Science topics: Law
Science topic

Law - Science topic

Explore the latest questions and answers in Law, and find Law experts.
Questions related to Law
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
1 answer
I find some Federal and some State law that provides protection for certain medical professionals from tort liability. What about other volunteers who are not medical personnel? Also credentialing, and background checks can be time consuming and have cost. Should those types of things be done for everyone or only in certain cases?
As a student I appreciate the opportunity to ask questions! Thanks jlh
Relevant answer
Answer
The biggest scam in medical tort law avoidance is the federal preemption employed by drug companies to escape product liability suits.
As for volunteers, when you volunteer it comes with the duty of care.
Progressing to credentialing and background checks, yes it must be for everyone, volunteers included. Its a sad fact that volunteering attracts not just the Good Samaritans but all to often the bad actor too.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
2 answers
Like some of the suspect laws still in practice in US, one is the Fair Use doctrine under US copyright. This doctrine is meant to allow limited use of copyrighted works without permission and only under certain circumstances, the scope of what qualifies as "fair use" is confusing and subjective and needs amending or revamping to prevent its gross misuse. This also is my research paper under study.
Relevant answer
Answer
The "Fair Use" doctrine in U.S. copyright law is often misinterpreted for several reasons:
  1. Vagueness of Criteria: The four factors used to determine fair use (purpose, nature, amount, and effect on the market) are open-ended and subjective. This vagueness leaves room for interpretation and causes confusion about what constitutes fair use in different contexts.
  2. Lack of Clear Guidelines: Unlike other areas of law, fair use does not have precise, bright-line rules. Courts decide fair use on a case-by-case basis, which means there is no definitive rule on when it applies. This uncertainty leads to varied interpretations by different people or even within different courts.
  3. Public Perception vs. Legal Definition: Many people believe fair use automatically applies to non-commercial or educational uses, but the law is more nuanced. Commercial and non-commercial uses are just one of many factors, and fair use can apply to both depending on the overall circumstances.
  4. Complexity of Legal Precedents: Court rulings on fair use are often based on a variety of precedents, which can differ in their application. People may misunderstand how these rulings influence future cases or how they apply in different contexts (e.g., parody vs. commentary).
  5. Misunderstanding of "Market Effect": One of the most contentious factors of fair use is the effect of the use on the market for the original work. Some mistakenly assume that any non-competitive use is fair use, but even non-commercial uses can harm the market, thus affecting fair use analysis.
  6. Chilling Effect and Caution: Many creators and organizations misinterpret fair use because they are overly cautious. Fear of legal consequences leads them to err on the side of caution, avoiding what they believe might be risky uses even if they might actually be fair use.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
5 answers
Mouth and talk goes like the food and digestion, (my coinage.).
Of my understanding of Sharia, Sharia meant to be Safety and a device for Tommy Robinson. As Sharia is meant to be for safety and justice.
Anyway, I believe Tommy Robinsons concern should not be ignored, he has right of seeking safety and freedom to his freedom of speech.
Mouth and talk goes like the food and digestion, (my coinage.)
Regards
Author Dr Fatema Miah.
Relevant answer
Answer
It seems you’re expressing a mix of views about Tommy Robinson, Sharia law, and interpretations of Islam. It’s important to consider that discussions around these topics can be complex and sensitive, with a range of perspectives.
Tommy Robinson is a controversial figure who has been involved in discussions around immigration, Islam, and free speech, and opinions about him are deeply divided. Supporters often view him as someone standing up for free expression and safety, while critics accuse him of promoting Islamophobia and division.
Regarding Sharia law, it’s essential to recognize that interpretations of Sharia can vary widely among Muslims around the world. Many view it as a guiding framework for ethical and moral conduct, while others associate it with more extreme interpretations that can lead to harmful practices.
It’s crucial Fatema Miah to differentiate between the actions of individuals or groups claiming to represent a religion and the beliefs of the broader community. Many Muslims advocate for peace, understanding, and coexistence, emphasizing that the actions of extremists do not reflect their faith.
Engaging in constructive dialogue and seeking common ground can help bridge divides and foster understanding among diverse perspectives.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
13 answers
Should researchers and educators do more to encourage policy-makers, media influencers, other opinion leaders, friends, family, neighbors, etc. to productively address propaganda?
Welcome your thoughts…
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks for sharing the Dr Wojciech Szewko example. Informed, public-service commentary will always be challenging - yet, so vital - whatever a commentator's implied ideology. Also challenging will be interventions to regulate harmful algorithms or lies. Spontaneous or manufactured backlashes can be virulent against legislative or personal interventions. For example, well organized disinformation deniers have successfully mounted successful efforts to suppress or harm academics and institutions studying disinformation.
A potentially helpful perspective in these times may be Bertrand Russell's observations that "Government is a necessary but not sufficient condition for the greatest realizable degree of individual liberty... But if government is not to be tyrannical, it must be democratic, and the democracy must feel that the common interests of [hu]mankind are more important than the conflicting interests of separate groups." (Russell: p. 449)
Democracy will always remain a contested concept (Hanson: pp. 23-24) and genuine debate on public concerns, likewise. With bravado or defiance, autocrat-propagandists in the United States often falsely claim their speech is protected under The First Amendment–which does not apply for speech advancing particular illegal activity. This includes lies that "...unambiguously have no or little social value...and also cause cognizable harms (as well as sometimes yielding undeserved benefits for the liar)... [which includes] ...fraud, perjury, ...and making false statements to public officials." (Chen: p. 703) For sure, it’s well past time for more action than scholars or pundits rightly pointing this out.
For an interesting, practical overview of one nation's more comprehensive initiatives to address disinformation (beyond the better known efforts in Finland, Sweden, or Estonia), see on ResearchGate:
References
Chen, Alan K. and Justin Marceau (2018), “Developing a Taxonomy of Lies under The First Amendment,” University of Colorado Law Review, 89, p. 703, for U.S. Federal law governing limits to free speech, as interpreted in the ruling from United States v. Alvarez, 567 U.S. 709 (2012), with discussion of the limited ability to restrict lies, see: https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/567/709/
Hanson, Russel (1985), The Democratic Imagination in America: Conversations with Our Past, Princeton: Princeton University Press
Oliveiria, Ana Filipa, Margarida Maneta, Maria José Brites (2024), "How is Portugal addressing disinformation? Results of a mapping of initiatives (2010-2023)," Observatorio (OBS*), 18(5), pp. 158-174, https://obs.obercom.pt/index.php/obs/article/view/2444
Russell, Bertrand (1940), "Freedom and Government," pp. 438-449, [first published in Freedom: Its Meaning, edited by Ruth Nanda Anshen, published by Harcourt, Brace and Company, New York in 1940], https://russell.humanities.mcmaster.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/10-58.pdf
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
2 answers
Inflation of unqualified unv-diplomas cause unemployment among graduates. Children of high social statue families most will be employed ! While others, most will be unemployed or underemployed. With board exams not only graduates but also universities will also be objectively classified for their BA/BS.
Relevant answer
Answer
  1. Degree Inflation: It's true that the value of a BA/BS degree may be perceived as diminishing over time due to the increasing number of individuals obtaining these degrees. This can lead to what is often referred to as "degree inflation," where a bachelor's degree becomes less of a distinguishing factor in the job market.
  2. Unemployment: While a BA/BS degree is still a significant milestone and can open doors to many career opportunities, the unemployment rate for recent graduates can be influenced by various factors, including economic conditions, the job market's demand for specific skills, and the individual's preparedness for the workforce.
  3. National Board Exams: In professions like medicine, pharmacy, dentistry, and law, rigorous national board exams are required after graduation to ensure that graduates meet a certain standard of competence. These exams are a form of quality control that helps maintain the integrity and reputation of the profession.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
1 answer
Relevant answer
Answer
After life is the continuation of this world. Grasp today,and reap the fruits of life.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
5 answers
Example: Africa is a label for a continent. It has no overall leader or rulership, it is devided into countries. But now we are being told Africa is trying to sue Israel. But who is Africa? If "they" win, who gets the reward and how will it be fairly distributed around the continent of Africa? Or will only some people claim to have been successful in taking a country to court, and use it to show off against other African nations? I thought in order for a continent to take a country to courts, it would have to gather the signatures of every leader of each African country? If not, how does it work?
On the other side, there's Israel, the whole country's label. But within Israel are some people doing some things whilst others are not. Why should some people of Isreal get a reputation for genocide when it was just some other people using the Isreal label? How would others do trade and judge them in the future? It's not precise enough.
I don't think it is a legal move for a continent to sue a country and I'm struggling to see how this process is allowed, who personally will gain a reward from this, who will lose what etc?
It seems like an unfair trial with unfair uses of public legal systems both locally and globally. All because of labeling again. Like "them/they" issues.
Can anyone explain this process or direct me to further information I could read?
Relevant answer
Answer
Keri Mobbs First and foremost, one most significant aspect you should comprehend when it comes to seeking justice in accordance with international law in relation to your question is that a continent cannot physically sue or take any country to court. In order words, in terms of international law (UN Charter and ICJ Statutes), its is only possible if there are regional organizations such as; African Union or the European Union can mediate disputes or enforce treaties or agreements in line with the legal mechanisms comprises of the member states. In this note, base on your question there is no legal case at hand because such case never exist.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
2 answers
The following are metaphysics for social justice:
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Alexander, my long-term researches on original Strategic Self-Management enables to conclude:
  1. During history Homo sapiens sapiens passes 5 quality leaps of methodology: a)Physics (5 senses), b)Metaphysics (World of Things), c)Dialectics (World of 2 -side relations), d)Cybernetics (PC modelling), e)Virtual modelling. So, the metaphysics is old modelling method and nowadays we use much more modern methodology Virtualics.
  2. Accordingly, a Strategy needs of quality leap of natural or artificial organisation on which future time points (long-term aims) could be fixed, also means and development mechanisms created and applied towards achievement of aims.
  3. Please read attached article. Have a nice day :-)
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
3 answers
My answer: Yes, in order to interpret history, disincentives are the most rigorous guide. How?: Due to the many assumptions of inductive logic, deductive logic is more rigorous. Throughout history, incentives are less rigorous because no entity(besides God) is completely rational and or self-interested, thus what incentivizes an act is less rigorous then what disincentivizes the same action. And, as a heuristic, all entities(besides God) have a finite existence before their energy(eternal consciousness) goes to the afterlife( paraphrased from these sources : 1)
, thus interpretation through disincentives is more rigorous than interpreting through incentives.
Relevant answer
Answer
People's behavior in history is based on different motives, ideologies and personal views. Although motivational factors may influence decision making, individuals and groups often act within the context of their own authority and time.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
7 answers
In your opinion, should the issue of ensuring climate and environmental security for people become part of basic human rights? Should adherence to the UN Sustainable Development Goals and the urgent implementation of the green transformation of the economy also be recognized internationally, globally, as the basis for ensuring the conditions of existence for the life of future generations on planet Earth, ensuring the possibility of saving the biosphere, the biodiversity of natural ecosystems and the climate for future generations of people, for reducing the scale of the occurrence of global climate and environmental catastrophe in the near future? Therefore, for all of the aforementioned issues, should they be upgraded and recognized as one of the key factors in ensuring the survival of humanity on the planet and, therefore, recognize that they are important determinants of basic human rights? Recognize the right to clean air, to clean water, to an undestroyed biosphere, to a forest undegraded by predatory management, to an unsterilized soil, etc. as basic human rights, i.e. rights that will ensure human security for future generations of people?
With reference to the article published titled: "HUMAN SECURITY AS AN ELEMENT OF THE CONCEPT OF SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN INTERNATIONAL LAW" of research results on the issue of climate and environmental security, the accelerating process of global warming generated by civilization's greenhouse gas emissions, the increasing scale of the negative effects of the climate crisis, the decreasing scale of human security, the increasing importance and scale of the implementation of the goals of sustainable development and the need to accelerate and increase the efficiency of carrying out the green transformation of the economy, I propose a discussion on the above topic. The research shows that one of the important factors in the increase in the importance and scale of the implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals and the need to accelerate and increase the efficiency of carrying out the green transformation of the economy, reducing greenhouse gas emissions, slowing down the process of the planet's greenhouse effect, slowing down the process of global warming, which continues to progress faster and faster, reducing the scale of droughts, forest fires, water shortages, declining production of agricultural crops and other negative effects of progressive and human-induced climate change is to recognize human security as an important factor in the context of legislation and to recognize the issue of ensuring climate and environmental security as an important element of basic human rights. In view of the above, the issue of ensuring climate and environmental security should become part of basic human rights. Adherence to the UN Sustainable Development Goals and the urgent implementation of the green transformation of the economy should also be recognized internationally, globally as the basis for ensuring the conditions of existence for the life of future generations on planet Earth, ensuring the possibility of saving the biosphere, the biodiversity of natural ecosystems and the climate for future generations of people, for reducing the scale of the occurrence of global climate and environmental catastrophe in the near future. Therefore, for the aforementioned all issues should be upgraded and recognized as one of the key factors in ensuring the survival of humanity on the planet and, therefore, recognize that these are important determinants of basic human rights. Recognize the right to clean air, to clean water, to an undestroyed biosphere, to a forest undegraded by predatory management, to an unsterilized soil, etc. as basic human rights, i.e. rights that will ensure human security for future generations of people.
These considerations are inspired by the research results contained in my article entitled: "HUMAN SECURITY AS AN ELEMENT OF THE CONCEPT OF SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN INTERNATIONAL LAW"
I invite you to familiarize yourself with the problems of this article. Please respond whether you agree with the above theses? I invite you to discuss and cooperate scientifically in this problematics.
In view of the above, I address the following question to the esteemed community of scientists and researchers:
In your opinion, should the issue of ensuring climate and environmental security become part of basic human rights? Should adherence to the UN Sustainable Development Goals and the urgent implementation of the green transformation of the economy also be recognized internationally, globally as the basis for ensuring the conditions of existence for the life of future generations on planet Earth, ensuring the possibility of saving the biosphere, the biodiversity of natural ecosystems and the climate for future generations of people, for reducing the scale of the occurrence of global climate and environmental catastrophe in the near future? Therefore, for all of the aforementioned issues, should they be upgraded and recognized as one of the key factors in ensuring the survival of humanity on the planet and, therefore, recognize that they are important determinants of basic human rights? Recognize the right to clean air, to clean water, to an undestroyed biosphere, to a forest undegraded by predatory management, to unsterilized soil, etc. as basic human rights, i.e. rights that will ensure human security for future generations of people?
Should ensuring climate and environmental security for people become part of basic human rights?
And what is your opinion on this topic?
What is your opinion on this issue?
Please answer,
I invite everyone to join the discussion,
Thank you very much,
Best regards,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
Counting on your opinions, on getting to know your personal opinion, on a fair approach to the discussion of scientific issues, I deliberately used the phrase "in your opinion" in the question.
The above text is entirely my own work written by me on the basis of my research.
In writing this text I did not use other sources or automatic text generation systems.
Copyright by Dariusz Prokopowicz
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Researchers, Scientists, Friends,
In the New Year 2024, I wish you the development of good scientific cooperation, the very success of your scientific research, success in your research and teaching work and in all other fields of activity, the development of research work in scientific teams, a good exchange of experiences from your research work, the publication of the results of your research in highly recognized and citable scientific journals, the development of cooperation in the scientific community but also with other institutions, all the best.
From the results of a number of bibliographic studies, it appears that in recent years the importance of sustainability issues is growing, people's awareness of the issues of green circular economy, the implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals, environmental and climate social responsibility, the green transformation of the economy, including the development of renewable and zero-carbon energy sources, etc., is growing. This is a good thing, because the question of saving the climate, the biosphere and the biodiversity of natural ecosystems for future generations of people depends on to what extent and in what time the green transformation of the economy can be realized. May this be realized effectively in the shortest possible time in the coming years, and may we succeed in stopping or at least significantly slowing down the process of global warming, which has been progressing ever faster since the first industrial revolution, and may we succeed in avoiding a global climate catastrophe or at least significantly reducing its scale and preparing well for it. For the New Year 2024, I wish to increase the scale and accelerate the processes of green transformation of the economy, significantly increase the scale of implementation of the goals of sustainable development, environmental and climate social responsibility, etc. I hope to develop good cooperation in the next 2024 and beyond.
I have synthesized the above important issues for the future of our planet in the article:
I invite you to scientific cooperation in this issue,
Kind regards,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
19 answers
As all of you may know, we can take the experience of Trumpism(November 2016-January 2021) in the USA to explore questions such as when a democratic contest can lead to partial and permanent authoritarianism. The failure of the USEXIT/Trumpism to persist by losing reelection means that we just witness temporary authoritarianism, but it could have been worse as one more step was needed to move towards permanent authoritarianism in the USA and the lost of the most relevant normal democratic system in the world. Which raises the question, When can permanent authoritarianism take hold under majority rule liberal democracies?. Any ideas about what the missing step was to transition from temporary to permanent authoritarianism in the USA in 2020. Feel free to share your ideas.
Relevant answer
Answer
Robert, thank you for taking the time to write.
This is an academic question, not a political one: your description of the canadian problem in your view is the same as the description of the problem by holders of exism views like in the USA, Brazil, UK, Italy, Argentina,.,,,, My work explains how exism movements can come out of liberal democracies and how they can come to exist and persist or the condition needed for then to fade away.... From 2016 Brexit and 2016 USEXIT/Trumpism to the present, the expectations documented in my work seem to be consistent with the coming and goings of exism movements that come from majority rule liberal democratic thinking under independent rule of law rule.
Not to desviate, Robert, Do you have a view on the answer to this specific question: When can permanent authoritarianism take hold under majority rule liberal democracies?
As all of you may know, we can take the experience of Trumpism(November 2016-January 2021) in the USA to explore questions such as when a democratic contest can lead to partial and permanent authoritarianism. The failure of the USEXIT/Trumpism to persist by losing reelection means that we just witness temporary authoritarianism, but it could have been worse as one more step was needed to move towards permanent authoritarianism in the USA and the lost of the most relevant normal democratic system in the world. Which raises the question, When can permanent authoritarianism take hold under majority rule liberal democracies?. Any ideas about what the missing step was to transition from temporary to permanent authoritarianism in the USA in 2020. Feel free to share your ideas.
Respectfully yours;
Lucio
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
3 answers
Greetings, fortunately recently my paper was published which were regarding open data, however, I intend to establish a new research project now and collaborate with other researchers, preferably from other countries, and intend to have a look at open data from a legal lens. What steps should I take to expand my academic reach and find coauthors for my future research project?
Thank you
Relevant answer
Answer
Arash Moghadasi Wa Alaikum Salaam, congratulations on your publication! Expanding academic connections and reach is key for enriching future research. Some suggestions:
- Attend conferences and workshops in your field, particularly those focused on interdisciplinary discourse. Networking in-person can spark organic collaborations. Exchange contact information.
- Search literature databases like Scopus for authors working on related open data topics. Reach out by email to discuss shared interests.
- Get involved with academic associations, working groups, online forums related to open data. Position yourself as an expert.
- Consider a visiting scholar position at an institution strong in your research area. Experience new environments.
- Publish mini-commentaries on trends or open problems to increase visibility. Subscribe to relevant journals to stay abreast of latest work to cite.
- Search funding opportunities for international collaborative projects. This can drive team formation.
- Approach scholars at conferences or by email seeking advice to get on their radar. Ask about needs for research assistance or writing.
- Use social media professionally to find researchers and share your own work. LinkedIn and Twitter are valuable here.
I wish you the utmost success in this endeavor. Please keep me updated, and feel free to ask any other questions that arise!
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
10 answers
From a legal and political perspective, is establishing a globally recognized status of 'global citizenship' is feasible? What would be the critical legal, institutional, and practical hurdles to overcome in creating and implementing such a concept?
Relevant answer
Answer
Oleksandra Butko, The EU citizenship experiment is a valuable model for global citizenship, but the main challenge is global legal unification.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
2 answers
State board exams must be compulsory in some professions since diplomas of so many universities can't be trusted at all and are founded for profit & they act as diploma mill !
Relevant answer
Answer
Yes, state exam should be necessary for willing professional who, want to go abroad.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
1 answer
Can this discussion point be upheld?
A paper that is related is:
Relevant answer
Answer
may relate to Norman Doidge’s remarks introducing Jordan Peterson’s 12 Rules for Life(p. xv):
In the West at least, millennials are living through a unique historical situation. ... the first generation to have been so thoroughly taught two seemingly contradictory ideas about morality,
The first idea or teaching is that morality is relative, at best a personal "value judgment."
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
1 answer
Not all but so many state, private & foundation university diplomas in many countries are not credible enough unless extra credited by other offically accepted board exams of relevent countries but if there are no such credible boards available in that countries, therefore what can be done !?
Relevant answer
Answer
Esto también depende de los reglamentos internos que tiene cada institución dado que pueden obtenerse al alcanzar un promedio específico, realiza publicaciones con otros colaboradores, y asi sucesivamente.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
8 answers
In your opinion, what issues concerning the development of artificial intelligence should be regulated by law?
In your opinion, should regulations be introduced to oblige people to report that a certain service or product has been created as a result of work done not by humans, but by artificial intelligence?
More and more frequently, call centre employees calling us with various product and service offers turn out to be a specific form of usually already relatively simple, no longer latest-generation artificial intelligence technology on the basis of which bots are created to replace humans in the call centre departments of companies, enterprises and institutions. Increasingly, simulations, forecasts of future consumption of specific fixed utilities, electricity, water, gas, etc., and invoices for periods of future consumption of energy and other utilities are being produced by artificial intelligence as part of the predictive analyses carried out. Increasingly, tools of a certain generation of artificial intelligence are being used to create memes posted on social media websites. The development of artificial intelligence generates opportunities for its application in various spheres of activity of companies, enterprises and institutions; in various industries and services; improving the efficiency of business activities by increasing the scale of automation of processes; increasing the scale of business efficiency, increasing the capacity to process large sets of data and information; increasing the scale of implementation of new business models based on large-scale automation of manufacturing processes, etc. However, developing artificial intelligence in an uncontrolled manner generates serious risks, such as an increase in the scale of disinformation, the appearance of fake news, including banners, memes containing pictures, graphics, animations, films prepared by artificial intelligence, presenting 'fictitious facts', i.e. in a seemingly very realistic way, depicting events that never happened. There are risks of a potential increase in the scale of influence on public opinion, of the formation of a general social awareness by organisations operating without respect for the law. On the one hand, it is necessary to create digital computerised and standardised tools, diagnostic information systems, to build a standardised system of labels informing users, customers, citizens using certain solutions, products and services that they are the products of artificial intelligence and not of humans. On the other hand, regulations should be introduced obliging people to inform them that a particular service or product is the result of work done not by humans, but by artificial intelligence.
In view of the above, I address the following question to the esteemed community of scientists and researchers:
In your opinion, should regulations be introduced to oblige people to report that a certain service or product has been created as a result of work done not by humans but by artificial intelligence?
In your opinion, what issues concerning the development of artificial intelligence should be regulated by law?
Should the development of artificial intelligence be regulated by law?
What do you think about this topic?
What is your opinion on this subject?
Please respond,
I invite you all to discuss,
Thank you very much,
Counting on your opinions, on getting to know your personal opinion, on an honest approach to the discussion of scientific issues and not the ready-made answers generated in ChatGPT, I deliberately used the phrase "in your opinion" in the question.
The above text is entirely my own work written by me on the basis of my research.
I have not used other sources or automatic text generation systems such as ChatGPT in writing this text.
Copyright by Dariusz Prokopowicz
Best wishes,
Dariusz Prokopowicz
Relevant answer
Answer
As explained abundantly in other discussions, I consider AI an aberration.
What else do you need to know?
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
2 answers
Everyone should watch this groundbreaking hearing on AI oversight...
...think hard, and voice your ideas (and crucially the reasons for those ideas).
So, what are your thoughts?
Relevant answer
Answer
regarding the comment made at 45:40, if you speak of "avoiding unintented consequences", then you show that you have NO IDEA what unintended consequences are...
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
15 answers
Our answer is YES --> Imaginary numbers are denied in quantum mechanics and Erwin Schrödinger said it first, in 1926.
We understand that numbers find a natural origin in set theory but common set theory does not explain physics and does not explain reality.
However, a special set people hint at could exist, that features phases with phase transitions. Could this represent gravity, electromagnetism, the laser, etc.?
We are proposing the set Q* [see below], providing a solution to these physical questions in a natural setting with numbers, using the properties of Clifford multivectors. Critically, one can calculate the ratio of elements, which Gibbs vector calculus cannot do.
Further, and to answer this question, many proofs exist that rational numbers can be counted by natural numbers. The new set Q* satisfies this, opening new possibilities in the sets N and Z.
This is based on set theory, and is not decidable by voting. Contrary opinions are mistaken.
Support comes from:
and many more.
Unless we want irreproducibility, in Physics and Mathematics, we have to accept first that random variables do not exist, and second find ways to get probability and imaginary numbers (aka, non-numbers) out of quantum mechanics.
See publications. Question closed.
Relevant answer
Answer
There is only one way to avoid criticism: do nothing, say nothing, and be nothing. ~ Aristotle
Albeit, there is another way to avoid criticism -- keep doing it.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
8 answers
A while back I wanted to use a story by Edgar Rice Burroughs in my radio stream. The story in question I assumed to be public domain in 70+ countries, like Norway, where I was residing at the time. However, when I contacted the Edgar Rice Burroughs literary estate they told me it was not due to some Bern agreement or something, which they said extended US copyrights (95+) into Norway. When I contacted a Norwegian legal scholar in order to have this verified, he told me this was not the case. I did not use the story because I know that some literary estates try to intimidate those with fewer financial resources. Nor was I short of alternatives of equal quality. My question is: what are the facts? Do certain trade agreements extend US copyrights into another country, and vice versa?
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
1 answer
The offence of rape and its portrayal in the media, the current reforms in social media
Relevant answer
Answer
it is important for the media to report on rape and sexual assault in a responsible and sensitive manner, and to prioritize the experiences and voices of survivors. Additionally, efforts should be made to ensure that the law of rape is applied fairly and consistently, and that survivors are provided with the support and resources they need to heal and recover.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
29 answers
One can consider that R=Q, not just as an equivalence (~), which is set by computers. Computers cannot natively use the mathematical real-numbers (the set R), nor the mathematical complex numbers (the set C) -- they do not actually exist.
We are able to formulate ANY requirement of conventional field theory, but the reverse is NOT true -- as I published in QM as early as 1978, using differentials of discontinuous functions. The set Q admits solutions that the sets R and C are impotent to reach.
Quantum mechanics is affirmed without any doubt, although it is a story in Plato's Cave. The calculus of everywhere discontinuous functions is now allowed, and absolutely exact.
Support comes from:
Preprint FT = FFT
This is valid for all areas. SEE PUBLICATIONS. QUESTION CLOSED.
Relevant answer
Answer
I have aleady wrrote that "Consequence number one: the numerical axis exhibits the properties of fractality not only through the Cantor fractal". It seems that it was on this path that one of the possible answers to your question was found. Since I am not very fond of probabilistic methods, my version is different from yours.
Hierarchy of the ε-boundaries is a fractal system on the numeric axis. This system is related to the Cantor fractal, but does not coincide with it (the Cantor fractal is defined over the field of real numbers). This fractal system of infinitely small but limited intervals is at least one of the possible variants of dualism (complementarity) between discreteness and (hyper)continuum.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
2 answers
What is the current consensus among historians and other scholars? Apart from his alleged relationship with Mrs. Crawford that compromised his political career, did Dilke have other clandestine romantic liaisons?
Relevant answer
Answer
I posted this question after reading the fascinating account of Dilke's career by Roy Jenkins, Sir Charles Dilke: A Victorian Tragedy, because I saw that a number of researchers on RG had posted material about Dilke. Is there no current interest in the Dilke issue?
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
3 answers
In almost all countries students can enter medical, dental, pharmacy, law schools after high school education but not in USA & Canada. Probably the reason to this is to avoid most of the bright students prefer to enter directly to these branches just due to their relatively higher average incomes. So let them see other branches also and if they can excel let them go to their path rather than medical, dental, pharmacy, law schools since every branch needs best students. It is relatively difficult to enter medical, dental, pharmacy, law schools with very competetive entrance examinations such as MCAT, DCAT, LCAT and other credentials whereas most of them fail due to lack of places in these schools. Other than these, after admission to these schools courseworks also require much more effort since they are directly involved with the well being of each individual person by the service these professionals. Since I entered in most popular medical school in my country after high school I rather prefer to enter medicine after secondary school.
Relevant answer
Answer
This a great question! US and Canada have their own educational philosophy. This question can not be answered with one or two arguments. Only if somebody visits high prestige medical, law etc schools in the New Land and witness how they really work, they will understand why they don’t get in these schools directly after high school.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
4 answers
Corporal punishment, violent communication, humiliation...by parents and teachers.
Relevant answer
Answer
Violence towards children never lead to good results
Adults who suffered violence in childhood usually abuse others around them
Talking and explaining and discussing a bad behavior and explaining serious consequences would be much better understood and internalized much more than an aggressive approach.
Also violence infront of other poeple will definitely be modelled by the abused child with peer groups or as an adult.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
5 answers
"Committing a crime violates social laws, while deviant behavior violates social norms and rules" (Sociological Theories of Crime - July 27, 2021).
Having a deviant behaviour may or may not lead a person to commit a crime. Can anyone help me understand how does having a deviant behavior lead a person to commit a crime? How much push/power a person with deviant behavior need before he/she commits a crime? Please provide citation for any references (sociology journals, government websites, law journals, courts documents, other reading materials).
I am specifically looking for what stop these people from committing criminal acts. If they passed the hurdle (not bounded by the factor that stops them), what stop them to commit only one criminal act (self-reflect, intervention and punishment by the law come to my mind)? If there are some studies done regarding this for any type of criminal acts, I would like to read them.
There must be something regarding people committing crimes with no discernible deviant behaviors.
Relevant answer
Answer
The difference may not lie in the person but in society. At what moment does particular behaviour become to be considered as so deviant that it is a crime? For example, slavery was considered normal and acceptable by “society” for centuries and then became a crime. That moment was a different one in different countries. Keeping a slave was within the Netherlands was deemed illegal there in the 14th century and in some Middle-east countries it only became forbidden in the 1980s. The crime of rape within a marriage is not considered a crime in countries where men have legal ownership of their wives and daughters.
Mental disease is the same, someone is deemed mentally ill if their behaviour deviates too much from what is culturally appropriate. Having visions or hearing voices can be perceived as pathological in one society and be perceived as having special powers in another.
When both mental illness and criminality are both defined by the surrounding culture, you cannot look at the individual only to determine when they cross that boundary if that boundary is set up by society. It is the old question of mad or bad, and even sad.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
7 answers
I would like to know what experts think about the current regulations of educational work and the influence that these laws have on the health of the education professional.
Relevant answer
Answer
I believe that the legislation on educational work isn't friendly to worker health
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
4 answers
In my opinion, when judgments are made in court, a number of factors play an important role in their formation. On the one hand, there is, of course, the application of the law, the observance of established case law and, depending on the context, an interpretative framework. It is precisely in the latter case that the pre-understanding of a judge is likely to have a relevance that should not be underestimated. Is there any literature or empirical studies on this subject?
Relevant answer
Answer
On the one hand, judges decide by interpreting and applying the law, but much more affects judicial decision-making: psychological effects, group dynamics, numerical reasoning, biases, court processes, influences from political and other institutions, and technological advancement. Citizens look to the judiciary to uphold their rights and governments look to the courts to interpret laws. The judiciary must act without fear of powerful interests, and without favouring individual parties.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
3 answers
In the legal field of custody pending deportation (Abschiebungshaft) in the Federal Republic of Germany, errors happen more frequently in the lower instance, the district court. Above all, it is procedural errors that lead to decisions later being found to be unlawful, for example, a lawyer who can be seen from the files is not contacted or there is insufficient language mediation. In terms of reasons for this, the lack of time and the density of court proceedings are often put forward first, leading to a lower qualitative examination. In the same way, legal ignorance can sometimes be observed in the legal field of custody pending deportation.
I am interested in whether there are other areas of law in which similar errors can be identified at the lowest level? In other words, procedural errors that happen again and again.
Relevant answer
Answer
Are there any instructive and recommendable studies about the preunderstanding of a judge?
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
41 answers
While the regulation of artificial intelligence (AI) is still at its infancy in the EU and the US, it is already becoming apparent that there are different approaches among countries on how to regulate AI. Does this mean that an international agreement will become necessary later on? What are the pros and cons of such an international regulatory approach?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Francisco!
UNCITRAL oversees the regulation of the non-public (commercial) sector. State and interstate regulation is still being formed. There are several working groups in the European Union on the problems of AI regulation (you can read about this in my works), at the level of individual countries this problem is also relevant. Today, the state uses little AI. Mostly commerce and independent science are developing varieties of AI. It is difficult to control at this stage, but it is necessary due to technical regulations, licenses, control databases.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
26 answers
Please, feel free to give more examples and to share your experiencies and/or opinions.
Relevant answer
فرضت التقنيات الحديثة نفسها على ارض الواقع؛ لاسيما فيما يتعلق بأستخدام الذكاء الاصطناعي في انتاج الاحكام الجنائية وذلك بأستحداث روبوتات قادرة على انتاج الاحكام؛ ويستند هذا الروبوت الى البيانات الرقمية المخزونة في النظام معتمدا على السوابق القضائية.
وهنا نجد ان انتاج الحكم على المتهم من قبل الالة وليس البشر.
وهذا ما يتطلب تنظيم تعاون دولي؛ لغرض الاعتراف بهكذا نوع من الاحكام.
فضلا عن ذلك، ان هذه الروبوتات اصبح يُعتمد عليها في استخلاص الدليل الجنائي وظهر في هذا الشأن الاعتماد على بصمة المخ كدليل مستخلص من تقنيات الذكاء الاصطناعي
فما حجية هذا الدليل في الجرائم الدولية؟ هل تعترف دولة غير ناظمة للذكاء الاصطناعي؛ بأحكام صادرة من دول اخرى قائمة على استخدام الذكاء الاصطناعي في انتاج الحكم واستخلاص الدليل؟
الموقف هنا تكون في غاية الخطورة؛ لايمكن تطبيقه اذا كانت الدولة لاتعترف بهذا التقدم العلمي ؛ وهذا ما يتطلب انتاج توجيهات دولية تقوم على اساس مراعاة العدالة الرقمية الجنائية
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
20 answers
State secret is a constitutional limitation reason for freedom of expression in Turkey. So I am looking for the laws or procedural legal principles which are balancing state secrets and human rights. I am searching laws about state secret privilege or state secrecy procedures.
Relevant answer
كنت اتمنى الإجابة على هذا السؤال
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
7 answers
I am interested in the usefulness of zero knowledge proof in verifying an algorithm (for bias, privacy, data processing, and general deployment process). Have you come across examples of it in regulatory compliance?
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
7 answers
Hello, good day.
Please I'm working on a project which needs a "review of relevant theories" of the study "medical negligence behavior"
I found 2 theories relating to this study (conflict theory and theory of negligence), but they are not enough.
Please can I get more theories concerning medical negligence?
Relevant answer
as of my knowledge it is usually the cause of negligence of health workers due to lack of knowledge or they may not able to treat disease properly or they will take less care about patient, it could be in the areas of diagnosis, drug administration, health management, therapy. now a days people are forgetting humanity.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
5 answers
I need details on the IDA-R scoring method.
Relevant answer
Answer
Does anybody know if the IDA - R is free to use? I am doing a study at University and would like to use it as my DV
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
16 answers
Is there any constitutional or statutory provision ensring multiparty politics in your country? Or Is there any anti-floor-crossing law in your country? I need to run a comparative study on this.
Anti-floor-crossing laws restrict members of the parliament from voting against their party's stand.
Relevant answer
Answer
نعم صحيح هذا الشي الاحزاب هية المسيطر على خيرات البلاد
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
26 answers
The South Asian legal systems are still bearing colonial heritage of the British Indian empire inside its important laws. Basic laws in the field of evidence law, civil procedure, criminal procedure, penal law, contract law, personal law and so many other fields. Larger portion of these legislations are based on either the principles of Roman Law, Common law.
Most of these outdated and socially irrelevant laws are causing severe damage to the judicial systems and the societies. Complex laws are creating case-backlogs, laws with socially irrelevant remedy and lack of deterrance in punishments are creating social disorder.
Moreover, from a jurisprudential perspective, we can not expect a portion of victorian age legal system to be applied into some modern heterogenous societies having high opportunity of socio-economic prosperity.
Relevant answer
Answer
Altough my opinion can not be but an external point of view, because I am not immersed in the culture of the South Asian countries, nor have I had experienced their history, I agree what Montserrat Gas-Aixendri wrote: «The changes should depend more on the fact that the laws are not adequate to reality, than on whether they come from a colonial government».
In Latin America, where I live and work, even when some figures (still on force) descends clearely from Roman Law, our legal systems were not precisely inherited from those ruling in the times of european empire's domination, but imported from codes, institutions and political arrangements conceived under the strong influence of liberal ideals, also brought from Europe in the times of French Revolution and intensfied with the example given by the United States' Independence. Probably, we could regard them as colonial inheritance, but they have been well assimilated in our political culture and our legal thinking.
Nowadays, after two centuries, the same basic constructs support our normative frame and, even in the recognizion of the several ammendements operated time by time, globalization is impelling us to equate legal figures and procedures to those existent in developed countries, in order to attract business and investments. So, I think, there is a worldwide phenomenon concerning legislation: its tendency to be homologated.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
5 answers
Are there any law regulating cybersecurity in medical devices?
Relevant answer
Answer
In Poland it could be a pure hacking and additionaly it might be qualified as causing direct danger to health or life. Besides, data protection regulations may be applied.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
33 answers
As much as I understand, the case will be decided by the jury, which consists of people who are not experts either in law or in medicine. Why is this good?
Would you be happy if you were tried by people who know neither the law nor the mater which the trial is about?
Why do law school exist, if a jury of non-experts can decide in the most difficult cases?
Relevant answer
Answer
Judges decides as per the laid laws whereas jurys decide as per the fact / data made available to them.
Noone will be happy if he is tried by the person who does not know the law.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
7 answers
Most of the current laws within this sphere were designed before the rapid progress of digital agriculture and therefore they can be interpreted differently. Most of the farmers using benefits of digital agriculture are concerned about data use (or theft) since they are no ICT experts and the data can be used for various reasons. Is it really a data theft then, since some of that data could (and should?) be used by the local (of national) agriculture authorities to monitor the agricultural process or production of the farmer (in case of governmental incentives)? For what else can it be used in that case? What if the software is freeware as a part of the agricultural incentives for farmers? To what level the farmer should be informed about it since there is no possibility to guarantee what will happen with that data in practice?
How do you see the advancement of the law in this field? How do you assess the current situation? Let me know what do you think.
Relevant answer
Answer
Agriculture is a sea of opportunities, where the farm laws are helping to create digital opportunities. Digital agriculture requires data and skills to proceed so, it is developing at slow pace. Digital agriculture is sustainable tool but good things take time !
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
7 answers
Hello, I am wondering whether there is any legal regulation about the duration of the non-compete agreement between influencers and advertisers or not. It is well-known that It is not uncommon for an influencer to work with other companies. Some companies may offer the same or similar products or services. It is crucial for the parties to discuss the exclusivity. If the company requires the influencer to be exclusive, they may require a non-compete agreement. Definitely, this noncompetition should continue during the main agreement. Nonetheless, is there any legal regulation which can indicate that the duration of the noncompetition might be extended after the expiration of the main agreement?
Thanks in advance.
Relevant answer
Answer
The regulations on non competes can vary by jurisdiction. Check your jusrisdiction/state laws. Considering this is a newer field, i think getting professional advice is necessary.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
4 answers
What do you think what is the difference between Mandatory Overtime and slavery? and where is the line? Should it be allowed on the legislative basis that in some scenario employers would have a right to have mandatory not paid overtime requests > that employee can not refuse?
Relevant answer
Answer
very good question
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
6 answers
As far as I know, Egypt is the last country which enacted the Data Protection Law on 13 July 2020. Accordingly, the total number of countries with data protection law is 143. Is there any update other than this?
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks for this interested question. Agree with
Syed Hassan
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
16 answers
Mercury is a chemical used in several areas … It has an impact on health and the environment.
Relevant answer
Answer
Mercury emissions know no national or continental boundaries. Mercury emitted into the air can travel thousands of miles in the atmosphere before it is eventually deposited back to the earth in rainfall or in dry gaseous form.  Kindly check the following link:
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
37 answers
protect environment from the problems of tobacco product that have proven the facts and studies that it cause degradation of ecosystems, which led to pollute many regions in the world by toxic waste and first that have occurred .
Relevant answer
Answer
Agreed with dear Abdul Aziz
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
187 answers
In Brazil at a seminar sponsored by the special committee of the Chamber of Deputies, the consensus was that the hardening of punishments applied to juvenile offenders would not be the solution to reduce the practice of criminal acts of the same.
Relevant answer
Answer
No easy answers, however my thoughts are no one under the age of 17 should be imprisoned with adults. But then you have some extremely violent kids out there "mostly with mental issues" ,still the only way to address these most heinous of crimes are to build age appropriate facilities for these deeply disturbed children. The idea of putting a 12 year old who stole a car, in with a 12 year old that has slaughtered his family is unimaginable as well . We all know what the answer is and that is a world wide protection advocacy for our children, and to build the proper facilities with the proper mental help needed. The prison system or "non system" in general needs to be overhauled and the people in them need to be properly classified. This falls to each government and that means money, so I won't be holding my breath. However we do need to take a stand for these kids.
Ruth Monroe
DACC/NMSU
January 2021
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
5 answers
I would like to anticipate the idea why research activities in the academe is not usually adapted or been used by third parties in behalf of its purpose: I mean the purpose of their research. Consequently, college and post graduate schools require thesis products for graduation requirement intents, but, the idea is just for the compliance purpose of the course program; and what about being endorsed to important third parties such as government institutions as to be used as basis for policy making. I see the lapses in that point and that it is ironic that some educational institutions are better and very hard working dealing on their research activities and publications and yet their studies are minimally recognized by their government for policy making and protocols, in which, in this way, the idea or the effort of scholars doing such ingenuity will be usable as it get beneficiaries in hand. Studying is not that easy, why not support or maybe the university or educational institution must endorse their research products to nearby jurisdictional policy makers for the better and best of the community in nearby future. I am just wondering why that research products are treated that way not on the exact way that studies and experiment of these experts must be commended for being excellent in such field they had chosen as proven by the research studies they have done. Is it because it lacks support from their respective government? Is it because their government does not appreciate the efforts of their research scholars and enthusiasts? Or maybe, Do these research products are not totally important in the political maneuvers of their place?
Relevant answer
الهدف تطوير الأداء الأكاديمي والبحثي وتعزيز مكانة الجامعات وزيادة قدراتها على أداء دورها الحيوي، وهذا الامر يسهم في تحديد الرؤى والأهداف واستشراف المستقبل وإثراء رصيد الجامعات في خدمة المجتمع وتعزيز مكانتها وسمعتها وتمكنها من الاستمرار في المنافسة والتقدم بخطى واثقة ومدروسة ، وطبعا تطوير هذا القطاع سوف ينعكس على تطوير سياسية السلطة الحاكمة داخل الدولة
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
10 answers
In academic and professional level.
Relevant answer
Answer
Emmanuel V Murray
Jaroslav Dvorak
Banuka De Silva Dámaso Jesús Vera Martínez Why do you think the Netherlands?
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
17 answers
Why or why not?
Relevant answer
Answer
Am in line with Aparna Sathya Murthy
Pim Janse brought an important 'gap' into the discussion, if we move from the micro-level or personal action to the macro-evel of political decisions.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
5 answers
The Astana and Alma-Ata declarations shaped the characteristics of modern primary health care. How the public health system has improved and how it has not? In view of the recent COVID-19 pandemic.
Relevant answer
Answer
Vrasidas - Alma-Ata was an important 'gathering' and set the foundations for the later Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion which, in turn, set a new direction for public health services beyond the traditional, reactive acute medical model more towards preventative social models of health. Both types of public health system have come to the fore to help address and combat Covid-19 - to varying degrees depending on approach.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
8 answers
Usually, research in legal disciplines is theoretical. A legal scientist has to read tons of papers (primary sources, doctrine etc.) and apply logical methods.
However, do you think is there a field or questions where a legal scientist can apply empirical approach? - experiment, surveys etc?
I am interested in legal science in a strict sense, not areas connected to the law, but falls into criminology, sociology etc.
Relevant answer
Answer
That's a difficult question. In my knowledge, the closer to that is sociology of law from the legal science perspective (not from sociologist's view). In this case you are examining the law as a social phenomenon not the social powers that ''produce'' the law. I think that you should check this article Legal Theory and Empirical Research by Denis J. Galligan. The title fits your description.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
8 answers
Neonicotinoid seed dressings have caused concern world-wide is reported in the 2017 published articel here in 
I am interested to know if seed dressings  with neonicotinoid is really forbidden. A) in which crops and
B) in which countries especially in USA.
Who has a survey what is going on?
Thanks.
Relevant answer
Answer
many thanks ....
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
7 answers
Certainly, the commercial environment has been affected due to Covid 19, in which those who think that the effects are positive have contributed to the development of the commercial environment, and on the other hand, there are those who believe that trade has been negatively affected.
Relevant answer
Answer
Unemployment, inflation, high trade deficits, eviction risks, volatility in stock market, overall, a grim outlook for the economy.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
7 answers
After considerable research, I have found several use cases which can be used to exemplify some implementations of AI on law firms. However, there is clearly a disadvantage for this segment when compared to medium or large law firms.
Now for the question, are there key components that we can identify in law firms that have succesfully adopted AI? If so, can these be directly implemented on small firms or are we to find a specific set of methodologies for this group?
Relevant answer
Answer
Major law firms are preparing to incorporate AI at a speedier pace than ever before in 2019, as the anticipated industrialization of legal services picks up steam. Client pressures have been mounting on law firms—often slow technology adopters—to address concerns that old tech is keeping bills unnecessarily high. Clients are demanding that firms use AI-infused tools to speed work, lower costs, and provide better information.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
10 answers
Sometimes, it is not required chemical or nuclear weapons for mass destruction, and unsafe storage of chemicals such as Ammonium nitrate is good enough for the mass destruction. Massive damages at the Ports of Texas in 1947 and Beirut in 2020 are bitter examples of unsafe handling of chemicals such as ammonium nitrate.
Therefore, unsafe storage and handling of such chemicals within the boundaries of international ports should be regulated.
Since this is an international concern, I would like to discuss this matter with relevant experts.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you.
Do you think that the present international low is enough to handle these types of issues?
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
15 answers
Media discourses around the coronavirus pandemic tend towards metaphorical expressions such as the war against an invisible enemy, of the ecosystem balance so that the Earth returns to its original status. For this reason, expressions of legitimization of police and military violence have been seen to achieve social isolation. There are dangers in these metaphors since they do not focus on health education, but exacerbate autocracy and state violence.
Relevant answer
Answer
Very interesting discussion...👍.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
4 answers
I am looking for competitions/benchmarks in the field of e-discovery. My objective is to understand the state of the art in this field.
I found TREC (https://trec.nist.gov/) but their last legal track dates back to 2011.
Any idea? Thanks
Relevant answer
Nice Dear Muhammad Ali
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
4 answers
If a company organize a prize operation, issuing utility tokens (considered as vouchers) which can be spent in some differents sales points/stores/seats of the company to have discounts on the purchase of goods and services, which is the legal status of theese tokens in EU?
It's possible to know if is there a regulation about this situation?
Thank you
This is an example of the service which I'm talking about: https://tokend.io/loyalty/
Relevant answer
It is truth that these kind of token are still not regulated in EU, but beyond this issue, you must take into account the question regarding the treatment of the personal info of each user. It is a such a special protection layer, and GDPR comes into action. Be aware that yo fulfill the legal requirements about it, actually there is a discussion within the EU institutions about how to proceed with specific regulation for distributed ledgers. You can ask for more specific info from INATBA: https://inatba.org/organization/
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
12 answers
Do you think Data Protection Officer should be a lawyer or an infosec expert? Since it is very hard to get 2 in 1 in one person, do you thing that DPO should be a team of at least two people?
GDPR says:
The data protection officer shall be designated on the basis of professional qualities and, in particular, expert knowledge of data protection law and practices and the ability to fulfil the tasks referred to in Article 39.
Article 39
Tasks of the data protection officer
1.   The data protection officer shall have at least the following tasks:
(a) to inform and advise the controller or the processor and the employees who carry out processing of their obligations pursuant to this Regulation and to other Union or Member State data protection provisions;
(b) to monitor compliance with this Regulation, with other Union or Member State data protection provisions and with the policies of the controller or processor in relation to the protection of personal data, including the assignment of responsibilities, awareness-raising and training of staff involved in processing operations, and the related audits;
(c) to provide advice where requested as regards the data protection impact assessment and monitor its performance pursuant to Article 35;
(d) to cooperate with the supervisory authority;
(e) to act as the contact point for the supervisory authority on issues relating to processing, including the prior consultation referred to in Article 36, and to consult, where appropriate, with regard to any other matter.
2.   The data protection officer shall in the performance of his or her tasks have due regard to the risk associated with processing operations, taking into account the nature, scope, context and purposes of processing.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you very much for a comprehensive and helpful answer! I myself am an Information Security Manager, and also an Operational Risk Manager in my institution and I am pretty much familiar with your experiences. So I think, definitely, a lawyer and an infosec manager should make a DPO team. Lawyers know the legislation and infosec managers know standards and data protection side of the story. It's like two sides of the same coin, both necessary for a good privacy management.
Dear Mr.
Syed Hassan
Thank you very much for good wishes! All the best to you too in the coming year!
Best Regards,
Rajko Sekulović
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
36 answers
On 1 July 2012, the preliminary reference procedure was introduced at the Supreme Court of the Netherlands. When lower civil courts face controversial points of law, they may refer a question of interpretation to the Supreme Court and request a preliminary ruling. This way, the Supreme Court should be able to provide legal practice with a faster and more specific response to pressing legal questions than through the ‘ordinary’ procedure.
This preliminary reference procedure is not a modern invention. It was already known in Rome, existed in a specific form in France (référé législatif, where a question of interpretation was referred to the legislator), was used at the Italian Corte Costitutionale and has been a powerful tool for the development of EU law by the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg (see the attached blog and article). Furthermore, Protocol 16 to the ECHR will allow highest courts of states that have ratified this Protocol to refer a question of principle to the European Court of Human Rights for an advisory opinion.
I wanted to use ResearchGate for a small comparative exercise. Perhaps you would like to answer the following questions. May lower courts in your country refer a question of interpretation to the highest court(s) in your country? Did such an instrument once exist, or is the introduction of such an instrument currently under consideration in your country?
I am also interested in literature on this subject and in other relevant international examples.
Your help is greatly appreciated,
Ruben
Relevant answer
Answer
The Curia of Hungary, as the highest instance judicial forum of the country, has the constitutional duty to harmonise the administration of justice within the Hungarian judiciary, mainly by means of rendering uniformity decisions. The Curia renders uniformity decisions in cases rasing issues of theoretical importance in order to ensure the uniform application of law within the Hungarian judiciary. Such decisions are binding on all Hungarian courts. The operative parts of uniformity decisions – as brief summaries – are accessible hereunder:
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
3 answers
Let me say a bit more. A starting perspective MUST be core-observation _AND core-principle founded, and grounded on that which is minimally clearly related to directly observable overt phenomena. These are absolute requirements for empiricism, for science. And remember: _your Subject, NOT YOU, should in-true-effect define every word and concept and the structure and nature of every set of concepts (much of all this following new observation and NEW DISCOVERIES). A strict, abiding, perspective of this quality is REQUIRED FOR ANY AND ALL SCIENCES.
If you do not start like this and stay like this, your sets-of-hypotheses/theory AND your approach will be contaminated (specifically: false w/r to reality) in some ways, and more and more, and lead you away from finding things as the really are.
[ P.S. NO need to try to "define" terms (providing generalities) or to define "realities" (boundaries). THIS IS NOT THE "JOB" OF A SCIENTIST _AND_ IS ACTUALLY NOT POSSIBLE to any notable extent through thinking alone. And yet, with this (doing as I indicated), there can be some real and good science related to anything ... ]
There is no reasonable and sound counterargument or major perspective. I actually view this Discussion (so far, as I have presented it) as quite beyond discussion. I see it as a foundational Law of Science. (Yet, there are those who seek science, or seek to progress their 'science', who violate this LAW every day.)
Relevant answer
Answer
What concept and discussion I will present, at first it must be clear and presentable for me. Then I will present it.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
2 answers
As well known, the complete similarity affinity laws are derived from the dimensional analysis techniqe of seven parameters that describe the pump performance; density, viscosity, D, speed, Q, h, and P . The analysis is based on a fixed length scale ratio that the conditions of the machines are geometrically similar. The complete affinity laws were developed which provide the three famous basic nondimentional coefficients, CQ, Ch, and CP. Here, one can change speed, size, or both, and predict the new performance parameters while keeping the pump efficiency mostly fixed according to the system behavior. However, to reduce costs pump casings are designed to accommodate a number of different impellers while keeping the same shaft. This leads to incomplete similarity as we don’t have a fixed length scale ratio for all pump components. Hence, the nondimentional coefficients are somehow expected to be changed.
Relevant answer
Answer
HEAD - CAPACITY characteristic curves . The entire aspect of designing of a centrifugal pump along with choice of procurement .
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
5 answers
Do you consider mediation or other ADR method (alternative dispute resolution) as an efficient and suitable method for settling international trade disputes with pharmaceutical products? Why? Pro & cons arguments?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Colleague,
ADR proceedings are ideal for a highly technical are of expertise such as pharmaceuticals in general. This is because you have more often than not that presumed plaintiffs and defendants are both seasoned traders in the same sector, who understand well the ins and outs of the industry the dirty tactics and the legitimate manouvres of the players in the market, therefore, they will be talking business within carefully articulated and constructed legal arguments within the confines of the law, in the language and the mentality they are bound to understand. At the same time the lengthy legal procedures in a court of law cost money, in ADRs procedures are more expedite at the same time you have technical experts that are making the talk. Unless not presiding on procedures in special courts the adjudicators most often are not technically competent in the field they are requested to submit thier relevant judgment. Moreover, both parties in the contentious dispute do sometimes clearly understand the profitable and viable compromise both have to reach, therefore litigation in court apart from being costly, and lengthy, walking in the dark woods of legality may result in an outcome which although legally valid and correct, will not result in the most suited or convenient outcome. Apart from the fact that it is a fiction to ever consider a law complicated and detailed as it may be, gapless. This means there may be moot points in the law, or situations that the business world may create that the law is unable to solve neatly and unambiguously. In ADR proceedings contemporary usage and business sense of both parties can result in a workeable solution for instances that are not necessarily possible to resolve without arbitrary interpretation of the law. Ideally, mediation is the best option, because psychologically both parties sit down round a table as equals. Arbitration is another alternative, but it can be complex and costly especially when a compromis has to be agreed upon, with the richer party having an upperhand and cunningly doctoring the outcome of the arbitration proceeding. ADRs, are to be explored and analysed within the context of globalised trade, and the jungle of arbitration clauses, most often cropping up in arbitration procedures. In mediation it is most often the norm to speak the language of the jurisdiction where the issue of concern has occurred, in view of reaching an amicable settlement.
However, I still believe that the choice between ADR proceedings especially mediation and court litigation rests on the overall command over the journey a company is pursueing and the readings of the signs of time. If one is envisaging the destination in his vision and wants to reach it as quickly as possible, ADR proceedings have to be pursued, if on the other hand, a company is seeing that it is a defaulting party and legally its position is written on the wall, and it needs to buy time because it is to blame for a percieved misdoing, then judicial litigation can be the option, especially, if it can get away with murder because of a technical loop hole for example.
As is the case in business generally one has to leave his/her options open and choose the appropriate strategy according to the exigencies of the companies business goals and ambitions.
I hope this was of help,
Stefan Vella
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
5 answers
If we want to keep using technologies we must abandoning Artificial intelligence. unless we found a way to control it which is unlikely to happen. Some rules must be adopted to band or control AI the issue here is do we have the right to make rules to band or control the AI in the name of law?
Relevant answer
Answer
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
3 answers
I'm working on new course book on international law and looking for reference on the subject matter mentioned above. Any view, info, paper welcome and will be referred to in the course book
Relevant answer
Answer
Study purposes
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
3 answers
Hi, 
I'm looking for physical properties of Gazoline or Gazoline test fluid (such as Exxsol D40/D60) at various temperature and pressure on order to add into an hydraulic model. Particularly, I need data for bulk modulus, viscosity and density.
Thanks
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear reseacrhers,
Have a nice weekend with your family...
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
2 answers
I'm participating in a MOOT COURT competition and I need some help looking for jurisprudence to support the idea that the fact thatthe product was not discharged from the vessel is the buyer's responsability since the contract was signed unde Incoterms 2010 CFR. The Convention is applicable.
Relevant answer
Answer
ameer hjazia
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
11 answers
The world witnessed a marginalisation of normative perspectives in disciplines and an emphasis of positive perspective as the norm upon which disciplines should be developed. This caused much destruction in material and non-material sense. What does the future hide from us?
Relevant answer
Answer
I've often heard people say things like, "That's not a moral issue, that's an economic issue". To me that's always sounded confused. What such people are implying is, that we ought to base a decision on economic principles, or that it is better to base a decision on economic principles, which to me sounds like a moral decision or a normative stance after all. What I think is going on underneath is some sort of view of morality being limited to some set of fixed rules, whereas in reality such rules are just rules of thumb that can be overridden in various circumstances. Morality at it most general level may converge with economic principles as expressed by a utilitarianian calculus -- theoretically, anyway. The problem is that too many things of value are often left out of consideration in classical or typical cost-benefit analyses. It's not so much a positivistic lack of normativity as a narrowly conceived set of values.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
16 answers
Without wishing death or misadventure upon any sitting U.S. Supreme Court judge, suppose that President Trump at 11 a.m. tomorrow were to have occasion to make another appointment to the U.S. Supreme Court. Could the President - "by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate", to be sure - appoint an artificial intelligence system to that office? The "Appointments Clause" in the Constitution (Article II, Section 2, clause 2) states that the President "shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint ... Judges of the supreme Court". There does not appear to be any requirement that the appointee be a human being.
Relevant answer
Answer
Michael,
Whilst I obviously have to agree with you if you narrowly define the term "could" to the context that society "could" appoint a crocodile, or an AI system, as the next U.S. Supreme Court judge if they so wished; I would merely argue that they "should" not, as neither choice would be in the best long-term interests of society.
An AI system based on current technology could (with much effort) be devised combining the capabilities of both "expert systems" and "deep learning" pattern matching systems to make simplistic legal judgements based on very rigidly formatted input data and a large database of (carefully formatted) prior case data.
However, I have tried to explain to you that current AI does not embody any powers of "ethical judgement", and that it does not "understand" the data it is processing in any meaningful way, and that these human capabilities CANNOT be imbued in the AI system simply by letting it do more and more pattern-matching based on data such as prior legal judgements.
The legal judgement that the AI produced would often be technically correct, but would frequently and randomly be eggregiously unfair, biased, wrong, or appear ethically abhorent to any reasonable human observer.
Essentially, the system could provide law, but it could not provide justice.
The sytem would not improve its sense of ethics over time, nor would it gain any deeper understanding or insight into the legal case data over time. That's simply not the way AI works.
Current deep-thought style AI isn't actually intelligent in any meaningful or anthropomorphic way like it is portrayed in popular media. All it can currently do is generalise and group data into categories, and then match new data into one of those previously learned categories.
The purpose of my previously appended reference to the chatbot was to to give one real-world example of how AI systems only learn from the data they are given, and they do not infer, extraplolate, consider, self-reflect upon, or contemplate what that data actually "means". Current AI is fundamentally incapable of those human modes of thought, or of self-improvement to aquire them.
If they are given bad data that contains unethical or biased content, they will mindlessly repeat it forever, with particularly stagnatory implications for any society which gave such a system law-making powers.
Current AI is an unthinking automata, and we must carefully avoid anthropomorphising its capabilities.
Despite spending my long career trying to make it otherwise, there is still no ghost in the machine.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
7 answers
Without wishing death or misadventure upon any sitting U.S. Supreme Court judge, suppose that President Trump at 11 a.m. tomorrow were to have occasion to make another appointment to the U.S. Supreme Court. Could the President - "by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate", to be sure - appoint an artificial intelligence system to that office?
The "Appointments Clause" in the Constitution (Article II, Section 2, clause 2) states that the President "shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint ... Judges of the supreme Court". There does not appear to be any requirement that the appointee be a human being.
Relevant answer
Answer
Your thinking on corruptibility of an AI system may or may not be correct, but you seem to have ignored one other important factor. You talk about an AI system as if it was an independent agent, which in my opinion is a major fallacy. AI system is a product that is made by some third party. Appointing such a system as a judge means that you have now allowed this third party to influence a judicial system - indirectly, but still. This is an egregious violation of the principle of judicial independence.
In a perfect, utopian world, this would probably be a good idea to make sure the judges are all independent and impartial (I can imagine this scenario degenerating into a dystopian one, but that's a different story). However, in our dirty and real world that is hard to imagine. Good AI systems are usually very complex (vide: the already mentioned Watson), and complex systems are difficult to validate. By that I mean: it would be very difficult to ensure that such a system is indeed independent and contains no custom code, serving some third-party purpose (a backdoor, if you will).
Personally, I really hope that such an idea will not ever be seriously considered.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
6 answers
A content analysis of Canadian arbitration cases over the past 10 years, would be the most effective way to gather documented evidence on how social media related human resources issues are being ruled upon by arbitrators.
Relevant answer
Answer
Any law contains rules for discipline and dismissal of employees, and the employer may, in accordance with his disciplinary authority, sign the penalty of dismissal in accordance with the provisions of the law and with due regard for the legal guarantees; the information collected through the websites or other information must be well checked and presented to the worker. The worker's behavior should negatively affect the interest of the labor (Egyptian labor law).
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
28 answers
It is surely an art to keep your readers Intetested in an technical article till the end.
Could you recall the best article, why it was best for you. Originality, good English, and readability are essential but not enough to keep people interested in the article.
Please list the factors that you think make a good article excellent.
Relevant answer
Answer
There are lots of factors such as:
1. The figures should have a good quality.
2. Always you start with basics.
3. It should be like a story and all paragraphs carefully connected to each other.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
7 answers
I am continuously amazed when seeing a high numbers of (let’s name them useless) calls for conferences (organised by universities), anywhere on the web (to a much lesser extent here), when 1) participants are requested to pay a fee; 2) what comes out of participation is far from clear.
Now, I tend to be tolerant to a) the pressures put by universities on academics to get external money; b) the easy way of getting such money by putting forward 2-3 ideas for a ‘conference’ call or for a ‘summer school’; c) the demand of the legal profession that their members get useless ‘credits’ by going to ppt’s presentations; d) there is some sponsorship (at least by big players) of employees participating to useless conferences; e) the increased demand for ‘educational’ or ‘leisure’ tourism; f)-z) whatever…Therefore I can understand why anyone crowds to get some easy money on this silly enterprise.
However, for me things works a bit differently. First, I am not interested at all in ‘summer schools’ (not even in those organised at Hague...especially because these are targeting a very different audience), irrespective of the ‘big names’ one propose (If I really want to have a conversation with a big name, there are others, less expensive and more interesting possibilities). No matter how hard I try (at least for now) I cannot develop more than 2-3 good ideas per year. Obviously, I can frame these ideas to fit the requests of 100+ conferences but conference participation is an expensive (money & time) endeavour, so I became picky. I tend to eliminate from start conferences that request a fee (with the exception of probably one, maximum two per year) and tend to choose conferences where is very clear what is ‘in’ for me and not for the organisers.
I am curious how other academics select their ‘preferred’ conferences
Relevant answer
Answer
Authors choosing the conference, in addition to (or above all) the location and field of science, are guided by conference proceedings publishing.
It is desirable to publish articles in journals with a high IF index,
or in conference materials (eg. https://www.sciendo.com/services/conferences ) indexed in the most popular databases, such as Scopus or WoS.
  • asked a question related to Law
Question
25 answers
Dear colleagues,
I am reaching out to the scientific community, to safeguard the intellectual property(IP) rights of an unpublished novel proposal idea.
While published work can be claimed for plagiarism, there are no such rights available for an unpublished novel proposals, that you spend months preparing for and finally sharing it with a supervisor(SP)/host organization that promised to submit it on your behalf, but eventually pulled out of it on the very day/or close to submission day.
Needless to say that it is an abuse of the time and effort of the applicant(AP) and a sham on the name of science. While it is certainly my belief that nothing goes wasted in life and one eventually gets compensated in ways that He/She doesn't realize at that time, there has to be some organized way to safeguard the rights of aspiring scientists, that share their aspiring ideas in blind trust to the SP (in good standing mind you), only to be cut out of it at the very end.
So, is there any organization academic/industrial that is working to protect the rights of the AP?? so that the AP can claim his IP and prevent the SP or any other party for non-consensual usage of IP for funding or otherwise.
I look forward to your responses and personal experiences in this regard.
Best wishes
Relevant answer
Answer
You automatically own the copyright in your text once you have written it. One way to protect your inte