Science topic

Giftedness - Science topic

Explore the latest questions and answers in Giftedness, and find Giftedness experts.
Questions related to Giftedness
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
4 answers
Including but not limited to Indigenous folks, LGBTQ+ folks, and racialized folks.
Relevant answer
Answer
I would imagine any counselling for this group would need to respect the intersectionality of gifted and minority experiences. As others have said, this group's gifted needs would be similar to or the same as non-minorities, although I believe the need for an intersectional lens is important given the evidence of minority stressors in psychology literature.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
6 answers
Best regards. I ask because this topic interests me because of my age and my psychological profile. I have belonged to MENSA and to the Spanish association of gifted and talented (AEST). Several members of my family are gifted. I know that this is inheritable in an average percentage of 50% in children and 70% in adults (effect of genes in the long term I suppose). I also see that certain diseases recur, but I prefer to ask the experts.
Thank you very much
Daniel Patón
Ecology Unit. University of Extremadura, Spain
Relevant answer
Answer
Gabriela test DEEPL
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
2 answers
Hello everyone. Some of us are not experts in psychology but we are interested in the subject and we want to have some basic ideas to help our students. I have some doubts about the similarities and differences between some concepts. I am referring to Dabrowsky's over-excitabilities, Aron's highly sensitive persons, the concept of giftedness itself and the aftermath of post-traumatic stress. There are experts who confuse these terms, deny the validity of some of them, consider them synonymous, etc... I would like to have a coherent explanation as to whether they are related aspects or whether some encompass others. Thank you very much.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks a lot Béatrice.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
1 answer
Hello everyone :)
I am trying to research the impact on corporate merchandise given to the employees (like t-shirts, hoodies, coffee cups, notebooks, etc. with the company logo) has any effect on the employees experience and cannot find any papers that have approached the subject.
Which honestly surprised me since it seems to be such a common practice that both big Companies (like Google) to small start ups engage in. So I am interested to see if it improves any key factor like motivation, satisfaction, retention, or performance, or if it is just a waste of resources that fills employees homes with objects they do not need.
Do you know of any research papers/studies or surveys that looks at this? Or do you otherwise know, if this topic has been studied at all? Or do you otherwise have any idea, where I might look to find some info on this?
Thanks a lot in advance!!!
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Daria, doing a quick literature search will help you to get a basic answer to your question. As with any search, the keywords used are important. In your case, you might first use "Total Rewards." I attached an article that I hope will help to get you started. You can also take a look at the sources used in the article.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
4 answers
Given the measurement, lack of universally agreed upon definition and myths regarding giftedness and gifted education, a number of methodological challenges appear in researching this new field. I have been reviewing gifted education literatures recently but lots of arguments surround methodological issues in studying giftedness and identification of individuals who are gifted or talented. Any form of help(sharing recent articles, dissertations or t or direction ) is appreciated.
Relevant answer
Answer
Since gifts can be manifested in different fields and in different ways, if possible, study can be carried out by sorting subjects by their talented area/specialty.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
5 answers
I am a graduate student at Arizona State University taking a course in research and evaluation in education. In our class, we are comparing and contrasting research and evaluation. After having read our text, (Mertens, 2020) Research and Evaluation in Education and Psychology, the author discusses the differences and parallels between the two. I had previously considered the two as interchangeable terms, or at least going hand-in-hand, however now there are evident distinctions that I can identify. The two do have overlap, but to me, research seems to be more of a process of uncovering and collecting new information in order to determine the "why" of a problem, scenario, or phenomenon. Evaluation, on the other hand, presents to me as a thorough process through which already available information is compiled to identify the "how well" or worth/value of an existing program or practice.
I am curious as to others' opinions on this topic. Do research and evaluation overlap, or are they singular and distinct? How are they used together? Must they be?
We are also discussing four paradigms that frame research and evaluation. Mertens (2020) describes them as post-positivism, constructivism, transformative and pragmatic. Do you feel that one paradigm would be more useful than another in carrying out research dealing with the efficacy of teachers of gifted populations based on their understanding of those students?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Ms. Hunt!
You raised a very important issue to consider. May I argue that research is a "collective platform" for working with science while evaluation (measuring) is a toolset to advance science and education. I searched for resources to support my claim:
1) Valle, N., Brishke, J., Shenkman, E. et al. Design, Development and Evaluation of the Citizen Science Cancer Curriculum (CSCC): a Design and Development Case Study. TechTrends (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11528-022-00737-6, Open access:
2) Blankenberger, B., Gehlhausen Anderson, S. & Lichtenberger, E. Improving Institutional Evaluation Methods: Comparing Three Evaluations Using PSM, Exact and Coarsened Exact Matching. Res High Educ 62, 1248–1275 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-021-09632-0, Open access:
3) Álex Escolà-Gascón, Josep Gallifa, How to measure soft skills in the educational context: psychometric properties of the SKILLS-in-ONE questionnaire, Studies in Educational Evaluation, Volume 74, 2022, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.stueduc.2022.101155. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0191491X22000323
4) Daraio, C., Vaccari, A. How should evaluation be? Is a good evaluation of research also just? Towards the implementation of good evaluation. Scientometrics (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-022-04329-2, Open access:
Yours sincerely, Bulcsu Szekely
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
7 answers
For my PhD dissertation, I would like to study critical reading/creative writing in English classes. How can I design my research? And, also, I would like to use Web 2.0 tools. My students are gifted ones.
I am also open to other research ideas.
Relevant answer
Answer
What is the difference between creative writing and critical writing?
The primary difference between creative and critical writing is one of lo cus. “Creative writing” presumes the presence of something like a writer's studio, a setting more relaxed than the habitat of “critical writing,” which requires an office, a professional building, a lab, as it were.
Thank you!
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
3 answers
According to Roberts (2004), all children should have leadership skills with those displaying leadership talents nurtured for future leadership roles. I am agreed with this.
I like to find some recent research to write an article about "Leadership Development for Gifted Elementary Students"
Ref: Roberts, J. L. (2004). Leadership is a “must” for children who are gifted and talented. Gifted Child Today, 27(1), 5. http://doi.org/10.1177/107621750402700101
Relevant answer
Answer
Not everyone agrees on the definition of the term "gifted". Educators and psychologists have looked at IQ tests and other achievement scores, which tend to measure linguistic and logical/mathematical abilities, but Gardner, for one, has researched other types of intelligence (including spatial, bodily-kinesthetic, musical, interpersonal, intrapersonal, and naturalist). So, which gifted elementary students would leadership development target?
PS: The trait theory of leadership, which correlates successful leaders and a limited number of factors describing them, has been much criticized. Beyond individuals, the ambit of investigations has broadened to look at the characteristics of followers and the characteristics of situations.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
5 answers
Hello!
I am nearly done with my M.Ed (C&I Gifted), and my passion is Twice-Exceptional (2e).
My current course's assignment is to complete a literature review. I have elected to examine three instructional strategies used to support the social-emotional learning (SEL) of twice-exceptional (2e) students.
Would anyone be willing to share recent research regarding this topic? The assignment parameters regarding research include the following: must be peer-reviewed AND be (ideally) published within the past 10 years OR be a foundational article by gurus in gifted education.
Warmly,
Connolly Sherwood
Relevant answer
Answer
Sorry, I have no such research
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
5 answers
What research is there (if any), about gifted students frequently getting easy questions on academic tests/exams INCORRECT and harder more challenging ones CORRECT – particularly in mathematics? Does anyone have any empirical evidence as to why this might occur? Thank you.
Relevant answer
Answer
Sorry, I have no such research
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
18 answers
I believe that the most intelligent strategy is to integrate this type of very creative persons in the research groups. Many researches have a high level of fear when they interact with gifted students or other gifted professors. This is completely absurd. The persons are different in their capacities and talents. Gifted persons can be very creative in certain areas such as mathematical analysis and not in social aspects for example. Gifted persons show tendency towards severe intellectual frustration, are chaotic in the methods of working, research in very different lines, show a low tolerance to stress, hypersensitivity, a bad adaptation to rigid academic hierarchies, etc... However, the gifted persons can help to integrate different specialties, are highly creative, with high productivity, work hard if they are motivated, are flexible and adaptable to different circumstances, etc.. . In a research group it is necessary to group the different aptitudes and characteristics of researchers. I believe that certain Universities are losing a huge amount of possibilities by mobbing against the gifted individuals. Obviously this is not good for the institutions and the society. Also, this can be a problem of discrimination with bad consequences for gifted researchers and their families. My main question is: Why this is permitted by certain institutions? Are there psychological or sociological studies that analyze these questions and their effects on educational organizations and the whole system?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dears Professors Jess Gregory and Daniel Patón, I agree with both of you.
Academic mobbing should not exist.
I found interesting the following publication:
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
8 answers
We used in our center Virtual Worlds like Secondlife for presentation, networking, sharing and global virtual exchange. Now I would like to know how we could use Virtual Reality to help gifted children? If you have experience in one of these topics, please let me know.
Relevant answer
Answer
I’ll share the top 10 free virtual field trips for gifted children:
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
3 answers
I am a Senior High School teacher handling Creative writing and creative nonfiction. more often than not, for the past three years, observe those who can really write are those who are gifted with the skills and the rest just take the writing for granted by copying from the internet or let others do their jobs. obe of the reasons why is the limited vocabulary they have. Now, want to conduct classroom action research and planning to come up with an intervention material using colored patterned cards in improving their vocabulary
Thank you
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you @Miss Sania Kokab
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
5 answers
I am doing a literature review regarding utilization of gifted strategies in a math class. Specifically, I am looking at how distance learning might impact math acceleration or math understanding for gifted students. What strategies with technology have you experienced with either negative or positive results?
Relevant answer
Answer
Distance learning is very helpful for matured learners. Some cases it will be helpful for freshers. Regarding mathematics is concern, only SLM or PCPs are not quite apt. we can take helps from some experts.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
13 answers
I have been preparing and gathering information for a literature review on instructional strategies in the area of reading for gifted learners. Many journals I have come across reflect and discuss the importance of grouping, acceleration, and differentiated curriculum/instruction. I agree that these are vital in the growth and learning of gifted learners. I am curious if there are any other strategies that are also beneficial to gifted learners and providing accelerated reading opportunities?
Thank you,
Serena
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with Stephen Reich when he says that the best way to advance a great reader is to provide a variety of reading materials in subject domain areas.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
3 answers
I intented to apply an educational intervention to improve the academic achievement of highly able underachieving adolescents. I found 79 gifted underachievers in total (gifted underachievers constitute a limited research population by definition). However, only 18 of them participated in my intervention. I have pre-tests and post-tests of academic achievement for the total of 18 participants and 61 non participants, but I'm worried about the statistical power of comparisons (non parametrics) due to unequal sample sizes. What if I picked a random sample of 18-20 subjects for the group of non participants? SPSS offers the option to pick a random sample of subjects. Is this an acceptable way to reduce the unequality of sample sizes?
Relevant answer
Answer
I tend to agree with Rachel Grieve in that using a matched sample would be more useful - particularly as you have small numbers and would be keen to ensure the groups are as similar as possible.
In case-control studies it is acceptable to have more than one control per case, with some authors suggesting 1:3 or even 1:4 ratios. I don't know if the same process is appropriate in an intervention study but if you had multiple matches using a matched sample strategy it may boost statistical power whilst maintaining group characteristics.
An interesting discussion I had a while back was on how to manage an RCT when uneven group sizes were a result of the randomisation process - you haven't indicated if your groups were derived from randomisation (I suspect they weren't) but you may find this conversation of interest. https://www.researchgate.net/post/How_important_are_group_sizes_in_randomisation_for_an_RCT
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
1 answer
I have been gifted a culture flask of 3d7 falciparum strain. I want to genotype the parasites to be sure I truly working with 3d7 as other strains are also cultured in the same lab.
Relevant answer
Answer
Here's a protocol I developed for our lab. In essence, you can sequence MSP2, as it's a very variable gene.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
9 answers
Dear colleagues, TCT-DP is known for its ability to check creativity. Since it is a drawing test, maybe there was an attempt to use it for artistic giftedness check?
If you have ever seen any info of that kind, please share.
Many thanks!
Relevant answer
Answer
Ekaterina Donii, About 5 years ago I took a particular interest in the TCT-DP as a test of creativity because I was editing a PhD thesis that included it and, independent of my editing work, I helped the candidate to do some of her analyses.
I therefore read the manual for the TCT-DP carefully. Overall, I was not at all impressed with the test despite it appearing on the surface to be valid.
Some of the analyses in the test's manual seem to be extremely biased, and in the thesis that I was editing there was strong evidence that the test did not exhibit test-retest reliability: Some people got very high scores on it at one point in time and very low scores not long after, and vice versa - but presumably their artistic ability (or creativity) had not changed across that time.
One thing I will say, however, is that some people came up with extremely clever and creative drawings - at least at one of the time points. So, some of the drawings were a lot of "fun", but I don't know what they really prove.
One other thing to note is that the TCT-DP is quite expensive to use if people abide by copyright constraints - which they should.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
4 answers
I hope for a global overview on mathematical giftedness and its support in school and/or on an extracurricular level. What programmes/opportunities are offered?
Relevant answer
Answer
First thanks , it is really an interesting question.
A problem is that gifted and talented students do not receive the necessary care
To meet their needs by remaining in regular classes. Therefore, I find it important to do the following:
- Staying away from traditional methods during teaching, this leads to boredom for students, especially talented people
- When constructing lessons conceptually, we take into account that gifted and talented students may also suffer
One of the weaknesses in understanding the curriculum and that they need to be considered. And when applying the teaching conceptually within
In the ordinary class, students of all levels will learn in a deeper way.
- Adding open-ended questions to both education and evaluation for their positive results on students ’understanding
As well as their attitudes towards the material.
The- direct and indirect financial support for talented people
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
3 answers
My colleagues and I issue a journal "Social Phenomena". It is an nonprofit independent platform for scholars who support the open science movement and wish to share their knowledge with others. The mission of our journal is to help authors share their ideas with the Russian-speaking scientific audience. We translate all articles into Russian and publish them for free in open access. We also do not charge authors any fees because we believe that there is no place for commerce in science.
The theme of the next issue is "Giftedness: the conditions and factors". We welcome all authors from various branches of science who are interested in this topic and want to make their research open to fellow Russian scholars.
The additional info is in the attached file and here http://journal.socialphenomena.org/en/
Relevant answer
Answer
Very interesting
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
11 answers
how can a teacher discover and identify a gifted and talented students in the first few days or weeks of interaction with the class?
Relevant answer
Answer
Akram Jabar Najim,
The question was, How can a teacher discover and identify a gifted and talented students in the first few days or weeks of interaction with the class?
My answer is,
Although there is no easy formula for identifying a gifted students, but we can note some of characteristics that appear to differentiate the gifted students from their classmates. Some of these characteristics I can summarize it in the following:-
1- Early use of advanced vocabulary or he can use new and a good sentences and early ability to read and to understand nuances in the language. Also, gifted students often amazes parents and teachers by learning new information quickly and remembering the details over long periods of time.
2- Students may be involved in many self-initiated projects at the same time. The ability to think abstractly, Some of those students can move from concrete to symbolic representation very comfortably and at an earlier age than most students.
3- The important thing is the critical thinking skills. The students are able to perform evaluations based on established criteria and often notices discrepancies between what people say and what they do.
4- Also, some students who is gifted often shows independence, self-reliance and responsibility in completing tasks.
5- Creativity and inventiveness, They can be able to view situations from varying perspectives, develop and explore alternative approaches and generate novel products.
6- Frequently a gifted students are alert and eager, delving into interests beyond the usual limitations of students his own age that may led them to take leadership roles in some situations.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
14 answers
How do you identify a gifted and talented child? What type of activity or test you can do?
Can it be done remotely in current circumstances?
Relevant answer
Answer
I have two brief comments.
1) One can certainly gain many valuable insights on the individual learning needs of students of all ability levels in an online diagnosis. (We ourselves offer online diagnosis in our Gifted Counselling Centre at the moment, too.)
2) However, like Dr. Verbić, I wonder why the label "gifted" is necessary? (No matter if it is online or offline diagnosis.) Isn't the crucial point of the diagnosis rather how individual learning can best be supported?
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
5 answers
The three mega findings of 1907 (gravitational redshift, gravitational light curvature, gravitational apparent reduction of c) are more than an excuse for overlooking a fourth mega implication of the same brain child.
The global constancy of c assumed at the outset does imply a fourth equally important implication: Optically masked gravitational size increase downstairs.
Who can blame Einstein for overlooking a fourth blossom in his unprecedented heavenly bucket?
So it is not his IQ that is put into jeopardy but that of the rest of humankind: for more than a century.
Posted on the evening of December 5, 2019 as a present to all children on St. Nicholas Day
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
3 answers
Does anyone know of a vendor or recipe to prepare MB-1 myogenic culture medium?
I have seen in several publications and not a single one linked to manufacturer.
In one instance it was gifted by Jacques Tremblay and that was about it.
I also see Thermofisher as manufacturer but they do not have it. I will contact sales rep regarding this.
Relevant answer
Answer
You can order it directly from Dr. Jacques P Tremblay (jacques-p.tremblay@crchudequebec.ulaval.ca)
He can send it to you if you are in canada or outside canada
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
2 answers
I have decided to use a specific cancer cell lines for my project. However, mostly I found only B16- OVA expressing cell lines and that too gifted from a lab. How can I engineer OVA antigen into my cell line?
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks a lot Govinda Sharma . This helps a lot.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
13 answers
I read different research about giftedness and genetic but I would like to ask you about this topic.
What do you think?
Relevant answer
Answer
Most contemporary scientists nowadays agree that being gifted comes from both genes and nurture, some (eg. C.Badcock) also consider the epigenetic effect. Some interesting research on monozygotic twins has been conducted to learn more about the role of genes in giftedness. The specific characteristics of the brain are also hereditary, that will also lead to "generations of scientists". Different models describe the factors contributing to being gifted (the Munich model, Gagne, Sternberg, Renzulli et al).
All people have their strengths but not all are gifted in the educational meaning of the word. Some students need to be accelelerated in school or they'll become frustrated and bored. Franz J. Mönks has defined the concept of being gifted quite well - as an individual's potential to reach outstanding/exceptional results in one or more areas.
Hope this clarifies the issue a bit.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
14 answers
Whenever I had a pleasure to meet in my life with professional/Experts and Researcher, the one thing i realized in their life is common is the hard work and dedication. Usually, when they share their story, they start with that i am from the countryside, and we were living basic life at my childhood. So that means one thing in common that most of the researchers achieved the success through self-made hard working and dedication, no doubt that to be intelligent is a gifted blessing, but at the end of the day, the Hard work Wins...
What's your Idea and story.....
Relevant answer
Answer
Intelligence is a gift of God some people are intellectually superior and they do great job for example Einstein where as the hard work is our choice and those who opt for hard work they are rewarded at some point of their life. So two are different one is a gift and another is a choice
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
16 answers
Dear colleagues,
We have many types of schools include private, public, and gifted schools in Iran. Educational policy makers have currently confirmed a law in higher commission of education system to removing the gifted middle schools. This foundation decision has mainly created huge debates among educational researchers and mangers. Advocates argued that by conducting this policy, gifted students will earn more opportunities to interaction with ordinary persons, improve the quality of public schools, and have happier moments in public schools. Also, opponents believe that gifted schools give their students higher level learning experiences and move them toward a better future. It would be great to hear your experiences in your home or your personal ideas about having gifted schools for gifted students.
Many thanks,
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Seyed,
In Turkey, there is no school for gifted students at middle level (lower secondary) . They are studying with their peer in general school. However, we have certain type of science and art centers. While gifted students are studying at general middle schools, they can also be registered to these centers. It is a kind of extracurricular one.
The point I want to emphasize that there is a big difference between gifted students and high performers. The first group of students are selected by their special talents (e.g, art, math, science). On the other hand, high performers are selected via exam score. It may be national, regional or school level. For instance in Turkey, we implement selective national exam at the and of middle school. Based on exam score students are registered to general or vocational high school. Even though a student is at the top of scale he/she study at these types of school.
Nevertheless this does not mean that they (gifted vs high performer) cannot occur together. Some students are both high-achieving and gifted learners
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
24 answers
How can a teacher develop and bring out the full potential in a gifted and talented student? What are the method initiatives to be adopted in carry out this task without the students been stress up and fighting back during the developmental process of the training?
Relevant answer
Answer
All suggestions are marvelous, a correlation of all of them shall results in a perfect solution. But can all teachers follow such procedures ?
I suggest a general solution based on tests and exams. Wherein, questions shall be carefully set, and answers of students shall very carefully revised, hence, gifted students may be distinguished in their talents upon their answers.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
2 answers
The disparity between "destination success with self-actualisation" and straight A grades - A very useful insights for educational reforms!
"Unfortunately, trying to force success at school can leave children not only ill-prepared for adulthood but at risk for mental health issues, substance abuse, and social isolation. While pretty much everyone can name a gifted high school/college drop-out who later went on to great achievements, very little time is spent understanding how these individuals were raised such that they grew into emotionally healthy, professionally thriving adults. So how do the parents of bright, capable, but seemingly unmotivated children help their children balance their passions with real-world practicality, learn the resiliency of working through non-preferred tasks, and develop a healthy sense of identity, despite their dislike of, or lacklustre performance in school?"
"Students who spend their energy trying to please others or chasing the academic brass ring often find themselves feeling burnt-out and unfulfilled. Conversely, students who are driven by internal goals, whether those goals conform to educational expectations or not, are likely to grow into self-actualized adults as long as we honour and protect who they are as individuals. "
Relevant answer
Answer
When I achieve "Straight A's" in the curriculum that you have mandated for me, am I learning what I want to or need to or am I receiving a "cookie cutter" education? Part of a proper education is to achieve the academic credentials to qualify to proceed to the next level of whatever it is that we want to do. This might be a job or pursuing a higher degree. But an essential part of education should be to advance the overall mind of the student. This will allow them to become the problem solver that jobs want and satisfy their innate intellectual curiosity. With governmental emphasis on outcomes and students being able to find employment, this becomes a problem for an educator. Many academics bewail that the classical liberal arts education is dying and being replaced with a much more vocational orientated type of education.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
3 answers
The human cost of what we don't know! A very important issue to raise and pursue at least now, rather than later!
"We wish for a world where ALL children can actualize their potential without fear of misdiagnosis, bullying, or isolation.
"Are misdiagnoses and mismedication really a problem? YES!"
"Professionals cannot diagnose what they do not understand"
"If we do not conduct research, we cannot increase understanding"
"I have little doubt you wish the same, but did you know that 1.4 million children in the United States alone are at risk of misdiagnosis and mismedication due to a lack of understanding about the affect being gifted has on their health and development? Did you know there is absolutely no required training for medical and mental health professionals to learn about how to recognize and respond to the physiological and psycho-emotional differences that gifted children experience each day?")
Relevant answer
Answer
This is an important subject which requires "thorough" care. The way research is directed & how budgets are allocated for R&D have negative aspects since "influential" countries emphasize upon the increase of military power,through research, at the expense of "central" topics.
Nothing, on earth, is more important than the human beings and children ought to be the top priority to look after if we "really" aim at human welfare & progress.
There are many persons, including intellectuals, who do not have the "correct" perspective with respect to human potential & development. They may think of providing children with food & allowing them to play… and that is the end of the story. How mistaken they are.
We still live in a primitive world with regard to natural & human sciences. Isn't it absurd to claim advances in medicine while we see an increase in illnesses & failure of giving remedies for as simple as common colds ?!
There are many ideas in my mind but I need pages to write them down so I better stop here.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
3 answers
The gifted in the arts fields suffer from being labeled as underachievers because they are forced to succeed in curricula that include scientific materials that are not inclined to them, which causes their loss and the loss of opportunities to refine their talents .
Relevant answer
Answer
I would try to use music to help the student learn other fields. As a philosophy and religion professor, I use musical selections that exemplify topics under investigation all the time. My rationale is that some of my students will only grasp the material by hearing the music, so that by sharing it, they will keep on pace with the other students in the class.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
9 answers
I am writing a lit. review. I want to concentrate on gifted cluster classrooms in Elementary Schools. How can I narrow it down to a specific topic and include it with literacy?
Relevant answer
Do thorough literature search on the broad topic. Read as many relevant titles as possible. Summarize in a few sentences authors' findings/views, at times agreeing or disagreeing. When you disagree, assert your own perspective.
By the time you'd done these, you're may find a general focus on the broad topic, with certain specific aspects mentioned scantily. You may also find some recommendations for further investigation. Some of the recommendations and some of the gaps or points/findings you question may be in the specific areas you're interested in. E.g  do you want to discover what makes reading and/or writing more engaging for a gifted class? Or what schools and the children have that can be a foundation for teaching technology literacy?
Note any recommendations and gaps, reflect, and do further search specifically in those areas, peradventure any reasonable works had been done in them. If already covered, how well? in which location? Findings of a study in an alien locality may not represent your own locality and so you may like to do a similar study in your own locality. If your further search in specific areas confirm the gaps found, it's time to frame some narrow topics.
Is this helpful?
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
1 answer
Looking at earthworm exposed to various pesticides and want to look at their feces to see changes in the microbiome. Is there a company/org in the US who can help on this? This is for students in the 8th grade middle school gifted students program. We are located in Maryland.
Thanks 
(Note that this is for personal interest, and not related to my employer).
Relevant answer
Answer
I have used MR DNA labs in Texas which gives results at a reasonable price ( www.mrdnalabs.com ).  This would give some good data on microbial diversity of the microbiome.  I think the amount of data and interpretation might be overwhelming.  I might suggest comparing the feces of of the exposed earthworms to non exposed by using a series of antibiotic containing media plates.where differences in number of resistant forms and some phenotypic variety could be easily seen and understood.  Just make sure you have some biosafety steps in place.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
8 answers
  • As an entirely independent  researcher -- not receiving any research grant from any Organization in the World -- active in several fields in Medicine, including Cardiology, Neurology, Neuro-Ophthalmololgy, Neuro-Endocrinology, Endocrinology, Gastroenterology, Hepatology, Immunology particularly occult sarcoidosis with published research in these and other fields, and, a reviewer of manuscripts from several prominent medical journals, I have found that scientific letter writing has the power to remove scientific clutter from the desk of the avid researcher, remove the dross and the flotsam that necessarily accompany human efforts, demolish long-cherished assumed areas of knowledge, and bring to the forefront "that which really matters".
  • I quote straight from my 1996 article in the Journal of Medical Ethics: "Critical letter writing entails the abilities to: maintain rational scepticism; refuse to conform in order to explain data; persist in keeping common-sense centre-stage; exercise logic to evaluate the biological significance of mathematical figures, including statistics; and, the ability to sustain the will to share insights regarding disease mechanisms on an ostensibly lower research platform"--see attachment.
  • For almost a decade, the journal "Neurology"--AAN, refused to accept scientific correspondence in response to published articles from scientists who were not members of the AAN and thus did not directly subscribe to the journal. This was clearly written across over the relevant pages of the issues of Neurology.
  • Talent is not a monopoly of advanced countries particularly the U.S.A., a land populated by immigrants of all hues and varieties. Neither is it the sole purview of the American Academy of Neurology and it voice -- the journal NEUROLOGY.
  • History must record this shameful and woeful editorial journal policy, as well as our responses to it, so that the future does not see such carbuncles of bias and outright prejudice in science.
  • Writers of critical Letters-to-the-Editor are a prized commodity -- the wealth of the scientific enterprise, with the ability to read between the lines -- an ability that is gifted only occasionally by Nature -- see attachments of Letters-to-the-Editor. I have published over a hundred of such pearls over the last three decades.
  • The science of Medicine is too important to be left to Editors and Reviewers or to the so-called Original Researchers flush with research funds, Institutional support, and knowledge to navigate the complex business of research. The paper claiming that aspirin had anti-platelet activity and prolonged bleeding time was initially rejected -- Desforges JF. NEJM 329, 14, 1038-1039, 1993 -- the very pillar of modern cardiovascular and cerebrovascular therapeutics.  
  • Nothing in Medicine cannot be improved (Popper KR. Conjectures and Refutations. London: Routledge, 1978, p.47; The Logic of Scientific Discovery; Lancet 342 (8879); 1063-1064,1993). The human quest for perfection will never cease -- the imperfect human seeking the Ultimate, the paradoxical enterprise that keeps our heads high and our spirit higher, to soar where our mind is no longer shackled, the finite existence in tango with the Infinite.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Dennis:
Thank you for your response.
I am an old hat at research publication after learning the ropes over 3 decades. The matter you provided was very thoughtful.
The issue I raised was a little different. What do you do if the Editor or the reviewer is heavily biased or prejudiced, based on their interpretation of the science involved? 
Vinod
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
3 answers
i have this article and it is so usefull for my research. for citing your article, i need the citing information. how can i cite your article? is it published?
Relevant answer
Answer
I have not seen the article. If well written, it can be publishable, I can only pronounce that if I read it. 
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
5 answers
L am looking for academic articles that address how teaching influence learning in music education where the group of students comprise gifted students who have music background and novices who are studying music for the first time at tertiary level.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thank you very much Karin
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
11 answers
for example, having a score of 130 on either the verbal comprehension or the perceptual organization ?
Relevant answer
Answer
It's always good to STICK WITH THE EVIDENCE, and treat words like "giftedness" with some skepticism. It's not the words --- it's the FACTS that matter ! :)
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
11 answers
I'm interested in finding out connections between abilities to learn EFL and intellectual giftedness. I'd like to compare achievments in learning EFL with other school subjects of primary school children. I've met many people who did not appear to posses high intellectual abilities, but they were very quick and efficient to learn foreign languages (in native environment though). I'd like to know whether there is a connection of intelectual giftedness and foreign language acquisition, or the ability to learn a foreign language is independent of intellect. Do you know about any research connecting the general abilities of learners with foreign language learning?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dobry den!
The ability to learn a foreign language is most easily predicted by measures (tests) of language learning aptitude. The research shows that, as might be expected, language aptitude and intelligence seem to be overlapping but also independent constructs. Considering both are measured using psychometric tests, it is not that surprising that they seem to be related. However, your observations that good language learners do not have to be particularly good at other subjects, although normally they are. A key area of overlap here is verbal intelligence, which seems to measure the ability of learners to profit from instruction, ie they more readily understand the words of those instructing them, be they a teacher or textbook, etc.
I've attached some links to some seminal papers looking at the link between intelligence and language aptitude and hope they help.
Some other references worth following up are:
Dörnyei, Z. (2005). The psychology of the language learner: Individual differences in second language acquisition. Lawrence Erlbaum.
Sasaki, M. (1996). Second language proficiency, foreign language aptitude, and Intelligence: Quantitative and qualitative analyses. New York: Peter Lang.
Sternberg, R. J. (2002). The theory of successful intelligence and its implications for language-aptitude testing. In P. Robinson (Ed.), Individual differences and instructed language learning (pp. 13–43). Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Hope that helps!
PS Say hi to Profesorka Hartanska for me! 
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
11 answers
What is an effective way to improve motivation in a gifted student who excels in math but doesn't like to do it. 
Relevant answer
Answer
I have studied gifted and talented students for many years. Top educators in the field in Australia have consulted me for case studies. My own daughter was recognised as gifted and talented at a very young age, she crawled at 6 weeks and walked at 4 months.
In Australia Miraca Gross is considered one of the top in her field. Eddie Braggart who I consulted with at Charles Sturt University wanted my daughter to attend university at 10, the Australian Board of Studies in New South Wales allowed her to go to a selective school in Sydney. 
The problem with gifted children is frequently they do not want to perform to their optimum as they will be perceived as unusual and some kind of freak, then they fall into the category of the gifted underachiever. This accounts for approximately 0.05% of the population.
While living in the USA I read an article which relied on the four p words to assist with gifted students I am not sure of the author, possibly Harry Passow. I have tried to locate the article for you but I have not had any success. 
I have used these four words and a couple of other p words to deal with the education of gifted and talented students for a number of years. I do not remember which were the original four words however I found that I have adapted them to meet my own needs. 
I have attached citation for an article which deals the unique problems faced by educators of the gifted, however this is not an all inclusive list.
The words I use are the following "persistently, positively, progressively pushing in order to promote progress". A student who doesn't like to do the subject in which they excel usually will find every excuse to do anything else that fills their time. The motivation needs to become intrinsic, help the student to find a valid reason for what you know or want them to achieve. These students need to be rewarded for achievements as does the average student. I hope this is of some help.
artatipratiwi/strategies-to-educate-gifted-children-4504283
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
4 answers
a copy of ready personality traits scale prepared elsewhere, with the norms and standards.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi. I have already developed a set of tests to assess personality from the Indian Vedic perspective. It is online on my website. I have developed my own software for the analysis and its online on my website and I also have a patent pending on the same. Do visit my website and take a look.
Thanks,
Shilpa
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
8 answers
There's this notion that mixed ability education is the best without making slow learners feeling less of themselves. In some cases, mixed ability grouping do not necessarily help, instead it serves as a disincentive to the slow learner, and sometimes, some them may even exhibit some form of labelled characteristics of 'special education needs'. 
Relevant answer
Answer
And yet, rolemodelling is important too. Some students do learn, while feeling intimidated. So you won't see the benefit straightaway but only later on, in the next step of education.
They take in, have fear to intervene orally and show they can do things. Sometimes they panic during written tests, as well and the benefits won't show. However, in the long run, you'll see the difference.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
4 answers
Trajectory of gifted education research.
Relevant answer
I agree it should be more investigated and also carry out more intervencione early in school.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
7 answers
Thank you in advance...
Relevant answer
Answer
Maybe these will be helpful:
McCoach, D. B., & Siegle, D. (2003). Factors that differentiate underachieving gifted students from high-achieving gifted students. Gifted Child Quarterly, 47(2), 144-154.
Melser, N. A. (1999). Gifted students and cooperative learning: A study of grouping strategies. Roeper Review, 21(4), 315.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
25 answers
When we know how important is education for all, to barbarism, ignorance and inequality prevailing in this wildly globalized world
As we explain that the effort is not engaged the attention of the less gifted or benefited by society.
Could it be that again, we neglect the great mass, and invest only in subjects that the political system requires, for the few jobs that offer creative quality?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello everyone and thanks for the contributions received: nuances, suggestions, light and shadow
Well, the question already died in his hands. My initial interest was not feeling alone in this swim upstream. I wanted to identify colleagues who do not get carried away by money and fashion it generates, support research lines and not others, indexed research and publication.
Also, certainly, we know we're not the only ones who will not compete for those officers money, given away from European banks (Mediterranean) rescued by public funds. Entities using their existence to score more poverty for the basic salaries are below the poverty line, as indicated by the European community, although the minister prime Spain still ignoring it.
Is it compatible with the signing of Horizon 2020 Protocol and taking investigative purposes marking the capital? Where is education for Sustainability?
Which of the principles of environmental sustainability, risk, social accountability college ... it is fulfilled when we dictate what we should investigate?
Perhaps if this is the real debate, and surely compensate launch as a new matter, for visibility
Thanks in advance, and to ask you that you might be interested in responding, that it might be best done through new question
Chema
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
3 answers
For doing my graduade thesis, Iam interest with measuring gifted. Actually ,I have bought manual and instrument screening for identification of the gifted, but I can't adapt it in my country, because I must buy a research translation license agreement application with a great price (the license would be for use in research only for a particular study). I mean, I am looking for people who can work together to develop their instrument in my country. thanks very much.
Relevant answer
Answer
What constitutes 'gifted' is a highly debatable point. I suggest you start by identifying what key elements must be present in order to consider somebody 'gifted' by studying the literature base. When you have identified some common elements, you can construct your own scale to do this, and validate it against the one that you were going to translate.
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
8 answers
WISC-R, Raven Color Test, Peabody,
Relevant answer
Answer
Identification tests of giftedness have some problems, such as adaptation of culturally and early ages (in terms of validity and reliability).
  • asked a question related to Giftedness
Question
6 answers
Why popularity of gifted education increase at developing countries nowadays?
What should be done firstly in these countries at gifted education?
Relevant answer
Answer
We are happy to inform that JEGYS have accepted Index Copernicus.(publishing index)