Science topics: LinguisticsPhonology
Science topic

Phonology - Science topic

Phonology is a branch of linguistics concerned with the systematic organization of sounds in languages.
Questions related to Phonology
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
Journal Manager is seeking editorial board and reviewers to process manuscripts for the journal.
Lisanudhad ISSN:  2356-1998 (P) |2527-6360 (E) is a scientific journal specializing in the Arabic language studies ranging from the Arabic teaching, linguistics and literatures. Lisanudhad seeks theoretically engaged work at the forefront of the field, written for a global audience comprised of the specialist, the researcher, the teachers and the student alike. The Lisanudhad is a scientific journal which focuses on the theme and topic of 1) Arabic Language and its Teaching and 2) Arabic Linguistics and Literature, including:
  1. Methodology of Arabic teaching for non-native speakers;
  2. Teaching for Arabic Competences;
  3. Strategy for teaching and learning Arabic for non-native speakers;
  4. Models of Arabic teaching for non-native speakers;
  5. The Technology of Arabic teaching;
  6. Design of Arabic teaching for non-native speakers;
  7. Evaluation in Arabic teaching for non-native speakers.
  8. Arabic Morphology and Syntax;
  9. Arabic Phonetic and Phonology;
  10. Arabic Applied Linguistics;
The Journal Manager welcomes you to join us to be Editorial Board or Reviewer of Lisanudhad.
Status                           : Part time Working language       : Arabic & English Working style               : Internet-based (web: https://ejournal.unida.gontor.ac.id/index.php/lisanu/about)
Payment                       : Voluntary job, no payment
This apllication are valid until June 2024. The selected applicant would be contacted by Journal Operational Manager (Haniatul Mabruroh +62 813-2741-5886)
Relevant answer
Answer
thanks prof. Kindly provide us one paper to be published in own platform. The editorial's paper would be an example for further authors!
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
6 answers
I am going to find out the different approaches and then measure each one effectiveness of teaching alphabet. It would be regarding phonology awareness, phenom learning, and so on.
Relevant answer
Answer
Will that contaminate the sample? Will the results be influenced?
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
1 answer
Are there any notable open-access journals with a rapid review and publication timeline in the field of phonology?
Relevant answer
Answer
You must focus well when choosing the journal. There are many open access journals, but their evaluation period is long. You must be careful of commercial and fake journals because they deceive researchers.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
2 answers
What recent studies have proposed changes to the traditional theory of optimality in phonology?
Relevant answer
Answer
The recent changes and developments in Optimality Theory (OT) within phonology:
  • Conspiracies and Soft Universals: OT addresses two main issues: Conspiracies: Some languages exhibit constraints that appear to be satisfied in multiple ways, as if rules conspire to achieve a single target. Soft Universals: Constraints that show evidence across unrelated languages but don’t hold universally. Researchers explore these phenomena to refine OT’s understanding of constraint interaction.
  • Output-Based Model: OT shifted from rule-based to an output-based model, emphasizing surface forms and constraints in shaping linguistic patterns.
  • Historical Sound Change: OT considers underlying representations as a locus of change. Surface structures derived by phonological processes may be reanalyzed as new input forms.
  • Connectionist Roots: OT has connections to neural network research, emerging as an alternative to harmonic grammar.
  • Stratal OT: Stratal OT models phonology with ranked violable constraints, revealing universals and typological generalizations.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
Is there anyone who could refer me to a phonology research team? I would appreciate any information or advice.
Relevant answer
Answer
i can and i will
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
Are there any phonological journals that are Scopus-indexed and well-known for their quick publication?
Relevant answer
Answer
Your work is really very interesting and useful .
my sincere congratulations!!
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
2 answers
What are some innovative approaches to data analysis and visualization in phonology research?
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you very much
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
5 answers
What should a researcher do immediately after obtaining a doctorate?
Relevant answer
Dear Maria,
First of all, I would like to congratulate you on obtaining such an important qualification as a doctorate.
Before I became a doctor, I worked in the public administration and once I obtained my degree, it allowed me to obtain the position because my merits increased. I think you should focus on the field in which you were trained and make different applications depending on your interests. In the European Union the job placement rate for doctors is very high. I don't know about other parts of the world.
Best regards and good luck in the new year.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
What are the most effective methods and technologies for collecting biological data, such as articulatory movement or vocal tract imaging, to analyze and model the production and perception of phonological features in human speech?
Relevant answer
Answer
MRI is helpful in getting spatial information of vocal tract with good spatial resolution. Problem comes when u want time dependent variation in vocal tract during speech. some attempts are being made to develop 3D recontructions from many MRIs obtained.
Alternatively ultrasound and articulographs are helpful for temporal variation studies.
some of references i have read, are here...many more info is available online.
Articulating Finnish Vowels: Results from MRI and Sound Data by jani saunavaara
4.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
Which evaluation instruments are available for phonological awareness testing?
Relevant answer
Answer
phonological awareness is tested in IPAS through subtasks of sound deletion and rhyme...
phonological awareness test ( PAT-2) by Carolyn Robertson and Wanda Salter is commonly used.
Metaphonological Skills Test (Prema, 1997) is one test available is Kannada. like that tests are available in different languages.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
How are researchers using experimental methods, such as eye-tracking or neuroimaging, to investigate phonological processing and perception?
Relevant answer
Answer
eye tracking allows to study auditory -visual integration or lack of it, in phonological processing. Studies are available in normal individuals as well as Hearing impaired.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
1 answer
What are some emerging trends in the application of Praat in phonological research?
Relevant answer
Answer
1. to study individual differences in acoustics of speech production e/g stop consonants variability in a native English speaking person.
2. to study variations in phoneme production across groups of individuals like AUS, UK and USA english accents.
3. automated transcription of recorded words / phonemes in non english languages.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
6 answers
How can mathematical modeling and formalism contribute to the development and refinement of phonological theories, such as Optimality Theory or Government Phonology?
Relevant answer
Answer
For acoustics you use a scalar velocity potential function, then derive a boundary integral equation and solve it using boundary elements. Myself, I did elastodynamic scattering for ultra sonic QNDE (see Achenbach) it works real good and the BIE is in my opinion most rigorous an you get displacements you can use in Hook's law etc. you can get everything from solving the BIE (see my current spotlight paper on this topic).
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
1 answer
Phonetic - What is progressive and regressive assimilation and dissimilation in the Romanic Languages (especially Spanish) and how do you recognize it? Was ist progressive und regressive Assimilation und Dissimilation in den Romanischen Sprachen, besonders im Spanischen? Que es la asimilación progresiva y regresiva y la disimilación fonética en las lenguas románicas (especialmente en el español)?
I am searching for an explication, a good source recommendation, where I could read more about this topic and some examples for the assimilation or dissimilation in the romanic languages, especially in the Spanish language. Thank you for helping me!!
Relevant answer
Answer
The assimilation phenomena are the influences that a sound makes to another. We have the progressive assimilation when the preceding sound changes the characteristics of the following: [aθ't̪̟eka] the voiceless interdental fricative consonant interdentalized the voiceless dental oclusive consonant. In the other hand, the regressive assimilation takes place when the following sound influences to the preceding: [an̪dalu'θia] the voiced dental occlusive consonant dentalized the alveolar nasal, but here we have also the progressive assimilation because the alveolar nasal made the voiced dental occlusive consonant mantain its occlusion. Finally, the dissimilation is the process by which two sounds variate their characteristics in order to emphasise the difference between them: an example could be the evolution of the medieval Spanish sibilants.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
1 answer
Use illustrations and examples to discuss this assumption.
Relevant answer
Answer
No
Autosegmental is a generative theory. Read Goldsmith (1990) for explanations.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
2 answers
Use illustrations and examples to discuss this assumption.
Relevant answer
Answer
No
CV phonology is a generative framework
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
2 answers
It seems that to date, there is not solid evidence for parallel phonological processing reflected by phonological POF effects. Why?
Relevant answer
Answer
I too am a bit unsure of what this question is about.
There is clear evidence at a phonetic level that lexical stress, sentential contour, and segmental forms are all processed in parallel. Some of these effects can be phonologically significant.
Perhaps nasalizad vowels are the simplest example of two segmental features operating in parallel: the vowel positioning and the opening of th velum - naso-pharynx. A similar interpretation of palatalization, or complex consonants in general, shows two phonological processes acting in parallel.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
20 answers
As a doctoral student specializing in phonology, I want to know the most important and newest theories in my field, and then try to apply it on Arabic language and other languages.
Thank you to everyone who participated in answering my question.
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
I am working on loan phonology. I am particularly interested in the morphophonological features/structures of English loanwords in Yoruba, especially within Optimality Theory (OT).
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr Ezekiel,
I hope you will be able to get what you need from the following publications. You can download them online or from researchgate.
Bamisaye, T.,Ojo, G.A.(2015).Phonotactic Adjustments in Yoruba Adaptation of English Syllable Structures. Open Journal of Modern Linguistics, 5(4),379-388.
Oyinloye, M.E. (2020).Monophthongization in the Adaptation of Selected English Loanwords in Yorùbá: A Constraint-Based Analysis. Journal of Universal Language, 21(1),29-67
Ogundepo, A.O.(2015). Contrastive study of English and Yoruba morphological systems- implications for Nigerian teachers and learners of English.
International Journal of English Language and Linguistics Research, 3(4),1-8.
Tone Loans: The Adaptation of English Loanwords
into Yoruba by Michael Kenstowicz. You can download it from Research gate
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
10 answers
Studying one of the varieties of Persian, it is assumed that, regardless of the stress position, all the short (mono-moraic) vowels are reduced to schwa in all of the open syllables. More clearly, all long (bi-moraic) vowels are kept intact and the short vowels have a surface representation only if they are the nucleus of closed syllables. Has any research provided any evidence of a language or a variety which can fit a similar phonological pattern?
Any information would be greatly appreciated.
Relevant answer
Answer
Johan Schalin Thanks for the reply. I will read it with great interest.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
9 answers
Dear Friends,
Greeting.
Happy New Year. I wish everybody a prosperous New Year.
I'm thinking of a project for checking the sound (phonetics) that will lost or promoted while switching from one set of alphabet to another. For example switching from Arabic letters to Latin in Turkey; does the set of Latin letters saved all Turkish phonetics (sound)? What is the advantages and/or disadvantages of such switching?
Did such work carried out anywhere?
Best Regards,
ABDUL-SAHIB
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear عائشة عبد الواحد thank you for the invaluable answer.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
In most of the existing cotton crop simulation models, the phenological events or developmental rate processes are not parameterized as a function of CO2. I wanted to investigate this since it will impact model results in case if the phonology is affected by atmospheric CO2 levels.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
23 answers
My two favourite courses are Phonetics and Phonology and General Linguistics with its other interrelated sub-divisions. I have been teaching them for over 35 years.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you for this great question,
For me, my favorite lessons are:
Distinctive features in structural phonology and generative phonology,
And the generative phonology in general, especially the modern generative phonology,
Prosodic phonology,
And the leadership of Indians and Arabs in the Ancient phonological studies.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
6 answers
can anyone tell me which part of cognitive phonology is suitable and rich enough to be used as a sample for a descriptive analytic study?
Relevant answer
Answer
I'd focus on memory span for sounds, louds, words and/or sentences as it's a well researched performance and part of working memory.
Alternative you could chose another performance related to the phonological loop of the working memory.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
20 answers
I was trying to determine whether there are differences in the frequencies of words (lemmas) in a given language corpus starting with the letter K and starting with the letter M. Some 50 000 words starting with K and 54000 words starting with M altogether. I first tried using the chi-square test, but the comments below revealed that this was an error.
Relevant answer
Answer
Did you try Python word count?
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
English phonetics and phonology
Relevant answer
Answer
There are 5 vocal cord positions
1. Median (midline)
2. Paramedian (1.5 mm from the midline)
3. Cadaver (3.5 mm from the midline)
4. Partial Abduction (7 mm from the midline)
5. Full abduction (9.5 mm from the midline)
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
I am asking for the new trends in writing researches in English phonology.
Relevant answer
Answer
specialized journals would help .
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
I seek your guidance on the methodology that I should use to collect, analyse and document false friends. My research concerns false cognates in Lusoga and Luganda.
Relevant answer
Answer
If I were you I would use advanced dictionaries which help you find out the entomology of both words.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
This is so far the procedure I was trying upon and then I couldn't fix it
As per my understanding here some definitions:
- lexical frequencies, that is, the frequencies with which correspondences occur in a dictionary or, as here, in a word list;
- lexical frequency is the frequency with which the correspondence occurs when you count all and only the correspondences in a dictionary.
- text frequencies, that is, the frequencies with which correspondences occur in a large corpus.
- text frequency is the frequency with which a correspondence occurs when you count all the correspondences in a large set of pieces of continuous prose ...;
You will see that lexical frequency produces much lower counts than text frequency because in lexical frequency each correspondence is counted only once per word in which it occurs, whereas text frequency counts each correspondence multiple times, depending on how often the words in which it appears to occur.
When referring to the frequency of occurrence, two different frequencies are used: type and token. Type frequency counts a word once.
So I understand that probably lexical frequencies deal with types counting the words once and text frequencies deal with tokens counting the words multiple times in a corpus, therefore for the last, we need to take into account the word frequency in which those phonemes and graphemes occur.
So far I managed phoneme frequencies as it follows
Phoneme frequencies:
Lexical frequency is: (single count of a phoneme per word/total number of counted phonemes in the word list)*100= Lexical Frequency % of a specific phoneme in the word list.
Text frequency is similar but then I fail when trying to add the frequencies of the words in the word list: (all counts of a phoneme per word/total number of counted phonemes in the word list)*100 vs (sum of the word frequencies of the targeted words that contain the phoneme/total sum of all the frequencies of all the words in the list)= Text Frequency % of a specific phoneme in the word list.
PLEASE HELP ME TO FIND A FORMULA ON HOW TO CALCULATE THE LEXICAL FREQUENCY AND THE TEXT FREQUENCY of phonemes and graphemes.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hola,
Para el cálculo de la frecuencia léxica de unidades simples o complejas, se suele utilizar WordSmith o AntCon.
Saludos
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
This is so far the procedure I was trying upon and then I couldn't fix it
As per my understanding:
- lexical frequencies, that is, the frequencies with which correspondences occur in a dictionary or, as here, in a word list;
- lexical frequency is the frequency with which the correspondence occurs when you count all and only the correspondences in a dictionary.
- text frequencies, that is, the frequencies with which correspondences occur in a large corpus.
- text frequency is the frequency with which a correspondence occurs when you count all the correspondences in a large set of pieces of continuous prose ...;
You will see that lexical frequency produces much lower counts than text frequency because in lexical frequency each correspondence is counted only once per word in which it occurs, whereas text frequency counts each correspondence multiple times, depending on how often the words in which it appears to occur.
When referring to the frequency of occurrence, two different frequencies are used: type and token. Type frequency counts a word once.
So I understand that probably lexical frequencies deal with types counting the words once and text frequencies deal with tokens counting the words multiple times in a corpus, therefore for the last, we need to take into account the word frequency in which those phonemes and graphemes occur.
So far I managed phoneme frequencies as it follows
Phoneme frequencies:
Lexical frequency is: (single count of a phoneme per word/total number of counted phonemes in the word list)*100= Lexical Frequency % of a specific phoneme in the word list.
Text frequency is similar but then I fail when trying to add the frequencies of the words in the word list: (all counts of a phoneme per word/total number of counted phonemes in the word list)*100 vs (sum of the word frequencies of the targeted words that contain the phoneme/total sum of all the frequencies of all the words in the list)= Text Frequency % of a specific phoneme in the word list.
PLEASE HELP ME TO FIND A FORMULA ON HOW TO CALCULATE THE LEXICAL FREQUENCY AND THE TEXT FREQUENCY of phonemes and graphemes.
Relevant answer
Answer
It will help if you use a suitable and powerful qualitative research software as Atlas.ti (https://atlasti.com/) or equivalent. This software allows you to introduce and research large amounts of text, written or oral, images, videos, etc. Then, you can select diverse research techniques, including frequencies, correlations, modulations, structures, and several other tools.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
I need research material on Brazilian Portuguese phonology.
Relevant answer
Answer
Não tenho certeza, entretanto, se você estiver interessado em Português do Brasil, entre em contato comigo. Fico feliz em trocar ideias. I am making an effort to communicate, hoping that one day, it will be easier! Um abraço
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
1 answer
I am looking for a good journal with sufficient ranking level for publishing a paper on a dialectology phonological processes. Can any one suggest me a good journal?
a phonological
Relevant answer
Answer
Depending on the analysis, I'd go for LabPhon or Phonology. But more phonetics oriented journals (Phonetica, Journal of Phonetics, Journal of the International Phonetic Association) would I'm sure also be good outlets if the analysis includes phonetic aspects as well.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
1 answer
i am working on the phonological system of a language and now i want to analyze the phonology of this language using Autosegmental and Lexical phonological framework . if there is anybody who can help that would be appriciated.
Relevant answer
Answer
You can use Pratt software for analysis(open source),what parameters you are concentrating.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
30 answers
Some language learners believe that some languages are too hard to learn due to their sound system (phonetics and phonology). Which language, do you think, is the most difficult one for learners, and why?
Relevant answer
Answer
Wouldn't it depend in part of your native language?
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
11 answers
Hi there, 
Me and my colleague are interested in developing experimental tasks to investigate lexical access in bilinguals speaking French and Turkish. We thus wonder if a Turkish lexical database exists in order to select materials according to lexical frequencies, phonological and orthographical neighborhood of words.
We know about "TELL project" but it does not provide the information we need.
We will be very grateful for your precious help.
Best regards.
Stéphanie Bellocchi
Relevant answer
Following.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
7 answers
I have this project for school with my students and we are trying to create a list of the non-native accents in English that are the most difficult to understand (by natives or non natives). In other words, I'm trying to establish if it is English spoken in France, Poland, or Liberia etc. Also, what are the deviant phonological features that make comprehension more difficult? (other than word stress on the wrong syllable). If anyone has thoughts or knows a study regarding these topics, I would be very glad to hear about it. Thanks for your help!
Relevant answer
Answer
Linguistically,we do not have an accent that is much knottier than others,nor more prestigous,but it is a matter that is mainly accompained with it spread and usage by the speakers.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
5 answers
English phonetics and phonology
Relevant answer
Answer
Accent is a variety of pronunciation whereas dialect is a variety of language. Allophone is a member of the same phoneme. Allomorph can be tackled within the framework of Grammar. These are some basic concepts. For further details, just have a look at the books of Grammar, Phonetics and Phonology.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
English phonetics and phonology
Relevant answer
Answer
Fortis is a term that refers to voiceless consonants as their production is stronger than the production of lenis consonants. They need much more effort. Lenis is a term referring to voiced consonants that need less effort in their production. As for phonemic transcription, both should be enclosed between slashes to make them different from the letters used in ordinary spelling.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
I am a student of Comparative Literature (Persian and English) and I am reading about the prosody of the English language. To master its metrical system and prosody, I think I should read more about the English phonetics more in the first place. So I would be extremely grateful if you recommend any advanced book on this subject.
Relevant answer
Answer
You can buy Peter Roach's "English Phonetics and Phonology Paperback with Audio CDs (2): A Practical Course"
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
To study the phonological processing abilities with non-word repetition task in children who stutter, we performed three non-word repetition tasks in two groups of children who stutter and who don't stutter. Responses from the nonword repetition task were scored into two different methods in below:
First, the per cent correct nonwords were scored based each nonword as a correct or error response.
Second, the overall per cent correct phonemes (the total number of phonemes that were correctly produced in each nonword divided by the total number of phonemes ∗ 100).
Each of these tasks has been made taking into account some of the factors affecting the non-word repetition performance. Each of these assignments includes sub-scales (one to five syllable). The aims of our study were:
1) To compare the performance of the two groups in three tasks to identify the task that distinguishes better between the two groups.
2) To identify items from each sub-scale for each task that could better differentiate between the two groups and put them in the form of a non-word repetition list.
I want to know which statistical methods I should use. Please guide me about the above issues.
Relevant answer
Answer
if ROC can be estimated for each task and then that can be compared for all three tasks to decide which task is better...probably..
Manova/ ANOVa for group comparison might help,, i guess...
selection of paramtric tests would depend on normalcy of data
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
I need an explanation of the Optimality Theory and hw I can use it as a framework for my study of the phonological features of Swazi English.
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
5 answers
I need information on the Optimality Theory and how I can use it as a framework for my research on the phonological features of Swazi English. Can anyone recommend sites/ sources where I can get information on OT.
Relevant answer
Answer
The optimal unit of phonological system is a separated sound when it is meaningful and able to form a meaningful semantic unit in combination with other well organized sounds. Of course the sound quantity changes causes grammatical categorization. Please read my papers about that subject, i hope that they would be useful for you, especially PHONO-GRAMMAR.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
1 answer
Do you know any implication research studies on American Sign Language phonological alterations on lexicon of "1st-person" or "self-possession"?
(Ex: Me, I, and We)
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi, Carey
Check: Hou, L., & Meier, R. P. (2018). The morphology of first-person object forms of directional verbs in ASL. Glossa: A Journal of General Linguistics, 3(1), 114. DOI: http://doi.org/10.5334/gjgl.469
Christina
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
6 answers
I am working on a paper trying to investigate the advisability of using animated charts in teaching phonetics and phonology for non-native speakers of English.
Relevant answer
Answer
yes, it can help at a considerable degree. I recommend using CALL programs as Pronunciation Power, it is very effective in the teaching of vowels and consonants for foreign learners as it demonstrates the lips movements, the tongue articulation and the jaw shape ( place and manner of articulation).
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
Hello,
Any article recommendations on Spanish learners of Russian, particularly — the acquisition of the Russian sound system?
Relevant answer
Answer
هل نستطيع أن نتبع آلية محددة لدراسة النص التراثي بلاغيا؟
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
5 answers
In English, AdSD is characterized by hyperadduction during phonation on vowels. AbSD, is characterized by prolonged voiceless consonants before vowel onset.
Also the perceptual quality of SD in English is different than French perceptual qualities as you will find in the Pearlmann-Lorch & Whurr 2009 study.
I was wondering if you found any differences in perceptual qualities or specific phonological instances where AdSD symptoms arise during the reading passage in Mandarin? I would really appreciate any feedback since I am assisting a professor with related research and I am trying to look for research that has addressed SD symptoms in other languages. Thank you so much
Relevant answer
Answer
I also suggest you contact the authors on Researchgate. I'm sure they'll provide answers to your questions.
I can also provide the extended abstract which gives a detailed description of the experiment, methods and material, in English. Just let me know and I'll attach it in a message.
Christina
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
2 answers
I am looking for recordings of "The North Wind and the Sun" in Romanian for a research about the phonetics and phonology of this language.
Do you know whether I can find any on the web?
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks, @diana.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
Dr. Mann.
So glad you are working in a school! Your research about morphology and literacy has been an important influence.
While I continue to publish, my main focus is working directly with schools and educators to help them understand English orthography so that they can target that understanding in literacy instruction from the beginning of formal instruction. My 2018 article with my brother, Jeff Bowers (https://tinyurl.com/y9gh6l8e) addresses this issue. Morphology is key, of course, but it's really about the interrelation of morphology, etymology and phonology. The evidence from meta-analyses of morphological instruction is that it brings the greatest benefits to younger and less able students.
However, few have an image of what morphology instruction can look like in early literacy instruction let alone orthographic instruction. I thought you might be interested in
Some practical examples from schools I've been working with. This recent piece shares examples from pre-school to Gr. 2 that may interest you. https://tinyurl.com/y7oan9wz.
If you find that useful, I'd be delighted to discuss any aspect of this kind of instruction further with you. I'm not good at Research Gate. Feel free to email me at peterbowers1@mac.com
You can see the practical work I'm doing at my website www.wordworkskingston.com
Regardless, I'm always excited to see researchers diving into schools!
Relevant answer
No
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
27 answers
Phonetics is the science concerned with the study of the sound system in the human language in general. Phonology, however, is the science concerned with the study of the sound system in particular languages. What are the main differences that can be added between the two disciplines?
Relevant answer
Answer
Phonetics is the study of the the physical properties of human speech, such as how basic sounds are physically produced, their acoustics, and how they are perceived.
Phonology deals with language sounds in abstract, grammatical terms. It often focuses on the systems of phonemes in particular languages and describes how they work. Phonology also deals with acoustic phenomena at syllable level (e.g., morae) or even sentence-level (e.g., sentence level stress).
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
Hi, I am trying to construct a receptive phonology task (i.e., odd-one-out: "bli" "bli" "bla", which sounded different?) for 3-year old children with various language backgrounds. As I want to compare kids with speaking different languages, I need to construct parallel tests with comparable item difficulty. I have found consonant and vowel confusion matirces for German and French (sadly only adult's data) but not (yet) for Italian and Turkish. Can anyone help me out?
Kind regards,
Jessica
Relevant answer
Thank you Christina Valaki! I have also come across that paper since my inquiry! However, I am still looking for information for the Turkish language.. This is turning out to be more complicated than anticipated..
Thank you all for giving me tips! This is all very helpful and highly appreciated!
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
I am interested in investigating the phonological development for children speaking Arabic (Saudi-Hejazi in particular), and I developed a word list to conduct a single naming task on children to have their speech sample. So, do I need to collect some sample from children as connected speech to complete my data and get a full picture of their speech skills? If you think it is important, could I have some references that support this idea?
Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
Mohammad Hamad Al-khresheh Thank you for your answer. My study design is cross-sectional, and the sample size will be 200 participants. I know that a longitudinal study is more useful than cross-sectional. But I cannot conduct this design because it is a PhD project and I will travel collect the data, so it would be impossible to follow the participants.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
9 answers
This article was brought to my attention by my good friend, Firmin Ahoua. Congrats to the authors for this research but they could have done it without framing it as if they found something contrary. In so doing they are being dishonest with their framing of this issue. They refer to my CSLI book the Structure of Dagaare and claim that I say the vowle /a/ is neutral to ATR harmony, but there is nowhere in my book that I say this. On page 23 of my book I acknowledge that /a/ occurs in both + and - ATR. They claim they see variants of /a/ but of course we all who work on vowel harmony systems know that as this low vowel is influenced by its ATR environment in each phonological word. So I really find the contestation here dishonest. It looks like an attempt to embellish their finding to sound as if it is a breakthrough but they are only providing evidence through instrumental analysis (which was not available in earlier studies) to confirm what myself and others say about ATR harmony in Dagaare and other Mabia languages.
Relevant answer
Answer
On page 21 of your book on Dagaare, you state that there are nine oral vowels in Dagaare and as you note in your response to our paper, on page 23 of your book you state that ‘even though /a/ is realised phonetically as a [-ATR] vowel it occurs both with the set of [+ATR] vowels and the set of [-ATR] vowels.’ The paper of ours that you refer to reports on data from 5 speakers and appears to be inconsistent with this position. Taking measurements for tongue root values at three points throughout the low vowel, including points where we would not expect to see significant coarticulatory effects from the following vowel, we interpret our data as motivating a tenth phonological vowel. The formant differences observed are larger than what we would expect from coarticulation alone. We certainly know that ATR systems can vary as to whether they have nine or ten contrastive vowels. The data we report on in this short paper suggest that at least the variety of Dagaare that we examined is indeed a ten-vowel system phonologically. The question of whether Dagaare has nine or ten vowels is an interesting one and will be resolved through data collection and analysis. It is unclear why raising this question, and contributing data to it, would be interpreted as a dishonest framing of the issue.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
My aim is to morph two sounds (e.g., light-right) so that they become an ambiguous sound (i.e., sometimes you'll hear it as 'right', sometimes 'light').
I have been practicing with a MATLAB based software called STRAIGHT-legacy and have had some success with the coding (non-GUI) side of it. However, there is very limited guidance available online, and I would like some more guidance:
Q1. Preferably, some UG students can use the GUI version of the software. From reading Hideki Kawahara's (2009) manual, this can be done by typing “TandemSTRAIGHThandler” in the Matlab command window (after setting path to src). However, this does not work. Since the manual was written some time ago, I'm wondering if the GUI for morphing is still operational, or has it been phased out? If anyone is still using it successfully, I'd appreciate if you can let me know how you activate it (i.e., which version of STRAIGHT did you download, and what version of MATLAB do you use?)
Q2. There are still some minor aspects of the coding interface I have trouble with, too. If anyone has experience of using STRAIGHT for morphing, please get in touch.
Many thanks,
Ryan
Relevant answer
ربما
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
Dear Colleagues,
Perhaps you could help me find answers to several questions on the neural organization of alphabet and number recitation:
1. Could recitation of numbers and letters rely on phonological long-term memory without accessing lexical information? Alternatively, could lexical information be accessed only for numbers (since they are words) but not letters (that are not words)?
2. Several neuroimaging studies (including clinical reports) have shown a dissociation between letter and number sequencing (recitation, reading and writing). Why do you think this is the case?
3. A patient could not recite the alphabet but could sing it upon electrical brain stimulation. Any suggestions why this happened?
Help with any of the questions will be greatly appreciated!
Thank you!
Monika
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Monika! Please see related articles in Attachment. All the best. Vladimir
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
Would you recommend any?
Relevant answer
Answer
In our paper "Sound to meaning mappings in the Bouba-Kiki effect." we've created hundreds of nonsense words with the aim of determining how the various phonemes contribute to attributed meanings (related the object shape). I don't have the other papers handy, but in our paper we reference several papers that similarly attempt to isolate/characterize how various phonemes are related to meanings. Some reads I would recommend 1) Nielsen, A., & Rendall, D. (2011). The sound of round: evaluating the sound-symbolic role of consonants in the classic Takete-Maluma phenomenon. 2) Magnus (2001) What's in a Word? Studies in Phonosemantics 3) Fort, Martin and Peperkamp (2014) Consonants are More Important than Vowels in the Bouba-kiki Effect
Most of these papers focus on specific sound-to-meaning mapping (e.g. sound-shape mapping)
The thesis by Margaret Magnus takes a more comprehensive look at how sounds in English are mapped to a variety of meanings.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
The mapping of word-level accentual phenomena and musical prominence and melody in text-setting is well-known. This leads to the question as to whether higher-level prosodic constituents are also mirrored in music, and if so how.
Relevant answer
Answer
Here’s a paper on prosodic structure and musical structure: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.01962/full
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
Hello,
I would like to see the full-version of the article " Short-term Memory and Language Processing: Further Evidence for the Existence of Separate Phonological and Semantic Short-term Memory Components " from MAJERUS S., VAN DER LINDEN M. & RENARD C.
Is it possible to publy it ?
Thank you
MINDER Camille
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi,
the page in researchgate does not state in what journal it was publish. However, there is probably another related paper available, also by Majerus. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3709421/
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
5 answers
Below are the case:
30 students to answered 4 types of questions : spelling, reading, writing and phonology test. I need to know which instrument is the most correct answered and the most worst instrument? My data have a few outlier due to 0 marks in a few instruments which resulted non-normalize distribution. Therefore I cannot simply use the mean ans the SD as in normal distribution. Then what types of statistical test should I used?
Relevant answer
Answer
As suggested above for each group you can provide median and Interquartile range.
.
Also you can go for kruskal Wallis test for the comparison between the groups, and then further you can do pairwise comparisons also for each pair so that you can see which pair is differing.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
1 answer
impact of regional prosody on severity and Which parameter varies ?
I suppose impact on prosody on patients living in Aix les Bains is different from Aix en provence, since regional prosody is different...
Thanks for your opinion.
Denis
Relevant answer
Answer
I am completing a study on VOT effects in a standardized reading, one of the most interesting findings is the neutralization of regional prosodic variation within the study group, therefore, I recommend a data collection strategy that allows comparing speech in different contexts in order to be able to measure prosodic variations.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
1 answer
Both short and tall children
Relevant answer
Answer
Quite simple selection criteria
- Height + or - 2.5 SDS
- Unknown cause for growth disorder
- DNA available (index case and family members)
- Phenotype well characterized
For short children We give priority to syndromic children born small for gestational age AND children with autosomal dominant disproportion short stature (abnormal sitting height : total height ratio SDS) without clear skeletal dysplasia
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
18 answers
I'm creating an artificial language that consists of auditorily presented CV nonwords. Because there are not that many CV nonwords that meet my criteria (neither in English nor in German, both of which I've considered using), I was wondering whether I could include letter names along with some actual nonwords.
Is there any evidence (ideally, from EEG/ERP studies, but not necessarily) for letter names (for example, /di/ in English) being processed as real words? My hint is that I shouldn't use them but I'm hoping that perhaps if all my items have an identical phonological structure (i.e., CVs starting with a plosive), and if most of them (~85%) are nonwords, then the letter names (~15%) won't be processed differently compared to the nonwords. I'd be thankful for any advice/references!
Relevant answer
Answer
I think letter names are words so they are stored in the lexicon as words (dee, tee etc).  Just because they represent a visual item (letter) there is no difference between a word representing a physical item such as a table.  Hope this helps.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
We are doing research about a gesture system called Visual Phonics.  The hand shapes, corresponding to sounds, can be useful in literacy instruction with young children, both with and without disabilities.  The individual hand shapes are fairly abstract initially, but, with repetition, do take on meaning.  Does this indicate a shift from one type of gesture to another?
Relevant answer
Answer
No. Iconic symbols must be perceptually similar to their targets (possibly in a broad way) and presumably at least partly understandable out of context. When an abstract symbol takes on a conventionalised meaning it does not change its nature.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
19 answers
What is assessment for you as a teacher. How do you improve your students learning? Which assessment way do you follow?
Now a days, I'm teaching "literary pedagogy" subject to my BS-4 students. I have prepared a teaching program and have divided my few lectures into two-two phases. In my last class, I involved my students into different works, including group discussion to judge their capacity to work in team, leader participation to judge their role as a leader, written task to evaluate their writing ability and critical thinking.. as well as I focused on their minor grammatical mistakes in writing  and speaking etc. After one phase, I gave feedback to the works of my students. I gave them scores on the basis of group discussion, leader participation, individual participation and their critical thoughts.
How do you assess your students' task..
I welcome you to join this discussion and  I thank you, in advance for your intellectual contribution.  
Best Wishes,
Sabah Zaib
Relevant answer
Dear Sabah,
I work with discursive approach (oral and written text production) in order to not hygienizing the observed subjects’ ways and desires.  This assessment supports pluralities: this practice becomes effective social work. This perspective is called "fourth-generation qualitative assessment"
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
In reading research, a frequently used dependent variable (DV) is the response/reaction time (RT). How sure are that we start uttering the word (thus triggering the response capture device (i.e., mic)) ONLY after accessing the full phonology of the word to be read?! 
Or put in simple words, how sure are we that the entire word is processed before we utter the word, in a reading experiment task?!
Regards..
G. Krishnan
Relevant answer
Answer
As far as I know, the evidence is not that clear. See for instance the work of Kathie Rastle and her colleagues: 
Reading aloud begins when the computation of phonology is complete.
Rastle, Kathleen; Harrington, Jonathan; Coltheart, Max; Palethorpe, Sallyanne
Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, Vol 26(3), Jun 2000, 1178-1191. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0096-1523.26.3.1178
A lot will depend on the ecological validity of the task and whether or not participants will be able to make use of strategic behavior.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
5 answers
The aim of my study was to see the effectiveness of my selected literature teaching method in my classroom. There were 24 students in class so I divided them into four groups of six members each. I narrowed down my purpose and gave to my students several tasks to see the effectiveness of this method with regards to 1. students' creative writing skills 2. their Critical thinking strategy, 3.their other language skills like reading, discussing, 4.  and their general opinion about this method. The response of my students are open ended. I first noted down the response of my students collectively with respect to their groups as "Group A said about this method "fantastic", G-B, innovative, etc. I also got their individual responses.
Now the data provides me in-depth knowledge. I'm confused how should I analyse my data systematically.
I need your guidance to analyse and interpret my data. 
Thanks in advance.
Relevant answer
Dear Sabah Zaib,
The French Discourse Analysis (Pêcheux, Les Vérités la Palice) uses the method of Carlo Ginzburg (Clues, Myths and historical Method), with a research strategy  based on reading clues and traces that reveal hidden information.
I wish you success in your search!
Dionéia Monte-Serrat
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
Mean syllable duration, Number of filled pauses, Number of silent pauses, Mean duration of silent pauses, Number of corrections, and Number of repetitions. I do really need suggestion as I am not sure whether PRAAT can measure all of that. Maybe there are someone who knows well about PRAAT and how to analyze that. I would be very thanksful. Thank you
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
We are looking for a French text in which speech sounds are selected such as to obtain a fixed proportion of voiced and unvoiced sounds (or more degrees of sonority). This text would we used in a contrastive multilingual experiment on vocal load.
In addition, we are interested in phonetically balanced corpora for French.
Thank you!
Relevant answer
Answer
You may find these books useful although quite old.
Lucile Charles & Annie-Claude Motron (2001). Phonetique Progressive du Francais avec 600 exercices. Paris: CLE International.
Lhote Elizabeth (1990). Le paysage sonore d'une langue, le francais. Hambourg: Buske Verlag.
Best wishes
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
3 answers
I am looking for the frequency average values of RP consonants in order to compare this with the accented English consonants pronounced by the students
Relevant answer
Answer
A.C.Gimson - An Introduction to the Pronunciation of English
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
9 answers
Genealogically, some languages may be attributed to a single source referred to as their proto-language. Similarly, dialects of the same language are related in a number of aspects but may differ phonologically.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi David,
An interesting aspect is that some phonological variations within language are non-continuous in space (i.e, distinct locations may share features while closer locations may show different features). This was been found for intonation contours, for example, and draws a picture unlike that found for segmental variation in most cases. The sources for this 'dispersion' may be various: some sound patterns may depend and/or interact with other aspects of grammar (e.g., , morphology, syntax, pragmatics); population drift within a country may also have a relevant impact; cultural issues can lead certain local communities to easily adopt the more general pattern or, by contrast, to persevere in the more local pattern. So, the array of factors is complex. We provided some illustrations in the Interactive Atlas of the Prosody of Portuguese (for intonation contours, phrasing, and rhythm features).
Hope this adds to the discussion...
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
2 answers
In my doctoral thesis I am comparing the pronunciation of different types of toponyms in Switzerland. I am wondering whether there is similar research being done in other projects at the moment.
Relevant answer
Answer
Murray Spiegel has done comprehensive work on name pronunciation for US place names and personal names for Text-to-Speech systems. He has an article "Proper name pronunciations for speech technology applications" in International Journal of Speech Technology 6, 419-427, 2003.  In this article you can find references of his earlier publications in 1985 and 1990, as well as other works on name pronunciations for speech technologies.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
4 answers
Length, tone and intonation can be distinctively used like phonemes, especially in the African languages. Therefore, they function as phonemes in such languages.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi David! Whether these concepts are legit might depend on the theoretical framework one adopts. For example, if length is used as a phonological feature [+long], then the notion lengtheme and the feature would be synonymous and could be justified simply by providing a minimal pair. However, if one adopts a theoretical framework where length is derivate, say as a sequence of two segments, then the notion is redundant and because it is not a primative.
In the treatment of tone, some researchers have analysed them as being compositional (features High and Low, see Hyman 1993 or Bao 1999 for details). In such approaches, the toneme would really just be a feature. For some researchers, tones may not be thought of as compositional. In Chinese languages, a syllable [ma] is contrastive if it has a high flat tone, a rising tone, a low tone or a falling tone. If you think of rising and falling tones as non-compositional (i.e. cannot be stated as aa sequence of tonal features), then the toneme would include all the various tone melodies. In African languages, it seems that there is a lot of evidence for treating tones as sequences of H and L, as can be seen in the patterns found in Mende, Margi etc (see Peng 2013: Chapter 4).
In the treatment of intonation, it is possible also to use only tonal features H and L. One merely has to state the locus where they occur in relation to the utterance (either the syntactic structure or the prosodic structure). If that's the framework adopted, then there is no need for the notion intoneme.
Best,
Lian-Hee
References
Bao, Zhiming (1999) The Structure of Tone. Oxford University Press.
Hyman, Karry M. (1993) Register tones and tonal geometry. In van der Hulst, Harry and Keith Snider (eds.) The Phonology of Tone: the Representation of Tonal Register. Mouton de Gruyter. pp. 75-108.
Peng, Long (2013) Analyzing Sound Patterns: an Introduction to Phonology. Cambridge Univ. Press.
Yip, Moira (2002) Tone. Cambridge Univ. Press.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
15 answers
Have asked in Statistical Area. Am interested in identifying probabilistic and statistic distributions of Mandarin tones [either in general or in specific corpora].
I have developed some very general data eg Tone 1 occurs around 18% of the time, Tones 2 and 3 slightly higher than Tone 1, Tone 4 occurs > 40%, and the neutral is relatively low. But I'd like to obtain more detailed data and also theories as to how experts view tones in probability [if this style can even be accomplished]. Would Bayesian probabilities not be appropriate?
Relevant answer
Answer
Stephen, that's really cool stuff! Thanks. 
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
6 answers
Dialect levelling is the phenomenon where there is a loss of localised features in urban and rural variaties of English in Britain, to be replaced with features found over a wider region.
How does one examine whether this has taken place or not, considering only Lexis and Grammar? Extensive research in the past has been done on Accent and Phonology, but Lexical and Grammatical diffusion seem to be overlooked.
Relevant answer
Answer
The prime historical example of lexical leveling in English is American English. Regional differences brought from England were "leveled" over time as children grew up forming new varieties. In England, the spread of Northern forms into the South in the late Middle English and Early Modern periods contributed to the loss of grammatical forms such as case endings, and of course famously, the spread of Danish plural pronouns from East Anglia wiped out the Old English forms. The processes which contributed to such changes are alive and well today. It is much easier to study lexical and grammatical variation/change by questionnaires than phonological variation, though people are always hypersensitive to school-taught notions of correctness, and tend to identify any inquiry as a test of knowledge of social correctness, so there are always hazards. Nowadays, corpora of telephone conversations are probably the best resources to tap for relatively unmonitored usage, but these may not exist in sufficient size or social variety in enough different regions to allow for lexical or grammatical research (phonology is always easier here).
Most leveling will be evident in age-graded differences in usage, so the old regional dialect dictionaries are probably your best starting-point. Most of the early research in England on regional differences was entirely lexical, so there is a large data-base to begin with. It should be easy to construct questionnaires based on these sources. Students can interview grandparents and parents to pick up on generational shifts (and the students can learn in the process).
   Rudy
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
6 answers
I'm working on a research idea related to the mispronunciation of some Arabic words such as "Islam" and "Assalam" by native speakers of English. I noticed that these two words in particular are often mispronounced, especially the syllable -lam which is pronounced as /lɑm/ as explained above instead of /læm/ as in "lamb" which is the closest English equivalent to the native speaker of Arabic's pronunciation of this syllable.
Therefore, I'm trying to trace the syllable /lɑm/ in English to see if it actually exists in the English phonological inventory.
So far I found these results on urbandictionary.com.
UPDATE 11/11/2015: I have found more examples, "llama," "lama (a Buddhist priest of Tibet or Mongolia)," and "Lombard".
Thanks in advance for your help :)
Relevant answer
Answer
I found this video on how to pronounce "Muslum"
I'd love to hear comments not only on the tips/ steps to pronounce "Muslim" but also on the comments made by viewers of the video.
Thank you :-)
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
2 answers
Do neurolinguists have any suggested model for phonological transfer direction ?? I want to know if there is any neurological support for the process through which phonological transfer happens.   To be exact i want to know how different parts of brain work when phonological transfer happens?? Any idea? Any model??any sources?? 
Relevant answer
Answer
Hallo Sorour,
I am not sure I understand you correctly (whether you talk rather about phonology in general or intonation or both). Transfer in learning ?
The things I have in mind (and which at least I found exciting) for intonation and neural models are these papers here:
But I am not sure they speak to your topic.
Best Susanne
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
5 answers
I am working with intonational bilingualism, but I am addressing the linguistic issue in a general way and answers from segmental phonology are welcome:
if on one hand I have a pair of synonymous (due to bilingualism), phonetically similar but phonologically distinct patterns that converge phonetically in a gradient way, creating a continuity of in-between forms without creating new phonological categories (gradent phonetic fudging), thus progressively (in time) eliminating their phonological distinction, and on the other hand I have another synonimous pair which creates a third intermediate fusion-form but also a fusion-category associated to it (phonological discrete fudging), am I allowed to say that (or is there a possible way to assess, and in this case, are there studies assessing whether) the first process is a more "below the level of awareness" than the second one (and therefore, is more bound to result in permanent change)?
Probably the very definition of phonological implies a "more" conscious process, but I mean specific self-awareness tasks, which in intonation may be of the kind "have you said it with an accent?" giving clearly polarized answers in some cases and many "I don't know"s or "sort of"s in others.
Relevant answer
Answer
Interesting but complex questions! Without going into any of them directly, I would like to mention an unpublished (and now lost, alas!) paper I wrote on the ability of a speaker who made the COT:CAUGHT distinction regularly and natively, to distinguish it after having lived among speakers who lacked it. The surprising result (to me) was that the speaker failed to recognize the distinction when listening to recorded word lists. I am sure that I have seen this point documented elsewhere, but I don't recall where just now. The moral is that what happens in production does not necessarily always mirror what occurs in reception. (Sometimes the result runs the other way: the hearer recognizes the distinction in the speech of others, but does not produce it -- pointing to the hazards of making internal psycholinguistic inferences based on external events.)
    --Rudy
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
7 answers
Is apraxia of speech (AOS) the same as language delay? and what are the most featured phonological patterns that characterize apraxic people?
Is there a specific battery used to diagnose apraxia of speech? and in case there is not, what are its symptoms?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dafydd Gibbon thank you so much.
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
18 answers
Given my rudimentary knowledge in phonology, I am somehow struck by this question of phonological rule condensation. 
There are three phonological rules:
a. A → B / C__D
b. A → B /    __DE
c. A → B / C __E
Now can you help me to collapse these three rules into a single rule schema? I would appreciate your help!
Relevant answer
Answer
I'm tempted to say that abbreviations are only useful (in phonology as elsewhere) if one remembers what they mean. Oops, I said it! Please bear with me, formalisms are so pedantic ...
1. Pankaj's formulation says nothing about word-initial position. The rules can apply anywhere within a word, initially or not, provided that the context terminates at a word-final boundary.
2. The rule
A→B/_
actually means that A is replaced by B everywhere (whether there is a word boundary or not). But Pankaj's formulation implies simply
A→B#
which means that A is replaced by B only before a word boundary (forgetting the other rules for a moment).
3. The full resolution of Pankaj's formulation
A → B / (C)__(D)(E)#
is the following set of 8 rules (i.e. 2^3 rules, as there are 3 binary options):
CADE# → CBDE#
CAD# → CBD#
CAE# → CBE#
CA# → CB#
ADE# → BDE#
AD# → BD#
AE# → BE#
A# → B#
This means that I have to revise my previous comments, as I had ignored the word boundary in the formulation. The solution is neither sound (in that it generates unwanted items) nor complete (in that it only generates contexts which contain a word-final boundary). In contrast, the original rule apply whatever follows, i.e. whether there is a word-final boundary or not (since no word boundary is specified in the rules).
4. Interestingly, in a context CADE, application of the rules is indeterminate: either of the following original rules can apply:
CAD → CBD
ADE → BDE
In each case, the output would be CBDE.
If the two rules had different rule changes, e.g. if the second of these two were
ADE → GDE
it would mean that a principle of rule ordering would be needed in order to decide whether the output should be CBDE or CGDE. Since the output is the same in each case in the given example, the ordering is irrelevant and the rules can be said to be unordered.
Next challenge: find a real language to which rules with comparable structural descriptions and structural changes apply! :)
  • asked a question related to Phonology
Question
6 answers
I am currently working on English / Arabic contrastive phonology. I need a tool for doing automatic Arabic speech segmentation. Can you recommend one, please? 
Relevant answer
Answer