Science topic

Metaphor - Science topic

The application of a concept to that which it is not literally the same but which suggests a resemblance and comparison. Medical metaphors were widespread in ancient literature; the description of a sick body was often used by ancient writers to define a critical condition of the State, in which one corrupt part can ruin the entire system. (From Med Secoli Arte Sci, 1990;2(3):abstract 331)
Questions related to Metaphor
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
  • metaphors
  • water metaphors
  • air metaphors
  • linguistic invisibilization of physical/technical infrastructure
  • risks of technically invisibilizing language
  • benefits of using metaphors to understand complex technical infrastructure like the internet
Relevant answer
Answer
I think a visual linked-node network image is helpful. It is the image that inspired Tim Berners-Lee to create it in the first place, hence the "net" part of the name. An orb-spider's web is another useful image, especially as it puts the user into the centre of the network as the spider-controller. Sometimes a visual metaphor is worth a thousand words.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
7 answers
We will time-travel to the time of Christ by looking at the language and culture of Afghanistan. In this PowerPoint, you will see a student’s wooden chalk board to help Afghan children learn verses from the Khoran, an Afghan Coloring Book, and a straw picture of Two Important Afghan Words: “Muhammad” and “Allah”
The Afghan language (Dari) is rich in metaphor. The Afghan word for a Prickly Pear Cactus is “zabane mader showhar” (which translates as “mother-in-law’s tongue.” The Afghan word for Ostrich is “shotor-morgh” which translates as “elephant hen.” The Afghan word for Popcorn is “chos e fil” which means “elephant’s fart. Another Afghan word for Popcorn is “pof e fil” which means “elephant’s puff.” The Afghan word for Lady Bird (the insect) is “kafsh duzak” which means “little shoe-smith.” A Turkey in Afghan Persian is “fil morgh” which means “elephant chicken.” And a Turtle is “sang posht” which means “rock back.”
Our favorite Afghan metaphor is their word for Walnut. A Walnjt is called “chahar maghs” which means “four brains.” If you think about it, that’s what a Walnut actually looks like—four brains.
From 1967-1969, when the Nilsen family lived in Kabul, Afghanistan we saw many beautiful English signs that were mostly misspelled, but the misspellings are perfectly logically. Our favorite sign advertised flowers, and the wording on the sign was “Flower and Buket Maker.” It took us a while to figure this one out. What the sign meant to saywas “Flower and bouquet maker.”
Relevant answer
Answer
Don and Alleen Nilsen have prepared PowerPoints for each chapter of their Language of Humor (Cambridge University Press, 2019).
If you would like to receive the PowerPoint related to any of the following chapters, please request it from Don Nilsen on Research Gate or at don.nilsen@asu.edu :
Chapter 1: Introduction & Humor Theories Chapter 2: Humor in Anthropology & Ethnic Studies Chapter 3: Humor in Art Chapter 4: Humor in Business Chapter 5: Humor in Computer Science Chapter 6: Humor in Education Chapter 7: Humor in Gender Studies Chapter 8: Humor in Geography (International Humor: Books, Conferences and Organizations) Chapter 9: Humor in Gerontology Chapter 10: Humor in History Chapter 11: Humor in Journalism Chapter 12: Humor in Law Chapter 13: Humor in Linguistics Chapter 14: Humor in Literature Chapter 15: Humor in Medicine and Health Chapter 16: Humor in Music Chapter 17: Humor in Names and Naming Chapter 18: Humor in the Performing Arts Chapter 19: Humor in Philosophy Chapter 20: Physical Humor Chapter 21: Humor in Politics Chapter 22: Humor in Psychology Chapter 23: Humor in Religion Chapter 24: Humor in Rhetoric and Composition Chapter 25: Humor in Sociology
If you would like to receive any of the PowerPoints above, please contact Don Nilsen on Research Gate, or e-mail me at don.nilsen@asu.edu .
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
Compare and Contrast Plant and Food Metaphors in English with Those in Other Languages
Here are some English proverbs based on plants and food:
1. Don’t put all of your eggs in one basket.
2. He jumped out of the frying pan into the fire.
3. He spilled the beans.
4. He’s nutty as a fruit cake, or He wants everything, from soup to nuts.
5. It’s as easy as pie, or She’s upper crust.
6. She’s buttering him up.
7. It’s like comparing apples and oranges.
8. Life is a box of chocolates.
9. That’s how the cookie crumbles.
10. There’s no accounting for taste.
11. You have to crack some eggs to make an omelet.
Check out the attached PowerPoint about Plant and Food Metaphors, and then discuss Plant and Food Metaphors in English and other languages.
Relevant answer
Answer
Chuck: I love your insights. Keep them coming.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
7 answers
Compare and Contrast Body-Part Metaphors in English and Other Languages
Linguistic or conceptual body-part metaphors relate not only to Heads, Shoulders, Knees, and Toes, but also to Eyes, Ears, Mouth and Nose and other human body parts.
Here are a few English metaphors related to “head”: head of lettuce, head of a company, head over heels in love, head Start, headers & footers, and headlights.
Check out the attached PowerPoint about Body Part Metaphors, and then discuss body-part metaphors in English and other languages.
Relevant answer
Answer
Virginia: Excellent. I'll send you some more examples.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
4 answers
Clothing Metaphors in English and in Other Languages
There are many linguistic or conceptual clothing metaphors in English. The outskirts and skirting an issue are marginal. “Girdle” relates to the “girth” of a horse. You might have something up your sleeve, related to magic.
In American English we refer to the “Hood” of a car, but in British English it is the “Bonnet.”
During the French revolution, “le jacquerie” referred to any person not important enough to be given a name, so in Charles Dickens’s Tale of Two Cities three of the characters are named Jacques Un, Jacques Deux, and Jacques Trois. “Jack” is a generic term for person, so we have the game of jacks, and “Jackets” for people, for books, and for records. There is also the “Jack of all trades.”
“Pants” comes from the “pantaloons” of Commedia dell’arte (16th C);
Sabotage comes from the wooden shoes that some French people wore—“sabots,” which they would throw into the machinery that was taking their jobs.
In American English there is the “Trunk” of a car, but in British English, this is the “boot.”
If a woman wears the pants in the family, she is in charge.
Check out the attached PowerPoint about Clothing Metaphors, and then discuss clothing metaphors in English and other languages
Relevant answer
Answer
Mehvish: Glad you liked it.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
English Animal Metaphors
Linguistic or conceptual animal metaphors in English and other languages fall into three categories:
1. Domestic (Cats, Chickens, Cows, Dogs, Donkeys, Goats, Horses, Mice, Rats, Sheep, etc.),
2. Fish & Water Animals (Crabs, Clams, Fish, Oysters, etc.),
3. Wild Animals (Bears, Buffalo, Foxes, Lions, Monkeys, Shrews, Tigers, etc.).
Compare and contrast the Animal Metaphors that occur in English with Animal Metaphors in other languages.
Relevant answer
Answer
Vietnamese: nó cáo già lắm. ('he/ she is an old fox'). This sentence could be explained by the fact that the person mentioned is cunning and has tricks up their sleeve.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
English Animal Metaphors
Linguistic or conceptual animal metaphors in English and other languages fall into three categories:
1. Domestic (Cats, Chickens, Cows, Dogs, Donkeys, Goats, Horses, Mice, Rats, Sheep, etc.),
2. Fish & Water Animals (Crabs, Clams, Fish, Oysters, etc.),
3. Wild Animals (Bears, Buffalo, Foxes, Lions, Monkeys, Shrews, Tigers, etc.).
Compare and contrast the Animal Metaphors that occur in English with Animal Metaphors in other languages.
Relevant answer
Answer
Brian: Good point. I'll make the additions. Thanks for your help.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
My work will contribute to the field of TESOL and Applied Linguistics. I’ll investigate the theory of conceptual metaphor by G. Lakoff (2004) and the theory of metaphorical modelling by A.P. Chudinov (2001). We’ll use in our research Metaphor Identification Procedure (MIP) which was introduced by E. Semino from Lancaster University (Pragglejaz group, 2007). Most of the previous works provided theoretical explanation of the metaphor, i.e. they analyzed its source domains and target domain (Lakoff, 2004) and metaphorical models within some types of discourse (Chudinov, 2001) or functions of metaphors in different kinds of discourses (Terry, 2019). What we want to do is to show that metaphors can be taught not from theoretical, but from the practical perspective and therefore it can make better teachers out of us; students will be able to understand more sophisticated forms of the language, i.e. it will develop students’ vocabulary (Tier 2, academic words) and it will develop students’ metaphor awareness.
Relevant answer
Answer
If you are at all interested in a very fine-grained look at this, there are several pieces of reserch that look at how metaphor awareness can help with phrasal verbs, specifically:
Boers, F. (2004). Expanding learners’ vocabulary through metaphor awareness:What expansion, what learners, what vocabulary? In M. Achard & S. Niemeier(Eds.), Cognitive linguistics, second language acquisition, and foreign language teaching(pp. 211–232).
Spring, R. (2018). Teaching phrasal verbs more efficiently: Using corpus studies and cognitive linguistics to create a particle list. Advances in Language and Literary Studies, 9(5), 121-135.
Yasuda, S. (2010). Learning Phrasal Verbs Through Conceptual Metaphors: A Case of Japanese EFL Learners. TESOL Quarterly, 44(2), 250-273.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
4 answers
PRAGMATICS AND HUMOR
It is amazing how many ways we have of displaying and presenting various types of lexical and pragmatic information. These displays and presentations are at various levels of abstraction, detail and presentation medium. They are chosen to represent time, space, significance, and other relative differences.
Consider the following: Advertisement, Audio-Visual Aid, Bar Graph, Bell-Shaped Curve, Blood Lines, Caricature, Cartoon, Category, Cause-Effect Line, Chain of Command, Chinese Boxes, Drawing, Family Tree, Floor Plan, Flow Chart, Hierarchy, Map, Matrix, Musical Score, Outline, Photograph, Diagram (e.g. Reed Kellogg), Set, Sketch, Time Line, Tree Diagram, Venn Diagram, etc. This lexical and pragmatic information can be presented over various mediums. Consider the following: Book, Card Catalogue, Catalogue, Chalk Board, Cell Phone, Internet, Journal, Magazine, Movie, PowerPoint, Radio, Skype, Teleconference, Telephone, Video Stream, Webinar, White Board, Zoom, etc. And information can be organized alphabetically, numerically, sequentially, spatially, etc.
Lexical items can also be semantically weighted, and related to other lexical items in various ways, and these weightings and relationships can be quantified (always, usually, sometimes, seldom, never, etc. I believe that the most important feature of Linguistics Pragmatics is that it is unlike all of the other levels of linguistics (Phonology, Morphology, Syntax, and Semantics) by being a non-linear approach. Kenneth Pike said that language can be viewed as Particles, as Waves (assimilation or dissimilation), or as Field. It is only Pragmatics that looks at language as Field (see above).
Another very important aspect of Pragmatics is the developing field of Script-Model Grammar. Victor Raskin is a linguist, and linguists tend to deal with one sentence at a time. Script Model Grammar allows linguists to deal with larger texts. Raskin talks about the structure of a joke by saying that everything in the set-up of the joke is ambiguous but primed in the direction of the mundane. What the punch line of a joke does is to change the priming of the joke from the mundane to the dramatic, or scatological, etc. At this point the audience is able to see that the entire joke—set-up and punch line—have been ambiguous, and that the punch line has just changed the priming. Because the punch line allows the audience to see all of the ambiguity of the joke (both mundane and dramatic), the punch line is very epiphanal.
Using the techniques of Script-Model Grammar as developed by Victor Raskin, Salvatore Attardo and others, develop a number of mundane scripts for your computer, as follows:
Eating at a restaurant
Getting a haircut
Getting dressed in the morning
Going to a concert
Going to a movie
Telling a joke or a story
Traveling by car
Traveling by plane
Traveling by subway
Traveling by train
Etc.
Tell your computer the details of the script in terms of a sequence of behaviors. For example, consider the script of “eating at a restaurant.”
1. You get hungry.
2. You look for a restaurant.
3. You find a restaurant.
4. You walk into the restaurant.
5. You’re seated by someone.
6. The server brings you a menu.
7. You look at the menu.
8. You order your meal.
9. You eat your meal.
10. Someone brings you a bill.
11. You pay the bill.
12. You leave a tip.
13. You leave the restaurant.
But what if one or more of the sequence of behaviors is missing? Or what if one or more behaviors are added to the sequence? The computer can then ask, “Why didn’t he leave a tip? Or “Why did he take his bike into the restaurant?” The computer has been taught how to speculate.
What Victor Raskin did for jokes (small texts), Salvatore Attardo and others did for larger texts (paragraphs, chapters plays, novels, trilogies, etc.). And rather than just dealing with the set-up, the punch-line, and the epiphany of the joke, Attardo developed ways of dealing with double entendre, embodiment, irony, metaphor, metonymy, paradox, parody, sarcasm, satire, synecdoche, allegory, and other types of “language play.” An even more important contribution of Script-Model Grammar, is its applications to the field of Artificial Intelligence. This brings us to the contributions of Christian Hempelmann, Anton Nijholt, Dallin Oaks, Leo Obrst, Maxim Petrenko, Graeme Ritchie, Julia Taylor, Willibald Ruch, Oliviero Stock, Carlo Strapparava, Igor Suslov, and Tony Veale.
Note that Noam Chomsky’s Generative Transformational Grammar has now become Deep Learning in the field of computers. Computers are now able to generate both language and images by receiving input from the entire internet, recombining this information in very sophisticated ways, and producing computer-generated material that is the same as human-generated material, only better. It’s very scary.
Relevant answer
Answer
I am thinking of three dominant trends in pragmatic research: pragma-linguistics, socio-pragmatics, and cognitive pragmatics, each focusing on a particular facet of language use. Pragma-linguistics is championed by Austin and Searle, and is paradoxically known as lexical pragmatics. It studies the linguistic forms that characterize utterances, usually linguistic items and structures in which utterances in a given genre are encoded. Socio-pragmatics, associated with Geoffrey Leech, deals with the socio-cultural contexts in which utterances are used. The more recent trend, cognitive pragmatics, studies the link between cognition and linguistic meaning in context as studied by Nuyts (1992 and 2004), Marmaridou (2000), and others.
I hope this is useful.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
I am writring my dissertation on lexicology, based on word-formation processes in english in the dialogues of the novel We Need New Names written by Noviolet Bulawayo. I want to focus on metaphor
Relevant answer
knowing that word-formation studies the structures and the meaning of words, as well as the rules and patterns that govern their formation. So metaphore is related top word formation because it involves changing of the context of an existion word or expression to make new word or expression. So i want to study the metaphorical aspects of the dialogues used in the novel.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
I am conducting a study on the metaphorical ability of CFL learners.
The question types for studying learners' metaphorical comprehension ability are usually multiple-choice and judgment questions, but the multiple-choice and judgment questions will be blindly correct.
The question types of metaphorical output ability, paraphrase questions, sentence construction questions, and fill-in-the-blank questions are more scientific, but paraphrase questions and sentence construction questions need to control many variables, such as the learner's native language background and second language level must be the same.
Is there a more rigorous type or means of testing questions?
Relevant answer
Answer
If I understood you well, your problem is how to be able to elicit answers about metaphor processing independently of metaphor production proficiency, which is always linguistic in the case of EFL. If I am right in my estimation, the problem of linguistic proficiency in EFL will always persist in this case. However, a way out is to elicit student responses to data, say, in English in their their mother tongue, say, Chinese.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
If the Yacaruna was not at least partially a metaphor for European colonists then what else could the mythological creature have represented?
Relevant answer
Answer
The identity of mythical and legendary characters are archetypal. See the know recurrent features in cultural media in my paper Blueprint. Your suspect is likely to express a cluster of meanings in mixed categories, that would reveal its number, one of the 16 regulars. The character's episodes are also likely to involve recurrent features, look them up in the ATU catalogue.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
1 answer
How likely is rationalism and empiricism a false dichotomy and the real epistemological divide is literal vs metaphorical? Why how?
Relevant answer
Answer
I see the rationalism–empiricism dichotomy as a very powerful tool to organize European history of thought; however, as all concepts, it is constructed. In my perspective, research cannot avoid either — we try to use real-life data (empiricism) to theorize about them (rationalism).
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
Solopova, O. A., Don Nilsen, and Alleen Nilsen. “The Image of Russia through Animal Metaphors: A Diachronic Case Study of American Media Discourse” Russian Journal of Linguistics 27.3 (2023), pp. 521-542. https://journals.rudn.ru/linguistics/issue/view/1690
The image of a country has a critical impact on the degree of its political, economic and cultural influence in the world. This indicates a need to understand various perceptions of a country that exist among other nations and mechanisms of their formation and change in an ever-shifting world. This qualitative case study seeks to examine the changing nature of wild animal metaphors employed to model the image of Russia in American media discourse in the XIX-XXI centuries.
The study is limited by two source domains, namely, the beast and the bear. They were analyzed within particular contexts: American English, culture and media discourse. The research data were drawn from dictionaries and corpora. The dictionaries included etymological and explanatory entries, as well as those covering idioms, symbols, and metaphors.
The corpora research data were collected from the Corpus of Contemporary American English and Chronicling America, a collection of historic digitalized texts. A total of 218 metaphors were selected from 4929 texts. The metaphors were studied through lexicographic, conceptual metaphor, culture-specific, corpus, discourse, and diachronic methods.
The findings of this study suggest that the two metaphors “Russia is a beast” and “Russia is a bear” are frequently used in realizing the strategy of ‘othering’ in XXI century American media discourse. Still, their meanings allowed for variation and modification in the periods of the two countries’ amity and cooperation. In the XIX century and in the years of US-Soviet alliance in WWII the metaphors could evoke positive images of Russia, thus, realizing the strategy of ‘bridging’ or ‘belonging’. The contribution of this study has been to confirm that, whatever metaphorical projections exist in language and culture, historical factors determine choices in any sample of discourse.
This could be important for understanding the mechanisms involved in modeling the image of modern Russia in foreign media discourses.
The image of Russia through animal metaphors: A diachronic case study of American media discourse
Solopova O.A., Nilsen D., Nilsen A.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi,
I guess you mean 20th and 21st century (+ 19th C) - and the answer is: that is a very broad field - and one that hs probably not been given much attention.
Looking at more recent metaphors (looking at the last 50 years) there are some publications like
Marks, Michael P., and Michael P. Marks. "Metaphors of International Political Economy." Revisiting Metaphors in International Relations Theory (2018): 31-89.
or
Andreas Mussloff's "Political Metaphor Analysis"
Clearly, in the 19th and early 20th C, the main European powers - England, France,Germany and Russia would have used a lot of this kind of language to describe other countries, the US, for most of the 19th C a relative backwater and political minion however - there would not be as much material to look at than there is since we have the pax Americana, I guess.
Hope this helps anyway -
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
True or false: Discrepancy exists between Theory of Cave and The Republic (both by Plato). Why or why not?
My answer:
If Plato claimed that elite people were obstructing the visions of the masses with the metaphorical cave then why was he advocating for a Republic ruled by philosophers fought for by soldiers, and financed by merchants? Hence the suspected discrepancy between Plato's Cave and his Republic. MAYBE Plato changed his mind at some point thus causing the discrepancy.
Sources:
Britannica, The Editors of Encyclopaedia. "The Republic". Encyclopedia Britannica, 21 Aug. 2023, https://www.britannica.com/topic/The-Republic. Accessed 26 September 2023.
Relevant answer
Answer
Because the Republic is an indirect proof against a move made away from Socrates iirc in book 2.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
4 answers
How (details), when, and to what extents ? I think these answers would be very telling.
Same questions for ANALOGY
Relevant answer
Answer
Metaphors and analogies are powerful tools for communication, especially when you need to explain complex concepts or ideas. They can help you simplify, illustrate, and connect your message with something familiar, relevant, and memorable.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
6 answers
What is the effect of metaphor as a semiotic structure on the form and meaning of discours
Relevant answer
Answer
Metaphor is a kind of expansion of speech and behavior of significance, it is formed in a conscious way by combining the imagined and the truth, in which emotion mixes with thought, and it is nothing more than a form of liberation; Because it is a conscious and rebellious practice against the laws of the ordinary that leads to an understanding of the intentions with the aim of excitement and persuasion. However, metaphorical acceptance is fraught with many dangers, as its path may be blocked, if a rift occurs in the circle of communication, as the creator and recipient must be close in ideology, to create some balance and adaptation between them. There must be a philosophical and jurisprudential entity that indicates understanding, or adaptation to the achieved semantic given. Metaphor is not only related to private taste and individual inclinations, it is not only an artistic phenomenon that is described as ugliness or approval, because it is a way of human thinking, and his own way of expression, it is intellectual awareness and linguistic management, and the right of the self in its visions of the worlds, and its share of creativity, and an expression of its freedom from restrictions. Understanding and realizing without exaggeration and excess, and thus is the release of the poetic metaphor that may be captured by the authority of normative taste. Metaphor is a linguistic phenomenon that bears the values, functions, knowledge and sciences that the language bears. It is - as "Umberto Eco" sees - the engine of renewal; Because it represents an unexpected result, and the attempt to understand and comprehend it makes it a semiotic mechanism that is manifested in all systems of signs in a way that refers the linguistic interpretation to semiotic mechanisms that are not of the nature of the language used in speech. Therefore, it is studied to find out its pragmatic, interpretive, semantic, and cognitive dimensions, claiming that it transcends the impressionistic view, which sees that metaphor is merely a departure from the expressive habit of replacing the properties of the thing or transferring it to something else that gives the image a meaning other than its original meaning. . We discuss metaphor as "the subject of philosophical, linguistic, aesthetic and psychological thinking" that is understood through interpretation and understanding, in order to know its pragmatic dimensions, especially when it interacts with psychological, semiotic, linguistic, symbolic, mythological, intertextual, and ideological mechanisms, and then it must be studied in its text and context; Because it does not live without a soul, or when it is isolated from its circumstances that produced it, and the activities that surrounded it in its inception and formation, so its formation is within a holistic vision that is not truncated from thought, awareness and conscience. It lives according to the social and cultural laws that regulate its deliberative acceptance. Hence, it constitutes a semiotic system, and the semiotics of metaphor pass through the semiotics of culture, which makes it semantically acceptable, and makes it in terms of humility achieve communication open to understanding and interpretation. Metaphor formation is the pillar of imagination and creativity, as the combination of things presents an innovative image that does not exist in reality, but it is combined in the perceptions when it comes specific to the activities of transformation, replacement, interaction, repulsion, strangeness, and growth, as it is one of the semantic variables that reveal the poet’s abilities to transform meanings, changing them, and deforming them, so they express the heresy of innovative poetic images in speech.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
6 answers
That fires may emit "sparks" is clear, but what of the sparks that can be witnessed while removing a woolen garment on a cold evening or after shuffling across a carpeted room and reaching for a metal object?  There don't even appear to be early references to the phenomenon we identify as static electric sparks.  Any mention in a text or letter qualifies.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you Chuck. William Gilbert did researched magnetic effects in the late 1500s and spent time distinguishing magnets attraction from the activity of electrics (He even coined the term), but beyond electric attraction and repulsion, electric sparks seem to be a rather noteworthy phenomenon that gets little or no attention until much later. It is puzzling that even the occurrence of such sparks is not mentioned in earlier literature, like Chaucer or Malory. Of course they would not be identified as "electric", but it would seem that anyone who has experienced the little shock after touching a grounded object, or heard the crackle or seen the tiny flashes while taking off a woolen sweater might find it worth mentioning or puzzling about.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
4 answers
Dear colleagues,
I am starting to draft an article on the use of metaphors in the theory of management.
Kindly ask you to help me find management metaphors.
Here are examples:
Organization as a living organism;
Organization as a brain (neural network).
Thank you in advance!
Best wishes,
Julia Rastova
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello Julia,
We may look at any organisation as a ship, an so we say: " A ship will sink if it has many shipmasters".
Regards
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
Could you give me information about the connection of myth and metaphor, mythopoetic feautures of metaphor?
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks for your support
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
7 answers
It is amazing how many ways we have of displaying and presenting various types of lexical and pragmatic information. These displays and presentations are at various levels of abstraction, detail and presentation medium. They are chosen to represent time, space, significance, and other relative differences.
Consider the following: Advertisement, Audio-Visual Aid, Bar Graph, Bell-Shaped Curve, Blood Lines, Caricature, Cartoon, Category, Cause-Effect Line, Chain of Command, Chinese Boxes, Drawing, Family Tree, Floor Plan, Flow Chart, Hierarchy, Map, Matrix, Musical Score, Outline, Photograph, Diagram (e.g. Reed Kellogg), Set, Sketch, Time Line, Tree Diagram, Venn Diagram, etc. This lexical and pragmatic information can be presented over various mediums. Consider the following: Book, Card Catalogue, Catalogue, Chalk Board, Cell Phone, Internet, Journal, Magazine, Movie, PowerPoint, Radio, Skype, Teleconference, Telephone, Video Stream, Webinar, White Board, Zoom, etc. And information can be organized alphabetically, numerically, sequentially, spatially, etc.
Lexical items can also be semantically weighted, and related to other lexical items in various ways, and these weightings and relationships can be quantified (always, usually, sometimes, seldom, never, etc. I believe that the most important feature of Linguistics Pragmatics is that it is unlike all of the other levels of linguistics (Phonology, Morphology, Syntax, and Semantics) by being a non-linear approach. Kenneth Pike said that language can be viewed as Particles, as Waves (assimilation or dissimilation), or as Field. It is only Pragmatics that looks at language as Field (see above).
Another very important aspect of Pragmatics is the developing field of Script-Model Grammar. Victor Raskin is a linguist, and linguists tend to deal with one sentence at a time. Script Model Grammar allows linguists to deal with larger texts. Raskin talks about the structure of a joke by saying that everything in the set-up of the joke is ambiguous but primed in the direction of the mundane. What the punch line of a joke does is to change the priming of the joke from the mundane to the dramatic, or scatological, etc. At this point the audience is able to see that the entire joke—set-up and punch line—have been ambiguous, and that the punch line has just changed the priming. Because the punch line allows the audience to see all of the ambiguity of the joke (both mundane and dramatic), the punch line is very epiphanal.
Using the techniques of Script-Model Grammar as developed by Victor Raskin, Salvatore Attardo and others, develop a number of mundane scripts for your computer, as follows:
Eating at a restaurant
Getting a haircut
Getting dressed in the morning
Going to a concert
Going to a movie
Telling a joke or a story
Traveling by car
Traveling by plane
Traveling by subway
Traveling by train
Etc.
Tell your computer the details of the script in terms of a sequence of behaviors. For example, consider the script of “eating at a restaurant.”
1. You get hungry.
2. You look for a restaurant.
3. You find a restaurant.
4. You walk into the restaurant.
5. You’re seated by someone.
6. The server brings you a menu.
7. You look at the menu.
8. You order your meal.
9. You eat your meal.
10. Someone brings you a bill.
11. You pay the bill.
12. You leave a tip.
13. You leave the restaurant.
But what if one or more of the sequence of behaviors is missing? Or what if one or more behaviors are added to the sequence? The computer can then ask, “Why didn’t he leave a tip? Or “Why did he take his bike into the restaurant?” The computer has been taught how to speculate.
What Victor Raskin did for jokes (small texts), Salvatore Attardo and others did for larger texts (paragraphs, chapters plays, novels, trilogies, etc.). And rather than just dealing with the set-up, the punch-line, and the epiphany of the joke, Attardo developed ways of dealing with double entendre, embodiment, irony, metaphor, metonymy, paradox, parody, sarcasm, satire, synecdoche, allegory, and other types of “language play.” An even more important contribution of Script-Model Grammar, is its applications to the field of Artificial Intelligence. This brings us to the contributions of Christian Hempelmann, Anton Nijholt, Dallin Oaks, Leo Obrst, Maxim Petrenko, Graeme Ritchie, Julia Taylor, Willibald Ruch, Oliviero Stock, Carlo Strapparava, Igor Suslov, and Tony Veale.
QUESTION: Should the growing fields of Script-Model Grammar, and Humor Studies be subfields of Pragmatics?
Relevant answer
Answer
Elena: Excellent points. Check out Slide # 29 of this revised PowerPoint about "Speech Acts." Thanks for your help!
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
8 answers
Teaching is a process than utilizes teacher's subject knowledge, pedagogical content knowledge, methods, communicative skills and other resources. Effective teaching is defined as one that has better learning outcomes (definition 1).
This is subjective since even if research shows some forms like student-centered yield better, the parameters are so many that some believe it is overrated.
Some agreement in defining effective teaching as one that is conceptually effective and demanding in execution/preparation (definition 2) in the sense that few can achieve it or maintain its standards are better definitions but this has not gained academic status and validity
Some forms of effective teaching definition 2 include
- congruency in communicative schemes and visuals i.e. showing a diagram that focuses on the process or schematic summary of goal AND strongly effective communicative schemes using antithesis, metaphor etc
- story-based teaching. Being able to substract details to a great degree while keeping the big picture of lesson to be learned and avoid distractions. This is very demanding
Relevant answer
Answer
Over the 30 years that I have been teaching, I have heard some teachers gloat because students drop their courses because the learning concepts are "too hard" for them to understand. In those cases, as a teacher you have limited your own audience to hear your wisdom. And you think that's great! To teach, meet the student(s) where they are, challenge them enough to get them interested, and then add to that initial interest at a pace that allows the students to feed their curiosity. If you are only intrested in showing the students how smart you are, then you are not teaching anything. You are just gloating about your own superiority. Knowing how smart you are, but not knowing why, can't be helpful to students if you are not willing to share your knowledge in a language students can understand. However, if you do share, (1) students will get that you are smart, (2) they will respect your knowledge, and (3) they will learn enough to use the knowledge and/or share it with others.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
129 answers
The reasons for the laughter can be different, not from the aspect of biology, but from the aspect of anthropology, sociology, psychology, politics, humor, cynicism, optimism, morality, non / freedom, hypocrisy ...
Really, why are people laughing?
It is necessary to give a symbolic, laconic, metaphorical ... answer.
Relevant answer
Dear Dr. Harun Hadžić
The mere idea that man is the only being on Planet Earth capable of laughing is as old as Aristotle himself [The parts of animals [PA] 3.1.673a8] since the face of the Human Being and possibly the timeless use of masks has the power to be not only a symbolic and suggestive artifact recognized in various cultures from the West to the East and the use of these masks goes back to the intramontable Greek Comedy that already enclosed in itself not only the idea of ​​appearance, of falsehood , of masking and apparent transformation, even assuming a different identity ranging from the Human to the Divine.
Aristotle [335 B.C.-323 B.C.] knew very well that the mask was not only an artificial satirical outfit but also a psychologically expressive and socially powerful means of communication because it was capable of giving free rein to the imagination as well as being very useful in the literary sphere from comedy to tragedy aimed at exposing the so-called inferiority complex or ridiculing the ideology of adversaries, weak points of heroes or specific sectors of power..
p.d. "Laughter is a bodily exercise precious to health" Aristotle
Photography= Phoenician terracotta mask from the 6th century BC. The purpose of such masks are much debated as knowlege of Carthaginian culture and ritual practice is limited. The similarity to later Greek and Roman theatrical masks of Comedy and Tragedy is striking. Mozia [Motya] Sicily]
Cf.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
6 answers
Linguistic or conceptual body-part metaphors relate not only to Heads, Shoulders, Knees, and Toes, Knees, but also to Eyes, Ears, Mouth and Nose and other human body parts. Here are a few English metaphors related to “head”: head of lettuce, head of a company, head over heels in love, head Start, headers & footers, and headlights. Check out the attached PowerPoint about Body Part Metaphors, and then discuss body-part metaphors in English and other languages.
Relevant answer
Answer
Peter: Excellent response. I especially like your German, Spanish, and Chinese examples.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
1 answer
conceptual metaphor, analogy, or categorization?
Relevant answer
Gravitational waves will bring us exquisitely accurate maps of black holes – maps of their space-time. Those maps will make it crystal clear whether or not what we’re dealing with are black holes as described by general relativity
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
4 answers
Hi all academicians and scholars.
If there are any who are interested in the theories of metaphor and its modern extension, please, text me.
Relevant answer
Answer
Yes, many studies have been conducted on Metaphor. What is exactly your inquiry? The theory of Conceptual metaphor has been conducted within the field of Cognitive Linguistics
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
hello, we're currently doing some research regarding metaphors in the urban environment
and we need some studying regarding the following
1) we need a case study on some city or part of a city about the existence of metaphors and the use of metaphors there for some environmental, functional, social, symbolic or aesthetic end
2) generally any study on metaphors in the urban environment
3) a study categorizing metaphors based on their use (the end which they serve)
Relevant answer
Dear Dr. Abbas Mohammed ,
I consider that it is not enough for us to find an analogy to say that "we are in a metaphor", we often do it through a statement of identity or category of an object or a relevant character. The metaphor continues to be simply the use of one of the many types of "loose language" whose process has always consisted in qualifying the objective that appears before our eyes or simply uses or uses metaphors through the same inferential mechanisms that we apply to any form of language.
In relation to a study categorizing metaphors based on their use [the end which they serve] ou can see my Academic Research Papers,
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
Should they be used indefinitely in order to protect someone from their sensitive data that was leaked?
Relevant answer
Answer
Could the discussion question be made more explicit so that we can contribute to the discussion?
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
8 answers
Can anyone recommend a journal for submission? I am particularly looking for journals that (i) accept pieces in the 800 to 2000 word range, and (ii) that have no publication fees.
Relevant answer
Answer
Here is a free one (Academic Voices) that serves a similar function:
However, I was hoping for a journal that was roughly in the same ballpark as my grammatical topics.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
Rhetorical figures - any of the forms of expression which give beauty, variety, force, etc., to a composition in accordance with the theory and principles of rhetoric, as metaphor, metonym, hyperbole, etc.
A literary trope is the use of figurative language, via word, phrase or an image, for artistic effect such as using a figure of speech.The word trope has also come to be used for describing commonly recurring literary and rhetorical devices, motifs or clichés in creative works.
Relevant answer
Answer
Literary forms enrich utterances in rhetoric
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
7 answers
I am undertaking a new project on "blood metaphors" across languages and cultures. I do have very few references on the topic. I was wondering if members of the RG community can think of or have come across publications on "blood metaphors". Many thanks for your collaboration. Best
Relevant answer
Answer
Just to add to these suggestions: Charteris-Black (2004) discusses the expression "blood is shed" (p. 25).
  • Charteris-Black, J. (2004). Corpus approaches to critical metaphor analysis. Palgrave-Macmillan.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
Can you give some examples to illustrate your opinions?
Relevant answer
Answer
It is the non-standard temporal axis that builds up moral ambiguity. The paradoxical power of time is transforming the borderline between "good" and "evil". By a somewhat simplified definition, this is an image of certain events in the past that can or should only occur in the future, which, in fact, is a goal, an obligation, but not a reality of the past. As a result, good turns into evil, and the other way round.
Did you ever observe other characteristic powers of abnormal temporal axis?
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
10 answers
I am looking for some books on wetland metaphors. Do you know any book or research on wetland metaphors? Even if you can suggest me books on wetland of any culture, any genre, kindly do so.
Relevant answer
Answer
J. C. Tarafdar I have got a PDF copy of the book you mentioned. I think, the book will be helpful for me. Thank you.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
Do you know a NLP research about extraction of sarcastic, metaphorical, polemical and rhetorical phrases in texts? For example, in the text “Find your patience before I lose mine.”
Relevant answer
Answer
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352060308_University_Students'_Attitudes_Towards_Online_English_Postgraduate_Programs
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
4 answers
The Ages of Life and the basic essential connection to the Earth that we all share, regardless of color or Race
Which other cultures have mystical references and metaphors in their music?
And please share examples with us- for our mutual upliftment
Relevant answer
Answer
Yes, many of the new styles, trends and types of music that arose in developed and developing economies from the late 19th century to the present day drew from various forms of music derived from African cultures.
Regards,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
8 answers
Hi.
I am searching for research and experiences in using of metaphors in therapy or/and caring in general. What kind of metaphors do you have an experience of and use? Visual (picture, text), auditive (story telling, proverbs etc...). Do you make a distinction between which metaphor you use and the diagnose?
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you, Keith,
It is a very interesting paper!
My best regards - Sabina
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
18 answers
Hello
Have you ever studied the new, mysterious world of online studies with the help of such a method? (1) visual and textual data generated by students (2) using the status quo metaphors as they are suggested by the students? (3) using such analysis to redesign/transform (change radically, not incrementally) the practice in question? It can be used in studying and transforming any other practice as well. As you can see in the attachment, I require my students to gather visual and textual data about the stakeholders' interactions, not about the individual actions, or perceiving subjects. This is along with the interpretative assumption of Social Practices Theory that every value formation is (1) interactive and contextual to the performed, replicable practice and (2) transformative. The metaphors are tools for interpreting the combined, visual and textual data. The metaphors come from agile teamwork procedures. Combining visual and textual data that explains the former comes from ethnographic studies. Any experiences/expertise/references as to such research method(s)?
Relevant answer
Answer
Effectively study online try to treat some good steps to effective online study Treat an online like a “real” course.., Hold yourself accountable. .Practice time management.,.teacher Create a regular study space and stay organized. .Eliminate distractions., .try figure Out How You learn best it the student essay to understand of learning, Actively participate. and Leverage your network.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
6 answers
I am also looking for some psycholinguists who will willingly help with my research.
Relevant answer
Answer
Alleen Nilsen and I have written two books on the subject: A SOURCE BASED APPROACH TO VOCABULARY INSTRUCTION, VOLUME 1 & 2. Here is a link to that book:
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
Re: It seems a major sort of addition needs to be made to cognitive-developmental ontogeny theory (Ethogram Theory)
I have been out just to describe the developing very early processing and all the later hierarchical developments and processing, yielding the development and the progressing of the [grand/always-important] "outer container" (cognition). These are the levels of/stages of cognitive abilities being most of, and what's central to, guiding behavior: cognition, representation, abstract concepts and thinking, and actions. I NOW do believe something more is involved than I have yet ever indicated (something I avoided). For years and for decades:
I almost perhaps incredulously spoke nothing of emotions. Now I do; BUT, reservedly: I want to "add-in" and speak of just basic, early-on emotions that may be central to ALL cognitive development, per se: in particular it is those that are likely necessary to transfer a level of representation and thinking abilities from one domain (once established in an early domain) to another domain (this is sometimes known as transfer, sometimes as generalization -- neither which captures all that goes on with true hierarchical development with ontogeny).
I have long sought to make emotions (relatively simple response PATTERNS) something that can simply be added-in ("tacked on"), AFTER cognitive ontogenies are under way (which seemed esp. good for AL /AGI). But, the problem of humans (as well for AI / AGI) going from using a level of skills somewhere at first and THEN going from one domain to other domains for a new same sort of transformation THERE, i.e. to a essentially new similar level/stage of which he/she is capable THERE, has remained unclear. This matter is now, in much of mainstream psychology, explained hypothetically (or supposedly) based on obvious/common-sense contingencies of guidance (from others and language) _OR_ as using analogies or metaphor to find the similar structures (alignments) in the new domain. This does not often seem plausible and is not sufficient for the broad and quite precise applications for a new level of thinking. (It is too crude and contains irrelevancies.)
FINALLY NOW, I thought of my likely neglect in not providing sufficient impetus or motivation OR direction (or "self"-reward) for ontogenic shifts (at inception: BASIC perceptual shifts), then changes. Early on, and then later, given the representational context of past key developments:
Maybe SOME key emotions help direct the organism to take a closer look at things, actions, and events and with the simple general sorts of motivations GIVEN BY SOME truly basic emotions; if there is more "dwell time" and the organism will take a closer look, THEN he/she will find more, and develop a similar system of structure and understanding THERE (as well as in contexts where such a system was applied earlier).
For, after all, a number of notable emotions have been with us sentient beings since mammals and birds (evolutionarily speaking). Not using any, even for the development of the grand "outer" container no longer seems possible. They (some emotions) are there, and, if they give direction and impetus, why wouldn't the be used in cognitive stages key unfoldings (and making them more precise and reliable). These few particularly important emotions are THERE basically from birth. For me, now, NOT making use of a small set of basic emotions aiding cognitive development does not seem adaptationally likely OR even plausible (from the point of view of logic and soundness, as well as evolutionarily). The set of such basic emotions for cognition and cognitive ontogeny (throughout), i.e. for all major cognitive developments, can be likely understood as interest-excitement-anticipation and surprise and joy. (The combination, in the first 'hyphenated term' are in part(s) present in all modern theories of the basic emotions, while the last two are IN ALL such systems of understanding.) In short such emotions ARE THERE to provide major motivations to dwell on aspects of things, circumstances, and situations -- even situations, in later ontogeny, very much spanning instances (situations/circumstances) across times and space -- AND also facilitating the basic associative learnings -- so things "carry on".
Some present proposals which put forth that for "generalization" or "transfer" metaphors and/or analogies doing the bridging just do not work for me. This brings in irrelevant distraction elements and does not give you the needed precision or focus on new things or things seen-anew. Analogies and metaphors WITHIN a single stage may be helpful to the degree workable and appropriate in more minor learning regards.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
7 answers
Hello everyone.
I'm trying to select the optimal approach to my research study and I'm having some doubts about solely using semiotics. My plan is to carry out a semiotic analysis on a small selection of visual texts (video ads), however I intend to not only analyse the mise-en-scène, sound, and camerawork, but also examine the text that appears on screen and what the voiceover says throughout the length of the commercials.
Thus, my question would be if I look at let's call them verbal aspects, would that mean I will also have to adopt discourse analysis or rhetorical analysis as a research method along semiotics? I'm asking this because I feel like a semiotic analysis would only help me to uncover the visual meaning and if I look at 'written text' I should employ a different approach. But on the other hand, I'm not trying to go in depth with the analysis. I would say that much of what I would do would involve an interpretation, similar to analysing a metaphor.
Thank you in advance for your answers. Any help is appreciated.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello Adelina, I suggest social semiotics first, and if you are looking for ideologies, you can add a critical discourse analysis approach. And lexicometric approches like Quantitative Discourse Analysis should be a plus to highlight representations, stereotypes and ideologies.
Good luck
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
12 answers
In my research, I have used metaphorical elicitation tasks to investigate learners' conceptualization of speaking fluency. In the analysis phase, I used thematic analysis to make themes out of their provided responses to the elicitation tasks. In the next step, I want to conduct an inter-rater (inter-coder) reliability to increase my analysis's credibility. Suggestions?
Relevant answer
Answer
If Inter-rater (Un)reliabilty is seen as an indicator of subjectivity/idiosyncrasy, you might find a way to make it useful.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
It is common that a source domain is conceptually linked to multiple target domains. According to the neural theory of metaphor, once a concept as a source domain is activated, signals will spread through neural circuits/mappings. This is, multiple target domains should be activated simultaneously. Is this true? Or context plays a moderating role in this process. Any terms or articles to recommend, please?
Can I inhibit the processing of several other mappings by making one mapping more accessible? (accessibility theory).
Relevant answer
Answer
focuses in the domains
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
It is based on philosophical enquiry.
Relevant answer
Answer
A formação metafórica deve ser a mesma, uma vez que os sonhos se pautam pelos mesmos processos mentais que acionamos quando estamos acordados. A perspectivação de uma base corpórea ancorada pelo nosso entorno ecológico é formadora da nossa base perceptiva. As ondas cerebrais que percorrem os sonhos, portanto, são guiadas pelos mesmos grupos neurais perceptuais, ocasionando, portanto, as mesmas bases metafóricas.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
Hello everybody,
I am currently working on a systematic metaphor analysis as established by Schmitt (2018), adapted from Lakoff and Johnson. My text material is comprised of statements in which palliative patients express their desire to die.
I am looking for metaphors on death and dying, suicidality, assisted suicide, life and meaning. A lot of these statements go along the lines of
  • "I just want it all to end."
  • "I can't take it anymore."
  • "Everything is pointless."
  • etc
These indeterminate words are used a lot within the context of death and dying and obviously stand in for something else ("it all" = "life", "it" = "suffering", "everything" = "life" and so on). I just don't see which broader image scheme (e.g. liquid, person, containment, etc) they refer to or how I could call it.
How do you deal with these explicitly vague concepts within metaphor analysis?
Kind regads
Kathleen
Relevant answer
Answer
I think that more than metaphorical analysis these are cases of endophoric coherence. the examples refer to "something" that was already spoken previously. Bernardez E.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
16 answers
I come across with research papers in which the researcher ask participants (about 30-50 people) to fill in the blank in two sentences such as:
X (the topic of the investigation) is like ......................................................................................
Because .........................................................................................................................................
The participants write their responses usually one or two sentences. Then the first responses are called metaphors, the second responses are considered as the underlying thoughts associating the X with the specific metaphor. Then the researcher categorizes the answers and claims that X is understood as such and such.
Is this a valid, acceptable way of doing a qualitative research? I may accept this as part of data collection in a research along with other data so it may provide a different lens to look at the data but I have hard time considering this as a research method when used by itself, let alone when it is called as phenomenology. What are your experiences and thoughts on this, I would really love to hear.
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with Younghoon Choi that this would probably yield only very "thin" data that would be difficult to analyze with traditional qualitative methods. However, I do think it would be possible to use a more content analytic framework to count how many times different answers or explanations were provided.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
I have designed 16 different mid-air haptic icons, and in an identification study I had participants guess what metaphors from a list each of the icons represented. This gave a percentage of the the participants success in identifying the correct metaphors through the haptic icon. I now want to know if there is a correlation between the type of icons and the participants' identification scores. Icons can be classified on a continuum between representational and abstract, with semi-abstract lying in between. In order to classify my icon designs on this continuum, 3 raters gave each of the icons a score between 1 to 5 relating to the continuum (i.e. 1 = abstract, 3 = semi-abstract, 5 = representational).
My question twofold:
- Can I accept the mode rating between the 3 raters as "true" (percentage agreement 66%) or do I need to find consensus agreement by revisiting the definitions with the raters?
- Also to take chance into account, how should I calculate the Kappa value (in SPSS) and what value would be acceptable?
Relevant answer
Answer
Rhianon Allen Thanks for your answer!, that has helped massively. To clarify, 3 raters rated 16 icons (stimuli) on a 5-point ordinal scale.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
10 answers
OK-this is a huge question with many possible replies. Is it simply directional as physical phenomena suggests? No. I doubt if anyone believes that as we can visualise past experience through memory and constructs of knowledge.
In another related question, I pointed out how religions employ the past to insinuate universal authenticity-the Mormons recruit everyone after death, Islam recruits real or imagined religious figures to insinuate its relationship to infinity, Christianity, after its prophets death, recruited YHWH for the same or similar purposes. He might have been limited in time, but not his time in infinity.
But there are so other understandings and metaphors of time: subject entirely to physical phenomena through the Big Bang: connected to autobiographical memory through external events and affect (Freud).
Relevant answer
Answer
Time is most precious and it waits for none. Stanley Wilkin
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
1 answer
the study of protein structure by modern spectroscopic techniques has shown that different types of motion are found in proteins. Molecular motion has been found to be essential in many protein-ligand interactions, and from this it is sometimes assumed that the “lock-and-key” metaphor is no longer applicable to proteins because it implies two rigid interacting elements and thus ignores the dynamics of protein structure.
So the question is, what is the metaphore which can explain the epitope paratope binding?
Relevant answer
Answer
I am not a biologist, but if, contrary to the lock-and-key metaphor, molecules are found to be capable of motion, when you said "molecule motion" it is already a metaphor. Now, if nobody so far is using it as a alternative or substitute for the old one, the intellectual community in your discipline should be able to create their own metaphor to capture all the properties of molecules or proteins. I know I have not been of much help.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
15 answers
Media discourses around the coronavirus pandemic tend towards metaphorical expressions such as the war against an invisible enemy, of the ecosystem balance so that the Earth returns to its original status. For this reason, expressions of legitimization of police and military violence have been seen to achieve social isolation. There are dangers in these metaphors since they do not focus on health education, but exacerbate autocracy and state violence.
Relevant answer
Answer
Very interesting discussion...👍.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
14 answers
All metaphors are false. But, on restricting this discussion to natural sciences, we hope to use a particular metaphor to clarify important areas in physics and often in dispute by researchers -- also in other areas, including those not a natural science.
The metaphor is that, all one can do in natural sciences is to be a "customer service rep" for someone else's product -- nature.
For example, I did not invent it, and works for billions of years, without halting. I am just the front-end of nature's message, the customer service rep. One can always ask questions and consult the manual, the universe, in case of doubts.
Of course, natural scientists are much more. Some view that our task is to find in all the relative data from phenomena (which is all physics is limited to measure), the absolute, the universally valid, the invariant, that is hidden in them, as Max Planck said first.
But the metaphor above can be useful, especially in other areas, including those not a natural science.
Some "disgruntled customers" (DC), familiar to any well-intentioned customer service rep, remain disgruntled, even when explained that it is not a bug, such that the speed of light is constant to all inertial observers in vacuo, it is a feature of the universe. A feature, not a bug.
When a DC understands, the average DC does not say "thank you", it should be a selfless customer service, good for the soul.
There is also a tendency for a DC to all but hide in silence until all his false answers (in nature, which is the arbiter of falsehoods) are diluted. By RG, or hidden in life. Then, he likely goes back and says it is a new feature, the old bug, that he just invented, and is just "spreading around".
Or, a DC can also repeat a fallacious interpretation, say we never measured it otherwise but locally. Natural science can explain that the Earth moves, the Sun moves, across the galaxy, we launch transmitters beyond the Solar system, and we can see and measure electromagnetism, light, billions of years away, across many galaxies. Then, what is a DC to do?
The average DC understands, but there is always the probability that a DC will name another fallacious argument, ad infinitum if life would physically allow, to deny what could be simply explained, it is not a bug, the DC bug -- it is a supposed feature.
It is a good customer service of someone else's product, though, because there is, actually, no DC. The concept of a DC is a mirage, itself a bug.
Everyone counts, DC or not, in the school called life, and even non-cooperation clarifies, inspires selflessness, is cooperation. Everyone cooperates.
Cooperation is a collective effect, producing unexpected efects.
Even those who try their mortal hand and time in life to be contrarian, a DC, just like Humpty-Dumpty, using nursery rhymes as a scholarly principle, trying strategies to get points at RG, get into a cabal to dialogue and create hits in search.
All is a legitimate, defensible, good use of their limited time, in the school of life, even as if, so may seem to them, that there is no future to account for, to earn.
So, a good customer service should handle all cases, sometimes with silence -- The trust that all is fine, there is no disaster in the whole universe, no wars but progress, it is an open-ended universe in harmony with laws we ignore, but feel more and more in the few laws we already know, and find out.
Nature is in no danger by humans. Everything is already solved, we just have to find it.
To help, Nature has many good customer service reps, in what should be done as a selfless customer service, a good task for the soul. And anyone can always ask questions and consult the manual, the universe, in case of doubts.
Relevant answer
Answer
All: See
Deleted research item The research item mentioned here has been deleted
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
7 answers
The invisible hand was a vivid metaphor for how the market works. No more, no less. It was an attractive metaphor. It was simple and perhaps simplistic. However, people are reading too much into this metaphor, and the misunderstanding has created tremendous confusion.
Relevant answer
Answer
That's a good question
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
7 answers
Is it ok to say political caricatures instead of political cartoons in visual and multimodal metaphor?
Relevant answer
Answer
Charles Forceville's remark seems to me as inspiring as can be. Political caricature, as a form of humor communication, borrows something from the visual structure of political banners, projecting certain features of the political character through the image, of course exacerbating them to be easily recognizable. On the other hand, in political cartoons, the reality effect of the animated film naturalizes and somehow insidiously gives way to the message, the verbal content.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
32 answers
A metaphor is a literary device that is used to help people see or explain one thing in terms of another. As an example, one could use a "building" metaphor to explain "starting a company" etc.,
An analogy on the hand, is a literary device that seeks to reconcile the differences between the source (metaphor) and the target (that which is being explained).
Creativity is the production of novel ideals that have potential to be useful to someone, a group, a nation or the world. The production of novel ideals can be done by one person acting alone, by a group or by groups.
The question is, in your view, is there a relationship between usage of metaphors and analogies on the one hand and creativity? Put differently, does the use of metaphors and analogies in the creative process, lead to more or better production of novel ideas?
Relevant answer
Answer
Excellent contribution, merging science, art and creativity.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
4 answers
If I want to write research that analyses the metaphor of Shakespeare's play and how it can be used to reflect and study accounting ethics implementation, what's the proper approach to the research? I do not conduct interviews and such, and my main resource for the research is just text of the play itself, and I will use the behavior and decision-making choices that the characters made throughout each acts and how it can be used as example in modern ethic behavior.
Relevant answer
Answer
When I read you question, some terms and expressions have captured my attention: metaphor, play itself, behavior and decision-making choices, and how it can be used as example in modern ethic behavior. I did something similar for my MA. Regarding Qualitative Analysis, it could be useful to think about content analysis or thematic analysis (it depends on the focus that you want to adopt). I would also suggest to consider the field of corpus linguistics approaches. In particular, to study metaphor you could read the subsection Metaphor (pp. 166-173) in the book Using Corpora in Discourse Analysis (chapter 7 Beyond Collocation).
Here, the link to the publisher's website of the book:
I think that work from The ESRC Centre for Corpus Approaches to Social Science (CASS) at Lancaster University can be quite inspiring (e.g., Elena Semino's works on metaphors and there are also professors interested in the analysis of Shakespeare).
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
9 answers
We can notice that pictorial metaphor works with the advertisements, but the question raises itself "Does the pictorial metaphor work with the political newspaper discourse?"
Relevant answer
Answer
Take a look on Chalie Hebdo, and you will see a very dynamic interplay between metaphorical and often hyperbolic drawings and a sober critical text. Charlie Hebdo is of course a rather untypical 'newspaper' but a most interesting weekly. This works so well, I think, because thesatirical genre allows much more to be said than what is permitted in the daily papers.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
I have read some articles about KPI's and found out KPIOnto. It is connected with KPI ontology. Ontology is the philosophical study of the nature of being, becoming, existence or reality as well as the basic categories of being and their relations. Do we need programming language for philosophical study? What is the big idea about KPIOnto? What is its practical use?
Relevant answer
Answer
The KPIOnto - ontology serves as a schema to represent KPIs as a knowledge graph. The format is RDF a W3C standard coming from the Semantic Web, it helps when you want to link and integrate different data sources with the KPIs and run some graph analytics on top. We have used it already in some projects.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
How does metaphors shape the reader's attention and thought?
Conceptual metaphors shape the reader's attention and thought especially in media discourse where it reveals the ideologies that the writer/ speaker and editor want his audience to perceive his message.
Relevant answer
Answer
Indeed, a good starting point would be to consult George Lakoff and Mark Johnson, Metaphors We Live By (1980). I also recommend Zoltán Kövecses, Metaphor: A Practical Introduction (2010); Mark Turner, Reading Minds: The Study of English in the Age of Cognitive Science (1991); R. W. Gibbs, The Poetics of Mind (1994); Raymond W. Gibbs article - Psycholinguistics studies on the conceptual basis of idiomaticity (1990), etc.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
I keep finding only sporadic observations by Musolff, Lakoff etc. on how SOURCE-PATH-GOAL schema functions as a basis for various JOURNEY metaphors (LIFE IS A JOURNEY, LOVE IS A JOURNEY, LONGTERM PURPOSEFUL ACTIVITY IS A JOURNEY etc). I would appreciate any suggestions on in-depth discussions on the matter, e.g. which elements are added in the JOURNEY metaphors or what exactly is the distinction between the schema's GOAL and the metaphors' DESTINATION. Preferably cognitive linguistic/psychological literature, not multimodality or other disciplines.
Relevant answer
Hi,
Metaphors we live by for lakoff& Johnson is a primary reference. You can also google JOURNEY metaphors. There is exhaustive literature. Metaphor in Discourse for Semino (2008) is an excellent book in which JOURNEY metaphors are thoroughly investigated in all walks of life.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
I am trying to write about how using a global metaphorical reading or structure in a text, we can change social imaginary. My hypothesis is that we can use global metaphorical readings of cognitive metaphors, for this purpouse.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello!
I think metaphor is very important in discussing literal style, literature, and culture of each nation, as Aristotle stated that the greatest thing in style is to have a command of metaphor. I have been working on metaphors, similes, puns, satires in Anglo-Saxon literature, skaldic poetry of the Scandinavian middle ages, and Japanese literature.
-- Kenichi
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
12 answers
This research project wants to question the statute of the production of the artistic object, systematically it will review the experience as an activity that elaborate the artistic object and consider the metaphor as the articulating axis for this construction new knowledge.
Relevant answer
Answer
Ignacio Nieto Larraín Wishing you success. With respect to your work, I do think that https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georges_Bataille is worth to reflect upon, i.e. theory of erotics, creativity and human/animal behavior (biology of behavior, lower and higher instincts of human nature). Also: the metaphoric dimension
of sacred literature (religion as relegere=rereading of 'vital' wisdom teachings).
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
Hello there,
For my doctoral thesis, I first interviewed for grounded theory. Then I developed the scale. But I also did metaphor analysis to support my scale. I also developed a hypothetical model as a quantitative study. Can I say that I used exploratory sequential design of mixed method research?
Thanks
Relevant answer
Answer
Nesrullah - you could frame it like that but it is unconventional to approach a mixed methods study, as one, after you have completed data collection. To maintain rigour, it really should have been structured as a mixed methods study from the beginning. That said - you could 'bolt' your components and data together to form a wider mixed methods study - and apply a 'back-step' process to try and convince the reader/reviewer that it was originally mixed methods. To determine exact approach - refer to the work of Morse and Niesgard (2009).
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
based on observation of my (young) dog I'm starting to think that thay are capable of conceptual metaphoric thought.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi! Take a look at this:
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
I am doing research on metaphors in organizations and want to classify the existing literature on some typology/framework. Is there one available?
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
Among these options; which do you think is more beneficial for designing enhanced wearables?
1) In terms of functionality e.g. through AI or actuators or machine learning
2) In terms of UX and embedded interactions e.g. metaphors and scenarios, telling stories
3) In terms of design methodologies e.g. mixed methods
4) In terms of thinking behind concepts
Relevant answer
Answer
I personally think that In terms of design methodologies e.g. mixed methods
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
4 answers
Since Lakoff and Johnson's "Metaphors We Live By", Applied Linguists use Conceptual Metaphor Theory for different pedagogical purposes. While some researchers use a pure cognitive perspective in researching Metaphor, some others add Sociocutural perspective to the cognitive view. Therefore, the question is what are the weaknesses of the pure cognitive view that led to the emergence of Sociocutural perspective in Metaphor studies?
Relevant answer
Answer
For literature on the socio-cultural perspective in metaphor research, I recommend that you read the work by e.g. Kövecses, Musolff and Charteris-Black. They have different takes on the relation between the socio-cultural, discourse and the cognitive, but provide relevant perspectives on the subject.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
4 answers
Is there a reliable method to extract all linguistic expressions of the metaphor and metonymy of an abstract word in corpus?
Relevant answer
Answer
Please search for the work of Gerard Steen: he and his group have developed a method that you are looking for. http://www.uva.nl/profiel/s/t/g.j.steen/g.j.steen.html?1551348000014
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
I would like to research about politeness and metaphor.
How can these concepts (politeness and metaphor) be related?
can you suggest any books or articles in this regard?
Do you know whether I can find any on the web?
Relevant answer
I am currently reading about irony and I found that many articles connect between politeness and metaphors representing ironic utterances.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
I think the strategy as: an adjective, which calls on every concept to have an action, which the actor believes is comprehensive and has a great impact.‏Since there is no concept of a strategy that is not related to action, for example in military aspects, the plan or a ploy was called a strategy, metaphor. But what is meant is a strategic plan, a strategic a ploy . The strategic plan in organizations is only a set of strategic actions on paper. The act is not called "strategic action" unless it is characterized by a holistic nature and a profound effect. Also does not enter the longest or shortest of time in determining the type of act, strategically or not.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear colleague,
There are two opposing views on understanding strategy in the references.
In the first case, a strategy is a concrete long-term plan for achieving a certain goal, and the development of a strategy is a process of finding a certain goal and drawing up a long-term plan. This approach is based on the fact that all emerging changes are predictable; the processes occurring in the environment are deterministic and can be fully controlled and managed.
In the second case, the strategy is understood as a long-term qualitatively defined direction of the enterprise development, concerning the sphere, means and form of its activity, the system of intra-production relations, as well as the positions of the enterprise in the environment. With this understanding, the strategy can be described as a chosen course of action, the functioning and scope of which should lead the organization to achieve its goals.
Good Luck,
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
Scientific knowledge is not being taken accurately ,and the new younger are ignoring many facts his neglect of ignorance reflects assumptions about ignorance that are questionable. For instance, Pascal’s metaphor is at the very least ambiguous, for it allows at least two distinct and irreconcilable interpretations (Mittelstrass 1996). The first interpretation takes knowledge to be the volume of the sphere. Hence as knowledge grows the area of the unknown – our ignorance – diminishes. Our knowledge grows faster than our ignorance. We may call this the optimistic view. The second interpretation takes knowledge to be the outer limits of the sphere. As knowledge increases the area of the unknown increases. In this interpretation, our ignorance grows faster than our knowledge. We could call this the pessimistic view. It is difficult to say which view is correct, and futile perhaps even to debate the issue. The conundrum indicates however that the relationship between know ,so what is the impact of knowledge?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear colleague,
Of course, increasing our knowledge leads to a decrease in ignorance, but scientists are constantly looking for something new to make human life easier. Global problems, unsolvable problems, incurable diseases are a sign that science is developing in the field of solving such problems. There would be no these problems, would not know the limits of science and its activity in determining and distinguishing the solved from the unsolvable.
The great philosopher, mathematician, logic, lawyer, one of the founders of natural science and initiators of the Academy in Russia G. Leibniz, defined the purpose of science as follows: "the Purpose of science — the welfare of human kind, that is, the multiplication of all that is useful to people, but not in order to then indulge in idleness. And to maintain virtue and expand knowledge. Every talent must do its part."
Good Luck
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
6 answers
So there is this 'two communities' theory / metaphor arguing that academics and policy makers are from separate communities, with distinct languages, values, and reward system, and that leads to limited knowledge use (Caplan 1979, Dunn 1980).
Although criticized by many (e.g. Bogenschneider and Corbett 2010, Jacobson 2007) it still in my opinion is a good story / starting point for analyzing determinants / context of knowledge use in public administration.
I wonder if you could point me to some other examples of alternative theories / metaphors that could serve the same purpose. Let me specify that I'm not asking for sources enlisting factors / determinants of knowledge / evaluation use or models consisting - again - of factors, but something more like a story / perspective (sth like two communities:)
Regards, TK
Relevant answer
Answer
Good Day, Thomasz. The below paper ' Effectuating Tacit and Explicit Knowledge via Personal Knowledge Management Frameworks and Devices' utilizes and references sources which differentiate (e.g. Wierzbicki A.P. and Nakamori Y. (2007a) Creative environments: Issues of creativity support for the knowledge civilization age, Springer Publishing Company) between the academic and business world but also point to cumulative synthesis as a common ground methodology (e.g. Usher, A.P. (2013) A history of mechanical inventions (Revised ed.), Courier Corporation). see: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/326877071
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
21 answers
Many other apparent clashes between the Quran and science are explained by scholars by treating the problematic passages as poetic language that can be reexpressed or explained by more literal statements that do not clash. However, the “seven heavens” seem to present a more difficult case; consider:
  • 71:15 “Allah has created the seven heavens, one above another”.
  • 37:6 “We have indeed decked the lowest heaven with an adornment, the stars.”
  • 71:15 “See ye not how Allah has created the seven heavens, one above another,”
  • 71:16 “And made the moon a light in their midst, and made the sun as a (Glorious) lamp?” [transl.: Yusuf Ali]
Therefore: If the stars deck the lowest of the seven heavens, and the moon is in the midst of the seven heavens, then the moon is higher than the stars.
An astronomical falsehood seems to be entailed. If not, can anyone here on RG give an explanation?
Thank you.
Relevant answer
Dear James Gary
Thank you for your good response
I hope you read this book
God's Guide to the Expanding Universe, 40 American Scientists Announce Their Positive Views of Religion
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
28 answers
When study of metaphor is at its fever pitch, will analogical reasoning remain at a reasonable level?
Relevant answer
Answer
Philadelphia, PA
Dear Manfredi & readers,
Well, I guess we have your answer. Arguments by analogy for the plausibility of a hypothesis are not reasonable.
It seems though that you simply equivocate on what it is that a "reasonable argument" is supposed to accomplish. We cannot define a reasonable hypothesis as one which will be finally proven. There is no way to know which hypotheses will turn out correct before hand. People try them out, develop them and look for ways to test them.
Also, there is no way to know which hypotheses will end up in unending arguments or disputes --before hand. That is why reasonable hypotheses are part of science even if they will in fact never proven--in which case, they are eventually given up and enter into the history of science.
A more basic difficulty in your argument is that you seem to be adverse to unconfirmed hypotheses however they are arrived at.
As it happens, though, the science and scholarly disciplines are full of yet to be tested and confirmed hypotheses, from string theory to gravity as a quantum field theory, to loop quantum gravity, etc and on to, say, theories of the location and identity of the original speakers of the reconstructed proto-Indo-european language. If you are not comfortable with this, then I see little sympathy with the growing edges of the sciences and scholarly disciplines.
My view is that there is better and worse among even untested hypotheses, and that we can sometimes tell the difference.
See:
H.G. Callaway
---you wrote---
And my answer continues to be, it may sound reasonable, at the outset, but may instead be proven fallacious. Meaning, no, that analogy is not reasonable (and perhaps, who knew?). In the criminal law example, people can argue both sides "until the cows come home," and continue to insist "it is reasonable" for the rest of time. In the quantitative sciences, eventually reality will rear its ugly head. .
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
I'm looking for how to starting the analysis for a group of qualitative study
Relevant answer
Answer
The terms "systematic review" and "meta-synthesis" are fairly general terms for the review of qualitative research on a topic, but "meta-ethnography" is a bit more specific in terms of the procedures it follows. So, if you did a thematic analyses on the results from a series of qualitative articles, that could be summarized as a systematic review or meta-synthesis.
Can you say more about how metaphors would fit into what you have in mind?
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
7 answers
Properly defined terms can help scientists communicate more effectively and efficiently.
Often, writers uses terminology based on their own concepts and preferences. As a result, the search used to interpret a particular topic may contain different (direct or metaphorical) conventions that certainly affect the linguistic and legal meaning of the search ...
Using specific terms may mitigate the risk of using erroneous terms, which can greatly affect translation.
But how do we guide writers to use standardized terminology at the global level, especially when translating research or rhetoric?
Relevant answer
Answer
Adil Salhi, this is a fascinating topic and the source of much frustration. I recently read a paper that specifically addresses this topic in the field of psychology where the use of the correct term can be critical for a questionnaire or professional report. I would be curious to hear your reaction. https://www.aclang.com/blog/is-there-inherent-bias-in/
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
I am interested in the primary patterns that have been used for constructing specific visions of human well-being through visual metaphors in advertising.
Relevant answer
Answer
It depends on what culture you are studying, as such visual metaphors in advertising can be culture-specific.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
280 answers
This discussion is about a regular, pretty useless, and embarrassing, confusion at RG. If there is no spacetime, special and general relativity do not include time dilation or length contraction, there is no fusion of space and time, and SR and GR do not apply to arbitrary motion. But these things happen, experimentally. Of course, one can use a kind of "inverse Wick rotation", as done in STA and Cl(1,3), but the predictive power reduces.
It is well-known that the `contraction of length´ is real, as is time dilation, both can cross a barrier, and produce thermodynamic work. They are not illusions or apparent, for non-comoving observers. Views to the contrary are a misuse of the resources offered by RG, in detriment of valid opinions.
Space is practically empty. Space and matter are different. Space and time may be 3+1 dimensions, but evidence, empirical and mathematical, point to 4 dimensions, hence treated as fusion -- there is no unique way to separate them. This is well referenced in physics, see below. Philosophy is not physics, it is subjectively defined. As an experience of the self, time is not the same as in nature.
The 3D gimbal suffers a lock on the way to the Moon. The Earth moves, and travels around the Sun. The Sun moves, and circles the Via Lactea. The satellite moves, and passes the Solar system. The galaxies send us their light, billions of years ago.The Big Bang I hear, the CMB I measure, the Hubble flow I sense. In all of that, the constancy of the speed of light in vacuo, the Lorentz transformation, and spacetime, I'd measured. [1-7] Now, what do we understand?
On September 21, 1908 Hermann Minkowski, an already famous mathematician, began his talk at the 80th Assembly of German Natural Scientists and Physicians with the now well-known introduction:
"The views of space and time which I wish to lay before you have sprung from the soil of experimental physics, and therein lies their strength. They are radical. Henceforth space by itself, and time by itself, are doomed to fade away into mere shadows, and only a kind of union of the two will preserve an independent reality."
One question has remained. How can one use special relativity to have some kind of union of space and time -- to “fuse” different things, experimentally and theoretically, and as they are even measured in a different way? Or, what does to "fuse" space and time mean?
This discussion attempts to clarify this common question. We are all cooperating (see below *). For example, as we see by attempts to use STA and Clifford(3,1) in special relativity. Also, in the original formulation of special relativity, that does not use the concept of spacetime. Both fail to work, as we see in the literature.
Note that comoving and non-comoving, as well as length contraction and time dilation, are not just words or optical illusions -- what they denote can cross a barrier, can produce thermodynamic work. They define different physics, different truth-conditions, not just different truth values [6]. And they manifest, or not, always in the same conditions. Length contraction and time dilation only exist for non-comoving observers, and do not exist for comoving observers. In cosmology, there is the non-conflicting addition of the Hubble Flow, which allows comoving observers to separate.
In all cases, there is only some sort of union we cannot separate -- or "fusion" -- between space and time. In other words, this "fusion" happens so that there is no unique way to split spacetime into space and time.
Otherwise the experimental data do not fit, the above sentences do not fit, life qua experience does not fit. Such as the experience of gimbal lock, which is well-known in 3D rotations at any speed, but becomes easy to avoid in 4D [7].
Globally, we can separate space and time, as we see, locally we cannot, as we also see. Like separated long wires, fused at a point, spacetime. Maybe even more wires, maybe even more dimensions exist. But, at least, we have a reality of 4D.
No ontological question is possible either, no philosophy (subjective mode) is possible, on what could be painful to one's prior convictions, like PEMDAS in middle school maths, maybe, but plain to see objectively, and forward looking. Not even words are important anymore, by themselves, but also what they mean, what they denote (in linguistics, reference and sense).
One can skip a discussion on existence, and focus on the effects.
This is at least, certainly, scholarly, possible, as a path we can take by following with an IF and entertaing what may happen.
Thus, after the IF, there is no rational discusion possible on the existence of spacetime. We can focus on the effects, using the predicted effects themselves versus observations, to affirm or deny spacetime.
* In this work, we define -- Cooperation: different people, at different times, doing different things, for the same objective. The discussion is just asked to not include ad hominem attacks, they do not advance any argument.
Even those who may seem NOT to cooperate, below, are cooperating. That way, we hope that the space in RG can be seen as more open and welcome for real effects, and where one's creativity can be useful to others.
REFERENCES
[1] H. Minkowski. ​ Space and Time: Minkowski's Papers on Relativity​. 2012. Online at: http://rgs.vniims.ru/books/spacetime.pdf
[2] C. P. Burgess. ​ General Relativity: the Notes​. 2009. Online at: http://www.physics.mcmaster.ca/~cburgess/Notes/GRnotes.pdf
[3] While the original but limited formulation of special relativity is still taught at various college-level textbooks, such as
Article Physics: For Scientists and Engineers J. .W. Jewett and R.A. Serway. Physics for Scientists and Engineers with Modern Physics. Thomson Brooks/Cole. 2012
[4] In another version of the SR, by Mashhoon, an accelerated observer is in effect replaced — on the basis of the hypothesis of locality — by a continuous infinity of hypothetical momentarily comoving inertial observers. Here, the accelerated observer and the otherwise identical instantaneously comoving inertial observer have the same velocity and position. In SR, two observers comoving are defined as having the same velocity and position. Cited by 36 references, with 14 occurrences of "comoving", Mashhoon paper at arXIv may further his treatment of accelerated motion in SR, and illuminate the use of "comoving" in SR:
[5] For the spacetime formulation, also this book:
Taylor and Wheeler. Spacetime Physics. . W. H. Freeman and Company. 1966.
[6] "Paraphrasing  one of Frege's examples, if I tell you "I will photograph the Morning Star" or if I tell you "I will photograph the Evening Star"  then, clearly, the two phrases have the same reference (i.e., the planet Venus) but one describes it as the last celestial body to disappear at dawn and the other as the first one to appear at dusk -- thus, they have different senses or meanings."
and following paragraphs, In Ed Gerck, 1998,
Relevant answer
Answer
Why have we only second derivative in Newton's law? Because with more than second derivative equations have no solution in common case. More than second derivative means more than two dimensional phase space where chaos begins.
The main Newton's secrete, coded by him in anagram was:
"It is usefull to solve differential equations"
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
How to measure different writers mental spaces,image schemata,conceptual metaphor different processing through texts?
Texts are products of multi-cognitive processing .
Writers are hidden shadows in their texts which represent their mental content ,spaces,images and semantic neural networks.
Texts can give analytics of situation of writer to his environment and predict his impacts in mental content of readers.
But How can we compare distinctive features of his/her mental processing quantitatively?
Relevant answer
Answer
One way to do this is to construct a corpus with these authors' writing as samples, then annotate the samples with the intented constructs that you desire to study, for example, annotate all cases of conceptual metaphors that you can identify, after you have done the annotation job, use a concordancer to extract all cases of conceptual metaphors, and compare their distributions (frequencies) across authorial differences, statistics, graphs, etc. may be used.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
10 answers
As a professional translator, it never occured to me that backtranslation could be taken seriously: translators know that a backtranslation seldom produces the original text. Of course, the backtranslation may mean the same as the original source text and be different from that source text.
Yet, recently, I have been asked to translate a medical questionnaire and started reading about protocols used to validate the translation of such documents. To my surprise, I found that back translation is a standard procedure in the medical field.
So, I would like the opinion of specialists in medical translation and of anyone interested in translation science.
Relevant answer
Answer
Backtranslation, like machine translation is only a tool in the toolbox of a translator.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
Dear all,
I already asked about this topic but my colleagues gave me information about simile in general , I am looking for its translation in popular science texts.
I found new information discussed in Maeve Olohan book about Scientific translation but still not enough.
This Question was proposed by Ms .Carol.
Thanks
Relevant answer
Answer
It is easier to identify a conceptual metaphor than to state the identity of a simile — because the metaphor is 'closed' in the sense that it is culturally self-explaining; example, the French @MeToo = @Balance ton porc! ("Report your pig/swine") — you are supposed to know what the animal predicat means. In simile, any A is like B counts, but it is always possible to add a third element: A is like B in respect to C, a sort of explanatory interpretant, which 'opens' the trope so that any A-to-B-{C} is possible, without a cultural pre-knowledge. This is a huge difference. A metaphor will never add such a C, because the conceptual force of this trope depends on this shared pre-knowledge. In other words, a simile is not culturally given, just an open formula.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
9 answers
Mental health, reconstructed as illness, is perhaps merely a metaphor for the social inequality and difficulties of advancement all face to one degree or another. By concentrating on individual angst (existentialism) and despair, does they stop us investigating our societies instead?
Relevant answer
Answer
It seems that social ills have become a universal phenomenon threatening the very foundation of hope and happiness almost in all societies. During our daily encounters with others, we often experience certain unpleasant, unexpressed emotions that will never die and are buried alive in our subconscious coming forth later in destructive ways. such state of affairs have been mitigating the true essence of human values giving rise to what Nietzsche calls "social decadence". These days, the ordinary citizen is in great despair because s/he is unable to give meaning to his/her meaningless life. The decadence is unavoidable and the politicians and moralists cannot control its damaging consequences , and most surprisingly, they have been principal culprits in promoting it. Therefore, the society and the individual should be considered two sides of the same coin. In point of fact, they have a symbiotic relationship. On this basis, investigating our societies may be a good starting point for fathoming out the true causes of individual angst and despair.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
Dear all,
We have introduced double stranded break in our gene (exonic) using a single gRNA. We have also checked efficiency of the cut by T7E1 assay. Now we are trying to genotype invidual clones by PCR followed by running on the Metaphor agaros gel. The size of our amplicon, which will anneal both side of gRNA seeding site, is 841 bp. Kindly provide advise to carryout the genotyping properly in our condition.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you Dr. Lepretre and Dr. Mahdi
!
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
8 answers
According to my project on portfolio in teacher training that I work on I would appreciate if someone could help me with providing the experience on reflective methods and techniques. I use journals, essays (reflective - digressive), metaphorical stories etc..
Relevant answer
Answer
You could use my propositions to analyze discourse. If it be usefull, I will be gratefull.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
Is studying turbulence from within mathematics or physics going to be useful when studying leadership, or is it just a metaphor? Or are turbulence and leadership what is known as a category error?
Relevant answer
Answer
I have much to learn. Much to learn.
I am humbled by your assistance.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
I have a procedure involves the using of polyacrylamide, but I don't have it! Can I use MetaPhor instead? What limits the using of MetaPhor instead of polyacrylamide?
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks Paul for all these details...
Is MetaPhor agarose applicable in MSAP technique?
Regards.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
I am interested in practical applications for teaching the dynamics of metaphor in colloquial expressions.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you very much for your perspective on this, Hussny.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
2 answers
In Pattern Activation/Recognition Theory of Mind (Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience, doi 10.3389/fncom.2015.00090), I have shown that neurons can describe other neurons.
I have also shown that this process of description allows ssociating representations via metaphoric mapping of one set of neurons to another one.
Here this metaphoric mapping would apply between a description of neurons representing the self and one representing others. It is then applicable to representing the self in relations to others, in short the social self?
Regards. Bertrand du Castel.
Relevant answer
Answer
It is neither a memory nor an empathy function. It is lower in the hierarchy. The metaphoric mapping works as follows:
1. consider a set of explicitly described neurons providing an input/output function
2. consider another set of neurons, also explicitly described, and itself describing the first set of neurons
3. then I show how yet another set of neurons, also explicitly described, can apply the function 1 to different input or/and output by added connections to specific neurons of the descriptions
4. I also show how another set of neurons, still explicitly described, can modify the function 1 itself. I even show how a set of neurons can modify the function 2, and actually, even itself, recursively up to a set of neurons that can universally describe any other set of neurons, by adding neurons and/or connections to other neuronal descriptions
5. above 3 and 4 are the neuronal mechanisms governing metaphorical descriptions
In terms of social self, 3 can describe the self (a given input/output) or describe others (different input/output) via 3, and 4 allows modifying the self/other relationship by modifying the corresponding functions, or, also, modifying the self and other descriptions themselves as applicable.
Memory or empathy functions should then be describable that way, as would be constructions on top of the neuronal descriptions I introduced, but they are not a product of them per se. I say "should" and "would" because I have never done an exercise at that higher level. The examples of treatment I provide in the article are fundamentals, regarding in particular learning, self-description, metaphors, and organization, and specifically intended to present the mechanisms involved. Applying those mechanisms on the scale necessary for your project is work yet to be done, but I do believe that the scaffolding is there, and I sure can help if needed.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
9 answers
I am looking for literature dealing with similies as figurative/metaphoric elements. Can research on similies be beneficial for metaphor research? If yes, how?
Psycholinguistic insight is especially welcome.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you all very much!
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
7 answers
Is is suggested that bureaucratic phenomena may be visualized and rationalized by relating administrative structures and processes metaphorically to structural equivalents in nature. Examples: Max Weber's "iron cage" vs. Faraday cage and cage rearing. Ohm's law to describe hierarchical stress as the product of management power and staff resistance. Organizational deficiencies vs. lattice defects in solids and metastases in oncology. Order/disorder/chaos vs. 2nd law of thermodynamics. Physical formulae and axioms are much more concise than social science prose. They remind us of the famous laws of C. Northcote Parkinson and Laurence J. Peter.
Relevant answer
Answer
Of course, the physics underlying our biology and our environmental contexts are fundamental for understanding life. As biological organisms interacting with our environments, we form part of a complex and dynamic system from which emerge our cognition, behavior, and extended networks of shared symbolic associations which we project onto ourselves, other people, and the rest of the environment. When you take it down to the level of the cell, the application of physical laws doesn't require metaphorical associations. At any rate, thinking metaphorically is inevitable, as understanding one thing in terms of another is a fundamental aspect of human cognition. If we step back and try to see the big picture, the dynamics of social behavior in an institutional setting should come into focus.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
How do people working with development (aid)-organisations (NGOs, government agencies, UN, ...) see their own role?
The focus is on people working in an international context, in particular "in the field". My interest is more on long-term development work, rather than on humaniarian aid/relief.
How do they see their position in regard to various stakeholders?
What do other stakeholders expect of them?
Which metaphors can be used to descibe their work?
Can you help me to find relevant literature and original studies?
Relevant answer
Answer
Yup, that's much more precise.
Of the top of my head, metaphors that can be used to describe them:
>DEVELOPMENT is BUILDING == development workers = masons, masterbuilders, craftsmen
>DEVELOPMENT is PROGRESS is FORWARD MOVEMENT == development workers = walkers, hikers, (marathon)-runners,
>DEVELOPMENT is PROGRESS is (FORWARD MOVEMENT ENABLING TECHNOLOGY for FORWARD MOVEMENT) == development workers = highways, engine, locomotives...
>DEVELOPMENT is PROGRESS is MOVEMENT TO A NEW DIRECTION == development workers = switches, track-layers, traffic regulators
>DEVELOPMENT is PROGRESS is UPWARD MOVEMENT == development wrokers = elavators, balloonists, aviators...
>DEVELOPMENT is PROGRESS is KNOWLEDGE is LIGHT {is FIRE} == development wrokers = lighthouses, igniters, torch-bringers, trailblazers, Prometheus...
>DEVELOPMENT is PROGRESS is KNOWLEDGE is BOOKS == development wrokers = parchement, printing press, ink
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
1 answer
I am currently trying to find an easy to use metaphor comprehension test. Preferably it is easy to administer through Qualtrics and does not require any additional software. If it is in a quantitative questionnaire format, then all the better! Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
Alger, C. L. (2009). Secondary teachers' conceptual metaphors of teaching and learning: changes over the career span. Teaching and Teacher Education, 25(5), 743-751. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2008.10.004
You can learn the method the author used to analyse metaphors. 
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
Following Entman (1993), Boeynaems, Burgers, Konijn & Steen (2017) construe metaphoric framing as using a conceptual metaphor or frame to characterise a problem, indicate its causality, and provide an evaluation thereof (either positive or negative).
I then wonder if metaphoric framing is cognitive (in the sense of knowledge structure or schemas) or/and interactive (in Goffman's sense). Thus, what of type of frame is a metaphoric frame?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello  Onwu Lnya,
You have certainly broached up a very insightful issue.As you have rightly observed, metaphoric framing defines cognitive knowledge structures materializing  social construction that  can be conceived as a process in which  individuals, dyads, and groups use metaphors ,and over time, they  build frames in order to observe the realities of the world. As such, metaphoric frames portray how linguistic metaphors construct  complex patterns of conceptual meaning that have already been identified and stored in non-metaphoric language. Understanding such shared semantic structures, and comparison of their roles and functions  in metaphoric and non-metaphoric constructions facilitates our  understanding of the way by which conceptual metaphors operate in every day language. In point of fact,  metaphoric frames constitute  specific  discursive frames which become more embedded in our daily social encounters causing alternative speculations to be  shut out and eliminated. On this basis, it can be stated that metaphoric frames are a cognitively sophisticated repertoire of organized information whereby individuals perceive events and objects in the world. Such prior knowledge structures save individuals the trouble of interpreting things anew every time they confront a new object or event because these frames act as ready -made forms of expectation which facilitate acts of communication.
Best regards,
R. Biria
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
9 answers
What research centres or groups of researchers nowadays study organizational metaphors by collecting data about ogranizational culture, conducting surveys and so on? Especially I'm interested in international projects.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dennis Mazur, thank you for the article you recommended Oates B.J., Fitzgerald B. Multi-metaphor method: organizational metaphors in information systems development // Information Systems Journal. – 2007. – №17. – p.421-449. It is helpful and shows IT developers interest in organizational metaphors.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
5 answers
I want to know what treatment, if any, figurative meaning is given within Conceptual Semantics and the Parallel Architecture: what it is understood as, how it is formalized (if in any way), and what implications it has, e.g. for the interfaces between semantics and the rest of the grammar (syntax and phonology, but also morphology and the lexicon).
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear EWG,
On metaphor, check the following:
1. Washing the Brain_ Metaphor and Hidden Ideology_Andrew Goatly-John Benjamins (2007)
2. Andrew Ortony, ed. Metaphor and Thought. 2nd ed. (Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 1993).
Good luck.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
83 answers
Dear All,
“Happiness in intelligent people is the rarest thing I know.”
― Ernest Hemingway, The Garden of Eden
How true this adage to you and your intelligent others?
Thank you and best regards.
Mariam
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mariam
Unfortunately in some  societies  is completely true!
One reason why smart people fail to be happy is that they tend to be too strict with themselves. And here, I’m not talking only about one’s achievements and failures. Intelligent, deep thinking individuals often analyze themselves and their own behavior in such a rigorous manner like if they are intentionally seeking out things to blame themselves for.
Being truly understood by someone is one of the greatest experiences a human being can have. How comforting it is to sit with a like-minded person somewhere quiet and have a meaningful conversation, realizing that this person understands your ideas and shares your views of the world…
Sadly, intelligent people rarely have this pleasure. Many of them feel alone and misunderstood, like if no one is able to see and appreciate the depth of their minds.
But on the other side  of the coin, I know some  intelligent people in some countries  who are so intelligent and   are too smart to be happy and their  views  to happiness are just like  a skill, maybe eventually the intelligent people  are  fighting for their survival !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
3 answers
You have no titles related to art therapy, expressive therapy, etc. Psychology is only part of out trade. our tools are the studio and materials. 
Thank you,
Nona Orbach
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
23 answers
Risk _taking is the ability to be risky in certain circumstances and it was the ability to make intelligent guesses. Risk taker is the one that can express his/her opinions frankly such as answering questions and take part in lectures without fear or hesitation. 
Relevant answer
Answer
A stress-free classroom atmosphere, with good teacher-student and student-student relationships, is obviously more likely to encourage risk- taking than a tense atmosphere. Having said that, a relaxed atmosphere must also be accompanied by techniques and activities that actively promote risk-taking, A good atmosphere will do little to encourage risk-taking if the activities conducted in class are excessively controlled. The idea of public and private tasks used in task-based learning can help to increase risk-taking: students first perform a task in a small group before performing it in front of the whole class.
For language education planners, it's important to take into account the backwash from the exams the students are asked to do. If the exams focus entirely on getting things right, they will encourage a play-safe attitude. If the exams positively encourage students to use a broad language range, and the examiners give credit for imperfect attempts at advanced language ( as seems to occur in the Cambridge Main Suite exams) the backwash on risk-taking will be positive.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
6 answers
Which field appeared first? Has not Firth's context of situation paved the way for some extra components of meaning? Is not language spoken before being written? 
Relevant answer
Answer
Discourse analysis is the breaking down of discourse and analyzing it for its meaning, function, and structure. Pragmatics and discourse (verbal discourse) are intertwined and is an interaction between or among individuals based upon familiarity of culture, perceptions and formality. Language itself is derived from and interrelated with social factors that are learned from your environment and from your culture.
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
4 answers
I personally feel that the writing part of any research is as much a part of the research meaning making process as any other stage. Has anyone researched this or written about it?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Jane Burt,
You are absolutely right about  envisaging  research writing as a kind of   meaning making process. Notably, researchers involved in reporting research seek to convey objective and subjective information based on  the patterns structuring world realities and the way such realities are conceived by different people ( see Popper's world three).  More specifically, the researchers employ a personal  lens relying on emic as well as etic sources of evidence in their choice of  an appropriate research  methodology . As such, their underlying ideological/ ontological  assumptions can be reflected through the methods they use for doing research. Therefore, in deciding to use a qualitative rather than a quantitative methodology, the targeted reality ,which the researchers tend to investigate,  plays a pivotal role in understanding the general research design required for exploiting the research topic. For more details, I refer you to the following links, which can hopefully shed light on what you are looking for.
Best regards,
R. Biria
  • asked a question related to Metaphor
Question
1 answer
Is there anyone know the reletationship between Toxoplasma gondii and suicide attempts?
Relevant answer
Answer
I found many articles on PsycInfo using the terms suicide and Toxoplasma. Here are the most recent.
Toxoplasmosis titers and past suicide attempts among older adolescents initiating SSRI treatment.
By Coryell, William; Yolken, Robert; Butcher, Brandon; Burns, Trudy; Dindo, Lilian; Schlechte, Janet; Calarge, Chadi
Archives of Suicide Research, Vol 20(4), Oct 2016, 605-613.
Latent infection with toxoplasmosis is a prevalent condition that has been linked in animal studies to high-risk behaviors, and in humans, to suicide and suicide attempts. This analysis investigated a relationship between suicide attempt history and toxoplasmosis titers in a group of older adolescents who had recently begun treatment with an SSRI. Of 108 participants, 17 (15.7 %) had a lifetime history of at least one suicide attempt. All were given structured and unstructured diagnostic interviews and provided blood samples. Two individuals (11.9%) with a past suicide attempt, and two (2.1%) without this history, had toxoplasmosis titers ≥ 10 IU/ml (p = 0.166). Those with a past suicide attempt had mean toxoplasmosis titers that were significantly different (p = 0.018) from those of patients who lacked this history. An ROC analysis suggested a lower optimal threshold for distinguishing patients with and without suicide attempts (3.6 IU/ml) than that customarily used to identify seropositivity. Toxoplasmosis titers may quantify a proneness to suicidal behavior in younger individuals being treated with antidepressants. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)
Is Toxoplasma gondii infection related to brain and behavior impairments in humans? Evidence from a population-representative birth cohort.
By Sugden, Karen; Moffitt, Terrie E.; Pinto, Lauriane; Poulton, Richie; Williams, Benjamin S.; Caspi, Avshalom
PLoS ONE, Vol 11(2), Feb 17 , 2016, Article e0148435.
Background: Toxoplasma gondii (T. gondii) is a protozoan parasite present in around a third of the human population. Infected individuals are commonly asymptomatic, though recent reports have suggested that infection might influence aspects of the host’s behavior. In particular, Toxoplasma infection has been linked to schizophrenia, suicide attempt, differences in aspects of personality and poorer neurocognitive performance. However, these studies are often conducted in clinical samples or convenience samples. Methods/Results: In a population-representative birth-cohort of individuals tested for presence of antibodies to T. gondii (N = 837) we investigated the association between infection and four facets of human behavior: neuropsychiatric disorder (schizophrenia and major depression), poor impulse control (suicidal behavior and criminality), personality, and neurocognitive performance. Suicide attempt was marginally more frequent among individuals with T. gondii seropositivity (p = .06). Seropositive individuals also performed worse on one out of 14 measures of neuropsychological function. Conclusion: On the whole, there was little evidence that T. gondii was related to increased risk of psychiatric disorder, poor impulse control, personality aberrations or neurocognitive impairment. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)
New findings: Depression, suicide, and Toxoplasma gondii infection.
By Hsu, Pao‐Chu; Groer, Maureen; Beckie, Theresa
Journal of the American Association of Nurse Practitioners, Vol 26(11), Nov 2014, 629-637.
Purpose: This article provides an overview of the evidence of a potential pathophysiological relationship between depression, suicide, and the Toxoplasma gondii (T. gondii) infection. It discusses the role of inflammatory processes in depressive illness and the infection theory of psychiatric disease. It also provides guidelines for the screening, diagnosis, and treatment of depression for nurse practitioners (NPs). Data source: A narrative review was conducted of the literature from PubMed, PsycINFO, and Google Scholar. References of identified articles were also reviewed. Conclusions: Seropositivity of the obligate intracellular protozoan parasite, T. gondii is related to various mental health disorders including schizophrenia, suicide attempt, depression, and other neuropsychiatric diseases. Depressive symptoms have been linked to interferon-γ (IFN-γ ) blocking T. gondii growth by inducing indoleamine-2,3-dioxygenase (IDO) activation and tryptophan depletion, which results in a decrease of serotonin production in the brain. Although exposure to T. gondii was considered unlikely to reactivate in immune-competent individuals, new findings report that this reactivation may be triggered by immune imbalance. Implications for practice: NPs caring for patients with psychiatric illness need to understand the potential mechanisms associated with depression and the T. gondii infection in order to provide effective screening, treatment, and disease prevention. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)
Toxoplasma gondii infection and suicide attempts: A case-control study in psychiatric outpatients.
By Alvarado-Esquivel, Cosme; Sánchez-Anguiano, Luis Francisco; Arnaud-Gil, Carlos Alberto; López-Longoria, Julio César; Molina-Espinoza, Luis Fernando; Estrada-Martínez, Sergio; Liesenfeld, Oliver; Hernández-Tinoco, Jesús; Sifuentes-Álvarez, Antonio; Salas-Martínez, Carlos
Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, Vol 201(11), Nov 2013, 948-952.
The association of Toxoplasma gondii infection with suicide attempts has been scarcely evaluated. Two hundred eighty-three psychiatric outpatients (156 patients with history of suicide attempt and 127 control patients without history of suicide attempt) were examined with enzyme-linked immunoassays for Toxoplasma immunoglobulin G (IgG) and IgM antibodies. Seroprevalences of Toxoplasma IgG and IgM in the cases and the controls were similar: 7 (4.5%) and 3 (1.9%) vs. 10 (7.9%) and 3 (2.4%) ( p = 0.23 and p = 0.55), respectively. In contrast, the Toxoplasma IgG levels higher than 150 IU/ml were more frequently observed in the cases than in the controls (100% vs. 50%, respectively; p = 0.04). The seroprevalence of Toxoplasma infection increased with age and with the number of suicide attempts. Toxoplasma seropositivity was associated with reflex impairment, national trips, and snake meat consumption. Our results suggest that although seroprevalence of Toxoplasma infection is not associated with suicide attempts, a high anti-Toxoplasma antibody level is, therefore warranting further research. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)