Wade H. Bingle’s research while affiliated with University of British Columbia and other places

Although S-layers are being increasingly identified on Bacteria and Archaea, it is enigmatic that in most cases S-layer function continues to elude us. In a few instances, S-layers have been shown to be virulence factors on pathogens (e.g. Campylobacter fetus ssp. fetus and Aeromonas salmonicida), protective against Bdellovibrio, a depository for surface-exposed enzymes (e.g. Bacillus stearothermophilus), shape-determining agents (e.g. Thermoproteus tenax) and nucleation factors for fine-grain mineral development (e.g. Synechococcus GL 24). Yet, for the vast majority of S-layered bacteria, the natural function of these crystalline arrays continues to be evasive. The following review up-dates the functional basis of S-layers and describes such diverse topics as the effect of S-layers on the Gram stain, bacteriophage adsorption in lactobacilli, phagocytosis by human polymorphonuclear leukocytes, the adhesion of a high-molecular-mass amylase, outer membrane porosity, and the secretion of extracellular enzymes of Thermoanaerobacterium. In addition, the functional aspect of calcium on the Caulobacter S-layer is explained.

Immobilized biocatalysts, including particulate enzymes, represent an attractive tool for research and industrial applications because they combine the specificity of native enzymes with the advantage that they can be readily separated from end product and reused. We demonstrated the use of the Caulobacter crescentus surface (S)-layer protein (RsaA) secretion apparatus for the generation of particulate enzymes. Specifically, a candidate protein made previously by fusion of the beta-1,4-glycanase (Cex) from the cellulolytic bacterium Cellulomonas fimi with the C-terminus of RsaA was evaluated. Cex/RsaA cleaved the glycosidic linkage in the artificial substrate p-nitrophenyl-beta-D-cellobioside with a KM similar to that of native Cex (1.1 mM for Cex/RsaA vs 0.60 mM for Cex), indicating that the particulate Cex enzyme was able to bind substrate with wild-type affinity. By contrast, the kcat value was significantly reduced (0.08 s-1 for Cex/RsaA vs 15.8 s-1 for Cex), likely owing to the fact that the RsaA C-terminus induces spontaneous unstructured aggregation of the recombinant protein. Here, we demonstrated that not only can an RsaA fusion protein be cheaply produced and purified to a high yield (76 mg/L of dry wt for Cex/RsaA), but it can also be efficiently recycled. The Caulobacter S-layer secretion system therefore offers an attractive new model system for the production of particulate biocatalysts.

Strains of Caulobacter crescentus elaborate an S-layer, a two-dimensional protein latticework which covers the cell surface. The S-layer protein (RsaA) is secreted by a type I mechanism (relying on a C-terminal signal) and is unusual among type I secreted proteins because high levels of protein are produced continuously. In efforts to adapt the S-layer for display of foreign peptides and proteins, we noted a proteolytic activity that affected S-layer monomers with foreign inserts. The cleavage was precise, resulting in fragments with an unambiguous N-terminal sequence. We developed an assay to screen for loss of this activity (i.e., presentation of foreign peptides without degradation), using transposon and traditional mutagenesis. A metalloprotease gene designated sap (S-layer-associated protease) was identified which could complement the protease-negative mutants. The N-terminal half of Sap possessed significant similarity to other type I secreted proteases (e.g., alkaline protease of Pseudomonas aeruginosa), including the characteristic RTX repeat sequences, but the C-terminal half which normally includes the type I secretion signal exhibited no such similarity. Instead, there was a region of significant similarity to the N-terminal region of RsaA. We hypothesize that Sap evolved by combining the catalytic portion of a type I secreted protease with an S-layer-like protein, perhaps to associate with nascent S-layer monomers to “scan” for modifications.

We report the development of an IHNV vaccine produced by a new protein production system based on the bacterium Caulobacter crescentus. The subunit vaccines that were tested contain a 184 amino acid segment of the IHNV glycoprotein in different fusion arrangements with the C. crescentus S-layer protein. Relative percent survival of 26 to 34% was demonstrated in rainbow trout fry for a vaccine that contained the 184 amino acid segment of the IHNV glycoprotein fused to the C-terminal one-quarter of the S-layer protein. Inclusion of the universal mammalian T-cell epitopes developed from the measles fusion protein or the tetanus toxin protein did not increase the effectiveness of the IHNV-G/S-layer recombinant protein.

A novel bacterial protein secretion system was used to produce vaccine candidates against Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The surface protein (RsaA) of Caulobacter crescentus was adapted to produce recombinant vaccine proteins based on the pilus tip epitope ('adhesintope') of P. aeruginosa. Two versions of the adhesintope, with (PCK) or without (PE) the cysteine residues that flank the epitope were investigated, fused to the C-terminus or inserted into full-length RsaA. When expressed in caulobacter the fusion proteins were secreted as aggregates. Full length RsaA-containing adhesintopes assembled on the cell surface as an S-layer; these were recovered by low pH extraction. Vaccine candidates were evaluated in a mouse challenge model. PCK-containing proteins produced at least 1000-fold higher antibody titers against the adhesintope, compared to the PE version, exceeding titers achievable with any other vaccine preparation method. Immunoglobulin isotyping indicated a balanced IgG1/IgG2 response, though when challenged with P. aeruginosa, the PE- and PCK-containing proteins did not afford mice a significant level of protection. Overall, we describe a new system for vaccine production that shows promise as a fast, economical way to construct, evaluate and produce vaccine proteins.

The secretion signal of the Caulobacter crescentusS-layer protein (RsaA) was localized to the C-terminal 82 amino acids of the molecule. Protein yield studies showed that 336 or 242 C-terminal residues of RsaA mediated secretion of >50 mg of a cellulase passenger protein per liter to the culture fluids.

Caulobacter sp.are gram-negative bacteria common in freshwater and marine environments. These organisms exhibit a life cycle alternating between a monoflagellated swarmer cell and nonmotile stalked cell. The stalked cell is typically found attached to inert surfaces by an attachment structure at the base of the stalk, the holdfast. It was observed more than forty years ago that the spatial positioning and temporal regulation of the structures associated with this developmental progression (e.g., the stalk, the flagellum) during the cell cycle is remarkably reproducible. As a result, one freshwater caulobacter species, C. crescentus, emerged as a bacterial model system for cell differentiation and temporal control of gene expression (Brun et al, 1994; Gober and Marques, 1995).

The paracrystalline surface (S)-layer of Caulobacter crescentus is composed of a single secreted protein (RsaA) that interlocks in a hexagonal pattern to completely envelop the bacterium. Using a genetic approach, we inserted a 12 amino acid peptide from Pseudomonas aeruginosa strain K pilin at numerous semirandom positions in RsaA. We then used an immunological screen to identify those sites that presented the inserted pilin peptide on the C. crescentus cell surface as a part of the S-layer. Eleven such sites (widely separated in the primary sequence) were identified, demonstrating for the first time that S-layers can be readily exploited as carrier proteins to display 'epitope-size' heterologous peptides on bacterial cell surfaces. Whereas intact RsaA molecules carrying a pilin peptide could always be found on the surface of C. crescentus regardless of the particular insertion site, introduction of the pilin peptide at 9 of the 11 sites resulted in some proteolytic cleavage of RsaA. Two types of proteolytic phenomena were observed. The first was characterized by a single cleavage within the pilin peptide insert with both fragments of the S-layer protein remaining anchored to the outer membrane. The other proteolytic phenomenon was characterized by cleavage of the S-layer protein at a point distant from the site of the pilin peptide insertion. This cleavage always occurred at the same location in RsaA regardless of the particular insertion site, yielding a surface-anchored 26 kDa proteolytic fragment bearing the RsaA N-terminus; the C-terminal cleavage product carrying the pilin peptide was released into the growth medium. When the results of this work were combined with the results of a previous study, the RsaA primary sequence could be divided into three regions with respect to the location of a peptide insertion and its effect on S-layer biogenesis: (i) insertions in the extreme N-terminus of RsaA either produce no apparent effect on S-layer biogenesis or disrupt surface-anchoring of the protein; (ii) insertions in the extreme C-terminus either produce no apparent effect on S-layer biogenesis or disrupt protein secretion; and (iii) insertions more centrally located in the protein either have no apparent effect on S-layer biogenesis or result in proteolytic cleavage of RsaA. These data are discussed in relation to our previous assignment of the RsaA N- and C-terminus as regions that are important for surface anchoring and secretion respectively.

Although S-layers are being increasingly identified on Bacteria and Archaea, it is enigmatic that in most cases S-layer function continues to elude us. In a few instances, S-layers have been shown to be virulence factors on pathogens (e.g. Campylobacter fetus ssp. fetus and Aeromonas salmonicida), protective against Bdellovibrio, a depository for surface-exposed enzymes (e.g. Bacillus stearothermophilus), shape-determining agents (e.g. Thermoproteus tenax) and nucleation factors for fine-grain mineral development (e.g. Synechococcus GL 24). Yet, for the vast majority of S-layered bacteria, the natural function of these crystalline arrays continues to be evasive. The following review up-dates the functional basis of S-layers and describes such diverse topics as the effect of S-layers on the Gram stain, bacteriophage adsorption in lactobacilli, phagocytosis by human polymorphonuclear leukocytes, the adhesion of a high-molecular-mass amylase, outer membrane porosity, and the secretion of extracellular enzymes of Thermoanaerobacterium. In addition, the functional aspect of calcium on the Caulobacter S-layer is explained.