Robert Beyer’s research while affiliated with University of Cambridge and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (56)


Modeling climate migration: dead ends and new avenues
  • Article
  • Full-text available

August 2023

·

112 Reads

·

7 Citations

Frontiers in Climate

Robert M. Beyer

·

Jacob Schewe

·

Guy J. Abel

Understanding and forecasting human mobility in response to climatic and environmental changes has become a subject of substantial political, societal, and academic interest. Quantitative models exploring the relationship between climatic factors and migration patterns have been developed since the early 2000s; however, different models have produced results that are not always consistent with one another or robust enough to provide actionable insights into future dynamics. Here we examine weaknesses of classical methods and identify next-generation approaches with the potential to close existing knowledge gaps. We propose six priorities for the future of climate mobility modeling: (i) the use of non-linear machine-learning rather than linear methods, (ii) the prioritization of explaining the observed data rather than testing statistical significance of predictors, (iii) the consideration of relevant climate impacts rather than temperature- and precipitation-based metrics, (iv) the examination of heterogeneities, including across space and demographic groups rather than aggregated measures, (v) the investigation of temporal migration dynamics rather than essentially spatial patterns, (vi) the use of better calibration data, including disaggregated and within-country flows. Improving both methods and data to accommodate the high complexity and context-specificity of climate mobility will be crucial for establishing the scientific consensus on historical trends and future projections that has eluded the discipline thus far.

Download

pastclim: an R package to easily access and use paleoclimatic reconstructions

July 2023

·

126 Reads

·

Emily Hallett

·

Robert Beyer

·

[...]

·

The recent development of continuous paleoclimatic reconstructions covering hundreds of thousands of years paved the way for a large number of studies from disciplines ranging from paleoecology to conservation, archaeology to population genetics, macroevolution to anthropology, and human evolution to linguistics. The downside to this process is that (paleo)climatic data are stored in large and complex file formats, and they can be challenging to handle for scholars unfamiliar with them. Here we present pastclim, an R package facilitating the access and use of paleoclimatic reconstructions (https://evolecolgroup.github.io/pastclim/index.html). It currently gives direct access to two such datasets, covering respectively the last 120,000 and 800,000 years, and a vignette provides instructions on how to include additional ones. We are expecting the number of datasets available to increase in the following months. The package contains a set of R functions to quickly and easily recover the climate for time periods of interest either for the whole world or specific areas, extract data from locations scattered in space and/or time, retrieve time series from individual sites, and manage the ice or land coverage, offering a handy platform to include the climate of the past into existing or new analyses and pipelines.


Outputs of Examples 1 and 2. Example 1: Location of Contrebandiers Cave, Morocco; relative abundance of habitat associated with Artiodactyla between 120 000 and 90 000 years ago; Variation of climatic variables through time between 120 000 and 90 000 years ago. Example 2: Map of the horse observations used for the analyses; principal component analysis based on bioclimatic variables; correlation between climatic variables in locations occupied by horses (both time steps); distribution of climatic variables in locations occupied by horses (right, in color) and in the whole of Europe (left, light gray) (both time steps). The data and code to run the examples are available in the supplementary material.
pastclim 1.2: an R package to easily access and use paleoclimatic reconstructions

January 2023

·

1,049 Reads

·

30 Citations

The recent development of continuous paleoclimatic reconstructions covering hundreds of thousands of years paved the way for a large number of studies from disciplines ranging from paleoecology to archaeology, conservation to population genetics, macroevolution to anthropology and human evolution to linguistics. Unfortunately, (paleo)climatic data can be challenging to extract and analyze for scholars unfamiliar with such specific file formats. Here we present pastclim, an R package facilitating the access and use of paleoclimatic reconstructions. It currently includes two of such datasets, covering respectively the last 120 000 and 800 000 years, and a vignette provides instructions on how to include additional datasets. The package contains a set of functions to quickly and easily recover the climate for time periods of interest either for the whole world or specific areas, extract data from locations scattered in space and/or time, retrieve time series from individual sites, and manage the ice or land coverage, offering a handy platform to include the climate of the past into existing or new analyses and pipelines.


Climatically suitable locations for rainfed oil palm expansion under ZDCs, by biome
a–c, Neotropics (a), tropical Africa (b), and tropical Asia and Australasia (c). Insets: b, East coast of Africa and Madagascar; c, South Pacific. Locations of ‘other biome’ are largely Neotropical ‘xeric shrublands’ with relatively high rainfall.
Comparison of potential for rainfed, zero-deforestation oil palm expansion among biomes
a, Estimated protection of climatically suitable areas for rainfed oil palm expansion under ZDCs, according to the HCSA. Data are plotted as a percentage of the total climatically suitable area of non-cultivated land by biome; this total suitable area is shown in brackets along the x axis. Locations that would be protected under ZDCs are shown in grey and locations potentially available for ZDC expansion are shown in colours (see Fig. 1). b, Potential for loss of remaining non-cultivated land of individual ecoregions (that is, percentage of remaining non-cultivated land per ecoregion that is climatically suitable for expansion under ZDCs). Boxplot centre lines show the median, lower and upper hinges show the first and third quartiles, respectively, whiskers extend to the maximum and minimum values within 1.5 × interquartile range, and outliers are plotted individually.
Source data
Expected annual fresh fruit bunch (FFB) yields in locations climatically suitable for oil palm expansion under ZDCs, assuming high-fertilizer-input cultivation
a,b, Under rainfed cultivation (a) and under irrigation (b; assuming up to 100% of surplus available water is used for irrigation). In b, dark colours show the expected yield in locations that are also suitable if rainfed, when under irrigation (that is, the expected yield in locations shown in a when irrigation is applied, if required), and pale colours represent locations only suitable under irrigation. The difference between the distribution of expected yield values for dark colours in a and b thus represents the effect of applying irrigation to the locations suitable for rainfed cultivation. Note differences in y-axis values for the oil palm suitability classes. See Supplementary Information 4 for sensitivity analyses of predicted suitability for irrigated oil palm to model suitability thresholds, habitat protection under ZDCs and water availability.
Source data
Potential impacts of rainfed, zero-deforestation oil palm expansion on vertebrates
a, Vertebrate species richness change (mammals, birds and amphibians; negative values denote number of species lost) from conversion of natural habitat to oil palm, by expected protection under ZDCs, within each biome and continent. Boxplots show potential richness change of non-cultivated land climatically suitable for oil palm expansion, where each datapoint is a 10-km grid cell (sample sizes are given to the lower right of each boxplot). Richness change in ‘Other’ biomes is negligible and shown in Supplementary Information 5. b, Potential percentage range reduction of threatened vertebrates from oil palm expansion under ZDCs (overlap between ranges of threatened vertebrates and locations climatically suitable for expansion) for all species that could undergo range loss from expansion (that is, species that have some range overlap with potential expansion locations and cannot persist in oil palm). Numbers of species overlapping with potential expansion locations are given in x-axis labels; note that a species can occur in more than one biome. For both a and b, boxplot centre lines show the median, lower and upper hinges show the first and third quartiles, respectively, whiskers extend to the maximum and minimum values within 1.5 × interquartile range, and outliers are plotted individually.
Source data
Implications of zero-deforestation palm oil for tropical grassy and dry forest biodiversity

November 2022

·

385 Reads

·

12 Citations

Nature Ecology & Evolution

Many companies have made zero-deforestation commitments (ZDCs) to reduce carbon emissions and biodiversity losses linked to tropical commodities. However, ZDCs conserve areas primarily based on tree cover and aboveground carbon, potentially leading to the unintended consequence that agricultural expansion could be encouraged in biomes outside tropical rainforest, which also support important biodiversity. We examine locations suitable for zero-deforestation expansion of commercial oil palm, which is increasingly expanding outside the tropical rainforest biome, by generating empirical models of global suitability for rainfed and irrigated oil palm. We find that tropical grassy and dry forest biomes contain >50% of the total area of land climatically suitable for rainfed oil palm expansion in compliance with ZDCs (following the High Carbon Stock Approach; in locations outside urban areas and cropland), and that irrigation could double the area suitable for expansion in these biomes. Within these biomes, ZDCs fail to protect areas of high vertebrate richness from oil palm expansion. To prevent unintended consequences of ZDCs and minimize the environmental impacts of oil palm expansion, policies and governance for sustainable development and conservation must expand focus from rainforests to all tropical biomes.



pastclim: an R package to easily access and use paleoclimatic reconstructions

May 2022

·

1,305 Reads

·

2 Citations

The recent development of continuous paleoclimatic reconstructions covering hundreds of thousands of years paved the way to a large number of studies from disciplines ranging from paleoecology to linguistics, from archaeology to conservation and from population genetics to human evolution. Unfortunately, such climatic data can be challenging to extract and analyze for scholars unfamiliar with such specific climatic file formats. Here we present pastclim , an R package facilitating the access and use of two sets of paleoclimatic reconstructions covering respectively the last 120,000 and 800,000 years. The package contains a set of functions allowing to quickly and easily recover the climate for the whole world or specific areas for time periods of interest, extract data from locations scattered in space and/or time, retrieve time series from individual sites, and easily manage the ice or land coverage. The package can easily be adapted to paleoclimatic reconstructions different from the ones already included, offering a handy platform to include the climate of the past into existing analyses and pipelines.


Figure 1. Modern ecoregional biomes of Sub-Saharan West Africa and location of Pleistocene archaeological sites. Original ecoregional data from Olson et al. (2001).
Figure 2. Satellite imagery of Anyama (1; a-b), Iho Eleru (2; d-e), Paloli (3; g-h) and Tanongou Valley (4; g-i) in Tanongou Valley. Below them are site photographs showing the mining activity which revealed Anyama (c), the dense forested environment which surrounds Iho Eleru (f), and the open forested environment of Tanongou Cave (i).
Archaeological sites and palaeoenvironments of Pleistocene West Africa

April 2022

·

274 Reads

·

10 Citations

African paleoanthropological studies typically focus on regions of the continent such as Eastern, Southern and Northern Africa, which hold the highest density of Pleistocene archaeological sites. Nevertheless, lesser known areas such as West Africa also feature a high number of sites. Here, we present a high-resolution map synthesising all well contextualised Pleistocene archaeological sites present in Sub-Saharan West Africa. A detailed elevation and ecoregional map was developed and correlated with palaeoanthropological sites. This map is supplemented with 1,000- and 2000-year interval climate reconstructions over the last 120,000 years for three subregions of high archaeological interest. The presented archaeological sites were compiled by reviewing published literature, and selected based on: (1) documented archaeological stratification or >10 characteristic artefacts, (2) published coordinates, and (3) published chronometric ages or relative dating. The data presented here elucidates the current state of knowledge of Pleistocene West Africa, highlighting the regional potential for human evolutionary studies.


Current and environmentally optimal distributions of global croplands
The estimated reduction potentials in a are based on an optimal trade-off between carbon and biodiversity impacts (see the “Methods” section). Potential yield data used here are based on current climatic conditions and assume high-input crop management and rainfed water supply, so that relocated areas are, by design of the approach, not irrigated. The global production levels of individual crops for optimally distributed areas are identical to current levels; in the scenario of national relocation, this is additionally the case for national production levels. For visualisation purposes, in b–d, the 25 crops were grouped together; maps of the optimal distribution of individual crops for across- and within-border relocation are shown in Supplementary Movie 1.
Optimal distributions of global croplands for end-of-century climate
The maps show the equivalents of Fig. 1c based on potential yields projected for 2071–2100 climate under four alternative emission scenarios: RCP a 2.6, b 4.5, c 6.0, d 8.5. In each scenario, the production levels of individual crops are identical to current ones, given the lack of suitable future projections (see text). Maps of the distribution of the 25 individual crops for each climate scenario are shown in Supplementary Movie 3. Optimal cropland sites for relocation within national borders (i.e., equivalents of Fig. 1d) were not estimated, as the optimisation problem in this case is ill-defined (see the “Methods” section).
Reductions of carbon and biodiversity impacts for different relocation levels and management scenarios
Each coloured line represents the set of simultaneously achievable carbon and biodiversity impact reductions, relative to current impacts, which vary according to the weight given to them in the optimisation framework (see the “Methods” section). As per the data used, relocated croplands are rainfed; the resulting percentage of irrigated croplands in each scenario (ranging between 21% for the current distribution, and 0% and 0.6% in the scenario of full relocation across and within national borders, respectively) is not displayed. Black markers represent the optimal trade-off between carbon and biodiversity impacts (see the “Methods” section); those in a and b correspond to the cropland maps in Fig. 1c, d, respectively, and those in c–f to the maps in Supplementary Fig. 3a–d. In all scenarios, the global production levels of individual crops are identical to current ones; in the scenarios of national relocation, this is additionally the case for national production levels. All estimates are based on current climatic conditions.
Relocating croplands could drastically reduce the environmental impacts of global food production

March 2022

·

531 Reads

·

69 Citations

Agricultural production has replaced natural ecosystems across the planet, becoming a major driver of carbon emissions, biodiversity loss, and freshwater consumption. Here we combined global crop yield and environmental data in a ~1-million-dimensional mathematical optimisation framework to determine how optimising the spatial distribution of global croplands could reduce environmental impacts whilst maintaining current crop production levels. We estimate that relocating current croplands to optimal locations, whilst allowing ecosystems in then-abandoned areas to regenerate, could simultaneously decrease the current carbon, biodiversity, and irrigation water footprint of global crop production by 71%, 87%, and 100%, respectively, assuming high-input farming on newly established sites. The optimal global distribution of crops is largely similar for current and end-of-century climatic conditions across emission scenarios. Substantial impact reductions could already be achieved by relocating only a small proportion of worldwide crop production, relocating croplands only within national borders, and assuming less intensive farming systems. Optimising the spatial distribution of global croplands could substantially reduce carbon emissions and biodiversity loss associated with rain-fed crop production, according to a mathematical framework applied to environmental impact and crop yield data


Gravity models do not explain, and cannot predict, international migration dynamics

February 2022

·

127 Reads

·

37 Citations

Humanities and Social Sciences Communications

The major social and economic impacts of international migration have led to a strong interest in better understanding the drivers of cross-border movement. Quantitative models have sought to explain global migration patterns in terms of economic, social, climatic, and other variables, and future projections of these variables are increasingly being used to forecast international migration flows. An important implicit assumption in the most widely used class of these approaches, so-called gravity models, is that their parameterisation based on panel data enables them to describe the effects of predictor variables on migration flows across both space and time, i.e., that they explain flow variation both across country pairs at a given time and across time for a given country pair. Here we show that this assumption does not hold. Whilst gravity models describe spatial patterns of international migration very well, they fail to capture even basic temporal dynamics, indeed, often worse than even the time-invariant average of the historical flows. We show that standard validation techniques have been unable to detect this important limitation of gravity models due to the different orders of magnitude of migration flows across spatial corridors, on the one hand, and over time, on the other hand. Our analysis suggests that gravity-model-based inferences about the effects that certain variables have had, or will have, on international migration over time may in reality represent statistical artefacts rather than true mechanisms. We argue that future predictions based on gravity models lack statistical support and that, in its current form, this class of models is not suited for informing policy makers about migration trajectories in the coming years and decades.


Fig. 2. From the Eemian (120,000 B.P.) to the present (0 B.P.), temporal alignment of (A) changes in global surface temperature during the last 1 million y (in Celsius compared to the present indicated by dotted, vertical line), (B) estimated latitudinal migration distance (kilometers), (C) predicted area of suitable breeding habitat (number of cells with suitability above monthly threshold; dotted line indicates the present condition), and (D) effective population size estimates (BSP) for Lanius clades 1 and 2.
Fig. 3. Summed area of all cells with predicted presence from binary projection (threshold maximizing sensitivity and specificity for each month), presented as mean of all months (Left) and quarterly means (Right) from 120,000 B.P. to present (0 B.P.). Shaded area indicates 95% CI.
Fig. 4. Effective population size estimates back in time. BSPs of the two Lanius clades based on complete mitochondrial genomes. The solid lines represent the median estimates of the effective population size, with the 95% high posterior density interval denoted by the dashed lines (note the logarithmic scale on the y-axis).
Response of an Afro-Palearctic bird migrant to glaciation cycles

December 2021

·

397 Reads

·

43 Citations

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

Significance We combine tracks of a long-distance migratory bird with high–temporal resolution climate data to reconstruct habitat availability month by month for the past 120,000 y. The seasonal changes of suitable habitat in the past imply that continued seasonal migration was necessary during the glacial maxima. Genomic-based estimates of effective population size indicate that more generally migratory lifestyles can be beneficially adapted to various climatic conditions. Our results provide a major step forward in understanding how migratory species will fare in the future and have important implications for how we understand the role of migration in the distribution of species and potentially speciation.


Citations (44)


... With climate change leading to more frequent and severe extreme weather events (AghaKouchak et al., 2020), disaster-induced population movement is becoming a topic of growing interest within academic, media and policy circles. Although the scale of the phenomenon is difficult to assess (Beyer et al., 2023;Hugo, 1996), there are numerous examples of large-scale displacement following floods, wildfires and cyclones. For example, over 500,000 people were displaced after Hurricane Katrina in 2005 (Gabe et al., 2005) and 7 million people following the Pakistani floods of 2010 (Din, 2010). ...

Reference:

Residential mobility responses to home damage caused by floods, cyclones and bushfires in Australia
Modeling climate migration: dead ends and new avenues

Frontiers in Climate

... To date, our understanding of climate conditions at a regional scale in Northwest Africa during MIS 4-2 (~71-11 ka) remains largely unexplored and demographic-ecology-driven hypotheses primarily based on site(s)-specific analysis (Stoetzel et al., 2014;Ben Nasr et al., 2016;Prendergast et al., 2016;Campmas, 2017;Merzoug, 2017;Barton et al., 2019;Terray et al., 2023;Uzunidis et al., 2023). Climate simulations have only been made widely available to archaeologists interested in exploring humans-environment interactions over the last decade, offering insights into climatic variability across wider geographic areas than typically provided by proxies at individual sites (Beyer et al., 2020;Krapp et al., 2021;Leonardi et al., 2023). When employed in combination with ethnographic and/or archaeological data, this offers a broad-scale approach to address such issues (e.g., Grove, 2018;Burke et al., 2021;Albouy et al., 2024). ...

pastclim 1.2: an R package to easily access and use paleoclimatic reconstructions

... As much as 27% of global forest loss from 2001 to 2015 can be attributed to commodity-driven deforestation, with permanent land use change to agriculture (including oil palm), mining or energy infrastructure (Curtis et al., 2018). Ecosystems such as savanna and peatlands are also affected by conversion (Fleiss et al., 2022;Warren-Thomas et al., 2022). ...

Implications of zero-deforestation palm oil for tropical grassy and dry forest biodiversity

Nature Ecology & Evolution

... Estimates for 18 bioclimatic and topographic variables (including temperature and precipitation indices, and elevation (Supplementary Data 12) in the target period with high spatial (0.5°× 0.5°) and temporal (2 kya timesteps) resolution, for the entire area of interest were accessed and extracted using the R package pastclim 57,134 . To avoid biases in fitting the species distribution model using redundant predictors, the 18 bioclimatic and topographic variables were tested for collinearity and multicollinearity on the whole studied area (883260 spatial points). ...

pastclim: an R package to easily access and use paleoclimatic reconstructions

... In recent years, numerous efforts have been made by several researchers to overcome the geographical bias in Stone Age research of Africa, particularly focusing on the search for Early and Middle Stone Age records in areas historically understudied like in West and Central Africa. The stateof-the-art has transitioned from more general overviews (Alabi, 2016;Baluh, 2017;Basell, 2010;Casey, 2003;Clark, 1959;Cole, 1967;Ervedosa, 1980;McIntosh and McIntosh, 1983;Sandelowsky and Viereck, 1969;Wai-Ogosu, 1973;Wendt, 1972;White and Clark, 1965) to site-specific publications and case studies across almost all the countries between Morocco and South Africa, namely Senegal, Mali, Ghana, Burkina Faso, Guinea, Sierra Leone, Ivory Coast, Niger, Benin, Nigeria, Cameroon, Equatorial Guinea, Gabon, Congo basin, Angola, and Namibia (Alabi, 2016;Allsworth-Jones, 1981Andah, 1979;Bagodo, 2004;Baluh, 2017;Cerasoni et al., 2022;Chevrier et al., 2018; focused on cleavers using the ''French school'' typology for the ''hachereaux'' in Northern Africa and concluded that there are several morphotypes identified in Capangombe-Santo Antó nio with specific features, suggesting the occurrence of a local tradition for the Late ESA/Middle Stone Age (MSA). The study presented here is a new analysis of the lithic assemblage curated at the University of Lisbon, Portugal. ...

Archaeological sites and palaeoenvironments of Pleistocene West Africa

... To increase domestic production there are three options: closing yield gaps on existing agricultural areas where there are large differences between current and attainable production, relocating agriculture to areas of higher potential production, or expanding the overall agricultural area in the country. While the net environmental impacts of intensification and land sparing versus more expansive diversified farming remain a subject of intense debate, intensification carries two potential benefits for global sustainability goals: first, supporting rural development and livelihoods by helping move farmers out of poverty traps (Beyer et al 2022), and second, contributing toward freeing up land for nature restoration (Meyfroidt et al 2018, García et al 2022. ...

Relocating croplands could drastically reduce the environmental impacts of global food production

... In the new model proposed here we assume that irregular immigration follow a logistic model, see (Giordano and Fox 2003) in the sense that host country put constraints and regulations laws that captures the idea of carrying capacity. Population migration models based on physical factors, the so called gravity models, or radiation models disregard intentions, emotions or interest see (Letouzé et al. 2009;Beyer et al. 2022;Yang et al. 2014). Machine learning models incorporate exogenous features to predict human flows (Robinson and Dilkina 2018). ...

Gravity models do not explain, and cannot predict, international migration dynamics

Humanities and Social Sciences Communications

... These significant shifts in global climate have been shown to correspond with fluctuations in historic population size in a number of species (Nadachowska-Brzyska et al. 2015;Kozma et al. 2016Kozma et al. , 2018. Over periods of cooling, temperate Western-Palearctic species will have likely been restricted to southern refugia in Europe (Iberia, Apennines, and Balkans; Hewitt 1999; but see Thorup et al. 2021). Restrictions to different glacial refugia and subsequent northward expansions during interglacial periods have been linked to contemporary population structure and subspecies divergence in multiple species, including birds and aerial insects (e.g., Schmitt 2007;Hansson et al. 2008;Nadachowska-Brzyska et al. 2016;de Greef et al. 2022). ...

Response of an Afro-Palearctic bird migrant to glaciation cycles

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

... These aspects could be highly significant when planning conservation or restoration efforts. In particular, if the changes observed in our data are linked to changes in community composition, this requires special attention for future projections, given the extent to which species go extinct 49,50 . ...

Range Sizes of the World’s Mammals, Birds, and Amphibians from the Mid-Holocene to the Industrial Period

Animals

... Environmental Data. We used a global dataset of downscaled and biascorrected monthly precipitation, temperature, and net primary productivity (NPP) for the past 120,000 y (48,49). Climate data in this dataset were derived by combining simulations of the HadCM3 and HadAM3H climate models with global observational records, while NPP estimates were obtained by applying the curated climate data to the Biome4 vegetation model (50). ...

Addendum: High-resolution terrestrial climate, bioclimate and vegetation for the last 120,000 years

Scientific Data