Manuele Faccenda’s research while affiliated with University of Padua and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (20)


Artificial age-independent seismic anisotropy, slab thickening and shallowing due to limited resolving power of (an)isotropic tomography
  • Article
  • Full-text available

January 2024

·

54 Reads

·

2 Citations

Geophysical Journal International

·

M Witek

·

M Faccenda

·

[...]

·

Seismic anisotropy is key to constrain mantle flow, but it is challenging to image and interpret it. Existing large-scale tomography models of seismic anisotropy typically show large discrepancies, which can lead to completely distinct geodynamical interpretations. To better quantify the robustness of anisotropy tomography, we create a 2-D ridge-to-slab geodynamic model and compute the associated fabrics. Using the resulting 21 elastic constants we compute seismic full waveforms, which are inverted for isotropic and radially anisotropic structure. We test the effects of different data coverage and levels of regularisation on the resulting images and on their geodynamical interpretation. Within the context of our specific imposed conditions and source-receiver configuration, the retrieved isotropic images exhibit substantial artificial slab thickening and loss of the slab’s high velocity signature below ∼100 km depth. Our results also show that the first order features of radial anisotropy are well retrieved despite strong azimuthal anisotropy (up to 2.7 %) in the input model. On the other hand, regularisation and data coverage strongly control the detailed characteristics of the retrieved anisotropy, notably the depth-age dependency of anisotropy, leading to an artificial flat depth-age trend shown in existing anisotropy tomography models. Greater data coverage and additional complementary data types are needed to improve the resolution of (an)isotropic tomography models.

Download

(a) Phase diagram of H2O‐peridotite after Iwamori (2004). The black (dotted) lines indicating liquidus and dry/wet solidus (the numbers indicate water content in wt%) of peridotite in the upper mantle to the mantle transition zone, are from Keller and Katz (2016). The abbreviations of major hydrous phases are as follows: Ol‐Olivine, Wd‐Wadsleyite, Rw‐Ringwoodite, Brg‐Bridgmanite, Amp‐Amphibole, Ta‐Talc, Chl‐Chlorite, Serp‐Serpentine, A‐phase A, E‐phase E, shyB‐superhydrous phase B, D‐phase D, H‐phase (h) The stability field of phase H can reach 60 GPa and 1600 K (Ohtani et al., 2014). (b) Dry solidus and liquidus of the lower mantle by Andrault et al. (2011), wet solidus by Nomura et al. (2014) and saturated solidus (MgO−Al2O3−SiO2−H2O system) by Walter et al. (2015) have been adopted. The stability of dense hydrous magnesium silicates phases in the lower mantle is from Nishi et al. (2014) and Ohtani et al. (2014). Collected solidus and liquidus from the literature are also shown in Figure S1.
Initial configuration of numerical models. (a) The colors indicate rock types of solid and melt‐bearing rocks. The transition from the dry lithospheric mantle to the dry hot (asthenospheric or lower) mantle occurs at 1573 K. The arrows are boundary velocities. (b) The initial temperature profiles for different thermal ages.
Evolution of the composition field (left panel) for the reference model (V = 5 cm/yr, Tage = 50, OC = 0) with three typical dehydration depths. Black blocks are zoomed areas in composition and water content for the right‐side panels. The black curves are isotherms in °C. Note that serpentine, superhydrous phase B and phase H break down at 600°C contour in (e), 750 km in (b and f) and 1,500 km in (c and g), respectively. Hydrous phases D, E, superhydrous phase B and nominally anhydrous minerals can be preserved in the subducting slab at the mantle transition zone depths.
Influence of subducting velocity and thermal age of the slab. The subducting velocities of the two columns are 5 and 8 cm/yr, respectively; the thermal ages at each row are 30, 50, and 90 Myr. The black curves are isotherms in °C. Other parameters are OC = 0 wt%, LM = 0.05 wt%.
The same models as Figure 4 but show the water content field.

+5

On the Dynamics of Water Transportation and Magmatism in the Mid‐Mantle

The distribution of water within the Earth's mantle has significant implications for the Earth's dynamics and evolution. Recent mineral physics experiments indicate that dense hydrous magnesium silicates can contain large amounts of water stable up to 60 GPa or even beyond along slab geotherms. Here we perform petrological‐thermomechanical numerical simulations of water transportation by deep slab subduction and related magmatism in the mid‐mantle. Key parameters including those defining the slab thermal parameter and the water storage capacity in the oceanic lithosphere and surrounding mantle are explored. The results show two major dehydration events of ultramafic rocks at around 150 and 750 km by dehydration of serpentine at 600°C and superhydrous phase B in the entrained wet upper mantle, respectively. Large amounts of water, ∼1.5 wt% at least locally, are carried down to the mantle transition zone and lower mantle. We estimate an upper limit of slab water flux into the mid‐mantle of 0.1–0.28 × 10¹² kg/yr, which is ∼13%–37% of the input water from the serpentinized mantle. Moreover, a substantial fraction of the water released by the slab is absorbed by the entrained mantle and overlying mid‐mantle portions, such that ∼30%–70% of the water injected at the trench could be delivered to the lower mantle. The deepest magmatism is observed at ∼1,500 km in case of phase H breakdown (MgO‐SiO2‐H2O system), coinciding with the depth of strong seismic attenuation. Overall, these simulations suggest that up to 0.2 ocean mass per billion years could be transported down to the mid‐mantle and beyond.



Radial anisotropy in (a) S362WMANI (Kustowski et al., 2008), (b) SGLOBE‐rani (Chang et al., 2015), and (c) SAVANI (Auer et al., 2014) as a function of ocean‐sea floor age beneath the Atlantic (left) for profiles within the white lines (up to 60 Ma) in the map of observed plate motion (NUVEL‐1A in a no‐net‐rotation frame from DeMets et al. (2010)). Profiles are removed within 3° each of each plume (red circles) in the Sleep (1990) hotspot list. Cross‐sections beneath the Pacific can be found on the right for the same tomographic models (d–f), respectively. The 1,000°C isotherm from the half‐space cooling model is shown by a dashed/solid magenta line.
(a) Temperature field showing the half‐space cooling solution overlying an adiabat gradient increasing from 1,540 K at 0.5 K/km to 1,890 K at 700 km, (b) stress and streamlines (white lines), (c) deformation mechanism (the fraction of deformation accommodated by dislocation creep is computed as ηeff/ηdisl and it varies from 0 (ηdisl ≫ ηeff; i.e., no dislocation creep) to 1 (ηdisl = ηeff; Sturgeon et al. (2019)), (d) predicted radial anisotropy (which is not smoothed before the application of the tomographic filter) and (e) tomographically filtered predictions of radial anisotropy for the slow plate model (2 cm/yr). (f–j) Same as (a–e) but for the fast plate (8 cm/yr) with the rheological parameters found in Table S1 in Supporting Information S1. The 1,000°C isotherm from the half‐space cooling model is shown by the dashed/solid magenta line.
Recovered ξ as a function of ocean‐sea floor age beneath the slow plate for the reference model with the rheological parameters found in Table S1 in Supporting Information S1 with effective number of model parameters (a) 17,000 (most damping), (b) 25,000, (c) 35,000, and (d) 45,000 (least damping). (e–h) Same as (a–d) but for the fast plate. The 1,000°C isotherm from the half‐space cooling model is shown by the dashed/solid magenta line.
(a) The dependence of radial anisotropy (ξ) on plate speed and (b) the difference in the observed anisotropy beneath fast (Pacific) and slow (Atlantic) plates for S362WMANI. The same for format can be seen for: SGLOBE‐rani (c, d), SAVANI (e, f) and the tomographically filtered geodynamical model presented in this study (g, h).
On the Relationship Between Oceanic Plate Speed, Tectonic Stress, and Seismic Anisotropy

August 2022

·

144 Reads

·

7 Citations

Seismic radial anisotropy (the squared ratio between the speeds of horizontally and vertically polarized shear waves, ξ=VSH2VSV2 ξ=VSH2VSV2\xi =\frac{{{V}_{SH}}^{2}}{{{V}_{SV}}^{2}}) is a powerful tool to probe the direction of mantle flow and accumulated strain. While previous studies have confirmed the dependence of azimuthal anisotropy on plate speed, the first order control on radial anisotropy is unclear. In this study, we develop 2D ridge flow models combined with mantle fabric calculations to report that faster plates generate higher tectonics stresses and strain rates which lower the dislocation creep viscosity and lead to deeper anisotropy than beneath slower plates. We apply the SGLOBE‐rani tomographic filter, resulting in a flat depth‐age trend and stronger anisotropy beneath faster plates, which correlates well with 3D global anisotropic mantle models. Our predictions and observations suggest that as plate speed increases from 2 to 8 cm/yr, radial anisotropy increases by ∼0.01–0.025 in the upper 100–200 km of the mantle between 10 and 60 Ma.


Slab Geometry and Upper Mantle Flow Patterns in the Central Mediterranean From 3D Anisotropic P‐Wave Tomography

May 2022

·

439 Reads

·

31 Citations

We present the first three‐dimensional (3D) anisotropic teleseismic P‐wave tomography model of the upper mantle covering the entire Central Mediterranean. Compared to isotropic tomography, it is found that including the magnitude, azimuth, and, importantly, dip of seismic anisotropy in our inversions simplifies isotropic heterogeneity by reducing the magnitude of slow anomalies while yielding anisotropy patterns that are consistent with regional tectonics. The isotropic component of our preferred tomography model is dominated by numerous fast anomalies associated with retreating, stagnant, and detached slab segments. In contrast, relatively slower mantle structure is related to slab windows and the opening of back‐arc basins. To better understand the complexities in slab geometry and their relationship to surface geological phenomenon, we present a 3D reconstruction of the main Central Mediterranean slabs down to 700 km based on our anisotropic model. P‐wave seismic anisotropy is widespread in the Central Mediterranean upper mantle and is strongest at 200–300 km depth. The anisotropy patterns are interpreted as the result of asthenospheric material flowing primarily horizontally around the main slabs in response to pressure exerted by their mid‐to‐late Cenezoic horizontal motion, while sub‐vertical anisotropy possibly reflects asthenospheric entrainment by descending lithosphere. Our results highlight the importance of anisotropic P‐wave imaging for better constraining regional upper mantle geodynamics.




How to quake a subducting dry slab at intermediate depths: Inferences from numerical modelling

November 2021

·

186 Reads

·

11 Citations

Earth and Planetary Science Letters

The origin of intermediate-depth subduction seismicity is a topic of research since long time. While plate unbending is considered as one of the main stress loading mechanisms, the processes responsible for earthquake nucleation are still unclear and depend on the question of whether failure occurs in the wet dehydrating portion of the slab or in the predominantly dry portion. Recently, the seismogenic portions of subducting oceanic slabs have been proposed to consist of dominantly dry metaperidotite that deforms by seismic brittle failure in absence of fluid-mediated embrittlement. In this work, we quantify by numerical modelling the differential stress achievable during unbending of a subducting slab. We show that the presence of discrete hydrated domains in a dry, strong slab amplifies the differential stress to high seismogenic values (ca. 3-4 GPa in the 100-200 km depth range) at intermediate depths. We also consider the effects of low temperature plasticity in olivine that can hinder the build-up of high differential stress to the first 100 km of depth.


Identifying Seismic Anisotropy Patterns in the Alps and Apennines with Splitting Intensity and Backazimuthal Dependencies

The current tectonics of the Alps and Apennines are driven and influenced by current and past subduction systems. Computational advances over the years made it possible to identify remnant and active slabs until great depths and large seismic deployments revealed mostly clockwise rotation SKS splitting measurements. But the effects of layered anisotropy and regional upper mantle flow through possible tears in the slabs remain unknown. A comparison of several seismological methods can be a very efficient tool to separate lithospheric and asthenospheric anisotropy. This study tries to understand if anisotropy patterns change with depth in some regions (e.g., possible subslab mantle flow in the Western Alps) and if tears can be identified with shear wave splitting measurements (e.g., Central Apennines). Furthermore, splitting intensities will be analyzed for backazimuthal dependencies and used to correct velocities in a full-waveform tomography. By mapping and comparing existing and new anisotropy measurements (e.g., SKS, Pn anisotropy, azimuthal anisotropy from surface waves tomography, and splitting intensities) we intend to identify anisotropic depth dependencies.



Citations (12)


... -Non-steady-state flows in 2D-3D Cartesian and polar grids Capitanio, 2012, 2013;Hu et al., 2017;Zhou et al., 2018;Lo Bue et al., 2022;Fac-cenda and VanderBeek, 2023;Rappisi et al., 2024). In polar coordinates the velocity gradient tensor must be computed in the external Cartesian reference frame, as described in Appendix C. The global-scale models are spatially discretised using so-called Yin-Yang grids (Kageyama and Sato, 2004). ...

Reference:

ECOMAN: an open-source package for geodynamic and seismological modelling of mechanical anisotropy
Artificial age-independent seismic anisotropy, slab thickening and shallowing due to limited resolving power of (an)isotropic tomography

Geophysical Journal International

... Therefore, we propose that one of the possible explanations for the observed E-W fast orientation from XKS splitting in the Himalayan block is the westward continuation of slab rollback-induced flow along the Burma subduction zone (Liu et al., 2019). The westward absolute plate motion of the Eurasian plate in the hotspot reference frame (Gripp & Gordon, 2002) may also contribute to the E-W anisotropy (Singh et al., 2016), although the slow rate of motion (23 mm/yr) might be too small to produce significant azimuthal anisotropy (Kendall et al., 2022). The upper layer fast orientation of Station H0230 generally aligns with the resulting crustal anisotropy measurements ( Figure 5), which could be caused by the lattice-preferred-orientation of crustal anisotropic minerals such as mica due to the northeastward compression between the Indian and Eurasian plates. ...

On the Relationship Between Oceanic Plate Speed, Tectonic Stress, and Seismic Anisotropy

... Example of combined data of the Alps, which shows the GPS surface velocity (arrows), topography, earthquake locations (colored dots) and cross-sections through a recent anisotropic P-wave tomography model by (Rappisi et al., 2022). ...

Slab Geometry and Upper Mantle Flow Patterns in the Central Mediterranean From 3D Anisotropic P‐Wave Tomography

... Theoretical considerations have shown that this mechanism requires stresses on the order of 1 GPa (Braeck & Podladchikov, 2007). Such stresses may be generated by dehydration-driven stress transfer (Ferrand et al., 2017), stress amplifications around weak inclusions (Toffol et al., 2022), dehydration embrittlement or transformational faulting. This dual-mechanism process has been proposed to explain the occurrence of deep-focus earthquakes outside of the metastable olivine wedge (e.g., Bezada & Humphreys, 2012;McGuire et al., 1997;Zhan, 2020). ...

How to quake a subducting dry slab at intermediate depths: Inferences from numerical modelling
  • Citing Article
  • November 2021

Earth and Planetary Science Letters

... Ho wever , the actual HSA in the Earth's interior may tilt in an y direction, particularl y in subduction zones, as re vealed b y recent studies of anisotropic tomography (e.g. VanderBeek & Faccenda 2021 ;Wang & Zhao 2021 ). Especially, in subduction zones, AAN media can be assumed to some extent in the mantle wedge due to corner flow but may not be assumed in the dipping subducting slab (e.g. ...

Imaging upper mantle anisotropy with teleseismic P-wave delays: Insights from tomographic reconstructions of subduction simulations

Geophysical Journal International

... Finally, viscoplastic-self-consistent (VPSC) modeling provides an alternative approach in which grains are not assumed interactionless but instead taken to behave as inclusions in a homogeneous effective medium (see Castelnau et al. (2008) for details, and Ledoux et al. (2023) for a recent application). This mean-field approach does not assume homogeneous strain or stress across the polycrystal scale, as the above methods do, but comes with a much greater computational cost and is therefore generally not feasible for integration with large-scale flow models (Hansen et al., 2021). Nonetheless, using it to inform parametrizations of viscous anisotropy has been fruitful (Mameri et al., 2020;Signorelli et al., 2021). ...

A review of mechanisms generating seismic anisotropy in the upper mantle
  • Citing Article
  • February 2021

Physics of The Earth and Planetary Interiors

... Subduction zones play a crucial role in the Earth's deep water cycle by transporting large amounts of water stored in the hydrated oceanic lithosphere into the mantle (Brovarone et al., 2020;Schmidt and Poli, 1998;Ulmer and Trommsdorff, 1995;Rüpke et al., 2004). The release of this water during slab dehydration, together with the subsequent fluid flow back to the surface, is a process that affects several geological phenomena, including arc volcanism Elliott et al., 1997;Ague et al., 2022), seismicity (Hacker et al., 2003;Ferrand et al., 2017;Shao et al., 2023), and mantle rheology (Hirth and Guillot, 2013;Reynard, 2013;Nakagawa et al., 2015). ...

Let there be water: How hydration/dehydration reactions accompany key Earth and life processes#

American Mineralogist

... The possible role of fluids in this process 22 , cannot be evaluated with our simplified numerical model. Intermediate-depths earthquakes occurring in dry rock volumes have also been proposed by field-based observations 10,60,61 : as an example, Scambelluri et al. 61 and Pennacchioni et al. 62 found pseudotachylytes in dry lithospheric mantle domains banded by serpentinites, coherently exhumed from the eclogite facies conditions, testifying a seismic rupture occurring at intermediate depths. ...

Record of intermediate-depth subduction seismicity in a dry slab from an exhumed ophiolite
  • Citing Article
  • October 2020

Earth and Planetary Science Letters

... introduction Clinopyroxenes (general formula M2M1T 2 O 6 ) are key minerals, due to their widespread occurrence in the Earth's crust and upper mantle (Skelton and Walker 2015), to characterize various geological settings and processes. They can be found as both rock-forming and accessory minerals in several terrestrial rock types from diverse geological contexts, including mantle xenoliths, magmatic rocks (e.g., Lentz et al. 2011;Murri et al. 2016Murri et al. , 2019bGianola et al. 2023) and high-pressure/temperature metamorphic rocks (Philpotts and Ague 2009;Gilio et al. 2020). Clinopyroxenes also occur as inclusions in diamonds (Meyer and Boyd 1972;Nestola et al. 2016;Pasqualetto et al. 2022) and as rock-forming minerals in meteorites (e.g., Papike 1980;Alvaro et al. 2015;Carli et al. 2023). ...

Cooling history and emplacement of a pyroxenitic lava as proxy for understanding Martian lava flows

... Beneath the Hindu Kush, the seismicity-imaged slab has generally been interpreted as the northward-subducting Indian Frontiers in Earth Science frontiersin.org 05 plate, with its dip steepening downward into sub-vertical or even overturned directions (Kufner et al., 2016;Kufner et al., 2017;Liang et al., 2020;Peng et al., 2020). Tomographic images show a low-velocity zone at~60-160 km depth and a high-velocity zone at~160-600 km depth, interpreted as the subducted crust overlying the lithospheric slab (Kufner et al., 2017;Kufner et al., 2021). ...

Mantle flow entrained by the Hindu Kush continental subduction inferred from source-side seismic anisotropy
  • Citing Article
  • November 2019

Earth and Planetary Science Letters