Xinyi Zhao’s research while affiliated with University of Oxford and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (9)


Mapping subnational gender gaps in internet and mobile adoption using social media data
  • Preprint

August 2024

·

22 Reads

Casey Breen

·

Masoomali Fatehkia

·

Jiani Yan

·

[...]

·

The digital revolution has ushered in many societal and economic benefits. Yet access to digital technologies such as mobile phones and internet remains highly unequal, especially by gender in the context of low- and middle-income countries. While national-level estimates are increasingly available for many countries, reliable, quantitative estimates of digital gender inequalities at the subnational level are lacking. These estimates, however, are essential for monitoring gaps within countries and implementing targeted interventions within the global sustainable development goals, which emphasize the need to close inequalities both between and within countries. We develop estimates of internet and mobile adoption by gender and digital gender gaps at the subnational level for 2,158 regions in 118 low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), a context where digital penetration is low and national-level gender gaps disfavoring women are large. We construct these estimates by applying machine-learning algorithms to Facebook user counts, geospatial data, development indicators, and population composition data. We calibrate and assess the performance of these algorithms using ground-truth data from subnationally-representative household survey data from 31 LMICs. Our results reveal striking disparities in access to mobile and internet technologies between and within LMICs, with implications for policy formulation and infrastructure investment. These disparities contribute to a global context where women are 21% less likely to use the internet and 17% less likely to own mobile phones than men, corresponding to over 385 million more men than women owning a mobile phone and over 360 million more men than women using the internet.



Fig. 1. Gender ratios among all published researchers (X-axis) and migrant researchers (Y-axis). In the subfigure for each period, only the countries with over 500 female mobile researchers are shown, as including the countries with small populations of mobile researchers may give rise to bias in the ratio measurements. The size of each country's circle is proportional to the number of female researchers who migrated from and to this country. Notably, to increase readability, the countries with no more than 2,000 female migrant researchers are set to the minimum size. The vertical and horizontal dashed lines indicate the median gender ratios of all published researchers and of mobile researchers in each period. The 45 • line in each subfigure is used to help compare the gender ratios of these two categories, with another double-arrowed line underlining the distance between it and the fitted regression line at the X value of one. This helps us to track the convergence tendency of female representation in the group of mobile researchers versus that in the total researcher population and how it changed over the four time periods.
A gender perspective on the global migration of scholars
  • Article
  • Full-text available

February 2023

·

91 Reads

·

18 Citations

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

Although considerable progress toward gender equality in science has been made in recent decades, female researchers continue to face significant barriers in the academic labor market. International mobility has been increasingly recognized as a strategy for scientists to expand their professional networks, and that could help narrow the gender gap in academic careers. Using bibliometric data on over 33 million Scopus publications, we provide a global and dynamic view of gendered patterns of transnational scholarly mobility, as measured by volume, distance, diversity, and distribution, from 1998 to 2017. We find that, while female researchers continued to be underrepresented among internationally mobile researchers and migrate over shorter distances, this gender gap was narrowing at a faster rate than the gender gap in the population of general active researchers. Globally, the origin and destination countries of both female and male mobile researchers became increasingly diversified, which suggests that scholarly migration has become less skewed and more globalized. However, the range of origin and destination countries continued to be narrower for women than for men. While the United States remained the leading academic destination worldwide, the shares of both female and male scholarly inflows to that country declined from around 25% to 20% over the study period, partially due to the growing relevance of China. This study offers a cross-national measurement of gender inequality in global scholarly migration that is essential for promoting gender-equitable science policies and for monitoring the impact of such interventions.

Download

Digital and Computational Demography

April 2022

·

185 Reads

·

10 Citations

Digital and computational demography explores demography in relation to the digital revolution – the rapid technological improvements in digitized information storage, computational power and the spread of the internet and mobile technologies since the turn of the new millennium. We cover three ways in which the digital revolution touches upon demography. First, we discuss how digital technologies, through their impacts on daily lives and in shifting how individuals access information, communicate and access services, have implications for demographic outcomes linked to health and mortality, fertility and family, and migration. Second, we discuss how the digital revolution has created a wide range of new data sources such as digital trace and geospatial data that can be repurposed for demographic research, and enabled respondent recruitment across the world via the internet and social media. Third, we discuss how improvements in computational power have facilitated the use of computational methods such as microsimulation and agent-based modelling as well as machine learning techniques for demographic applications. We conclude by discussing future opportunities and challenges for digital demography.


Fig. 4 Proportion of female researchers in different groups by discipline and cohort. The colored version of the figure is available online in high resolution
Fig. 5 Return rates and collaborative ratios across disciplines. The colored version of the figure is available online in high resolution
Fig. 6 Return rates and collaborative ratios by discipline and cohort. The colored version of the figure is available online in high resolution
Return migration of German-affiliated researchers: analyzing departure and return by gender, cohort, and discipline using Scopus bibliometric data 1996–2020

March 2022

·

102 Reads

·

9 Citations

Scientometrics

The international migration of researchers is an important dimension of scientific mobility, and has been the subject of considerable policy debate. However, tracking the migration life courses of researchers is challenging due to data limitations. In this study, we use Scopus bibliometric data on eight million publications from 1.1 million researchers who have published at least once with an affiliation address from Germany in 1996–2020. We construct the partial life histories of published researchers in this period and explore both their out-migration and the subsequent return of a subset of this group: the returnees. Our analyses shed light on the career stages and gender disparities between researchers who remain in Germany, those who emigrate, and those who eventually return. We find that the return migration streams are even more gender imbalanced, which points to the need for additional efforts to encourage female researchers to come back to Germany. We document a slightly declining trend in return migration among more recent cohorts of researchers who left Germany, which, for most disciplines, was associated with a decrease in the German collaborative ties of these researchers. Moreover, we find that the gender disparities for the most gender imbalanced disciplines are unlikely to be mitigated by return migration given the gender compositions of the cohorts of researchers who have left Germany and of those who have returned. This analysis uncovers new dimensions of migration among scholars by investigating the return migration of published researchers, which is critical for the development of science policy.


Outward flows (from Germany) and respective returning rates across countries. The size of the countries are proportional to the flows of outward researchers from Germany. The colors indicate the differences in the returning rates of German-affiliated researchers returning to Germany from each country.
Fig. 4 Proportion of female researchers in different groups by discipline and cohort
The rates of leaving Germany within first 5 years since first publication per 1000 person-year (left), and the rates of return to Germany within the first 5 years after departure per 1000 person-year (right).
Returning rates and collaborative ratio of returnees by discipline in three cohorts
Return migration of German-affiliated researchers: Analyzing departure and return by gender, cohort, and discipline using Scopus bibliometric data 1996-2020

February 2022

·

315 Reads

The international migration of researchers is an important dimension of scientific mobility, and has been the subject of considerable policy debate. However, tracking the migration life courses of researchers is challenging due to data limitations. In this study, we use Scopus bibliometric data on eight million publications from 1.1 million researchers who have published at least once with an affiliation address from Germany in 1996-2020. We construct the partial life histories of published researchers in this period and explore both their out-migration and the subsequent return of a subset of this group: the returnees. Our analyses shed light on the career stages and gender disparities between researchers who remain in Germany, those who emigrate, and those who eventually return. We find that the return migration streams are even more gender imbalanced, which points to the need for additional efforts to encourage female researchers to come back to Germany. We document a slightly declining trend in return migration among more recent cohorts of researchers who left Germany, which, for most disciplines, was associated with a decrease in the German collaborative ties of these researchers. Moreover, we find that the gender disparities for the most gender imbalanced disciplines are unlikely to be mitigated by return migration given the gender compositions of the cohorts of researchers who have left Germany and of those who have returned. This analysis uncovers new dimensions of migration among scholars by investigating the return migration of published researchers, which is critical for the development of science policy.



Figure 2. Migration flows of researchers to Germany (a) and from Germany (b) over the 1996-2020 period.
Figure 3. Net migration rates for researchers (in red) and for the general population (in blue).
Figure 4. Citation class composition of immigrants by origin (a) and emigrants by destination (b). Vertical gridlines are shown to enable a comparison to the average migrant researcher, who is equally likely to belong to any of the three citation classes.
Number and proportion of researchers by mobility type.
International Migration in Academia and Citation Performance: An Analysis of German-Affiliated Researchers by Gender and Discipline Using Scopus Publications 1996-2020

April 2021

·

380 Reads

·

9 Citations

Germany has become a major country of immigration, as well as a research powerhouse in Europe. As Germany spends a higher fraction of its GDP on research and development than most countries with advanced economies, there is an expectation that Germany should be able to attract and retain international scholars who have high citation performance. Using an exhaustive set of over eight million Scopus publications, we analyze the trends in international migration to and from Germany among published researchers over the past 24 years. We assess changes in institutional affiliations for over one million researchers who have published with a German affiliation address at some point during the 1996-2020 period. We show that while Germany has been highly integrated into the global movement of researchers, with particularly strong ties to the US, the UK, and Switzerland, the country has been sending more published researchers abroad than it has attracted. While the balance has been largely negative over time, analyses disaggregated by gender, citation performance, and field of research show that compositional differences in migrant flows may help to alleviate persistent gender inequalities in selected fields.


Figure 1. Average (diamond marker), median (circle marker), and standard deviation of annual citations by discipline and mobility type. The vertical dashed lines show the mean across all disciplines. Magnify all figures on the screen for higher resolution and more details.
Figure 2. Migration flows of researchers to Germany (a) and from Germany (b) over the 1996-2020 period.
Figure 3. Net migration rates for researchers (in red) and for the general population (in blue).
Figure 4. Citation class composition of immigrants by origin (a) and emigrants by destination (b). Vertical gridlines are shown to enable a comparison to the average migrant researcher, who is equally likely to belong to any of the three citation classes.
Number and proportion of researchers by mobility type.
International Migration in Academia and Citation Performance: An Analysis of German-Affiliated Researchers by Gender and Discipline Using Scopus Publications 1996-2020

April 2021

·

128 Reads

·

1 Citation

Germany has become a major country of immigration, as well as a research powerhouse in Europe. As Germany spends a higher fraction of its GDP on research and development than most countries with advanced economies, there is an expectation that Germany should be able to attract and retain international scholars who have high citation performance. Using an exhaustive set of over eight million Scopus publications, we analyze the trends in international migration to and from Germany among published researchers over the past 24 years. We assess changes in institutional affiliations for over one million researchers who have published with a German affiliation address at some point during the 1996-2020 period. We show that while Germany has been highly integrated into the global movement of researchers, with particularly strong ties to the US, the UK, and Switzerland, the country has been sending more published researchers abroad than it has attracted. While the balance has been largely negative over time, analyses disaggregated by gender, citation performance, and field of research show that compositional differences in migrant flows may help to alleviate persistent gender inequalities in selected fields.

Citations (5)


... Digitalized scholarly databases with bibliometric information are a new source for studying scientists as a population, even though they first need to be repurposed to focus on individual scientists rather than individual publications. This allows for the exploration of questions about science and scientists at an unprecedented level of detail (Kashyap et al., 2023;Liu et al., 2023;Wang & Barabási, 2021). Individuals can be studied according to age, seniority, gender, discipline, and institutional type-and most importantly, for the present study, scientists can be tracked over time. ...

Reference:

Quantifying Attrition in Science: A Cohort-Based, Longitudinal Study of Scientists in 38 OECD Countries (Published in "Higher Education", August 2024)
Digital and computational demography
  • Citing Chapter
  • March 2023

... The statistical analysis presented in Table 4 (Zhao, Akbaritabar, Kashyap, & Zagheni, 2023), (Zhang, Mirza, Mohamad, & Azlan, 2024). These findings emphasize the need for targeted interventions that consider age-specific and profession-specific factors to address the migration trends among healthcare professionals effectively. ...

A gender perspective on the global migration of scholars

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

... Digitalized scholarly databases with bibliometric information are a new source for studying scientists as a population, although they first need to be repurposed to focus on individual scientists rather than individual publications. This allows for the exploration of questions about science and scientists at an unprecedented level of detail (Kashyap et al., 2022;Liu et al., 2023;Wang & Barabási, 2021). Individuals can be studied according to age, seniority, gender, discipline, and institutional type-and most importantly for the present study, scientists can be tracked over time. ...

Digital and Computational Demography
  • Citing Preprint
  • April 2022

... Considering the limitations of discussing the findings here with international migration, the gender gap in most disciplines, is also a reflection of other international realities. In Germany [19], the return migration streams are gendered imbalanced, and for those men who return they composed the ~65% of positions as senior professionals compare to women. Also, the highest proportion of women by discipline that emigrates in Germany is concentrated in agricultural, biological and environmental sciences; biochemistry, immunology; neuroscience; pharmacology; and psychology. ...

Return migration of German-affiliated researchers: analyzing departure and return by gender, cohort, and discipline using Scopus bibliometric data 1996–2020

Scientometrics

... It objectively assesses researchers' quality and productivity in a specific field, retrospectively explores research history, and identifies frontiers in various disciplines or research areas . In the field of migration and integration, several studies have employed large-scale bibliometric data to explore academic mobility to and from a specific country (Miranda-González et al., 2020;Subbotin & Aref, 2021;Zhao et al., 2021) and to study specific integration dimensions in literature (Atçeken & Dik, 2023;Gao & Wang, 2022;Picanço Cruz & de Queiroz Falcão, 2016;Shuangyun & Hongxia, 2020;Sweileh et al., 2018). For instance, Shuangyun and Hongxia (2020) used the bibliometric method on 1,557 articles to analyze the research institutions, key authors, keywords, and citations to map knowledge about ethnic identity and immigrant acculturation. ...

International Migration in Academia and Citation Performance: An Analysis of German-Affiliated Researchers by Gender and Discipline Using Scopus Publications 1996-2020