Science topic
Fire - Science topic
Explore the latest questions and answers in Fire, and find Fire experts.
Questions related to Fire
Note ceiling lights getting brighter as the evening progress?
Instead of firing expanded clay into aggregates, is it possible to direct the expansion of the clay so that it forms cubes of desired sizes? And are there methods to shape it as desired?
I modelled a RCC Beam in Abaqus and did dynamic implicit analysis. It is working. But I am facing problem, when I am going for couple temperature displacement analysis of the same beam in two steps. It is showing time incrementation problem. Can anyone, please suggest me, how can I solve this problem?
Hi
Me and my collegues found a strange rock aggregates here Lunda Sul, within Kalahari sand suite.
Similar formations (ferricrite, ferricrete) are found within Lunda Sul, Angola on the surface and in the strata of the Neogene-Paleogene red-brown sand deposits of the Kalahari as different unshaped fragments with different sizes.
I guess it could came from more ancient sedimentary rocks. I have attached some photos and description
So, we have these cylinders splited on 4 sector, 5 sector and 6 sector bofy filled by iron mineralization mixture (mainly composed by goethite, hematite, relics of fayalite, few inclusions of quartz). We have done only X-ray diffraction analysis and single thin sections, but wave microprobe have not yet been done. The spaces between sectors filled by Kalahari sands. Aggregate of goethite botryoidal form, porous filling, brownish dark-gray color, metallic luster, yellowish-brown streak, hardness 5, density about 4 g/cm3, slightly oxidized on chips, in voids and pores. Magnetic susceptibility about 0.16 SI*10^5.
I have one exotic idea about origin but with many questions.
It could be tree trunks, splited into pieces after drying or fire, filled with clay soil during wet season, which was then consolidated after next dry season or new fire. Subsequently the wood (or coal) in sectors were weathered and..... replaced (?) by iron-rich mineralization. Perhaps the processes of psephdomorphic replacement occurred in several stages. As a result, we obtained botryoidal goethite.))
It remains unclear the olivine origin in the botryoidal aggregate?
Why, instead of vertical zoning and the ring structure of the tree, we have, on the contrary, horizontal sinter structures?
What do you think? Please look at the concretes. May be you have seen similar or have idea what is it? Which signs and features I could check without any complex analytics??
Below attached images of aggregates:
Schrödinger's PDE is too old (+100 years) and fundamentally incomplete but it has proven itself in almost all scientific fields.
He can't die or be fired all at once, at least in the next ten years.
However, in the long term, it is very likely that they will gradually disappear and be replaced by elegant and brilliant theories of modern statistical mechanics.
what steps do we need to perform the fire analysis on the steel structure already subjected to earthquake in Abaqus?
I need to test fire performance of concrete cubes (150 mm * 150 mm * 150 mm). May I know about what kind of arrangement need to conduct this test at home? It shouldn't be a scientific one. But it should have been used to measure fire performance of concrete.
I recently published, for the first time, in Fire, an MDPI Journal. I felt the peer review process was weak in comparison to other journals; I essentially had one substantive peer review, and comments from the 2nd reviewer were mediocre at best but did not help improve the article I wrote; yet the editor chose to publish my article anyways - of course, this was a special issue publication.
Having served as a peer-reviewer for Forests and Fire before, I had considerable questions on their timelines and ethics of publishing and feel that the pay-to-publish and short timelines result in questionable peer-review processes, though it is neither universally good nor bad.
Now, Forests is asking me to serve as a guest editor and I admit I feel both flattered and baited into their system. They offer incentives (free publications for myself and people I invite), but I also admit that I feel like this is a bit of a predatory and bait scheme to help them get more articles and more special issues to support their business model.
They also are suggesting that by serving as a guest editor they may invite me to join their editorial board... which has a large number of recognizable and admirable scientists on it, however, I fear my ethics are leading me to think that the great good of science would benefit by not supporting these predatory styles of journals.
I feel conflicted, what are other peoples thoughts on these matters and MDPI?
FIRE:crash: wrf: SUCCESS COMPLETE WRF. Fire has reached domain boundary.
-------------- FATAL CALLED ---------------
FATAL CALLED FROM FILE: <stdin> LINE: 152
crash: wrf: SUCCESS COMPLETE WRF. Fire has reached domain boundary.
-------------------------------------------
"rsl.error.0000" 105163L, 6095612C
A hazard is anything that could cause harm. And, A hazard refers to anything with the potential to cause harm, damage, or adverse effects to people, property, the environment, or any other entity.
Hazards can be physical (e.g., fire, electricity), chemical (e.g., toxic substances), biological (e.g., pathogens), ergonomic (e.g., repetitive motion), or psychosocial (e.g., stress).
Risk, is part of everyone's life. For example, there is a risk of injury due to traffic accidents when we go out onto the street. Also, when we put money in a bank, there is a risk of not being able to retrieve it if the bank goes bankrupt.
How to plot co & cross polarization for end fire antennas in HFSS ?
The Pauli effect or Pauli's device corollary is the supposed tendency of technical equipment to encounter critical failure in the presence of certain people. The term was coined after mysterious anecdotal stories involving Austrian theoretical physicist Wolfgang Pauli, describing numerous instances in which demonstrations involving equipment suffered technical problems only when he was present.
This Scientist Made Labs Set on Fire, But How?
Whenever this Nobel Prize winner entered a lab, equipment would break, electrical systems would malfunction and go out of control, and beakers would crack. Sometimes even fires would break out. The name of the scientist was Dr. Wolfgand Pauli, and even his colleagues believed all those incidents weren’t just a matter of bad luck. They called this phenomenon “the Pauli Effect.”
a retail company took the decision to reduce employees' hours over the firing employee . They communicate badly this decision , in a hurry and with perspective of lay off
is icbrrecible in his lasss on fscultsd de matematicas uv i apotbed wuth helper clas an di habe f on exams n is very unfari please support me all comunity of mu 636m paers porved
I am trying to model heat transfer as result of a fire in a reinforced concrete wall in 2D.
I get the following error when combing a 2D homogeneous part (concrete) with a 2D wire (rebar): STRESS-DISPLACEMENT ELEMENTS OR OTHER ELEMENTS WITHOUT TEMPERATURE DEGREE OF FREEDOM ARE NOT ALLOWED IN A HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS
I am working on a fire segmentation algorithm. I would like to ask you if there is someone than has the possibility to share radiometric images, or even better videos, of fire, hot body, also a buring candle, in order for me to test the correctness of my algorithm solution?
I would be very grateful if you could help me.
Hello there,
I have seen the website https://cwfis.cfs.nrcan.gc.ca/maps/fw?type=fwi which generates maps of fire weather parameters like DMC, FWI , FFMC etc. based on the date. Is there a way i can get the data in the form of a .nc file or something that contains the continuous historical data of these parameters for canada?
I want to model CDP model that will incur the effect of fire in the degradation of concrete properties with continuous changing temperature. I have read few literatures but unable to finf a suitable one that will be pf some help to me. Kindly suggest any particular one knows of. It would be really very helpful.
I'm thinking to add phospates, corrosion inhibitors, organic acids, some inorganic compounds and glycol in to my agent. But without surfactants I've got concerns about the extingusihing capacity.
Do you agree to my concerns ?
If not what should I change in order to increase suppression capacity ?
Is there a way to produce more ecofriendly and human safe non foaming agent ?
Thank you for your ideas
natural draft furnace (fired heater) is designed for 620°C outlet temperature of process gas , due to high fuel pressure (tip pressure) we are not able to increase the heat load .
how can we reduce the tip pressure in running plant.
The chemistry of combustion is a process where a fuel reacts with oxygen in the presence of heat, resulting in the release of energy in the form of light and heat. The process can be explained using the fire triangle, which represents the three essential components required for combustion to occur: fuel, oxygen, and heat.
- Fuel: A fuel is any material that can undergo combustion and release energy. Fuels can be in various forms, such as solid, liquid, or gas. Common examples of fuels include wood, gasoline, natural gas, coal, and hydrogen. The chemical composition of the fuel determines the products formed during combustion.
For example, in the case of hydrocarbons like gasoline or methane (natural gas), the combustion reaction can be represented as follows:
Fuel (hydrocarbon) + Oxygen → Carbon dioxide + Water + Energy
C8H18 (Octane) + 12.5O2 → 8CO2 + 9H2O + Energy
- Oxygen: Oxygen is a critical component for combustion because it acts as the oxidizing agent. It accepts electrons from the fuel during the combustion process, leading to the oxidation of the fuel. In the Earth's atmosphere, the oxygen concentration is about 21%, which is sufficient for most combustion processes.
During combustion, the oxygen reacts with the carbon, hydrogen, and other elements present in the fuel, breaking the chemical bonds and forming new compounds like carbon dioxide and water.
- Heat: Heat is the energy required to initiate and sustain the combustion reaction. Combustion is an exothermic reaction, meaning it releases heat. However, for the reaction to start, an initial input of energy, known as the activation energy, is required. This activation energy breaks the initial chemical bonds in the fuel molecules, allowing the reaction to proceed spontaneously.
Once the combustion reaction begins, the energy released during the process further provides the heat needed to sustain the reaction. The heat generated helps maintain the high temperature required to continue the combustion process.
The Fire Triangle: The fire triangle represents the interdependence of these three components in the process of combustion. If any side of the triangle is removed, combustion cannot occur. For example:
- If the fuel is removed or depleted, there is nothing to burn, and the fire will be extinguished.
- If oxygen is restricted or removed (e.g., in a sealed container), the fire will be deprived of the oxidizing agent necessary for combustion, causing it to go out.
- If heat is removed (e.g., by cooling the fuel or using a fire extinguisher), the combustion reaction cannot sustain the high temperature required for continued burning, and the fire will be extinguished.
The fire triangle helps to understand the essential components needed for combustion and is a fundamental concept in fire safety and firefighting.
I'm considering putting together a database of instances where researchers and scientists were censored or punished for their ideas, preferably their scientific or research ideas, but also interested in those censored or punished for their political or religious ideas. I've found a few news articles about climate scientists who were fired for their opinions or researchers who were fired for their religious views, but I would like more examples. They don't have to be firings. I think there must be many other instances where a faculty member was denied research funding, or denounced by other faculty or students for views expressed in a private or public setting. The only inclusion criteria is that I have to have some kind of evidence, like screenshots of a discussion on twitter, a school newspaper article, a petition to get someone censored or suspended. Preferably I would like two sources for each entry. If you are willing to email me directly, that would be wonderful -- or for discussion's sake, put your comments here and also email me at AristotlesPride@mac.com if you don't mind.
I produced a fire crucible, but unfortunately, it cracked after two uses. How can I improve its performance? I think the problem is in not choosing the correct granulation of raw material particles
If the moving body is rigid, then E denotes kinetic energy, where E = (mv^2)/2 and v approaches c (velocity of light).
I have been trying to get sustained combustion in ANSYS using the Species Transport Model and Finite Rate Mechanism. However, even when i manage to get ignition the flame eventually dies out. I'm using the following boundary conditions:
Inlet : velocity inlet of Methane at room Temperature.
Free air flow in the surroundings at room temperature.
Initially the domain has air and methane comes in at room temperature. I can add a high temperature zone to get ignition and once i remove that high temperature zone the flame goes out.
If anyone can guide me on how to sustain this flame to mimic actual experiments where once ignition is achieved the flame is sustained. Thanks.
I'm reading a paper about memory consolidation during sleep. It says "Replay of firing patterns in hippocampal neuron ensembles during sleep is a key feature of active systems consolidation". Is the replay of this firing pattern the same as it was originally formed? How can the brain replay such pattern without samples input?
Here is the article:
Mechanisms of systems memory consolidation during sleep | Nature Neuroscience
If yes, i need a reference.
I am proposing to introduce steam driven cookstoves instead of LPG cookers to overcome the community suffering current issue of LPG in my country. It is planning to operate a cluster of stoves in urbanized area through centrally located biomass fired steam boiler. I have quite manageable knowledge, skills and experiences in thermal engineering such as steam generation, distribution, boiler operation etc. But lack of in steam operated domestic stoves/cockers. I would appreciate, if any expert can help me either to design or purchase such product or contact of such dealers.
Thanks,
Burnt bricks are used so that the building remains intact in case of a fire; burnt bricks don't burn.
I'm not talking about the fire statistics
More precisely, it is talking about people's behavior with the building and the behaviors that are formed in it.
Looking forward to receiving your comments
Thank you
Fire ignition is a unique result process of many sort of different fires, but according to the conventional definition of fire triangle simplifying fire as the presence of three elements only (fuel, heat & oxygen), then chemical reaction was added at some stage, as a fourth element, even it’s a process of the existing three elements, it is not a true element on its own. However the remaining issues that need to be questioned are:
- How much of each element can cause fire ignition …?
- How could this be estimated or measured …?
- Would electric fires i.e. have the same amounts of each elements like any other inflammable substance’s fires …?
- Why (low humidity) or (dryness) is not part of fire elements …? Since high humidity can cause high temperature but wouldn’t necessarily ignite fire…!
- Why (high pressure) is not among fire element’s list…?
The world-leading maritime insurance company Allianz reported 178 vessels were lost due to fire/explosion between Jan - Dec in 2021, generalising that is one every second day. Fires at sea are increasing by almost 10% year on year. I hope to estimate the dollar value of these costs to propose research in maritime firefighting technology.
Battery explosion or burning of the electric bus was a new type of fire for the vehicles. How to put out this type of fire if there is any passenger in the vehicle?
Please see:
In khyber pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan in last month about 280 forest there occurred fire. Some people says it's naturally due to very high day temperatures but other says it's man made. What is the researcher thinking about this it's naturally or artificially?
I am an upcoming researcher and this is going to be my first research. My research involve that why all countries preferably India are extensively building up a swarm of drones in every field like agriculture, fire fighting, surveillance , etc.
Please suggest me that whether this topic is valid or not and how to approach towards it .
I want to calculate the required PSVs for a plant with several distillation column, vessels and reactors, connected together. But before that I need to estimate relief load of each one of them under different scenarios like power failure or fire.
I need a reliable standard or reference for relief load calculation.
Is it possible to calculate with following given data? outlet temperature and pressure of steam, capacity of boiler, Diameter of pipeline.
A colleague is interested in the problem of mega-fires. If there are scientific papers for the United States, Australia or France, there is little research for South America. In France, a mega fire can be identified from 1,000 ha, in the United States or Australia from 10,000 ha.
Are there any studies in South America (e.g. Chile)?
Are there objective criteria for defining a mega fire?
Many thanks!
Hi everyone !
I'm working as an intern in fire safety engineering , and i have a question regarding something that i've read. It was in a previous fire safety study (for a steel column fire stability ) and it was said : "preliminary calculations ensured that a generalized fire would generate maximum thermal stresses around the column".
I don't really understand the meaning and don't know if that is possible to do ?
And if it is, how can we do that ?
Thank you !
I try to model RC slab Strengthening with High Performance Concrete under Fire using abaqus.the epoxy resin was used as bond between the two concrete layer. When define d the epoxy resin that used as cohesive material in heat transfer model an error occurs 850 element missing its materials properties. So which model is used for modeling epoxy in heat transfer model?
I am looking for up-to-date publications about the performance of Canadair aircraft in reducing fire front intensity and in particular the value of intensity in kW/m. The few references I know are very dated. Can anyone help me?
What is the impact of large fire emissions on satellite and in-situ (ARGO floats) Chl a measurements?
How accurate are satellite observations of surface ocean Chl a during large fire events (close and at increasing distance to the fire emission source)?
Is there a consensus on correction to be applied in that regard?
This is the flue gas composition from the Ammonia fired furnace which I have modeled in Aspen Plus. Does anyone have any idea about NOx emissions? Is this emission amount of emission accepted by the EPA?
Dear all,
I am developing a code to analysis concrete structures in Fire condition and I know the effect of high temperature on the behavior of concrete. But I don't know the implementation.
Do you know any algorithm to describe that how I can implement the temperature dependent constitutive law for concrete in FEM?
Best Regards,
I'm doing research study among the fire Brigade, police personals, and municipal Corporation workers.
What word I can use to describe the above population..
Hi all, I was wondering why people bin the EPSP slope to construct a firing probability curve in both field and single-cell recordings. I assume it is a way to avoid any contamination by the action potential but I feel like I'm falling short on how to explain the mechanism here. Any thoughts and references are welcome.
Coordinates,AOD, Angstrom parameter or smth.
Hi,
For our bachelor's thesis in ECE, we are creating a fire alarm monitoring system using ANFIS similar to the links below:
We have been stuck with our data and unable to train it with ANFIS because we have no clue as to how the fire chance was determined. Does anyone know how the Chances of True Fire (%) is computed?
Any help is deeply appreciated.
We are working on a piping sprinkle fire supression system for an %100 electrical bus.Currently we are using C02(g) for physical suppression with 50 bar but we can not obtain the measurment in barometer. First do you have an advice for this problem ? Second is there any other suppression option for this type of vehicle ?
I need ASTM E-119-(19 or 18 or 20) Standard Test Methods for Fire Tests of Building Construction and Materials.
Kindly if any one have these codes in pdf file kindly share with me.
very thankful to you.
Describe the working principle of an ioT based smart fire detection system with automatic water sprinkler
Hello everyone.
I am encountering some problems while chasing after the convergence of my model.
I am using Ansys APDL in order to model the creep in steel under high temperatures.
I already did all the code, but I cannot find the issue.
All the geometry is very simple, just a cantilever beam under tension stresses.
The material model is composed by the multilinear elastic model, multilinear isotropic hardening model, creep model (time hardening P+S) and thermal strains.
The solution is divided in three stages:
- applying the uniform temperature;
- applying the force;
- enabling the creep effect by turing the rate on.
Even though, there is no convergence, and the log file keeps showing this:
"Material property EX of material 1 of element 2 is evaluated at a temperature of -14571.8048, which is below the supplied temperature range. Temperature range checking terminates."
Due to the excessive amount of errors and warnings, the program terminates. I've already looked in lots of discussions and could not find any situation similar to mine.
Here is what my solution steps looks like:
/SOLU
ANTYPE,0
NLGEOM,ON
OUTRES,ALL,ALL
NROPT,FULL
DK,1, , , ,0,UX,UY,UZ,ROTX,ROTY,ROTZ,
!-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FK,3,FZ,1000
SBCTRAN
RATE,OFF
TIME,1e-8
AUTOTS,1
NSUBST,100,10000000,10
KBC,0
SOLVE
!-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
/SOLU
NLGEOM,ON
OUTRES,ALL,ALL
NROPT,FULL
BFL,ALL,TEMP,500
SBCTRAN
RATE,OFF
TIME,0.10
AUTOTS,1
NSUBST,100,10000000,10
KBC,0
SOLVE
!-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
/SOLU
NLGEOM,ON
OUTRES,ALL,ALL
NROPT,FULL
RATE,ON
TIME,1000
AUTOTS,1
NSUBST,100,10000000,10
AUTOTS,1
KBC,0
SOLVE
Anyhow, I've attached the .txt file (sorry for the portuguese comments, they help me to go through the problem).
If someone could give me a help, I'd be very grateful!
Kind Regards,
Arthur
I am trying to build a model and simulate vegetation change using the fire polygons from the past 36 years. However, the main problem that I am having is to move the randomly selected different fires within the study area. I need to get the high severe fire within a fire boundary and be able to move it randomly and rotate it in the landscape.
I would appreciate any guidance to solve this issue.
Dear all,
Do you know any relation between tensile strength of concrete and temperature?
I want to calculate the tensile strength of concrete at high temperature by having tensile (or compressive) strength at room temperature.
Best regards.
Please help, I am a graduating student doing my bachelor's thesis and our research includes using ANFIS to minimize false alarms in fire detection. We are using temperature, smoke, and carbon monoxide sensors to detect fire. In real time, the values from these sensors will be the input to ANFIS and if fire is detected, output will be visual (flashing LED) and audio (buzzer) alarms. We are going to use python for training (unfortunately, we don't have MATLAB) and the ANFIS controller will be deployed to a Raspberry Pi 4. What IDE do you recommend? Do you know any libraries or sources that can help? Also, can this setup detect cooking or smoking as false alarm?
Hello,
We are making a liposomal cream in our lab . We are mixing around 30% ethanol, liposomes, water among other substances where we are subjecting it to 200 bar. I understand that ethanol/water mixture (20% ethanol) has an average flash point of 22 degree Celsius.
1. Would this pose as a hazard in a lab setting?
Which pressure sensors are most suitable to measure combustion instability in rocket motor firing tests?
Now I'm dealing with ANSYS V12 about R.C beams under thermal effects (under standard fire curves) .
My question . I defined variable stress strain curves for both concrete and steel reinforcement and also the other properties then the model was solved but the results are less than the experimental results where the deflection in model is about 38mm while the experimental one is 180mm also the temperature on the beam surface in ANSYS is 50 degree centigrade while in the experimental one is 900 degree centigrade ,,, any help please?
Dear all,
I want to analysis a beam under fire condition by developing a code based on finite element method (FEM). I have some problem with calculation of axial force in the beam due to temperature change. Do you know a good source which has explained the algorithm in detail?
Best regards
Can we combine fire pumps for High Velocity Water Spray system, hydrant system and Sprinkler system.?
I Want to design water base fire protection system for Substation & Oil type transformer having oil about 25000 ltr. Substation is having fire pump with diesel driven pump requirement. Wanted to understand correct approach for design of fire fighting system.
Selection criteria of fire pump flow rate, head for above application while combining.
Selection criteria Fire Water tank capacity for all application.
A 3d model of a four-layer composite is developed to predict the temperature levels of each layer during fire/elevated temperature conditions. Due to the larger thermal expansion coefficients, a coupled temp-displacement analysis was used with Nlgeom to incorporate the geometrical changes that occurred during the fire.
However, my results do not include the effect of modified geometry. Have anyone else encountered such an issue? If anyone could advise me, that would be really helpful.
Dear community :
iam working on forest fire risk of emission where we used static variables of interest In GIS (slope ,climate,vegetation,fire intensity) fire frequency is included in the model .
how to use Monte Carlo simulation in arcgis or any software to validate the Model .(if its the right way to validate it )
Actually i want to know the specific items which are emitted from the firing thing/from the burning thing.
I'm trying to programmatically calculate the Burned Area Index (BAI) for photos that include the following 6 bands: Blue, Green, Red, NIR, RedEdge and Thermal.
After researching a bit, I noticed that, when it comes for fire remote sensing, the NBR index is more popular and preferred.
However, I cannot calculate the NBR, as it requires the SWIR band, which I do not have.
My questions are:
1) Why nobody talks about Burned Area Index ? I haven't found a single programmatic example that calculates it. I've also didn't find many studies that talk about it or any examples of people calculating it with a software. Most people go with the NBR for some reason. Is there something I'm missing?
2) Is there any other index (or a combination) that could be used to remote sense fire, other than BAI or NBR (which I cannot calculate) ? For example, could the NDVI provide a fairly accurate indication of burned scars on an area?
Hello, I am modeling rc slab subject to fire on its tension side in the first step, and i have to apply load after fire on it as a second step, the question is how to apply this load knowing that there is no possibility to define static step after heat transfer step ?
thank you...
what are the ways to improve the fire resistance of the carbon steel cellular beams and make it equivalent to the fire resistance property of austenitic steel
I am looking for a simple empirical fire model that includes the general principles. A fire is controlled by the presence of fuel, supply air and heat from the flame causing pyrolysis for solid fuel and evaporation for liquid fuel, see figure.
As a consequence, a fire (size or growth) may be controlled by limiting air supply, removing fuel or cooling. I found several papers on numerical analysis of pyrolysis for specific fuels including detailed chemistry, but I am interested in a more empirical approach that is applicable in a more general way.
Hello honorables,
Please I am designing a study that investigates the linkage between certain health outcomes and wildfire-driven air pollution. Is there a simple way we can derive these air pollutants from fire ignition points?
Thank you for your invaluable suggestions.
For example, I know that FWI has been adapted for Mediterranean forests (DOI: 10.1007/s11069-014-1397-8). Do you know similar studies for Arctic regions?
Thank you
"THIS IS AN ABSOLUTELY SCIENTIFIC QUESTION"
Firefighting drones in buildings have been developed for some years on their own, that is, without the military's "fabulous and generous budgets" for killer drones.
Machines that can actually save lives instead of taking lives.
The Chinese company EHang Holdings Limited, has been developing manned drone vehicles. One of its new products is the EHang 216F (Firefighting Model) designed to fight fires in big cities.
Tell us your scientific opinion on use of manned drones for firefighting?
PLEASE ANSWER IN ENGLISH ONLY.
VERY IMPORTANT: Participate only if you are original, be yourself give your opinion, do not put links or texts from "Genio Google" or things found out there on the web! No one has any interest in stupid web answers, if that's the case, please be so kind as to ignore this debate!
SOURCE LINKS: