Paola Marziani’s research while affiliated with National Institute of Astrophysics and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (108)


Dark and bright sides of the Broad Line Region clouds as seen in the FeII emission of SDSS RM 102
  • Article

March 2025

·

6 Reads

Astronomy and Astrophysics

Alberto Floris

·

·

·

[...]

·

Contamination from singly ionized iron emission is one of the greatest obstacles to determining the intensity of emission lines in the UV and optical wavelength ranges. This study presents a comprehensive analysis of the ii emission in the bright quasar RM 102, based on the most recent version of the CLOUDY software, with the goal of understanding the nature and the origin of the emission. We employ a constant pressure model for the emitting clouds, instead of the customary constant density assumption. The allowed parameter range is broad, with metallicity up to 50 times the solar value and turbulent velocity up to 100 km s^-1 for a subset of models. We also consider geometrical effects that could enhance the visibility of the non-illuminated faces of the clouds, as well as the presence of additional mechanical heating. Our investigation reveals that the broad line region of RM 102 is characterized by highly metallic gas. The observed ii features provide strong evidence for an inflow pattern geometry that favours the dark sides of clouds over isotropic emission if the heating is predominantly radiative. Solutions with mechanical heating are also an interesting option, but they require further self-consistent analysis. This study underscores the critical role of the dark versus bright side interpretation for reproducing the strong ii features in RM 102, highlighting both the geometry of the emitting region and the presence of chemically enriched gas as fundamental factors. Additionally, we report that CLOUDY currently still lacks certain transitions in its atomic databases, which prevents it from fully reproducing some observed ii features in quasar spectra.


Monitoring AGNs with Hβ\beta Asymmetry. V. Long-term Variation and Evolution of the Broad Hβ\beta Emission-Line Profiles

March 2025

·

2 Reads

The physical origins of the diverse emission-line asymmetries observed in the spectra of active galactic nuclei (AGNs) remain incompletely understood. Monitoring the temporal variations of line profiles offers a promising approach to investigating the underlying physics. In this study, we present an analysis of the broad Hβ\beta emission line profiles of eight AGNs observed from the end of 2016 to May 2023 as part of the reverberation mapping campaign titled "Monitoring AGNs with Hβ\beta Asymmetry" (MAHA), utilizing data obtained from the Wyoming Infrared Observatory (WIRO) 2.3-meter telescope. We measure the temporal variations of line asymmetry, width, and central velocity shift for the eight objects. Our findings reveal that the variation in asymmetry is positively correlated with Hβ\beta flux in five of the eight objects, while the remaining objects exhibit negative or complex correlations. Furthermore, we observe anti-correlations between line width and Hβ\beta flux for most objects, indicating the presence of the "breathing" phenomenon in their Hβ\beta emission lines. In contrast, two objects demonstrate an "anti-breathing" phenomenon or complex behavior. We discuss the physical origins of the temporal variations in line profiles and propose the possibility of decomposing the variations in Hβ\beta asymmetry and width into components: one that corresponds to short-term variations in Hβ\beta flux and another that reflects long-term variations in continuum light curves, perhaps driven by radiation pressure.


Schematic representation of the optical plane of the quasar main sequence, with the subdivisions into spectral bins clearly marked. The numbers in square brackets beneath each spectral type label indicate the prevalence of the spectral type (number nST of sources in each spectral type normalized by the number of sources in the full sample), and the fraction of RL (jetted) sources nRL/nST within each type. The data are from the sample of Marziani et al. [42].
Examples of emission line profile analysis for Hβ (left column) and Mgiiλ2800 (middle column). The top plot of each panel shows the original spectrum (thin black line) and the full model (dashed magenta line) along with the adopted continuum (gray). The bottom plots show the multiple components employed in the non-linear fit as follows: broad and very broad Hβ component (black and red Gaussians) [101,102], Hβ and [Oiii]λλ4959,5007 narrow line emission (gold), semi-broad emission of [Oiii]λλ4959,5007 (magenta) and Feii (dark green). Feii emission is very weak in most of the sample, both in the optical and in the UV. The right column shows a comparison between the Hβ and Mgiiλ2800 (gray) broad profiles.
Distribution of centroids at four different fractional intensity levels, from left to right 14, 12, 34 and 0.9. Top: Hβ; bottom: Mgiiλ2800. Radio-loud sources are shaded brown. The rest frame radial velocity is represented by the dashed line, while the thick black line is the average of the sample. The shaded gray box shows the ±1σ range for the c(34) measurement of the B1 spectral type from the sample of Zamfir et al. [79].
The black hole mass–luminosity diagram for a low-z type quasar sample. The B1⁺⁺ quasar location in the MBH– L diagram corresponds to the contour in the middle upper part of the diagram. The vast majority are located close to the limit L/LEdd∼10−2, close to the domain expected for inefficient radiators. The black diagonal line at L/LEdd=0.1 separates Population A and B. On the high Eddington ratio side, the possible super-Eddington accretors are labeled as xA (extreme Population A), with Eddington ratios not exceeding 1 by a large factor, as found observationally [103], and as derived from the theory of super-Eddington accretion disks as well [104,105,106,107].
Basic properties of the B1 ++ sample.
Where to Search for Supermassive Binary Black Holes
  • Article
  • Full-text available

February 2025

·

4 Reads

Supermassive binary black holes (SMBBHs) are the anticipated byproducts of galaxy mergers and play a pivotal role in shaping galaxy evolution, gravitational wave emissions, and accretion physics. Despite their theoretical prevalence, direct observational evidence for SMBBHs remains elusive, with only a handful of candidates identified to date. This paper explores optimal strategies and key environments for locating SMBBHs, focusing on observational signatures in the broad Balmer lines. We present a preliminary analysis on a flux-limited sample of sources belonging to an evolved spectral type along the quasar main sequence, and we discuss the spectroscopic clues indicative of binary activity and highlight the critical role of time-domain spectroscopic surveys in uncovering periodic variability linked to binary systems.

Download

Figure 3. Distribution of centroids at four different fractional intensity levels, from left to right 1 4 , 1 2 ,
Where to search for supermassive binary black holes

February 2025

·

3 Reads

Supermassive binary black holes (SMBBHs) are the anticipated byproducts of galaxy mergers and play a pivotal role in shaping galaxy evolution, gravitational wave emissions, and accretion physics. Despite their theoretical prevalence, direct observational evidence for SMBBHs remains elusive, with only a handful of candidates identified to date. This paper explores optimal strategies and key environments for locating SMBBHs, focusing on observational signatures in the broad Balmer lines. We present a preliminary analysis on a flux-limited sample of sources belonging to an evolved spectral type along the quasar main sequence, and we discuss the spectroscopic clues indicative of binary activity and highlight the critical role of time-domain spectroscopic surveys in uncovering periodic variability linked to binary systems.


Super-Eddington Accretion in Quasars

February 2025

·

43 Reads

This review provides an observational perspective on the fundamental properties of super-Eddington accretion onto supermassive black holes in quasars. It begins by outlining the selection criteria, particularly focusing on optical and UV broad-line intensity ratios, used to identify a population of unobscured super-Eddington candidates. Several defining features place these candidates at the extreme end of the Population A in main sequence of quasars: among them are the highest observed singly-ionized iron emission, extreme outflow velocities in UV resonance lines, and unusually high metal abundances. These key properties reflect the coexistence of a virialized sub-system within the broad-line region alongside powerful outflows, with the observed gas enrichment likely driven by nuclear or circumnuclear star formation. The most compelling evidence for the occurrence of super-Eddington accretion onto supermassive black holes comes from recent observations of massive black holes at early cosmic epochs. These black holes require rapid growth rates that are only achievable through radiatively inefficient super-Eddington accretion. Furthermore, extreme Eddington ratios, close to or slightly exceeding unity, are consistent with the saturation of radiative output per unit mass predicted by accretion disk theory for super-Eddington accretion rates. The extreme properties of super-Eddington candidates suggest that these quasars could make them stable and well-defined cosmological distance indicators, leveraging the correlation between broad-line width and luminosity expected in virialized systems. Finally, several analogies with accretion processes around stellar-mass black holes, particularly in the high/soft state, are explored to provide additional insight into the mechanisms driving super-Eddington accretion.




Dark and bright sides of the Broad Line Region clouds as seen in the FeII emission of SDSS RM 102

August 2024

·

5 Reads

·

1 Citation

Contamination from singly ionized iron emission is one of the greatest obstacles to determining the intensity of emission lines in the UV and optical wavelength ranges. This study presents a comprehensive analysis of the FeII emission in the bright quasar RM 102, based on the most recent version of the CLOUDY software, with the goal of simultaneously reproducing UV and optical FeII emission. We employ a constant pressure model for the emitting clouds, instead of the customary constant density assumption. The allowed parameter range is broad, with metallicity up to 50 times the solar value and turbulent velocity up to 100 km s1^{-1} for a subset of models. We also consider geometrical effects that could enhance the visibility of the non-illuminated faces of the clouds, as well as additional mechanical heating. Our investigation reveals that the broad line region of RM 102 is characterized by highly metallic gas. The observed FeII features provide strong evidence for an inflow pattern geometry that favours the dark sides of clouds over isotropic emission. This study confirms the presence of chemically enriched gas in the broad line region of bright quasars, represented by RM 102, which is necessary to explain the strong FeII emission and its characteristic features. Additionally, we report that CLOUDY currently still lacks certain transitions in its atomic databases which prevents it from fully reproducing some observed FeII features in quasar spectra.


Exploring the links between quasar winds and radio emission along the main sequence at high redshift

August 2024

·

5 Reads

·

2 Citations

Astronomy and Astrophysics

Context. Despite the increasing prevalence of radio-loud (RL) sources at cosmic noon, our understanding of the underlying physics that governs the accretion disc outflows in these particular sources and its dissimilarity with radio-quiet (RQ) quasars remains somewhat limited. Aims. Disentangling the real impact of the radio-loudness and accretion on the outflow parameters remains a challenge to this day. We present ten new spectra of high-redshift and high-luminosity quasars and combine these with previous data at both high and low redshift with the aim being to evaluate the role of the feedback from RL and RQ AGN. The final high-redshift (1.5 ≲ z ≲ 3.9), high-luminosity (47.1 ≤ log(L) ≤ 48.5) sample consists of a combination of 60 quasars from our ISAAC and the Hamburg-ESO surveys. The low-redshift ( z ≤ 0.8) sample has 84 quasars that have been analyzed in the optical and with the Faint Object Spectrograph (FOS) data in the UV. Methods. We perform a multicomponent analysis of optical and UV emission line profiles along the quasar main sequence, and provide a relation that can be used to estimate the main outflow parameters (mass rate, thrust, and kinetic power) in both the BLR and NLR through the analysis of the [O III ] λ 5007 and C IV λ 1549 emission lines. Results. Spectrophotometric properties and line profile measurements are presented for H β +[O III ] λλ 4959,5007, Si IV λ 1397+O IV ] λ 1402, C IV λ 1549+He II λ 1640, and the 1900 Å blend. High-ionization lines, such as C IV λ 1549 and [O III ] λ 5007, usually present a significant asymmetry toward the blue, especially in radio-quiet sources. This is strong evidence of outflow motions. In the ISAAC sample, 72% of the quasars where [O III ] is clearly detected present significant outflows, with centroid velocity at half intensity blueshifted to values of greater than ∼250 km s ⁻¹ . Radio-loud quasars tend to present slightly more modest blueshifted components in both the UV and optical ranges. The behavior of [O III ] λ 5007 mirrors that of C IV λ 1549, with blueshift amplitudes between the two lines showing a high degree of correlation, which appears unaffected by the presence of radio emission. Conclusions. In contrast to the situation at low redshift, both RL and RQ AGN outflow parameters at high luminosity appear in the range needed to provide feedback effects on their host galaxies. Both high- and low- z RL quasars exhibit smaller outflows compared to RQ quasars, suggesting a potential role of radio-loudness in mitigating outflow effects. Nevertheless, the radio-loudness effect on AGN feedback is much less significant than the effect of accretion, with this latter emerging as the main driver of nuclear outflows.


The Correlation Luminosity-Velocity Dispersion of Galaxies and Active Galactic Nuclei

June 2024

·

25 Reads

·

3 Citations

In this work we discuss the correlation between luminosity L and velocity dispersion σ observed in different astrophysical contexts, in particular that of early-type galaxies (ETGs; Faber–Jackson (FJ) law) and that of active galactic nuclei (AGN). Our data for the ETGs confirm the bending of the FJ at high masses and the existence of similar curvatures in the projections of the Fundamental Plane (FP) approximately at the mass scale of ∼1010M⊙. We provide an explanation for such curvatures and for the presence of the Zone of Exclusion (ZoE) in these diagrams. The new prospected theory for the FJ law introduces a new framework to understand galaxy evolution in line with the hierarchical structure of the Universe. The classic analysis carried out for a class of type 1 AGN accreting gas at very high rates, confirms that a FJ law of the form L=L0σ4 is roughly consistent with the observations, with a slope quite similar to that of ETGs. We discuss the physics behind the FJ law for the AGN in different contexts and also examine the biases affecting both the luminosity and the velocity dispersion, paying particular attention to the effects induced by the spherical symmetry of the emitting sources on the accuracy of the luminosity estimates.


Citations (48)


... FeII emission of xA sources can overwhelm other emission lines and create a pseudo-continuum, exceeding the emission of Lyα and the strongest metal lines. Especially in the UV around the MgII doublet, the contamination of the underlying accretion disk continuum creates difficulties even in assessing their relative contribution (e.g., [100,124,125]). The optical FeII emission is not only a key SE indicator, but also remains remarkably stable over time in most cases (and at least within the temporal extension of monitoring campaigns [126,127]), which is uncommon in other quasar spectra, especially in Pop. B sources where at low accretion rate the changing look phenomenon occurs frequently [128]. ...

Reference:

Super-Eddington Accretion in Quasars
Dark and bright sides of the Broad Line Region clouds as seen in the FeII emission of SDSS RM 102

... A major survey carried out with the ISAAC instrument at the Very Large Telescope (VLT), covering 53 Hamburg-ESO (HE) quasars (hereafter HEMS), revealed very strong FeII emitters at 1 ≲ z ≲ 2 [90,103,104]. Recent observations using ground-based infrared (IR) spectrometers and James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) have reinforced the stability and distinctiveness of the spectral features defining the MS [105][106][107][108]: they confirm that the MS-defining properties are consistent across various luminosities and cosmic epochs [90,[109][110][111][112]. A higher prevalence of Population A sources at intermediate redshift reflects an evolution in accretion rate of quasars coming down from the Cosmic Noon to the present-day Universe [113][114][115][116]. ...

Exploring the links between quasar winds and radio emission along the main sequence at high redshift

Astronomy and Astrophysics

... where Hβ can be observed only with IR spectrometers [28]. Preliminary applications have been carried out employing several samples where the virial broadening estimator has been Hβ FWHM and σ only or Hβ and AlIIIλ1860 jointly [26][27][28][29]347]. Despite high dispersion (presently around 0.3 dex in the luminosity estimates), this method provides a promising approach for using quasars as cosmological standard candles, especially for measuring the matter density parameter (Ω M ) [27,28]. ...

The Correlation Luminosity-Velocity Dispersion of Galaxies and Active Galactic Nuclei

... Nor were they detected in the HEMS survey ( [90], and references therein). This might not be surprising as a large part of the accretion power is funnelled into the mechanical power of the jet, which usually exceeds its radiative power by a large factor (≲ 10 [388]). ...

The Power of Relativistic Jets: A Comparative Study

... At the upper left end of the MS, we encounter sources withṁ so low that they are at the verge of the inefficient radiative domain. In several cases, Hβ emission is showing a relativistic disk profile, meaning that the emission is associated with a bare, small-size (perhaps truncated) accretion disk [282,283]. These systems are starving black holes [97]. ...

Quasar 3C 47 : Extreme Population B jetted source with double-peaked profile

Astronomy and Astrophysics

... The scheme of Figure 9 (see also Figure 6 of Marziani et al. [277]) illustrates a possible evolutionary path, emphasizing the transition from highly accreting, young quasars to massive, low Eddington ratio systems. Population A quasars are characterized by lower black hole (BH) masses (M BH ), higher L/L Edd , strong outflows, and low equivalent width [OIII]λλ4959,5007 and CIVλ1549 HILs. ...

From Sub-Solar to Super-Solar Chemical Abundances along the Quasar Main Sequence

... The standard AGN AD theory posits that the effective temperature of a thin disk, varying with radius, depends on black hole mass and accretion rate (Lynden-Bell 1969;Pringle & Rees 1972;Novikov & Thorne 1973;Shakura & Sunyaev 1973;Pringle 1981;Czerny & Elvis 1987;Narayan & Yi 1994;Collier et al. 1998;Sergeev et al. 2005;Cackett et al. 2007;Czerny & Hryniewicz 2011;Yuan & Narayan 2014;Panda et al. 2023). Therefore, the AD's radial extent can be investigated by studying the continuum emission at different wavelengths (see Pozo Nuñez et al. 2023a and references therein). ...

Spectral Variability Studies in Active Galactic Nuclei: Exploring Continuum and Emission Line Regions in the Age of LSST and JWST

... These sources also exhibit a very low, often undetectable, R FeII , in contrast to Population A, where the majority of sources have a measurable R FeII . A hallmark of Population B is the pronounced redward asymmetry in low-ionization lines, such as Hβ, a feature well-documented in the literature [35,[54][55][56][57][58][59]. However, the situation for spectral type B1 ++ remains unclear; the MgIIλ2800 and Hβ median spectra show an asymmetry index consistent with a symmetric profile (AI ≈ 0.02 ± 0.06 and ≈0.04 ± 0.06 for the two lines, [42]). ...

Accretion/Ejection Phenomena and Emission-Line Profile (A)symmetries in Type-1 Active Galactic Nuclei

... The presence of a second black hole with q ≳ 0.04 may induce a truncation in the BLR emission, as the mass flow in the circum-binary Keplerian disk is perturbed by tidal forces which carve annular gaps in the second black hole orbital path [117,118], hampering to various extent the accretion process [119]. This might be the case of the classical double "peakers" with a broad-line profile consistent with the emission from an accretion disk truncated at ∼1000 gravitational radii [120][121][122][123]. ...

Optical and near-UV spectroscopic properties of low-redshift jetted quasars in the main sequence context
  • Citing Article
  • August 2023

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

... This choice is justified in Section 4. We derive the posterior probability distributions and the Bayesian evidence with the nested sampling Monte Carlo algorithm MLFriends (Wandel et al. 1999;Negrete et al. 2014;Panda 2021), which together with the smaller scatter ∼0.2 dex compared to ∼0.3 dex from the R BLR -L relationship is an indication that the former is affected by contamination, e.g., by BLR scattering including DCE (Netzer 2022;Pozo Nuñez et al. 2023a;Pandey et al. 2023;Jaiswal et al. 2023) and intrinsic reddening (Gaskell & Benker 2007;Heard & Gaskell 2023). Furthermore, the C IV emission is dependent on the spectral shape of the ionizing continuum 9 of the AD, which can develop additional anisotropy with increasing accretion rate (Panda 2021;Panda & Marziani 2023b. ...

Modelling the quasar spectra for super-Eddington sources -- The What, the Why and the How
  • Citing Preprint
  • August 2023