Peter J. Carrington’s research while affiliated with University of Waterloo and other places
What is this page?
This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.
The interurban network of criminal collaboration in Canada is described, and possible explanations for its structure are explored. The data include all police-reported co-offences in the 32 major cities of Canada during 2006–09. Component analysis and graph drawings in network space and in geospace elucidate the structure of the network. Quadratic assignment procedure multiple regressions, repeated separately on the networks of instrumental and noninstrumental co-offences, test hypotheses about possible determinants of the network structure. The cities form one connected component, containing two clusters connected by a link between Toronto and Vancouver. One cluster, centred on the triad of Toronto, Montreal, and Ottawa, comprises the cities in Ontario and Quebec, with weak links to cities in the Atlantic provinces. The other cluster, centred on Vancouver, comprises the cities in the four western provinces. The structure is strongly correlated with the residential mobility of the general population, which in turn is strongly correlated with intercity distances. The correlation with mobility is less strong for instrumental than for noninstrumental crimes. The structure of this co-offending network can be explained by criminals’ routine activities, namely ordinary residential mobility, but the alternative explanation of purposive interurban criminal collaboration is more plausible for instrumental crime.
Prior to 2003, Canada discretionary approach to youth justice resulted in the country having one of the highest rates in the world for use of courts and custody for adolescent offenders. The Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA) came into force in 2003 and has significantly structured the discretion of police, prosecutors and judges, and been accompanied by very substantial reductions in youth charging and use of custody for adolescents and more use of community-based sentencing options; youth crime has fallen slightly. Canada’s federal parliament has jurisdiction over juvenile justice legislation, while provincial and territorial governments are responsible for the establishment of youth courts and the provision of services for young offenders, as well as jurisdiction over child welfare, so there is significant variation in the implementation of the law across Canada. There are concerns in Canada about such issues as overrepresentation of visible minority and Aboriginal youth in custody.
Most MPA networks are designed only with ecological processes in mind to increase their conservation utility. However, since MPA networks often involve large geographic areas, they also affect and involve multiple actors, institutions, and policy sectors.
A key challenge when establishing an effective MPA network is to align the ‘social system’ with the biophysical MPA network (the ‘ecological system’). This challenge is often denoted as ‘social–ecological fit’.
Facilitating collaborative social interactions among various actors and stakeholders (social connectivity) is equally as important as accomplishing ecological connectivity. New analytical approaches are required to effectively examine this ‘social’ dimension of fit.
An emerging marine reserve network in Jamaica and the recent invasion of Indo‐Pacific lionfish are used as a case study to: (1) examine the extent to which horizontal and vertical social ties bring local and national actors together to collaborate, coordinate, and share knowledge; and (2) assess the extent to which different attributes and features of such multilevel social networks may enhance or inhibit particular aspects of social–ecological fit.
Findings suggest that multilevel linkages have played the greatest role in relation to enhancing fit in the marine reserve network in the context of the recent lionfish invasion. However, the long‐term propensity of the multi‐actor and multilevel networks to enhance social–ecological fit is uncertain given the prevalence of weak social ties, lack of a culture of information sharing and collaboration, and limited financial resources.
Objectives
Assess gender and age segregation and stratification among co-offenders.
Methods
The population comprises co-offenders aged 5–75 in police-reported co-offenses in Canada, 2006–2009. Segregation is indicated by observed and inbreeding homophily, measured with cross-tabulations and log-linear distance models. Stratification is assessed with elaborations by crime type. Intersectionality of gender and age status is estimated with interaction terms in the log-linear models.
Results
Female and younger offenders are over-represented among co-offenders. Co-offending exhibits gender and age status homophily: same-gender dyads are approximately twice as frequent as mixed-gender, and same-age-status dyads are almost 7 times as frequent as mixed-age-status. Gender homophily varies by crime type, being stronger in robbery, aggravated assault, common assault, and minor theft, and weaker in serious drug crime and homicide, and (especially) sex crimes against children. Age homophily is strong in all types of crime. Gender and age homophily have a negative interaction: dyads comprising a female child or youth and an adult male occur 1.4 times as frequently as predicted from the main effects of gender and age status.
Conclusions
Female and younger offenders are not excluded from co-offending per se but, consistent with expectations from Blau’s (Inequality and heterogeneity. Free Press, New York, 1977) and Steffensmeier’s (Soc Forces 6:1010–1032, 1983) theories, they are segregated from co-offending with male and (especially) adult offenders. There was limited evidence of gender stratification, and no evidence of age stratification. The interaction of gender and age status in the segregation and stratification of co-offending attenuates their individual effects, contrary to expectations from feminist intersectionality theory and consistent with Blau’s (1977) theory.
This article demonstrates the innovative use of the log-linear distance model in the assessment of homophily in a set of small groups, such as the co-participants in a set of events. It traces the development of the application of the log-linear distance model to the study of homophily and reviews its recent use to assess the extent and structure of gender and age homophily in groups of criminal accomplices (‘co-offenders’). The transformations of the group membership data that are a prerequisite of the log-linear analysis, and the interpretation of the log-linear parameters, are explained in detail in order to make the approach accessible to potential users. Although the described applications are to gender and age homophily in groups of criminal accomplices, the method can be used to assess homophily on one or more variables in any small groups.
Canada, military, resistance, social capital, territories
What follows is a description and interpretation of the cooperation between the North-West Mounted Police (nwmp) and its Metis1 auxiliaries during the last decades of the nineteenth century. This partnership has until now been largely overlooked in historiography because historians’ attention has been focused on the conflict between the Metis people and the Canadian government.2 Following Confederation in 1867, the Canadian government undertook to integrate the northern part of the Great Plains without regard to the wishes of the Aboriginal inhabitants. This move led to the Resistance of the Red River Metis, which delayed the incorporation of the North-West Territories into the Dominion until 1870. Despite this initial clash between the Metis and the government, the North-West Mounted Police became reliant on Metis auxiliaries, hired as scouts, guides, and interpreters. This cooperation, anchored in the Peelite functioning of the early nwmp, is highly relevant to an understanding of the colonization of western Canada. We argue that the concept of Peelite cooperation can help to explain both the limited recourse to coercion by the nwmp in its colonial mission, and the agency of the Metis auxiliaries in dealing with colonizing forces, as they sought sociocultural and material benefits from their employer.
The nwmp was created by the Canadian Parliament in May 1873 as a part of the government’s efforts to impose its sovereignty in the Prairie West. The Canadian government was aware of the difficulties faced by the United States as it colonized its western lands during the 1860s. Rather than opting for the costly military approach followed by its neighbor,3 Canada chose to deploy a permanent [End Page 101] and hybrid police force, with both civilian and military attributes. The powers and responsibilities of the nwmp included controlling Aboriginal populations (Metis and First Nations), preventing crime, and enforcing Canadian law and sovereignty.4 The judicial authority of the nwmp was also defined: the commissioned officers of the force were made ex officio justices of the peace and possessed limited but very real judicial powers. This double function gave them great power and was described by John Jennings as a “legal tyranny.”5 Considering their services and help to destitute Aboriginal populations, R. C. Macleod opted for the term “benevolent despotism.”6
Prime Minister John A. Macdonald was ambivalent about the nature of the force he envisioned. On the one hand, he wrote in 1869 to Captain D. R. Cameron, a militia officer accompanying the Canadian delegation sent to effect the annexation of the North-West Territories, “that the best force would be Mounted Riflemen, trained to act as cavalry, but also instructed in the rifle exercises. They should also be instructed, as certain of the line are, in the use of artillery. This body should not be expressly military but should be styled Police and have the military bearing of the Irish Constabulary.”7 The nwmp incorporated these military elements, along with the red uniforms of the British army.8 On the other hand, at the time of its inception, Macdonald expressed a preference for the least martial appearance possible. In 1873, during the parliamentary debates he stated: “They are to be purely civil, not a military body with as little gold lace, fuss and fine feathers as possible; not a crack cavalry regiment, but an efficient police force for the rough and ready—particular ready—enforcement of law and justice.”9
The civilian aspects of the projected Canadian force have not been given sufficient recognition by historians.10 The “Principles of the British Police,” an expression coined by Charles Reith, stemmed from the instructions of Robert Peel, home secretary, and of Charles Rowan and Richard Mayne, commissioners of London’s “New Police” in the 1830s.11 These so-called Peelite principles called for the limited use of force and for the cooperation between the public and the police.12 The conduct of the British police throughout the mid-nineteenth century demonstrated the importance of cooperation, public approval, and such communicative aptitudes as advice...
Background:
The success of treatment for substance use issues varies with personal and social factors, including the composition and structure of the individual's personal support network. This paper describes the personal support networks and social capital of a sample of Italian adults after long-term residential therapeutic treatment for substance use issues, and analyses network correlates of post-treatment substance use (relapse).
Methods:
Using a social network analysis approach, data were obtained from structured interviews (90-120min long) with 80 former clients of a large non-governmental therapeutic treatment agency in Italy providing voluntary residential treatments and rehabilitation services for substance use issues. Participants had concluded the program at least six months prior. Data were collected on socio-demographic variables, addiction history, current drug use status (drug-free or relapsed), and the composition and structure of personal support networks. Factors related to risk of relapse were assessed using bivariate and multivariate logistic regression models.
Results:
A main goal of this study was to identify differences between the support network profiles of drug free and relapsed participants. Drug free participants had larger, less dense, more heterogeneous and reciprocal support networks, and more brokerage social capital than relapsed participants. Additionally, a lower risk of relapse was associated with higher socio-economic status, being married/cohabiting, and having network members with higher socio-economic status, who have greater occupational heterogeneity, and reciprocate support.
Conclusions:
Post-treatment relapse was found to be negatively associated with the socioeconomic status and occupational heterogeneity of ego's support network, reciprocity in the ties between ego and network members, and a support network in which the members are relatively loosely connected with one another (i.e., ego possesses "brokerage social capital"). These findings suggest the incorporation into therapeutic programming of interventions that address those aspects of clients' personal support networks.
This article examines age homophily among co-offenders, using data on approximately 440,000 co-offenses recorded by police in Canada during 2006 to 2009. Log-linear models for social mobility tables are applied to an 86-by-86 table of frequencies of co-offending among year-of-age groups for individuals from 3 to 88 years old. The results indicate strong age homophily for co-offenders of all ages, but decreasing with age. There is further structuration into four age groups: children (3-11 years), youth (12-17 years), young adults (18-45 years), and older adults (46-88 years). The “Fagin” hypothesis that offenders below the age of criminal responsibility are particularly attractive as co-offenders for older offenders is disconfirmed.
This edited volume demonstrates the potential of mixed-methods designs for the research of social networks and the utilization of social networks for other research. Mixing methods applies to the combination and integration of qualitative and quantitative methods. In social network research, mixing methods also applies to the combination of structural and actor-oriented approaches. The volume provides readers with methodological concepts to guide mixed-methods network studies with precise research designs and methods to investigate social networks of various sorts. Each chapter describes the research design used and discusses the strengths of the methods for that particular field and for specific outcomes.
Citations (38)
... [31][32][33] SNA has been described as neither qualitative nor quantitative, but structural (that is, relying on both qualitative approaches for describing the contextual nature of social action and standardised quantitative measures for describing network structure). 33,34 Hence, we adopted a parallel mixed-methods approach by situating the ego-centric SNA within semi-structured interviews. We collected quantitative (for example, information for deriving network size, tie strength and ego-alter similarity index) and qualitative data (for example, meanings associated with ego-alter interaction) at the same time, followed by an analysis and integration of our findings. ...
... Conversely, a Canadian study by Carrington and Moyer (1990) found that youth defendants who have legal counsel were less likely to be convicted. The authors, however, cautioned that this was because legally represented defendants were more disposed to challenge the state's case. ...
... In addition to national data, information about youth cases appearing before the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal from 1990 to 1999 were collected with the assistance of the Court staff. Saskatchewan consistently has high rates of youth incarceration by Canadian stan-dards (Carrington & Moyer, 1994;Doob & Sprott, 1996). In June 1998, 421 youths were in custody, representing a rate of youth custody of 461.27 per 100,000 youths aged 12 to 18 (Saskatchewan Social Services, 1998). ...
... Establishing the recidivism rates of YSOs guides (a) the types of research questions to investigate and (b) the types of policies appropriate for responding to this group. The variability of risk of recidivism observed across studies (e.g., Barra et al., 2018;Caldwell, 2010;McCann & Lussier, 2008;Worling et al., 2012) may be due to different sampling procedures (e.g., clinical versus correctional settings), different time periods of sample recruitment (Caldwell, 2016), and/or different research designs (e.g., retrospective versus prospective designs). This makes it difficult to clarify the rate of recidivism among YSOs and may explain why the prediction of recidivism, especially sexual recidivism, is reported to be relatively poor (e.g., Viljoen et al., 2012). ...
... Principles of wrongfulness and harmfulness ensure that sentencing decisions, including the length of custody, are based on the totality of ofending severity and are minimally impacted by extralegal factors. As evidence of this approach's success in minimizing bias in evaluating of ending severity, Brantingham (1985 ), using data from Canadian courts, reported that the strongest predictors of sentence length, aside from the index ofence, which was not investigated, were the number of prior convictions and the use of a weapon; sociodemographic characteristics did not afect sentence length (also see Carrington and Moyer 1995 ;Latimer and Foss 2005 ); Doob and Sprott 2007 ). Mitigating circumstances are also used to inform level of wrongfulness. ...
... The police have a significant role as the 'gatekeepers' of the juvenile justice system [11,41,44]. They are the first point of contact a juvenile offender has with the system. ...
... 4,14,28 Indeed, opposition to MPAs can arise when they do not meet local needs or their benefits are oversold. 29,30 Social and ecological fit should, therefore, be a top priority for all conservation initiatives, [20][21][22]31,32 if not a moral obligation. 33 As global coverage of MPAs is likely to increase at a fast pace to comply with Target 3 of the Kunming-Montré al Global Biodiversity Framework, improving the inclusivity and fit of MPAs constitutes a pillar of ocean justice and equity. ...
... Nevertheless, the offenders in this sample were drawn from an era when youth incarceration occurred more frequently than is currently the case (Bala 1997;Bala, Carrington, and Roberts 2009;Dauvergne 2013). A recent study by Bala and Carrington (2017) shows how the implementation of the Youth Criminal Justice Act dramatically reduced the number of youth serving custodial sentences in Canada over time from 186 per 100,000 in 1997-98 to 30 per 100,000 in 2013-14, which translates into an 84% decrease. As such, we would expect youth custody costs to be lower with a contemporary sample of offenders followed up prospectively, given the system's current preference to use extrajudi cial, non-custodial measures allowable under the Youth Criminal Justice Act. ...
... The NWMP (precursor to the Royal Mounted Canadian Police) was formed by the federal government in 1873 to enclose, dispossess and regulate Indigenous peoples (Shantz, 2016). This includes suppressing the Red River provisional government (Ayala and Carrington, 2016), displacing Indigenous peoples from the Prairies (Nettelbeck and Smandych, 2010) and enforcing the pass system on the Prairies that restricted the movements of Indigenous peoples on and off reserves (Barron, 1988). Indigenous peoples were imprisoned at Lower Fort Garry until the construction of a larger penitentiary at Stony Mountain in 1878 (Edginton, 1988;Horky, 2020). ...
... Moses (2003) identified the career motivational type of Novelty seekers that strive to innovate. On the one hand, this career motivational type could be widespread amongst teachers, because innovations are positively assessed in education and perceived as good (Carrington, Coomber, Letherby & Scott, 2016). On the other hand, teachers are restricted in their impulses for changes by the school rules, curricula, traditions, etc., so Novelty seekers may be not strongly expressed teachers' career motivator. ...