R. Paul Butler’s research while affiliated with Carnegie Institution for Science and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (337)


Two Earth-size Planets and an Earth-size Candidate Transiting the nearby Star HD 101581*
  • Article
  • Full-text available

December 2024

·

32 Reads

The Astronomical Journal

Michelle Kunimoto

·

·

·

[...]

·

Joshua Winn

We report the validation of multiple planets transiting the nearby ( d = 12.8 pc) K5V dwarf HD 101581 (GJ 435, TOI–6276, TIC 397362481). This system consists of at least two Earth-size planets whose orbits are near a mutual 4:3 mean-motion resonance, HD 101581 b ( R p = 0.956 − 0.061 + 0.063 R ⊕ , P = 4.47 days) and HD 101581c ( R p = 0.990 − 0.070 + 0.070 R ⊕ , P = 6.21 days). Both planets were discovered in Sectors 63 and 64 TESS observations and statistically validated with supporting ground-based follow-up. We also identify a signal that probably originates from a third transiting planet, TOI-6276.03 ( R p = 0.982 − 0.098 + 0.114 R ⊕ , P = 7.87 days). These planets are remarkably uniform in size and their orbits are evenly spaced, representing a prime example of the “peas-in-a-pod” architecture seen in other compact multiplanet systems. At V = 7.77, HD 101581 is the brightest star known to host multiple transiting planets smaller than 1.5 R ⊕ . HD 101581 is a promising system for atmospheric characterization and comparative planetology of small planets.

Download

Jitter Across 15 Years: Leveraging Precise Photometry from Kepler and TESS to Extract Exoplanets from Radial Velocity Time Series

December 2024

·

2 Reads

Stellar activity contamination of radial velocity (RV) data is one of the top challenges plaguing the field of extreme precision RV (EPRV) science. Previous work has shown that photometry can be very effective at removing such signals from RV data, especially stellar activity caused by rotating star spots and plage.The exact utility of photometry for removing RV activity contamination, and the best way to apply it, is not well known. We present a combination photometric and RV study of eight Kepler/K2 FGK stars with known stellar variability. We use NEID RVs acquired simultaneously with TESS photometry, and we perform injection recovery tests to quantify the efficacy of recent TESS photometry versus archival Kepler/K2 photometry for removing stellar variability from RVs. We additionally experiment with different TESS sectors when training our models in order to quantify the real benefit of simultaneously acquired RVs and photometry. We conclude that Kepler photometry typically performs better than TESS at removing noise from RV data when it is available, likely due to longer baseline and precision. In contrast, for targets with available K2 photometry, especially those most active, and with high precision (σNEID\sigma_{NEID} << 1 m s1^{-1}) NEID RVs, TESS may be the more informative dataset. However, contrary to expectations, we have found that training on simultaneous photometry does not always achieve the best results.


Figure 3. RV observations from PFS (green), UCLES (blue), and HARPS (orange). PUCHEROS+ RVs are not included due to the large uncertainties (∼50 m s −1 ). While the expected RV semi-amplitudes of the three planets are too small to be resolved (< 0.4 m s −1 ), the observations do not feature large RV variations corresponding to stellar-mass companions.
Figure 4. The field within 60 ′′ of HD 101581 in blue (far left), infrared (center left), and red (center right) filters from the SERC and AAO-SES Surveys, and from LCO/CTIO observations taken shortly after the end of the TESS observations in 2023 (right). The location of HD 101581 at the time of each image is marked with a blue cross, while the location at the start of TESS Sector 63 in 2023 March is marked in orange. The width of a TESS pixel (21 ′′ ) is marked in the top left of each panel. HD 101581 has moved ∼ 32 ′′ between 1977 and 2023. v sin i < 10 km s −1 , with measurements of lower v sin i limited by the resolution of the spectrograph. Perdelwitz et al. (2024) used the SPECIES codebase (Soto & Jenkins 2018) to extract parameters from the archival HARPS spectra for 3612 stars including HD 101581, finding T eff = 4709 ± 62 K, log g = 4.11 ± 0.13, [Fe/H] = −0.58 ± 0.05 dex, and v sin i = 2.47 ± 0.30 km s −1 . The T eff and log g values from the Hypatia, PUCHEROS+, and HARPS results all agree within 1σ, while the HARPS-based measurement of metallicity is slightly lower (1.6σ) than that from PUCHEROS+. Both analyses conclude that HD 101581 is a metal-poor star.
Figure 7. Plots of the transit model fits, with residuals after subtracting the median models provided in the lower panel of each phase diagram. Black points show observations with offsets subtracted and jitter terms added in quadrature with uncertainties, while colored circles represent binned data. Colored lines represent median model values. In each planet's phase diagram, the best-fit models for the other two planets have been subtracted from the data.
Figure 10. Estimated TSM and ESM values (Kempton et al. 2018) for known terrestrial planets (Rp < 1.5 R⊕) with TSM > 10, based on their properties given in the NASA Exoplanet Archive Planetary Systems Composite Data Table (NASA Exoplanet Archive 2024). Planets are colored by equilibrium temperature assuming zero albedo. Sub-Earths (Rp < 1 R⊕) are plotted with a black outline. The top-right box indicates the TSM/ESM parameter space in which the planets lie. The planets orbiting HD 101581 are among the best sub-Earths for characterization with both transmission and emission spectroscopy.
Figure 11. Instellation flux as a function of planet escape velocity, in log-log scale. Based on data from the NASA Exoplanet Archive (2024) downloaded on June 30, 2024. The empirical "cosmic shoreline" and the water vapor greenhouse runaway threshold (Zahnle & Catling 2017) are shown as cyan and yellow shaded regions, respectively. Planets are categorized into terrestrial planets (magenta), sub-Neptunes (blue), Neptune-like planets (green), and gas giants (yellow) based on radius, see legend. The red rectangles represent escape velocities calculated based on HD 101581 planets' mean estimated masses assuming Hypatia Catalog metallicity. Because only radius, but not mass, is known, we further plot light red regions covering all possible interior compositions, ranging from pure iron to pure silicates. Height of the rectangles represent uncertainties in insolation.

+1

Two Earth-size Planets and an Earth-size Candidate Transiting the Nearby Star HD 101581

December 2024

·

22 Reads

We report the validation of multiple planets transiting the nearby (d=12.8d = 12.8 pc) K5V dwarf HD 101581 (GJ 435, TOI-6276, TIC 397362481). The system consists of at least two Earth-size planets whose orbits are near a mutual 4:3 mean-motion resonance, HD 101581 b (Rp=0.9560.061+0.063 RR_{p} = 0.956_{-0.061}^{+0.063}~R_{\oplus}, P=4.47P = 4.47 days) and HD 101581 c (Rp=0.9900.070+0.070 RR_{p} = 0.990_{-0.070}^{+0.070}~R_{\oplus}, P=6.21P = 6.21 days). Both planets were discovered in Sectors 63 and 64 TESS observations and statistically validated with supporting ground-based follow-up. We also identify a signal that probably originates from a third transiting planet, TOI-6276.03 (Rp=0.9820.098+0.114 RR_{p} = 0.982_{-0.098}^{+0.114}~R_{\oplus}, P=7.87P = 7.87 days). These planets are remarkably uniform in size and their orbits are evenly spaced, representing a prime example of the "peas-in-a-pod" architecture seen in other compact multi-planet systems. At V=7.77V = 7.77, HD 101581 is the brightest star known to host multiple transiting planets smaller than 1.5 R1.5~R_{\oplus}. HD 101581 is a promising system for atmospheric characterization and comparative planetology of small planets.


Three Warm Jupiters orbiting TOI-6628, TOI-3837, TOI-5027 and one sub-Saturn orbiting TOI-2328

December 2024

·

5 Reads

We report the discovery and characterization of three new transiting giant planets orbiting TOI-6628, TOI-3837 and TOI-5027, and one new warm sub-Saturn orbiting TOI-2328, whose transits events were detected in the lightcurves of the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite \textbf{(TESS)} space mission. By combining TESS lightcurves with ground-based photometric and spectroscopic follow-up observations we confirm the planetary nature of the observed transits and radial velocity variations. TOI-6628~b has a mass of 0.75±\pm0.06~MJM_\mathrm{J}, a radius of 0.98±\pm0.05~RJR_J and is orbiting a metal-rich star with a period of 18.18424±0.00001\pm{0.00001} days and an eccentricity of 0.667±0.016\pm0.016, making it one of the most eccentric orbits of all known warm giants. TOI-3837~b has a mass of 0.59±\pm0.06~MJM_\mathrm{J}, a radius of 0.96±\pm0.05~RJR_J and orbits its host star every 11.88865±\pm0.00003~days, with a moderate eccentricity of 0.1980.058+0.046^{+0.046}_{-0.058}. With a mass of 2.01±\pm0.13~MJM_\mathrm{J} and a radius of 0.990.12+0.07^{+0.07}_{-0.12} RJR_J, TOI-5027~b orbits its host star in an eccentric orbit with e~=~0.3950.029+0.032^{+0.032}_{-0.029} every 10.24368±0.00001\pm{0.00001}~days. TOI-2328~b is a Saturn-like planet with a mass of 0.16±\pm0.02~MJM_\mathrm{J} and a radius of 0.89±\pm0.04~RJR_J, orbiting its host star in a nearly circular orbit with e~=~0.0570.029+0.046^{+0.046}_{-0.029} at an orbital period of 17.10197±0.00001\pm{0.00001} days. All four planets have orbital periods above 10 days, and our planet interior structure models are consistsent a rocky-icy core with a H/He envelope, providing evidence supporting the core accretion model of planet formation for this kind of planets.


HD 222237 b: a long period super-Jupiter around a nearby star revealed by radial-velocity and Hipparcos-Gaia astrometry

September 2024

·

7 Reads

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

Giant planets on long period orbits around the nearest stars are among the easiest to directly image. Unfortunately these planets are difficult to fully constrain by indirect methods, e.g., transit and radial velocity (RV). In this study, we present the discovery of a super-Jupiter, HD 222237 b, orbiting a star located 11.445 ± 0.002 pc away. By combining RV data, Hipparcos and multi-epoch Gaia astrometry, we estimate the planetary mass to be 5.190.58+0.58MJup{5.19}_{-0.58}^{+0.58}\, M_{\rm Jup}, with an eccentricity of 0.560.03+0.03{0.56}_{-0.03}^{+0.03} and a period of 40.84.5+5.8{40.8}_{-4.5}^{+5.8} yr, making HD 222237 b a promising target for imaging using the Mid-Infrared Instrument (MIRI) of JWST. A comparative analysis suggests that our method can break the inclination degeneracy and thus differentiate between prograde and retrograde orbits of a companion. We further find that the inferred contrast ratio between the planet and the host star in the F1550C filter (15.50μm15.50\, \mu \rm m) is approximately 1.9 × 10−4, which is comparable with the measured limit of the MIRI coronagraphs. The relatively low metallicity of the host star (0.32dex\rm -0.32\, dex) combined with the unique orbital architecture of this system presents an excellent opportunity to probe the planet-metallicity correlation and the formation scenarios of giant planets.


Single-star Warm-Jupiter Systems Tend to Be Aligned, Even around Hot Stellar Hosts: No T eff –λ Dependency*

September 2024

·

44 Reads

·

3 Citations

The Astrophysical Journal Letters

The stellar obliquity distribution of warm-Jupiter systems is crucial for constraining the dynamical history of Jovian exoplanets, as the warm Jupiters’ tidal detachment likely preserves their primordial obliquity. However, the sample size of warm-Jupiter systems with measured stellar obliquities has historically been limited compared to that of hot Jupiters, particularly in hot-star systems. In this work, we present newly obtained sky-projected stellar obliquity measurements for the warm-Jupiter systems TOI-559, TOI-2025, TOI-2031, TOI-2485, TOI-2524, and TOI-3972, derived from the Rossiter–McLaughlin effect, and show that all six systems display alignment with a median measurement uncertainty of 13°. Combining these new measurements with the set of previously reported stellar obliquity measurements, our analysis reveals that single-star warm-Jupiter systems tend to be aligned, even around hot stellar hosts. This alignment exhibits a 3.4 σ deviation from the T eff – λ dependency observed in hot-Jupiter systems, where planets around cool stars tend to be aligned, while those orbiting hot stars show considerable misalignment. The current distribution of spin–orbit measurements for Jovian exoplanets indicates that misalignments are neither universal nor primordial phenomena affecting all types of planets. The absence of misalignments in single-star warm-Jupiter systems further implies that many hot Jupiters, by contrast, have experienced a dynamically violent history.


HD 222237 b: a long period super-Jupiter around a nearby star revealed by radial-velocity and Hipparcos-Gaia astrometry

September 2024

·

10 Reads

Giant planets on long period orbits around the nearest stars are among the easiest to directly image. Unfortunately these planets are difficult to fully constrain by indirect methods, e.g., transit and radial velocity (RV). In this study, we present the discovery of a super-Jupiter, HD 222237 b, orbiting a star located 11.445±0.00211.445\pm0.002 pc away. By combining RV data, Hipparcos and multi-epoch Gaia astrometry, we estimate the planetary mass to be 5.190.58+0.58MJup{5.19}_{-0.58}^{+0.58}\,M_{\rm Jup}, with an eccentricity of 0.560.03+0.03{0.56}_{-0.03}^{+0.03} and a period of 40.84.5+5.8{40.8}_{-4.5}^{+5.8} yr, making HD 222237 b a promising target for imaging using the Mid-Infrared Instrument (MIRI) of JWST. A comparative analysis suggests that our method can break the inclination degeneracy and thus differentiate between prograde and retrograde orbits of a companion. We further find that the inferred contrast ratio between the planet and the host star in the F1550C filter (15.50μm15.50\,\mu \rm m) is approximately 1.9×1041.9\times10^{-4}, which is comparable with the measured limit of the MIRI coronagraphs. The relatively low metallicity of the host star (0.32dex\rm-0.32\,dex) combined with the unique orbital architecture of this system presents an excellent opportunity to probe the planet-metallicity correlation and the formation scenarios of giant planets.


TOI-2379 b and TOI-2384 b: two super-Jupiter mass planets transiting low-mass host stars

September 2024

·

6 Reads

Short-period gas giant planets have been shown to be significantly rarer for host stars less massive than the Sun. We report the discovery of two transiting giant planets - TOI-2379 b and TOI-2384 b - with low-mass (early M) host stars. Both planets were detected using TESS photometry and for both the transit signal was validated using ground based photometric facilities. We confirm the planetary nature of these companions and measure their masses using radial velocity observations. We find that TOI-2379 b has an orbital period of 5.469 d and a mass and radius of 5.76±0.205.76\pm0.20 MJ_{J} and 1.046±0.0231.046\pm0.023 RJ_{J} and TOI-2384 b has an orbital period of 2.136 d and a mass and radius of 1.966±0.0591.966\pm0.059 MJ_{J} and 1.025±0.0211.025\pm0.021 RJ_{J}. TOI-2379 b and TOI-2384 b have the highest and third highest planet-to-star mass ratios respectively out of all transiting exoplanets with a low-mass host star, placing them uniquely among the population of known exoplanets and making them highly important pieces of the puzzle for understanding the extremes of giant planet formation.


TOI-2379 b and TOI-2384 b: two super-Jupiter mass planets transiting low-mass host stars

August 2024

·

5 Reads

·

5 Citations

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

Short-period gas giant planets have been shown to be significantly rarer for host stars less massive than the Sun. We report the discovery of two transiting giant planets – TOI-2379 b and TOI-2384 b – with low-mass (early M) host stars. Both planets were detected using Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite photometry and for both the transit signal was validated using ground-based photometric facilities. We confirm the planetary nature of these companions and measure their masses using radial velocity observations. We find that TOI-2379 b has an orbital period of 5.469 d and a mass and radius of 5.76±0.205.76\pm 0.20 MJ_{J} and 1.046±0.0231.046\pm 0.023 RJ_{J} and TOI-2384 b has an orbital period of 2.136 d and a mass and radius of 1.966±0.0591.966\pm 0.059 MJ_{J} and 1.025±0.0211.025\pm 0.021 RJ_{J}. TOI-2379 b and TOI-2384 b have the highest and third highest planet-to-star mass ratios, respectively, out of all transiting exoplanets with a low-mass host star, placing them uniquely among the population of known exoplanets and making them highly important pieces of the puzzle for understanding the extremes of giant planet formation.


Stellar and Planetary Parameters
Single-Star Warm-Jupiter Systems Tend to Be Aligned, Even Around Hot Stellar Hosts: No TeffλT_{\rm eff}-\lambda Dependency

August 2024

·

28 Reads

The stellar obliquity distribution of warm-Jupiter systems is crucial for constraining the dynamical history of Jovian exoplanets, as the warm Jupiters' tidal detachment likely preserves their primordial obliquity. However, the sample size of warm-Jupiter systems with measured stellar obliquities has historically been limited compared to that of hot Jupiters, particularly in hot-star systems. In this work, we present newly obtained sky-projected stellar obliquity measurements for warm-Jupiter systems, TOI-559, TOI-2025, TOI-2031, TOI-2485, TOI-2524, and TOI-3972, derived from the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect, and show that all six systems display alignment with a median measurement uncertainty of 13 degrees. Combining these new measurements with the set of previously reported stellar obliquity measurements, our analysis reveals that single-star warm-Jupiter systems tend to be aligned, even around hot stellar hosts. This alignment exhibits a 3.4-σ\sigma deviation from the TeffλT_{\rm eff}-\lambda dependency observed in hot-Jupiter systems, where planets around cool stars tend to be aligned, while those orbiting hot stars show considerable misalignment. The current distribution of spin-orbit measurements for Jovian exoplanets indicates that misalignments are neither universal nor primordial phenomena affecting all types of planets. The absence of misalignments in single-star warm-Jupiter systems further implies that many hot Jupiters, by contrast, have experienced a dynamically violent history.


Citations (44)


... Under such assumptions, planet-planet interactions could excite mutual inclinations between planets, but not significantly so (i mutual < 40 • ; Anderson et al. 2020). This is consistent with the trend of low stellar obliquity observed in the warm Jupiter population around single stars (e.g., Rice et al. 2022;Dong et al. 2022;Radzom et al. 2024;Wang et al. 2024). Some warm Jupiters, such as TOI-1859b (Dong et al. 2023), are found in misaligned orbits; however, their host stars often have distant stellar companions, with projected distances around 2400 au in this case. ...

Reference:

Origins of Super Jupiters: TOI-2145b Has a Moderately Eccentric and Nearly Aligned Orbit
Single-star Warm-Jupiter Systems Tend to Be Aligned, Even around Hot Stellar Hosts: No T eff –λ Dependency*

The Astrophysical Journal Letters

... giant planets per M star within 2.5 AU (see also Sabotta et al. 2021). Nevertheless, a few such high-mass-ratio systems (e.g., Morales et al. 2019;Gan et al. 2023b;Hartman et al. 2024;Bryant et al. 2024;Stefansson et al. 2024;Hotnisky et al. 2024) were found to stretch the core accretion theory and may favor the gravitational instability model (Boss 2002) instead, making them particularly crucial to understand the giant planet formation. Plenty of techniques such as broadband photometrybased empirical relations (e.g., Terrien et al. 2012;Mann et al. 2013Mann et al. , 2015Mann et al. , 2019Newton et al. 2014Newton et al. , 2015 and detailed spectroscopic analysis (e.g., Veyette et al. 2016;Marfil et al. 2021;Passegger et al. 2022;Bello-García et al. 2023;Jahandar et al. 2024) have been developed to determine the stellar parameters of M dwarfs, allowing for better characterizations for M dwarf planetary systems (Gore et al. 2024). ...

TOI-2379 b and TOI-2384 b: two super-Jupiter mass planets transiting low-mass host stars
  • Citing Article
  • August 2024

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

... Furthermore, 10 of those 12 planets orbit stars below the Kraft break (Kraft 1967) at T eff ≈ 6100 K, thus the results are only valid for cool stars. Perhaps surprisingly, more recent measurements in eccentric warm Jupiters suggest that this trend toward alignment could be independent of eccentricity (e.g., Sedaghati et al. 2023;Espinoza-Retamal et al. 2023b;Hu et al. 2024). Moreover, Wang et al. (2024) revealed that the trend could be independent of the stellar effective temperature. ...

The PFS View of TOI-677 b: A Spin–Orbit Aligned Warm Jupiter in a Dynamically Hot System*

The Astronomical Journal

... A prime example is the recent detection of oscillations in ò Ind A with VLT/ESPRESSO, making it the coolest dwarf with detected oscillations to date (T. L. Campante et al. 2024; see also M. S. Lundkvist et al. 2024). ...

Low-amplitude Solar-like Oscillations in the K5 V Star ϵ Indi A

The Astrophysical Journal

... NASA's Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS; Ricker et al. 2014) has enabled the discovery of many Jupiter-sized exoplanets (e.g. Cañas et al. 2020;Kanodia et al. 2023;Hobson et al. 2023;Delamer et al. 2024), and brown dwarfs (e.g. Artigau et al. 2021;Cañas et al. 2022) orbiting M-dwarf stars, which have already started to raise interesting questions about the formation and evolution of these planets (Durisen et al. 2007;Chabrier et al. 2014). ...

TOI-4201: An Early M Dwarf Hosting a Massive Transiting Jupiter Stretching Theories of Core Accretion*

The Astrophysical Journal Letters

... For Kepler-9, wide of resonance (where the planets are observed to lie today) and short of the 2:1 resonance, the systems display similar behavior, producing similar mutual inclination excitation between the inner planet and the outer pair. However, on resonance, the system exhibits chaotic behavior, where the inclinations and eccentricities of the planets vary within a broader range (consistent with observations; see, e.g., M. Rice et al. 2023). For Kepler-487, the outer and inner planets lie very close to a 16:1 ratio. ...

Evidence for Low-level Dynamical Excitation in Near-resonant Exoplanet Systems*

The Astronomical Journal

... Following initial indications of a potential wide-orbit companion in the RV data (Endl et al. 2002), continued efforts have been made to monitor and image this companion, culminating in the first successful image captured by Matthews et al. (2024) using JWST/MIRI. The imaging of this system was guided by combined analyses of RV and Hipparcos-Gaia data (Feng et al. 2019b;Philipot et al. 2023a;Feng et al. 2023). The solutions and data from these studies are summarized in Table 2. ...

Revised orbits of the two nearest Jupiters
  • Citing Article
  • July 2023

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

... We also made use of the Fiberfed Extended Range Optical Spectrograph (FEROS; Kaufer et al. 1999) mounted on the 2.2-m MPG/ESO telescope at ESO La Silla to take further RV measurements of NGTS-EB-7. These observations were performed in the context of the Warm gIaNts the tEss (WINE) collaboration (Brahm et al. 2019;Schlecker et al. 2020;Hobson et al. 2021;Trifonov et al. 2023;Brahm et al. 2023;Jones et al. 2024). Between the nights of 2023/11/17 and 2024/05/07, 11 spectra were taken with exposure times of 1200 s at airmasses ranging between 1.09 and 1.25 resulting in SNRs ranging between 42 and 68. ...

TOI-2525 b and c: A Pair of Massive Warm Giant Planets with Strong Transit Timing Variations Revealed by TESS*

The Astronomical Journal

... Accessed 2024 June 9) to reconstruct their sample. We found only one meaningful discrepancy: the putative super-Earth HD 26965 b was initially reported by B.Ma et al. (2018), but was recently found to be spurious (K.Laliotis et al. 2023). The removal of this planet would also exclude HD 26965 from the BL24 sample. ...

Doppler Constraints on Planetary Companions to Nearby Sun-like Stars: An Archival Radial Velocity Survey of Southern Targets for Proposed NASA Direct Imaging Missions*

The Astronomical Journal

... For transiting exoplanets, estimates of the stellar mass have predominantly relied on stellar evolution models constrained by measurements, including parallax, stellar radial velocity, and stellar density (Hartman et al. 2019;Hellier et al. 2019;Yee et al. 2023). Alternatively, a planet's radial velocity signal can also be used and high-resolution ground-based infrared spectrographs have been used to detect exoplanet molecular Corresponding author: D. K. Sing dsing@jhu.edu ...

The TESS Grand Unified Hot Jupiter Survey. II. Twenty New Giant Planets*

The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series