Michael Jakob’s research while affiliated with Ecologic Institute and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (17)


Carbon pricing and household welfare: evidence from Uganda
  • Article

October 2024

·

6 Reads

Environment and Development Economics

Raavi Aggarwal

·

·

Michael Jakob

·

Jan Christoph Steckel

Policymakers frequently voice concerns that carbon pricing could impair economic development in the short run, especially in low-income countries such as Uganda. Using a consumer demand system for energy and food items, we assess how households’ welfare, and demand for food and energy, would respond to a carbon price of USD40/tCO2. We find welfare losses of 0.2–12 per cent of household expenditure on food and fuel, due to the carbon price. Average demand for electricity and kerosene decline by 11 and 20 per cent respectively, while firewood demand rises by 10 per cent on average. We observe shifts within food consumption baskets, with declines in the demand for meat & fish, and vegetables, alongside an increase in cereal consumption. Household nutrition is adversely impacted, with declines in protein and micronutrient intake across the population. Complementary social protection policies such as cash transfers are therefore required to ease adverse effects on economic development in Uganda.


CO2 emissions covered by an EU CBAM under different implementation options
Bars show how much CO2 emissions would be covered by an EU CBAM (assuming no trade adjustments), depending on the scope of emissions accounting (i.e., the number of layers in the supply chains included in emissions estimations - vertical coverage) and on the sectoral coverage (i.e., the sources of emissions covered by the EU CBAM — horizontal coverage). Four alternative vertical coverages are shown here. The option “Scope 1 emissions” only covers emissions directly caused by imports to the EU. Option “Scopes 1 and 2 and downstream products” also includes the emissions of the direct suppliers of exporters to the EU. These two implementation options are in line with the current EU CBAM proposal. By contrast, the “Direct and indirect imports” options account for all upstream emissions caused along the supply chains used to produce exports to the EU. In the setting “With export rebates”, emissions caused by EU imports for producing goods that are further exported from the EU are excluded from the EU CBAM coverage. Estimated CO2 emissions are detailed based on the process causing them (see Methods and Data). These processes are grouped into three horizontal coverage aggregates. The “Conservative coverage” category (dark, wide blocks) entails emissions that are explicitly addressed in the EU CBAM proposal. These provide a lower bound estimate of the emissions that would be covered by the current EU CBAM proposal. Sectors included in the “Ambitious coverage” category (half-transparent, medium width blocks) are processes covered by the current EU ETS which may eventually be covered by the EU CBAM as well. The sum of the emissions covered in the conservative and ambitious categories form together the upper bound of a sectoral coverage in line with current EU CBAM policy proposal. Adding light and thin blocks forms a “Comprehensive coverage” category, which would cover all sectors and all sources of emissions and hence corresponds to an extension of the CBAM to all industrial emissions. All data refer to 2016. International transportation-, land use- and final use-related emissions are not included here. Detailed data points are provided in Supplementary Table 1. Supplementary Table 2 details the processes covered in the different horizontal coverages.
Multilateral effects of comprehensive carbon pricing options in the EU
Panel a shows the upstream CO2 emissions released along the supply chains involving the EU (central black bar). These emissions occur either in the EU (blue bar, upper left) or in the rest of the world (white bar, bottom left). The final product of these supply chains is used either in the EU (brown bar, upper right) or in the rest of the world (white bar, bottom right). The flows’ thickness is proportional to the volume of upstream CO2 emissions caused. Panel b describes the type of the supply chains covered by different comprehensive carbon pricing options and the size of the carbon market created, assuming an illustrative carbon price of 100€ per tCO2. A Domestic Carbon Price (DCP) would cover all emissions generated within the EU, both for producing goods consumed in the EU (Intra-EU supply chains, dark green) and for producing goods consumed abroad (exports, light green). A comprehensive CBAM without export rebates would cover imported emissions as well (dark and light red), no matter whether these imports ultimately serve final users in the EU (Imports, dark red) or are used to produce goods further reexported outside of the EU (traversing supply chains, light red). Export rebates would exclude exported as well as traversing supply chains from the carbon pricing. We consider no free allocations here, as these are supposed to be phased out while the EU CBAM gets implemented. The comprehensive coverage analyzed here corresponds to a comprehensive sectoral coverage and a comprehensive depth coverage (see Fig. 1). We do not consider potential trade adjustments here.
Relative upstream pressure induced by a comprehensive EU CBAM without export rebates
The relative upstream pressure is defined as the share of CO2 emissions caused to supply the final demand in the EU, as a percentage of domestic carbon emissions. Grey indicates lack of data, hatchings indicates member countries of the EU ETS. The relative upstream pressure does not consider possible trade adjustments.
Inclusiveness of a comprehensive EU CBAM without export rebates if the revenue is fully recycled towards non-EU countries based on different indicators
The proportion of the revenue each country receives is estimated based on the following indicators (see Materials and Data for details): a No recycling; b Emissions covered by the comprehensive EU CBAM; c Historical impacts of anthropogenic warming on economic output²⁰; d Difference in per capita Gross Domestic Product to the EU average. Losses are assumed to correspond to the upstream pressure, measured as the value of CO2 emissions caused in a country to supply the final demand in the EU multiplied by a carbon price of 100€ per tCO2. Grey indicates lack of data, hatchings indicate member countries of the EU ETS. Supplementary Fig. 2 shows the revenue recycled to each individual country on a per capita basis.
Distribution of the relative upstream pressure under different EU CBAM implementations
Coloring shows the share of domestic emissions of each country covered by the EU CBAM implemented. Rows indicate the types of emissions covered by the EU CBAM (see Fig. 1). Columns correspond to the scope of emissions being covered by the EU CBAM (see Fig. 1). The numerator of the relative upstream pressure corresponds to the volume of emissions caused in the corresponding country and priced by the EU CBAM (absolute upstream pressure). The denominator is the domestic volume of emissions in the sectors covered by the EU CBAM. The upper-left panel corresponds to the most conservative estimation of the coverage of the EU CBAM (only direct emissions from a few sectors). The bottom-right panel corresponds to a comprehensive EU CBAM without export rebates, as shown in Fig. 2.
Assessing different European Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism implementations and their impact on trade partners
  • Article
  • Full-text available

April 2023

·

536 Reads

·

16 Citations

The European Union (EU) will implement a Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) to reach its climate mitigation targets while avoiding the relocation of its industries to countries with less stringent climate policies (carbon leakage). The exact implementation and possible future extensions of such an EU CBAM are still being debated. Here we apply a throughflow-based accounting method on detailed trade network data to assess the coverage of different implementation options. Using a stylized comprehensive EU CBAM as benchmark, we then quantify how an EU CBAM may affect the EU’s trade partners by channeling the EU carbon price to other countries. We find that middle- and low-income countries for which the EU is an important export market would be disproportionally impacted even under conservative implementation options. We finally explore different international revenue recycling schemes to make the EU CBAM inclusive toward vulnerable countries and able to foster global climate cooperation.

Download


How trade policy can support the climate agenda

June 2022

·

230 Reads

·

29 Citations

Science

Michael Jakob

·

·

·

[...]

·

Sven Willner

Economic analysis has produced ample insights on how international trade and climate policy interact (1). Trade presents both opportunities and obstacles, and invites the question of how domestic climate policies can be effective in a global economy integrated through international trade. Particularly problematic is the potential relocation of production to regions with low climate standards. Measures to level the playing field, such as border carbon adjustments (BCAs), may be justified for specific emissions-intensive and trade-exposed sectors but need to be well-targeted, carefully navigating tensions that can arise between the desire to respect global trade rules and the need to elaborate and implement effective national climate policies. The conformity of specific trade measures with international trade and climate change law is not entirely clear. Yet, clarity is needed to ensure that the industry actors affected will find the rules predictable and be able to adhere to them.



Globalization and climate change: State of knowledge, emerging issues, and policy implications

March 2022

·

245 Reads

·

21 Citations

Wiley interdisciplinary reviews: Climate Change

In an integrated global economy, trade policy and climate policy are closely intertwined. This paper adopts an interdisciplinary approach to provide an overview of the key debates in economics, political science, and legal studies related to globalization and climate change. We identify a number of emerging issues that deserve increased attention in future research in this direction. These include international financial flows, migration, telecommunication, and digitization as well as changing lifestyles and consumption patterns across the globe. We also present potential research question regarding the diversification of import and export portfolios in the face of growing climate impacts and the decarbonization of industry, aviation, and shipping. Finally, we discuss how these recent developments could shape trade and climate policy formulation. We conclude that ambitious climate policies seem more likely to flourish in an open world trading system which provides sufficient flexibility for individual countries to adopt nationally appropriate climate policies. This article is categorized under: Climate Economics > Economics and Climate Change




The All-in pathway, in which all countries achieve to net zero by 2050
Industrialized-2030 pathway, wherein OECD countries reach net zero before 2050, and non-OECD after 2050
The Industrialized-2050 pathway, where OECD countries reach net zero by 2050, and non-OECD later
Equity implications of net zero visions

December 2021

·

445 Reads

·

30 Citations

Climatic Change

With national governments almost universally pledging to achieve net zero emissions, a key uncertainty is how net zero policies will affect global equity. It is unclear which policy measures are available for achieving net zero equitably, what the social and environmental implications of these measures will be under global pathways, or how they might be implemented in ways that advance rather than undermine equity. By means of three stylized future pathways, we show that there are potentially serious international and domestic equity effects from global net zero policies, as well as opportunities to achieve an equitable net zero future for all through appropriate policy design.


The political economy of coal: Lessons learnt from 15 country case studies

December 2021

·

66 Reads

·

24 Citations

World Development Perspectives

This article summarizes lessons learnt from 15 case studies on the political economy of coal following one integrated framework. It proposes four country categories that show comparable properties to analyze the political economy of coal, including countries that i) phase out coal, ii) phase in coal, iii) are established users and iv) depend on coal exports. Regarding the prevalence of coal investments in many countries, it highlights the role of conflicting societal objectives, e.g. affordable electricity prices being more important than environmental targets. Vested interests are mainly related to locally concentrated job losses, expectations regarding regional development, coal royalties, as well as lobbying by a politically well-connected coal industry. Those factors can be either strengthened or extenuated by structural factors, including multi-level governance issues and the structure of the energy market. Entry points for policy vary for different country categories. De-risking financing of alternatives to coal as well as reforms of energy markets are most important entry points in countries that still invest in coal or plan to phase in coal to their energy systems.


Citations (13)


... For other methods, we found Beaufils et al.'s study [32], which used a throughflowbased accounting method to analyze the impact of CBAM on the EU's trade partners. They found that the most negatively impacted countries were the low-and middle-income countries with a proportion of exports to the EU. ...

Reference:

Measuring the Cost of the European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism on Moroccan Exports
Assessing different European Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism implementations and their impact on trade partners

... The growing concern about climate change and sustainability has increased interest in sustainability indices, such as the Dow Jones Sustainability Index (DJSI) and its relationship with different economic spheres. Oil continues to be one of the most important raw materials in the global economy, being a significant source of income for companies and producing countries, the volatile price of crude oil can affect both the economy and the environment, especially after the Paris agreement, focused on reducing carbon emissions to address climate change, assuming a push towards greener energy sources (Steckel and Jakob, 2022). ...

To end coal, adapt to regional realities
  • Citing Article
  • July 2022

Nature

... To address concerns about carbon leakage, 3 some countries have introduced supplementary measures, such as border carbon adjustments and tariffs on imports based on their carbon content. These measures aim to ensure a level playing field for local industries subject to carbon pricing while encouraging global adoption of more sustainable practices (Böhringer et al., 2022;Jakob et al., 2022). ...

How trade policy can support the climate agenda
  • Citing Article
  • June 2022

Science

... Any globally successful decrease in agricultural emissions, on the other hand, necessitates global pacts for agriculture to limit emission leakage, and methods for decreasing emissions of greenhouse gases on consumers may be required (Fellmann et al., 2018). However, the difficulty is that ambitious climate policies aimed at reducing carbon emissions are more likely to thrive under an open global trade system that allows individual nations to choose domestically suitable climate policies (Jakob, 2022). Vol.3, Issue No.1, pp 45-61, 2024 www.carijournals.org ...

Globalization and climate change: State of knowledge, emerging issues, and policy implications

Wiley interdisciplinary reviews: Climate Change

... This includes multiple energy and power development plans. The respective case studies congruently highlight the interests of the Communist Party and incumbents in Vietnam [61] and the objectives of politicians and conglomerates in the Philippines [62] for energy policy making. The case study on Pakistan has not been published yet. ...

Conglomerates and the Department of Energy promote coal development in the Philippines1

... How will densely populated cities adjust, given the substantial changes that climate change mitigation and adaptation directives require in both built form and patterns of movement? And in proposing such sweeping changes to regional economics and lifestyles, is the first world, speaking through the IPCC, imposing yet another heavy burden on developing economies (Lenzi et al. 2021)? ...

Equity implications of net zero visions

Climatic Change

... Some of these barriers have been highlighted in previous studies on the political economy of coal in Indonesia, which relied on interview data from Ordonez et al. (2021) collected in 2018 (Jakob et al., 2020;Steckel and Jakob, 2021;Ohlendorf, Jakob and Steckel, 2022;Manych, Müller-Hansen and Steckel, 2023). This paper seeks to update and deepen the analysis from these studies using a narrative literature review and 10 interviews with key respondents conducted in 2023. ...

The political economy of coal: Lessons learnt from 15 country case studies
  • Citing Article
  • December 2021

World Development Perspectives

... Emissions pricing adopted by only a few frontrunners could spark carbon leakage, i.e. relocation of energy-intensive activities to jurisdictions with less stringent climate policies [29]. Yet, this issue arises for every unilateral climate policy that raises costs for firms and is thus not a particular feature of a carbon prices [30]. ...

Climate policy and international trade – A critical appraisal of the literature
  • Citing Article
  • September 2021

Energy Policy

... Attributing all the CO 2 emissions to the producers is unfair 21,22 . In fact, large amounts of CO 2 emissions are driven by consumers from trade 23 , leading to carbon leakage 24 . Therefore, evaluating accurate CO 2 emissions embodied in the trade is a need for quantifying the CO 2 emission reduction responsibilities between producers and consumers more equally 25 . ...

Why carbon leakage matters and what can be done against it
  • Citing Article
  • May 2021

One Earth

... In the same year, the members of the United Nations were invited to sign the Paris Agreement aiming to support sustainability efforts by ensuring regulatory compliance, societal legitimacy, and competitiveness (Escoto et al., 2022;Raneem et al., 2021). In response to these challenges, policymakers around the globe have been pushing companies in the energy sector to adopt sustainability practices that lead to overall sustainability performance improvement (Bansal, 2021;Golla et al., 2022;Ordonez et al., 2021). However, little is known about whether and how contextual factors affect the sustainability performance of energy firms, represented by environmental, social, and governance (ESG) scores. ...

Coal, power and coal-powered politics in Indonesia
  • Citing Article
  • September 2021

Environmental Science & Policy