Science topics: LinguisticsSyntaxGrammar
Science topic

Grammar - Science topic

Explore the latest questions and answers in Grammar, and find Grammar experts.
Questions related to Grammar
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
1 answer
Implementing structural grammar and immediate constituent (IC) analysis among Saudi EFL (English as a Foreign Language) students in intensive English programs can be approached through several strategies:
1. Curriculum Design: Integrate structural grammar concepts into the curriculum, focusing on sentence structure, parts of speech, and grammatical relationships. Develop lesson plans that explicitly teach these concepts alongside vocabulary and reading comprehension.
2. Focus on Form: Teach the rules of structural grammar explicitly. This could involve identifying the subject, verb, and object in sentences and understanding modifiers and phrases. Use diagrams or charts to represent sentence structures visually.
3. IC Analysis Workshops play a crucial role in developing students' grammar skills. These workshops teach students how to break down sentences into their constituents and provide a practical and effective way to enhance their understanding of sentence structures.
4. Interactive Activities: Use activities like sentence diagramming, where students can visually map out the structure of sentences. Include pair or group work to encourage collaborative learning and discussion about different structures and their uses.
5. Contextual Learning: Incorporate authentic materials, such as articles or stories, and have students analyze the sentence structures used in them. This helps students understand practical applications of structural grammar in real texts.
6. Regular feedback is a key component of effective teaching. By using IC analysis to help students understand errors in their grammar structure and guide them in correcting their sentences, educators can ensure that students are continuously improving their language skills.
7. Technology Integration: Utilize language learning apps and software that provide exercises based on structural grammar and analysis, allowing students to practice outside the classroom.
8. Professional Development for Teachers: Ensure that instructors are well-versed in structural grammar and IC analysis, providing them with the necessary training and resources to teach these concepts effectively.
9. Assessment Strategies: Include assessments that require students to demonstrate their understanding of structural grammar and their ability to perform IC analysis on both written and spoken English.
10. Cultural Relevance: Connect grammar instruction to cultural contexts familiar to Saudi students. Use examples and scenarios that resonate with their experiences, making the learning process more engaging.
By employing these strategies, educators can effectively teach structural grammar and IC analysis, thereby significantly enhancing the language skills of Saudi EFL students in intensive English programs and inspiring them to achieve their full potential.
Your valuable opinions, more scientific comments, creative suggestions, and critical analysis are not just invited but crucial to share and make it a complete discourse analysis of the above-asked question and discussion topic.
Best,
Dr. Meenakshi
Relevant answer
Answer
Many thanks for your reply!
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
provide me with the main topics and subjects dealt by the domain mentioend
Relevant answer
Answer
The main concerns of Developed Traditional Grammar include:
Parts of Speech:Classification of words (nouns, verbs, adjectives, etc.).
Sentence Structure: Analysis of components like subject, predicate, and object.
Syntax and Morphology: Study of word forms and their arrangement in sentences.
Prescriptive Rules: Guidelines for correct and formal language use.
Concord and Agreement: Ensuring subject-verb and noun-adjective agreement.
Punctuation and Orthography: Rules governing writing conventions.
This grammar focuses on maintaining linguistic standards and clarity through well-defined structural principles.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
3 answers
Actually, AI tools such as ChatGPT are types of facilitators of nowadays' task-crowded life, so why don't we get the ultimate use of these tools?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello,
in my opinion, using the tool for checking / correcting grammar and other MISTAKES in a text is perfectly fine. As long as the utilisation ends there. :)
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
1 answer
How do Otto Jespersen’s contributions to 19th-century comparative grammar inform our understanding of modern language changes, particularly in relation to historical linguistics?
Jespersen's work is more aligned with historical linguistic studies and comparative grammar rather than modern linguistic changes.
Could someone clarify how Jespersen’s work fits within the broader scope of both historical and modern linguistic studies?
I've been meaning to invite someone to write and article with me related to that.
Relevant answer
Answer
I suppose that you refer to Jespersen work Language: Its Nature, Development and Origin (1922). I have little to say about this book, but as your question also concerns "how Jespersen's work fits within the broader scope of ... modern linguistic studies", I would like to say that his book The Philosophy of Grammar (1924) seems to me to be an important forerunner, still read, to modern typological research in linguistics.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
1 answer
It seems that it is difficult to find and download some measurment tools such as questionaires.
Relevant answer
Answer
you can download ChatGpt
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
2 answers
How does CFG contribute to the practical applications of natural language processing , particularly in parsing and language recognition? Provide a how CFG facilitates these processes in a real-world scenario.
Relevant answer
Answer
Context-Free Grammar (CFG) plays a significant role in natural language processing (NLP) by providing a formal framework for describing the structure of languages. Here's how CFG is utilized in practical applications, particularly in parsing and language recognition:
1. Parsing
  • Definition: Parsing involves analyzing a sequence of tokens to determine its grammatical structure according to a given grammar.
  • CFG in Parsing: CFGs define rules that describe the syntax of a language. These rules can be used to construct parse trees, which represent the syntactic structure of sentences.
  • Example: In a CFG, you might define rules for simple sentences like:S → NP VP NP → Det N VP → V NP Det → "the" | "a" N → "cat" | "dog" V → "chases" | "sees" Using these rules, a parser can analyze a sentence like "the cat chases the dog" and generate a parse tree that shows the sentence structure: mathematicaCopy codeS ├── NP │ ├── Det ("the") │ └── N ("cat") └── VP ├── V ("chases") └── NP ├── Det ("the") └── N ("dog")
2. Language Recognition
  • Definition: Language recognition involves determining whether a given string belongs to a particular language.
  • CFG in Language Recognition: CFGs are used to define the syntax of languages. By constructing a parser based on a CFG, you can determine if a string adheres to the grammatical rules of the language defined by the CFG.
  • Example: A CFG can be used to recognize valid email addresses by defining rules for what constitutes a valid email format. For instance:Email → LocalPart "@" Domain LocalPart → Letter (Letter | Digit)* Domain → Subdomain ("." Subdomain)+ Subdomain → Letter (Letter | Digit)* Letter → "a" | "b" | ... | "z" | "A" | ... | "Z" Digit → "0" | "1" | ... | "9" A CFG-based recognizer can then check if an input string like "example@domain.com" is a valid email address according to these rules.
3. Real-World Applications
  • Syntax Highlighting: CFGs are used in text editors and IDEs to provide syntax highlighting by analyzing the structure of code according to the grammar of programming languages.
  • Speech Recognition: CFGs can model the grammar of spoken language to help in transcribing spoken words into written text.
  • Machine Translation: CFGs help in translating sentences from one language to another by understanding and generating grammatically correct structures in the target language.
How CFG Facilitates These Processes
  1. Grammar Definition: CFGs provide a clear and formal way to define the rules of language syntax, making it easier to develop parsers and recognizers.
  2. Parse Trees: CFGs enable the generation of parse trees, which help in understanding and processing the structure of sentences.
  3. Validation: CFGs allow for validation of whether a string conforms to the expected grammatical structure of the language.
Summary
Context-Free Grammar is crucial in NLP for defining syntactic structures and enabling parsing and language recognition. By providing formal rules for language syntax, CFGs facilitate the construction of parsers and recognizers that are used in various real-world applications, including code analysis, email validation, and machine translation.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
7 answers
The Sydney School versus Berkeley...
Relevant answer
Answer
According to my experience, functional grammar becomes a sort of "mindset" and is often applied implicitly, either if you translate or carry out interpretation.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
2 answers
I've seen a lot of work, and even didactic unit productions, that approach language teaching through the lens of translanguaging. These works may deal with teaching grammar, vocabulary, but rarely pronunciation.
Most of the studies I've come across on teaching pronunciation through translanguaging use it only as an oral support. Here, the teacher allows the students to speak in another language or uses other languages to explain the content. We know that translanguaging is much more than that, so my question is how to work on pronunciation in a way that really accesses the students' repertoire for that purpose.
Relevant answer
Answer
Teaching pronunciation through translanguaging involves using students’ multilingual abilities to enhance their pronunciation in the target language. Key approaches include:
  • Utilizing Multiple Languages,
  • Allowing Code-Switching,
  • Making Phonetic Comparisons,
  • Incorporating Cultural Contexts,
  • Engaging in Interactive Activities,
  • Integrating Technology,
These strategies create an inclusive and effective learning environment by respecting and utilizing students’ linguistic diversity.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
1 answer
Dead languages are potentially easier to automate because they are stagnant thus have both permanent vocabulary and grammar.
Relevant answer
Answer
A very interesting question. I would say yes and no.
Yes, because of what you mentioned: vocabulary and grammar.
No, because texts written in dead languages usually refer to old cultures, whereas words and phrases could be quite challenging to translate accurately, so that present day's readers get it. Alone the fact that some text can be a thousand years old makes it hard to understand. Look at some parts of the Bible for example. Even Christian priests and preachers struggle with explaining it, because of the use of words.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
It was Pavlov who showed that language was a consequence of the human cerebral complexity and that it objectified the superiority and specificity of the human brain with respect to animal brains. He perceived language as a special type of conditioned reflexes, a second system of signalization, the first one being that of gnosis and praxis of direct thinking by images. To each image will be substituted through education its verbal denomination. Since they name everything, instead of associating images, human beings can directly associate the corresponding names, a system more efficient in maximizing the abstraction capabilities of the human brain” [Chauchard 1960, p. 122, from Michaud 2019].
In short, Pavlov believed that the process of thinking is possessed by all animals (which runs contrary to the views of Chomsky 1965, 2012), and what happened to humans (between 2 and 0.5 mya, Everett 2016; Kimura 1993) is that they invented language (as they invented writing, the steam engine, and AI) by using the ‘thinking’ process of the neocortex to make associations between sounds and objects in the real world (a little like what Chat-GPT does today, but more efficiently and at an accelerated rate during development). The universal grammar proposed by Chomsky (1965) is merely an acknowledgement that all Homo sapiens are of the same species and therefore have a common capacity to acquire language, which today includes reading and writing both of which have become global requirements for citizenship by way of state-sponsored education from K to 12. Indeed, Pavlov’s view (unlike Chomsky’s) fits better with our understanding of evolution and human inventiveness (Michaud 2019), two notions ignored by Chomsky.
Relevant answer
Answer
Furthermore, regarding a previous comment defending Noam Chomsky, the commentator needs to read more Noam Chomsky to understand that Chomsky is a philosopher and not a biologist. In all my years at MIT, he never attended not even one neuroscience seminar and I very much doubt that he attended seminars on genetics and evolutionary biology.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
Hello everyone,
I hope you are all doing well.
I have already checked plagiarism, related articles’ structures, and grammar, and they seem fine, but good impact factor journals that I have written my article based on their latest published articles are rejecting my article so fast without any obvious reason. Does anyone know what the problem might be?
Relevant answer
Answer
The editor's appraisal of (your) article is most probably the reason, I reckon.
By the way, how many articles have you published so far?
Try to start with Journals in your country.
A special attention should be given also to the cohesiveness of the work, where linguistic elements of , particularly, semantic and style overlap.
Don't get disappointed. Keep going. Revise your work thoroughly ; perhaps you come across some of things you overlooked.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
8 answers
I am wondering which term is more appropriate for use in titles when discussing a group within a larger category: 'among' or 'in'?
For example:
'Prevalence of sleep disorders among children with autism'
'Prevalence of sleep disorders in children with autism'
Could you explain the difference between using 'among' and 'in' in such contexts and advise which option is more suitable for title usage?
Relevant answer
Both "among" and "in" can be appropriate in titles when discussing a group within a larger category, but the choice depends on the specific context and emphasis of the title. Here's a brief overview of the optimal usage for each term:
Among:
Use "among" when you want to emphasize the idea of being part of a larger group or set, but not necessarily confined to it. This term suggests that the group you're referring to is integrated or exists within a broader context.
Example title: "Patterns of Communication Among Adolescents in Urban Schools"
In:
Use "in" when you want to emphasize the idea of being contained or located within a specific category or context. This term suggests a more specific or bounded relationship between the group and the larger category.
Example title: "Factors Affecting Academic Achievement in Students with Disabilities"
In summary, consider the nuances of meaning and emphasis you want to convey in your title when choosing between "among" and "in." If you want to highlight the group's integration within a larger context, use "among." If you want to emphasize their specific location or relationship within a category, use "in."
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
I am trying to research the way to teach English to students in an EFL environment. My major is English education, especially in English grammar. I read some papers about this. (FonF, task-based learning, Inductive method, ...) I would like to know more about grammar instruction in an EFL environment, especially grammar instruction that takes place in the classroom. If you have a paper you would recommend, please let me know. I would prefer something free to read.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello Kokona Hinoke , I appreciate your consideration to share your thoughts with me and I am so honored to help you. Given that educators and researchers have addressed this topic with studies for decade, yet every single teacher has their own unique experience of applying any approach. So I recommend that you reserve yours. Have your own teaching style and be proud of your signature work. This is my personal belief I loved to share with yo.
However, to answer your question I will share you a very enriching paper written by a bunch of valuable scholars and experts in this field. I believe it would help you so much. Thanks for sharing and best wishes for you👌🏽
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
Words get thrown around. Terminology changes. Therefore, syntax is center of linguistics.
Relevant answer
Answer
sentence is the center of linguistics; starting from phonological level, moving to morphological level, then grammatical one(According to De Saussure structuralism)
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
3 answers
I would like to see a paper on grammar instruction that conducts experiments with English language learners (students) and analyzes the results.
I am planning the instruction of "subjunctive mood" for junior high school students or high school students. I am searching for an effective introduction or essential grammatical elements, the way of explanation, and so on. Then, I check whether they can get a better understanding or not.
If there are some interesting research papers, please recommend me!!!
Relevant answer
Answer
Google Scholar can help you better to find the papers you want.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
7 answers
I am trying to write a paper on English education in Japan. I am particularly interested in paying attention to English grammar and wondering if there are effective ways to introduce and explain English grammar to students in a way that will deepen their understanding of the subject. I am looking for papers on grammar essentials and grammar instruction. Please let me know if you have any recommendations.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Kokona,
I can think of the classic "University Grammar of English" by Quirk and Greenbaum. I also suggest the Co-Build Grammar, which is corpus-based, relying on genuine English as used by real people.
I hope this useful.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
10 answers
Is there any extra English grammar checker/proofreader of papers that can be plugged in the microsoftwords that is free?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Basilio,
For the English editing of your manuscript at different levels and with affordable prices, you may contact me by my email address: amirh.montazer@gmail.com
I wish every success with your manuscript.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
explicit or implicit grammar
Relevant answer
Answer
Grammar is the basis of literacy. One has to choose the right methods to teach it, always combining the explanation of rules with practical exercise.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
3 answers
transitivity Analysis can identify the development of the human language according to the analysis done by Halliday and Roqaia Hassen on the work of William Golding's novel " the inheritors"
Relevant answer
Answer
I share Maalej's point of view: systemic linguistics is not known to have shed light onto the human mind. It is cognitive linguistics that did it. Moreover, which version of so-called 'systemic linguistics' are we speaking of ?
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
1 answer
Visit Today: Grammar Lessons, Quiz, PDF, YouTube Videos, worksheets etc.
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
2 answers
If a language’s grammar is unnecessary to study, to learn the tongue, then is linguistics more rationalist or empiricist? How? Why?
Relevant answer
Answer
Grammar is the definite feature of any language; so, I do agree with Khaled Ait El Khouch
Linguistics must not be about learning a language to speak, but it is a scientific method to dissect patterns of a language, e.g. by AI tools.
______
Statistical example:
The number of distinct words in the Hebrew Bible is 8,679, of which 1,480 are hapax legomena, words or expressions that occur only once.
The number of distinct Semitic roots, on which many of these biblical words are based, is roughly 2000.
According to the current version, the Hebrew Bible has approximately 22,864 verses, 306,757 Hebrew words, and 1,202,972 Hebrew letters.Out of these, there are 5,845 verses, 79,980 Hebrew words, and 304,805 letters in five Torah pentagrams.Various statistics of the Hebrew Bible have been published in Jewish literature over the generations.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
1 answer
¿En Español, cuàndo los numerales se transforman en ordinales por añadir “ismo” al fin? ¿Cómo? ¿Por Què?
Relevant answer
Answer
Alexander Ohnemus, no entiendo tu pregunta. ¿Podrías darme algún ejemplo de numerales transformados en ordinales por añadir “ismo”?
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
I am wondering this because I have seen two articles using different tenses despite being published in one publisher. This question is nothing important but once the reviewer told me it's better to be written using past-tense grammar stuffs.
Relevant answer
Answer
When I have written about my research, it has been in the past-tense because I was looking back at what I had done.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
2 answers
Atypical Chinese nominal uses(nouns are typically used as subject and object) such as nominal predicate sentences are commonly used in daily life.Can anyone suggest some other usages and theire analytical framework?
Relevant answer
Answer
Atena Attaran thanks for your kindness.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
Grammar and linguistics are both important fields within the study of language, but they differ in their focus and scope. Here are some key differences and similarities between grammar and linguistics:
1. Definition and Focus:
- Grammar: Grammar refers specifically to the set of rules and structures that govern how words are organized and combined to form sentences in a particular language. It focuses on the study of syntax, morphology, and semantics, dealing with the structural and functional aspects of language.
- Linguistics: Linguistics is a broader field that encompasses the scientific study of language, covering various sub-disciplines such as phonetics, phonology, morphology, syntax, semantics, and pragmatics. It explores language from a more comprehensive and theoretical perspective, aiming to understand how language is acquired, used, and processed.
2. Scope:
- Grammar: Grammar is more concerned with the description and analysis of specific languages, looking closely at grammatical structures and rules within those languages. It aims to provide a systematic account of how language works in a given context.
- Linguistics: Linguistics, on the other hand, takes a broader perspective, seeking universal principles and patterns that underpin all languages. It investigates the similarities and differences across languages, aiming to uncover the fundamental properties of human language as a cognitive system.
3. Application:
- Grammar: Grammar is essential for the practical application of language. It provides guidelines and rules that enable effective communication and understanding within a specific language. It is often used in language teaching, writing, editing, and translation.
- Linguistics: Linguistics informs our understanding of language structures, acquisition, and usage. It contributes to fields such as psycholinguistics, sociolinguistics, computational linguistics, and forensic linguistics. It helps develop language technologies, analyze language disorders, and unravel the intricacies of human communication.
Despite their differences, grammar and linguistics share some similarities:
- Both study language and its structures, seeking to describe and understand how language functions.
- Both employ formal analysis and observation to uncover patterns and rules within language systems.
- Both contribute to the effective use and comprehension of language, enabling communication in various contexts.
- Both contribute to our knowledge of human cognition, perception, and cultural expression through language.
However, grammar focuses on the specific rules and structures of individual languages, while linguistics is a broader, interdisciplinary study of language as a whole. While grammar provides practical guidelines for language usage, linguistics delves into theoretical aspects and seeks universal patterns across languages.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello, thank you for sharing your knowledge!
I would also add the fact that Linguistics (applied linguistics) also focuses of Discourse Analysis (or Conversation Analysis) and the related grammar of spoken language. Hence, there are basically two grammars: the one of written discourse and the one of spoken interaction...
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
15 answers
CASE GRAMMAR: A MERGER OF SYNTAX AND SEMANTICS
Charles Fillmore’s Deep Cases are determined not by syntax, but rather by semantics. Rather than having Subject, Indirect Object and Direct Object, Fillmore uses such terms as Agent, Experiencer, Instrument, and Patient.
The semantic features often occur in contrasting pairs, like Animate vs. Inanimate, and Cause vs. Effect. Thus:
Agent: Animate Cause
Experiencer: Animate Effect
Instrument: Inanimate Cause
Patient: Inanimate Effect
In an Active Sentence the most active Deep Case is eligible to become the Subject and the least active is eligible to become the Direct Object.
In a Passive Sentence the least active Deep Case is eligible to become the Subject and the most active case becomes an Object of the Preposition “by.”
Normally, the most active deep case is selected as the subject of the sentence:
The Actor if there is one
If not, the Instrument if there is one
If there is no Actor or Instrument, the Object becomes eligible. Therefore we have the following:
The boy opened the door with the key.
The key opened the door.
The door opened.
Is Case Grammar an effective method for showing the interrelationships between syntax and semantics?
Relevant answer
Answer
Anton: Excellent response. It's OK if the levels remain separated as long as there is eventually an interface between the two. This is the tricky part.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
10 answers
Dear all
Our new article "About Probiotics" is ready for final submission after two peer reviews. However, the reviewer and editor recommend minor grammatical corrections in MS either by a native English speaker colleague or to avail paid online grammar editing service. We do not have sufficient funds to bear the cost, nor do a native speaker, what should we do in this case, the MS has already taken more than 6 months, please suggest.
Thanks a lot for your attention. Have a great day.
Relevant answer
Answer
I suggest you to read thoroughly and do it by yourself, or you can ask for help to one whom u have known involve in scientific writing (not necessarily a NES). In my case i did myself when the editor ask for the same..
You can drop me a mail if u need further help at nkrdas2@gmail.com
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
the name of the person mentioned as the author in the article
If you are interested, send an email to the following address.
Relevant answer
Answer
I can help.Don't hesitate to contact me via email : prosper.languages@kp.ac.rw or murwaprosper17@gmail.com or prosper.educ.produce@gmail.com
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
3 answers
Hi everyone,
I'm wondering if there are tests to measure the learners' explicit productive knowledge in the field of SLA, focusing on the grammatical aspect. I'm aware of some tests to measure learners' receptive explicit/implicit knowledge (e.g., timed/untimed GJT) and productive explicit knowledge (e.g., Cloze test), but I couldn't find ones for explicit productive knowledge.
Thank you in advance !
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Darrel Ocampo and Andreas Wirag , thank you for your comments. I imagine learners who possess productive explicit knowledge are able to both use a certain grammar correctly and explain why that grammar use is correct/incorrect in certain sentences. On the other hand, those who possess productive implicit knowledge, for instance, would be able to use a certain grammar correctly, but unable to explicitly articulate/explain why. One simple example would be the use of article in English: some people can correctly use a/an/the according to the context and sentence and further explain why, while others can also use that, but can't explain why. I hope my wording is understandable.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
8 answers
as i have joined a progressive school in teaching practices.
Relevant answer
Answer
The basis lies in reading, comparing and building habits for reading and practicing. When combined with practice, we get extremely strong results through conversation.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
The most frequent interpretation of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis has been that of a synchronic working. This interpretation focuses on how users of different grammars come to a different evaluation of the world at the same time.
In contrast, a diachronic study would research how the same people come to a different evaluation of the world at different moments in time, in order to investigate how their grammar has evolved. This approach would involve studying language change over time and its impact on thought and perception.
Do you know of any research that has been conducted on this topic? My interest is in applying Sapir/Whorf to the role of communication in crisis resolution, starting from the hypothesis that the solution to the crisis must have found its way into linguistic expressions of the people who originally experienced the problem.
So far, I have been unable to find such research. Any help will be greatly appreciated!
#sapir/whorf #linguisticrelativity #diachronical #crisisresolution #CCO
Relevant answer
Answer
About your intriguing large language model idea: I guess we could easily identify differences in syntax, morphology and word choice of the language at different time points. But I don't quite see how we could examine the speakers' perceptions using a large language model. In Psycholinguistics, this is usually done in experiments with different L1 native speakers, for instance via their reaction time to the same stimulus. But this is of course impossible in diachronic research, since "older" L1 speakers are no longer ... available.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
Hello everyone!
I'm not a native speaker of English and Chat GPT (besides Grammarly) has been helping me immensely in correcting and improving my texts.
However, a professor told me that many universities and journals are reproving the use of Chat GPT. Considering many people do not have enough money to hire a person to correct texts and check grammar, why would be outrageous to use chat GPT?
What is your opinion?
---------------------------------
(In the text above I wrote using my knowledge. Now I'm gonna jot down the same text, but improved by Chat GPT:)
Hello everyone! I am not a native English speaker, and I must say that Chat GPT, along with Grammarly, has been tremendously helpful in correcting and enhancing my texts. However, I recently heard from a professor that many universities and journals are disapproving the use of Chat GPT. I find this rather puzzling because not everyone has the financial means to hire a person for text correction and grammar checks. In light of this, I wonder why it would be deemed inappropriate to use Chat GPT. I am curious to know your opinion on this matter.
Relevant answer
Answer
Chat GPT can be an excellent tool for people who are not native speakers of English and need help with their grammar and syntax. It can help correct grammar mistakes, suggest better word choices, and even improve the overall readability of the text. However, some universities and journals may disapprove of using Chat GPT because they want to ensure that the paper is entirely original and not "over-edited" by an AI language model. In some cases, using such tools may also lead to plagiarism if it's not used appropriately. That said, if you're using Chat GPT for learning purposes and not for generating original content, then it can be a useful tool. It's essential to understand when and how to use such tools appropriately to avoid any ethical issues.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
1 answer
To what extent could this study ascertain the current assertions about Philippine English grammar and lexical features as a unique variety of English and acceptable in the classroom context?
Relevant answer
Answer
This research title focuses on evaluating the acceptability level of Philippine English grammar and lexical features among selected public high school English teachers. The study aims to identify the current assertions regarding the Philippine English grammar and lexical features as a unique variety of English in the classroom context.
The study could potentially shed light on the current teaching practices in Philippine English classrooms, as well as the attitudes and beliefs of teachers towards the use of Philippine English grammar and lexical features in the classroom. Further, the study could also provide insights into the challenges faced by teachers in teaching Philippine English and the possible solutions to address these challenges.
To conduct this study, a survey can be administered among selected public high school English teachers in the Philippines. The survey can consist of questions that evaluate teachers' knowledge, attitudes and beliefs towards Philippine English grammar and lexical features. Additionally, the survey can also gather information on the teaching practices of teachers in relation to Philippine English, and any challenges they may face in the classroom.
This study could provide useful insights into the current state of Philippine English in the classroom and help guide future teaching practices and policies related to the use of Philippine English in education.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
8 answers
HUMOR AS IT RELATES TO RHETORIC, COMPOSITION, AND DISCOURSE
The classical rhetoricians of ancient Greece and Rome were concerned with the “five canons of rhetoric: 1. Invention, 2. Arrangement, 3. Style, 4. Memory, and 5. Delivery. Aristotle provided insights into invention, arrangement and style. But Aristotle’s most important contribution was in the direction of argument and persuasion. He said that an argument is usually developed from one of the following points of view: ETHOS: (Speaker Credibility), PATHOS: (Audience Appreciation), and LOGOS: (Logical Development).
Walker Gibson later wrote a book entitled, Tough, Sweet, and Stuffy in which he modernized Aristotle’s Ethos, Pathos, and Logos. For Gibson, Tough language was the language of the novel (told from the point of view of the author, or a character). Sweet language was the language of the advertisement (AROMA: Advertising Rhetoric of Madison Avenue, which is written for particular audiences). And Stuffy language is the language of academe (standard English).
But why is it that ambiguity is bad, while double entendre is good;
cliches are bad while idiomatic expressions can be good;
confusion is bad, but paradox is good;
contradiction and incongruity are bad while oxymorons are good;
faulty grammar is bad, but anacoluthon (intentional faulty grammar) is good;
faulty parallelism is bad, but zeugma (intentional faulty parallelism) is good; repetitiveness is bad, but parody and caricature are good;
exaggeration is bad but hyperbole is good;
a spelling is bad, but cacography (intentionally bad writing) is good;
understatement is bad, but litotes is good.
For each of these pairs, the first example is an “error,” while the second is a “rhetorical device.”
How is it possible to distinguish between an “error” and a “rhetorical device” in student writing?
Relevant answer
Answer
Michael: I agree. Well stated.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
1 answer
The only thing I know is some grammar mistakes like 'ain't' or the wrong grammatical order, which is normal in Mark Twain's fictions, using as a way to highlight the educational status of African Americans.
With the time goes by, I am thinking that maybe the author of Caroline, or Change uses it as a stereotype to express the particularity of the ethnic group. If it does work, there is must be some 'good' Characteristic to convey the African culture. Therefore, I wish people who have watched it before can give me some inspirations, thanks a lot!!!
Relevant answer
Answer
The use of contractions such as "ain't" is not limited to English in the United States or to African-Americans. It was and is still used in London Cockney English. So this contraction (and others) were and still in use in British English dialects prior to the language migration and adoption in the United States. There are some other modern grammatical changes that have occurred in US English such as "I wrote her" which would be considered erroneous in the UK and where the correct sentence would be "I wrote to her". Again this change and its use is not limited to ethnicity or education.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
3 answers
We have been trying Khan Academy and NoRedInk but apparently, this doesn't yield many results because students don't apply the skills learnt independently and transfer them into Academic Writing. What strategies would you propose?
Relevant answer
Answer
Teaching grammar, punctuation, and sentence structure, and identifying errors independently online requires thoughtful instructional strategies that engage college students and promote active learning. Here are some effective strategies to consider:
  1. Clear Learning Objectives: Clearly define the learning objectives and outcomes for each lesson or module. This provides students with a clear understanding of what they will achieve and helps keep them focused.
  2. Interactive Online Modules: Develop interactive online modules or lessons that present grammar and punctuation rules, sentence structure, and common errors. Use multimedia elements such as videos, infographics, and interactive exercises to enhance student engagement.
  3. Practice Exercises: Provide ample opportunities for students to practice their grammar and punctuation skills through exercises and quizzes. Include both formative assessments for immediate feedback and summative assessments to measure progress.
  4. Collaborative Activities: Incorporate collaborative activities into the online learning environment, such as discussion forums or virtual group projects. These activities encourage peer-to-peer interaction, allowing students to learn from each other and reinforce their understanding of grammar and sentence structure.
  5. Feedback and Corrections: Provide timely and constructive feedback on students' written assignments, pointing out specific grammar or punctuation errors and suggesting improvements. Encourage students to revise their work based on feedback, promoting continuous learning and improvement.
  6. Self-Assessment Tools: Offer self-assessment tools or checklists that students can use to review their own writing for grammar, punctuation, and sentence structure errors. This empowers students to take ownership of their learning and identify areas for improvement.
  7. Virtual Writing Center Support: Establish virtual writing support services where students can seek guidance from writing tutors or language instructors. These resources can provide personalized feedback, address specific questions, and offer additional grammar resources.
  8. Real-World Application: Connect grammar and punctuation skills to real-world contexts to emphasize their practical value. Provide examples of how proper grammar and sentence structure enhance written communication in professional settings or academic disciplines.
  9. Scaffolding Instruction: Start with basic grammar concepts and gradually progress to more complex sentence structures and errors. Provide clear explanations, examples, and additional resources at each level to support student's understanding and skill development.
  10. Continuous Assessment and Progress Tracking: Implement a system to track student's progress throughout the course. Regularly assess their grammar and punctuation skills and provide opportunities for them to demonstrate their understanding of sentence structure and error correction.
Remember, creating an engaging and supportive online learning environment is crucial for effective teaching. Offer opportunities for students to seek clarification, engage in discussions, and collaborate with their peers.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
I am working on non-finites forms in Turkish. Your suggestions will help me a lot
Relevant answer
Answer
you should go through these names and their works., RONALD LANGACKER, GEORGE LAKOFF. and this one is a school of psychology,,,, GESTALT PSYCHOLOGY. best luck.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
Overtime, there have been many methods , approaches and strategies being used and adopted in the teaching and learning of English Language ranging from grammar method, audio-visual, communicative competence teaching , etc.
However, most of these approaches, strategies and methods are usually being referred to as being traditional or something, significantly at the advent of technological advancements and information-driven economy.
There have been many new methods, approaches and strategies infused with technology principles and practicals in the 21st century.
Kindly tell me the ones that you know or have applied before or have read about before.
Thank you for you for your time and help.
Relevant answer
Answer
I have applied Mobile-Assisted Language Learning (MALL): MALL leverages mobile devices and apps for language learning anytime and anywhere. Mobile technology provides access to language learning apps, online dictionaries, language exchange platforms, and multimedia resources. MALL harnesses the power of mobile technology to provide learners with accessible, personalized, interactive, and continuous language learning opportunities, making it an impactful method for language acquisition and skill development.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
1 answer
I am currently drafting a paper on andative/ventive (also dislocative/cislocative) verbal morphosyntax and I would appreciate suggestions on grammars or specific studies that deal with this topic in any language. I am already familiar only with what has been said about andative/ventive in Sumerian and in the languages of the Caucasus so any hint will be more than appreciated. Thank you!
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Elia! The distinction you mention is pervasive in several languages of the Americas, off the top of my head I can think of Southern Uto-Aztecan (several Nahuatl varieties and Cora). SIL's (open-access) 'Studies in Uto-Aztecan Grammar' should get you off to a good start. Northern Iroquoian (Mohawk and Oneida) are also excellent examples. Feel free to contact me for further details, I can check my sources for you.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
How is the evaluation process at the level of secondary school in your country? Do educators divide the lesson into speaking, writing, listening, grammar sections?
How about your books ? Do they include speaking, writing, listening and grammar exercise parts?
Do educators use English or native language to instruct their students?
Do you have smart boards with internet access and use interactive materials and activities from the board?
How do you evaluate your students?( How is the design of your exams?)
Relevant answer
Answer
In the Philippines, we teachers are so serious about the teaching of English in the classroom. We do look into the 4 macro skills of communication: Listening, Speaking, reading and writing. We know very well, that we partner listening and speaking (for oral communication), and we tandem reading and writing (for written communication). Thus when we teach Listening, we cannot get read of speaking. In the same manner, when we teach Reading, we also touch on writing. Assessment of success in the teaching of these skills is very important, because it is our only to know the status of our students in their English proficiency. Our Filipino students are doing well in the use of the English language.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
7 answers
As in French le/la, in German der/die/das & other languages, thera are genders for words & so articles in some languages. Grammaticaly gender for words are complete redundancy !? Governments have to cancel them offically as soon as possible so that people can learn those languages easily also. One of the reason English almost became universal language is due to being genderless for words !
"It's an inheritance from our distant past. Researchers believe that Proto-Indo-European had two genders: animate and inanimate. It can also, in some cases, make it easier to use pronouns clearly when you're talking about multiple objects."
As Mark Twain once wrote in reference to German:
A person’s mouth, neck, bosom, elbows, fingers, nails, feet, and body are of the male sex, and his head is male or neuter according to the word selected to signify it, and not according to the sex of the individual who wears it! A person’s nose, lips, shoulders, breast, hands, and toes are of the female sex; and his hair, ears, eyes, chin, legs, knees, heart, and conscience haven’t any sex at all…
Relevant answer
Answer
Each language has its own rules and structure. Governments have nothing to do with this. It is language specific. You can not change it in a fortnight.
Regards
Mustapha Boughoulid
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
19 answers
The Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, also known as (the) linguistic relativity (hypothesis), more or less states (in one of the most specific descriptions by Whorf): users of markedly different grammars are directed by their grammars towards a different evaluation of reality ('Language, Thought and Reality' (selected writings by Benjamin Lee Whorf), 1940: 221).
To my knowledge, research into this hypothesis has to date not touched on the paradox it introduces (and please let me know when I'm mistaken). How is this hypothesis paradoxical?
When someone denies the hypothesis, it means that he or she has arrived at a different evaluation of reality than Whorf, as witnessed by his articulation of the hypothesis. Understanding that Whorf not necessarily meant 'actual wording' by 'grammar' (implying that it's not because those people don't understand the sentence that they reject it), upon asking for clarification of their rejection, they will rationalize their opinion as to why they consider the hypothesis to be wrong. In other words: although in all likeliness expressed in English, their rationalization will reflect an underlying logic different to the one they will say to have read in the hypothesis they rejected. That underlying logic (expressed in a configuration of arguments) will therefore indicate a different 'grammar' which orients the intention of the words they use.
The paradox is that, when people reject linguistic relativity, they can only attempt to make their rejection understood by creating a different grammar intended to persuade their opponents to share their evaluation of reality, not Whorf's. Two grammars, two evaluations of reality (hypothesis is wrong, hypothesis is right). They will, at that point, have paradoxically proven the hypothesis.
Or am I wrong?
Relevant answer
Answer
Cees Jan Mol states that "when people reject linguistic relativity, they can only attempt to make their rejection understood by creating a different grammar." On the other, Hand Alireza Khormaee is right when he writes: "Sapir-Whorf hypothesis has to do with language not logic [...] , and we are dealing with the normal interpretation of language as a means of thought and communication." If we take 'grammar' in its usual meaning (see also Spring's reply), it is undeniable that there exist 'markedly different grammars' in Whorf's wording. Neurosciences and large typological studies have nowadays raised strong doubts on the ALEC axiom (All Languages are Equally Complex), already discussed by Bickerton in his 'linguistic bioprogram'. Moreover, studies on Second Language Acquisition (SLA) have proved that some languages are more difficult to learn than others that show a more complex grammar. Evidence seems to speak in favour of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
3 answers
The most venerable professors and research scholars
Your critical comments, valuable opinions, scientific facts and thoughts, and supportive discussion on how can structural grammar and IC analysis be justified in the recent pedagogical and enhancement trends in EIP for EFL adult learners.
I shall be thankful sincerely for your kind participation.
Best,
Dr. Meenakshi
Relevant answer
Answer
In my opinion, it will depend on to what extent the language learner would like to view how the language works. I would say that if we opt to view language from the perspective of medium/tool in conveying messages or communication; incorporating structural grammar and IC analysis are beneficial to use the grammar correctly within the exact communication function to deliver the correct message by the encoder to the decoder.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
I am working on Tamil grammar rule based sentiment for Tweets (Tamil Movies). How many grammar rules are there in Tamil and how to use those grammar rules for Tweets for categorization.
Relevant answer
Answer
தமிழ் மொழியில் 100க்கும் மேற்பட்ட இலக்கண விதிகள் இருப்பதாக கூறப்படுகிறது. ட்வீட் வகைப்படுத்தலுக்கு அவற்றைப் பயன்படுத்த, ட்வீட்டின் சூழலில் ஒவ்வொரு விதியையும் எவ்வாறு பயன்படுத்துவது என்பதை நீங்கள் புரிந்து கொள்ள வேண்டும். தமிழ் இலக்கணத்தின் அடிப்படைகள் மற்றும் ட்வீட்களுக்கு அது எவ்வாறு பொருந்தும் என்பதைப் புரிந்துகொள்ள உதவும் பயிற்சிகளை ஆன்லைனில் நீங்கள் காணலாம்.
Tamil grammar and how to use it for tweet categorization: Tamilcube, Etsyakalam, and Tamil Language and Culture
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
9 answers
Good morning, dear Researchers, I am looking for a colleague to work on a research project about “Advanced Grammar Checkers”, please let if you would like to be part of the team.
Sincerely,
Angel Tellez Tula
Relevant answer
Answer
On peut vous aider mais on a besoin de plus d’explication
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
3 answers
Good morning, dear Researchers, I am looking for a colleague to work on a research project about “Advanced Grammar Checkers”, please let if you would like to be part of the team.
Sincerely,
Angel Tellez Tula
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello Angel. I would like to know what the project is about. Kind regards
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
I am currently working on a project for which I would like to know people's experiences of learning Croatian as a second language.
The project consists of writing a handbook of Croatian grammar designed to make the process of learning the language easier for foreigners, focusing on the areas that they struggle with the most.
I got the idea for this project both from my own experience learning the language, and from this paper, which remarks that an appropiate Croatian grammar handbook for foreign learners has not yet been published.
CROATIAN WITH OR WITHOUT GRAMMAR
Vesna Požgaj Hadži; Maša Plešković; Tomislav Ćužić; Faculty of Philosophy, University of Ljubljana, Slovenija
Relevant answer
Answer
My Serbian wife and I wrote such a course to learn Serbo-croation from Dutch (see: www.astrovdm.com/srpski.htm).
The grammatical cases were certainly the most difficult thing to learn! But also the sometimes illogical word formation like "duhovnik" = spiritual person, "govornik" = speaking person, "grešnik" = sinning person, but "hodnik" is not at all a walking person. Very confusing!
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
1. The Writing Assignment Calculator by Concordia University. Originally developed by the University of Minnesota. http://cdweb.concordia.ca This helps to break down your assignment writing. Just put in your assignment due date and you will get how to go about writing your assignment in eight steps. For sample images check here: https://lnkd.in/ezEdYiNQ Note: They also have -- “Dissertation Calculator”. Check here: https://lnkd.in/eaUmfGxy 2. Trinka.ai: This is an online grammar checker and language correction AI tool for academic and technical writing. https://lnkd.in/e_hYcmP6 3. Ref-N-Write: Referencing Tools, Paraphrasing Tools, Academic Phrasebank, Plagiarism Checker https://lnkd.in/eNAau3qV 4. Authorea: Upload or create your research work, disseminate your research rapidly, and get published in a refereed journal https://www.authorea.com 5. Hemingway app: I am sure you will know about it. The “Hemingway app” makes your writing bold and clear. https://hemingwayapp.com 6. Spinbot: Intelligent, Free Text Rewriting Tool https://spinbot.com 7. Online correction: this is a tool designed to find spelling, as well as basic grammar and stylistic mistakes, in English texts. https://lnkd.in/eapTTZEp 8. Power Thesaurus: is a fast, convenient and comprehensive online thesaurus https://lnkd.in/emm7uGQQ For some more academic tools. You can read my other post here: https://lnkd.in/eCjduv8J Thank you for reading! #writingtools #sciencecommunication #researcher
Relevant answer
Overleaf and LaTEX is the best for changing paper formats.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
2 answers
Hi all,
I'm looking for research that has assessed the efficacy - or lack thereof - of Murphy's Grammar in Use series.
Can anyone help?
Thanks in advance.
Eloy
Relevant answer
Answer
Eloy Romero Muñoz, I share with you the following open access articles for your consideration.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
1 answer
  1. .......................
Relevant answer
Answer
Maeona Canam Treatments are classified into two types: descriptive statistics, which describe your data in the form of a graph or summary statistic, and inferential statistics, which make predictions and test hypotheses based on your data.
Statistical treatment of data is the use of a statistical approach to a data set in order to change it from a collection of meaningless numbers into meaningful output.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
37 answers
The students from the least developed country can not afford the expensive plagiarism checker tool. Further, its almost impossible to finance the paid version. Could you suggest/find the best plagiarism checker free software or webpage for student?.
Relevant answer
Dear respected colleagues,
Related to this valuable discussion thread of Prof. Nabaraj Gautam, please let me point to another critical issue related to plagiarism software-detectors.
My friend was accused of plagiarism. Why?
After about five months, his promotion process to associate professor was rejected because of plagiarism. When he checked the promotion report, he found that one of his papers was accused of plagiarism and with a 100% percentage. The reason is that his manuscript was checked by his co-author using one of these checkers. It took him several months time of following up to solve the problem and removing the manuscript from their database. After that long period, he re-applies the promotion order for the second time.
Therefore, plagiarism software may retain a copy of the manuscript in its database. To state the truth, this is depending upon the settings and type of account subscription.
So, you may face a similar situation when you submit your manuscript after plagiarism checking to a journal. It may be rejected instantly because it would show up 100% similarity index.
To solve the problem, it may take several months time of following up and removing the manuscript from their database.
If there were accusations of plagiarism, it is not well for your reputation, in any meaning.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
7 answers
A free site where you can check plagiarism and grammar.
Relevant answer
In my opinion, most of the free-software-checkers for plagiarism don't work effectively. Since there is no guarantee that the original content of your manuscript might not be copied and sold to others before it is published by you, I discourage using any free-software-checkers for plagiarism; some of them are betrayers.
  • WARNING 1: There are a massive number of betrayers!
  • WARNING 2: Plagiarism is a sin! If it is, severe action may be taken and/or legal notice may be given.
Unfortunately, you have to pay for the sake of getting good results. In any way, it is not well for your reputation if there were accusations of plagiarism.
In my personal opinion, free anti-plagiarism software is not safe.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
3 answers
How can I find a topic that links grammar to literature or links grammar to language analysis, such as
1,Ellipsis in Literature "select text "
2,The Pragmatic Functions of Modal Verbs in Dostoevsky's " The Dream of a Ridiculous Man"
To do a graduation research ,as a student in the English Department.
Can you suggest topics for me .
with many thanks🌼
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi there! Stylistics uses linguistics to explore literary texts. For example, is the language used in a specific text / corpus what you'd expect or are there aspects that make you think the author was (unwittinglly) conveying some kind of underlying message?
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
13 answers
I have been thinking about hiring a writing coach to help me get better at planning and scheduling my writing activities, separate from actual conduct of the research. Not for grammar/language purposes, but for actually getting the writing done productively! Has anyone done this? Any recommendations for online coaches?
Relevant answer
Answer
Lilianne Dominguez Céspedes Yo te aconsejaría buscar un artículo scientifico que te gusta y luego intentar de "copiar" la estructura con tus proprios datos. Puedes empezar con el abstract / resumen por ejemplo. Si lo miras bien, abstract lleva muchos "chunks" que son frases estereotipadas como "this article investigates..." o "The purpose of this research is to...".
Te aconsejo consultar este enlace: https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/purdue_owl.html
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
1 answer
Hello dear reader!
Have you any idea about any good english books/publishers for writing, grammar, language etc. for ages 11-15 that's famous around the globe(uk, us, germany: you get the gist). Secondly, the same request for science books. Any particulars based on conceptual understanding? Which is common within schools around the world?
Thank you in advance,
Best,
Birajita
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello, I suggest using the Hewings grammar/vocabulary series, FCE/CAE practice books, and as a source of reference, Longman Grammar of Spoken and Written English.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
13 answers
There are different views on teaching grammar to be or not to be. Does teaching grammar need to be taught explicitly for adult L2 learners? If you think so, how ?
Relevant answer
Answer
Grammar is the backbone of any language, therefore it essential
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
I have been searching for a platform to run a timed forced grammar judgment test. I have found many that allowed timing for the entire test, however, I have yet to find one that allows timing for the individual questions.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you again to those who responded to my question.
I actually found a platform that works near perfectly. It is called Riddle. They offer a 14-day free trial with no credit card required. It is worth checking out.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
20 answers
Since the 1800s, linguistics have been using Reed-Kellogg diagramming to teach about English syntax, but in 1916 we have Ferdinand de Saussure’s “Langue vs. Parole.” In 1954 we have John Gumpers’s and Dell Hymes’s S.P.E.A.K.I.N.G. model for language variation. In 1955 we have George Trager’s and Henry Lee Smith’s –eme and allo- forms (phoneme, allophone, etc.). In 1957 we have Noam Chomsky’s Generative Transformational grammar. In 1959, we have Kenneth Pike’s “Particle, Wave, and Field” grammar. In 1966 we have Charles Fillmore’s Deep Cases. In 1969 we have John Searle’s and J. L. Austin’s “Speech Acts” grammar. In 1980 we have George Lakoff’s “Metaphors we Live By.” In 1989 we have H. P. Grice’s “Conversational Implicatures.” In 2000 we have George Lakoff’s Embodiment. In 2000 we have Victor Raskin’s Script-Model Grammar, Salvatore Attardo’s adaption of Script-Model Grammar to long and sophisticated discourses, and Christian Hempleman’s adaption of Script-Model Grammar to Artificial Intelligence. So what is next in the continuing history of linguistics?
Relevant answer
Answer
Michal Mistecky: Excellent link. Thanks.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
2 answers
I'm looking for an instrument to measure teachers' cognitions about grammar teaching. Any suggestions?
Relevant answer
Answer
You may want to have a look at a questionnaire we (Van Rijt, Wijnands & Coppen) used in 2019, for a study published in L1-Educational Studies in Language and Literature: . Hope you will find it helpful. Good luck!
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
8 answers
Can anyone recommend a journal for submission? I am particularly looking for journals that (i) accept pieces in the 800 to 2000 word range, and (ii) that have no publication fees.
Relevant answer
Answer
Karl Pfeifer you can try Wiley or the International Journal of Linguistics, Literature, and Translation (IJLLT)
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
19 answers
What are the best scientific proof editing and proof reading services?
I'd came across few articles with very limited scope and extremely humble results, but somehow they managed to publish the work in really good journals (I don't want to put any reference here).
The thing I observed from those articles is their presentation. The data presentation and writing was impressive and the flow of those articles was touching maximum limits. And i think this was the only reason that the article got published.
I'm not native English person, and often have some serious grammatical errors, along with content flow problem. Is there any proof editing service (not proof reading only that check grammar) that may suggest the content flow, sentence structure and other things that make the findings more colorful?
I tested with one service that roughly edit the article but most of the article remain like that, giving me the impression that my language was already good.
Relevant answer
Answer
You might find the following articles helpful:
Proofreading and Proof-Editing:
Academic Editing vs. Academic Proofreading:
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
In linguistics, literary criticism, and in many other fields of study, the FORM vs. FUNCTION dichotomy is interesting, and fundamental. For instance, in linguistics, this distinction opposes the British and Russian SYSTEMIC-FUNCTIONAL grammars (Jakobson, Halliday, Quirk, Greenbaum, Leech, Crystal, etc.) to the American STRUCTURAL-TRANSFORMATIONAL grammars (Chomsky, Gleason, Fries, Pike, Bloomfield, etc.). There has also been a strong semiotic tradition in linguistics (Saussure, Barthes, Derrida, Eco, Sebeok, etc.) that has claimed that language is ENTIRELY systemic, rather than functional. And recently, I have claimed that language is fundamentally temporal/rhythmic, with rhythmic qualities being the foundational of form. This series of related, but distinct grammars, it seems, gets very close to the essence of things, philosophically. Ontologically, things can be rhythmic, and/or formal, and/or functional, and/or systemic, with the most pervasive things, such as language, being ALL of the above, simultaneously. So my question, I guess, is this: What is going on here? What is the best way to deal with this issue? For instance, the great Quirk et al. COMPREHENSIVE GRAMMAR OF ENGLISH, alternates chapters, first one on form and then one on function. It also has a large section, later on, that addresses discourse, and so things that are more systematic than formal and functional. It also has an appendix that addresses things like prosody and rhythm, and so flushes out all four of these concerns, but in a kind of disjunct, chaotic, if not incoherent, way. In the end, I think, it seems evident that, on these issues, the authors know not what. But they are trying. Oh well.
Relevant answer
Answer
interested
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
24 answers
Hi everyone
Language editing is a major concern for authors who do not have English as their primary language. Problems with grammar, language, and syntax can result in the rejection of manuscripts from international biomedical Journals. The editors and experts often recommend professional editing which can sometimes cost hundreds of dollars. This is not feasible nor affordable for the majority of authors and researchers based in developing countries who do not have sufficient funds or institutional support.
Many online language editing softwares are now available but the better ones have limited functionality for the free version for example Grammarly.
Please share your experience of using online language editing software with their and strengths and shortcomings. I have been Trinka for 4 months now with excellent results and would highly recommend it
It is the world’s first grammar and language enhancement tool is custom-built for academic & technical writing. Its standout features are that it works with the author and goes beyond the grammar and spellcheck to ensure holistic language enhancement.
If you have not tried it yet, Sign up for a free account from this link
Share your experience of other software too
Relevant answer
Answer
You can use grammarly
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
8 answers
Whether overt or covert method of teaching English grammar is more effective and why?
Relevant answer
Answer
Amalgamation of both will be more effective.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
22 answers
Grammar has been a debatable issue in language acquisition. However, what are actually the specific reasons why some teachers' perceptions debunk the use and teaching grammar to students?
Relevant answer
Answer
There are always circumstances that accompany the teaching process of both L1 and L2. Since learning is a complex cognitive process, many variables affect and associate the whole process of learning. You may wish to consult the literature available on language learning and teaching.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
9 answers
I am looking for software that can suggest grammar and plagiarism related issues offline. The checking should be based on paragraph.
If any scholar have information on link it will be of great help for my upcoming research work.
Thank You in advance for your support.
Relevant answer
Since there is no guarantee that the original content of your manuscript might not be copied and sold to others before it is published by you, I discourage using any free-software-checkers for plagiarism; some of them are betrayers. On the other hand, I don't believe that there is a completely free one!
In any way, if you are insisting to use anti-plagiarism software, offline checker programs are better than online ones. If I were you, I prefer to use my own words instead.
Anyhow, you can see the following site:
Moreover, there is a related discussion thread on this portal:
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
البحث عن استخدمات حرف اتش فى النحو اللغة السوحيلية
Relevant answer
Thanks a lot! You are right. But in other areas it is
/jɔ:k/
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
8 answers
Good morning!
I am looking for references in connection with the topic given in the title section. I would like to carry out a research regarding the usage of grammar among ESL students in videogames' multiplayer mode. Can you help me?
Thank you in advance.
Bence Dukavits
Relevant answer
Answer
The following systemic review of studies conducted in L2 gamification might help. Check it out.
Poole, F. J., & Clarke-Midura, J. (2020). A systematic review of digital games in second language learning studies. International Journal of Game-Based Learning, 10(3), 1-15. https://doi.org/10.4018/ijgbl.2020070101
Cheers,
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
Hello everyone,
It was my first experience for a research. I plan to explore the differences in grammar teaching in the two kinds of books: one is task-based and one is currently used in a target secondary/elementary school. But I still cannot find the appropriate TB materials for me to base the comparison on. I saw the series ATLAS 1-4 of Nunan (1995) is claimed to be task-based, but I couldn’t find ways to get it in pdf. Could you kindly give me some suggestions on my problem?
Manh thanks!
Relevant answer
Answer
In my experience, TBL is difficult to organise into a course/syllabus, but Cutting Edge claims to use a (weak) task-based approach.
Language Leader includes task-based 'Scenarios'
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
have used shape grammar methodolgy in analyzing facades of identified buildings in historical texture of Tehran city in Iran. And I have suggested generated facades based on the grammar of existing facades. I want to improve the paper in order to publish the paper for one of the top ranking journals of ISI. I was wondering if anyone is interested to help me to improve the paper.It is also worth mentioning that your name will be mentioned as one of the authors of the paper and the paper is ready and by the guide of an expert it has the potential to be puplished in journal.
Relevant answer
Answer
The topic itself sounds interesting but in order to tell if I can be of any help first I need to read your draft and see the figures/images you have probably prepared. If you like you could send me the materials with a message.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
5 answers
Would you have any suggestions for bibliography on the grammar of the Italian language? Would you have any suggestions for bibliography on the grammaticography of Italian ? I have investigated how the Italian standardization process took place through grammars.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks, Leslie. I'll look for these suggestions! If you can help me to find them I would be very happy.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
4 answers
Would you have any suggestions for bibliography on the grammaticography of Spanish? I have investigated how the Spanish standardization process took place through grammars.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks. My e-mail addres is araujoleandrosilveira@gmail.com. I hope you find them!
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
6 answers
is it possible free grammar and punctuation checker and corrector?
Relevant answer
Answer
I just tried it, Nicholas R Walker . It scored me 14% on grammar and give me a mark of 36% on an excerpt from one of my published papers in philosophy. It couldn't even recognize the use of the verb "may", which it flagged as an error because months should be capitalized.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
11 answers
I am looking for papers (articles / chapters / presentations) which report on studies that examined the grammatical knowledge/awareness of teachers of English as a foreign/second language (ELT / TESOL) or teachers of English to L1 primary/secondary students. Please note that I am interested in the grammatical knowledge of *practising* teachers -- not trainee teachers.
Relevant answer
Answer
In order to correct the grammatical mistakes the EFLU has proposed a course where the people can learn and teach better way.
some scholars are doing research about this and they are in the progress.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
14 answers
I'm conducting a research to measure the development of EFL students' grammar knowledge by using grammar tests focusing on parts of speech and tenses in the forms of multiple choices, short essays, and error recognition. What is the appropriate term of the measured variable? I really appreciate your responses.
Relevant answer
Answer
The use of different terminology may require different type and criteria of test. For example, if you use the term 'mastery' it means the you test comprehensive knowledge of grammar. Then you will come to the intricacy of 'comprehensiveness of the type of grammar' that you may want to test. If you use 'skill', it means you test their ability in using grammar. It will require you to explore their ability in using the grammar in speaking and or writing. If you use the term competence, you will need to the test for both theoretical knowledge and application; both knowledge and skill. So, you need to match the definition of the terminology you use with the type of test that you will make. And then you can avoid using certain term that can mean something else.
  • asked a question related to Grammar
Question
3 answers
These questions refer to Swain’s Comprehensible Output theory and Schmidt’s Noticing Hypothesis.
Swain’s (1997) comprehensible output theory posits learning partly happens when learners encounter knowledge gaps. Learners become aware of the gaps and modify output accordingly.
Through, Schmidt’s (1990) Noticing Hypothesis, students learn grammatical features once noticing them. The first step involves learners becoming aware of knowledge gaps in grammar and afterward strategizing plans for overcoming those gaps.
Here are my questions.
First, is there any literature that attempts to identify a minimum amount of content for comprehensible input or noticing to occur? I’m assuming the more is better and the exact number depends on student characteristics. That being said, is there any literature on the subject? I would like to reference something tangible.
Second, Swain seems to hedge her definition of the comprehensible output theory by providing example dialogues of Person B telling Person A what is wrong with A's grammar (wording, pragmatics) explicitly. For example:
A: How you doing?
B: No, not “how you doing”? You want to say, How are you doing?
A: Thanks
To reference Swain’s CO theory, should we refer explicitly to interactions containing people talking about error corrections?
I would like to think the theory states that language acquisition occurs regardless of one person correcting another person’s language during a conversation.
I am thinking about using the term “modified CO theory” but not if I don't have to.
Relevant answer