Science topic

Neolithic Archaeology - Science topic

Explore the latest questions and answers in Neolithic Archaeology, and find Neolithic Archaeology experts.
Questions related to Neolithic Archaeology
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
3 answers
Apart from outdated sources, all of the scholarly literature I have been able to come across asserts that agriculture was discovered in China independently. Are there any studies which suggest that agriculture arrived in China from another region such as India?
Relevant answer
Answer
In scientific history, we don't use the terms "discoveries," "origins," and similar, but rather processes. The fundamental problem is identifying societies shifting systematically towards agriculture as the main economic and social structure. You would be surprised with the archeological data that we have gathered nowadays showing that the domestication of plants and animals existed in Southern Africa or Papua New Guinea much before China, India, or the Middle East. The question is: when did agricultural societies become dominant trends. Discussions on discoveries and origins, the "frists" or "priorities," are not any longer historiography subjects.
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
19 answers
For hundreds of thousands of years human society was confined to the life style of the subsistence hunter gatherer. Small bands of people, based largely around family groups spent countless generations living in this manner.
After the last Ice Age, at the beginning of the current interglacial that we are living in today humans developed agriculture and animal husbandry within a very short time and began living in fixed or semi-fixed settlements. Some of these found in archaeological sites are around 11,000 years old such as those at Göbekli Tepe & Çatalhöyük show a sophisticated type of architecture and artwork we would feel comfortable in today.
What pressures and influences initiated this drastic change in individual and group behaviour and why had it not happened before?
Relevant answer
Answer
In the past, many thousands of years ago, our ancestors were mostly nomadic. The next stage was the sedentary lifestyle, when man learned to grow plants and raise livestock. Agriculture has been a key factor in converting from a nomadic lifestyle to a sedentary one. Subsequently, the development of craftsmanship and manufacturing involving the creation of various tools of useful agricultural and other tools contributed to the sedentary mode. Currently, sedentary mode continues, for example in connection with working at the computer. However, in a situation where we work for many hours in a sedentary mode, it is important to also carry out physical activity as a break from work, as a hobby, etc. This issue is important for health.
Best regards,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
7 answers
especially in Europe
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
40 answers
I raise this as a point of discussion.
Two days ago I heard a news story about newly found ca. 6,000 year old hillfort at Khirbet Abu al-Husayn in the Jordan desert.  The remarkable stonework at Goblekli Tepe are 9,000 years old.  While in Malta there are sophisticated ruins dating back to 4,000 BC.  The old tradition of civilisation arising in Mesopotamia and Egypt is looking fragile.
Is anyone working on consolidating this new archaeological evidence to redraw the time line of human history?
And what other recent archaeological finds should be added to this picture?
Relevant answer
Answer
Breaking News.
From what I've read of it since first posting this question, Gobleki Tepe appears to have developed a a regular ritual assembly point for hunter-gather communities. (I'm grossly oversimplifying here.) It was not a place of human settlement.
News coming on line in the past few days has now revealed the discovery of an ancient city housing 2,000+ people, close to modern Jerusalem. This city appears to have been roughly as old as Gobekli Tepe. The site apparently includes large buildings, dwelling, ritual, public function and burial places, with alleys between the buildings.
You can read about it here.
And here
The latter, and other news reports does include a photo of what looks like a bronze spearhead that is anachronistic. This may be just journalistic licence - and ignorance, or an artifact found on site during the excavations from a much later time period that overlay the much older city.
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
2 answers
X-Ray Diffraction analyses made on Neolithic beads from Sudan have identified them as Natrolite, a silicates aluminum and variety of Zeolite. Does anyone know any analogy please? And where are the sources of this material in Africa? Many thanks!
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Hala,
After a quick search, I found reference to natrolite beads in a 1973 issue of the Nyame Akuma newsletter. Please check the link for downloading the pdf below. Hope it helps!
Cheers,
Tiago
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
10 answers
Does anybody know support-pots with a rectangular shape such as those from the attached picture dated in Neolithic or other prehistoric periods?
In Romania, they are specific to Boian culture, final phases (ca. 5000-4500 BC).
Thanks in advance.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Catalin,
I hope you will find which you searched at the below.
Özdoğan, M. 1983“Pendik: A Neolithic Site of Fikirtepe Culture in the Marmara Region”, R. M. Boehmer ve H. Hauptmann (yay.) Beiträge zur Altertumskunde Kleisasien, Festschrift für Kurt Bittel: 401-411. Verlag Philipp von Zabern, Mainz.
Özdoğan, M. 1989“Neolithic Cultures of Northwestern Turkey”, S. Bökönyi (yay.) Neolithic of Southeastern Europe and its Near Eastern Connections: 201-215. Varia Archaeologica Hungarica II, Budapest.
 Özdoğan, M., Y. Miyake ve N. Özbaşaran-Dede 1991“An Interim Report on the Excavations at Yarımburgaz and Toptepe in Eastern Thrace”, Anatolica XVII: 59-121.
Özdoğan, M. 1996“Tarihöncesi Çağlarda İstanbul/ İstanbul during Prehistoric Periods”, M. Beykan (yay.), İstanbul, World City: 88-101. HABİTAT II, Türkiye Ekonomik ve Toplumsal Tarih Vakfı, İstanbul. written in turkish
Özdoğan, M. 1999“Northwestern Turkey: Neolithic Cultures in Between the Balkans and Anatolia”, M. Özdoğan ve N. Başgelen (yay.) Neolithic in Turkey: 203-224. Arkeoloji ve Sanat Yayınları, İstanbul.
Özdoğan, M. 2000“The Appearance of Early Neolithic Cultures in Northwestern Turkey. Some Problems”, S. Hiller ve V. Nikolov (yay.) Karanovo III Beiträge zum Neolithikum in Südosteuropa: 165-170. Phoibos Verlag, Wien.
Özdoğan, M. 2003“The Prehistory of Northwestern Turkey”, D. V. Grammenos (yay.) Recent Research in the Prehistory of the Balkans: 329-368. Archaeological Institute of Northern Greece and the Archaeological Receipts Fund, Thessaloniki.
Özdoğan, M. 2004“The Fourth Millennium in Eastern Thrace: an Archaeological Enigma”, B. Hänsel ve E.Studeniková (yay.) Zwischen Karpaten und Ägäis. Neolithikum und Ältere Bronzezeit: 19-26. Verlag Marie Leidorf GmbH, Rahden.
Özdoğan, M. 2011“Eastern Thrace: The Contact Zone between Anatolia and the Balkans”, S. R. Steadman ve G. McMahon (yay.) The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Anatolia (10,000-323 B.C.E.): 657-682. Oxford University Press, New York.
best regards,
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
16 answers
I am interested in relevant archaeological evidences from any areas and periods.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Rigaud,
There is an ancient reference of a burial urn from the brazilian Amazon (Maracá tradition), with glass beads used as decoration. It's on page 53 of the pdf contained at the link below.
Nevertheless, as far as I know, there are no known examples of this in the currently known urns. There is no reason to doubt the description, but this means we cannot confirm the information nowadays...
Hope it helps
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
18 answers
Do you believe in portable XRF dating of desert varnish?
Do you think that associated dates for single component sites spatially associated with the rock art are reasonable?
What techniques have you used?
How have you attempted to obtain chronological controls?
Relevant answer
Answer
Well said, Alicia: Each pictograph or petroglyph must be evaluated for possible dating on its own merits. I chose micro-stratigraphy because most people can do it with very simple equipment. Bryan.
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
4 answers
Does anybody know Lithoglyphus pygmaeus specimens (or ornaments manufactured from this gastropod) discovered in prehistoric sites?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Cătălin,
From what I could find on a quick search on the Internet, I understand that L. pygmaeus is a species currently found only near the Danube in the area of Giurgiu (http://www.iucnredlist.org/details/156068/0).
It may be possible that the species had a larger geographic range in the past, but, just in case it didn't, I suggest you also look for information on ornaments made from other Lythoglyphus species, as close comparison material.
For example, L. naticoides was used in prehistoric times for making ornaments. Here's a paper that can get you started:
Apparently, a L. naticoides necklacewas also found in Romania:
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
14 answers
I need some literature about Linear Pottery ceramics and its impact on the neolithisation of Central and Western Europe?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Vera,
I would reccomend:
Maria Cladders, Die Tonware der Ältesten Bandkeramik. Untersuchung zur zeitlichen und räumlichen Glliederung. Universitätsforschungen zur Prähistorischen Archäologie 72 (Bonn 2001).
and also:
Bart Vanmontfort, Leendert P. Louwe Kooijmans, Luc W. S. W. Amkreutz, Leo B. M. Verhart (eds.),  Pots, Farmers and Foragers. Pottery traditions and social interaction in the earliest Neolithic of the Lower Rhine Area. Archaeological Studies Leiden University 20 (Leiden 2010).
online here:
and a single chapters here:
Erich Claßen, Some technological aspects of LBK and non-LBK pottery in the Rhineland . p. 115-124.
Maybe these papers are also of help:
Juraj Pavúk / Zdeněk Farkaš, Beitrag zur Gliederung der älteren Linearbandkeramik. in: Alexandra Anders / Gabriella Kulcsár / Gábor Kalla, Viktória Kiss / Gábor V. Szabó (eds.), Moments in time. Papers presented to Pál Raczky on his 60th birthday. Ősrégészeti Tanulmányok / Prehistoric Studies (Budapest 2013) 213-236.
Juraj Pavú, Typologische Geschichte der Linearbandkeramik. In: Jens Lüning / Christiane Frirdich / Andreas Zimmermann (eds.), Die Bandkeramik im 21. Jahrhundert. Symposium in der Abtei Brauweiler bei Köln vom 16.9.-19.9.2002. Internationale Archäologie - Arbeitsgemeinschaft, Symposium, Tagung, Kongress, Band 7 (Rahden / Westfalen 2005) 17-39.
(use Google for the last ...).
Best regards,
Stefan
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
10 answers
The Thera  eruption destroyed most of the island today known as Santorini.
Akrotiri, located on the eastern tip of the island, was destroyed as the archaeological excavations show at present..
Nevertheless, no human remains have been found wit the exception of a few skeletons.
The primary question is: What happened to the Akrotiri population of which no remains have been found?
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with George, they did not stay around to see what will be the end of the volcanic activity on their island. Also, no gold was ever found in the ruins suggesting they left with some possessions. Where did they go? Well, the first "Americans" landed in the Gulf of Mexico some short time later and became the first settlers, the Olmecs. Coincidence ? I think not! Only expert mariners like the Minoans could have crossed the Atlantic to get there.  
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
12 answers
I would be very grateful if anybody was interested in my research about the clay balls - rounded handy sized clay objects. I am trying to distinguish among them, sort them according to the dimensions, weight and shape. I will compare them with the artefacts assigned as sling balls from the sites where they are attested. If anybody has a good database (e.g.. xls data sheets) of clay balls from Halafian sites and wants to share it, please contact me.
I need this for my master thesis.
Greetings, 
Relevant answer
Answer
If the Sitagroi vol 2 is not available in your library I can scan  the pertinent chapter , etc.
and send to you. Let me know.
ESE 
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
17 answers
Donald E. Brown's book, "Human Universals", explores and describes physical and behavioral characteristics that can be considered universal among all cultures, all people. I have not been able to get my hands on a copy of that work. Can someone who has read the book tell me if Brown employed a systematic cross-cultural analysis? Or did he employed a different methodology? If so, what was the procedure he used to determine which traits are ubiquitous in human societies? Are his findings robust and reliable? Or are they based on a somewhat haphazard survey of regionally isolated studies?
Relevant answer
Answer
Methodology is not normally a term applied to writing a book (as opposed, say, to doing field or laboratory research), or at least not that sort of a book. 
In a sense the book 'Human Universals' is a "review" of the literature.  They are written all the time in many fields (n psychology, sociology, and of course anthropology). But there is no standard methodology for writing a book about cultural or biological universals. Brown did search the term 'universals' to go through various published journal indexes that listed references for further investigation.  
 In particular, aside from the anthropological evidence for cultural and biological universals, Brown paid attention to the evidence in psychology and evolutionary psychology.  
He also drew on his own field experiences in Brunei, Bali, Mexico, and of course the US--hence he relied on the comparative method.  That in turn was much supplemented by a long interest in world ethnography.  He had prepared for field work in Latin America.  He studied with Africanists (Leo Kuper, M.G. Smith, Victor Turner) to learn British Social Anthro, and thereby read a lot of African ethnography.  All this adds up to the comparative method.
 There is a section of my book where Brown discusses how he assessed the universality of problematic cases for universals and he dealt with the quantitative issue of absolute vs near universals. Much of this is not dignified with the term methodology but is standard method across many fields as part of what constitutes objective or scientific writing.
Brown followed in the footsteps of Murdock and others who had focused on the study of universals, but produced a more nuanced account of universals that had been neglected by the majority of anthropologists who tended to focus on cultural differences.  
Of course Brown does not deny tremendous cultural variation and differences throughout the world.   But the neglect of cultural and biological universals often led anthropologists to 'exoticize' humans in various regions of the world, reducing the ability to empathize with the so-called 'other.'   Anthropologists must emphasize both the similarities and differences of people and societies they investigate to produce a more comprehensive understanding of humanity.  
Question
19 answers
I have discovered these objects from a 3rd millennium BC site.
Relevant answer
Answer
That children have made the small ceramic utensils found in excavations, I have seen already in imported Late Bronze Cypriote pottery found in Akko, Israel.
Concerning measuring the width of fingerprints taking into account the shrinkage of clay, we should be careful because every clay has a different shrinking characteristic depending on the amount of water, hygroscopic water and mineral water (yes, three types of water) on the one hand and the firing temperature of a potter's kiln on the other.
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
8 answers
Iron Age, Scotland, Subterranean, Cave, ritual, not including Souterrrains. Thank you. A site name would help, an excavator name would help more, links to papers or details of publication would be best.
Relevant answer
Answer
There are the Iron Age burials from MacArthur’s Cave in the article by Saville and Hallén in Antiquity.  Also, how about the cisterns in brochs, said by various people, e.g. Mike Williams in his Prehistoric Belief book, to be like Mine Howe?  Could you see Neolithic tombs as being thought of by Iron Age people as a kind of cave, suitable for offerings, as at Calf of Eday Long (Calder's excavations).
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
3 answers
research for master thesis
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Barbora Kubikova,
I've visited quite a few kites and haven't noticed anything resembling sling balls in or near them. (Of course, it's possible that they are buried beneath aeolian deposits). Alison Betts, who has considerable experience with kites, hasn't mentioned them in any of her many publications. We have recovered large numbers of smooth spherical and ovate quartz pebbles from the interior of collapsed Late Neolithic houses at Wisad Pools, and it is conceivable that they  were used as sling balls, but I think instead that they are gizzard stones from large birds such as hubaras and ostriches that were processed in the abandoned houses.
Best wishes,   Gary Rollefson
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
8 answers
I'm looking for evidence for bone projectile points in Neolithic pre-pottery and pottery of the Near East. Can anybody point out relevant literature?
Relevant answer
Answer
Not direct injuries, but some studies on neolithic arrows from central Portugal here
Sadly only in portuguese.
Will try to translate it into a more common language, and updated with most recent findings.
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
7 answers
Has anyone tried converting data obtained with a Bruker Tracer III-V+ pXRF to be comparable to data obtained with the new Tracer III-SD? I'm working on obsidian and I have tried both compressing and expanding the spectrum but the numbers do not even come close to being comparable.
Relevant answer
Dear Veerle,
I have not yet contacted Bruker, but that's my next step if the RG community is also unable to help me with this problem :). Thanks for your suggestion.
The issue, as I detailed above, is not that they instruments are yielding different results in terms of elemental counts (same elements are being detected), this is to be expected. But that I was told that you can either expand the channels or compress them to make data collected on two different instruments comparable. But this is just not working out. I have tried making the old data comparable to the new by expanding its spectrum channel from 1024 to 2048 and have tried the reverse and neither work.
Again, thanks for  your suggestion!
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
28 answers
This zoomorphic figurine - a lion - alabaster made, is a fortuitous find on a chalcolithic tell settlement (Gumelnita, ca. 4000 BC) in Teleorman county, southern Romania. This is a quite unusual representation for this period.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Cristi,
I think you already know the lioness clay figurine from Goljamo Delcevo tell settlement (Bulgaria), belonging to KGK VI cultural complex, published by  Fol, A., J. Lichardus (eds.). 1988. Macht, Herrschaft und Gold: das Graberfeld von Varna (Bulgarien) und die Anfänge einer neuen europäischen Zivilisation. Saarbrücken, Moderne Galerie des Saarland-Museums.
This figurine was republished by  H. Manhart 1998, Vorgeschichtliche Fauna Bulgariens. Die vorgeschichtliche Tierwelt von Koprivec und Durankulak und anderen prähistorischen Fundplätzen in Bulgarien aufgrund von Knochenfunden aus archäologischen Ausgrabungen. Documenta Naturae 116: 3-353 (also with additional data about lion bones in Neolithic and Eneolithic periods from SE Europe) and  N.R. Thomas 2004, The Early Mycenaean Lion up to Date. In: Anne P. Chapin (ed.), Xάρις. Essays in Honor of Sara A. Immerwahr, Hesperia Supplement 33: 161-206 (see attach).
Best wishes,
Catalin
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
16 answers
In the summer of 2014, we discovered a new Eneolithic cemetery at Sultana (Romania), and near one of the skeletons we identified a fragment of red ocher bead.
Does anybody know other similar artefacts from prehistory or other time periods?
Thanks in advance.
Relevant answer
Answer
Alright, as no one else has answered yet I'll have a crack!
When you say a fragment of red ochre bead do you mean a bead made of an iron oxide mineral (such as hematite) or a bead made out of other materials (such as clay or shell) that has been coloured using an iron oxide pigment?
Ochre has been used as to colour objects associated with personal adornment for a long, long time. In 2007 there was the widely reported discovery of 82,000 year old shell beads with ochre traces from the Grotte des Pigeons in Morocco (link to the paper in PNAS below).
A good general place to start looking for information on the use of iron oxides (both as objects and pigments) is George Rapp's book Archaeomineralogy (2009). A couple of relevant pages are available to preview on Google Books (linked below).
One of the points that Rapp raises is that there is, amongst archaeologists, often a lot of confusion over exactly what we mean when we say 'ochre' (with it frequently being applied to anything a bit reddish). Following on from this I was wondering if you'd managed to have the bead analysed or if it's designation as red ochre was solely based on the colour. If the latter then it might be worth (if the budget is available or there is a friendly scientist nearby) having it analysed to check if it is indeed red ochre, another iron oxide pigment (such as umber) or a different colourant entirely. 
As to the main point of your question: I'm not a prehistorian, so am afraid I can't provide any examples or parallels for your region or period.  Hopefully someone with real knowledge will be along shortly to answer :)
Edit: removed the bit about contacting Dušan since I saw via ResearchGate that you know him already, sorry!
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
5 answers
I am looking for a relevant archaeological synthesis on the Neolithic periods of Corsica, South France, Italy and Sicily, possibly with data on lithic material consumption.
Relevant answer
Answer
  • asked a question related to Neolithic Archaeology
Question
1 answer
a) My interest in Neolithic face (NF) began by serendipitous observations along 1000 miles long Sepik River of Papua New Guinea in 1971. I noted a consistent basic difference between the face depictions in the art the frequently visited and missionized (literate) Middle Sepik region as against the exclusive NF representation in drawings as well as in the ritual sacred art of the pre-literate Upper Sepik River region (that had only been opened since the late 1960’s Even then it was rarely visited, since the Swiss expert Alfred Buehler had written:“there is virtually nothing in the way of art in the Upper Sepik region”.
However, by chance , shortly after the completion of a ritual, I came across Upper Sepik sacred ritual woodcarvings and clay figures.which were all destroyed after one use, since they had lost their “mana”. Such ritual objects presented “neolithic faces” and were very rarely revealed to strangers not even to the expert Dr. Douglas Newton . (He graciously acknowledged the authenticity of my collection in writing and told me that he had spent 3 x 6 months each looking in vain specifically for such art for the then Rockefeller Museum of Primitive Art in New York City).
b) After having tested many face drawing with the DAPF, I identified certain “ visual or spatial” dyslexics (from a Heidelberg School, where 3rd grade students had not yet been taught how to draw a face (in contrast to schools in USA, where Sesami Street had also already been on TV) .
c) The face drawing test, was later supplemented by culture-fair modifications of the Kohs Block Design test and administered to pre-literate “stone-age” Amazonian Auca Indians (Brain & Cognition l989;10:54-75) and to various hunter-gatherers on 3 continents, eg. Experientia (was available in the HMS Reference Room) 1976;32:1431-1435 – same, 1980;36:83-86 – same, 1982;38:579-587..
Note: Many drawings of the human body by various tribes people, photo copies of the 30 Upper Sepik River ritual objects (Figs 1 & 2, JAMWA 1974;29:434-444) reprints on NF and travel diary are available on HOLLIS : http://www.radcliffe.edu/schlesinger_library.aspx (Click on HOLLIS Classic and search on Pontius, Anneliese Alma.). ”
d 1) Using NF and control masks, I tested newborns’ reflex-like wide-open mouth “smiling response” (disappearing after c. 4 months of life) . The newborns “smiled” significantly faster ( p< 0.001) to “neolithic face“ patterns than to 4 control masks, including my natural face (Experientia 1975;31:126-128).
. d2) As an example of the very short time widow of the “smiling response” (probably fostering bonding between newborn and care giver) consider my accidental observations of one- year- olds, who happened to enter the test situation while NF masks were worn .These infants screamed with fright and clang to their nurses’ legs.
Such fright reaction to “NF” by persons older than 4 months has also been reported to me by the Upper Sepik art expert Dr. Douglas Newton, who graciously explained to me that my 5 small clay-faces with NF (JAMWA 1974 29: 435-44, Fig’s 1 & 2) were used to frighten children into weaning. Further, shields with NF, he said, were used during fights to frighten the enemies.
(Not by accident, it seems, do certain modern artists, and particularly advertisers etc show NF’ patterns to catch attention).
Supporting the innateness of the neuro-developmentally early pattern of NF are the following findings (as listed in the Encyclopedia of Human Biology 1997:Vol. 3:513-527).
a) NF is reacted to preferentially during the brief-lasting period of the reflex-like wide-open-mouth “smiling response” existing only up to 4 months of age (Pontius., Experientia 1975;31:126-128 (above).
b NF resurfaces regressively in the pathological dysfunction of the posterior neocortex in prosop-agnosia, where specifically the familiar face is no longer recognized, since it appears to the patient as “flattened out”, “without any relief” (J.Bodamer ,Arch .Psychiatrie & Nervenkrankheiten 1947:179:6-54) . Such a dysfunction erases precisely the subtle visuo-spatial processing of the root of the nose area (as tested by the DAPF).
Such rare patients’ few published face drawings also show mostly NF.
c) NF also re-appears regressively in the drawings of US-educated “skid row” alcoholics (Pontius, Ann. New York Academy Sci’s, 1985;444:475-477.)
d) Strikingly, the NF resurfaces as an apparently unchanging global schema, persisting even in a patient suffering from “unilateral neglect” of one side of the visual field due to a unilateral parieto-occipital tumor, as unwittingly depicted by A.R. Luria (“Higher Cortical Functions in Man”, Basic Books, 1980, Fig. 41). This patient “copied” from samples only one half of all non-human objects. However he “copied” even from normal face samples both(!) sides of NF.
Consistency between Hypothesizing on “amygdalar shortcut” processing (Pontius 1998) and that proposed by neuroscientists (2003)
Intriguingly and independently recent research by neuroscientists using fMRI & ERPS (Science 2003;300:568-569, Fig. 1) has engendered the same hypothesis of a second , i.e. amygdalar visual pathway with faster (by c. 250 msec) but cruder processing, by-passing refined neocortical processing., exemplified by their “blurred face” in Fig. 1.
Their “blurred face” is consistent with NF: both omit any indication of the suble visuo-spatial relations of the root of the nose area
Correspondingly, I too had hypothesized in regard to NF the existence of “amygdalar shortcut” processing, by-passing refined neocortical processing, to explain the crude NF (HMS Research Day Poster Session 1989).
That such a coarse processing is also faster and might be life-saving was supported by significant results of the two tests (above) with pre-literate tribes peoples living in constant fear for life due to warring neighbors in remote areas on 3 continents. By contrast, non-NF face drawings were produced by peaceful and largely literate controls living nearby (Aggression & Violent Behavior (Elsevier) 2005:10:363-373.
Thus, future use of NF patterns may prove valid and meaningful within its naturalistic context in certain sophisticated research designs related to the human face pattern.
Relevant answer
Answer
Is NF an innate schema mediated by the parieto-occipital systerm?