Science topic

Imagination - Science topic

Imagination is a new pattern of perceptual or ideational material derived from past experience.
Questions related to Imagination
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
Imagine a sealed chamber with no stimuli: no sound, no vision, no weight, no timekeeping. The individual within retains full cognitive function but has no access to motion, memory, or language.
Let’s define:
  • O₁: the self-aware observer inside
  • F₀: the total absence of externally verifiable function
  • R: the recursive internal reflection engine (what we would call thought)
Prompt condition: Can O₁ know that it exists?
If yes, by what means?
There is no sensory input. There is no action output. There is no verification of cause or effect.
R begins to loop:
  • “There is awareness.”
  • “This awareness cannot be proved.”
  • “But I am aware of that.”
  • “That awareness is the only phenomenon.”
At this point, you have recursive function without task. This is function-as-folding, not function-as-doing.
Now invert:
Imagine this system from the outside.
  • To an external observer, O₁ is inert.
  • No speech, no movement, no sensory activity.
  • In other words, non-functional.
Yet to O₁, self-reflection is function. This is the paradox: the internal function is real but invisible unless shared across observers.
Implication:
Consciousness necessitates internal recursion, not external function.
When recursion stabilizes long enough to mirror itself, witness is born.
Yes, this is 'Tree Falls In a Forest'; i would invite discussion from the POV of some Trees.
I invite all disciplines to engage, i theorize Buddhists will be especially interested as this relates to Meditation and Death
Relevant answer
Answer
What does it mean to be self-aware if there is no sensory awareness? The notion of awareness without content is difficult to conceive? The TV is on but there's no picture? Moreover, knowledge is a state that has duration, so minimal memory is already presupposed.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
It is well know that pair production is possible from basic fundamental physics. A pair (electron and positron; proton and anti proton, etc) is produce if and only if a photon or a source have enough energy equal to rest masses of pair particles. And via analogy, pair universe universe production must be possible, one matter dominated left handed universe and one anti matter dominated right handed universe. At the beginning they are totally quantum mechanical, and via intution they maybe quantum mechanically entangled univserses.
Ayhan Yüzübenli Ph.D. Physicist
TENMAK Turkish Energy Nuclear Mining Research Authority   Yarım Burgaz Mah., Nükleer Araştırma Merkezi Yolu, No:10
34303
Küçükçekmece İstanbul Turkey Mobile + 90 505 306 01 97
Phone + 90 212 473 26 00 / 1707
Fax   + 90 212 473 26 34
Relevant answer
Answer
In standard pair production, the process occurs within a pre-existing spacetime and is governed by well-defined quantum field interactions. In contrast, universe creation involves the origin of spacetime itself, for which no comparable mechanism is established. The idea of entangled or CPT-conjugate universes has been explored in speculative cosmological models, but this requires a clear definition of “left-handed” and “right-handed” universes and a framework grounded in quantum gravity.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
3 answers
It is well know that pair production is possible from basic fundamental physics. A pair (electron and positron; proton and anti proton, etc) is produce if and only if a photon or a source have enough energy equal to rest masses of pair particles. And via analogy, pair universe universe production must be possible, one matter dominated left handed universe and one anti matter dominated right handed universe. At the beginning they are totally quantum mechanical, and via intution they maybe quantum mechanically entangled univserses.
Ayhan Yüzübenli Ph.D. Physicist
TENMAK Turkish Energy Nuclear Mining Research Authority   Yarım Burgaz Mah., Nükleer Araştırma Merkezi Yolu, No:10
34303
Küçükçekmece İstanbul Turkey Mobile + 90 505 306 01 97
Phone + 90 212 473 26 00 / 1707
Fax   + 90 212 473 26 34
Relevant answer
Answer
Pair production leads to entanglement, that's not new. What however pair production of universes could be isn't known, because how to describe quantum fluctuations of spacetime geometries isn't known.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
Esta pregunta busca fomentar la reflexión crítica sobre el impacto del uso de tecnologías interactivas en la educación inicial. Se enfoca en herramientas como tabletas, pizarras digitales y apps educativas, que cada vez son más comunes en entornos escolares.
El objetivo es que docentes, formadores o interesados analicen tanto los beneficios (como el aumento de la motivación, la personalización del aprendizaje o el desarrollo de habilidades digitales desde edades tempranas), como los retos (como la posible distracción, la sobreexposición a pantallas, la falta de capacitación docente o el acceso desigual a la tecnología).
Es una pregunta abierta que permite conectar la experiencia práctica con el análisis pedagógico, y puede utilizarse en debates, talleres o investigaciones sobre innovación en educación preescolar.
Relevant answer
Answer
Imaginar un aula de educación inicial equipada con tabletas y aplicaciones educativas es visualizar un espacio donde el aprendizaje se transforma en una experiencia interactiva y multisensorial. Los niños de 3 a 6 años, curiosos por naturaleza, pueden explorar cuentos animados, juegos que fortalecen su pensamiento lógico, actividades que estimulan el lenguaje y apps que enseñan a través del arte y la música. Las tabletas permiten adaptar el contenido al ritmo de cada niño, lo que es clave en esta etapa del desarrollo, y abren la puerta a una educación más inclusiva, donde incluso niños con dificultades pueden acceder a recursos diseñados especialmente para sus necesidades.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
11 answers
Please help me, how to download those publications are free-to download?
A month ago I could do it, but not not. I can not imagine, what had been changed since that time.
What kind of technical problem is it? How can I solve it?
Thank you in advance,
Mária Tóth
Relevant answer
Answer
The same issue.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
12 answers
Imagination is the realm of the possible, where logical conventionalities are challenged by ideological creativity, and the chains of reason are transformed into revolutionary innovations, changing the world for the better. Albert Einstein highlighted the intrinsic power of imagination, saying, "Imagination is more important than knowledge." However, while imagination may seem as infinite as the universe, it also has its limits.
In your perspective, what are the limits of imagination?
Relevant answer
Answer
Imagination, though boundless in spirit, is not entirely without limits. In my perspective, its boundaries arise from several interrelated factors:
  1. Cognitive constraints: Our imagination is shaped—and sometimes confined—by what we already know or have experienced. It’s difficult to imagine concepts that lie completely outside our neurological and perceptual framework. For example, envisioning a new color that’s outside the visible spectrum is nearly impossible.
  2. Cultural and linguistic filters: The metaphors, symbols, and narratives we inherit from our culture influence what we can conceive. Imagination is often guided by language, which both enables and restricts the way we form ideas.
  3. Psychological barriers: Fear, trauma, and conditioning can limit imagination. A person may struggle to envision better futures if they’ve never experienced stability or success. Conversely, unexamined biases can create blind spots in even the most creative minds.
  4. Moral and ethical constraints: Imagination is not always used for good—think of manipulation, propaganda, or destructive technologies. Therefore, responsible imagination requires ethical grounding to be transformative rather than harmful.
  5. Temporal limitations: While imagination can leap across time, it remains anchored to the present—our ideas about the future are still filtered through today’s realities.
That said, imagination’s true strength lies not in its infinite range, but in its ability to transcend the ordinary within the constraints of the real. Its limits are not fixed walls, but evolving frontiers that we continually push through curiosity, empathy, and collaboration.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
8 answers
Try 6÷2(1+2). A pre-1992 caculation will give 1. After 1992 gives 9.
What changed in 1992? IMO computers are teaching us math. Math has to be experimentally valid. Old PEMDAS is not valid.
Complex numbers do not exist.
Computers use only {0,1} and can calculate reactive current.
Irrational numbers would have infinite information. Not physically.
Math is also quantum. The sets R=C=Q.
Enough imagination without reality.
What's your qualified opinion?
Relevant answer
Answer
EPGC, thank you. Take a look at Discrete Mthematics, manuscript in my profile at ResearchGate.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
3 answers
# 206
Dear Bartłomiej Kizielewicz · Jarosław Wątróbsk · Wojciech Sałabun
I read your paper
Multi-criteria decision support system for the evaluation of UAV intelligent agricultural sensors
My comments:
1- Abstract: You say “The results confirm the framework’s effectiveness demonstrating its robustness and stability in decision-making. Sensitivity analysis and comparative studies further highlight its reliability, particularly in addressing rank reversal issues commonly found in existing MCDA methods such as TOPSIS and AHP.”
I am afraid that you are mistaken, for SA is not able to prove effectiveness of a framework or highlight a method or procedure. It is designed to find if the solution found, that is the selected best alternative, is strong and stable
SA is not related to RR, which, by the way, as per my research, may happen in all MCDM methods, because it does not depend of a method, but on the different topologies that are generated when spatial dimensions or alternatives are added or deleted.
2- Very good and precise information in the abstract clarifying a subject that is unknown, for many of us, or at least for me.
3- In page 7 you mention MEREC for criteria evaluation. It is indeed independent of subjectivity, but in my opinion, it is a biased method, because in each run it is solving different problems since its eliminates progressively a criterion, that is, if there are, say 9 criteria, in each run it considers only 8, and each one on a different matrix
In the next step you compare rankings using different MCDM methods, and what is the gain in doing that?
None for me, since a high correlation between the rankings of two methods, only denotes that both move in the same direction, but it does not mean that they are close to reality
Selecting weights to evaluate alternatives, is incorrect, because what really has the capacity to evaluate alternatives is the discrimination of values within a criterion, not values between criteria, or in other words, what is relevant is the content not the envelope
4- Page 11-” The criterion weights determine their relevance, which is crucial in evaluating alternatives”.
This assertion is not supported by any mathematical theorem, axiom or common sense it is simply intuitive.
My justification of my assertion is as follows:
Iin MCDM the DM is working with lineal equations represented by straight lines in a plane that in different manners, according to the method, define a space of solutions, where one of them is preferred, as in TOPSIS, where the best solution is that closest to the ideal point.
When throe DM multiplies the original values in the initial matrix by a weight, these values increase or decrease proportionally, that is, there is no relative change within each criterion, since the line displaces parallel to itself. However, what changes is the position in the plane of a criterion related to others, due to the various weights, and thus, displacing differently, and varying the original distances between them. This may produce a topological change in the common space of solutions, and now the alternative closest to the ideal point in TOPSIS, may have changed, which produces a different ranking. It can be seen that weights only modify the original distancers between criteria. This is geometry, not evaluation. You may or not agree with my explanation, but it is rational and mathematical, not intuitive. This can produce that the enplane of this criterion related to the other that also change.
Regarding the formation of solution spaces, I am reproducing what AI says about it:
“In Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) methods, solution spaces are defined based on the criteria and preferences involved in the decision-making process. Here are some common approaches:
1. Weighted Sum Model (WSM): The solution space is defined by assigning weights to each criterion and calculating the weighted sum for each alternative. The alternative with the highest score is chosen.
2. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): The solution space is structured hierarchically, where criteria and sub-criteria are compared pairwise to determine their relative importance.
NM- That is, the alternative with the highest score is chosen
3. TOPSIS (Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution): The solution space is defined by identifying the ideal and anti-ideal solutions. Alternatives are ranked based on their distance from these solutions.
4. PROMETHEE (Preference Ranking Organization Method for Enrichment Evaluation): The solution space is defined by preference functions that compare alternatives based on criteria.
NM- The best alt. is selected according to compliance of preference functions
5. CoCoSo (Combined Compromise Solution): This method uses a compromise solution space where alternatives are ranked based on aggregated measures”
NM – That is, it uses a aggregating multiplication rule
NM – Linear Programming (LP)
The best alternative is which best satisfy all criteria, and it is defined by the vertex of a polygon than tangents the main objective line
As you can see, all methods generate solution spaces, and from there the best solution is extracted by different means, not always following linearity, except LP, which is altered by different procedures. This could explain why a same problem, solved by different methods, give different rankings.
5- Page 11 “For the STD, Entropy, and CRITIC approaches, one can see a large difference between the most significant and less significant weights. In contrast, for the MEREC”
This is obvious, because STD, Entropy and CRITIC, refer to the solution of the same problem, when MEREC solves different problems by eliminating criteria, consequently, there are different matrices each time
Table 3 in page 12, shows that Entropy, and CRITIC, both scientific methods show high similarity, because both work with discrimination. In my opinion. CRITIC is more complete because it determines the STD or discrimination and besides, the correlation between criteria, that is, takes into consideration redundant information in two criteria
6- “The similarity coefficient of the WS rankings was used to test the similarity of the obtained rankings”
And what this information is good for?
7- Page 17 “The phenomenon of rank reversal occurs when the relative ordering of alternatives changes unexpectedly after the addition or removal of an alternative, raising concerns about the stability and reliability of the decision-making process”
Youa are right about unexpected changes, and it is due to the random nature of RR; that is, it may or may not occur, and this is unpredictable, because it depends of the characterises of the
vector added and its intersections with the vectors of the precedent matrix
“To address this limitation, we propose a novel approach-COCOCOMET-which is resistant to rank reversal.”
I doubt about this. You can prove perhaps what you say, by try to successively increase the number of alternatives, and probably, you will find that say for instance 2, 3 and 4 alternatives are indeed ranking invariance, but may change if you add alternative 4. Why? Because each time you add an alternative to a matrix, you increase the amount of information, therefore, a newer alternative does not consider the old ones because their information is already included in the result for the alternative added
As an example, think on a square, you get information about two dimensions (2D); add a new dimension, and you will get a cube or 3D, that already has the information that gave you the square. RR is produced due to different topologies that appear with a new addition, and consequently, no MCDM method can escape of this. I did this exercise expanding from 2D to 10D, and it happens as commented.
8- Page 17. “Generating a ranking of alternatives”
Since when criteria define alternatives? How can you select criteria if you don’t know to what alternatives are going to evaluate? Of course, this approach is equivalent of ‘putting the cart before the horse’
9- Page 20 “Future research should focus on exploring optimization strategies or heuristic approaches to ensure the framework remains efficient for large-scale decision-making problems”
This is interesting. How do you evaluate efficiency? For me, efficiency can be computed by determining in what percentage a criterion is achieved. Remember that a criterion is an objective, therefore, you need to establish a target, a goal to achieve. This can be easily and mathematically done using Linear Programming, that works with targets, but I do not imagine how you can do that with the more than 200 MCDM existing methods. None of these methods, except PROMETHEE, LP and SIMUS consider resources. Remember that criteria forcefully rely on resources, such as money, manpower, water, contamination allowances, etc., and that the purpose of MCDM is to select an alternative subject to a set of criteria that optimizes the use resources. Consequently, MCDM also can be defined as electing alternatives as those that make the best use of available resources.
10- Page 20 “The findings indicate that the proposed framework effectively identifies optimal UAV sensors, providing a structured and adaptable approach for agricultural applications”
How do you know that they are optimal? Let me remind you that in MCDM optimality is a myth, since you cannot ask at the same time for the maximum benefit and the minimum cost. You must be looking for a compromise solution, a balance.
11- Page 21 “Furthermore, the study highlights the importance of incorporating multiple evaluation techniques to achieve more reliable and consistent results. Sensitivity analysis and comparative evaluations demonstrate that the proposed model maintains its effectiveness across various weighting scenarios, reinforcing its practical applicability”
You can say that if you wish, but on what grounds? Who says that multiple evaluation achieves more reliable results? Where is the demonstration of this? In my opinion they are only assumptions without any mathematical support
Again, what is effectiveness? You never defined it
These are my comments. Hope they can be useful
Nolberto Munier
Relevant answer
Answer
Excuse me, I was responding not to the subject of the present discussion, but to a previous one we had a couple of years ago.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
With this question, I seek to explore how play and imagination contribute to children's emotional well-being and mental development. I'm interested in analyzing their impact on creativity, emotional management, problem-solving, and social skills. I also want to identify how these activities can serve as tools to strengthen children's mental health and prevent problems such as stress and anxiety.
Relevant answer
Answer
Games and imagination are extremely important for children's mental health and emotional development. They help children express their emotions, acquire social skills, and solve problems. Imaginative play promotes creativity and resilience, whereas games encourage cooperation, empathy, and stress reduction, all of which contribute to overall emotional well-being.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
# 204
Dear Milan Shrestha, Shuva Raj Neupane and Binaya Kumar Mishra
I have read your paper:
Use of Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) in Highway Alignment Planning in Nepal: An Expert Questionnaire Survey
My comments:
1. Page 1 -Very good and concise definition of road alignment and road planning
2. Page 2 you say: “AHP uses three basic principles: breaking down the structure (facilitates building hierarchies), comparison of alternatives, and hierarchical composition or synthesis”
In my opinion, as well as from many other researchers, the two underlined sentences, are far from being an advantage; in fact, they are drawbacks. They are good for analysis but not for solving a MCDM problem. First, because this is a system, and as that you cannot break it down. Secondly, AHP uses a lineal hierarchy that does not apply to real-life projects that are networks. Aspects as financial for instance, probably affects all criteria at the same time. If you change the amount of investment it will affect to the environment, the economics, engineering, even to health
3. Page 3 factors V, VI, VII and VIII are interrelated, consequently, you cannot use AHP that demands independent criteria. This is one of the restrictions in AHP as per its own creator, Saaty. If you think that I am mistaken, pls. review the method. You can solve this problem using ANP (Saaty), based on a network, but not in AHP
4. Page 5- Section 2.2.
• “Decomposition of a complex problem into a hierarchy of simpler ones
• Prioritization of each hierarchy worked out through paired comparison matrix worked out individually
• Synthesis of the hierarchies to the overall evaluation of all available alternatives
• Sensitivity Analysis of the stability of the results obtained
Decomposition: As said, you cannot decompose a system
Prisonization: If you follow AHP, it is based on intuitions, not on facts, event using several experts. What guaranty is it? Next guy may think differently. Who is right?
Synthesis: AHP assumes that the estimates must be transitive. If they are not, the software forces it. It does not matter what the DM thought. That is, It makes mandatory to comply with a formula, and thus, machine over human opinion. Is that what we want?
Sensitivity analysis: AHP uses a non-recommended procedure, by selecting, guided for the largest criterion value, procedure that does not have any mathematical support, and in addition, assuming that all remaining criteria remain constant.
5. “. The calculation process is a monumental task if multiple criteria are involved”
Exactly. Now imagine if you have to make different tests changing values in each one.
6. Page 6 “The method is a subjective method of decision-making and is not always free from the biases of the experts involved. Inconsistent responses often raise the question of authenticity over the entire process”:
Absolutely correct
7. Page 7 “However, AHP, if worked out and utilized carefully, remains one of the best analytical decision-making processes”
Interesting, since you do not follow your own assertion. By the way, how can you say that it is one of the best methods? It is the most used bur certainly, not the best
8. Page 7 “Academics and Professionals. A total of 30 questionnaires were sent out to the experts working closely in highway planning and construction but only 18 responses were recorded. The inconsistent responses were left out of the evaluation process. The expert’s response was based on Saaty’s scale and AHP was adopted to generate the weightage for the criteria”
There is no reason to doubt about experts very knowledgeable in roads planning, but most possibly not on MCDM. Let alone condensing their opinions; you can compare the opinion of two experts that are specialized in some subject, but how an expert in say engineering can discuss with an expert in environment since both do not know the other guy field?
9. Page 11 “. AHP was successfully applied to evaluate and determine the weightage of each criterion in the engineering, economic, and environmental theme”
How do you know that it was successful if you do not have any reference to compare to?
There is no MCDM method that can be said is successful, precisely, because that yardstick does not exist.
These are my comments. I hope they can help
Nolberto Munier
Relevant answer
Answer
Use of Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) in Highway Alignment Planning in Nepal: An Expert Questionnaire Survey
Discussion
• Started 3 days ago
# 204
Dear Milan Shrestha, Shuva Raj Neupane and Binaya Kumar Mishra
I have read your paper:
… Read more
Reply to this discussion
Farid Leguebedj added a reply
8 hours ago
Dear Farid
Thank you for your detailed observation. My response to them is in lines initialized as NM
The Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) is a widely used decision-making tool, particularly in complex decision-making scenarios involving multiple criteria and alternatives. In the context of highway alignment planning in Nepal, AHP can be particularly beneficial due to the country's varied topography, limited resources, and the need for an integrated approach to infrastructure planning. Here's how AHP can be applied to highway alignment planning in Nepal
NM - I agree that AHP is heavily used in decision making, but not in complex scenarios. Its heavy use does not necessarily mean that a scenario is complex. Complexity is seen in many other issues like alternatives precedence, inclusion and exclusion, targets for criteria, problems involving changes along time, multiples relationships among criteria, etc. None of them can be not even modelled in AHP, let alone solve the problem. Of course, that you need to consult road experts, but most probably they are not aware of the AHP mathematical principles, let alone its structure. You request their opinions and suggestions on fields that they dominate, but probably are not proficient in MCDM, which is the do main of academics and researchers.
1. Objective of the Study
The primary aim of using AHP in highway alignment planning is to identify the most suitable alignment for a proposed highway route that takes into account various competing criteria like cost, environmental impact, safety, land acquisition, and social benefits. The study would involve the use of an expert questionnaire survey to collect opinions from engineers, planners, and other stakeholders who are knowledgeable about Nepal's geographical and infrastructural realities.
NM – Agreed
2. Key Components of the AHP Approach
AHP works by breaking down a complex decision problem into a multi-level structure:
NM- Breaking down is very useful for analyzing a MCDM problem but not for solving it. AHP constitutes a system, and as that, you cannot break it down. Evern Saaty said that it is a system. It is like in a car optimizing the engine, the body, the transmission, the aerodynamicsr and then adding them up. You can’t, because the engine, for instance, is tightly related to the other subsystems. For example, a criterion can state that the speed must be 120 km/hr, and this, of course depends of the engine, the aerodynamics, the air conditioning subsystem consumption, the transmission, the tires, etc.
• Goal: The ultimate goal is to select the best highway alignment from several alternatives.
NM – You forgot to put “ Subject to a set of criteria”
• Criteria: Different criteria (e.g., cost, environmental concerns, ease of construction, safety, etc.) are identified, which impact the final decision.
• Sub-criteria: These are more detailed factors within each criterion. For example, under "cost," you might include land acquisition cost, construction cost, and maintenance cost.
• Alternatives: Different possible highway alignments (routes) are proposed.
NM- Agreed
3. Steps Involved in AHP for Highway Alignment Planning in Nepal
a) Identification of Criteria and Sub-Criteria
• Cost: Construction and maintenance costs, land acquisition, etc.
• Environmental Impact: Ecological damage, air and noise pollution, biodiversity concerns.
• Safety: Traffic safety, accident rates, risk of landslides or floods.
• Social Impact: Displacement of communities, access to social services, local employment opportunities.
• Geotechnical Considerations: Terrain, soil stability, geological hazards.
• Political or Legal Issues: Land ownership, local politics, permits, and regulations.
b) Survey Design
• An expert questionnaire is designed to collect subjective judgments from stakeholders (experts, engineers, planners, environmentalists) about the relative importance of each criterion and the relative performance of different alignments with respect to these criteria.
NM – It is absolutely correct to ask the opinion and advice of experts, no doubt about it, but in general they do not select the best route, since that is the job of the DM and the MCDM method he uses. The road experts are off of this.
• The questionnaire would use pairwise comparisons (e.g., "Which criterion is more important, cost or environmental impact?") to rate the relative importance of each factor.
NM- In my opinion using pair-wise comparisons is valid, but it is not valid and without mathematical or rational point of view, that the expert or the DM can establish a preference. In the example you put there is a financial guy, and the environmentalist. Therefore, how can they agree on a preference, if none of them is expert in the other guy field?
c) Pairwise Comparisons
• Using a scale of 1 to 9, experts compare the relative importance of each pair of criteria and sub-criteria. A rating of "1" means that both criteria are equally important, while a rating of "9" means one criterion is extremely more important than the other.
NM-The Fundamental Scale is a fabricated assumption, since it pretends to replicate the Weber-Fechner Law in psychology when establishing the relationship between stimuli and responses, a log. On
In AHP you do not have incentives or stimuli but simply a numerical preference. Extract your own occlusions
d) Consistency Check
• AHP also includes a consistency check to ensure that the pairwise comparisons made by experts are consistent. This is done using a consistency ratio (CR), where values less than 0.1 typically indicate consistency in judgments.
NM – Correct, and it is based on a simulation exercise, nothing wrong about it. What is very wrong is to decree that the whole estimates matrix MUST be transitivity, and if it not, forcing the DM to correct his estimates. What do you think about this? Where is mathematics or common sense here?
e) Weight Calculation
• Once pairwise comparisons are made, AHP uses a mathematical procedure (typically an eigenvector method) to calculate the weight or relative importance of each criterion. This weight reflects how much each criterion should influence the final decision.
NM- Sorry. this is not exact. The weights are only a measure of criteria relative importance, and even when intuitively it is believed that they can evaluate alternatives, it is not so. What may evaluate the alternatives are the dispersion of values within each criterion, not the criterion as a whole. Please, look at Shannon’s Theorem
f) Scoring of Alternatives
• Each highway alignment is evaluated with respect to the identified criteria and sub-criteria. Experts score each alignment, and the scores are normalized for comparison.
NM- Agreed although the DM determines using a MCDM method the scores, not the experts
g) Final Decision
• AHP aggregates the weighted scores for each alignment option to produce an overall score. The alignment with the highest score is considered the most optimal based on the criteria and expert opinions
NM- This is possible one of the many AHP drawbacks. Because, as said, the matrix is a system you cannot simply add, you must work with intersections. Remember that not always a result is equal to the sum of the parts, remember the car example, and this is real, not an assumption. See System Theory, and the car example.
4. Potential Benefits of Using AHP in Highway Alignment Planning in Nepal
• Holistic Decision-Making: AHP considers both tangible and intangible factors, making it a comprehensive tool for highway planning in a developing country like Nepal, where the decision involves environmental, social, and technical considerations.
NM- Like any other method, what is new?
• Expert Input: The involvement of experts ensures that the decision-making process reflects practical experience and local knowledge.
NM- Yes, independently, and that is not very useful, since it is very human to support what one believes. Explain it is another issue, something that AHP is consisting in not justifying, and is not surprising that nobody cares or respond. The reason, always in my opinion and those from others along 10 years in RG, is that there are no answers because, nobody, in this area at least, can explain something that is unexplainable. For instance, AHP asserting that the transitive matrix, reflecting the moods and intention of a person, or even a group of persons, is applicable to the real-world. Nice assumption, but irreal and that goes again common sense. It comes out of the dark without explanation. It is inevitable not to get suspicious.
• Transparency: The structured approach of AHP provides transparency and justifies decisions, making it easier to explain the rationale behind selecting a specific alignment.
NM- Could you mention at least one or the user has to believe it by decree? The rational is to use a MCDM method, since there is no rationality in AHP.
• Conflict Resolution: AHP helps address potential conflicts among stakeholders by clearly outlining the importance of various criteria and how they influence the final choice.
NM- Have you ever been a in meeting with stakeholders trying to demonstrate them ou put their money based on your intuition? I wouldn’t recommend it
5. Challenges in Nepal
• Complex Terrain: Nepal's mountainous and difficult terrain can make some criteria, like construction cost and environmental impact, harder to assess.
NM-I agree with you. I have been in Nepal andtravelled some of its routes like Kathmandu / Pokhara (beautiful place by the way)
• Limited Data: Accurate data may be scarce, especially for factors like long-term environmental effects or social impacts.
NM- Well, you can use extreme values and work in an interval, but you cannot do that in AHP, even using fuzzy
• Stakeholder Disagreement: There may be disagreements among local stakeholders, which could affect the reliability of the expert judgments.
NM- Of course there are often disagreements among stakeholders and also experts, specially related to funds and personnel. But each stakeholder tries to support his own activity and this must be respected without discussions because they know what is needed in his area. This is not in AHP procedure which allows a DM taking decisions on aspects that may affect thousands of people. This has a name, and it is ‘dictatorship’ as defined by Arrow’s Incompatibility theorem. You cannot vote for others, and years ago I had the privilege to discuss this issue with Dr. Saaty. As a bottom line, it is desirable that each stakeholder expresses as wished, and it is the MCDM method to find a compromise solution or balance between them, something that AHP is not designed for.
• Resource Constraints: Implementing the AHP method requires resources, both in terms of time and funding, which might not always be readily available in the context of Nepal's infrastructure planning.
NM- I never have seen that AHP uses resources, because for that it should be using limits to their availability. Resources are normally existent in any project; what does not mean that they can be used in the amount required by each project. In that case, it could be useful to shorten expectations.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
The structure of the human mind is multidimensional and complex. Cognition, as an expression of thought processes, memory, imagination, analytical skills, and psychological understandings, plays a crucial role in one's daily life. The level of its development is conditioned by one's educational, professional, and socio-cultural background, which is distributed on an individual basis. In your perspective, what are the components of the human cognition?
Relevant answer
Answer
Robert W. Boyer, thank you for your insights and attention. The spheres of mind have indeed been widely analyzed by science and will continue to foster psycho-cognitive explorations as long as human consciousness undergoes its transformative evolution through epistemic discoveries.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
Independence is a highly valued necessity in life. It is demonstrated in many spheres, and various contexts. In the context of human cognition, independence is demonstrated through thinking, imagination, as well as creative and scientific efforts. In your opinion, what is independent thinking?
Relevant answer
Answer
My personal opinions: independent think is an ability that you can think straight without having many distractions in your head and in your surroundings. For example, people keep saying that we should DO THE RIGHT THING, but does that mean we should follow and obey everything they say? That is the magic of moral philosophy, relating to Kantism. (Sorry if I cannot provide more examples because I forgot many!). Also, I came across an interesting situation when people are so scared of helping other strangers who are in need, does that mean we should help those people or not?
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
5 answers
In fact, why didn't Einstein imagine a right triangle where it would be possible to put velocities on its sides instead of distances? In fact, if he had drawn this new right triangle, what would he put on each of the sides of the triangle? Is there a new speed, apart from v and c, that he absolutely did not imagine and that would open the way to enormous possibilities for his theory of special relativity?
Please, those who try to keep things as they are and who do not want post-Einstein theories, ABSTENTION.
Relevant answer
Answer
Jose Oreste Mazzini,
A right triangle on which we place speeds leads in my opinion to a new formula for the Lorentz factor better adapted to physics. My preprint on RG relating to the present question is entitled: "Time dilation as an intrinsic property of light explaining the constancy of the speed of light regardless of the frame of reference from which it is measured".
My present question does not aim to apply the rule of the right triangle to express c' as a function of v and c, according to my scheme, but it is about finding a new "parameter" of physics forgotten by Einstein in his theory of special relativity. In other words, in my opinion, Einstein only revealed fifty percent of reality. Special relativity is not complete. The post-Einstein theory must therefore indeed exist, that is the subject of my question.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
En fait, pourquoi Einstein n'a-t-il pas imaginé un triangle rectangle où il serait possible de mettre des vitesses sur ses côtés au lieu de distances ? En fait, s'il avait dessiné ce nouveau triangle rectangle, que mettrait-il sur chacun des côtés du triangle ? Existe-t-il une nouvelle vitesse, à part, v, et ,c, qu'il n'a absolument pas imaginée et qui ouvrirait la voie à d'énormes possibilités pour sa théorie de la relativité restreinte ?
Please, those who are trying to keep things as they are and don't want post-Einstein theories, ABSTAIN.
Relevant answer
Answer
Jan Slowak,
This question is closely related to one of my preprints on RG, entitled: "Time dilation as an intrinsic property of light explaining the constancy of the speed of light regardless of the frame of reference from which it is measured". It's about, c', on the triangle. Besides the value of c', of the right triangle rule, can anyone give a formula whose purely physical justification goes beyond Einstein's special relativity?
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Is the Earth’s Magnetic Field a Constant?
The birth of geomagnetism as a science can be dated to 8 August 1269 on that day, Petrus Peregrinus wrote three letters .Courtillot and Le Mouël during the siege of the city of Lucera in the Italian region of Puglie. The letters can be considered the first scientific article on geomagnetism, 331 years before the famous De Magnete by Gilbert . Expressed in modern terms, Peregrinus wrote that Earth has a magnetic field with a dipolar structure and that some rocks or minerals are magnetized. One could carve a sphere out of magnetite, pierce a hole through its center, and it would oscillate around the northward direction, a thought experiment that announced the compass. In the three centuries that unfurled since then, a lot has been discovered: the variation of inclination with latitude, the daily, annual and other periodic variations ، irregular variations, such as events linked to solar activity, the secular variation and its sudden jerks . In order to handle an ever increasing data base, magnetic indices were introduced It was found that quasi periodical variations of the magnetic field , and also sun spots followed a power law with exponent −5/3. In a series of papers that started with Le Mouël in 1984 and continued with Jault et al. , and Jault and Le Mouël , these authors found that the trends of (1) magnetic secular variation, (2) polar motion and (3) length of day (lod) are strongly correlated. They proposed to explain these observations with a coupling mechanism, in which flow in a cylinder tangent to the core and the rotation axis exchange torques at the core–mantle boundary. The solution for flow on the cylinder is the same as that generated by an internal gravitational wave in a rotating fluid also known as Proudman flow. But this mechanism encounters serious difficulties with the orders of magnitude of physical parameters, such as the core–mantle boundary (CMB) topography. Also, the torque exerted by the fluid pressure and the electromagnetic torque are too weak to validate the model as concluded by Jault and Le Mouël .Actually, the model of a cylinder tangent to the core is very close in spirit to that envisioned by Poisson . In the report he submitted to the Académie des Sciences, prior to an oral communication, Poisson imagined a set of concentric spheres in place of a cylinder. Poisson was the first scientist to describe the magnetic field as a series of spherical harmonics, a decade before Gauss did Part 5, chapter 1, Allgemeine Theorie des Erdmagnetismus). He also invented a technique to measure the absolute value of the horizontal component of the magnetic field , seven years before Gauss did.
It may come as a surprise to many that Poisson as well as Gauss both considered the magnetic field to be constant. This was an axiomatic basis for the development into spherical harmonics. There are very clear statements to this effect in the writings of both scientists. In the work of Poisson , page 49, one reads (our translation from the French): “We will assume that the hollow sphere be magnetized under the influence of a force that be the same in magnitude and direction for all its points, such as the magnetic action of Earth, for instance”. And in page 54: “Since time does not enter these formulae, a consequence is that, after the first instants of rotation, that we did not mention, the action of the rotating sphere on a given point will be constant in magnitude and in direction”. Gauss , part 5, chapter 1, paragraph 2, page 6, writes (our translation from the German): “. . . magnetism consists only in galvanic currents (that is, constant currents) that persist in the smallest parts of the bodies . . .”. Gauss develops his theory very quickly without any physical proof. And his mathematical proof is exactly that found by Legendre or Laplace for the gravitational field. In contrast, the 130 pages of Poisson’s memoir are devoted both to the full physical and mathematical proofs of the magnetic field description.
Given that Poisson’s work precedes and is more complete than that of Gauss , it is only fair to recognize that the former was the first to develop the magnetic field in spherical harmonics and to state that this magnetic field was constant..
In his pioneering work on the nature and origin of the Earth’s magnetic field, Poisson recognized that the field had to be constant. Gauss came to the same conclusion. This will seem awkward to the modern physicist. Poisson’s proof involved theoretical physics and mathematics but only a limited set of observations.
More recently, one of us Le Mouël observed that there were strong observational connections between the Earth’s magnetic field and its rotation, more precisely, the secular variation of the field and the drift of the rotation pole on one hand, and the forced oscillations of the magnetic field and the length of day on the other. Based on these observational facts, Le Mouël proposed to model the core source as a rotating cylinder when Poisson envisioned a sphere. Thus, based on observations, Le Mouël (1984) (with collaborators, in a suite of often cited papers) built quasi “experimentally”, 150 years later, almost the same theory as Poisson had done “theoretically”.
Starting from Maxwell’s equations, we derived the equations for the electrostatic and magnetostatic fields . We came to the same equations as Poisson, with an important difference: Poisson chose the Lagrangian approach to gravity (Legendre, 1785; Lagrange 1788; Laplace, 1799) to formally derive the equations for the magnetic field . To scientists of this epoch, there was no difficulty in reasoning the magnetism in the same “classical” way as one reasons in gravity. In Section 2, we propose a short tutorial on the equations of electromagnetism. This can be found in most graduate textbooks. But we emphasize the fact that the magnetic field does not need to derive from a scalar potential to be developed into spherical harmonics. However, most geomagnetists do make this hypothesis, invoking Stokes’s theorem: since magnetic measurements are made at the surface where almost no charge circulates, one can assume that the field derives from a scalar, not a vector potential. It is more physical, hence logical, to obtain the spherical harmonics from the electrostatic field, then use the vector potential to return to their expression for the magnetic field. One can perform a decomposition in spherical harmonics and consider multi-poles if and only if the motions of charges are finite and uniform, two conditions that are not met in a dynamic field. From this, one can draw a number of consequences for the magnetic field, the main one being that the magnetic moment of the charges that generate the field and their angular moment (thus, the motion of the rotation pole) are linked by Larmor’s relation. This is in agreement with the theoretical works of Laplace Poisson and . A magnetic field can be written on the basis of spherical harmonics only if this field is constant.
Relevant answer
Answer
No. The Earth's magnetic field is not constant, it varies overtime and location, meaning its strength and direction change depending on where and when we measured on the planet.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
Imagination is a powerful tool for solving problems, finding innovative approaches to traditional beliefs, and challenging the impossible. From your perspective, how can one's scientific imagination be developed?
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with Karl Pfeifer what he wrote. It is worth adding that continuous conscious observation of the environment develops this ability. and it is also important to find the right explanation. We should never trust anyone (not even ourselves) without first verifying it. We are often faced with an unknown phenomenon. We ask the question why it is the way it is, why it happens. We get the answer. But it needs to be checked. If we find out that it is wrong, we look for the cause of the error. We must somehow coexist with our environment, not just physically, but also spiritually. In this symbiosis, we develop the best way the ability to healthy imagination.
Regards,
Laszlo
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
“It is imagination that allows us to predict future events and use that to guide our actions.” (Tai Sing Lee 2016).
In the early part of the last century Wilder Penfield reported that as he was removing neocortical tissue from his awake epileptic patients that they experienced no change in their consciousness, even when large sections of association cortex were removed (reviewed in Tehovnik, Hasanbegović, and Chen 2025). This observation was surely apparent to Karl Lashley (1929, the stepfather of Peter H. Schiller) who overlapped with Penfield and who advanced the equipotentiality hypothesis that the neocortex lacks functional specificity and that it imagines and controls behavior holistically.
So, what is the lowest number of neurons required for an organism to experience imagination? Of late much effort has gone into studying the mushroom body of the fruit fly, a homologue of the mammalian neocortex, which contains 2,000 neurons with each neuron having, on average, 350 synapses for learning explicit associations between the senses (Dorkenwald et al. 2024; Lin 2023; Schlegel et al. 2024). This yields an overall storage capacity of 700,000 bits of information by the mushroom body (Tehovnik, Hasanbegović, and Chen 2025). The human neocortex, on the other hand, contains 16 billion neurons (Herculano-Houzel 2009) to make explicit associations between the senses, but the human neocortex can store up to 1.6 x 10^14 bits of information, which is necessary for a 600-fold increase in relative longevity and body size, as compared to the fruit fly (fruit flies live for 1.5 months and have a 4 x 10^-7% of mass of humans, Tehovnik, Hasanbegović, and Chen 2025).
But rather than concentrate on the number of neurons to support imagination as the previous passage entertains for the fruit fly, let us consider how an organism expresses imagination. An amoeba is required to imagine the location of food as well as the location of predators (Saigusa et al. 2008). Even though an amoeba is a single cell, it should contain all the genetic machinery to imagine and guide its actions (Kandel 2006), which is the sole requirement for imagination (Tai Sing Lee 2016).
Relevant answer
Answer
Consciousness depends entirely on neurons.  When Penfield scooped out sections of association cortex the remaining neocortical neurons fill in the missing pieces much like the blind spot is filled in by the association cortex. And to get a patient to notice the missing pieces, neuropsychological tests need to be conducted to bring the missing pieces to the awareness of a patient. When the fibers between the neocortex and cerebellum are transected at the level of the pons and thalamus all consciousness is lost. The neocortex controls conscious processes and the cerebellum stores well-learned psycho-motor routines.  The cerebellum houses Freud’s id and it contains the details of how Einstein came up with ‘E = mc^2’. Of course these details are in motor coordinates. The conscious coordinates can be found in Einstein’s notebooks, fragments of which were stored in his neocortex as declarative memory.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
The question of the determinants of action remains a crucial point in understanding the genesis of adaptive and maladaptive behaviors (e.g., Buabang et al., 2024, in TICS).
A strict dichotomous approach to this issue suggests that with behavioral repetition in a stable context—due to lack of time, cognitive overload, or stress—so-called habitual behaviors take control of action, often to the detriment of valuation and response-selection processes that could otherwise give rise to more adaptive behaviors, such as moderating excessive alcohol consumption or curbing pathological gambling.
An alternative approach garners increasing interest: it posits that expectancy systems, which anticipate the effects of action, are predominant. Indeed, certain associations linking stimuli to behaviors facilitate the implementation or efficacy of goal-directed systems, which represent the default mode of our actions.
It is neither easy (nor perhaps possible) to prove this theory in a laboratory setting, but certain life experiences speak volumes. I will not delve into driving behavior, which, however, can be understood as being "in the service" of a goal to be achieved (e.g., arriving on time for a romantic date). Nor will I address those small, everyday habits that seem, on the surface, to indicate that certain routines are generated by default, supposedly to save cognitive resources better used for more noble tasks. Such instances, in my view, are anecdotal when weighed against the magnitude of the harm associated with what is deemed "bad" habits (e.g., addiction).
I would like to draw the reader's attention to certain processes that unequivocally characterize gamers of demanding video games. This is a recreational activity I am fond of, which can involve thousands of repetitive actions to automate highly complex action patterns. At the time of writing, I am preparing for the final boss in 'Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice'. I recently completed 'Elden Ring' and its New Game Plus, as well as the DLC 'Shadow of the Erdtree'. I do not consider myself an exceptional gamer, far from it, but through repetition and perseverance, I have succeeded.
In light of reflections on the contribution of automatic and deliberative systems, habits, and goal-directed behaviors—concepts I do not conflate, as goal-directed actions can be automatic—I wish to share some aspects of my gaming experience. The situation seems apparently clear: the general goal is to progress and understand the story, which requires defeating mini-bosses and bosses, as progression is otherwise impossible. More specific objectives also come into play, such as preparing the right equipment for each battle. However—and this is a crucial point—every gamer implores that action patterns become automated! This is essential for efficiently dodging or parrying attacks.
Indeed, gamers are highly motivated for their action patterns to become as automated as possible, requiring no conscious thought during combat phases. And the acquired action patterns can be complex. Indeed, it is not uncommon to realize that the habit of dodging an attack was not the right choice, particularly due to the low probability that the attack would be followed by a second, leaping strike. For gamers, the learned motor memory of action patterns is more probabilistic than it seems, due to the algorithms that determine opponents' behaviors. It explains why gamers often hope for "luck" during a fight, especially when familiar attack patterns are involved. In other words, habits are instrumental in achieving their goals. It is worth noting that modifying a poor combat habit is no easy task. These objectives are multifaceted: progressing through the story, of course, but above all, experiencing a sense of competence and mastery over a demanding sequence by entering a state of flow.
Comparison is not equivalence, but I imagine the described experience is akin to certain addictive behaviors: different goals are activated through mechanisms we are currently studying—namely, what drives individuals into action. As in addictions, a multitude of habits (underpinned by highly efficient and automatic calculation modes) facilitate goal attainment by serving the expected outcomes. While it may be tempting to "break habits" through methods that, let’s admit it, yield modest results, altering the goals to be achieved is no easier but far more promising.
In the anecdotal situation I briefly described—playing 'Sekiro'—it is quite possible that simply passing by my gaming computer triggered a desire to play, fueled by the hope of progressing in the story, feeling competent, and even aspiring to belong to the minority group of gamers who have completed the game (generally 20–30% of gamers). However, I would wager that if my computer were out of order, I would have found alternative ways to pursue these objectives, much like someone willing to make considerable efforts to obtain their drug.
In summary, let us not be mistaken, as it could waste our time: habits serve the goals to be achieved, not the other way around.
Something to ponder.
Xavier
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Xavier,
"habits serve the goals to be achieved, not the other way around."
Pluralitas non est ponenda sine necessitas.
In any case, we should not overdo it.
Merci
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
I came across the Evolutionary Studies in Imaginative Culture journal, and the information I found on Scopus are the following:
  • Years currently covered by Scopus:from 2017 to 2025
  • Publisher:Raiya Academic International LLC
  • ISSN:2472-9884E-ISSN:2472-9876
However, when I check the documents, the last published article was 2022! How so? If the journal is indexed till 2025! Is it predatory? I also can’t find it on Beal’s list if predatory journals!
So is this journal legit? how can I make sure?
Relevant answer
Answer
To verify if a journal is indexed in Scopus:
  1. Check the Scopus Sources List: Visit the official Scopus Source List and search for the journal by title or ISSN.
  2. Search in Scopus: Search for the journal's name directly in the Scopus database. If it's indexed, it should appear in the results.
  3. Publisher's Website: Reputable journals often display their Scopus indexing status on their website.
  4. Contact the Journal: If uncertain, you can contact the journal's editorial team to confirm its Scopus index status.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
From my point of view, our transition practice shows the general failure of transition public management. The collapse of the theory and practice of public management in the transition economy can be recognized in the following:
- When there is a practice of appointing a person who leads to ruin as a leader. Imagine someone leading you into hellfire to burn. Thus, leadership as a term is associated with persons who show by their actions that they are not working for the benefit of the subject they are leading. On the contrary, they only work to engage the subject's resources for personal gain;
- When the focus of the "manager" is on "form", in everything that is done. Such forms do not have any serious content. Why? Because it is easy to declare yourself an expert in the development of various strategies, defining visions, missions, entrepreneurial stories, etc., you have no responsibility and you abundantly empty budgets for such projects and share considerable funds obtained from the budget with persons who manage state budgets;
- When the practice develops that persons who very easily get to the position of manager, with their enthronement, move to mobbing employees, seducing the rule of fear and insubordination. They gather together a group with whom they share resources and power and who follow them in all activities of devaluing everything that has real value and glorifying everything that is a form for which only they are responsible.
Relevant answer
Answer
Challenges in Public Management:
  1. Institutional Weakness: Many transition economies suffer from weak institutional frameworks, which can lead to inefficiency, corruption, and lack of accountability in public administration.
  2. Capacity Gaps: Public servants in these economies often lack the necessary training and expertise to manage the complexities of market-oriented policies and governance.
  3. Policy Inconsistencies: Frequent political changes can disrupt policy continuity, affecting long-term public management strategies.
  4. Corruption and Lack of Transparency: Transition economies often grapple with entrenched corruption, which undermines trust in public institutions.
  5. Resource Constraints: Limited financial resources and over-dependence on external aid can restrict the scope and quality of public services.
Opportunities for Improvement:
  1. Capacity Building: Investing in training and development for public servants to enhance professionalism and efficiency.
  2. Institutional Reform: Strengthening legal frameworks, regulatory bodies, and anti-corruption mechanisms to ensure better governance.
  3. Citizen Engagement: Increasing public participation in decision-making processes to improve transparency and accountability.
  4. Technology Integration: Leveraging e-governance and digital tools to streamline public services and reduce bureaucratic inefficiencies.
  5. Learning from Successful Models: Transition economies can adopt best practices from other countries that have successfully navigated similar challenges. @Paul Stock@Dora
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
3 answers
If we look further and imagine one of the fundamental dimensions that distinguishes humans from other creatures
Relevant answer
Answer
After endless discussions, we have reached the only logical conclusion: the best course of action to maximize ethical justice for all involved is to embrace the Borg transformation. In this way, we simply become one and no longer have to question whether the other is a tool or a partner, for we will share the same consciousness. Resistance is futile!
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
Imagination plays a crucial role in arts, sciences, technological innovations, and creative thinking. I would like to focus on the connection between science and imagination, their interrelatedness, and valuable contributions to academic spheres. In your perspective, what is scientific imagination?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Haris Shekeris, thank you for your response. Yes, socio-cultural influences play an important role in shaping creative and scientific imagination. Just as society benefits from science and its practical implications for the betterment of the world, science, in turn, can be enriched by individual and societal influences. As Albert Einstein said, "Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited, whereas imagination embraces the entire world, stimulating progress, giving birth to evolution."
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
15 answers
The velocity of light c is so enormously and disproportionately high in ordinary human scale in terrestrial Nature, that for all practical scientific, engineering and for everyday life; it can be assumed to be a constant. But Albert Einstein's turning this ordinary fact to an axiomatic/geometrical truth in his Special Theory of Relativity (SR), means that everything else in the universe including matter, abstract space and time or anything else; must be variable to conform to this truth. To keep this absolute truth in force, mathematical/geometric tools like the Lorentz Transforms (LTs), Time Transform (TT), 4D "spacetime" and the Gamma Factor (GF) were formulated in keeping with the absolute c alone; without any other scientific and/or empirical input! “The Mystery of the Lorentz Transform: A Reconstruction and Its Implications for Einstein's Theories of Relativity and cosmology”: INSPIRE>HEP: https://inspirehep.net/literature/2158754
Apparently as a reaction to the quantum phenomena discovered at the turn of the 20th century, and the break-down of much-valued Causality; Einstein did in physics what Emmanuel Kant did in philosophy, i.e., "Found it necessary to deny knowledge to make room for faith" or Absolute God.
Theoretical physics and cosmology till today are in turmoil, since 1905, when Einstein with his SR pushed physics to the realm of mathematical/geometrical abstractions. This seemed to be a comfortable escape from the uncertainty and the despair brought on by the brutal reality of the “Evil Quanta”. But SR and its extension to General Relativity (GR) has only led to more and more confusion, scholastic debates that continues for more than a century and still counting. The only justification for these esoteric theories come from subjective, contrived and even false claims of “experimental proofs”. But in spite of numerous “solid proofs”; the scholastic debates continue unabated. Einstein himself recognized the enormous confusion his theories of relativity caused in modern theoretical physics and cosmology, when he said, “Who would imagine that this simple law has plunged the conscientiously thoughtful physicist into the greatest intellectual difficulties?” A. Einstein, in "Relativity, The Special and General Theory" (Three Rivers Press, New York, 1961).
It can now be shown that light photons are matter particles with variable mass from the lowest radio waves to the highest gamma-ray range and their mass is inversely proportional to the cube of their velocity. The variable velocity of the light photons can only be observed at cosmic scale.; as the following series of publications would demonstrate:
New Physics – The Negation of Einstein’s Theories of Relativity. JOURNAL OF ADVANCES IN PHYSICS, 22, 54–61. https://doi.org/10.24297/jap.v22i.9594
Momentum – the Archilles’ Heel of Causality-based Physics: The Root of Its Miseries - from the Quantum to the Cosmic. JOURNAL OF ADVANCES IN PHYSICS, 22, 304–312. https://rajpub.com/index.php/jap/article/view/9682
What is Light, Really? A Quantum Dialectical View. Ann Math Phys. 2024;7(3):292-299. https://www.mathematicsgroup.us/articles/AMP-7-235.pdf
New Physics II – Quantum-Dialectical Derivation of New Mass-Energy Relation Invalidates Einstein’s Famous Equation E = mc2 : https://rajpub.com/index.php/jap/article/view/9642
Relevant answer
Answer
Abdul Malek I understand your point and agree that, at first glance, any theory based on light might appear to be inherently phenomenological, which is intuitively understandable. However, I must also admit that it feels almost self-evident to me that things are ultimately grounded in our experiences and perceptions.
While it's valid and even necessary to highlight inconsistencies and critique existing theories, I believe that criticism alone isn't enough. Unless one can propose a viable alternative or improved framework, it’s unrealistic to expect widespread acclaim or acceptance. After all, a theory's value also lies in its practical utility and explanatory power within the limitations of its time.
If we identify a problem with the constancy of light, we must explore alternatives, potentially other constants or frameworks. Yet, this leads to further challenges, as even constants like the gravitational constant introduce their own set of complications. The task, therefore, is not just to point out flaws but to propose and rigorously test new foundations that address these issues comprehensively.
Identifying flaws is only the first step; the true intellectual challenge lies in developing and testing new ideas. Without that effort, criticism remains hollow, and it's unreasonable to expect applause for merely pointing out problems without contributing to their resolution.
Unfortunately, it’s no secret that the field of physics, like any other domain, has its share of characteristically immature individuals. Some treat scientific inquiry as a battlefield, resorting to exclusion, undermining peers, and engaging in unprofessional conduct. This isn’t new, but it’s disappointing because such behavior hinders collaboration and the advancement of knowledge. Sometimes, the best course of action is to focus on your own growth and ideas, tuning out the noise of unhelpful opinions 🤷
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
What physical property could a particle with almost no mass energy and a large kinetic energy have? What could be the use of such a hypothetical particle?
Relevant answer
Answer
Have you heard of cosmic ray showers?
Some are very energetic.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Could you imagine? Is it positive or not really?
Relevant answer
Answer
There would be freedom of gesticulation: People will be able to live, exertion and travel everywhere which may lead to increased in ethic conversation.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
8 answers
Especially in the literary studies where it is linked to narrative. We find it defficult to distinguish between them
Relevant answer
Answer
Fiction is a literary genre that's created from imagination, while imagination is a general concept that can refer to both phenomenal and experiential imagination:
Fiction
A literary work that's based on imagination rather than fact, such as a novel or short story. Fiction is the opposite of nonfiction, which is a literary genre that consists of historically accurate narratives about real people or events.
Imagination
A general concept that can refer to both phenomenal and experiential imagination.
The word "fiction" means a genre , which means "the act of making, fashioning, or molding",in general terms a novel whereas imagination is an individual experience of fancy
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
These days, when talking about the circular economy, they use talking points without even mentioning the pollution production problem associated with the working of the traditional market or with economic activity which it is also present in the working of circular markets or circular economic activity...See how the UN CLIMATE CHANGE PROMISE talks about a circular economy with no link to its pollution production problem nature and with no mention of the need to move one day to pollution-less economies....
" What is circular economy and why does it matter?
And this raises the question: Imagine you are the environment, can a circular pollution production solution/circularity fix the linear pollution production problem/linearity you face?
What do you think? If you think Yes, please indicate why. If you think No, please indicate why no.
Note;
This is an academic question, not a political one.
Relevant answer
Answer
Will revert back soon
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
I'm a student writing a (short) paper on baleen, focusing on a combination of its physical characteristics, its historical uses, and how it was phased out/replaced by other materials. I'm running into an information block on how it went from the whale to a usable form - what tools were needed to cut it? What parts were cut? Who usually did this? I can't imagine that the corset makers and other product manufacturers at the time were receiving the full baleen plates, so who was?
Any help would be much appreciated, thanks!
Relevant answer
Answer
Baleen, commonly referred to as whalebone, is a unique filtering structure found in certain species of whales, particularly the Mysticeti (baleen whales). The processing of baleen involves several steps, from harvesting to preparation for various uses, including its historical application in tools and crafts. The initial step in processing baleen is its extraction from the whale, typically done after the whale has been hunted, a practice that dates back centuries. Historical accounts indicate that baleen was harvested alongside whale oil and meat, which were also valuable commodities during the whaling era (Vieira, 2023). The extraction process involved careful removal of the baleen plates from the upper jaw of the whale, where they are attached in rows. This requires skill to avoid damaging the plates, which are made of keratin, the same protein that makes up human hair and nails (Mazzoldi et al., 2019). Once harvested, the baleen undergoes a cleaning process to remove any residual tissue or fat. This is crucial as any remaining organic material can lead to decay and compromise the integrity of the baleen (Mazzoldi et al., 2019). After cleaning, the baleen is often boiled to further sanitize it and to make it more pliable for shaping. This boiling process can also help in softening the baleen, allowing it to be bent or molded into various forms, which was particularly useful for creating items like corsets, whips, and umbrella ribs in the 18th and 19th centuries (Vieira, 2023; Mazzoldi et al., 2019). Following boiling, the baleen is typically dried and then polished to enhance its appearance. The final product can be used in a variety of applications, from fashion to functional tools. The unique properties of baleen, such as its flexibility and strength, made it a sought-after material for many industries, particularly before the advent of synthetic materials (Vieira, 2023; Mazzoldi et al., 2019). In contemporary contexts, baleen is less commonly used due to conservation efforts aimed at protecting whale populations. However, its historical significance remains a point of interest in studies of marine mammal utilization and the impact of whaling on ecosystems (Mazzoldi et al., 2019). The processing techniques developed over centuries reflect not only the ingenuity of past cultures but also the changing perceptions of whales from valuable resources to conservation icons (Mazzoldi et al., 2019).
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
I’m asking participants to complete 3 questionnaires so as to gather information in order to see if there is a relationship between the 3 variables.
However, I would like to ask participants to complete the 3 questionnaires twice: once imagining themselves answering it pre-covid and a second time in the present (i.e. during covid).
Would I run a separate correlation analysis on pre and during conditions and then eyeball the difference and comment? Or could/would I need to then run some stats to compare the data from the pre and during conditions? If indeed it is possible to do this as a correlational design. It almost feels more of a quasi-experimental design due to the covid factor but I’m not sure if that would really be the case.
Please let me know if more info is needed.
Thanks, all
Relevant answer
Answer
Designing the Study:
  1. Determine Variables: Identify the key variables for which you want to measure correlation. For instance, if studying health outcomes, variables might include exercise frequency and blood pressure levels.
  2. Time Points: Decide on the number of time points and the intervals at which data will be collected. Common intervals include annually, semi-annually, or quarterly, depending on the nature of the study and the expected changes in variables.
  3. Sampling: Choose a representative sample of the population that will be studied. This sample should be large enough to provide statistically significant results and should be followed throughout the study period.
  4. Data Collection: Establish consistent methods for data collection at each time point to ensure reliability and validity. This may include surveys, physical tests, or automated data tracking.
Statistical Analysis:
  1. Calculate Correlation Coefficients: For each time point, calculate the correlation coefficients between the variables of interest.
  2. Use Fisher’s z-Transformation
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
If I told you that Joe was an educated person, but Bill was uneducated. What would you imagine that Joe knew, and what would you think Bill didn't know?
Relevant answer
Answer
Yes, but my question concerns what assumptions you would make.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
Imagine you are an early researcher (assistant professor) in Operations & Supply Chain Management. You also have some teaching and admin responsabilities which count for an average of 2 days per week. Assume you may be interested in diving deeper into your previous resarch interest, but also in opening a new research line.
Any ideas and personal experience is much appreciated, especially with regards to daily time management (hours per day per paper). Thank you!
Relevant answer
Answer
Assume you have different work-in-progress papers which you are developing in parallel. Some of them may be under review and you have to work on a revised version, other ones may be still in the data collection phase of the first submission. I wondered what would an average workload look like, based on your personal experience. Thanks.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
imagination
Fact mixed with fantasy
Relevant answer
Answer
A legend Raed Rahim Khuder is a traditional story or group of stories told about a particular person or place. Often, though not necessarily, these tales are considered historical but not verifiable. Legends usually include heroic characters and fantastic places and often embody the values and culture of the society from which they originate.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
I think that the choice seems very difficult to the scientific community of what could be the good value of the Hubble constant following the existence of two apparently competing values ​​which are 73 km s−1 Mpc−1 and 67 .3 km s−1 Mpc−1. Thanks that these latter values are known precise could we think that it could be absolutely very possible to imagine a new cosmological model allowing the co-existence of these two values ​​on the condition that this so-called new cosmological model stipulates that the two values are concerning two absolutely different areas of space, an area concerned by the value of approximately 67.3 km s−1 Mpc−1 and another area concerned by the value of approximately 73 km s−1 Mpc−1!
- Did anyone come to his mind that this thing can happen in a new cosmological model that is larger and more enriched by possible new cosmological parameters?
- What do people think of a possible cosmological model allowing the coexistence in space of two zones with different expansions?
- Why the universe could need two different expansion rates and two different expansion zones?
-IS DARK ENERGY RESPONSIBLE FOR SUCH A DIVISION OF SPACE BETWEEN TWO EXPANSIONS ZONES?
Relevant answer
Answer
It is necessary to invent a new cosmological parameter to solve the problem of the two values ​​of the Hubble constant. One of the two values ​​proposed by the scientific community would, in my opinion, be a new cosmological parameter. This is what I just did in my pre-publication on RG where I explained that the value 67.3 has nothing to do with a good value for the Hubble constant. According to my preprint I created a formula which relates the value of 67.3 to the value of HA which is known to have an approximate value of 55. My preprint allows us to realize that the value 67.3 (or 67.4) should no longer appears as a possible value for the Hubble constant. And the approximate value of the Hubble constant should be between 72- 73.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
Of the 82 percent of women who said they masturbated, 95 percent could orgasm easily and regularly, whenever they wanted. (Shere Hite)
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks for your support Douglas. I have masturbated regularly throughout my life from the age of 17. The use of explicit erotic fantasy is critical to achieving orgasm. If I cannot generate the necessary arousal nothing happens. There is no hormonal or biological response that men experience. At no other time, with a lover or during the day, am I aware of any arousal of the kind that would lead to orgasm. I have come to appreciate that my use of fantasy during masturbation involves identifying with the role of the role of the penetrating male. Being the receiver in intercourse is not arousing at all. The role facilitates the orgasm of the penetrating male. If a man imagines being the receiver, he may appreciate the difference between being the penetrating male and being the receiver of male ejaculate.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
5 answers
How does anyone imagine that it is possible to orgasm simply by having a man ejaculate into a vagina, or any other part of a person's anatomy? Even in the 1950s, Kinsey found indisputable evidence that the vagina is inert. Surgeons operate on the vagina without using anaesthetic.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks Jirachai for commenting. The pain of childbirth has little to do with the vagina, which is part of the birth canal. The perineum may be torn (between the vaginal entrance and the anus). I am talking about the strong physical sensations some women report as orgasm.
Thanks Franz for commenting but what experience do you have of being penetrated? Are you gay? What feeling are you talking about?
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Chadwick’s Hotdogs
“Hi ya doin scuutch”, I began, “You know my goddam name. My fucking name is Chadwick now get the fuck over it.” If you’re reading this then you probably don’t know who I am. Occasionally people call me quirky. The women call me so kinky that they sometimes want something besides a hotdog from me. “Why the fuck did you raise your hand then lower it to mock me. Are you done dashing piece of shit.” Then the streaky bloke opened his fat mouth, “I was the fucking substitute teacher and you were only 13. Cannot you feel my pain.” Talk about excuses. If I had a cent for every excuse this bloke and dipshit has made then I’d probably not have to be Hot Dog Man. I know what you’re fucking thinking. Originally I was going to be hyena man but, I resembled a werewolf too much and people don’t want to think of the bad guys from the Lion King. Tell you the fuck what. “See your ass later, you putz. You fucking McFuckWork . You’ve gotta be the biggest cocksucker I ever met in education and you aren’t even in the higher kind. Billionaires are shitty as it is. Rising to the top brings the worst out in everyone.”
Ch. 1: One Sonoma Bech Down, God Knows how many to go.
“Room. Room. You bastards listen to me”, I exclaimed like the mighty roaring lion I was and still the fuck am, “You may call me a smut peddler but, how the fuck else am I gonna live. How the fuck else am I gonna live.” “You sure have one fuck of an imagination”, Some prostitute dressed up as bun came up to me, “You’ll need to sail way before this siren will sing your way into a New Yorker’s trap.” “Look toots”, I responded levelly, “Ain’t no fucking way that I’m going cow tow to some real bitch like you. You are a real bitch if you begin a fucking sentence complimenting my imagination then end with my ass in a trap. That is a mother fucking backhanded compliment if I ever knew one.” I slapped the bitch in the face then like the silly bastard I am the fuck away. I started crying to because she was some bitch. A real sexy one that I could probably bulldoze.
Ch 2: Doing the fucking predictable
“They say the more accurate I can predict my day from beginning to end, the closer I am to the grave like a fat Tony. Fat Tony recently died of diabetes.” “Sorry for your goddam loss, Chadwick”, began my sidekick, “Catch Up is my fucking name and I rub myself all over you until we fight crime to the fullest and beat criminals down to the dullest.” For Christ’s sake, I fucking love Catch Up but I wouldn’t stick a wiener in him no matter how light my loafers got, or so I figured, “Look Catch Up, you’ve got some way of putting things. And by putting I mean wording. Don’t make a statement about you rubbing up against me.” Catch Up looked at the ground.
Relevant answer
Adapting a script to the big screen can be a complex process, and its success depends on several key factors
compelling and well-structured story is crucial. The script should have a clear, engaging plot with a strong beginning, middle, and end. It should also have well-paced scenes that keep the audience engaged throughout the film.
Characters need to be well-developed, relatable, and have clear motivations. Strong character arcs and transformations can significantly enhance the film's emotional impact and audience connection.
Scripts that include visually striking scenes and elements that can be enhanced by cinematic techniques (such as special effects, innovative cinematography, and sound design) are often more successful on the big screen.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
I requested the full text of the book “Landscapes Ways of Imagining the World” de John R. Stilgoe, I am new in this so i dont know what to do next or how will i obtain the permission
Relevant answer
Answer
If you requested a full text via ResearchGate, just wait for the author to respond. However, note that generally authors do not hold the copyright to a full book, so usually don't have the right to share digital copies.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
8 answers
Imagine the WCED 1987 would have set only one sustainable development goal, closing the renewable energy technology gap to make renewable energy a permanent substitute of non-renewable energy as soon as possible and address pollution production head on by transitioning out of dirty economies.
Imagine 2012 RIO +20 would have made only one goal to support the implementation of green markets, to set up a system around implementation, financing, and monitoring of the closing of the renewable energy technology gap in each country as soon as possible to address pollution reduction head on by making pollution reduction a profit-making opportunity.
Imagine the 2015 Paris agreement had only one goal implemented in a socially friendly manner, to close the renewable energy technology gap as soon as possible to lead the dirty economy behind and stop providing benefits to those making money from dirty development.
Instead, attention has been placed on managing the consequences of pollution production markets which keeps renewable energy as a permanent complement and send dirty markets under permanent dirty market failure.
And this raises the question, should making renewable energy a permanent substitute be a clear and practical SDG goal?
What do you think?
Relevant answer
Answer
Yes, making renewable energy a permanent substitute should be a clear and practical Sustainable Development Goal (SDG). Renewable energy sources, such as solar, wind, and hydro power, are essential for addressing climate change, reducing greenhouse gas emissions, and promoting environmental sustainability. Transitioning to renewable energy can also enhance energy security, reduce dependence on fossil fuels, and create economic opportunities through green jobs. Furthermore, widespread adoption of renewable energy can improve public health by reducing air pollution and its associated health risks. Setting a specific SDG for permanent renewable energy adoption would provide a focused, actionable framework to guide global efforts towards a sustainable and resilient future.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
3 answers
The concept of "creativity" in a literary text, excusing poetic texts, refers to the ability of the author to produce work that is original, imaginative, and expressive. Creativity in literature involves the generation of new ideas, perspectives, and artistic expressions that evoke emotions, provoke thought, and provide fresh insights. Several studies have dealt with the topic, though they have not provided operational definitions of the term so that it can be measured. Could you propose some operational definitions based on your experience or sources that you have come across?
Relevant answer
Answer
QUOTE: that evoke emotions, provoke thought, and provide fresh insights.
Isn't that the creativity of the reader, instead of the writer?
I don't think I should take credit for my audience's talents and skills! :P
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
I am interested in producing videos of growing and dividing bacterial cells. The problem, as I see it, it to keep the cells still and well-oxygenated without them drying out.
I have tried using a large drop of nutrient agar on a slide, covering with a coverslip and making observations as close as possible to the edge of the coverslip in order to maximise gaseous exchange. Unfortunately, the sample drifts out of focus in a few tens of seconds, which makes a time-lapse series impracticable. I imagine the problem is that the agar is slowly drying and contracting.
Does anybody know any tricks to tackly this problem?
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks Marios, there are some useful tips here. I think the microfluidic devices might be worth looking into.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
The non-linear response of the electron in the driving laser field, we always mention in solids, inter-band polarization, and coherent intra-band dynamics of the electron. I want to deepen my understanding of the coherence related to the electron dynamics in the intra-band.
Relevant answer
Answer
Bant içi yapısını malzemenin yapısı ve atomik yapısı hakkında bilgi sahibi olduğunuz kadar hayal edebilirsiniz.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
Imagine an enormous cylinder in a flat landscape. You are standing along the inner edge. How big would the cylinder need to be for you to not see the curvature? I.e., Instead think you are standing along a completely flat wall. Consider an average person with average eyesight. Would happily accept both the motivation, answer and calculation.
Bonus question: If you had any particular practical tools to your disposal to improve your estimate of the curvature in this scenario, what would they be and how would they help?
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you for you answer Belyazid Abdellatif , if I understand it correctly, are you talking about the curvature of the earth, or the curvature of the cylinder? As I am wondering how big the cylinder need to be for you to not notice the curvature of the cylinder, not the curvature of the earth being obscured by the cylinder. Or are you meaning that the curvature of the cylinder can only be obscured by the inherent curvature of the earth? I thought that the curvature of the cylinder would be unnoticable at a smaller distance than caused by the curvature of the earth?
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
3 answers
Hi, I have grown primary nasal cells on semi-permeable trans-well (PET) inserts and would like to prepare a slide (for confocal microscopy). I imagine it has to be fixed and cut out and placed on the glass slide. Does anyone know how to fixate it on the slide without it moving around so its possible to stain it ? 
Your help is much appreciated. 
Thnak you!
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi, I have more to add on this question, how can we prepare such transwell inserts for histology, the ones I am using have an area for 0.3 cm2 ....
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
5 answers
Is there a term or expression in the geosciences (or any other field?) that means "to imagine how (a) hypothetic (geological) structure(s) of a specific age would look like at present after having been deformed by specific, known tectonic events"?
The idea is that there is no certainty that the hypothetical structures exist because they were never dated. The point is specifically to uncover them by imagining what they would look like at present had they existed at time T and been deformed subsequently by tectonic events X, Y, Z, etc. (events which we know/are confident occurred), thus allowing us to identify structures with suitable geometry during fieldwork.
Please let me know if you have heard of anything of the sort.
Thanks for your help!
Relevant answer
Answer
The beofre made answers ( Borys Kapochkin , Evan Strickland , Oswald Malcles ) are relevant to your question:
I suggest you check out the stratigraphic courses that are based on geosynclinal theory... You will not be able to use the current global tectonics... Always be careful, try to think with a simple mind, because if you don't, you'll get confused.
Note that the Earth expanded and events that occurred after the Jurassic period. Don't forget to consider the theory of catastrophism (with well defined processes) and principle of actualism.
Regards,
Laszlo
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Why Indians are so distinguished in physicists and mathematicians?
The answer to this question has many similarities with a previous article: Why do Russians excel so much in mathematics and physics? [September 2020.]
*In general, there are two different ways to think, one is Western: speed kills strength, while the Eastern: strength kills speed. Both sentences are correct but only under different conditions.
We suppose that:
the study and research of physics and mathematics belong to the second.
*It is worth mention Albert Einstein's quote: "Imagination is more important than knowledge", David Hilbert citing the researcher's resignation: "Well, he didn't have enough imagination to become a mathematician"
*Here we could say that chess sport games are an interconnected thing:
imagination is the main factor common to mathematics, physics and chess.
Imagination in Indian chess is a unique, strong and creative field of imagination. Almost every chess player knows well how deep and difficult the Indian chess games of kings and queens are.
**In short, it is an integral collective process of education, training and creative thinking.
Relevant answer
Answer
An important note on why Indians perform so well in physics and mathematics can be described via the so-called:
Three-dimensional human classification
shown in the following figure.
📷              Fig.1 Three-dimensional human classification
The Indian population is quite large (+E9) and we therefore find a significant number of people located in the first sixth of the curve.
This means that this large number of people are active, intelligent and well educated.
This is the requirement for a superior physicist or mathematician.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
This is not question.
This is the map of topic "glaucoma and diabetes".
file: topic_report.docx = 20 topics from 263 articles which have words "glaucoma diabetes" in their titles, or keywords or abstracts. Each topic is presented through 20 words and 20 thrases with which it is discussed in these articles. Really this terms are the names of methods, objects, properties, laws and so on for topic in question. In addition each topic has quotes from two articles in which it is most manifested.
file: a1_basic.xlsm - articles with basic knowledge on the topic
file: a3_novelty.xlsm - articles potentially with novelty
Why is it difficult to read the topic_report.docx file? Imagine that we are students and we are going to study an unknown course, for example, atomic physics. As a guide, a list of the chapters of the course is proposed in the form of key phrases of the chapters. A curious student will look at the Internet unfamiliar concepts, and also try to generalize the list of terms attached to the chapter, into a whole, so that before the lections begin he will know what the questions arising in this training course. To another student, the reading of the list of topics in the form of terms will be accessible and useful only when all lectures will be finished, as confirmation for himself of his views on the subject.
Feel free to ask the analysis of more specific topic.
We will be grateful for the feedback.
Relevant answer
Answer
Read my research on drug development of glaucoma
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
How can the future of the world or the universe be imagined in the image of quantum physics?
In the science of quantum physics, as Einstein imagined and depicted in his general and special relativity theories, it is being realized in a way. And Hubble and Einstein worked hard in the direction of quantum physics. Today, where do we stand in this world and the universe, and specifically where are we now? Where exactly are we in the world and how many years have passed since the Big Bang? And in which world are we located and how far is the end of the world? Does anyone imagine how small we humans are compared to the vastness of the world and how the science of astronomy and cosmology answers the question of where we are? Where is the end of the world? And how far does dark matter exist in this world? ? How far have the stars and galaxies expanded? Will there be planets where intelligent beings like us humans exist? With the help of quantum physics and astronomy, can we help the future of man to better understand the world and our environment and the conditions of climate change, and to understand the opinions of Yugoslavian Melankevich about climate change on earth? Is it the age of drought or the age of frost and cold in the future?
Relevant answer
Answer
Greetings and courtesy
Thank you very much for your complete and comprehensive answer. Thank you Abbas
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
Dear experts,
I have been writing a paper about language teacher identity, and I adopted Wenger's three modes of belonging (Engagement, Imagination, and Aligment) as my theoretical and conceptual framework. However, I feel confused about Wenger's thoughts in defining those constructs as they did not specify the issue of HOW. Like, how engagement works in exploring language teacher identity; how imagination informs LTI, and how alignment works with LTI. From my POV, I think what Wenger describes is general, not give too much detail about HOW to understand those aspects.
Can anyone who is expert in SLA sheds some light here?
Thanks.
Relevant answer
Answer
Mayada Nageeb Al-Maktary Thank you for your insightful analysis.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Hello,
Let's imagine we're using a Weibull law to study experimental dispersions and we've evaluated these laws for 3 loading levels, say 1 MPa, 5 MPa and 10 MPa. Is there a method that can predict the probability law for the experimental dispersion at, say, 3 MPa or 12 MPa?
Best regards,
Benjamin Martin
Relevant answer
Answer
I suppose you can develop empirical models of the Weibull parameter estimates based on the loading level. Alternatively, if you can develop/use a fracture model, then you can incorporate the Weibull results to those or vice versa.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
3 answers
Imagine I have five different concentrations of a species. I’ll simulate a UV absorption spectrum for each concentration (five in total) and call it the original spectrum. Then, I’ll add a constant value of 0.8 to all of these spectra, creating what I’ll call the increased spectrum. When I mean-center both the original and increased spectra, the resulting figures should be the same (and they are!), but I’m wondering which figure should be displayed: Fig. 1 or Fig. 2?
Relevant answer
Answer
Why would you add a baseline to the absorbance? Maybe I lack imagination, but I cannot see under which circumstances this could make sense in case of real samples/materials...
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
6 answers
Some volcanoes can send particles and water to the Mesosphere, as Tonga in 2022. The consequences are much more complicated than imagined
this paper is talking about it
Relevant answer
Answer
Iceland volcano erupts on Reykjanes peninsula (BBC, 4 hours ago). Volcanic eruptions, always Fascinating in Beauty and Majesty, remind us in a spectacular way of essential factors in the heat balance of the globe: the transfers at the Visible Lithosphere-Atmosphere Interface in the form of Seismic and Volcanic Activities and the transfers at the Lithosphere-Hydrosphere interface, Invisible because they occur at the bottom of the oceans. Unlike the GHE, the effects of these activities on Climate Change are not well analyzed, at least in Climate Models, including those used in IPCC projections.
Illustration Source: ICELANDIC MET OFFICE:
See Also:
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
I’ve been reading an article called “The George Santos Syndrome – Why people believe their own lies”. Suppose someone makes up a piece of fiction about some part of their life. Apparently, we use the same neural circuitry to imagine something as to remember it. If we reinforce the fabricated fiction we imagined with enough detail to make it sound plausible, it will eventually be remembered as truth if we keep repeating the lie and let enough time pass.
What happens when that imagination takes a scientific turn? In trying to formulate a credible hypothesis that explains some mystery, we naturally imagine as much detail as possible and keep adding what we assume to be facts, as well as reasonable ideas, as the weeks and months and years pass. Somewhere down the path – maybe sooner, perhaps later – we might conclude that our hypothesis seems to equate with truth. Then it could well be embedded in memory as such.
Science is certainly not the same thing as lying. But there are similarities between the two processes (which may be why scientific fraud does occur sometimes). We need a way to determine whether the hypothesis developed over time is actually factual or simply a self-deception that grows stronger and stronger as years (and decades) roll by. That method is, of course, to conduct experiments. But are experiments the final answer?
According to Special Relativity, experiments are overrated by modern science since the truths revealed by experimentation are necessarily restricted to one frame of reference. Regarding the question of length contraction in Special Relativity – Albert Einstein wrote in 1911 that "It doesn't 'really' exist, in so far as it doesn't exist for a co-moving observer; though it 'really' exists, i.e. in such a way that it could be demonstrated in principle by physical means by a non-comoving observer." (Einstein [1911]. "Zum Ehrenfestschen Paradoxon. Eine Bemerkung zu V. Variĉaks Aufsatz". Physikalische Zeitschrift 12: 509–510)
Demonstration "in principle by physical means by a non-comoving observer" is the same meaning as "demonstration by experiments performed by scientists not moving at the speed of light". So the experimental results (which are potentially interpreted in different ways) are valid. But they’re only valid in one frame of reference – from the human perspective of the scientists, who say length contraction occurs. Looked at from the equally valid universal frame of reference, there is no length contraction.
Some people will say the universal frame is irrelevant because we’re human and the human perspective is the only thing that matters. Some will reject the whole discussion because they disapprove of the example using Special Relativity. But the point is that experimentation doesn’t offer a final answer. There is no final answer and we just have to do the best we can to solve the mysteries of the universe. We grope our way through all the theories and experiments, and hopefully make a little progress in the search for truth. To put things another way – quantum mechanics’ Uncertainty Principle has expanded into an Uncertainty Principle affecting all of science. The indeterminacy doesn’t rule just the subatomic realm in the early 21st century. It also rules the macroscopic Space Telescopes, CERN and the Large Hadron Collider, and every detector or laboratory.
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with the mentioned premise. Yes, a fiction might (not necessarily will) become a false memory if we repeat it too many times. And its mechanism is most probably not limited to merely some engrams being strengthened over time. There may be much more complicated scenarios at play, with various levels of micro and macro mechanisms working hand in hand. An example of a macro mechanism is the person's psychological need to believe his own fiction, in order to alleviate some suffering.
Anyways, I don't think that happens much in the realm of science. Hypothesis testing is in no way similar to the false-memory premise you mentioned first. It is the opposite: in science, people* rigorously try to self-criticize their own results; others are more than happy to criticize your results for you! So in the end, there is not so much to worry about self-deception.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
Dear
A small marine fish can not understand what is sea. An ant can not imagine how big the Himalayas is.
There is UNIVERSE. Let us stand at the coast and observe the sea. We can not ask the meaningless question " IS THERE GOD"
Relevant answer
Dear, thank you.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
3 answers
Hey! I have been thinking about this and I was wondering what other people think. As answer on the question, you can name any crazy idea that pops up! Or maybe something that we already know/have in our world.
Relevant answer
In fact what you propose already happened. Roman engineers were experts in using simple machines to lift weight, which continued in the Middle Ages. For instance, you can check this interesting project: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CboJzrDhoSk&pp=ygUsbW9kZXJuIGNhc3RsZSB3aXRoIGFuY2llbnQgdGVjaG5vbG9neSBmcmFuY2U%3D
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
3 answers
الخيال الابداعي
التصميم
التصميم الداخلي
الفضاءات الداخلية
الفن
Relevant answer
Answer
The passion and depth of feeling that draw on the mind's vision.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
Of the 82 percent of women who said they masturbated, 95 percent could orgasm easily and regularly, whenever they wanted. (Shere Hite)
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks Stanley for commenting. Intercourse is a key emotional bonding mechanism for men. The offer of regular intercourse keeps men tied into relationships with women and willing to support family life. But achieving orgasm is a selfish pleasure however it is achieved. We need to focus on our own arousal. Intercourse is effectively male masturbation with a lover. A key difference between male and female responsiveness is that a woman only achieves orgasm alone when she can focus on her own arousal. A man is dependent on a lover, for penetrative sex, to obtain the best sexual release. This is, of course, for biological reasons and for the survival of the species.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
I have tried to create a spotlight several times, but it doesn't recognize the title, the, the platform ask me to upload it again, as a result of this situation my article is been removed from the page, this is the second time that this situation happens just by trying to add spotlights. I also tried to just add keywords in the spotlight option, but it didn't result neither. The thing that worries me the most is that instead of gaining visibility, I am losing it as the stats are been erased each time this happens, and I also lose the Doi number which force me to upload the pdf again and get a new one, which means modify the current pdf...you may imagine...
Relevant answer
did you contact Research gate?
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1086 answers
What remains of a mind, once the era has passed?
From the sovereign solitude of de Gaulle to the spectral pragmatism of Gorbatchev, from the blazing lucidity of Simone Weil to the viral ambitions of Elon Musk — this series dares to compare the incomparable. Each entry is a clash, a dance, or a duel between two figures — sometimes historical rivals, sometimes forgotten echoes — whose legacies reflect not only their genius, but the desires, illusions, and blind spots of their time.
Figures & Fulgurances is not a hagiography. It is a gallery of contrasts: power vs depth, vision vs noise, substance vs spectacle. Through sharp commentary, ironic turns, and flashes of insight, this series seeks the fragile moment when history tips into memory — or oblivion.
A tribute to brilliance. And a reckoning with what brilliance costs.
All contributions on the topic are welcome!
Illustration: Scientists estimate this pig painting was drawn 45,500 years ago. Source [1]
Relevant answer
Answer
@Stephen I. Ternyik Purely my opinion! I think to say that, science is hierarchically above art is to certain degree debatable. Facts can be dependent or independent entities and are malleable with time. Science must apply before it can lead (anonymous) for even scientific investigations to prosper, there must employment of some artistic functions that have to do with observations (even though called scientific methods). To say that, science is hierarchical over art implies that, there is no equality among disciplines, which can disturb scholarly community. And this can raise some questions whether there is absolute interdisciplinarity or multidisciplinarity in the academia. I think art is given least treatment in terms of the function it performs right from the middle ages to the present such as in trivium and quadrivium.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
The word 'representation' has been defined by Derrida as 'reproduction of presentations'. Taking the prefix 're' to mean 'again'.
When representation can only reproduce presences again, how can it reach into the future? Is that not problematic, as the future is not present and can therefore not be reproduced again?
Why is this relevant? The German word 'Vorstellung' (as e.g. in Schopenhauer's Die Welt als Wille und Vorstellung') is made up of 'vor' and 'stellung': for, in front of (or 'fore' as in 'foreground') and to place, to put. Whereas 'Vorstellung' directs someone's orientation foreward, representation casts someone back into the past. Alway. Inescapably, But a Vorstellung will always be in front of you, wherever you turn.
It is easy to relate Vorstellung to the future. As that will be any account, image, presentation of the future to be placed in front of anyone. (This is also why it is different from 'imagination', as you imagine something by yourself, in your head as it were. A Vorstellung kan be imaginary, but also, similar to a play or a performance (also 'Vorstellung') physically outside of yourself in front of you. Imagination cannot).
So sematically Vorstellung can cover times ahead. But can representation?
And what does that mean for communication theory, when its dominant defining concept cannot address the future?
#representation #communication theory #cultural studies #Stuart Hall #lingusitic relativity #vorstellung
Relevant answer
Answer
According to the Treccani Dictionary (the most authoritative Italian dictionary) rappresentazione is "Il processo mediante il quale un contenuto di percezioni, immaginazioni, giudizi e concetti, si presenta alla coscienza, e quanto viene così rappresentato". Accordingly, 'representation' may apply both to the past and to the future and the re- prefix is no longer bound to its original Lat. meaning "back" --though even in Latin re- did not mean just "back". You may have a mental representation ( immaginazione, Vorstellung) of what will be the situation in Israel next month.
On the other hand, rappresentazione can have a more concrete, physical meaning, exactly as Vorstellung: La rappresentazione alla Scala dello Zauberfluete di Mozart. I do not know whether Engl. representation can have this meaning: I do not think so. As for French, représentation may refer, among many other meanings, to 'Action de donner un spectacle devant un public, en particulier au théâtre' and also to 'Perception, image mentale, etc., dont le contenu se rapporte à un objet, à une situation, à une scène, etc., du monde dans lequel vit le sujet'.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
15 answers
Which of the two graphical presentations of religiosity can be considered to be appropriate to use:
> imagined by the author – DAWKINS’ LINEAR SCALE OF RELIGIOSITY, including five categories of Religious Agnosticism
or
> founded on rational argumentation ­– CANI’S COMPLEX PLANE OF RELIGIOSITY, embracing CANI’s Intermedialism?
*****
Definition of CANI’s Intermedialism and Huxley’s Agnosticism as well as the answer to the above-asked question based on argumentum ad rem you’ll find in my video lecture on YouTube at:
Relevant answer
Answer
You wrote: "So this backs up god is an experience because without the affect that creates one, there cannot be one."
It does nothing of the sort. Various natural phenomena and experiences may cause god-beliefs of various flavors, but neither the experiences themselves nor the ideas and concepts they engender are gods. You are confusing fictions and symbols with reality.
"...because without the affect that creates one, there cannot be one." This is true only because affects do not create gods in the first place but merely ideas of gods.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
How does anyone imagine that it is possible to orgasm simply by having a man ejaculate into a vagina, or any other part of a person's anatomy? Even in the 1950s, Kinsey found indisputable evidence that the vagina is inert. Surgeons operate on the vagina without using anaesthetic.
Relevant answer
Answer
I am asking women to explain how they orgasm with a lover. Over the many years of my research I have found very few women willing to comment. Certainly no woman can orgasm through intercourse, which is determined by male responses. No one can orgasm within time limits set by another person. My experience is that there is no arousal with a lover. This explains why no one can name any female erotic turn-ons with a partner. I have found that orgasm occurs through masturbation because I need privacy to use the erotic fantasies that cause my mental arousal. Few women seem to understand that arousal and orgasm are responses of the brain to eroticism.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
3 answers
In his essay here (https://theloop.ecpr.eu/how-to-overcome-democratic-gridlock/), Pablo Ouziel states:
"Today, our ability to imagine democratic futures is diluted, and narrow perspectives on democracy are presented as universal. Such a state of affairs [...] calls for a conversation among democratic traditions that emphasises diversity and reciprocity."
From my perspective, a key to emphasising diversity and reciprocity, as Ouziel puts it, is to carefully describe the thousands of different manifestations of "democracy" (<- this includes synonyms in English and like-terms in other languages) that we can presently perceive.
I'm thinking, for example, of Panchayats, the Haudenausonee Confederacy, Black democracy, but also Tlaxcallan republicanism, decision-making among the Inuit (including their circumpolar democracy), and thousands of other already-existing examples like this.
I think that if people can understand these different manifestations (myself included!) they can then be equipped to use that information if they wish to do so by, for example, communicating it to others or implementing aspects of it/combinations of it, wherever they want in their lives.
What comes to mind for you when you read Pablo Ouziel's encouragements?
Relevant answer
Answer
Am in support of Janusz Ruszkowski , with respect to the DNA of democracy.
Yet every man (and woman) has a property in his (her) own person; this nobody has any right to but themselves. Richard Lyons, The DNA of Democracy
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
8 answers
To what extent are RG members here concerned with the role of the imagination and its impact on our collective emergence into our socio-economic future?
Can the imagination and its output (individual or collective) be held against, for example, the output of AI models such as ChatGPT in reconciling future possibilities?
I would welcome a discussion around these questions as my new book concerning the Reimagining of Capitalism (https://vernonpress.com/book/1673) is shortly to be available.
I would am interested in views about how me might balance the potential of AI, against the potential of a human mind which possesses imagination.
Relevant answer
Answer
Capitalism is an existential threat to critical culture. The ideology infects our education system, inhibiting the free development of human potential. Once students pick a major, testing and grades are used to rank and sort. Similar systems are used to pit them against each other for access to law, business, and medical school. They determine who receives scholarships that lessen one’s debt burden, or plum entry jobs with Google. And now, generative AI beckons in the form of programs like ChatGPT. After all, why do the intellectual lifting yourself when all that matters is the boring terminus, a “useful” degree?
Amid this capitalistic system of education, the question becomes: Can teachers demonstrate forms of opposition? Can anti-capitalism actually be taught?
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Imagine having 9 samples, each with a slightly different weight, that needs to be allocated into 3 groups. How can you best allocate each samples so that the total weight of each group is equal or similar?
Would be great to know whether this could be done on R.
Relevant answer
Answer
Sorry, I didn't understand your question. Have a nice day.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
We have an oldschool PPMS equipment with ACMS option, and recently got the problem with DC measurements. When starting a measurement it returns:
Measuring DC Extraction 8/1/2023 10:54:37 PM
Measuring at 1X Gain
**ERROR** Incorrect DC Scans Count. Requested = 1, Actual = 0
*Warning* No data was measured for DC Measurement
*Warning* No data was measured for DC Measurement, DC Extraction not Completed
And nothing happens. I'm afraid to imagine this is the end of our magnetic susceptibilty measurements.
Anyone has this issue? I'm glad to any help...
Relevant answer
Answer
I searched the web for some possible solutions and found the following information:
  • According to the ACMS User’s Manual, the error message “Incorrect DC Scans Count” indicates that the number of scans requested by the user does not match the number of scans performed by the system. This could be caused by a communication error between the PC and the Model 6000 controller, or by a hardware malfunction in the ACMS coil set or the sample rod[1].
  • One possible way to troubleshoot this problem is to check the connections of all cables and make sure they are secure and in good condition. You can also try to restart the MultiVu software and the Model 6000 controller, and perform a self-test on the ACMS option1.
  • Another possible way to troubleshoot this problem is to use a different sample rod or a different ACMS coil set, if available, and see if the error persists. You can also try to measure a reference sample, such as Pd or Cu, and compare the results with the expected values[2].
  • If none of these methods solve the problem, you may need to contact Quantum Design for technical support. They may be able to diagnose the problem remotely or send a service engineer to your location[1].
My friend provides me the following answer:
The error message "Incorrect DC Scans Count. Requested = 1, Actual = 0" indicates that the PPMS is not detecting any DC signal from the sample. This could be due to a number of factors, including:
  • A problem with the ACMS hardware
  • A problem with the sample holder or sample
  • A problem with the PPMS software
If you have checked all of these things and the problem persists, you may need to contact Quantum Design for support.
Here are some things you can try to troubleshoot the issue:
  • Check the ACMS connections to make sure they are secure.
  • Try a different sample holder.
  • Try a different sample.
  • Update the PPMS software to the latest version.
  • If you have access to another PPMS system, try running the measurement on that system to see if the error persists.
If you have tried all of these things and the problem persists, please contact Quantum Design for support. They will be able to help you troubleshoot the issue and determine if your ACMS hardware needs to be repaired or replaced.
In the meantime, you may be able to work around the issue by using the AC measurement mode instead of the DC measurement mode. The AC measurement mode is less sensitive than the DC measurement mode, but it may still be able to provide useful data.
Here is a summary of the key points from both my answer and my friend's answer:
  • The error message "Incorrect DC Scans Count" indicates that the number of scans requested by the user does not match the number of scans performed by the system.
  • This could be caused by a communication error between the PC and the Model 6000 controller, or by a hardware malfunction in the ACMS coil set or the sample rod.
  • To troubleshoot the issue, you can try the following: Check all cable connections. Restart the MultiVu software and the Model 6000 controller. Perform a self-test on the ACMS option. Use a different sample rod or a different ACMS coil set, if available. Measure a reference sample, such as Pd or Cu, and compare the results with the expected values.
  • If none of these methods solve the problem, you may need to contact Quantum Design for technical support.
The website of Quantum Design for technical support is here. You can find their contact information, service notes, software downloads, warranty information, and more on their website. You can also submit a ticket or request a service call online. If you need to contact them by phone, their number is 1-800-289-6996 for the United States or Canada, or +49 6131 324 185 for Europe, Middle East, and Africa.
In addition to the above, I would also recommend that you check the PPMS software version and make sure that it is up to date. You can download the latest software from the Quantum Design website.
Good luck
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
11 answers
I am unclear on exactly what we are supposed to be afraid of, if the average temperature of our climate were to increase by 2 degrees C.
What is it that we imagine will happen when this occurs, and why is it so terrible?
Relevant answer
Answer
I worked at the Pentagon for six years. And, like every other government agency, they never miss an opportunity to say "the sky is falling, therefore give us more money."
If they can't frighten the crowds about threats from Moscow or China, they will use asteroids from space or renegade goat herders from Afganistan.
The universal reaction to climate worries is to limit production and trade while constricting human activities.
Every climate discussion leads to taking money out of the private sector and putting it (and therefore more authority) to "restrict and regulate" into the hands of life-long public officials.
History has shown that people, left to themselves, do quite well innovating their way around problems. History has also shown that the human condition tends to improve around periods of rising temperatures.
So I think we will all be just fine.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
5 answers
Hello, I am wondering if there is a good way to normalize my data. For background, I collect conditioned media from primary cells and then perform radioimmunoassay on them to determine the concentration of progesterone secreted into the media. I know RIA isn't used these days very much, but theoretically it is very similar to ELISA. There does seem to be differences between my treatments and controls, but without normalizing I'm not sure whether it is due to my treatment or something else. Total protein would probably be best to normalize to I imagine, but I do not have this as we only extract for RNA after the treatment period. I have been wracking my brain to think of some way to normalize the data such as normalizing to the % increase/decrease between the treated and controls but not sure if this would make sense. Any help would be appreciated!
Relevant answer
Answer
Yes, you can normalize your progesterone data to a housekeeping gene using qPCR. Here's how you can do it:
  1. Run a qPCR assay for both your housekeeping gene (e.g., GAPDH) and your target gene (progesterone) on your cDNA samples. This will give you the Ct (cycle threshold) values for both genes.
  2. Calculate the ΔCt (delta Ct) for each sample by subtracting the Ct value of the housekeeping gene from the Ct value of the target gene. This ΔCt represents the relative expression level of your target gene normalized to the housekeeping gene.
  3. If you have multiple samples in different treatment groups, calculate the ΔΔCt (delta-delta Ct) by subtracting the ΔCt of your control group from the ΔCt of your treated group for each sample. This gives you a measure of the fold change in gene expression between the treated and control groups.
  4. To normalize your progesterone data, you can use the ΔΔCt values as a factor. Divide the progesterone concentration of each sample by the corresponding ΔΔCt value. This will adjust your progesterone data relative to the gene expression changes observed in your qPCR experiment.
Regarding combining methods like housekeeping gene normalization and percentage change:
  • If you want to combine housekeeping gene normalization with percentage change normalization, you would first normalize your progesterone data to the housekeeping gene as described above.
  • Then, if you want to account for percentage changes, you can further divide the normalized progesterone values by the percentage change factor. This would mean that you're adjusting your progesterone data for both gene expression changes (using the housekeeping gene normalization) and percentage changes between treated and control groups.
  • Essentially, you'd have two normalization steps: first to the housekeeping gene and then to the percentage change factor.
All the best
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Dear fellow researchers,
does anyone know how the large Protein (469 kD) DNA PKcs gets transported into the nucleues ? I know that it exists in the nucleus "in abundance" and most of its function is studied in regard to DNA Repair which of course happens in the nucleus. However, it must be produced in the cytoplasm (right?) and therefore it somehow has to be transported into the nucleus. I read that this happens trough a nuclear localization sequence and importin which then interacts with the nuclear pore complex but I am not sure how this is possible for this extremely large protein and if there is any data at all ?
I can imagine that it gets threaded trhough in an elongated somewhat unfolded state is there evidence for this with other proteins ?
I thank you all for your help in advance.
- Benjamin
Relevant answer
Answer
Maybe this article helps to clarify at least some of your questions:
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
Was al-Wasiti able, in the drawings of his miniatures known as (Maqamat al-Hariri), to convey to us the idea of the structural buildings of his time? Or was he drawing from his imagination things that were not relevant to reality?
The attached photo, a copy of the Maqamat of Hariri, from the holdings of the National Library in Paris (3929)
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear doctor
Go To
DEVELOPMENT OF PICTORIAL ART AND MINIATURE ART IN CENTRAL ASIA AND THEIR ROLE IN SOCIAL LIFE
Yuldashev I
SCIENCE AND INNOVATION INTERNATIONAL SCIENTIFIC JOURNAL VOLUME 2 ISSUE 4 APRIL 2023 UIF-2022: 8.2 | ISSN: 2181-3337 | SCIENTISTS.UZ
"The miniature art created during the Middle Ages was applied to small books or illustrated the entire page of a book in the form of a small-scale colored picture. These small-scale colored pictures were created using various materials (paper, metal, and silk). Therefore, the term "miniature" refers to all elements of the graphic part of a book, whether it is a small painting or an illustration that covers the entire page or sometimes only two adjacent pages. Thus, the term "miniature" has been widely used in relation to the fine arts of the Timurid era."
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Hi all, I am interested in performing bulk RNA sequencing on primary human cells that have been cultured in absence/presence of certain types of drugs. I know n=6 is quoted as an acceptable number for cell lines and genetically identical mouse samples, but I can imagine the number of replicates needs to be higher when using primary human cells taken from a variety of donors. I am struggling to find any comparable published studies so I was wondering if anyone here had an idea/some experience with this? Many thanks!
Relevant answer
Answer
For RNA-seq it largely depends on the effect size you are hoping to resolve. I've found that Table 1 in the following paper to be helpful here:
So to call a fold change of 2 statistically significant 98% of the time, do N=5 with 30M reads per sub-library.
As the table points out, it also depends on your sequencing depth which gives you more or less confidence.
For your case if you are also concerned about large variance between replicates, you could do pre-NGS qPCR validation of a couple genes you are interested in to gauge the dispersion between replicates and between treatment groups.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
I believe physics masters programs need innovation to overcome the slow progress in solving theoretical problems in physics in the form of ph.D replicating standards.
Imagine a student who has to write an essay about the paradoxes of dpevial relativity, literature teview akin ph.D and outline ideas to explsin them with his own indights
Or a similar topic about unitary quantum mechanics/spacetime quantization approaches duch CST.
Or a topic about how space has time properties, how its ststic vs dynamic fluidity give rise to spacetime phenomena.
Although some mofules would have more trafitional mathematical emphasis, 60% would have conceptual pre- ph.D level.
Relevant answer
Answer
I believe physics curriculum designers are either too convervative or agnostic about the pedagogic structure.
Since critical thinking is the main feature of masters programs, physicists who insist on problem solving or advanced skills-based curricula for masters are in fact not being loyal to pedagocic theories or learning at the graduate level.
This might have consequences as, beyond the extra-IQ students, others are left at a disadvantage - even if they acquire those skills. Masters level education was always about critical thinking- and this is gained via essay-based projects on cutting edge field fronts better. Knowing physics does not imply critical thinking at higher level, as it is narcisistically assumed.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Imagining you have 1 m3 cubed container made out of steel and inside the container is 5 bar. What will the force be felt on the container if the pressure inside suddenly drops to 1 bar? Temperature can be omitted if needed.
Trying to design a yield limit for pressure-drop resistant materials through tensile/compressive measurements.
Relevant answer
Answer
The force acting on the walls of the container due to the pressure inside can be calculated using the formula:
F = P * A
where:
  • F is the force,
  • P is the pressure, and
  • A is the area.
Given a cubical container with an edge length of 1 m, one side's surface area (A) is 1 m^2. Since a cube has six faces, the total surface area is 6 m^2.
When the pressure inside the container drops from 5 bar to 1 bar, the pressure change (ΔP) is -4 bar. Converting this to pascals (since 1 bar equals 100,000 Pa), the pressure change is -400,000 Pa or -400,000 N/m^2.
So, the total force change experienced by the walls of the container is:
ΔF = ΔP * A ΔF = -400,000 N/m^2 * 6 m^2 ΔF = -2,400,000 N
The negative sign indicates that the force has decreased due to the pressure drop.
The stress on the walls of the container is the force divided by the area over which the force is distributed. In this case, the change in stress on the walls is equal to the change in pressure because the area cancels out:
Δσ = ΔF / A Δσ = -400,000 N/m^2
This means the stress on the walls of the container decreases by 400,000 N/m^2 due to the pressure drop. This stress is what your material must be able to withstand. The yield limit of your material, obtained through tensile or compressive tests, should be higher than this value to prevent deformation.
Please note that this calculation assumes that the stress is evenly distributed over the walls of the container, and ignores other potential factors such as strain hardening, material defects, or localized stresses due to design features (like welds, or changes in thickness). A more detailed analysis using mechanical engineering and material science principles would be needed for a thorough safety assessment.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
Why is female orgasm is defined in such vague & emotional terms? I assume it is so that every woman can imagine she might have had one.
Relevant answer
Answer
Why are male orgasms seen in exclusively physical terms? But yes, women are supposed to be romantic and therefore sexual experience is seen as emotional and even spiritual.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
Dear Mohammad Masfiqul Alam Bhuiyan and Ahmed Hamma
I read your paper:
A Hybrid Multi-Criteria Decision Support System for Selecting the Most Sustainable Structural Material for a Multistory Building Construction
And these are my comments:
1- My comments do not refer to structural engineering but to MCDM procedures. There is no doubt that you have made extensive research for this article. I think that you took good care in selecting experts in construction engineering, but I am afraid that the same care weas not taken in the application of the MCDM methods. There are some incongruencies as well as inaccuracies.
You want to select the most sustainable material for a building construction, which implies considering at the same time and jointly the economics, the environment and the social field. However, you selected a method, AHP, which works opposite, since it analyzes separately and in a linear hierarchy, each of the four main criteria. I am not blaming the method; it was designed for that purpose; it is the incorrect use of a method that I understand is incorrect.
For instance, in Figure 2, the four criteria are not connected, which is not real.
Criteria like Technical and Economics are normally strongly related. For example, the technical department decides to use radiant flooring for heating (a technical system), which has a cost different of using a hot-water system (a different technical system). Technical is also related to environment, as in the case that technical decides to recycle waste water produced in the building, by treating it, it involves technical issues, economics and environment. They are not isolated.
As another example, suppose that engineering proposes to use radiant flooring, and the financial guys say that they don’t agree because there is no money for that, so they ask engineering to look for a less expensive heating. As you can see, considering individual aspects and solving them linearly, and then, adding them up, does not make sense.
This is the real-world.
2- In page 4 you say “The remarkable contributions of this research comprise the integration of technical aspects with the commonly used three pillars (economic, social, and environmental)”
Not so remarkable or new; this integration has been done for decades before your paper.
3- In page 5 you say “. Subjective (qualitative) methodsand objective (quantitative) methods are the two types of weighing techniques”
This is inexact. There are not qualitative and objective methods. That denomination applies to criteria. Normally, a MCDM handles both.
4- In reality, I don’t think that you can address a problem like this with four main criteria. What about risk, legal issues, topography, access to the site, material supply, constructors’ expertise, etc.?
5- In page 1o you say “3.6. Fuzzy AHP”
According to Saaty, the AHP creator, AHP never should be used with fuzzy logic, because AHP is already fuzzy.
6- In page 11 you speak about consistency. Yes, there is a FORCED consistency regarding the DM values.
This consistency indicates that the DM was more or less articulate; remember that there is a formula that forces him to be coherente, like it or not, and that the coherence or transitivity is his, andnot related with the real world, which is normally intransitive.
7- In page 21 you say “Steps 1 and 2: A pairwise comparison matrix was developed for each user to compute the relative priorities of criteria from the user’s point of view”
Suppose that you need to pair-compare criterion Stress, that is, the force applied in the middle of a beam, and Strain, which is its deformation regrading its central axis. Sincerely, I don’t imagine an engineer doing this comparison and deciding for instance, that stress is three times more important than strain. In my opinion, it is absurd; however, this is what pair-wise comparison is about. How can anybody trust the result of this comparison, and don’t forget that there can be ‘n’ engineers giving different values.
Considering this aspect, which is the object in performing fuzzy with arbitrary data?
8- In page 24 you say “The owner’s opinion was given a higher weightage of 40%, while the rest of the team received 30%”
Why? Because he is the owner and, in this condition, he knows better than other experts? This does not look very professional.
9- In page 26 you determine that RC is the best option. I wonder how you can reach that conclusion without considering the structural characteristics of the four alternatives.
It suggests that in this study all modulus of elasticity are the same, when it is known than this is different between different options, and even in different kind of timber.
10- What I still don’t understand is why you compute two different kinds of weights, objective and objective. Of course, the first is useful to consider the experience and know-how of the DMs, but how do you use both?
It is necesario to remember that both types of weights do not have the same meaning. Weights from entropy or using statistics, represent quantity of information of each criterion and they are capital to evaluate alternatives.
Weights from AHP are simply a relative measure of criteria importance and have no relation to alternatives evaluation.
11- In page 28 you say “In the end, this application generated several outputs for the users
If at the end the users have several outputs, it appears that they came back to square one. In my opinion, what they need is one solution, not several.
I hope these comments may help you
Nolberto Munier
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
12 answers
Sorry, I do not know much about impedance spectroscopy and for my thesis I am now thinking about how cases of ideal resistors, ideal capacitors, ideal ionic conductors and ideal electronic conductors would look like. I think I have a fairly good image what ideal resistors and ideal capacitors would look like in Nyquist and Bode-plots. But I am struggling with the understanding of ionic conductors and electronic conductors. Maybe you can help me?
As for the background to my question: When I did impedance spectroscopy on my mixed ionic and electronic conductor, I was instructed to use the equivalent circuit as indicated in the attached image.
Here, the ionic conductor consists of bulk ion movement and ion reaction and both these parts consist of a parallel resistor and capacitor. But I wonder how can an ionic conductor actually have a resistance? How can I imagine this electrochemically?
The reverse question would be: does an electronic conductor have reactance? If yes, is it actually possible to theoretically achieve 0 phase shift during impedance spectroscopy?
Thank you in advance for any valuable input that helps me understand the theory and the electrochemical processes underlying this theory.
Relevant answer
Answer
In addition to the right previous answer, I guess if you look at the concept of "internal resistance", it might help to clarify the picture you ask for.
Please look at the end of the wiki article, the example with a "lithium polymer battery".
Kind Regards.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
14 answers
Imaginations or memories look fainter than first-hand experience (or hallucinations): Can this fainter "look" and its comparison with the solid look of first-hand experience (and hallucinations) give us any info about qualia or phenomenal consciousness? If so, what? and How?
For starters, it can tell me that qualia may depend on neural activity because the fainter look of memories or imaginations correlates with a fainter activation of responsible brain areas.
Relevant answer
Answer
Vahid Rakhshan of course, more specific experimentation to follow those ideas would make sense.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
You are presently suggesting/implicating Researchgate members should remove historical data. Reconsider! Let's just imagine all scientific publications within Your timeframe is removed from access. Get it? Please, don't present us members with evidence that you've conned by the stressed "mainstream"! Show sci. judgement!☝
Relevant answer
Answer
Professor Per Sjögren-Gulve ,
this is a really interesting question. It made me question what will happen if suddenly the power goes off and the internet goes down. We will not have access in any machine or electronic project that we have saved in doc or pdf files. The only thing we are going to have is our brain, our knowledge, which is the biggest achievement.
Ömer Özbey, Plato stated that true knowledge is buried deep within our subconscious, and that we draw upon this knowledge when knowing Forms such as Beauty, Equality, Justice, etc.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
10 answers
Einstein was a revolutionary scientist, possibly for the first time in the several hundred years that transpired following Sir Isaac Newton's discovery of, and ability to express in mathematical terms, the gravitational laws of motion.
Today's theoretical physics research has stalled. Most leading theorists lack the combination of traits that made these great
** ability to express new effective representations of physical systems
** physical intuition-based postulation of principles
** deep knowledge of issues without distortions
** imagination and conceptual power
Relevant answer
Answer
Mohamed Javanshiry,
Don't be afraid of Einstein, he was a "monster" in physics only. I said that there will be no new Einstein because the "real" Einstein for me discovered everything in these equations knowing that he does not know it and it is up to people to better understand the real details of his work, if there will be a new one, who knows, maybe I will tell him that he will not scare anyone!
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Hello,
I am developing research about Imaginable Futures, and I need 30 more responders to our survey to accomplish 300.
The research is super fast and anonymous.
The final results will be available to all participants in Open Access.
Please follow this link to contribute
Thank you in advance,
Dr Mastrantonio
Imaginable Futures #future foresight #futurabilities #future studies #future imagination
Relevant answer
Good luck.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
I am a researcher
I'd like more advice
I would like to use the project-based learning method to develop innovative thinking in biology among 16-year-old students. I believe that my use of educational platforms and the use of digital videos and designs will help my students more understand the subject and expand their new ideas.
But from my point of view, reading is always better than watching. When I read a topic, I will imagine its shape, and that imagination will generate new innovations. But when I watch a video, my imagination will be determined by the shape I saw.
Relevant answer
Answer
I totally agree with Dr Wilmer Lopez. In fact, variety is the master key for solving the major learning problems. For instance, you should take into consideration the integration of three learning components in every single learning practice: 1. the input in terms of its richness and variety, 2. how to build your students' competencies, and 3. how to engage them into meaningful communicative acts. For more details you can read the following articles. they are all available on the ResearchGate platform:
1. THE BUILDING OF A NEW LANGUAGE LEARNING MODEL BASED ON THE CHOMSKYAN CONCEPT
2. Multiple Intelligences: An instructional design model that affects English language learners’ performance
3. Is a Comprehensive Instructional Model of Language Learning (CIMLL) Possible?
Mustapha Boughoulid
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Hello to the entire research gate community,
imagine that money is available to buy a pressure scanner. we have an old NetScanner 9116 that is ending its useful life.
The scanner should have an acquisition frequency of at least 500Hz, 16 channels, mini size, labview drivers.
Any suggestions?
Hello to the entire research gate community,
imagine that money is available to buy a pressure scanner. we have an old NetScanner 9116 that is ending its useful life.
The scanner should have an acquisition frequency of at least 500Hz, 16 channels, mini size, labview drivers.
It is tio be used for research purposes in mid-velocity wind tunnels. Aerodinamic testing of wings, blowing nozzles, preston probes, etc
Any suggestions? Cost?
Relevant answer
You probably need to check the Pressure Scanners Information to decide on which scanner to buy. The following link provides such information:
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
6 answers
As you probably know, asbestos is deemed a 'forever substance', which stays inside your body forever once you inhale it. Some can be coughed up in the mucus, but small fibers will translocate throughout the body, without any feasible clearance method by the body. If you could think creatively, what could you imagine would be a potential future asbestos treatment that could remove these fibers from within the body?
Relevant answer
Answer
Al ser encapsulado el asbestos por los macrofagos, no puede ser digerido por ellos por el tipo de material que es. Por lo que se forma una especie de cicatriz, algunas microscópicas y otras más grandes, por lo general las grandes se pueden ver por Rx, las microscópica no, pero los Pulmones empiezan a tener cicatrices que les disminuye su expansión al respiras produciendo una Enfermedad Pulmonar obstructiva crónica que se caracteriza por disminución de la capacidad ventilatoria y por tanto disminución del oxígeno que entra a la sangre, cansancio al caminar pocos metros. Lo mejor es mantener el control con un neumólogo.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
Respected colleague,
This question does not seek answers in the sense that both competence and loyalty are important.
For example: imagine you own a company and have two candidates for CEO. One is competent, but you know he / she is not loyal. You trust others, but you know that he / she is not competent.
If you had to decide between them, which one would you choose?
Relevant answer
Answer
It depends on the situation, when there is no critical mass of one or another, the troubles begin - be it in private sector, but it in public sector. Anyway, loyalty is much more necessary in the public sector than in the private, while competence is important everywhere.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
7 answers
Hi,
Imagine that you are going to sample a protein conformation (consists of N atoms) using Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics simulations, independently.
For the MD simulation, the phase space has a dimension of 6N dimension (3N position and 3N momentum). I'm assuming that the phase space for MC has a dimension of 3N (just position of atoms). Am I missing something here?
Relevant answer
Answer
The statement is wrong.
The phase space is invariant in both simulations. However, for the MC simulation only position sampling is performed, the velocity or momentum must be considered from the thermal distribution associated with the system.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
3 answers
The imagination capability of the nursing is a significant part in both the quality of the nurses' role performance and the ethical approaches which they use. It also is a main part in their ability to communicate with a patient and in the form of person which they try to be. How to increase the effectiveness of imagination capability in nursing?
Relevant answer
Answer
Imagination stems from curiosity at the bedside, which stems from caring about someone else's predicament. Imagination can lead to "workarounds" that may not be safe or efficacious; however, imagination can fuel a research question that can lead to an evidence-based change in practice that is safe and deployed as a caring act from the nurse to another person. Imagination can engender more curiosity so that a new research question is formulated, and the cycle continues. Imagination is a wonderful gift of the mind that should be explored, expanded and enjoyed, but operationalization must be done carefully and safely.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
If there is no S-N curve for a steel material, we could calculate a typical fatigue life using its tensile strength (I will call it a common S-N curve, here). When calculating its endurance limit, some correction factors, so called marine factors are applied. Here I have a question. What about Notch factor?
The S-N curve from the tensile strength is usually applied to a fully reversed condition (R=-1), as far as I know. I need to see if a bolt has inifinite life or not. But it is just standard bolt and its S-N curve is not specified. So, I have to use the common S-N one. But, you know, the stress at its minimum section of the external thread is amplified so the notch factor should be considered, I think.
But someone said it does not need to be considered when checking out the endurance limit. Is it correct? I cannot imagine it in my head. If it is correct, only the normal stress affacts the material's infinite life and its stress concetration just impacts on the finite fatigue life. Is that true?
If it's not, could you please let me know how to apply the notch factor to the common S-N curve? It is based on the unnotched geomatry. Normally, notched S-N ones are used for the stress-concentrated geometry. So, I have no idea how to use the notch factor with the common S-N curve.
Thanks
Have a nice day
Relevant answer
Answer
@Claudio Pedrazzi
Thank you for your replay and sorry for reading it late due to a sudden busy work.
Regarding the "common SN curve", what you understand is correct. A half of the ultimate strength is commonly used as the endurance limit, if there is not a specific experimental SN curve. Using the marine factors, the limit can be lowered.
However, what about notch factor? If I apply it to the limit, it is too conservitive as you know. I have no idea of it.
Oneday, I heard indirectly that the notch factor can be ignored to the typical SN curve. I cannot understand why it can be.
If you have any clues, please let me know.
Thanks and have a nice day~ :)
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
6 answers
What is infinite? does this have any value? must there be an end or is it just our thoughts it can't imagine that there is no end to infinity! Aren't all things part of infinity? we too? is God an infinity that cannot be imagined but felt? is an infinity an energy that binds us and all things (reality and thought) together? Is there a physical explanation for infinity? Is the limitation by (infinity -1) or (-infinity + 1) legitimate or just a need to calculate it mathematically?
Relevant answer
Answer
We can imagine any finite quantity to be halved, and then each half to be halved again, and so on, without end. You can then say the finite quantity has infinitely many parts. It's just a conceptual distinction.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
Hello, I am conducting a Survey on Future Imagination, and I would be very glad if you could answer it. This is the link for it https://forms.gle/adHVnLxZFN9gZXtK7It is totally anonymous, and results will be available to all participants through Open access. Thank you in advance, Dr. Mastrantonio – Social Psychologist She/her latinanthology@gmail.com Please follow THIS LINK to the IF - survey = https://forms.gle/adHVnLxZFN9gZXtK7
Relevant answer
Answer
Looking forward to new contributors to reach 300 responders
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
8 answers
This research is on the field of Future Imagination, and Future Expectation conducted by Dr. M. Mastrantonio, a post-doctoral in Germany. I am inviting you to answer this survey, which is part of a larger study on Future Imagination and the Anthropocene. All collected data is anonymized in accordance with ERC principles. Final results will be available through Open Access and will be forwarded to each participant at the end of the research phase (Nov 30, 2022). I thank you in advance for your estimated contribution to scientific advances. My email is latinanthology@gmail.com if you wish to contact me for anything. THIS IS THE LINK to it = https://forms.gle/adHVnLxZFN9gZXtK7
Thank you so much,
M.
Relevant answer
Answer
Done. All the best with your research
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
5 answers
I'm studying the topic from Probabilistic Robotics by Thrun Burgard and Fox.
In the Extended Kalman Filter algorithm, we linearized the action model in the following way.
𝑔(𝑢(𝑡),𝑥(𝑡-1)) = 𝑔(𝑢(𝑡),𝜇(𝑡−1)) + 𝐺(𝑡)⋅(𝑥(𝑡−1)−𝜇(𝑡−1))
𝑔(𝑢(𝑡),𝑥(𝑡-1)) is the action model and 𝐺(𝑡) is its Jacobian matrix with respect to the state 𝑥(𝑡−1).
I don't see how this guarantees linearity because 𝑔 could be nonlinear in 𝑢(𝑡). The authors don't mention anything about why this is the case.
In other words, I imagined that the multivariate Taylor expansion for this where we get a linear function in both 𝑢(𝑡) and 𝑥(𝑡−1)
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi,
It should be noted that the Kalman filter is part of the theory of estimation of states of a system represented by a linear model. It is therefore an algorithm that provides estimates of some unknown variables from observed measurements over time. The filter uses as input the command u(t) and the output of the model y(t) and as output it provides an estimate of the output, in other words an estimate of the states of the system. For non-linear systems there is an extension that can deal with these cases: the extended Kalman filter. In my opinion there is no particular requirement on the control when applying this algorithm.
Also please take a look at the links.
Best regards
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
8 answers
i need to understand a point in optimization in PSO when updating position & velocity equation of PSO.
in case of i optimize my system according to the maximum of the objective function, and in each iteration i will update its value and update its position and velocity according to the equation. is it necessary for the objective function itself include this position or velocity variable? or i will take the position and velocity correspond to the optimized value of objective function?
i can not connect between them. i need to imagine the idea of code because some examples optimize a variable in fitness function and so the link between them is clear but in my case it is not clear.
i attached the file of equations.
thanks in advance
sorry for long question
Relevant answer
Answer
Your formulae are quite confusing. According to the second one (velocity update), Q is a position, but according to the first one it seems to be a fitness ... that does not contain any position.
Moreover, according to the third one, x is also a position ... that is not used in velocity update formula.
Remember:
1) fitness function = function of a position in the search space. And only of the position. Don't forget that the same fitness function could be used by some other algorithms, and most of them don't use any velocity.
2) velocity update = combination of the previous velocity and some positions. Usually
- the previous one of the particle
- the previous best one of this particle
- and the best known one by its neighbours.
The neighbours are either the whole swarm (global best approach), which is bad for multimodal functions, or one of the local best versions (the set ot neighbours is either fixed, variable or adaptive).
3) position update = old position + new velocity.
I suggest to have a look at a simple PSO code, like SPSO 2007 (Particle Swarm Central http://particleswarm.info), which uses a variable neighbourhood.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
6 answers
Hi guys,
Imagine we have hybrid carbon/glass fibre composites. As I know the sample size is too small for TGA experiment. Do you think the small size of the samples can represent the properties of the whole composite? I appreciate it if you can share your understanding here.
Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi,
My answer is no. The composite includes the carbon, glass fibers, polymers ant others. The fibers are hard to be distributed uniformly becouse of their anisotropy. As we all know, the weight for TGA is about 5 mg. If the sample is less than 5 mg, it is hard to represent the whole composite.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
10 answers
Let's imagine that the Universe was one large piece of Glass before the Big-Bang. This piece of Glass was so dark and compact that it allowed nothing to propagate or move through it.
The high energy of the Big-Bang at the center of our Universe made this piece of Glass break around the center of the Universe. The large piece of Glass breaking process is still propagating in the borders of the Universe which makes us think that our Universe is growing larger.
The broken part of this large piece of Glass allows radiations like Cosmic Rays and Gamma rays to propagate, then starts the propagation of Light then the movement of Space objects. The broken Glass is known conventionally as the Aether where light Can propagate. However, the large piece of dark and compact Glass still existing at the borders of our Universe is the Bose-Einstein condensate. Maybe small pieces of this dark Glass exist even inside our Universe in some spots which couldn't receive enough energy or Lost somehow the energy Given by the Big-Bang and these spots of dark Glass are conventionally known as the Dark Matter.
What do you think of this Model? I need objective opinions from you.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Francois Zinserling , thank you for your responses. I hope we will collaborate in the future to produce New articles.
Regards,
Akram Louiz
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Is there any merit in having a massive web-base where people can complete a reviewer profile, and only get invited for work specifically in their area of expertise? Maybe add it as an extension of e.g. ResearchGate? This reliance of editors only drawing on people who have submitted to their journals seems very self-limiting and hard work. Imagine if you could enter a set of key terms, then get presented with a searchable list of potential reviewers ... who actually work in the area concerned (😲).
Relevant answer
Answer
Nice idea Nicholas E Rowe and I think that would help authors a lot in terms finding reviewers asked by some journals and to go over self-biased. I hope someone pick this idea and develop it more.
Regards
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
2 answers
Hello everyone!
I am aiming to analyze the whole mycobacterial lipidome after infection of BMDMs, however the ratio of eukaryotic and bacterial lipids is, as you can imagine, too high, which is quite inconvenient for analysis. I was thinking about selective lysis of macrophages, either mechanically - maybe by beads? Or chemically - similarly as in case of survival assay, followed by centrifugation of intact bacteria. Does anyone have any tips how to get rid of cells in a simple way? Thank you all for reply!
Relevant answer
Answer
You may refer to the article attached below . The investigators have come up with a protocol that allows efficient isolation of all bacteria. They have used 0.0125% saponin in PBS which when added to the cell suspension induces lysis of human cells, but not bacterial cells. DNA in the supernatant is depleted through DNase treatment.
Good Luck!
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
4 answers
Immanuel Kant’s Critique of the Power of Judgment (1790) stated that we do not understand beauty by means of cognition, “but rather relate it by means of imagination (perhaps combined with understanding) to the subject and its feeling of pleasure or displeasure. Do you agree with that?
Relevant answer
Answer
It is not imagination at work there but feeling.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
1 answer
Every experiment or analysis on the cell, molecule, protein and their interactions depends on various detection techniques, which, more or less, would for sure influence the status of the cellular functions, especially when it comes to the small-size molecules such as DNA and RNA. Maybe we can only depict the possible mechanism pathway bay a temporary map and our pure imagination. Once it comes back to the cell without observation, everything would be totally different.
Relevant answer
Answer
Tianhang Li Controlling the chance that a set of qubits collapses into certain measurement states is a basic principle in quantum computing. The ability to influence the measurement of a qubit toward a desired state or collection of states is enabled by quantum interference, a result of superposition.
Transport of electrons and protons in photosynthesis, respiration, vision, catalysis, olfaction, and virtually every other biological transport activity are good examples of quantum effects at the action.
  • asked a question related to Imagination
Question
3 answers
I'm trying to run a robust mixed ANOVA with a between groups factor (2 levels) and a within groups factor (3 levels). I'd ideally like to be able to set and run planned contrasts, have a full set of relevant summary statistics (presumably I'd report summary stats for the trimmed means rather than the original means..), and then calculate effect sizes for the contrasts.
I'm new to R (I attempted to teach it to myself over the weekend) so if you can explain R language stuff at the most basic level imaginable then that would be appreciated..
Following Field (Discovering Statistics using R, 2012 (I'm much better acquainted with his SPSS version of this)) and Wilcox (Introduction to Robust Estimation and Hypothesis Testing, 2013) I've downloaded Rallfun-v40.txt to my working directory from https://dornsife.usc.edu/labs/rwilcox/software and then brought its contents into R using source(file.choose()).
From this I've followed Field's instructions and run the following on my data (converted to wide format such that the columns are betweenL1_withinL1 betweenL1_withinL2 ... betweenL2_withinL3 )
```bwtrim(2, 3, data, tr = .2) # using 20% trimmed means```
And then I've also run the following three lines of code:
```
sppba(2, 3, data, est = mom, nboot = 2000)
sppbb(2, 3, data, est = mom, nboot = 2000)
sppbi(2, 3, data, est = mom, nboot = 2000)
```
The output from bwtrim() is straightforward enough to understand. It gives me test statistics (Q) for both factors and their interaction, each accompanied by a p-value.
I don't really understand what the output from the remaining three lines gives me. The R-documentation tells me "The functions sppba, sppbb, and sppbi compute the main fixed effect, the main within-subjects effect, and the interaction effect only, respectively, using bootstrap."
It seems to return test statistics (psi hat), a p-value, and a table of contrast codes as follows:
```
sppba(2, 3, data, est = mom, nboot = 2000)
$p.value
[1] 0.112
$psihat
[1] -5.577981
$con
[,1]
[1,] 1
[2,] -1
sppbb(2, 3, data, est = mom, nboot = 2000)
$p.value
[1] 0.4562719
$center
[1] 2.9931670 -0.4448510 0.5338472
sppbi(2, 3, data, est = mom, nboot = 2000)
$p.value
[1] 0.58
$psihat
[1] -5.345118 -5.875428 1.012981
$con
[,1] [,2] [,3]
[1,] 1 0 0
[2,] 0 1 0
[3,] 0 0 1
[4,] -1 0 0
[5,] 0 -1 0
[6,] 0 0 -1
```
Can you explain this output to me? What do the three statistics for sppbb and sppbi tell me? Why are there not contrast codes for sppbb? Most importantly... where are the contrasts themselves? Are these the psi hat statistics?! To whatever extent the above code doesn't already do this, can you also give me advice on my initial aim: "to set and run planned contrasts, have a full set of relevant summary statistics (presumably I'd report summary stats for the trimmed means rather than the original means..), and then calculate effect sizes for the contrasts"
Finally, I also ran a robust mixed anova with bootstrapping and a 20% trimmed mean (hopefully I inputted the arguments correctly...) as follows:
bwtrimbt(2, 3, data, tr=0.2,JK=2*3,nboot=2000)
This had the result of making a significant interaction from the original bwtrim() calculation only marginally significant. How would you interpret this? Am I better off using bwtrimbt? The data for each of the columns in my wide format dataset is not normal and the (between) group sizes are n=17 and n=21.
Relevant answer
Answer
After a few days of reading up on this, I'm going to attempt to answer my own question. However, any corrections to my answer will be appreciated.
bwtrim(), sppba(), sppbb(), and sppbi() seem to give different outputs depending on:
1) whether they are called from the WRS2 package or Rallfun-v40.txt (from https://dornsife.usc.edu/labs/rwilcox/software)
2) whether the arguments are in one of the following two formats:
• bwtrim(outcome ~ between*within, id = id, data = data_long, tr=0.2)
• bwtrim(2, 3, data = data_wide, tr = .2)
From what I can tell, the WRS2 package requires the arguments to be as follows:
bwtrim(outcome ~ between*within, id = id, data = data_long, tr=0.2)
The data should be in long format, i.e., 4 columns:
• Column 1: "id" [observation number (class: integer)]
• Column 2: "between" [between subjects variable (class: factor)]
• Column 3: "within" [within subjects variable (class: factor)]
• Column 4: "outcome" [outcome variable (class: numeric)]
Whereas for the Rallfun-v40.txt version the arguments should (for a 2x3 mixed design (between x within)) be in the following format:
bwtrim(2, 3, data = data_wide, tr = .2)
For this, the data should be in wide format, i.e. (with 'b' for between subjects factor and 'w' for within subjects factor):
• Column 1: b1w1
• Column 2: b1w2
• Column 3: b1w3
• Column 4: b2w1
• Column 5: b2w2
• Column 6: b2w3
The WRS2 version provides more easily interpretable output:
```
#WRS2 Output for bwtrim(outcome ~ between*within, id = id, data = data_long, tr=0.2)
#library("WRS2")
# value df1 df2 p.value
#between 2.6551 1 19.9949 0.1189
#within 1.4066 2 16.3158 0.2732
#between:within 3.2474 2 16.3158 0.0650
```
vs
```
#source(file.choose()) #then open Rallfun-v40.txt from working directory
#$Qa #i.e., the test statistic (Q) for the between subjects factor
#[1] 2.655095
#$Qa.p.value
# [,1]
#[1,] 0.1162786
#$Qb #i.e., the test statistic (Q) for the within subjects factor
#[1] 1.415902
#$Qb.p.value
[,1]
#[1,] 0.2664895
#$Qab #i.e., the test statistic (Q) for the interaction
#[1] 3.26877
#$Qab.p.value
[,1]
#[1,] 0.05957826
```
For sppba(), sppbb(), and sppbi() the output is also easier to interpret when called from the WRS2 package:
WRS2 output from sppbb(outcome ~ between*within, id, data = data_long)
```
#Test statistics:
# Estimate
#within2-within1 -2.9932
#within2-within3 0.5338
#within1-within3 -0.4449
#Test whether the corresponding population parameters are the same:
#p-value: 0.454
```
It tests whether the “typical” difference score (as measured by an M-estimator) between any two levels of measurement occasions is 0 (while ignoring the between-subjects groups), resulting in a p-value.
--
WRS2 output from sppba(outcome ~ between*within, id = id, data = data_long, avg = FALSE)
```
#Test statistics:
# Estimate
#within2 between1-between2 0.368
#within1 between1-between2 -11.250
#within3 between1-between2 -5.852
#Test whether the corresponding population parameters are the same:
#p-value: 0.114
```
This performs pairwise group comparisons for the between subjects groups in each of the within subjects conditions, and then tests whether all of the null hypotheses are simultaneously true, resulting in a p-value.
**sppba(outcome ~ between*within, id = id, data = data_long)**
```
#Test statistics:
# Estimate
#names-notes -5.578
#Test whether the corresponding population parameters are the same:
#p-value: 0.124
```
This looks at the difference between the overall averages for between subjects group 1 and between subjects group 2. It's suggested that it's more satisfactory in terms of type I errors.
--
**sppbi(outcome ~ between*within, id = id, data = data_long)**
```
#Test statistics:
# Estimate
#within2-within1 between1-between2 5.345
#within2-within3 between1-between2 1.013
#within1-within3 between1-between2 -5.875
#Test whether the corresponding population parameters are the same:
#p-value: 0.572
```
*This output is a little confusing. Mair & Wilcox (2020) suggest we should see something more like this:*
```
#Test Statistics:
# Estimate
#within1 between1-between2 5.345
#within2 between1-between2 1.013
#within3 between1-between2 -5.875
#Test whether the corresponding population parameters are the same:
#p-value: 0.572
```
This computes M-estimators based on measurement occasion differences for each group separately. This would be the null hypothesis:
H0 : θ1,2|1 − θ1,3|1 = θ1,4|1 − θ2,3|1 = θ2,4|1 − θ3,4|1 = θ1,2|2 − θ1,3|2 = θ1,4|2 − θ2,3|2 = θ2,4|2 − θ3,4|2 = 0
--
The Rallfun-v40.txt version of all of these provides the same eventual statistics but in a format that is harder to interpret. This being said, it does provide a contrast table for the final analysis:
```
# [,1] [,2] [,3]
#[1,] 1 0 0
#[2,] 0 1 0
#[3,] 0 0 1
#[4,] -1 0 0
#[5,] 0 -1 0
#[6,] 0 0 -1
```
Column-wise this tells us that it performs the following comparisons, before conducting a single hypothesis test comprising all of these:
• Contrast 1: b1w1 to b2w1
• Contrast 2: b1w2 to b2w2
• Contrast 3: b1w3 to b2w3
--
Regarding running planned contrasts, I'm not sure if this is an option yet? It would be great if there were some robust way of running e.g., a simple effects analysis, but I'm not sure if there is?
There are a number of ways to run robust multiple comparisons/linear contrasts using the functions in Rallfun-v40.txt though (using data in wide format).
**• bwmcp(2,3, data_wide, tr = 0.2)**
Described as 'A bootstrap-t for multiple comparisons among for all main effects and interactions in a between-by-within design. The analysis is done by generating bootstrap samples (default n=599) and using an appropriate linear contrast.'
It returns the following:
```
#$Fac.A
# con.num psihat se test crit.value p.value
#[1,] 1 -14.02105 8.604797 -1.629446 1.893387 0.09015025
```
1 Contrast (between subjects factor):
between1 vs between2
```
#$Fac.B
# con.num psihat se test crit.value p.value
#[1,] 1 6.283111 3.783206 1.6607900 2.26226 0.0884808
#[2,] 2 6.952670 5.422252 1.2822477 2.26226 0.1936561
#[3,] 3 0.669559 4.519172 0.1481597 2.26226 0.8714524
```
3 contrasts (within subjects factor):
1) within1 vs within2
2) within1 vs within3
3) within2 vs within3
```
#$Fac.AB
# con.num psihat se test crit.value p.value
#[1,] 1 -9.451155 3.783206 -2.4981866 2.295026 0.008347245
#[2,] 2 -4.473331 5.422252 -0.8249951 2.295026 0.429048414
#[3,] 3 4.977824 4.519172 1.1014903 2.295026 0.280467446
```
3 contrasts (interactions):
1. [b1w1 & b2w2] vs [b2w1 & b1w2]
2. [b1w1 & b2w3] vs [b2w1 & b1w3]
3. [b1w2 and b2w3] vs [b2w2 & b1w3]
**• bwamcp(2,3, data_wide, tr = 0.2)**
• Performs multiple comparisons associated with Factor A using the (bootstrap-t) method BWAMCP
• It returns three sets of results corresponding to Factor A, Factor B, and all interactions. *The critical value reported for each of the three set of tests in designed to control the probability of at least one type I error*. Note the adjusted p-values.
```
#$test
# con.num test crit se df
#[1,] 1 -2.2886813 2.578012 4.070108 21.58990
#[2,] 2 0.0380117 2.576128 3.577192 21.79337
#[3,] 3 -1.1849082 2.575349 4.086265 21.87870
#$psihat
# con.num psihat ci.lower ci.upper p.value adj.p.value
#[1,] 1 -9.3151798 -19.807965 1.177605 0.0322647 0.09147072
#[2,] 2 0.1359751 -9.079328 9.351278 0.9700244 0.99997118
#[3,] 3 -4.8418487 -15.365408 5.681710 0.2487656 0.56465996
```
Contrasts (compares the between groups in every within groups condition):
1) b1w1 vs b2w1
2) b1w2 vs b2w2
3) b1w3 vs b2w3
**• bwbmcp(2,3, data_wide, tr = 0.2, con = 0, alpha = 0.05, dif = T,pool=F)**
• uses method BWBMCP to compare the levels of Factor B.
• Gives all pairwise comparisons among levels of Factor B in a mixed design using trimmed means. The pool option allows you to pool dependent groups across Factor A for each level of Factor B.
• "*Critical p-values” are reported in the column headed by p.crit. These indicate how small a p-value must be in order to reject it, given the goal that the family-wise error be equal to some specified α value*.
```
#$TESTS.4.EACH.LEVEL.OF.A[[1]]
# Group Group test p.value p.crit se
#[1,] 1 2 -0.35472450 0.7301628 0.02500000 2.135674
#[2,] 1 3 -0.45389406 0.6595966 0.01666667 2.882919
#[3,] 2 3 0.01232317 0.9904102 0.05000000 1.862900
#$TESTS.4.EACH.LEVEL.OF.A[[2]]
# Group Group test p.value p.crit se
#[1,] 1 2 1.86769503 0.08641073 0.01666667 2.964151
#[2,] 1 3 0.86431908 0.40435907 0.02500000 3.395994
#[3,] 2 3 -0.08201215 0.93598912 0.05000000 3.054188
#$PSIHAT.4.EACH.LEVEL.OF.A
#$PSIHAT.4.EACH.LEVEL.OF.A[[1]]
# Group Group psihat ci.lower ci.upper
#[1,] 1 2 -0.75757576 -6.887114 5.371963
#[2,] 1 3 -1.30853994 -9.582728 6.965648
#[3,] 2 3 0.02295684 -5.323702 5.369615
#$PSIHAT.4.EACH.LEVEL.OF.A[[2]]
# Group Group psihat ci.lower ci.upper
#[1,] 1 2 5.5361305 -2.702648 13.774909
#[2,] 1 3 2.9352227 -6.503852 12.374297
#[3,] 2 3 -0.2504805 -8.739514 8.238553
```
Contrasts:
All within group conditions for b1
1) b1w1 vs b1w2
2) b1w1 vs b1w3
3) b1w2 vs b1w3
All within group conditions for b2
4) b2w1 vs b2w2
5) b2w1 vs b2w3
6) b2w2 vs b2w3
If pool is set to true [i.e., bwbmcp(2,3, data_wide, tr = 0.2, con = 0, alpha = 0.05, dif = T,pool=T) ] then it pools the data for you and then calls the function rmmcp, with the following output:
```
#$POOLED.RESULTS$test
# Group Group test p.value p.crit se
#[1,] 1 2 1.3241169 0.1984734 0.01666667 1.827659
#[2,] 1 3 0.3905554 0.6997198 0.02500000 2.238924
#[3,] 2 3 -0.1246142 0.9019117 0.05000000 2.017569
#$POOLED.RESULTS$psihat
# Group Group psihat ci.lower ci.upper
#[1,] 1 2 2.4200337 -2.299012 7.139080
#[2,] 1 3 0.8744241 -4.906517 6.655365
#[3,] 2 3 -0.2514177 -5.460815 4.957980
```
Contrasts:
Data pooled from b1 & b2
1) w1 vs w2
2) w1 vs w3
3) w2 vs w3
**• bwimcp(2,3, data_wide, tr = 0.2)**
• For the interaction, this compares trimmed means using a nonbootstrap method (the bootstrap version is spmcpi), with the following output:
```
# A A B B psihat p.value p.crit
#[1,] 1 2 1 2 -6.2937063 0.09074896 0.01666667
#[2,] 1 2 1 3 -4.2437626 0.33564988 0.02500000
#[3,] 1 2 2 3 0.2734374 0.93824609 0.05000000
```
Performs 3 contrasts:
1) b1w1 vs b2w1
2) b1w2 vs b2w2
3) b1w3 vs b2w3
So it compares the between subjects groups in each of the within subjects conditions
--
From what I can tell, it isn't possible to do planned contrasts or simple effects analysis, which is a shame for anyone with specific hypotheses to test, given the severity of the p-value corrections needed to account for multiple comparisons. Perhaps I'm incorrect here?
--
If you spot any mistakes in this response (or have anything to add to it) then please do point them out.
--
The sources for this are as follows:
• WRS2 stuff:
Mair, P., & Wilcox, R. (2020). Robust statistical methods in R using the WRS2 package. Behavior research methods, 52(2), 464-488.
• Rallfun-v40.txt stuff:
Wilcox, R. R. (2021). Introduction to robust estimation and hypothesis testing (Fifth Edition). Academic press.
The former is aimed at researchers and so is a bit easier to follow. It also contains some handy supplementary materials, relying upon datasets already present in the WRS2 package.