Science topic

Applied Mineralogy - Science topic

Explore the latest questions and answers in Applied Mineralogy, and find Applied Mineralogy experts.
Questions related to Applied Mineralogy
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
7 answers
I wanted to determine the mineral depositional type at the area marked with green (Maran, Pahang - Central Belt of Peninsular Malaysia). The regional geology study shows the mineral deposition of this area is mainly in metasediment. There are 2 mines nearby the study area which are the RED and the PURPLE. I wonder is it possible to determine the mineral depositional type of my study area based on the nearby deposition type?
RED - Skarn type deposits copper mine (Au is very less)
PURPLE - VHMS type deposits gold mine
ORANGE - Normal fault (NW - SE trend) associate with serial of synclines (NE - SW trend)
Relevant answer
Answer
Of course...that is how scientific exploration works. Otherwise you have to keep re-inventing the wheel. The real question is not "type" but what you say about it. I attach a little "cartoon" I made regarding a major porphyry copper deposit in Chile. Having proposed a coherent geological mechanism involving a mine and a process...in this case copper bearing magmatism associated a proposed tectonic detachment feature, now I try to tie local deposits together. They may all be different types but they might fit into a larger process that you can use to predict or explain. You might find skarns here and dikes there or the remnants of a leakage pattern in a "fault" but they are part of a whole...assuming, of course the respective age dating allows it.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
3 answers
Bit of background… Geotechnical engineering in mining focus on broader classification (RQD, Q, RMR etc). The makeup of rocks grouped in these classifications and other classes like lithology can vary significantly. For example, some data I’ve looked has a range of 40% iron content for an individual lithology. I would expect something like iron influence rock mass strength, an influence which would be masked if not lost, when relating the broader categories to excavation performance.
Relevant answer
Answer
All of the points listed above can be applied also to underground mining works with some adaptations to the individual stoping designs and types of mineral deposits
HGD
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
1 answer
I am working to Determine Entrainment in Flotation of Minerals.
What are the problems of Determine Entrainment in Flotation of Minerals? And how do I fix them?
In general, what suggestions do you have for reducing the Entrainment in Flotation of Minerals?
Relevant answer
Answer
particle size, density, and shape are the most sensitive factors in the entrainment. However, the particle size is still the most critical one; the more fineness of particles, the more entrainment. However, the simultaneous presence of fines and ultrafine particles will make a problem in the separation degree. There are also other factors such as flotation operating conditions and froth properties. There are many methods to reduce the entrainment, however, the enlargement of the particle size of gangue minerals is the most successful factor by the selective aggregation of hydrophilic gangue minerals.
I recommend the following paper that will be more beneficial for you.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
6 answers
Geometallurgical knowledge should be integrated into advanced process control and optimisation systems (APC) from a plant-wide to a mine-wide perspective. In order to understand the synergy between geometallurgical data (for instance mineral liberation, texture, mineralogy, geochemistry), plant Key Parameter Indicators (product particle size, recoveries, circulating loads, etc), and process control objectives in mineral processing operations, plant-and-material sampling and characterisation campaigns are necessary.
  1. The challenge of integrating these pieces of information (especially mineral liberation) into APC in real-time lies in the technological limitations, specifically the availability of online sensors).
  2. A standard solution for considering this type of non-measurable variables are model-based state observers (Hodouin, 2011 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jprocont.2010.10.016), i.e. a virtual instrument or soft sensor that provides an estimate of a given state of a real system based on available measurements, for instance, more fundamental sensors such as Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS), X-ray fluorescence (XRF), X-ray diffraction (XRD), Raman spectroscopy (RS), and hyperspectral imaging (HSI), to name a few. These provide extremely valuable information that can be translated into ore texture, mineralogy, geochemistry and physical properties.
  3. Although there are commercially available sensors (LIBS, XRF, XRD, RS,HSI), the capital and operation costs may be prohibitive in the sense that the companies concern (as everyone would do) about the investment not paying off.
Relevant answer
Answer
My thinking for geometallurgy is that it is used to select and blend the feed material to the process plant to maximise throughput, product quality, or economic factors by removing uncertainty of the future outcome of processing the ore. Online or real time analysis (ie measuring the plant performance) is only measuring the outcome, enabling feedback to the planning process, or limited feed forward control.
Online analysis (of whichever type) is a powerful tool to reduce uncertainty of the plant performance and enables feed forward control. Geometallurgy is an important component of plant performance, but more so to the understanding of the plant performance with certain ore types which typically falls into the process control side of things more than geometallurgy.
I.e. it is easy to lump everything into geometallurgy as ultimately it does prescribe how an ore is going to behave, but that is like saying it is Gods will, it is way to general and not helpful. The geometallurgy therefore needs to be defined if it is related to ore blending from the pit, a specific process plant step, or combination of, which will determine the cost and complexity of executing it.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
6 answers
I know that this is a very difficult question, as the areas of application can vary greatly. However, if you want to operate low as well as high resolution (from a few millimeters to nanometers), need the highest possible beam current for analysis, but also very flexible with regard to large samples or non-conductive samples (low vacuum device), a whole series of devices or manufacturers fall out, as far as I know. If you don't want to constantly change pressure stage apertures, the only manufacturer I can think of at the moment is Zeiss.
Relevant answer
Answer
Tijmen Vermeij : you do not exactly know which type of FEI -SEM would be beneficial? I've heard, Mira4 shall be also able to switch between low and high vacuum?
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
27 answers
I've put a photo of mineral that I do not know.
This mineral generally occurred near the contacts of chromite lenses on the surface of serpentine foliation like sheet Silicates. The color shows copper or bronze and metallic luster but it is a very strange formation such a mineral in a sheeted form especially in serpentinized dunite!
Relevant answer
Answer
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
I would be grateful if anyone could provide me with the heat capacity coefficients of Ca[B3O4(OH)3] · H2O colemanite. Thanks.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Valentini
I am looking for standard heat capacity Cp of colemanite. If you found it, would you share it with me.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
8 answers
My mafic meta-volcanic rocks can be devided into two groups. Group 1 rocks are distinct from Group 2 as displayed by their markedly higher concentrations of Fe2O3T (18.5-18.6 wt.%), TiO2 (3.5 wt.%) and P2O5 (1-1.1 wt.%), lower MgO (5.1-5.2 wt.%) and lower silica contents (SiO2 = 43.6%-44.3 wt.%). And the higher concentrations of the incompatible elements (i.e., Zr, Y, Nd, Sm, Nb and P) and lower concentrations of compatible elements (i.e., Cr and Ni) in Group1 are also distinct from Group 2. These features are similar to the Fe-Ti basalts which are characterized by iron- and titanium enrichment (FeOT>12 wt.%, TiO2>2 wt.% and FeOT/MgO>1.75) but silica depletion (Sinton et al., 1983; Hunter and Sparks, 1987; Furnes et al., 1998; Jang et al., 2001; Harper, 2003; Qian et al., 2006). Because of the absence of Fe-Ti oxides phenocrysts, most researchers consider that the high concentrations of iron and titanium were not caused by the cumulus Fe-Ti oxides, and the Fe-Ti basalts are interpreted to be products of moderate to high degree of Fenner trend differentiation of basaltic magma at low oxygen fugacity (Jang et al., 2001; Xu et al., 2001; Qian et al., 2006). However, there are many Fe-Ti oxide phenocrysts in my samples, and no cumulate structures were observed in my samples. So it is hard to get the conclusion that they were formed from the cumulation process, I  want to konw which process can cause this geochemical features. 
Relevant answer
Answer
I recently published on high Fe-Ti amphibolites at Broken Hill, Australia.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
Ladies and gentlemen, I have a favor to ask of you. If you've collected beautiful and back-corrected EBSD patterns of preferably non-cubic phases... could you send them to me along with the information about the projection center (pattern center + detector distance)? If this information is not available, it doesn't matter... It would also be nice to know the diffracting phase, but even that is not necessary if the pattern looks good. The resolution should not be lower than 400x300 pixels. In any case, it doesn't necessarily have to be high resolution patterns. The image format is irrelevant. I want use the patterns for tests regarding crystal lattice description (approximate lattice parameters and crystal symmetry). If I should use the patterns later in publications you can be sure that I will refer to you. Thanks in advance!
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Mehran, actually not since they cannot be processed as three-dimensionally periodic.crystals. I am more intested in mineralogical samples which contain numerous phases so that people should have access to patterns of many different phases.
Which symmetry does the quasicrystal have?
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
14 answers
Is there any (real) advantage of a hexagonal grid used during orientation mapping? And if yes, is there any paper which discusses and proves this in comparison to a regular map? And why all other companies do not use this (inclusive other mapping software like ASTAR in TEM) ?
Relevant answer
Answer
@ Bogdan: there is mainly one reason what irritates me: except of EDAX no other company does not care about this obviously irrelevant advantage. Theoretically, benefits might exist, but why standard grain size analysis in microscopy does not use a hexagonal grid as well. And even if this would be disadvantageousl isn't it counterproductive, if EBSD uses a hexagonal grid which might be better, but which is then also not comparable to other techniques? Standard procedures do not have to be "correct" or deliver the "true" wvalue(who knows what is true?) but a universally accepted value.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
8 answers
Invite a discussion on quantification of minerals in thin section and their correlation with XRD quantification using Rietveld Method for Quantitative Phase Analysis.
1. Different Approaches for quantification of minerals in thin section
2. Can we compare mineral quantification in thin sections with XRD quantification?
3. How to approach these techniques combined?
4. Or what is the relevance of other geo-chemical procedure such as Rittmann’s norm for stable mineral assemblage (or any other).
5. Accuracy of other mineral quantification techniques (when compare to thin section analyses) !
Relevant answer
Answer
1. Different Approaches for quantification of minerals in thin section
It depends on the grain size and the orientation of your thin section relative to the texture, especially in metamorphic and sedimentary rocks showing any cleavage or bedding, respectively
2. Can we compare mineral quantification in thin sections with XRD quantification?
Only if the grain size is suitable for microscopic studies and no anisotropic systems are involved. On the other hand for the Rietveld Method you need precise crystallographic data, particularly for phyllosilicates.
3. How to approach these techniques combined?
I do not understand your question. Any combination is recommended
4. Or what is the relevance of other geo-chemical procedure such as Rittmann’s norm for stable mineral assemblage (or any other).
Norm (Rittmann, Niggli) calculation is always an artificial composition and different from the modal content.
5. Accuracy of other mineral quantification techniques (when compare to thin section analyses) !
It depends on your experience but I would not work with decimal figures and exaggerate the accuracy
With kind regards
H.G.Dill
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
14 answers
These photos taken at Sandstone layer . Please can somebody help me in the identification of these concentric and parralel laminations ? And which is the origin of this process ? NB : outcrops located on the coast influenced by marrine erosion.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Dr. Idries
These fine-grained sandstones show a rock parting on a different scale and intensity which allows the infiltration of (meteoric) fluids to a different extent and leave behind a residue of Fe-oxide hydrates (“limonite”). The latter “mineral” gives rise to the concentric structures resembling the contour lines of topographic map which reflect the different altitudes. It is a near-surface (supergene) process.
With kind regards
H.G.Dill
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
7 answers
Are there any specific minerals related to baddeleyite like the relationship between zircon and biotite minerals?
Relevant answer
Answer
I have found a paper, Zu et al. (2008), including baddeleyite images under microscopes in serpentinite samples.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
13 answers
These are thin-section photomicrograp of Continental Carbonate rocks ( XPL and PPL). Can somebody help me in the identification of minerals marked by red arrows ?
Thank you very much in advance.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr Saber,
I agree with prof. Dill. These grains looks impurities released during the polishing of your thin sections. In your image 3-PPL, fibres from tissues used during the cleaning of your thins section are still attached to the surface. when you clean it it will disappear.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
15 years after the introduction of CCD-based EBSD detectors a new camera technology enters the EBSD world. It is hard to believe, the formerly demonised CMOS chips are now the saviours of the EBSD market. In contradiction to all prevously made statements CMOS are now not only faster but also more sensitive and less noisy. Well, companies are (primarily) not founded to make scientists happy. They need to sell in order to survive (or make their shareholders happy), and if the market does not increase as expected a new technology is very welcome to increase the business ono this way.
In fact, I believe that the spec sheets of the new detectors are credible, but how the detectors really work in practice? Are there some users which have direct comparisons? How profitable is the change if one considers the comparatively huge price?
Relevant answer
Answer
The speed might be really one argument... On the other hand, does speed really helps? For drift, 3D measurements (although I am not sure how useful they often really are), sensitive sample etc. However, my impression is that we already now generate too many measurements without analyzing them carefully enough. If something does not look like it should: take another measurement :-)
Anyway, with which detector did you measure before (or still) in your institute? I mean, I wonder when I hear that you still do overnight measurements. We don't do this anymore for a decade. And huge maps only make trouble when you want (re)analyze them. Therefore, my common maps are 640x480 or often simply 400x300. This takes already with an old detector about 30min (if you really squeeze the last accuracy out), i.e. not speed but precision optimized measurements. Otherwise it would take only a few minutes with the previous detector generation.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
6 answers
The backscattering of electrons obviously happens with the core of the atoms or ions. If it is related to the mass I would expect an impact of protons and neutrons. If it is an impact of the charge (quite unlikely since plus and minus should attract each other) it should be proportional to the the protons only (i.e. Z, the atomic or periodic number). Nevertheless, it is not a single event since we have a practically unlimited number of interactions which should be related to the number of atoms (cores). This would bring the packing or mass density (or in first approximation the materials density) into the business. This from my present point of view very logical conclusion is in strict contradiction to experimental observations: comparing lead (density around 10g/cm³) and gold (density around 20g/cm³ ), lead has a higher backscatter coefficient. Does anybody have an idea, why the backscatter coefficient scales with Z and not with the density...or something else like a proton-density since the mass density also considers the neutrons?
Relevant answer
Answer
If we talk about the tabulated backscattering coefficient of the element, it cannot contain contribution from the packing, otherwise we would have to have a special coefficient for each compound that contains this element. For example, density of the gold-containing compounds can range from 3 to 20 g/cm3. It is much more convenient to separate the contributions from the element and packing, providing the former in the database and calculating the latter every time from the known structure.
As for the driving force, it is Z. But the electron does not have to hit the nucleus directly. The classical analogy is movement of the long-period or non-periodic comets in the Solar system: the purely attractive gravitational interaction forces them to turn around the Sun and leave the inner part of the system with high 'scattering angle'.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
8 answers
We measured a microstructure of hydrothermal Au by EBSD and EDS which contains locally a small amount of Ag. The pure gold areas are not separated as grains but obviously linked to large angle grain boundaries only, see the attached image. Has anybody seen a similar microstructure or can explain the occurence of (secondary) Au?
Relevant answer
Answer
I recommend Shirley's answer
Best Regards
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
46 answers
We've just analysed a microstructure of a cubic closed-packed (fcc) material. As visible from the color-coded IPF map (Y parallel to the long axis of the grains) the aspect ratio of the grains is quite high so that I would expect a fiber texture. Surprisingly, the related pole figures do not show a very pronounced texture. I already considered a half width of 10° in order to get something like a smeared pole distribution. There is certainly no "homogeneous" distribution (MUD=5) but the maxima are more related to a few major texture components than to a fibre. To me it seems that the number of grains is too small for a description of the really existing texture.
Has anybody observed already a similar phenomenon? Grains with a high aspect ratio but no "matching" texture? What could be the reason?
The materials has not been heat-treated!
Relevant answer
Answer
This is not answering your central question, but why do you insist that there is no thermal gradients during growth. Shouldn't growth involve some form of latent heat evolution which needs to be conducted away from the growing interface.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
I would like to know how should I determine the price of the possible monazite sand? I do have an ICP-Mass test result which indicates elements present (attachment). For a feasibility study I need to determine the price for the raw sand but I do not know any guidelines or references to do so.
Suggestions are more than welcome.
Relevant answer
Answer
Prepare a composite sample of the heavy mineral sand, representing overall average composition of a survey part of the sand deposit. Determine both total heavy mineral wt. % and individual heavy mineral wt. %, by sequential processing of the sample comprising dil.. HCl treatment, drying, wt. loss, magnetite separation, weighing, magnetic and heavy liquid like bro mo form separation of different si eve fractions.
Estimate wt. % of different h.m. in each fraction and sum up respective wts. to
get wt. of each important h.m. and total h.m. Get the price of each important h.m. from the current market prices and calculate rough value of the ton n age of each important h.m. and for the total deposit at about 80% recovery.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
10 answers
Usually the chemistry (Elemental composition) by Rietveld results is not correlating with Chemical assays (XRF or Whole Rock Analysis). When I refine my diffractogram, using scale refining, i'm matching  more or less the Rietveld  chemistry, however to hold the visual match and good GOF I refine (constrained) the occupancies. Is it right?  
Relevant answer
Answer
More essential are factors related to crystallographic texture. Only if you can exclude these factors I would think about occupation and substitution. Only because something is mathematically possible it does not make sense, automatically. Also a better fit does not say that the produced results are better of more reliable. This has been discussed already many times. Only refine parameters you can confirm by other techniques. Many parameters have been implemented for a very special problem and are not valid for a general application.
First, it would be the best if you would post a diffractogram so that we could evaluate what would make sense.  
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
14 answers
I did check the ammonium containg two different samples such as 2:1 clay mineral and jarosite in XRD, FTIR, EA/IRMS analysis .
and I have a plan to SEM analysis for 2:1 clay mineral  (i.c. Montmorillonite, nontrite, saponite etc..) and jarosite. 
How to distinguish between above the  two samples on the SEM images, for mineral structure or texture?  
And also, how to estimate that dioctahedral or trioctahedral type for 2:1 clay mineral on TEM analysis? I don't know whether it is possible or not.
Of course, i confrimed at 060 peak in XRD analysis..
anybody, teach me above my current issues..
Relevant answer
Answer
XRD is efficient
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
Using Ti for the calculation, various geochemical process might add or subtract Ti in zircons, as inclusions, overgrowths, mantled e.t.c. Ti-rich mineral or fluids can be incorporated, thus does give any meaning on the crystallization history. What is the opinion of experts in this field.
Relevant answer
Answer
The Ti-in-zircon model of Watson was modelled for crystallized magmas saturated in Ti (i.e., rutile-bearing). Outside these conditions, the geothermometer is not valid.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
when I study the  evolution of barck-arc basin magma, we find some melt inclusions in plagioclase have much higher silca than matrix glass from andesite,why?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello Ji Qiang,
    I liked your question, but I don't have a good answer.
   Could you perhaps clarify a space-progression as forearc, arc, backarc with regards to the chemical abundances? How significant and consistent or universal is the possible progression? there should be some space ordering relation.
Felipe
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
I have been working on research about gold characterization so, I got a few questions regarding on my research that I curious to know such as; 
i) Is there any standard range value for LOI if the gold was characterised as carbonaceous gold ore?
ii)What is standard temperature normally used for LOI test on gold ore sample?  
iii) Let say if the Carbon element was detected on every spot of the gold rock sample in SEM/EDX analysis with the high percentage, does it mean the gold sample belonged to carbonaceous gold ore based on the SEM/EDX result?
Thanks.
Relevant answer
Answer
standard temperature normally used for LOI test is different depend on rock type For example, organic matter is oxidized to carbon dioxide and ash at temperatures between ~200 and 500ºC.
Further evolution of carbon dioxide from carbonate mineral forms occurs at temperatures between approximately 700 and 900ºC
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
rock compositions of sampling area are mainly clay silt, sandstone, conglomerate etc.  sample depths : 50-650cm,  yellowish brown color.
i want to know peak position  (2θ,  near 9º ?, 12-13º ?, 15º ?, 17-18º?   , meybe 24-28º are quartz? frankly speaking, i'm not sure that .. 
 
just, i confirmed nitrogen contents all samples by EA/IRMASS analysis.  so, i suggest that the existence of K-bearing minerals such mica group or smectite group.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Jaeguk,
It usually depends sample preparation sensibility for clay fractions and XRD on clay fractions for untreated, ethylene glycolated and heated to know the specific clay type. Secondly, for quartz peaks it depends about specification of XRD equipment either it is Cu or Co. If it is Cu then 26.6, 20.85, 50.2, 60.09, 36.56 and 39.49 peaks are for quartz.
Thanks
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
8 answers
I follow the Niggli's diagrams for the amphibloite rocks which I am working on.
Could you help me how the Niggli ratio should be calculated?
Please let me know in details as well as an example.
Thanks.
Relevant answer
Answer
     Not today,but the petrological literature (mostly from Europe) till the mid to late seventies have used Niggli values for both igneous and metamorphic rocks. It would not be surprising if they are still used today. Niggli primarily used the values to describe magmas and not rocks. The Niggli norm/Barth Niggli norm is better than the CIPW norm, as it applicable to both metamorphic and igneous rocks. Certain parameters, for example, 'mg' approximates the Mg#, 'k' - alkalinity ratio, and 'w' - to calculate the oxidation of iron, are still useful.
     Are they still good parameters of geochemical association of rocks? Yes, if you construct a Niggli variation diagram and apply the interpretation indices devised by Niggli (as detailed in Petrochemical Calculations by Conrad Burri). The Niggli variation plot has the same limits as a Harker variation diagram - mainly applicable to co-magmatic rocks and set of lavas from a single volcano.   
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
7 answers
I'm trying to float oxidized zinc ores but the lead oxide (cerussite) was floated with the concentrate of zinc !!!
Relevant answer
Answer
Merci pour les liens
En effet le dichromate de sodium deprime la galene, mais je n'ai pas une idée claire sur son effet sur la cerussite qui est un carbonate de plomb (oxyde de plomb : terme industriel ) quant a la densité, la séparation densimetrique ou gravimetrique n est pas rentable dans ce cas d etude puisque la teneur du plomb ne depasse pas 2%.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
17 answers
It is well known that pyrite shows striations along <001>. Although cubic but according to the point group symmetry m-3 the striation is commonly only visible along one of the <001> on {100} or {210}. Invisible on {100} but on {210} is a change of striation which is called positive or negative. The positive is assumed to be || <001>, the negative is perpendicular to <001>, i.e., ||<-120>.
Is it possible that in the last case {210} is actually {120} and the striation is always || <001>? Is there any experimental confirmation known which shows that the formed dodecahedron plane is definitely the {210} or not perhaps in rare cases {120}?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Gert,
The {210} and {120} forms are seemingly twin related by the iron-cross law. This twinned crystals are abundant in special conditions of formation.
A nice paper on this issue appears soon in the Min.Mag.
regards, Istvan dodony
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
13 answers
I'm looking at altered volcanic tuffs hosting Cu-Zn-Co-Mn manto mineralization at the Boleo deposit, Baja California Sur, Mexico.  We are trying to find evidence of hot spring activity.  Silica deposits are very fine grained and have not yielded fluid inclusions yet, but we have what appears to be  carbonate-silica sinters with tubes lined with a coat of Fe-saponite (tentatively identified).  Other minerals present include gypsum, dolomite, Mn oxides, strontianite, and a few others.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear James, Illite, Mg-Chlorite and/or chamosite among others are clay minerals indicators of hydrothermal processes and can be discriminated from supergene clays by difference in geochemical composition, majors, traces and REEs (e.g., see the paper joined). See also the text book of Georges Millot (1970): The Geology of clays, Weathering, Sedimentology, Geochemistry. Springer Verlag, pp. 427. All the best, Anicet
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
6 answers
Is there any free software that can calculate tetrade effect, Eu, and Ce anomalies of rare elements?
Relevant answer
Answer
GCDKit is a very good option.
But i suggest to you to build by yourself an Excel file.
It will help you to verify also error propagation on paramenters such as Eu* Ce* and tetrad effects.
Formulas are vey easy to write, following the related papers.
Ciao
F
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
Hey guys,do you know any useful methods to define a adularia whitout obvious rhombic-like shapes? Raman or some other agents?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Bau,
adularia is a cryptoperthitic alkaline feldspar, often very inhomogeneous with monoclinic and triclinic domains and diffuse twinning. The K feldspar component used to be > Or80. The host mineral is microcline the inclusions albite. The striking difference to be recognized often with the unarmed eye is its X morphology called "adularia habit" with the prevaling faces (110) and (001) and a very small face labeled according to Miller´s indices (101-). You can also write the arrangement and size of faces as follows: (110)=(001)>>(101-). It formed in vugs and druses as low-temperature modification of the alkaline feldspar s.s.s. It is per se no mineral of its own but a crystallographic morpho-type of this feldspar series
Best regards
H.G.Dill
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
Antigorite, Lizardite and Chrysotile are serpentine minerals which have the same chemical composition but they are formed separately, so what are the conditions that control that?
Relevant answer
Answer
Have a look at  Andreani et al, 2007. This provides links to research on the role of reaction kinetics, P, T and tectonism of formation of the respective minerals species.
Jana
Andreani, M., A. Baronnet, A.-M. Boullier, and J.-P. Gratier (2004), A microstructural study of a crack-seal type serpentine vein, using SEM and TEM techniques, Eur. J. Mineral., 16, 585–595.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
6 answers
I am working on Columbite-Tantalite-Cassiterite deposit in West Africa. We have intersected numerous high grade Columbite and Tantalite mineralisation in our trenches on hill top grading over 1Kg/m3 with numerous +25mm grains (largest grain weighing 1.35 Kg). However when our trenches reaches the weathered pegmatite which we expect is source rock we do not find mineral grains. Is there any geological explanation for this? 
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Sillah,
Coltan grains respond in a way to weathering depending on the Nb-Ta ratio. Ta is much more released that Nb from columbite s.s.s., especially in kaolinite-enriched saprolite, than Nb.  One clue to the enigma you have to test your entire cross-section in the trenches down to the saprock and last but not least the unaltered pegmatite for homogeneity. This is achieved at its best by investigating the heavy mineral suite. The mineralogical composition and the morphology of the mineral grains will get you a bit closer to a solution. I am attaching some papers on this matter and will not go any further, because for some other pieces of advice I need to know the geomorphological setting with a full-blown insight into the drainage system and a bit more about the heavy minerals in question in the parent rocks, including pegmatites and their country rocks.
This unroofing story is often a very complex and multistage process which cannot be answered in a simple way. I hope that the papers and the general answer will help you come to grips with this issue in this initial stage of exploration.
Good luck !
Harald G. Dill
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
15 answers
How reliable is a determination of lattice parameters using a single electron backscatter diffraction pattern? Who determines lattice parameters in order to discover/identify a local phase, e.g. precipitates in a matrix? Is there any specific software available?
Thanks! 
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Gert Nolze,
My contribution to this discussion follows a side track.
1. For the study of preccipitation/transformation the study of lattice parameter changes, e.g. as a function of time, may provide valuable information.
2. For such purposes, high accuracy values of lattice parameters are more than welcome.
3. DeBije-Scherrer photographs combined with Nelson-Riley extrapolation provide lattice determinations with high accuracy, a tool that is often overlooked.
References:
1. Ageing of liquid-quenched ans solid-quenched Aluminium base alloys: analysis of lattice parameter variations, i.e. my thesis available via ResearchGate
2. a text book on X-ray diffractometry, e.g. H.P. Klug & L.E. Alexander, X-ray diffraction procedures, latest edition (2nd ed. John Wiley and Sons, New Yorik, 1974)
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
12 answers
I am trying to find a safer and cheaper way to separate heavy minerals. I heard that bromoform is highly toxic, SPT or LST are too expensive for sole researcher from Africa, is there another method I can try.
thank you 
Relevant answer
Answer
 I agree with Herald. The method also depends on the amount and size of the material to be processed. Larger quantities (several kg) are probably better pre-processed by some type of shaker table. Smaller quantities will do fine with other methods.
Bromoform is ok and I have used it many times. It is primarily classified as an environmental toxin. It can be reused multiple times though. It will be absorbed through skin and by inhalation. By using a fume hood and wearing disposable gloves you should be fine. For post processing acetone is used for washing your separated samples and the glassware. This wash has to be properly disposed.
While tetrabromoethane (TBM) is slightly less expensive than bromoform I find it much more toxic.
There is a new Open File report from the United States Geological Survey prepared by one of my students that deals with separation methods for heavy minerals. https://pubs.er.usgs.gov/publication/ofr20161022
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
8 answers
Q4. In below Pictures can Any one Identify The Mineral?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Asif:
Using the petrographic microscope and polarized light to identify minerals in thin sections makes use of a couple of optical and morphological properties. It cannot be shrinked to a comparison of colors and images. You must measure the extinction, determine the pleochroism, assess the birefrigence and the refraction indices. And first and foremost you must know where the samples come from and how they are interrelated with the associated lithologies. I have some ideas about your minerals in Q1 to Q4 but I think you should prior to this provide us with more basics, some of which I have mentioned here.
Best regards
H.G.Dill 
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
This is from quartzite sample.
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with Mr.Dill, it is muscovite. Regards, Anicet B.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
14 answers
it lookslike chloritoid but with bright interference colours
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with those who said it is an amphibole, probably a hornblende, but a chemical analysis is needed to identify which green amphibole it is.  Microprobe would be best, given the zoning that is present, but energy dispersive spectrometry on an SEM might be sufficient, and might be more readily accessible. Determination of the optical properties (all three refractive indices, optic sign, 2V, extinction angles, and orientation of the indicatrix might also be useful. 
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
2 answers
Ten 10 of the samples analyzed have values that range from 0.45 - 0.61 while 3 samples range from 0.51 - 0.59. I assume the samples analyzed are more of hydrogen - poor vitrinite A. I need more enlightenment on the subject.
Relevant answer
Answer
All organic macerals with lower reflectance than inertinite, and higher reflectance than liptinite are usually given the generic name vitrinite, and their reflectance is measured. For Ro measurements from coals, the situation is a little better, because hydrogen-rich vitrinite, such as desmocollinite, and hydrogen-poor vitrinite, such as pseudovitrinite, can be distinguished by comparing their reflectance and relief with those of telocollinite and semi-fusinite, which can be found easily in most humic coals. However, the problem still exists to some extent, because even the telocollinite in coals with high contents of desmocollinite or pseudovitrinite has relatively higher or lower initial hydrogen contents than that in “normal” coals.
In very good oil source rocks and coals deposited under marine influence, vitrinite macerals have higher initial hydrogen contents and lower maturation rates, and thus lower Ró values and, even with the same thermal histories, smaller ∆Ro values than telocollinites (on which Ro for coals is usually measured in “normal” coals). Thus, very good oil source rocks and marine coals will have highly-suppressed Ro values.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
11 answers
I obtained a chemical composition of a plagioclase grain in weight percentage using SEM-EDS technique. The recalculated chemical formula of the grain is as follows using an MSExcel worksheet based programme.
Na0.5Ca0.2Al1.1Si2.3O8
Here the charge balance is problematic. What could I have possibly missed here?
Thanks in advance 
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Tharanga,
Here is a copy of a paper that I authored with chemical formula of albite based on EPMA analyses from parent rock minerals in lateritic weathering profiles of Central Africa. Kind regards, Anicet
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
3 answers
The mineral, picroilmenite, which means ilmenite containing Mg. I want to ask whether this mineral could indicate the pressure conditions? Thanks a lot!
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Peng,
picroilmenite is an ilmenite enriched in Mg. The end member with a complete substitution of Mg for bivalent Fe is named geikielite. Mg-enriched ilmenite is not uncommon in Mg-enriched basic igneous and ultrabasic rocks, whereas the end-member type is rather rare and confined to ultramafic rocks.
H.G.Dill
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
Hello
i am collecting published lead isotope data for mineral deposits( mainly copper, zinc, lead,and tin) in the  Urals, Kazkahstan and Siberia(Altai, Minusinsk , Tuva and Baikal). Does anyone know which journals or books I should look for? Either  Enlgish or Russian publications are okay. 
Can someone suggest  any introduction books for tectonics and metallogenic provinces in Russia?
many thanks,
Gary
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Gary,
Please find enclosed book chapters about Pb isotopes. 
Best wishes
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
13 answers
Little info:
-These grains have been tested in the SEM with the EDAX attachment and the data reads as the following (on average):
20 - 25 wt. % Na, 20 wt. % Zn, 20 wt. % S, 5 wt. % Au
The rest of the total 100% is oxygen and carbon with trace elements filling up the rest.
This is an incredibly high amount of gold and I'm pretty sure that it is some kind of ZnS sphalerite, but the amount of Na is seriously throwing me off.
-p.s. the grains I'm talking about are the lighter grays with inclusions of some metal I'm unsure of.
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with Harry, the mineral is sphalerite, but there is an overlap between  NaKa 1.041eV and Zn La 1.009eV, and overlap between Au Ma 2.123eV and SKa 2.308eV SkB which need to be resolved and give you this high Na vlaue
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
3 answers
Hi, somebody had written about methamorphism of orto piroxenites?
Thanks alot in advance.
Greetings
Marco
Relevant answer
Answer
You might contact Dr. Ernesto Bjerg who has been working since long time ago on a well-known metamorphosed ultramafic igneous complex with ortopyroxenites (Las Águilas) in central Argentina.
Regards.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
I have the cif file of a certain crystal,I was wondering how I can do AE or BFDH calculation to get the morphology,is there a free software to do these sort of calculation?
Relevant answer
Answer
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
2 answers
Help me Transfer measured values of gamma activity of rocks from units API to system units SI, please
Relevant answer
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
2 answers
I'm looking for stability fields for variscite, wavellite, kidwellite and millisite, function of PO4, Al, Ca, Na and K availability.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Alves,
see the physical-chemical constants in:
Vieillard, P., Tardy, Y., Nahon, D., 1979. Stability fields of clays
and alumium phosphates: parageneses in lateritic weathering
of argillaceous phosphatic sediments. American Mineralogist
64, 626–634. Also consult: Stoffregen and Alpers (1987), Schwab et al. (1993, 1996) 
and further literature in:
Dill H. G. 2001. The geology of aluminium phosphates and sulphates of the
alunite group minerals: a review.-Earth-Science Reviews 53, 35–93.
Best regards
H.G.Dill
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
Dear all,
Recently I got a Cenozoic picrite sample containing a lot of olivine grains (Fig. 1).
The major element result of the picrite is:
SiO2 42.24
TiO2 1.50
Al2O3 10.02
Fe2O3T 11.50
MnO 0.18
MgO 19.51
CaO 8.64
Na2O 2.39
K2O 0.74
P2O5 0.61
LOI 2.04
Total 99.37
The whole rock composition represents a liquid + accumulated olivine.
The trace element result shows an OIB-type pattern, with significant depletion of K, Zr, Hf, Ti and Y, likely indicating a mantle source of carbonated peridotite (Fig. 2).
The olivine in the picrite are typical igneous origin. They have melt inclusions and high CaO content, and a very narrow rim with lower Fo value and higher CaO content (Fig. 3). The composition of the olivines in the picrite are homogeneous:
Na2O 0
NiO 0.229
K2O 0
SiO2 40.12
FeO 11.96
CaO 0.226
Al2O3 0.056
MnO 0.187
MgO 47.269
Cr2O3 0.04
TiO2 0.06
In order to calculate the mantle potential temperature and the depth of partial melting, I tried the software PRIMELT2.xls. The mantle potential temperature is ~1500 celsius degree. However, the calculated primary melt is balanced with Fo 91 olivine but not the measured olivine (Fo = 88)...
Relevant answer
Answer
The thermal gradient of eastern China varies dramatically, in general.  For example, NE China has a very high thermal gradient, hence the extensive graphite at the surface.  SE China has a lower thermal gradient.  Both produce oil & gas, but in isolated areas.  To answer your question:  it depends ...
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
12 answers
The samples of U-sandstones/siltstones consist of quartz and very fine grained matrix. The huge amount of quartz (60-90%) complicates a more detailed determination of ore-phases. These are bonded to the fine-grained matrix, which contains clay minerals and ore-phases (smaller than 1 μm). One of the possibilities is to remove quartz and thus to concentrate the uranium and uranium-bearing minerals. Many thanks for help!
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Mikysek,
I expected a mineralization of the Königstein-Hamr type which is really delicate and obviously not confined to the sandstone-hosted U deposits of Cretaceous age in and at the edge of the Bohemian Massif as you can infer from the photographs attached. Methods which make use of the surface characteristics of the grain such as flotation are fraught with difficulties as the outer part may be rich in zircon or the other way round in coffinite which form a s.s.s. I have dealt with these minerals, a playground for all those who want to find new minerals. There are combinations (I do not use in this case the technical term s.s.s.) of U titanates (e.g. brannerite, U "leucoxene") U-Ti silicates and the Zr-U mineral association documented in the attached file.  In your country U deposits most closely resembling this type to my present knowledge, which I studied at Poppenreuth, are located near Zadní Chodov (Hinterkotten) and to a lesser extent well represented in the Dyleň vein-type deposit.
In this case I would try to deprive the ore mineralization as  much as possible of its siliceous gangue. If you want to avoid the  non-toxic but expensive Na polytungstate make use of bromoform or tetrabromethane. It is cheap and used for commercial swim-sink procedures. Then try and elaborate a differential leaching procedure for the different grain size intervals. I know that the U silicates and titanates respond in a different way  to the solvents (HCl, HNO3..). It is not a simple job but it may work. I attempted it for getting material appropriate for U/Pb age dating. I think nobody can provide you with a nice flow sheet or family-tree of mineral processing. But these different ways, combining heavy-liquid separation and differential leaching will get you a step closer to the enrichement of one or the other mineral types. To achieve an almost pure fractions seems a hard nut to crack and not possible. But for age dating it should work as well as for a more detailed description of the minerals.
Glückauf !
H.G.Dill
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
1 answer
In the paper "The key role of mica during igneous concentration of tantalum" contributed by Stepanov et al., (2014), they summarized that "crystallization of 99.9 % of melts precipitating 10 % of muscovite might increase Ta/Nb by a factor of 8 and concentrate Ta to 760 ppm in the residual melt. I am confused how they get this conclusion and how they calculate that. I used the equation for Rayleigh crystallization but failed to get the same value.
Relevant answer
Answer
The calculation seems roughly correct. They use DNb =3.5 and DTa = 0.4 in muscovite. If the fractionating assemblage contains 10% muscovite, then the bulk D is 0.35 for Nb and 0.04 for Ta (assuming the other minerals do not take up any Nb or Ta, which is of course an oversimplification). The fraction of liquid remaining is 0.001 (as the crystallised fraction is 0.999). for Nb: Cl/C0= (0.001)^(.35-1) = 89. For Ta: Cl/C0 = (0.001) ^(0.04-1) = 759.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
I've noticed this visual attribute is a known indication of oxidised ASS. But I can't find any information on the geochemical nature of the material.
From the academics I've spoken to, they hazard a guess at it being an extremely disordered Fe-oxyhydroxide. Another suggestion included organics as a component due to the shiny-ness of the film.
Just wondering what other thought?
XRD analysis was performed on a sample yielding a mineralogy of vivianite, gypsum (both of these appearing in several other samples), then pyrite, ankerite and Al, which were unique to this sample. However there was a very high noise level on the pattern trace for this sample, so the reliability of these results are in question.
I've attached a pic. any help would be greatly appreciated as I'm so very curious.
thanks heaps
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Anne-Marie
The films are poorly crystalline Fe oxyhydroxide minerals formed by iron oxidising bacteria such as Leptothrix and Gallionella.  I can send you a paper on their mineralogy if you are interested
Regards
Steve Appleyard
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
16 answers
See the mass spectrum and the SEM image below.
Thanks for your help.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Löcse,
in reply to your question I am convinced that these data corroborate your idea of this APS mineral to be kemmlitzite or a kemmlitzite-enriched s.s.s.. To get some independant support for this idea, would you please so kind as to describe the environment of deposition, host rock lithology and mineralogical setting. Maybe I know the area, if it is from Central Europe and I can get a better impression on the physical-chemical regime and thus it is might be easier  to take a decision in favour or against the determinaton which is in this case placed upon a more secure basis.
Mit Glückauf !
H.G.Dill
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
20 answers
A dacitic rock sampled from a dike has a very fine grained, reddish mineral that gives brown color to this rock. This mineral is almost everywhere in the matrix of the rock. What could it be? An alteration product? 
Photos and photomicrographs are attached.
Thanks in advance!
Jovid.
Relevant answer
Answer
 I don't agree with any of the comments.  Looking at the thin-sections there is undoubtedly some iron oxide which could be magnetite, haematite or maghemite.  But the band of dark, undefined globular material with a reddish diffuse colouration, as well as the photo showing numerous films defining grain boundaries, is hydrated iron oxide, of which there are a few types differing in their crystallinity.  The hydrated iron oxides are the oxidation products not only of the oxides but also some of the ferromagnesian minerals.  It is typically the hydrated iron oxide specks which provide the reddish colouration to many volcanic rocks.  Determining the cause or causes and the timing of the oxidation and subsequent discolouration is another field of research
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
14 answers
we have gold in pyrite ore, we extract this gold by flotation, but some time we have with our ore kaolinite clay which interfere with gold in flotation and give and give us bad gold recovery.
Relevant answer
Answer
The method depends on quantity of clay in your ore and mode of it's occurrence.
First of all you may try attrition scrubbing the ore prior to milling, washing it in a perforated drum to remove clay from coarse crushed material. it will give you improvement in milling and flotation and increase flotation feed rate.
You may also use long cone cycloning on ground product if you have no gold/pyrite in fines. It will take most of the slimes out of the circuit.
To depress the clays in flotation you may try sodium silicate, sodium polyacrylate, starch, dextrin or other cellulose compounds using them before addition of collector and frother. NaSiO3 is probably the cheapest.
You can send us some samples to give you the most concrete solution.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
6 answers
The study of ore mineralization is difficult for the size of mineral phases (in μm), gel nature of components etc. Application of traditional geological instruments (EPMA, SEM, XRD) is often limited due to the low-grade ore, particle size or colloidal nature of uranium and uranium-bearing phases.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Mikysek,
The identification of the element content of micro grains smaller than 5 microns should not be a big problem.
The bottom line for the use of SEM and EPMA is the surface quality of the samples. The highest surface quality can be achieved with an ion beam cross section polisher. Latest SEM and EPMA analyzers can measure even element profiles in the nanometer range in very sensitive materials.
As an example, I show you here attached a SEM image of an arsenic sulfide surface which has been prepared with an ion beam cross section polisher and was analyzed by an SEM or EPMA quantitatively along a profile line. The tiny spherule (approx. 100 nanometers in diameter) is embedded in a matrix of arsenic sulfide.
Best regards,
Guenter Grundmann
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
21 answers
I have been observing a metamorphic rock that contain Almandine garnet using SEM-EDS. The presence of garnets is confirmed by the very rock's XRD patterns (both Pyrope and Almandine are present).
Element analysis (SEM-EDS) of various points on Almandine/pyrope shows the following general chemical composition in wt%
Na - 0 - 1%      K - 0 - 1 %  Al - 17-19%
Mg - 4 -7 %     Si - 25 - 30%
Ca - 4 -1 %     (Total)Fe - 30 - 35 %
Strangely, Sulphur is there ranging 0 to 2%
Is it natural to have Sulphur in garnet? and are Na, K, Mg and Ca inter exchanging with each other?
Additional Info (XRF analysis (FP method) shows S element about 1.6 wt%. but XRD does not show any peak for possible Sulphur bearing minerals such as  pyrite or gypsum. Still the rock samples have strong sulphur smell).
Thank you in advance
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Udagedara,
Using SEM-EDS is not suitable for accurate chemical analyzes of garnet.
Exact quantitative chemical analysis of garnet are possible only with an electron beam microprobe.
In almandine garnet may be present, the trace elements:
Sodium, potassium, chromium, vanadium and in very minor quantities, scandium, yttrium, europium, ytterbium, hafnium, thorium, uranium.
In pyrope garnet may be present, the trace elements:
chromium, iron, sodium (in eclogite), potassium, phosphorus, vanadium, nickel, scandium, ytterbium, lutetium.
Sulphur does not fit in the garnet crystal lattice. Measured sulfur contents come from tiny solid inclusions of sulfides such as pyrite, pyrrhotite, chalcopyrite, which are often found in garnet crystals.
Mg and Ca Sodium are interchangeable. Na and K are trace elements.
Best regards,
G. Grundmann
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
14 answers
Is it possible to have Fe2O3 in Sillimanite?   I observed (under SEI) a sillimanite looking grain (in a metamorphic rock sample)  with characteristic cross fractures in my SEM-EDS studies. But several points along the very same grain show the following composition;
Alumina - 58 - 61 wt%
Silica - 35-38 wt%
FeO+Fe2O3 - 3 -5 wt%
Is this gain is sillimanite or something else. Is it possible Alumina to be replaced with Fe2O3?
Thanks in Advance!
Relevant answer
Answer
Secondary hematite micro powder is quite common in some rocks when even mild oxidation is takin place. You do not have to have high hematite content because red staining gives very very strong effect. Obviously Al can folllow Fe and vice versa. This may not be taking place in your sample but it is worthy to check measurinf Fe content. Fe Ka spectral line is very efficient and you can get detection limit around 0.01wt%.
Cheers, HK
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
7 answers
I have to work with major and trace element data of mafic dyke samples from the  different swarms of Eastern Dharwar Craton.Although several published literature used the correspondence analysis method for their data, however I am concerned about the procedure. How it will be useful in comparison to the other variation diagram ?
Relevant answer
Answer
The software you may find useful will be one that has factor or principal component analysis, cluster analysis and other classification tools. I used the following: Statistica by Statsoft (http://www.statsoft.com/Products/STATISTICA/Data-Miner), ioGas by Reflex (http://reflexnow.com/iogas/). Some geochemists use JMP (http://www.jmp.com/en_us/software/jmp.html) and R - free open source software environment that works in Windows, Mac or Unix, but it will require some programming skills to build your own application. Statistica is very expensive, only Windows based and needs transferring data to Excel of other software to do custom graphics and classification. ioGas is more reasonable in price and can work both on Windows and Mac. It is more versatile for your application. It provides built-in classification diagrams for rock types by major components, SPIDER diagrams and other useful petrochemical stuff. 
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
I'm studying augitic pyroxenes from a back arc volcano, included in basalts. Till now I find all those pyroxenes quite similar in terms of major elements, but different sized crystals and along one crystal (from core to rim) the composition in minor elements (such as Ti, Al and Cr) vary significantly, being Cr the one varying from 0.1 to 1.2%. 
I find Ti and Al (and also Na) with fitting profiles, but Cr seems not to be related with all the rest. Does anyone have a clue processes leading Cr partitioning? fOmay be an candidate but I'm not sure ti may be the main reason.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi,
Phenocrysts of Cpx usually have high Cr content. Cr content of CPX depend also from pressure, looks the publications of Paolo Nimis for example.
Regards
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
13 answers
During some routine pegmatite mineralogy we came across an unknown mineral in association with the very rare-mineral 'fluorcalciomicrolite'. We no longer have the grab sample from which the thin section was taken but still have the thin section and have had the opportunity to analyse it quantitatively, along with some element mapping.
The results confirm that our mineral is possibly unique or possibly a second world occurrence of the recently discovered 'peterandresenite' but with high concentrations of Ta, presumably substituting for the Nb. The question is, what additional work can be done to confirm or publish the results bearing in mind all that we have is a normal 30 micron thin section of the mineral in question? 
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Dr. Brough,
the addressee is the Commission on New Minerals, Nomenclature and Classification (CNMNC) of IMA
Details for new minerals are found here:
Best regards
H.G.Dill
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
9 answers
The correct identification of phases is a fundamental information for a meaningful characterization of a microstructure by EBSD, especially when the phase is of minor fraction and cannot be discovered by other, more sensitive  techniques like XRD.
How accurate lattice parameters need to be known if the phase is assumed to be identified properly? Is there any important application where it would be beneficial to know the used phase better than now?  
Relevant answer
Answer
A serious application for lattice parameter detection via EBSD would be the analysis of martensite in steel. Martensite is quite similar to ferrite (bcc structure), but due to rapid cooling the carbon in the austenite (fcc structure) had no time for duffusion and is stuck in interstictal sites in the bcc lattice. Therefore the lattice constant in the martensite is slightly higher than in ferrite. Due to the German wikipedia http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martensit the martensite changes from cubic to tetragonal lattice depending on the carbon concentration.
So far we can not distinguish ferrite from martensite via EBSD. We can only see a higher band slope contrast in ferrite compared to martensite. If you could develop software for measuring the lattice parameters that would help a lot in understanding the steel better.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
6 answers
I would like to compare my analysis from the tweefontein area (South Africa) to other localities in order to better understand the formation processes.
Relevant answer
Answer
I cannot find the analyses of sperrylite I have from the Great Dyke, but I do remember that they were fairly uniform, close to stoichiometric PtAs2, as Dr Oberthür suggests. The publications cited in the answers above will provide suitable analyses for comparison. It would be interesting to compare trace metals in sperrylite from Tweefontein to those from more classic magmatic deposits, but you would probably need to use a more advanced technique than EPMA, such as PIXE, SIMS or LA-ICPMS, and find suitable standards of course. You could also compare compositions of any co-genetic minerals like pyrite, ilmenite, hematite using EPMA.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
11 answers
Could anyone please let me know that max and min value of CaO/Al2O3 and Na2O/Al2O3 in plagioclase or in feldspar?
Thanks in advance
Relevant answer
Answer
Not need for further explanation, your question has been answered through the discussion thanks to the input of all the participants. By the way, that figure is from one of my papers (Fig 3f): Campos Alvarez and Roser 2007. Geochemistry of black shales from the Lower Cretaceous Paja Formation, Eastern Cordillera, Colombia: Source weathering, provenance, and tectonic setting, Journal of South American Earth Sciences 23, 271–289, and simply reflects the abundance of clay minerals is indicated by low K2O/Al2O3 ratios (<0.3), similar with the ranges of clays (Fig. 3f) but significantly different from the higher ratios (0.3–0.9) typical of feldspars.........just keep it simple
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
23 answers
Tiger's eye consists of quartz crystals. As far as I know it has been transformed from riebeckite (asbestos) which still is the reason for the fiber-like structure of tiger's eye. Does anybody know how riebeckite is transforming into quartz? The grains obviously still remain, and both structures contain of SiO4 tetrahedra (differently linked). 
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Gert,
May I present you a graphic that can help to explain the parallel structure of the quartz palisades. It is clear that the tiger eye mineralization is a vein filling type.
The attached graphic from the book by Ron H. Vernon (2004) 'A practical guide to Rock Microstructure', Cambridge University Press (ISBN: 0 521 89133 7) shows very clearly how the fibers are bent during deformation (shear) and crystallization. It is precisely this structure, that is at least partially visible in your image, where the upper ends of the quartz palisades are clearly bent to the right.
The wave-like character of the 'tiger eye' mineralization is produced by the simultaneous crystallization and deformation of Magnesioriebeckite fibers and quartz palisades (falcon eye).
Best regards,
Guenter
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
6 answers
recently, i received a green stone, and grounded it to perform XRD analysis, but without the composition information, i cannot make sure what phases it contains. is there any one who are warm-hearted to help me?
Relevant answer
Answer
Ok, it is classical scientific puzzle. Any way to understand what it is, you should start from chemical analysis. I am not met before green (actually turquoise-colour) clay. Try find out presence of Ni, Cu, CO32- (this a carbonates). Definitely the shell has differ composition from core. Test for CO32- is very simple: drop acetic acid (10%), if burbles rises - it contain carbonate. possible it can be Malachite. It is a copper carbonate hydroxide mineral, with the formula Cu2CO3(OH)2. This opaque, green banded mineral. If not it can be Turquoise. It is an opaque, blue-to-green mineral that is a hydrous phosphate of copper and aluminium, with the chemical formula CuAl6(PO4)4(OH)8·4H
2O  But ONLY versions!!! Isn't possible make mineral analysis by picture!
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
How can I find research papers or reports about "preparing the metallogenetic maps". Their standards and coverages?... Thanks.
Relevant answer
Answer
Metallogenetic maps are produced in order to allow a synopsis of metallogenetic, geological (metallotects) and basic economic data (e.g. the size of deposits). A generalized geological background is used to display information on location, size and nature of ore deposits. Depending on the scale, metallotects may be displayed. Symbols aim at depicting generalized genetic and shape information, and the main metal or mineral (Figure 1.87). Metals are indicated by colour, e.g. yellow for gold and silver, blue for lead and zinc, red for tin and tungsten, etc. The relative size of deposits is expressed by varying the size of symbols. Usually, boundaries of metallogenetic provinces and districts are sketched. Many countries published national metallogenetic maps. Europe is covered
by several sheets of the Metallogenetic Map of Europe and Neighbouring Countries (scale 1:1 250 000; Emberger 1984) and by one sheet of the Mineral Atlas of the World (scale 1:10 000 000; published by the Commission de la Carte Géologique du Monde, CGMW, Paris, and the Geological Survey of Norway, NGU, Trondhejm 1997). Digital maps and supporting mineral deposit data banks are replacing the printed media; stacked data (including geology, geophysics, geochemistry etc.) are analysed in GIS or comparable software, often draped over satellite images or digital elevation models (DEMs). Spatial metallogenetic information serves scientific interests, but its main use is practical, for estimates of undiscovered resources and mineral deposits, and for mapping mineral prospectivity that facilitates strategic planning of exploration (e.g. Carranza & Sadeghi 2010).
A statistical method to identify metallogenetic provinces and epochs was presented by Wilkinson & Kesler (2009), built from a large data-base on porphyry copper deposits. The authors propose to determine regions with a special endowment (metallogenetic provinces) and periods of enhanced deposit formation (metallogenetic epochs), after correcting the age-frequency and deposit-density distributions for loss by uplift and erosion as well as subsidence and burial. Although the authors discern the Late Eocene and the Middle Miocene as epochs of enhanced porphyry copper mineralization in South America, they find that spatial distribution remains unpredictable. The key to “deciphering the predisposition of orogen segments for exceptional mineral endowment” (Sillitoe 2008) remains improvement of geological understanding.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
9 answers
Can somebody explain the formation of the reaction rim around these Quartz  derived from felsic igneous rocks occurring in Lower Cretaceous Urgonian-type lms?
Photos are taken with crossed nicols.
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Kamil,
Your photos show the quartz grains with blue and yellow interference colors. This means that the thin section is too thick. Therefore, you can see the edges of the quartz grains rather unclear, because the extremely small grains of the matrix are superimposed. Therefore, one can not clearly see a suspected reaction rim.
In any case, I suspect a younger growth generation of quartz as fine-grained secondary rims around the older quartz grains.
Best regards,
Guenter
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
I am going to establish the pH of montmorillonite or bentonite dispersion at a previously set ionic strength (e.g., 5 mM NaClO4) in order to study their aggregation subsequently over a period of several days. However, once I adjust the pH with 0.1 M HCl/NaOH, immediately afterwards it changes, e.g., from 8 to 7.5 within a few minutes in the case of montmorillonite, or from 9, 7 and 5 to 8.3, 7.6, and 6.4, respectively, within several days in the case of bentonite.
The use of standard buffer solutions may not be appropriate for these experiments, since the buffer solution can change the surface characteristics of colloids as well as having no significance to the real environment.
I would highly appreciate it if somebody could suggest a simple and fast way to maintain the pH for this kind of experiment. 
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Peyman,
This is not an uncommon phenomenon as we also observe changes in pH when engineered nanomaterials are dispersed in aqueous media. The underlying mechanisms have been discussed in the literature and you can read up on that. This is why we often use buffers when studying aggregation to keep pH as constant as possible. You are right in that buffers themselves may affect the surface properties of your colloids but you may not be totally right to say buffers have no relevance in the real environment. It is well known that natural water systems are typically well-buffered (e.g. carbonate buffer system). My advise is that you carefully choose a buffer that does not change the surface properties of your colloids too much and is relevant to the real environment. Or you could keep adjusting the pH of your clay materials till you reach equilibrium but that way you must have also changed their surface properties significantly.
Best wishes.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
How can I differentiate igneous and metamorphic zircon base on the REE of zircon for example Eu, CE anomaly or enrichment of HREE
can anyone suggest references?
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Mr. Choon Lee,
I prefer a combination of zircon morphology and chemistry as I am going to constrain the source rock area. In the paper attached you will find the apporach to be taken and further literature which hopefully will be of assistance to you.
With my kind regards
Harald G. Dill
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
1 answer
Hello,
I am working in a project with GIN methodology, I have some question about considerations.
1. In order to obtain a seal criteria of the injection what is the consumption criteria? I read in Lunardi documents and he explain that the criteria will be Pmax, PvsV or flow. What will be the flow criteria or consumption of bags of cement?
2. If I change my GIN number so drastically in my construction stage, I need to evaluate the initial injections that I did or re inject?
Relevant answer
Answer
Lo siento, pero aunque lo haría con el mayor agrado, no es mi especialidad
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
Spectroscopic equipment of which company would you recommend for research and why?
In order to concretize the question...
Investigated objects are heterogeneous in structure and color of the surface (e.g., mineral objects, food items).
The task is to search for selective features
The spectral range of research - from UV to NIR.
Thanks for your opinion
Relevant answer
Answer
What kind of instruments do you plan to use؟ If you are interesting in ( Uv/Vis) I recommend the Agilent but if you are interesting in Raman systems my recommendation is Raman spectroscopy - Renishaw or Raman Spectrometers and Microscopes Bruker
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
I would like to compare background rock material with marine sediments of the northern Arabian Sea continental slope.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Sven, did you check the EarthChem sites: http://www.earthchem.org/? There are 100,000s of samples in there, and although they are focused in the US, some are maybe even from your region?
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
8 answers
I am working on sediments to identify and study the depositional environments in lakes of the east coast of India
Relevant answer
Answer
Dear Dr. Kundula,
the procedure applied to clay mineral analysis depends upon the goals of your studies. Is it more related to an environment analysis, devoted to economic geology or a provenance study of fine-grained sedimentary rocks? I was faced with all of these problems. Even if you speak about clay minerals I would not cast aside the coarser particle sizes such as silt and sand. Focusing on the clay minerals which needs to be defined first (phyllosilicates or a technical term used to describe a grain size interval). Some strictly focus on < 2µm or an evens smaller (smectite) grain size others prefer < 20µm with an option for further grain size separation (settling tube, centrifuge).
The mineralogical work encompasses some routine techniques such as XRD (power samples, oriented/random) which can be up-graded up to a quantitative analysis by means of Rietveld-refinement and different types of spectroscopy. Cation exchange capacity studies for expandable phyllosilicates, such as the smectite group, are a must. SEM/EDX and SEM/WDX will be helpful for chemical and morphological studies.
Thermo-physical techniques (e.g. differential thermo analyses) are useful if your focus lies within the final use of clay minerals. The techniques are sometime very specific.
If you want to capture digital data in the field, e.g. for mapping and cross sectioning use a portable XRD, combined with IR mineral analyzers, and a kappameter, gamma-spectrometry and conductivity meter determining the relative resistivity (smectite/ silica ratio) according to the Wenner Array.
I exclude age dating of clay minerals using the K/Ar and Ar/Ar method. We did it by you can write a book about how to prepare the sample most suitable.
This is a first-hand introduction based upon my knowledge and practical experience which I collected in the field and the laboratory aimed a tackling problems in the three approaches taken above.
The lacustrine environment should always been looked at in context with the fluvial and aeolian environment dependent upon whether you deal with an ephemeral or perennial lake.
DILL, H.G., DOHRMANN, R., KAUFHOLD, S. and TECHMER, A. (2014) Provenance analysis and thermo-dynamic studies of multi-type Holocene duricrusts (1700 BC) in the Sua Salt Pan, NE Botswana.- Journal of African Earth Sciences, 96: 79-98.
DILL, H.G., BALABAN, S.- I., WITT, B. and WERSHOFEN, H. (2014) Capturing digital data of rock magnetic, gamma-ray and IR spectrometry for in-situ quality control and for the study of the physical-chemical regime of residual kaolin deposits, SE Germany.- Ore Geology Reviews, 57: 172-190.
DILL, H.G., KAUFHOLD, S., LINDENMAIER, F., DOHRMANN, R., LUDWIG, R. and BOTZ, R. (2012) Joint clay-heavy-light mineral analysis: A tool to investigate the hydrographic-hydraulic regime of the Late Cenozoic deltaic inland fans under changing climatic conditions (Cuvelai-Etosha Basin, Namibia).- International Journal of Earth Sciences, 102: 265-304.
These papers are first and foremost to give you an idea what the technical approaches are like. Sedimentological studies on lacustrine environments and adjacent ones are countless.
Best regards
Harald G. Dill
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
I discovered new occurrences of the mineral Laumontite in Jordan.
The mineral Laumontite is one of the zeolite minerals. I would appreciate any publications regarding this.
Relevant answer
Answer
The ICSD contains tens of structure descriptions of Laumontite, incl. lattice parameters of course, but also the free AMCSD (American Mineralogist Crystal Structure Database) lists around 16 descriptions of this mineral.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
Whiteness and brightness of Kaolin are vital factors for relevant markets such as paper and ceramic industries.
Is there any numerical relation between Brightness of Kaolin and chemical analysis of kaolin contents especially coloring impurities such as MnO, TiO2; Fe2O3 and so on? Is there anybody have  relevant publications, data-set or research in this respect? 
Regards,
Hamed
Relevant answer
Answer
Hello Hamed,
I have studied Brazilian kaolins in this regard. For the crude ore, we found that the mineralogical content has a stronger relation with brightness than the total oxide content. It is even possible (although not always easy) to model this relation using the Kubelka-Munk theory. Particle size can be a potential complicator.
Regards,
Ítalo
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
2 answers
As far as I know, two groups spend some time to investigate and determine lattice parameters in EBSD patterns using HOLZ rings. The first is the group around J.R. Michael from Sandia Lab. (USA) who developed this technique, and the second were E. Langer and S. Daebritz (TU Dresden, Germany). As far as I remember, Noran even sold a commercial system around 10 years ago based on the Michaels code, however I never read anything about an application. Is there any reason known why it is not applicable? 
Relevant answer
Answer
Yes, but I must admit that their argumentation is quite questionable. Our current believe is that HOLZ rings are visible if structures are quite perfect and not the opposite. So their conclusion is more speculative... especially becuase they do not have any pattern simulation. Nevertheless many thanks, Volker.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
The arc-like geochemical characteristics of granites could inherit from their source rocks or result from the arc tectonic setting they formed. How can I distinguish between these two factors?
Relevant answer
Answer
The problem is that you cannot distinguish between the two options. Granitoids can be formed in arc settings, but they can also represent remelting of material with an arc-type signature. And remember that an arc signature is almost the same as the geochemical signature of the upper crust. The main distinction between arc and crust lies in the positive Sr anomaly for arc magmas, but once you get to an evolved magma, the positive Sr anomaly will have disappeared as a result of plagioclase fractionation. So there is no easy answer just from the geochemistry of the granite - you will have to take all the geological evidence into account to come up with a model.
Radiogenic isotopes could help a bit, since 'original arc' should have somewhat more primitive Sr and Nd isotope ratios than 'recycled arc', but I fear that this answer won't be unequivocal either. Oxygen isotopes on quartz could perhaps help, to see whether there is evidence of surface exposure...
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
In texture analysis the data are often symmetrized in order to increase the statistical significance assuming an expected symmetry. To this aim terms like triclinic, monoclinic and orthorhombic have been introduced which practically results in a reduction of the first Euler angle, and an adaptation of the second and the third. Unfortunately, these term are already used for the classification of crystal systems which is at least irritating but also misunderstanding since often it is not clear that the assumed (sample or process) symmetry required a well-aligned sample before application of this symmetry. Is there any reason why one uses these terms, and who introduced them? Is it still necessary to "symmetrize" data since the detection techniques have been strongly improved?
Relevant answer
Answer
It's a good question/observation (a terminology designed to confuse ? :-) ).
One of my mentors on this general topic, Prof. Tony Rollett advocates using a combination of crystal and sample symmetries to describe symmetry of any particular case, i.e. crystal-sample, e.g. cubic-orthorhombic, or hexagonal-triclinic.
I see from your question you already appreciate probably all of what follows, but for anybody else who wants a lead into the general issues, I thought it might be helpful to them to lay some of it out & add a source or two to the discussion. Going to Tony's webpages is also recommended for a good introduction to texture. http://neon.mems.cmu.edu/rollett/27750/27750.html
For a known crystal structure that you can enforce its crystal symmetry on the data is the general assumption (perhaps there are esoteric crystal cases where this is not the done thing ? ). Having symmetries present reduces the size of Euler space required to fully describe the texture of a sample, as shown in Table 2.2 of 'Introduction to Texture Analysis, Macrotexture, Microtexture & Orientation Mapping' by V. Randle and O. Engler. Crystal symmetry on one hand affects the range of PHI and phi2 required for a full texture description. Sample symmetry on the other hand affects the range of phi1 required to fully describe the texture of a sample (see Table in book).
Sample symmetry unlike crystal symmetry is only a statistical symmetry, if it actually appears in your data, (with the expected symmetry for the sample reference frame (say deformation mode) investigated), then it is because with respect to the mirror/symmetry plane involved you have sampled enough material on either side of that reflection plane to satisfy the statistical requirements.
On the other hand you may decide this or that sample symmetry will be present and simply enforce the requisite symmetry on your data.
The question then arises when is it appropriate to enforce the sample symmetry ?
That really depends upon the question you were trying to answer in the first place with your investigation, and its affect on the data (i.e. that of sample symmetry) depends upon the influence of the processes that created the texture in your sample, and the practicalities of how you went about investigating your sample, technique, exact location sampled & size of area examined, accuracy of sampling plane alignment etc. etc. I guess it is quite a fundamental/basic thing in such investiagtions to make sure you are doing the right things to get the answer you were after.
As another poster noted, in the various software suites there is often a function to tweak (rotate) the 'raw' data (typically pole figures) to symmetry before processing it,  if the alignment was a bit off.
Hopes this helps in some way.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
9 answers
Some minerals such as calcite, asbestos... are commonly described in the geological literature as resulting from growth in extensional context (i.e. tension gashes filled with calcite), but some other minerals found in the nature can exhibit some fibrous habits too. Are there any review papers on the topic, or industrial methods in which synthetic minerals are grown according to specific conditions - pH, stress, rate of growth/cooling?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi André! How are you???
There is an interesting paper by P. Cobbold and colleagues in Marine and Petroleum Geology (2013), 43, 1-20
"Bedding parallel fibrous veins...: worlwide occurence and possible significance in, terms of fluid overpressure...." 
An oustanding review in my opinion.
Dominique
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
9 answers
Are all types of granites with temperature (based on zircon thermometry) less than 750 C are named cold granites?
Relevant answer
Thank you for your answer
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
12 answers
I need to disaggregate some well-lithified sandstone samples into individual quartz grains to examine quartz microtextures using an SEM.  As such, I'm looking for a disaggregation method that won't induce (or will minimize) artificial grain-surface features.  
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree that a well-lithified sandstone is a poor candidate for considering grain surface microtextures.  Presumably you need to remove the cements from the detrital grains as well if you intend to observe grain textures.  Any method you apply to cleave quartz overgrowths or clays from grain surfaces will likely introduce irreconcilable effects.  Your only (slim) hope is if these sandstones are cemented by calcite.  In this case you could remove the cement with a weak acid.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
I need EBSD patterns from beta-quartz but do not have a heating stage in SEM. Is it possible to get high-quartz prepared and investigated below the transformation temperature because of stabilizing conditions as known for other phases?
Relevant answer
Answer
Since the quartz inversion is a second order phase transition and therefore depends solely on lattice dynamics (phonons) and not the formation or breakage of bonds, it should not be possible to obtain high quartz at temperatures below the transition temperature, since it cannot be supercooled. This is unfortunate, but cannot be helped. Of course, the transition temperature is affected by pressure, but this will hardly help because Tc increases with pressure (www.minsocam.org/ammin/AM59/AM59_1099.pdf).
Besides, I was wondering what you need these patterns for. In order to get textural information on quartz samples which acquired a texture above Tc  you should be able to just do EBSD at ambient temperatures and use the low quartz patterns: the c-axis orientation of the low-quartz will be exactly identical to the original orientation of the c-axis in the high-quartz for each grain (grain boundaries are not affected by the transformation), and unless the sample is strained in some way, there should be equal volume proportions of the two distinct low-quartz orientations resulting from the transformation of every high-quartz crystallite. These two distinct orientational domains are rotated with respect to each other by 60° around the mutual c-axis. Any preferred orientation of the high-quartz should therefore be inherited (subject to the rules stated above) by the low-quartz. No need for fancy experiments unless you are worried about the volume change accompanying the transition, in which case you will have to find a way of measuring at high temperatures.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
2 answers
Everybody knows that EBSD already has a lot of problems which are related to drift phenomena. This becomes unpredictable at higher magnification which are typical in combination with FIB preparation. If already in 2D the predicted beam position is quite unreliable and can be several steps away from the assumed position, how reliable is a beam position in 3D which presupposes an ideal (constant) ablation rate of the FIB preparation? How accurate the crystallographic description of grain or phase boundaries can be?
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi Eric, your remarks only concern the third dimension and certainly shows how problematic a collection of a 3D dataset is, despite the effort of a careful alignment after each ablation by image cross correlation. But even if you would be able to have an exact ablation in z (what I hardly disbelieve if you consider the effect of 70 degree tilt which gains any deviation from the ideal value by a factor of about three) the uncertainties of (unknown) local charging and perhaps (unknown) magnetic effects in your sample caused by single phases results in distortions in 2D EBSD scans which differs from layer to layer so that a simple stacking of the layers can give only "roughly" an impression of the micro (or better: nano) structure. There is nearly no 3D data set where all layers havn't to be realigned in order to minimize "obvious" deviations, and as far as I know there are standardly only translations in x and y possible. Voxel related algorithms are still the exception, and the restrains you have to define for the "best correction" already implement some information one actually wants to get from 3D datasets. 
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
1 answer
  • anchoring
  • soil types
  • rock types
  • Length of anchors
  • Binding agent to extent the anchor by existing length
Relevant answer
Answer
On-site anchor tests are generally the best way to accurately determine anchor lengths and capacities for the given geological conditions. Please refer the work
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
2 answers
Despite missing knowledge about intensities of reflectors, dynamical diffraction effects, superimposition of higher order reflections, and low accuracy in bandwidth determination, how reliable is phase ID using EBSD patterns? How problematic is pseudosymmetry?
Relevant answer
Answer
I am quite new to learning my way around a SEM, but I found this link below really useful for tips in accurate phase ID.
A great article discussing the problems at a deeper level is by Nowell and Wright (2004) 'Phase differentiation via combined EBSD and XEDS' Journal of Microscopy
Volume 213, Issue 3, pages 296–305, March 2004
Hope this helps.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
Does anybody know a phase which crystallizes in the same trigonal point group but in space groups with different alignments of the symmetry elements, e.g. in 312 or 321, or 3m1 or 31m, 3c1 or 31c etc.?
In case there is no example, is there any paper which describes the reason why this is impossible?
Relevant answer
Answer
I agree with you (with the same reasons: feeling :-). But I would like to understand it. My assumption is that it has something to do with the translation symmetry: for 321 parallel to the two-fold axis, for 312 not parallel to the symmetry axis.
I also wonder why the order in IT is different:
149: 3 1 2 ...... 150: 3 2 1
151: 3_1 1 2 ...... 152: 3_1 2 1
153: 3_2 1 2 ...... 154: 3_2 2 1
156: 3 m 1 ...... 157: 3 1 m
158: 3 c 1 ...... 159: 3 1 c
162: -3 1 m ...... 163: -3 1 c
164: -3 m 1 ...... 165: -3 c 1
For 2 they start with 2 || [100] (149-154), but for m=-2 (156-159) they change to -2 || [210]. For 162-165 the International Tables even "mix" this using first -2 || [100] and then -2 || [210]. A closer look in the International Tables (Vol A) shows that commonly a very high systematic is applied. However, here I am a bit surprized.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
5 answers
Recently, I submitted a paper in a crystallographic journal where I used Miller-Bravais indices (hkil) for lattice planes, and Weber (Schweizer) symbols [uvtw] for lattice directions. One reviewer complained the indexing with the following words: "The fourth symbol for a direction has no meaning (please check this in a good crystallography book). The general accepted rule for indexing directions is to write [hk.l]." There are a few things which puzzle me. a) the meaning of four indices are discussable for directions in lattice as well as in reciprocal lattice. Maybe they are more used for lattice planes since symmetry-equivalent planes are easier to recognize by permutation (like for cubic crystals), but this is also correct for lattice directions. b) the use of [hk.l] instead of [uv.w], and c) the application of [uv.w] in general. As I know, [uv.w] is used instead of [uvtw] in order to express that t is a redundant information, but still is valid: t=-(u+v). The reviewer however claimed: "Everything is o.k. for planes, where h+k+i = 0 or i = -(h+k). A bit more complicated is the application for directions. You can´t use in a one by one mapping the formula i = -(h+k)." I believe he is wrong. I found a very convincing and comprehensive description in McHenry, DeGraef: Structure of Materials.
Relevant answer
Answer
Here a short comparison of the indexing of identical directions described in crystal as well as reciprocal lattice....
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
3 answers
There are lots of high pressure studies on this phase, but I am specifically looking for the cell parameter of the phase from 10 to 25 GPa and at room temperature. I would appreciate it, if someone could help me to find the cell parameters on that pressure range.
Thank you very much for your attention.
Relevant answer
Answer
A good place to start is here:
Mao, H., J. Shu, Y. Fei, J. Hu, and R. J. Hemley (1996), The wüstite enigma, Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors, 96(2–3), 135–145, doi:10.1016/0031-9201(96)03146-9.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
6 answers
Is there an updated list of cave minerals in the world? According to the excellent book Cave Minerals of the World by Carol Hill and Paolo Forti (1997) there was 255 minerals found in caves. Do you maybe know the number today?
Relevant answer
Answer
Many interesting minerals are found in caves in addition to the calcite which forms the major features. Aragonite, a calcium carbonate mineral similar to calcite but not as common, often occurs in intricate needles known as anthodites. Gypsum (calcium sulfate) and related calcium sulfate minerals are next to calcite in abundance. Some caves, although they are developed in limestone, have extensive passages lined with fine, curling growths of gypsum flowers. In other caves, selenite (a less common variety of gypsum) forms long transparent rods or nests of fibrous crystals. Sulfates of sodium and magnesium are also found in caves, although they are less conspicuous than gypsum. Iron minerals in the form of oxides (limonite) and hydroxide (goethite) occur in caves and in some places form stalactites. Manganese minerals in caves are commonly present as thin, sooty coatings on walls and ceilings and in earth fills. Nitrocalcite (calcium nitrate) is abundant in earth fills in many caves, but individual fragments are generally microscopic. Barite (barium sulfate) and celestite (strontium sulfate) also occur in earth fills. In some solution caves, clay minerals exist in relatively pure forms; these include the less common varieties attapulgite and endellite.
In deep caves encountered during mining operations, a number of ore minerals have been found in the decorative wall draperies. Most common are azurite and malachite (forms of copper carbonate). About 50 other minerals also have been reported in cave deposits.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
6 answers
Noting that acetone procedure determines anhydrite and gypsum together and not anyhdrite.
Relevant answer
Answer
Thanks all Golnaz, Lucci and Vincent for very good ideas. All of them are good and applicable but not available everywhere and maybe expensive. Hence, we are trying to develop an easy to use procedure through quantifying gypsum plus anhydrite in air dry soils by acetone and gypsum in oven dry soil, after gypsum loses its water and becomes anhydrite, by weight loss procedure, and the difference gives anhydrite. How this sound? Your comments would be appreciated and welcome.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
3 answers
There are methods for Ilmenite & Rutile, but what process or method can be use for extracting TiO2 from Titanomagnetite?
Relevant answer
Answer
The answers given above are essentially correct. Basically this is smelting of low grade Ti ores (or perhaps Ti contaminated Fe ores). Huge deposits of 'iron sands' are present on the beaches of New Zealand's north island so it may be worthwhile to have a look at the web pages of NZSteel to see a description of the overall process they use.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
2 answers
I want to identify minerals in dusts collected in different metal mines around the US. The ultimate goal is to identify potential counfounders for the quantification of crystalline silica via FTIR. I wonder if full scan XRD can be used for small quantities (few mg of material) deposited on PVC filters. Thanks
Relevant answer
Answer
Consider incineration of the used PVC filter, having the collected dust, following some convenient protocol. Standard ASTM D5630-13, entitled "Standard test method for ash content in plastics", could be useful. A few powder standards could be obtained by mixing ash from unused filter(s) ─ also analysed for a blank essay ─ with known quantities of added mineral. After analysis, a calibration line is obtained, used to quantify the actual samples. This being a quite general procedure, it can be expected to perform generally better with either X-ray spectrometry or X-ray diffractometry, compared to FTIR. With FTIR absorption spectroscopy the results are typically less accurate, in practice, because last technique usually does not favour precise quantitative analysis, particularly considering that powdered samples are to be analysed. Usually, FTIR is just used for qualitative or semi-quantitative approach. On the other hand, since a lower limit of detection can be often achieved with FTIR, compared to quantitative X-ray analysis, it seems interesting to study the possible use of FTIR for the quantification of minerals present in the collected dust at very small levels, even considering that a significant error can presumably affect the results.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
Scientists have suggested an experimental system to study serpentinization and look at chemical reactions that pave the way for life. Ref- NASA Astrobiology Group.
Relevant answer
Answer
Geologic hydrogen production has long been thought to fuel deep ecosystems. Hydrogen-producing reactions known to take place between water and rock at high temperatures and pressures, however, have only been recapitulated in the laboratory at very slow rates, perhaps too slow to support Earth’s ubiquitous deep biosphere. In a report published in the October 2013 edition of American Mineralogist, DCO scientists Muriel Andreani, Isabelle Daniel, and Marion Pollet-Villard of University Claude Bernard Lyon 1 show that the rate of one such reaction, serpentinization, can be increased by an order of magnitude using aluminum oxide as a catalyst [1].
Serpentinization reactions take place naturally under hydrothermal conditions, such as those found in and around deep ocean vent systems, and result in the production of molecular hydrogen (H2). High-energy molecular hydrogen is liberated from water, and the rocky, ultramafic substrate is simultaneously modified to produce serpentine. Such reactions have been reproduced in laboratories around the world for several decades, but proceed slowly, over the course of weeks or months. This sluggish reaction would likely be unable to support the thriving, sunlight-deprived, deep microbial ecosystems present on our planet today.
“For the first time we understand why and how we have H2 produced at such a fast rate. When you take into account aluminum, you understand the amount of life flourishing on hydrogen,” said study co-author Isabelle Daniel.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
4 answers
In general, the XRD results are semi-quantity, is it possible to use the software to get quality information of mineral phases? Is it possible to the use these semi-quantitative information to make correlations with other quantity-data? For example, temperature change is related to metallic aluminum in salt cake, is it valid to make correlation of aluminum abundance in salt cake to temperature change?
Relevant answer
Answer
Easy answer: google "QPA Round Robin".
Ian Madsen, CSIRO is the name to look for. Besides being a good friend, Ian is one of the leaders in the field. You can find info also e.g. in:
You can also have a look at Reynolds' cup if you want to see the limits of current mineral analysis techniques (identification and quantitative phase analysis on complex mineral mixtures)
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
13 answers
Can these Ti minerals be identified by an ordinary microscope?
Relevant answer
Answer
If you have microscope with transmitted light and relected light arrrangement, then prepare a thin-polished section of grain mounts (if possible) or prepare grain slides and polished section and study under microscpes. .These minerals have distinct optical properties. Count them to obtain quantitative mineralogy.Dr. S.K. Das
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
15 answers
I couldn't match this spectra with any spectra at www.rruff.info (raman database). I've tried 100's of mineral spectra for matching but no success. My guess according to microprobe data, this can be some kind of Ca - Mg or Ca - Fe silicate!
Relevant answer
Answer
Check in Rruff database:
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
21 answers
Many published reports are available regarding improving leaching rates in presence of certain activators.
Relevant answer
Answer
Hi I do happy that your experience is same in your conditions.
May be it'll be very interesting to make some joint experiments or study for this technology - Macedonian ores and ores from your region. Joint publishing of papers etc.
  • asked a question related to Applied Mineralogy
Question
3 answers
Agilent; Thermo Fisher, PerkinElmer etc? Does the collision mode display better results than the reaction mode for multi-element analysis or are they similar in performance? Are there any problems that can arise with 90-degree deflector lens types?
Relevant answer
Answer
We have been running Agilent ICPMS instruments (3) for about 10 years, and have found them to be generally trouble-free while producing excellent and reproducible results (published in >100 papers). But a lot will depend on the availability and quality of your local service apparatus, so you need to assure yourself on that before considering different intstuments.