in the demographic structure of society consisting in the aging of the population and the accompanying process of depopulation of cities, agglomeration, decreasing number of births, decreasing fertility rate in families. These processes, which are unfavorable for the economic development of the country, usually have at least several causes.
Extending the average life expectancy of citizens results from improved living standards, increased income and related improvements in quality of life, improvement of nutrition and improvement in the health care services sector. In addition, some of the lowly, educated people go to look for more interesting jobs and higher salaries by hiring in other countries. In a situation where young people paying off housing loans, are also burdened with various taxes, they are forced to work, to professional activity all adult members of the family of working age.
As a result, the pressure, the need to have more than 1 or 2 children are decreasing, and then the fertility decreases, which contributes to the decline in the number of citizens in the long term. In order to counteract this disadvantage for the national economy, this country should develop social policy to support young people, including subsidizing the purchase or rental of housing, establishing guaranteed income related to raising children, developing programs supporting the nursery, pre-school and education, pediatric health care system, etc.
Examples of such programs of active socio-economic policy are: Family 500 Plus Program and Flat Plus Program (Mieszkanie Plus Program). Because these programs have been developed only for 3 years, so you can not objectively assert how they affect the demographic structure of society, or motivate you to make decisions about having a larger number of children. In order to be able to answer this type of questions objectively, ie with regard to relevant scientific data, these Programs should be conducted with a minimum of 2-3 subsequent generations of citizens.
On the other hand, there has already been a noticeable increase in consumption for various types of goods purchased by citizens, which has a pro-development effect on the economy as it increases the level of economic growth. It may be one of the key elements of the socio-economic policy of anti-crisis, countercyclical importance, ie increasing the resilience of the domestic economy to global economic crises and the slowdown in global economy growth, e.g. the currently observed slowdown in global economy caused by the so-called war wars and other restrictions on the development of international trade.
In the context of the above issues, I am asking you the following question:
How can changes in the demographic structure of society affect the economic development of the country?
Please reply
I invite you to the discussion
Thank you very much
Best wishes
Relevant answer
Answer
The
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
5 answers
Problem description:
In socio technical systems an idea of technological initiative can emerge and different groups can be organizing around it. Each groups little by litle are organizing sponaneously based on common interest, shared values including ethics, around of an idea of progress and potential benefits that sometimes is vague.
Sometimes those groups start to interact each other and at certain point of development a macro context start to be needed in order to reach the necessities of the society.
Lately despite of the potential social benefits of the new technological initiative, the political body do not create the institutional conditions for the development of a new regulation and public policy (this is what I call the macrosystem). So the socio-technological initiative do not thrive.
Some of the hypothesis about why this issue is happening are:
1) Politicians do not take care or interest of the posibilities of the new technology and initiative.
2) Politicians sees the new technology as a loss of self power threat.
3) Politicians want to take control of the different technical groups resources and assets but not the values and real purpose, because they want to have more power for themselves.
4)...
In consecuence the work done by different technical groups will never be enough organized and coordinated as well as is required by a common purpose that reach societal necesities.
What I want to do is describe the problem in terms of the interaction of technological working groups (the system) and the political and policy level (the macrosystem)
Do yo know if there are a systemic theoretical framework that can help me to analyse and describe this problem and dynamic?
Relevant answer
Answer
It is recommended to follow one quite useful part of complex systems modelling methodology: agent based modelling. There might be different types of agents, some in a few copies like politicians, other in larger numbers like society cliques. There might be defined engagement rules among different types of agents.
Dirk Helping is definitely having research on societal interactions. The seminal book on agent based modelling is by Illachinski: Artificial War. There is explained how to program agents to achieve their desired behavior.
Entropy measures can be used to classify the mode of behavior of the system. Each system undergoing a phase transition express it in changes of entropy even when globally there is nothing substantial to observe!
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
102 answers
In my opinion, the improvement of pro-development instruments of socio-economic policy is particularly important in a situation of a downturn in the economy.
Currently, this issue is particularly important in connection with the forecasted decline in the rate of economic growth in 2019.
In the context of the above issues, the following question is valid:
What pro-development instruments of socio-economic policy carried out according to the concept of Keynesian economics are currently the most effective in the area of economic growth as measured by, for example, the Gross Domestic Product index?
I invite you to the discussion
Dear Friends and Colleagues of RG
The issues of specific programs to improve the economic, financial, material and housing situation of households as key instruments of pro-development state intervention and significant components of the socio-economic policy of the state I described in the publications:
I invite you to discussion and cooperation.
Best wishes
Relevant answer
Answer
Multiplier impact: consumption
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
38 answers
How can the effectiveness of the environmental policy of the state be increased in order to achieve sustainable ecological development based on the concept of green economy in the shortest possible time?
Please reply
I pointed out the high level of relevance of the issue taken up in the above question in the article:
Please respond with what do you think about the issues described in this article?
Best wishes
Dariusz Prokopowicz
Relevant answer
Answer
today 18 March is World Recycling Day.
World Recycling Day was established in 2018 by the Global Recycling Foundation.
The anniversary of 18 March celebrates the importance of recycling and at the same time aims to raise awareness of citizens and institutions in protecting the environment. The correct differentiation of waste makes them come back to life, with the mission of safeguarding our Earth.
An anniversary, therefore, dedicated to celebrating the importance of correct waste separation in order to create a circular economy that enhances resources and protects the future of the planet. A green goal strongly reaffirmed also by the constraint placed by the European Union in the Next Generation EU. In fact, a large portion of the post-Covid-19 funds to be distributed to individual states is bound to policies and economic choices aimed at the ecological transition, at a strongly and truly sustainable change.
For more details, please see at: https://www.globalrecyclingfoundation.org/
My best regards, Pierluigi Traverso.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
248 answers
In modern economies, various instruments of budgetary and fiscal policy are used, supporting the activities of business entities, and also instruments of socio-economic policy, including housing, etc., aimed at activating economic processes.
In view of the above, does Keynesian state interventionism mainly activate growth or economic development?
Please reply
Dear Friends and Colleagues of RG
The issues of specific programs to improve the economic, financial, material and housing situation of households as key instruments of pro-development state intervention and significant components of the socio-economic policy of the state I described in the publications:
I invite you to discussion and cooperation.
In 2020, there was an economic crisis caused by the SARS-CoV-2 (Covid-19) coronavirus pandemic and lockdowns imposed on various service industries. In order to mitigate the negative, recessionary effects of the pandemic, the so-called economic programs were used. Anti-crisis shields consisting in the applied large-scale public financial aid to commercial business entities. The issue of activating entrepreneurship as an important element of the anti-crisis socio-economic policy applied during the economic crisis caused by the SARS-CoV-2 (Covid-19) coronavirus pandemic in 2020 was described in my article published at the end of December 2021. I am providing a link to this article:
I invite all those who study this subject to research cooperation.
I invite everyone to the discussion,
Thank you very much,
Best regards,
Dariusz
Relevant answer
Answer
Growth as it aims to impact Aggregate Demand
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
5 answers
Has any of you studied the economic and financial situation, including the material and housing situation of households against the background of a specific socio-economic policy of the state?
If so, please comment on the results of the research or link to the publication in which the results of the research have been published.
What interventionist, pro-development instruments should be applied within the socio-economic policy of the state in order to improve the economic and financial standing of households?
Please reply
Relevant answer
Answer
Much has changed in the economy over the past few months due to the SARS-CoV-2 (Covid-19) coronavirus pandemic. Construction industry companies received financial public aid. Therefore, the construction investments started in previous years could be completed in 2020. Consequently, the construction sector was one of those sectors where many jobs were saved despite the economic crisis.
Regards,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
18 answers
What instruments of state intervention are applied in your country as part of a pro-development, anti-crisis, counter-cyclical, Keynesian socio-economic policy and pro-social housing policy?
In some developing countries, pro-development, anti-crisis, countercyclical, Keynesian socio-economic policies and pro-social housing policies are currently underway, which are a significant determinant of high economic growth and provide citizens with material and economic well-being. In individual countries, analogical instruments of state intervention are usually used as part of pro-development, anti-crisis, counter-cyclical, Keynesian socio-economic policy and pro-social housing policy.
The applied state intervention instruments also contribute to the activation of innovation and entrepreneurship, reduction of unemployment, investment growth, income and consumption. In individual countries, analogical instruments of state intervention are usually used, including selected instruments of fiscal, budgetary and monetary policy, however, in a different structure of the use of individual instruments and a different share of their financing from the public finances of the state.
In view of the above, I am asking you the following question:
What instruments of state intervention are applied in your country as part of a pro-development, anti-crisis, counter-cyclical, Keynesian socio-economic policy and pro-social housing policy?
Please reply
I invite you to discussion and scientific cooperation
Dear Friends and Colleagues of RG
The issues of specific programs to improve the economic, financial, material and housing situation of households as key instruments of pro-development state intervention and significant components of the socio-economic policy of the state I described in the publications:
I invite you to discussion and cooperation.
Best wishes
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you for the kind words and the positive recommendation of the topic taken on the RG discussion forum. You have added to our discussion important issues and examples of activating investments as part of pro-development socio-economic policy implemented in Ethiopia. The examples given by you perfectly match the issues of anti-crisis and pro-development programs of motivating the private sector to investments through specific financial instruments of the public sector discussed in this discussion.
Have a nice day, Stay healthy! Best wishes,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
3 answers
International Financial flows are the major instruments to bridge the gap between revenue and expenditure. Since the LDCs have lower capacity for capital mobilization, the Foreign Aid and foreign public investment are the some of the major sources of financing the development projects. But the questions arises, how much are they effective for domestic resources mobilization and their contribution in the economic development of particular country?
Relevant answer
Answer
It's an interesting question, Nabaraj, probably already treated exhaustively on RG - probably!! But the point is this: Such LDCs need to shun public sector corruption. Some of the funds accruing from the previous attempts to attract international finance into the putatively needy countries, were easily siphoned back to the sources of the funds for safekeeping by sleazy public sector operators. Who is deceiving who? Indeed, such international funding, can only meaningfully be channeled through private sector (overt business) collaboration.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
6 answers
Distinguished colleagues,
I need your professional opinion for my ongoing research. If possible, please elaborate your opinion in detail. Any input, supporting materials or comments will be highly appreciated!
Thank you in advance!
Best regards,
Dr. Vardan Atoyan
Relevant answer
Answer
To stop vast emigration from Your country in general, and to stop vast emigration of intellectuals too. Of course, this refers only to those countries, which suffer from vast brain emigration (as many developing countries and such countries as Lithuania and Latvia in the Baltics).
But it is easy to recommend, difficult to implement.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
17 answers
Do you think that the Family 500 Plus and Mieszkanie Plus programs as key social and host policy programs significantly increase the country's GDP?
Do you think that these programs are mainly social or investment in the context of long-term, prospective socio-economic policy?
Will these programs, after their many years of application, contribute to a significant increase in fertility and thus slow down the unfavorable economically progressive change in the demographic structure of society identified as aging (and thus reduce the risk of a strong deficit in the finances of the participatory pension system serviced in the future by Social Security?)?
How many years in the future do you think these programs should still be run under an active socio-economic policy so that you can fully objectively diagnose their real effectiveness in terms of slowing down, stopping the aging process and assessing the scale of investment functions of these programs in macroeconomic terms?
Do you conduct scientific research in this field? If so, I invite you to cooperation.
Please reply
I invite you to the discussion
Thank you very much
Best wishes
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
19 answers
Distinguished colleagues,
I need your professional opinion for my ongoing research.
Thank you in advance!
Warm regards,
Dr. Vardan Atoyan
Relevant answer
Answer
Work-based policy should be implemented in universities where students gain marks through internship say 60% and 40% written exam which include theory, presentation and research.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
3 answers
Tax reform is a crucial step in mobilizing revenue in developing countries. However, it is not a easy agenda to be implemented because of political and social challenges.
Relevant answer
Answer
The topic is a complex one and related to the political economy rather than state finance or macroeconomics. Relying on the developing or underdeveloped countries' experience, I would recall the "domestic political will" as a key determinant to the success of tax reforms. I clearly remember a quote from the president of Georgia, Mikheil Saakashvili: "the most difficult thing to do was to force the citizens to pay the taxes". Tax is a concept that is usually associated with political and institutional endowments of a country. The rulers of the country might not be interested in the collection of taxes for several reasons: maybe they made a deal with certain shadow interest groups that are involved in big "games"; maybe there is a huge revenue stream into the country and nobody is interested in the alternative revenue sources, simply their marginal utility is low. The measurement of the success of tax reforms is simple. If the tax revenues of the state budget are increasing and the government expenditures towards the social needs are in an increasing trend, then we might have an initial stepping stone to argue about the certain measurement of it.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
12 answers
Distinguished colleagues,
I need your professional opinion for my ongoing research. Please briefly state your opinion on this issue.
Thank you in advance!
Warm regards,
Dr. Vardan Atoyan
Relevant answer
Vardan Atoyan, Welcome.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
22 answers
How is the pro-development Keynesian and anti-crisis socio-economic policy carried out with what state intervention instruments in your country?
Please reply
Dear Friends and Colleagues of RG
The issues of specific programs to improve the economic, financial, material and housing situation of households as key instruments of pro-development state intervention and significant components of the socio-economic policy of the state I described in the publications:
I invite you to discussion and cooperation.
Best wishes
Relevant answer
Answer
Investment in Education in Switzerland.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
6 answers
Distinguished colleagues,
I need your professional opinion for my ongoing research. Any input, support, materials or comments will be highly appreciated!
Thank you in advance!
Regards,
Dr. Vardan Atoyan
Relevant answer
Answer
I think some of the key issues are
- availability of big data
- availability of analytic tools that allow data to be used
- ability of think tanks to work virtually with web conferencing world wide and for workers to work remotely
- use of digital platforms to collect stakeholder and public views including public participation in creating and testing solutions
- connected to this greater ability to use international as well as national learning
- increased competition in the space occupied by think tanks means brand value and quality/perceived quality of the agency will be critical to ensuring stakeholders listen
- distrust of experts
- need for visible leadership that is tech savvy but also credible
- need to tailor messaging precisely to the target audience and deliver in the correct medium
- need for leaders at various levels in think tanks that are credible with different audiences and adept with digital and analogue channels
- ability to deliver quick, timely, analysis to meet stakeholder needs
- ability to work in partnership and share platforms with other credible stakeholders
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
5 answers
What do you think about European Social Model? Is it a good way to describe social policy in Europe? Is it really a policy goal or only an idea?
Do you know any articles about it?
Relevant answer
Answer
Am in line with Arvydas Guogis
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
5 answers
 I am trying to find out how technological change associated with  implantation of new idea has  been explained 
Relevant answer
Answer
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
7 answers
In the context of developing countries, mainly in subsaharian Africa, a large number of the population do not have access some products because of their lack of financial means because they are poor! They can not afford to buy food in a supermarket because the price is high! I can see them as non-consumer according to Clayton Christensen's definition of disruptive innovation. Do you have about other publication that show the relationship between poverty and innovation? High-end market and low-end market...
French version
Dans le contexte des pays en développement, la plupart des personnes ne peuvent pas accéder à certains produits faute de moyens financiers parce qu'elles sont pauvres ! Cette situation me semble correspodre aux caractéristiques de la définition des innovations de rupture selon clayton Christensen. Avez vous des références à partager
Relevant answer
Great question. I wonder if we should't reframe it slightly. Isn't poverty dependent at least in part on property rights and on access to the equity in those rights to fund application of mere ideas into funded (financed) innovation? Disruptive innovation a la Clayton Christensen may actually assume the presence surrounding it of a system of financing that makes the ideas have access to investors seeking to maximize their future earnings. Is the same system available or present surrounding innovation in Africa? Furthermore, is it feasible that the finance through Venture Capital system available in the West may actually hold innovators hostage to their dependence upon having to fund their idea inside that system? In contrast, could it rather be that in Africa a different system altogether may emerge or has already been emerging, one that is verified in innovation and inventions across humankind's history already? If we take solely the Selden v Ford patent infringement case which ultimately Henry Ford won (for an analysis from an IP law perspective see here ), did poverty impact Ford's invention abilities at all? What did Ford do to start his Ford Motor Company, attempting to convince banks to give him loans several times and failing? He tried to finance his vision building an enterprise based on bank loans that were initially refused. The system is based on the funding of applied ideas by financial asset holders with the goal of maximizing reproduction of invested capital. We are trying to point to the many failures in the West. Understanding those thoroughly may help answer little by little the Africa question by inductive and deductive reasoning combined. A great start by far predating a Clayton Christensen framework of innovation is in a great classic article here
and subsequent improvements and on Grieco's timeless piece. My immediate take is that local capital formation in Africa shall fuel innovation there much better than the dependency trap fueled by continued purchasing there of Western products and services. In support of my argument I use anecdotal evidence on the disruptive patent on cone over cone continuous variable transmission for automobiles (1923, by Aurel Persu) and how the West was interested to buy the patent to simply kill its use. That in effect led to the technology not being developed commercially and fully implemented for several decades. Thus I'm willing to bet that poverty is _not_ an independent variable in the original question. It may be a dependent variable after all, based essentially on a willingness to maintain dependency by those benefitting from it from outside Africa. I'm interested to see where this question is going further.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
5 answers
I am looking for studies or papers that have combined the ACF with critical realism or who have realigned the ACF so that it fits critical realism (or at least tried to do so).
Relevant answer
Answer
I don't know if it could fit your question, but an alternative approach to ACF is the discourse coalitions framework (refer to the work of Martin Hajer and following development). This framework surely follows a critical approach, whereas in concerned with power and hegemonic practices, but it rely on a constructivistic, rather than realistic, ontology.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
41 answers
In some countries a minimum guaranteed income for citizens is introduced. In individual countries, various arguments are given for such a socio-economic policy. I described the key arguments in favor of introducing the Family 500 Plus Program in Poland, which is a kind of social policy instrument of this kind.
Do you agree with me on the above matter?
In the context of the above issues, I am asking you the following question:
How would you rate the introduction of minimum income as part of the socio-economic policy of the state?
Please reply
I invite you to the discussion
Thank you very much
Best wishes
Relevant answer
Answer
I personally do not like distinctions between deserving and undeserving poor as they try to suggest that poverty is self selected. I think that poverty has structural causes and not everybody who wish to work is able to find employment. In the USA there is also the phenomena of the working poor, meaning that at times an income does not take people out of poverty. Not sure, if it is correct, but I heard of cases where people need at least two jobs to escape poverty. Maybe those who are more familiar to conditions in the USA can contribute....
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
14 answers
Post-Keynesian economics is the basis of the current anti-cyclical, anti-crisis, pro-development socio-economic policies. I described these issues in my publications below.
In the context of the slowdown in global economic growth forecasted in 2019, the following key question appears:
What kind of instruments of interventionist, Keynesian, anti-crisis, pro-development socio-economic policy should be used in the period of slowdown in the country's economic growth?
More and more macroeconomic analyzes indicate that in 2019 a slowdown in economic growth will appear in many countries. In order to limit the scale of the decline in growth or absolute economic decline, the governments of individual countries try to activate economic processes and consumption using various instruments of socio-economic policy.
In my opinion, the improvement of pro-development instruments of socio-economic policy is particularly important in a situation of a downturn in the economy.
Currently, this issue is particularly important in connection with the forecasted decline in the rate of economic growth in 2019.
In my opinion, post-Keynesianism has been used in practice many times in countries when leaving deep economic crises. Until now, post-Keynesianism has been used to a large extent in many countries to restore the entire national financial systems and, indirectly, entire economies and to save the selected major manufacturing enterprises and financial institutions from the bankruptcy of the global financial crisis in autumn 2008.
The economy was restored to balance at the expense of increasing budget deficits in national public finances. New formulas of post-keyism were applied under state intervention. Paradoxically, the potential consequences of the potential deepening of the global financial and economic crisis in the event that this state intervention is not applied are unknown.
Probably the crisis would be much deeper, more socially costly and would last much longer. this type of assumption determines that post-Keynesian instruments of state intervention are used almost without restrictions, ie according to the proverb: "the end justifies the means". In this assumption, theoretical foundations become a secondary element, added according to anti-crisis, anti-cyclical interventionist, and active economic policy. I conducted research and wrote scientific publications on this topic.
Do you agree with my opinion on this matter?
In connection with the above, I am asking you:
- What anti-crisis instruments of Keynesian state intervention in the framework of an active socio-economic policy are applied in your country in order to limit the scale of the forecasted slowdown in economic growth in 2019?
- What kind of instruments of interventionist, Keynesian, anti-crisis, pro-development socio-economic policy should be used in the period of slowdown in the country's economic growth?
- Does government co-financed by the state budget, national housing development programs as part of housing policy, be an important element of anti-crisis, pro-development socio-economic policy as an effective instrument for reviving economic processes and improving the economic slowdown in the global economy?
- Do you know examples of countries where in recent years new concepts of pro-development, anti-crisis, Keynesian socio-economic policy have been implemented and developed, used to improve the country's economic growth, which have been developed and described in scientific publications in recent years?
- What kind of instruments of socio-economic policy have been applied with the positive effects of a significant improvement of the country's economic growth?
- What new concept of pro-development, anti-crisis, Keynesian socio-economic policy has been implemented and why?
- What positive effects on the functioning of the economy have been achieved by using a specific concept of socio-economic policy?
- Is the importance of improving the pro-development and anti-crisis concept, Keynesian socio-economic policy growing due to the predicted decline in the economic growth rate of the global economy in 2019?
In view of the above, I am asking you the following question:
Is the Keynesian and Post-Keynesian economics the basis of the current anti-crisis national socio-economic policies?
Please reply
I invite you to the discussion
Dear Friends and Colleagues of RG
The issues of specific programs to improve the economic, financial, material and housing situation of households as key instruments of pro-development keynesian anti-crisis state intervention and significant components of the socio-economic policy of the state I described in the publications:
I invite you to discussion and cooperation.
Best wishes
Relevant answer
Answer
yes, It is possible but with limitations
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
7 answers
Can value judgments in normative economics generate abuses of unreliable use of economic knowledge for the purposes of designing socio-economic policies?
In my opinion, economics is a neutral science in terms of valuation. In my opinion, it is not only neutral in terms of valuing the processes of host reality described by economic concepts, but should be neutral. One of the areas of economics in which value judgments are allowed is normative economics referring to the assessment of economic processes that will occur in the future or which are planned for implementation in the future. In this respect, economics is a tool for debates, discussions, brainstorming at the academic level but also in the pre-election debates in the world of politics. However, often the economics used for the needs of politicians, in the field of electoral programs, social and economic policy projects are created abuses. Often in such political applications of economic knowledge selectively selectively some theories, concepts from the history of economic thought, selected economic laws, specific dependencies, etc. which perfectly serve to explain the legitimacy of the application of a specific socio-economic policy, but usually do not include the holistically described economic reality, they do not represent all economic knowledge comprehensively.
Please reply
Best wishes
Relevant answer
Answer
If we start from this assumption, that efficiency is desirable is a core value judgment in economics, so, if we can judge that from a point view of gains, than your question will be treated in depth, specialy, in valuating normative economics.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
5 answers
I've been using Ostrom's IAD for a couple of years now to take on local public policies but would like to expand on the tools and perspectives that institutional economy (particularly it's takes on public policy analysis) has to offer on the task of identify and comprehend stakeholders in public policy process in a local level of government.
Relevant answer
Answer
Paulo Krischke thanks for the recommendation. I'll look it up.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
2 answers
Hello, any ideas about topics for PhD in enterprise risk management preferably linking it with public policy? I am however open to suggestions on the topic not relating to public policy.
Relevant answer
Answer
I don't hear about that type of PhD
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
4 answers
how to calculate tax rate for overall economy if the tax rates for different heads are not available ?? i have found 2 measures in literarures (1) tax revenue to gdp ratio as avarage tax rate (see Taner Turan et al. 2014, Jayawickrama and Abeysinghe 2013) (2) Empirical works of Rudi Kurniawan (2011), Mesut KARAKAS (2014) etc estimated overall tax rate as central govt tax revenue divided by GDP. Which tax rate is representative one for whole economy? And Why ?? What is the logic to said it as tax rate in Public finance ??
Relevant answer
Answer
Marcos Cintra Cavalcanti de Albuquerque thanks you sir for your reply. the total revenue your are talking about, is it the total revenue of the central government or only total tax revenue ?
i have gone through various literature but the concrete definition and theoretical justification for measuring gross effective tax rate is not found. Any suggestions and literature is highly appreciable.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
17 answers
I have gone through some literature that focuses more on privatization failure and failure to privatize but I haven’t found much literature/case studies where privatization process went well (relatively smoothly, without substantive failure and/or reversal) and, privatization goals and objectives are accomplished. I am also curious to know if there are any specific criteria to evaluate privatization success or failure.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Fred
If you need more references please le me know. i could also try and retrieve my Leeds University lecture PPTs which I used for teaching a Leeds
Best wishes
Colin Barnes
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
14 answers
Enhanced Visitation Programmes for Children and their incarcerated parents in correctional facilities
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree that visitation is a key privilege within the correctional setting. The opportunity of visitation between parents and children, if properly vented (ensuring the parent/child relationship is positive for both) is beneficial.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
10 answers
I am trying to review and analyse few public policies in migration studies. What could be the approaches or methods that help to go through and analyse policies effectively and efficiently. I would love to hear from you public policy analysis approaches and frameworks.
Thank you!
Relevant answer
Answer
You can also use USE THIS approach . I am attaching a document for your reference.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
6 answers
I am currently doing research to analyze environmental challenges and opportunities regarding participatory governance in small-scale democracies. Success stories are usually found in larger states. Does anyone have any case studies or articles on citizen participation in SIDS maybe? 
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Solange
You may like to study the model of participatory governance from CostaRica in Central American region. I guess in all parameters of UNDP on sustainability , Human Development and environmental governance, it has outsmarted many of the big democracies.Their Payment for Environmental Services Programme (PESP) is worth replicating as a public policy on environmental governance based on people's participation.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
11 answers
In my book, titled: "Public Participation as a Tool for Integrating Local Knowledge into Spatial Planning" (Springer, 2017), I claimed that alongside goals - such as encouragement of democratic jurisdictional governance, enhancement of trust among participants and facilitators, strengthening civil society and social justice - the initial practical goals of public participation are the exposure of residents' local knowledge (e.g., spatial perspectives, perceptions, needs, reservations, opinions and desires) and the incorporation of that knowledge into the planning and decision making processes. In my book I indicated that the later practical goals fit together with and constitutes a key condition for the achievement of the former inventory of goals. What do you think ?
Relevant answer
Answer
Public participation , has its own intrinsic merit , in planning process and for a vibrant democracy. It has a value in engaging the actual stakeholders. But , it shouldn't be romanticized too much. While, the people at the grassroots should be consulted to get their inputs, their concerns and priorities, it should be actually factored in the planning and budgeting process.It shouldn't be mere tokenism. Or else, people will lose their faith in the planning process. I guess local self-governing units have important roles to play and there should be healthy dialogue between the votaries of bottom-up and top-down approaches.Ultimately, there should be continuous engagement in this dialogue so that the feedback loop remains open to correct the deviations and distortions.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
10 answers
How might knowledge sharing—across and within international organizations, governments, government agencies, the private sector, civil society organizations, and other development practitioners—be advanced to create synergies toward the Sustainable Development Goals? Specifically: What are the needs for knowledge partnerships? What strategies should they adopt to meet needs? What issues and challenges can one foresee and how might they be overcome?
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you Dr Shapira for your kind response. I deeply value your insight from your works in the field. I will buy the book authored by you -"Mismanagement, "Jumpers"and morality :Covertly " from Amazon. It is certainly insightful as you have shown from your work at Kibbutz in Israel.
Our so-called experts don't know when to say "No, I don't know ". This arrogance of power is one of the bane in effective partnership .
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
3 answers
I am currently investigating the development of water management that a operating authority make in a natural spring to provide water service in a congregation.
I want to compare what they should do (according to the legal and normative framework) vs what they actually do.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello,
I am not sure whether it fits your needs, but this paper is about the Chinese domestic context. The discussion in China has largely revolved around the best practices adopted abroad, particularly in the European Union (EU), where the Water Framework Directive (WFD) has introduced an integrated management model based on the core concept of unity of the water cycle. May be the EU comparison can help your research:
regards
Paolo
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
10 answers
In my book "Public Participation as a Tool for Integration Local Knowledge into Spatial Planning" (Springer, 2017) I claim that Local Knowledge in urban and regional planning refers to the knowledge of people who could be affected by plans, and that it is "a large, complex epistemological system related to a broad conceptual scope that includes perceptions, desires, grievances, opinions, ideas, beliefs, thoughts, speculations, preferences, common sense, feelings and sensations; it also addresses needs, cultural codes, spatial conducts, social relations, societal norms, and everyday life scenarios and practices, all of which are rooted in the locals' everyday reality". 
Relevant answer
Answer
Local knowledge can be seen from different perspectives and embedded in different discourses. The word 'local' puts it in the immediate space for which plans are drafted. As such a local Urban Planner, who lives since long time in the respective city has such local knowledge, at least more of it than an urban planner who has been hired from far away. However, and some of the contributions argue in this direction, local can also mean people's knowledge in comparison to scientific knowledge.
Other expressions that at times appear in the discourses are 'traditional knowledge' and 'indigenous knowledge'. Of course there are slight, but very meaningful differences between all of these expressions, but what they might have in common is the assumption that beyond the scientific way of conceptualizing things there are also other qualities, which can add perspectives to the scientific view that are essential.
I just came back two week ago from doing research about 'traditional cyclone shelters in Vanuatu'. These shelters, which have survived the strongest cyclones ever are the result of 'local' knowledge. Aren't they? E.G. an important way o9f putting wooden logs together is by tying them together with wild vines instead of using nails. This flexibility provides stability as logs fixed by nails would disconnect soon when the power of heavy winds would slowly but surely loosen the connection.
Indeed I came across a similar principle many years ago in South India, where fishermen built boats by stitching the wooden planks together with coir. Also here the flexibility enhanced the stability when the boat went through the surf of the ocean.
‘Local knowledge’ here might be the knowledge which is built from experience, from being practically attached to something instead of reflecting and researching things.
Stein, D. S. (2002). Creating local knowledge through learning in community: A case study. New directions for adult and continuing education, 2002(95), 27-40.
Bishop, B. W. (2011). Location‐based questions and local knowledge. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 62(8), 1594-1603.
Aveling, E. L. (2011). Mediating between international knowledge and local knowledge: the critical role of local field officers in an HIV prevention intervention. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 21(2), 95-110.
Mammo, T. (1999). The paradox of Africa's poverty: the role of indigenous knowledge, traditional practices and local institutions--the case of Ethiopia. The Red Sea Press.
Sekhar, N. U. (2004). Local versus expert knowledge in forest management in a semi‐arid part of India. Land Degradation & Development, 15(2), 133-142.
Thomas, D. S. G., & Twyman, C. (2004). Good or bad rangeland? Hybrid knowledge, science, and local understandings of vegetation dynamics in the Kalahari. Land Degradation & Development, 15(3), 215-231.
Gerhardinger, L. C., Godoy, E. A., & Jones, P. J. (2009). Local ecological knowledge and the management of marine protected areas in Brazil. Ocean & Coastal Management, 52(3), 154-165.
Šūmane, S., Kunda, I., Knickel, K., Strauss, A., Tisenkopfs, T., des Ios Rios, I., ... & Ashkenazy, A. (2017). Local and farmers' knowledge matters! How integrating informal and formal knowledge enhances sustainable and resilient agriculture. Journal of Rural Studies.
Benham, C. F. (2017). Aligning public participation with local environmental knowledge in complex marine social-ecological systems. Marine Policy, 82, 16-24.
Shearmur, R., & Doloreux, D. (2008). Urban hierarchy or local buzz? High-order producer service and (or) knowledge-intensive business service location in Canada, 1991–2001. The Professional Geographer, 60(3), 333-355.
Yigitcanlar, T., O’connor, K., & Westerman, C. (2008). The making of knowledge cities: Melbourne’s knowledge-based urban development experience. Cities, 25(2), 63-72.
Yigitcanlar, T., & Velibeyoglu, K. (2008). Knowledge-based urban development: The local economic development path of Brisbane, Australia. Local Economy, 23(3), 195-207.
Skytt-Larsen, C. B., & Winther, L. (2015). Knowledge production, urban locations and the importance of local networks. European Planning Studies, 23(9), 1895-1917.
Pineda-Zumaran, J. (2016). Learning and knowledge generation in local decision making in the South: The case of urban infrastructure provision in Arequipa, Peru. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 36(1), 60-75.
Lau, U., & Seedat, M. (2015). The community story, relationality and process: Bridging tools for researching local knowledge in a peri‐urban township. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 25(5), 369-383.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
11 answers
With the massive advancement in robotic system and biomimetics, many people fear that the use of robots in undertaking duties in institutions especially the industries may eventually widen the gap of unemployment on a global scale. Can robots execute assigned tasks better than humans? What are the merits and demerits of each other? What are your projections of the future?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Prof. Yeray,
Thank you so much for your insightful comment and the article that says it all. I appreciate it so much. All the best.
Dickson Adom
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
6 answers
What are the precedents and results?
Relevant answer
Answer
 There are some other reasons why SP fails;
budget and strategy is not compatible,
feature public services,
Unspecifying targets,
political interventions,
lack of evaluation,
nit including cultural values,
unrealistic targets
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
3 answers
I have seen so many leaders misuse their power and authority to get their personal agendas done. 
Relevant answer
Answer
Interesting question as this is common anywhere in the globe. See our experiences in Sri Lanka.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
1 answer
It is interesting as SL government (MOH) has complied a policy document for ''Elderly care'' in Sri Lanka. I think this type of research can have a valuable input to that document
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Gayani,
Thank you for your interest in the study.
This is still ongoing and hoping to complete so soon.. Pleasure to share the information once it's completed.
Regards
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
10 answers
Is it Economical policies
or 
Political Economy 
Relevant answer
Answer
Actually there's a very big difference between "Economical Policies" and "Political Economy".
In my opinion I believe that the "Politics" is "How to perform" a thing like economy while "Economics" is "Management of the resources" like policy.
Economical policies are pointed "how to perform relevant economy" while the Political economies are pointed to the "Exclusive resources which cause to make the others as dependent".
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
4 answers
It is also the responsibility of law enforcement to seek out and identify potential victims through awareness initiatives and investigations.
Relevant answer
Answer
Mr. Kumar: I'm just going to jump in to support Marcel on this question, and to add some additional thoughts.
Your question: How does law enforcement learn of potential cases to investigate" is dependent upon the jurisdiction, the scope or remit of the law enforcement agency, their relationship with the community and NGO's as well as the scope of their ancillary investigations.
I will provide you some examples that I'm familiar with.
Drug trafficking investigations.  Having identified frontline dealers, Drug Officers undertake wiretap and surveillance operations to move "up=stream", during observations on the target at a motel, they notice large numbers of young women and middle aged males moving in and out of the same rooms. The investigation moves from just drugs, to drugs and human trafficking.  Following awareness of the crime, the investigative team moves into the reactive/intelligence model that Marcel has detailed above.
Money laundering and fraud: A series of banks have been defrauded in the region, all the suspects are young women who come into the bank with a relative (cousin) who help them apply for a bank account and credit card.  Large amounts of purchases are made and the "suspect" disappears. Bank video shows that the accompanying male is the same person for a number of "suspects". Fraud investigators along with Surveillance officers identify the target, who is using trafficking victims as fraud "fronts" as well.  The money laundering and fraud investigation moves to include human trafficking. Another reactive/intelligence led example.
Labour dispute: A member of the public witnesses an assault on a male office cleaner in a building and police attend. The victim is evasive, the assault suspect reports that it was just a disagreement in the workplace.  Officers concerns are raised and they ask detectives to attend.  The victim has limited English language skills, so an interpreter is brought in.  The victim doesn't have any identification documentation, can't provide details about their abode, their arrival, their employment agreement.  Additional workers are interviewed and a pattern starts to emerge.  The assault suspect and "company" owners are brought in for investigation. This falls into the reactive investigative model.
Sex Trafficking/Forced Prostitution:  Organized Crime investigators have been made aware of a criminal enterprise that is utilizing trafficking victims through a "Strip" club and local hotel.  Undercover officers are gathering evidence, but have identified trafficking victims that look like that have been violently assaulted.  Members of the criminal organization have a history of violence, and investigators are concerned that the months of surveillance required to gather sufficient evidence may result in serious harm to the victims.  The investigative team contacts the municipal licencing office, the national tax enforcement agency, and the regional labour regulatory agency and the liquor regulatory agency. All of these agencies are coordinated with the police investigations and undertake an immediate series of investigations on the location, resulting in a suspension of the liquor service permit, a suspension of the business licence, and labour "cease and desist" order.  As a result, the criminal organization is disrupted, investigators and NGO's work with victims to secure their recovery and the business is closed.  However, insufficient evidence is gathered to criminally prosecute the suspects, however, they are subject to a series of fines from other agencies and their business enterprise is closed.  This is an example of the disruptive investigative model.
While these are some examples that I've seen, human trafficking investigations can stem from a broad range of occurrences; simple assaults, labour disputes, frauds, domestic violence, overdose, weapons offences, drug trafficking, etc.  In some jurisdictions, human trafficking awareness has escalated to the point where citizens may see the signs of trafficking in an interpersonal interaction and notify the police; in some cases that victim has reached the point where they are willing to report it to the police; and yet in others, the police uncover the crime through the investigation of another offence.
I hope that has some value in your inquiry.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
5 answers
many of today's value chain interventions have generally been unsuccessful in sustaining competitiveness in developing countries' value chains despite claims to the contrary by proponents of the value chain strategy.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you Arthur. We are better off understanding the 'political economy' constraints in African countries' value chains.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
4 answers
I am looking for data that shows how much it costs to get elected (as president, or congress member) in the USA compared to other OECD countries to evaluate the role that money plays in the democratic process.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
16 answers
I'm writing a quantitative analysis on this and I need a dependent variable for my indicators such as the rule of law, government stability, voice and accountability and government effectiveness.
Relevant answer
Answer
The rule of law, government effectiveness and respect for all human beings.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
2 answers
I'm looking for environmental historians and policy scientists having documented long term evolution of river restoration/renaturation policies and recent challenges in one or more countries, at local and/or national scale.
Relevant answer
Answer
In the NGO world, American Rivers is doing some amazing work in the U.S. Here's the link: https://www.americanrivers.org/
Good luck.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
8 answers
Which one is stronger, Condition Coverage or Path Coverage? Please do justify with suitable example? I will also share my thought.
Relevant answer
Answer
Which kind of "path" do you mean?  In general there are a very large number of possible paths, so you should always specify exactly what kind of path you mean. If you mean entry-exit paths, it is possible to achieve ee-path coverage without condition coverage, and to achieve condition coverage without ee-path coverage. Several detailed analysis of this were developed about 30 years ago - look at papers on "subsumes" and those by Elaine Weyuker.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
8 answers
I am trying to understand and develop a theory for private management of commons, especially emerging from the shortcomings of the community management of the commons. 
I am following the 'Tragedy of Commons', and the community management solution suggested by Elinor Ostrom. 
Any good critique of Ostrom's work is also welcomed? Thanks for your suggestions. 
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with the other answers. The notions of "private" and "community" are both in my view too broad. For example, "private" includes profits, non-profits, charities, friendly societies, coops etc all with a very different approach. And where to do faith communities sit as they straddle state, private and community in many countries?  Community includes formal and informal networks but also shared values and assumptions and normative behaviours, as mentioned above. So I would go for a more sophisticated breakdown. Virtual communities also manage some commons now. The concept of "management" is also perhaps unhelpful as commons are maintained, curated, built, re-built, nurtured, destroyed and re-created not just managed. Intangibles are very important and relate to health and well-being in profound ways e.g. loneliness and its links to disease and its sustenance through networks or even just behaviours (saying hello). I think the issue is in fact too big for over-arching analysis and generalisation and that would be my fundamental criticism of much work and thinking. Commons often thrive at the micro and meso levels whereas thinking is often misdirected to the macro.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
1 answer
Currently doing a project regarding road diversion :)
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
1 answer
I have to identify and discuss some of the factors that affect investigative tools and approaches used by law enforcement here and abroad. Is this affected by media pressure and actions or by public criticism. 
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Angel,
Recommending to read the book written by Gary Dessler. It is very useful in which you can find the information which affect investigative tools and approaches used by law enforcement in the U.S.
Rgds
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
3 answers
I am looking for links that can assist with exploring the effects that government regulations and policies can have on a transportation system of the country.
Relevant answer
Answer
This is the transport policy of South Africa. Go through it to get some Idea about the transport management. 
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
4 answers
I am looking for resources and information on how an individual in an organization in a management position experiences and describes intersections of gender and discourse and what challenges are evident.  Also, how precisely does discourse construct social reality in an organization that one may be employed.
Relevant answer
Answer
You may get some inputs in the following paper:
Sharma, Radha, R. & Sharma, NP (2016)."Opening the gender diversity black box: causality of perceived gender equity and locus of control and mediation of work engagement in employee well-being"
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
3 answers
Need ideas of how to approach different perspectives in a logical paper about the Climate Change Regime -Paris Accord
Relevant answer
I think the main drivers of the global economy are conditioned by climate change. Any conventional adaptation mechanism takes longer than is available to suit the drivers of climate change and there is still not enough awareness of the need to adapt.
I am not sure if a legal document - of global scope - can work better than the existing ones on health, human rights, water or the environment.
However, ongoing with the question, one way of integrating these elements I think will be about the main global public policies on health, natural resources, the environment and energy.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
6 answers
I am now working on my paper aiming to identify the way many development donors (e.g. DFID, USAID, etc.) utilise the gender mainstreaming (and/or green agenda) to generate their power and control over international organisations and local NGOs as aid recipients. Their conducts, including their performance focus, development practices, development paradigm, and their performance results in project reports, should be in accordance with donors' conditionalities. I initially interpret that they become a particular type of subject that donors would like to see and would like to engage in their relationship. 
However, I am not sure if I could apply Foucault's 'Governmentality' and his 'Technologies of Power' to this work. If not, Is there any theories from any particular theorists suitable for this? Please give me some advice. Thank you very much!  
Please give me some advice. Thank you very much!  
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Tinnaphop. From what you describe, governmentality and technologies of the self sound like an appropriate theoretical frame to apply, if you are able to trace how aid recipients 'internalise' governmental power. Other potential conceptual frames for this situation stem from the broad suite of ideas captured in institutional theory - legitimacy theory, institutional logics, and isomorphism. Best of luck with your research
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
12 answers
In my book, titled "Public Participation as a Tool for Integrating Local Knowledge into Spatial Planning" (Springer 2017) I claim that the initial practical goals of public participation in planning are "the exposure of residents' local knowledge and the incorporation of that knowledge into the planning and decision-making processes".
Relevant answer
Answer
As to the possibility of public participation, I think one important factor is whether or not people are organized.  Many have shown that individuals are less interested in or less likely to participate in planning activities such as public hearings than their organizations such as NGOs or homeowners associations (HOA).  When there are homeowners associations in the local area, they are more active in local planning activities.  Then, a question remains open: how will the renters' interests be represented in public particiaption in planning?  Should they be represented given their much higher mobility?  Should they rely more on "exit" than on "voice"?  Public participation is certainly a method for people to "voice" their preferences or knowledge on local affairs.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
6 answers
I'm going to study tax reforms and I need to learn micro simulation modelling to have better analysis. I studied some texts but I cannot understand how micro variables are linked to macro variables.I need an elementary text.
Any help is appreciated.
Thanks.
Relevant answer
Answer
I think this text should be very good for the beginners, and its concentrated on public policies (tax policies as well):
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
2 answers
My overall research project is in the area of safety management system implementation in an international organisation. Looking to examine why we have successes in some locations and barriers to acceptance in others. Any help you can offer would assist.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Adam,
I am working on acceptance of information security rules and I would suggest that behavioral theories may be useful in your case, too. TRA/TPB, General Deterrence Theory (GDT), and Protection Motivation Theory (PMT) are frequently used in information security studies. These theories also provide well established variables. I hope this helps, good luck with the study.  
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
1 answer
according to elias tuma (1965) agrarian reform consists of land tenure reform and land operation reform. but in my country Indonesia, agrarian reform program does not seem to include both of them but only to legitimize the land redistribution
Relevant answer
Answer
I suggest that you email Leon Terrill (University of New South Wales). He has just published an excellent critical account of land tenure reform in the context of Aboriginal Australian land rights. His knowledge of the theory is likely to be relevant to the particularities of Asian projects of land tenure reform. leon.terrill@unsw.edu.au
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
3 answers
I'm looking for recent studies (or literature review) on the relationship (cross-country, individual country or regional analysis) between human capital (education, lifelong learning) and the distribution of income, starting from the pioneering work of Mincer (1958). In particular, I'd be interested in studies on regions or areas of a country. Thank you all
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks for the references!
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
11 answers
Local governance and citizens participation.
Relevant answer
Look into Graham Smith book Democratic Innovations and Archon Fung & Erik Olin & Rebecca Neaera book Deepening Democracy, Institutional Innovations in Empowered Participatory Governance. There you will find a lot of resources 
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
2 answers
There is a new trend in local governance in Nigeria. State governments are recently creating local council development areas (LCDAs), with Lagos setting the pace in 2003. Though, initially contentious but has come to stay, after a court ruling by the Supreme court in favour of Lagos state. Judgement declared the LCDAs inchoate, until the consequent listing in the constitution by the national assembly.
This is 14 years after and yet no consequent listing by the national assembly. But the LCDAs are been run smoothly in Lagos state, with other state copying their model.
So how then do this LCDAs differ from LGAs.
Relevant answer
Answer
LCDA are not recognised and listed in the 1999 Constitution. Rather, they are created by various state governments for administrative convenience and pursuit of developmental objectives. They are often perceived at some quarters as objects of partisan politics of the state governments that created them.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
4 answers
Dear all, I am wondering why design strategies in citizen culture generate changes in social behavior? And my closest reference is Antanas Mockus (Mayor of Bogotá of the 90's) with his policy on respect for norms, laws, and culture. There may be other approaches than policies.
Thanks in advance
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks for sharing Jorge, I know the work of Rocío Londoño. If you have worked on the topic I would like to read the publications, they would be very useful in my research project. Thanks again and I hope to see you soon
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
1 answer
Could this be construed as author bias as there appears to be an agenda to prove poor communication rather than from a neutral view point.
Relevant answer
Answer
no.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
3 answers
Japan has, from 2008 developed a tax system whereby citizens can designate that part of their tax burden be paid as tax transfer revenue to a specified prefecture or municipality or, within that location, to a specific policy area. I am wondering if Japan is unique in this or if other countries have any provision in their tax system that allows payers to designate the recipient of their tax revenue? I am less interested in discussions of developmental and welfare states than I am in considerations of 'shared citizenship through tax payment' versus a 'designation system,' whereby citizens can prioritise places and policies. For more background, please see my Working Paper titled: Japan's Furusato Nozei Tax System; please also comment on the paper.
Relevant answer
Answer
In Italy O,8% of the income tax can be donated to some religious institutions, and o,5% to a long list of charities and research bodies
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis
Question
1 answer
The contradiction between supply and demand of parking is apparent in the downtown areas of metropolitan around the world. One of the most important reasons is that not all kinds of parking resources within the region have been applied fully. With the advent of shared economy, I wonder how can we tackle this thorny problem of parking by sharing the private parking lots. Are there some relevant research or materials of it? Thanks for your reply!  
Relevant answer
Answer
I wrote this paper to explore the relationship between the sharing economy and urban property rights. I think parking space is an important "durable good" that could be shared by people living in downtowns. It will be interesting to analyze its effects on urban economy.
  • asked a question related to Public Policy Analysis