Serge Thill’s research while affiliated with Radboud University and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (121)


Questions: A Taxonomy for Critical Reflection in Machine-Supported Decision-Making
  • Preprint
  • File available

April 2025

·

12 Reads

Simon W. S. Fischer

·

Hanna Schraffenberger

·

Serge Thill

·

Decision-makers run the risk of relying too much on machine recommendations. Explainable AI, a common strategy for calibrating reliance, has mixed and even negative effects, such as increasing overreliance. To cognitively engage the decision-maker and to facilitate a deliberate decision-making process, we propose a potential `reflection machine' that supports critical reflection about the pending decision, including the machine recommendation. Reflection has been shown to improve critical thinking and reasoning, and thus decision-making. One way to stimulate reflection is to ask relevant questions. To systematically create questions, we present a question taxonomy inspired by Socratic questions and human-centred explainable AI. This taxonomy can contribute to the design of such a `reflection machine' that asks decision-makers questions. Our work is part of the growing research on human-machine collaborations that goes beyond the paradigm of machine recommendations and explanations, and aims to enable greater human oversight as required by the European AI Act.

Download


Support, But Do Not Replace, Human Expertise: A Few Considerations for the Deployment of Machine Learning in Support of Neurodiverse Children and Adolescents

December 2024

·

6 Reads

Machine learning and artificial intelligence currently see rapid developments and growth. In this chapter, we discuss some of the implications of the increasing ubiquitousness of resulting algorithms in technology used to support neurodiverse children in various contexts. The focus is less on discussing specific methods, given the rapid pace at which they currently evolve, and more on an attempt to highlight general principles and concerns. We highlight in particular that although algorithmic approaches can support various stakeholders, such as parents, therapists, teachers, and the children themselves, they cannot and should not replace them. More generally, we will distinguish between different uses of algorithms, namely the description of observable data and the interpretation thereof. We also discuss some of the fundamental challenges, for example in assessing vaguely-defined mental states. Overall, the purpose of this chapter is to create an awareness of the potentials, but also the limitations of machine learning approaches to supporting neurodiverse children in various contexts.



Survival games for humans and machines

August 2024

·

223 Reads

Cognitive Systems Research

·

Niklas Engsner

·

Simon Ulfsbäcker

·

[...]

·

Serge Thill

Survival games can be described as video games where the player searches for energy and treasures, while avoiding obstacles and hostile attacks. Ms.Pac-Man and Minecraft are two well-known examples. Currently there are AI models that outperform human players at Ms.Pac-Man, while AI models playing Minecraft above the human level has been a long-standing challenge. This paper concerns what we call pure survival games, which take place in previously unseen worlds containing only energy, water, and obstacles. The challenge of the player is to navigate and survive in those worlds by continuously finding resources and avoiding obstacles. Arguably, animals need to master physical analogues of pure survival games in order to survive and reproduce. Here we begin to explore human and machine performance on pure survival games. We define two games called the Grid game and the Terrain game and two corresponding AI agents based on deep reinforcement learning: the Grid agent and the Terrain agent. We explore to what extent these agents can match human performance and how their performance is affected by variations in their perception, memory, and reward models. We find that (1) the Terrain agent performs above human level, while the Grid agent performs below human level. (2) the smell, touch, and interoception models contribute significantly to the performance of the Grid agent. (3) the memory model contributes significantly to the performance of the Grid agent; and (4) the performance of the Grid agent is relatively stable under three quite different reward signals, including one that rewards survival and nothing else.


Autopoiesis meets mechanistic computation: A proof of concept of computational post-cognitivism

July 2024

·

13 Reads

Historically it was assumed that computation requires representation, which meant that Post-Cognitivism (PC) naturally rejected computationalism as well. Recent research suggests that computation is possible without explicit representation [7, 6]. This led to the proposal that PC does not necessarily imply anti-computationalism [10]. In this work, we provide initial empirical support that a theory of Comutational Post-Cognitivism (CoPC) [10] is feasible. On the example of Autopoietic Theory (AT) [9] we demonstrate that by choosing a suitable theory of computation such as Mechanistic Computation (MC) [8] as suggested by Villalobos and Dewhurst, it is indeed possible for an observer to interpret a system as being both computationalist and autopoietic. We achieve this using a simulation built on Game of Life (GoL) as virtual environment, as it has previously been shown that autopoietic properties can be identified in GoL [2]. GoL is inspected under the lenses of MC and AT as examples of computationalism and of post-cognitivism, respectively. When we identify something that arguably qualifies as computational mechanism (according to MC) and autopoietic (according to AT), then we have identified something that is qualifies as CoPC.


Autopoiesis meets mechanistic computation: A proof of concept of computational post-cognitivism

March 2024

·

14 Reads

For a long time it was taken for granted that computation requires representation, which meant that Post-Cognitivism naturally rejected computationalism as well. However, recent advances in neural network research showed that computation is possible without explicit representation. This led to the proposal that Post-Cognitivism does not necessarily imply anti-computationalism. Most of the discussions however remain philosophical in nature. In this work, we provide initial empirical support that such a theory of Comutational Post-Cognitivism is feasible. Specifically, we demonstrate on the example of Autopoietic Theory that, given a suitable theory of computation such as Mechanistic Computation as suggested by Villalobos and Dewhurst, it is indeed possible for an observer to interpret a system as being both computationalist and au- topoietic. We achieve this using a simulation built on Game of Life as virtual environment, as it has previously been shown that autopoietic properties can be identified in GoL.


Overview of studies and datasets. Type refers to the variable type.
Datasets for Artificial Intelligence in Education: The Case of Children with Neurodevelopmental Disorders

August 2023

·

188 Reads

·

1 Citation

Artificial intelligence has shown promise for supporting children with neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs) in educational settings. For such vulnerable population, aspects such as emotion, communication, and motivation are very relevant, but also challenging to be modeled. In this work, we focus on the machine learning technology used in such scenarios, in particular the characteristics of datasets used for model training. We do this by analyzing recent papers on children with NDDs. This will give insight into existing trade-offs, such as data annotation involved in data collection, as well as automation aspects. We also analyze opportunities offered by the functionalities of ML models trained on such datasets. In addition, we point out limitations and future challenges to help advance the area.Keywordsmachine learningdata annotationneurodevelopmental disorderschildreneducationhuman-computer interaction


Designing Visual and Auditory Attention-Driven Movements of a Tabletop Robot

August 2023

·

16 Reads

·

5 Citations

This work presents a framework for a visual- auditory attention-driven robot eye-head gaze movement, which combines visual and auditory inputs to determine the direction of movement for a social robot. The framework computes the most salient changes in position by considering both visual and auditory cues. The proposed system was implemented on Haru, a tabletop social robot, where eye-head gaze movement was controlled using visual input from a camera positioned above the eyes and auditory input from a seven-channel microphone. This allowed for eye rotation on a two-dimensional flat screen and body movement towards the person who is speaking. This framework provides a representation of the robot’s attentional gaze that leverages both visual and auditory cues, resulting in more natural and responsive coordinated eye- head gaze movements of the social robot. The potential benefits include improved communication, increased engagement, and a stronger sense of connection with the robot.


Learning Policies for Continuous Control via Transition Models

March 2023

·

9 Reads

·

2 Citations

Communications in Computer and Information Science

It is doubtful that animals have perfect inverse models of their limbs (e.g., what muscle contraction must be applied to every joint to reach a particular location in space). However, in robot control, moving an arm’s end-effector to a target position or along a target trajectory requires accurate forward and inverse models. Here we show that by learning the transition (forward) model from interaction, we can use it to drive the learning of an amortized policy. Hence, we revisit policy optimization in relation to the deep active inference framework and describe a modular neural network architecture that simultaneously learns the system dynamics from prediction errors and the stochastic policy that generates suitable continuous control commands to reach a desired reference position. We evaluated the model by comparing it against the baseline of a linear quadratic regulator, and conclude with additional steps to take toward human-like motor control.KeywordsContinuous neural controlPolicy optimizationActive inference


Citations (72)


... In consequence, their movements can appear unnatural, scripted, or even disturbing [20,21], possibly leading to an ignorance of the eyes in the long term. Virtual eyes that are presented on displays [14,16,22] may overcome many limitations related to latency and available degrees of freedom but can have difficulties in unambiguously conveying spatial information due to their two-dimensional screen projection. ...

Reference:

Virtual Reflections on a Dynamic 2D Eye Model Improve Spatial Reference Identification
Designing Visual and Auditory Attention-Driven Movements of a Tabletop Robot
  • Citing Conference Paper
  • August 2023

... Ferrari et al. [16] conducted pilot studies to design interactions to help children cope with pain in a hospital setting. While focusing on an adult population, Boumans et al. [11] developed a robot to explain the physical examinations. Their findings indicated that the robot's explanations were perceived as clear, highlighting the potential of social robots in enhancing understanding of medical procedures. ...

A Social Robot for Explaining Medical Tests and Procedures: An Exploratory Study in the Wild
  • Citing Conference Paper
  • March 2023

... The works of McDougall (2018) and Salloch and Eriksen (2024) tend to address the restoration of patient's autonomy in medical decisionmaking within the context of ML_CDSS application in healthcare. To begin with, Salloch and Eriksen (2024) allude that when it comes to the use of ML_CDSS in healthcare, concepts such as 'meaningful human control' or 'effective human oversight' (Haselager et al. 2024) must be employed to serve as key ideas to aid the control of the decisive steps in medical decision-making. It is imperative to introduce regulatory frameworks that ensure human agents can overrule and control the machine when necessary (Salloch and Eriksen 2024). ...

Reflection Machines: Supporting Effective Human Oversight Over Medical Decision Support Systems

Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics

... In recent years, several review articles have significantly advanced the understanding of human-vehicle interactions (HVIs), particularly in decision-making and AI collaboration. For instance, [6] explored the future development of autonomous vehicles through a cognitive systems perspective, establishing foundational approaches for enhancing intelligent decision-making. Similarly, [7] examined hybrid intelligence systems, emphasizing their potential to improve decisionmaking in dynamic and nonlinear driving scenarios. ...

Where to from here? On the future development of autonomous vehicles from a cognitive systems perspective
  • Citing Article
  • December 2022

Cognitive Systems Research

... Recently, there have been works focused on behavioral analysis of the machine-learned prediction models. Zgonnikov et al. [16] conducted an interdisciplinary workshop focused on how human robot interaction (HRI) can be enhanced by utilizing human behavior modeling. Rahwan et al. [17] argued the importance of understanding the behaviors of the artificial intelligence (AI) including machine learning (ML) algorithms since they are becoming ubiquitous in day-to-day life. ...

Modeling Human Behavior in Human-Robot Interactions

... However, in human-human interaction, we often observe mutual understanding, suggesting that it is possible to establish shared perception. Recent evidence shows that the brain tends to reduce the reliance on prior experience when someone is involved in an interaction in favor of a more veridical perception of the physical event Tsfasman et al., 2022). Extending our comprehension of the processes by which our brain enables sharing perception with another agent is a significant challenge in building computational models promoting effective human-machine understanding. ...

The world seems different in a social context: A neural network analysis of human experimental data

... The choice and combination of modalities are critical for the robustness of robotic systems. According to [18], redundant modalities, such as dual cameras, enhance positional awareness and obstacle detection by providing multiple sources of the same type of information, similar to human binocular vision. Additive modalities, like combining depth scanners with cameras, offer complementary information that allows robots to navigate even in challenging conditions like low light. ...

Multiple Roles of Multimodality Among Interacting Agents
  • Citing Article
  • July 2022

ACM Transactions on Human-Robot Interaction

... Such robots need to swiftly adapt their eye movements in response to changes in their surroundings, enabling people to perceive the robot's attention state through its gaze behaviors. This, in turn, facilitates more effective communication and interaction between humans and robots [25,28]. On one hand, a robot's ability to focus on a human's face enhances the meaningfulness of its behavior. ...

Developing The Bottom-up Attentional System of A Social Robot
  • Citing Conference Paper
  • May 2022

... Social assistive robots and intelligent environments in psychological well-being in the elderly: a systematic review 249 anales de psicología / annals of psychology, 2025, vol. 41, nº 2 (may) three studies (Balasubramanian et al., 2021;Gosetto et al., 2024;Lee et al., 2024) had a low methodological quality (score between 0-4), likewise five studies were found (Assander et al., 2022;Boatman et al., 2020;Parker et al, 2021;Pino et al., 2020;Tseng and Hsu 2019) that possessed mod-erate methodological quality (score between 5-6) and four studies (Bradwell et al., 2022;Papadopoulos et al., 2022;Pollak et al., 2022;Taramasco et al., 2023) that possessed good quality (score between 7-8). All studies except Gosetto et al. (2024) described the selection criteria of the research participants, while four performed random and concealed assignment to each research group (Bradwell et al., 2022;Papadopoulos et al., 2022;Pollak et al., 2022;Taramasco et al., 2023). ...

Exploring the effect of implementing affordable socially assistive pet robots in eight care homes before and during the COVID-19 pandemic: a stratified cluster randomised controlled trial and mixed-method study. (Preprint)

JMIR Aging

... Additionally, the need for XAI systems to operate effectively across varying levels of data granularity calls for the design of frameworks capable of fluidly transitioning between detailed analysis of individual interactions and broader examination of social patterns. As empirical studies in XAI suggests that users would like to receive explanations at various levels and stages, depending on what they know and would like to know [150], research on conflict resolution and data granularity adaptation promise to not only facilitate the seamless incorporation of social explanations into XAI frameworks but also advance the XAI field toward more nuanced and user-centric explanations. ...

The challenges of providing explanations of AI systems when they do not behave like users expect
  • Citing Conference Paper
  • July 2022