Karin S. Bruwelheide’s research while affiliated with Florida Museum of Natural History and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (17)


Figure 2. The four aligned graves in the chancel area of the 1608 Jamestown church (c. 1608-1616). Shared coffin style and orientation contribute to the possible identification of the second (JR2992C) and fourth (JR170C) individuals from the left as members of the prominent West family. Image's left is directional north (photograph by Donald E. Hurlbert, Smithsonian Institution).
Figure 3. Broadly Western European ancestry detected in JR2992C and JR170C. Principal component analysis of 1320 present-day individuals from 66 populations from Europe and the Near East from the Human Origins dataset. All present-day individuals are shown in grey. The two Jamestown individuals of European ancestry (JR2992C and JR170C) are projected (figure by Éadaoin Harney).
Figure 4. Three generations of the family tree of William West, First Baron De La Warr (figure by Deborah A. Hull-Walski & Andrew J. Ramsey, Smithsonian Institution).
Historical and Archaeogenomic Identification of High-Status Englishmen at Jamestown, Virginia
  • Article
  • Full-text available

August 2024

·

223 Reads

Antiquity

Douglas W. Owsley

·

Karin S. Bruwelheide

·

·

[...]

·

David E. Reich

The authors report on ancient DNA data from two human skeletons buried within the chancel of the 1608–1616 church at the North American colonial settlement of Jamestown, Virginia. Available archaeological, osteological and documentary evidence suggest that these individuals are Sir Ferdinando Wenman and Captain William West, kinsmen of the colony's first Governor, Thomas West, Third Baron De La Warr. Genomic analyses of the skeletons identify unexpected maternal relatedness as both carried the mitochondrial haplogroup H10e. In this unusual case, aDNA prompted further historical research that led to the discovery of illegitimacy in the West family, an aspect of identity omitted, likely intentionally, from genealogical records.

Download

Fig. 1 Manassas National Battlefield Park area map showing its location in Virginia and identifying important sites within. (Map by National Park Service, 2014.)
Fig. 3 The impact surface of the extracted bullet has well-defined, parallel ridges and the imprinted weave of uniform fabric. The bullet weighs 34.5 g (1.215 oz.), with a mid-bullet diameter of 0.63 in. (Photos by James D. Tiller, 2018.)
Howard intermediary amputation possible matches
A Civil War Surgeon’s Pit at Manassas National Battlefield Park, Virginia

November 2023

·

130 Reads

Historical Archaeology

Human bone fragments were discovered during archaeological monitoring of earth moving on Manassas National Battlefield Park in Virginia. Later mitigation recovered bones in situ—two skeletons and seven amputated limbs. Interdisciplinary research affords an unusually detailed level of interpretation, including identification of the remains as Union soldiers wounded during the Battle of Second Manassas (28–30 August 1862). The reconstructed narrative includes military and personal markers of identity, as well as causes of death and injury, and establishes a window from 1 to 6 September 1862 when the pit was dug. Records of Union surgeons make future personal identification of the amputated limbs possible and confirm the pit’s location as a key treatment center after Second Manassas, a battle that marked an inflection point for combat military medicine by highlighting the urgent need for improved systematic recovery and treatment of the wounded.


Remains of the Invisible: Reconstructing Nineteenth-Century Plantation Life through the Biohistories of an Eastern North Carolina Family

August 2023

·

22 Reads

Historical Archaeology

Planned restoration of a 19th-century burial vault in Jones County, North Carolina, associated with the Foscue family, led to its excavation in 2010. Family lore and related documents identify only three family members buried in the vault, but nine individuals are represented by the remains. Possible identities of the unnamed individuals are explored using biological data, family documents, and family lore. The invisibility of some individuals in the historical record reflects a period of shifting family structures, high female and infant mortality, and the effects of social status on documentation and remembrance.


Figure 1. Genomic ancestries of Avery's Rest individuals against the global Human Origins panel (A) PCA results showing separation of individuals with European and African ancestry components. (B) PCA results for the eight European-affiliated Avery's Rest individuals, plotted against European populations in the Human Origins panel. (C) ADMIXTURE results at K = 8 for the Avery's Rest series. See also Figures S2 and S3 and Data S1C.
Figure 2. African ancestry profiles for AR09, AR10, and AR11 against a custom African reference panel (A) Map of Africa with the countries used in the reference panel colored according to the accompanying PCA plot. The subpanel displays the Lesser Antilles Islands, for which the island of Barbados is highlighted. (B) PCA plot of the three Avery's Rest individuals with African ancestry. (C) ADMIXTURE profiles of the three individuals with African ancestry at K = 9. See also Figures S2 and S3, Tables S1 and S2, and Data S1.
Figure 3. Kinship estimation for the Avery's Rest individuals (A) Burial locations at the Avery's Rest site. Individuals AR01-AR08 are located in the southern burial cluster; individuals AR09-AR11 are located in the northern cluster. The space between the dots represents a 5-foot scale. Note that due to the scale of the map, burials AR01 and AR03 appear to overlap but are buried parallel to each other. (B) READ results for the African individuals, with error bars showing one standard error for average pairwise distance. (C and D) (C) NgsRelate results for the 2DSFS method, displaying R1 and the KING-Coefficient, and (D) R1 and the R0 values for the European-affiliated individuals. (E) Constructed pedigree chart showing relationships among Avery's Rest individuals. Squares indicate males and circles represent females, as estimated in the Chromosomal sex estimation section of the STAR Methods. See also Figure S2 and Data S1D-S1F and S3A-S3D.
Archaeological, osteological, and sequencing results summary for the Avery's Rest individuals
Historical genomes elucidate European settlement and the African diaspora in Delaware

June 2023

·

555 Reads

Current Biology

The 17th-century colonization of North America brought thousands of Europeans to Indigenous lands in the Delaware region, which comprises the eastern boundary of the Chesapeake Bay in what is now the Mid-Atlantic region of the United States. The demographic features of these initial colonial migrations are not uniformly characterized, with Europeans and European-Americans migrating to the Delaware area from other countries and neighboring colonies as single persons or in family units of free persons, indentured servants, or tenant farmers. European colonizers also instituted a system of racialized slavery through which they forcibly transported thousands of Africans to the Chesapeake region. Historical information about African- descended individuals in the Delaware region is limited, with a population estimate of less than 500 persons by 1700 CE. To shed light on the population histories of this period, we analyzed low-coverage genomes of 11 individuals from the Avery’s Rest archaeological site (circa 1675–1725 CE), located in Delaware. Previous osteological and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequence analyses showed a southern group of eight indivi uals of European maternal descent, buried 15–20 feet from a northern group of three individuals of African maternal descent.5 Autosomal results further illuminate genomic similarities to Northwestern European reference populations or West and West-Central African reference populations, respectively. We also identify three generations of maternal kin of European ancestry and a paternal parent-offspring relationship between an adult and child of African ancestry. These findings expand our understanding of the origins and familial relationships in late 17th and early 18th century North America.


Historical genomes elucidate European settlement and the African diaspora in Delaware

May 2023

·

759 Reads

Current Biology

The 17th-century colonization of North America brought thousands of Europeans to Indigenous lands in the Delaware region, which comprises the eastern boundary of the Chesapeake Bay in what is now the Mid- Atlantic region of the United States.1 The demographic features of these initial colonial migrations are not uni- formly characterized, with Europeans and European-Americans migrating to the Delaware area from other countries and neighboring colonies as single persons or in family units of free persons, indentured servants, or tenant farmers.2 European colonizers also instituted a system of racialized slavery through which they forcibly transported thousands of Africans to the Chesapeake region. Historical information about African- descended individuals in the Delaware region is limited, with a population estimate of less than 500 persons by 1700 CE.3,4 To shed light on the population histories of this period, we analyzed low-coverage genomes of 11 individuals from the Avery’s Rest archaeological site (circa 1675–1725 CE), located in Delaware. Previous osteological and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequence analyses showed a southern group of eight individ- uals of European maternal descent, buried 15–20 feet from a northern group of three individuals of African maternal descent.5 Autosomal results further illuminate genomic similarities to Northwestern European refer- ence populations or West and West-Central African reference populations, respectively. We also identify three generations of maternal kin of European ancestry and a paternal parent-offspring relationship between an adult and child of African ancestry. These findings expand our understanding of the origins and familial relationships in late 17th and early 18th century North America.



The Lead Coffins of St. Mary’s: Burials of the Elite in the Early ChesapeakeBurials of the Elite in the Early Chesapeake

May 2021

·

9 Reads

Three unidentified lead coffins were discovered at Historic St. Mary’s City during a remote sensing and archaeological excavation of a 1660s brick chapel. Their investigation led to a re-examination of two additional lead coffins from a nearby brick vault constructed in 1694 and believed to house the bodies of Maryland’s first royal governor and his wife. These five rare coffins and their contents, examined by an interdisciplinary team including nuclear physicists, engineers, a pollen specialist, geologist, archaeologists, and forensic anthropologists, provide information on seventeenth-century identities, colonial life, and behaviours lost over time. Previously unknown aspects of diet, health, and childcare are revealed through skeletal and chemical analyses. The information from these high-status individuals serves as a contrast and comparison to other, less affluent individuals buried at St. Mary’s and throughout the Chesapeake region.


Restoring Identity to People and Place: Reanalysis of Human Skeletal Remains from a Cemetery at Catoctin Furnace, Maryland

December 2019

·

119 Reads

·

9 Citations

Historical Archaeology

Nearly four decades ago, a highway expansion project resulted in the excavation of 35 unmarked graves at Catoctin Furnace, an industrial ironworking village in western Maryland. Initial analysis identified the remains as Africans or African Americans associated with the late 18th- and early 19th-century operation of the ironworks. Renewed efforts to learn more about these poorly documented individuals and connect the site’s untold past to present generations through heritage tourism, prompted reanalysis of the skeletons. Updated assessments of demography and pathology, along with new analyses including heavy metals and carbon and nitrogen stable isotopes, elucidate the life histories of these early laborers and their involvement in furnace operations. Some data derived from recent testing differentiate the Catoctin Furnace individuals from their plantation-based contemporaries in the mid-Atlantic, suggesting regional differences in diet and possible occupational exposure to toxins.


Stable isotopes from the African site of Elmina, Ghana and their usefulness in tracking the provenance of enslaved individuals in 18th‐ and 19th‐century North American populations

November 2019

·

143 Reads

·

7 Citations

American Journal of Physical Anthropology

Objectives: Stable isotope values for historic period human remains from Elmina, Ghana, are compared to isotope data from 18th- and 19th-century North American sites as a test case for examining African origins and identifying first generation Africans in the Mid-Atlantic region of the United States. Materials and methods: Stable carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen isotope values were measured in skeletal remains. Values from the cosmopolitan port city of Elmina provide the first available reference data from Africa during this time period and region. These values serve as a proxy for West African groups in general which are statistically compared to Euro-Americans and African Americans. Results: Elmina carbon isotope values are relatively higher than those of North Americans, and African Americans show greater statistical similarity to West Africans. Elmina nitrogen isotope values are higher than those of North Americans. Elmina oxygen isotope values are notably higher than those in all Mid-Atlantic North American sites in this study. Discussion: Similarity in carbon isotope values between Elmina and African Americans suggests commonalities in food availability or food preferences between these groups. Elevated nitrogen isotope values in Elmina individuals support the documented reliance of the local population on marine dietary resources at this coastal port. While carbon and nitrogen isotopes provide insight into foodways, oxygen isotope data, sourced from drinking water, provide better geographical information. The higher oxygen values from Elmina not only differentiate this group from North American Mid-Atlantic sites, but also make it possible to identify outliers at these sites as potential recent arrivals from West Africa.


Ancient DNA and bioarchaeological perspectives on European and African diversity and relationships on the colonial Delaware frontier

July 2019

·

343 Reads

·

9 Citations

American Journal of Physical Anthropology

Objectives: Ancient DNA (aDNA) and standard osteological analyses applied to 11 skeletons at a late17th to early18th century farmstead site in Delaware to investigate the biological and social factors of settlement and slavery in colonial America. Materials and methods: Osteological analysis and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequencing were conducted for all individuals and the resulting data contextualized with archaeological and documentary evidence. Results: Individuals of European and African descent were spatially separated in this colonial cemetery. The skeletal remains exhibited differences in osteological features and maternal genetic ancestry. A specific mtDNA haplotype appeared in a subset of the European-descended individuals suggesting they were maternally related. Individuals of African descent were not maternally related, and instead showed a diversity of haplotypes affiliated with present-day Western, Central, and Eastern regions of Africa. Discussion: Along with the bioarchaeological and documentary evidence, the aDNA findings contribute to our understanding of life on the colonial Delaware frontier. Evidence of maternal relatedness among European-descended individuals at the site demonstrates kin-based settlements in 17th century Delaware and provides preliminary identifications of individuals. The maternal genetic diversity of the individuals with African descent aligns with the routes of the trans-Atlantic slave trade but broadens our understanding of the ancestries of persons involved in it. Burial positioning, osteological pathology, and lack of maternal kinship among individuals of African descent provide tangible evidence for the emergence of racialized labor and society in Delaware during the late17th century.


Citations (9)


... Overall, the lead levels for individuals from Catoctin were low. Women at Catoctin, however, appear to have experienced slight increases in lead exposure through life, but this was not linked directly to occupational exposure from the furnace, and lead was commonly found in many products of the period (Bruwelheide et al. 2020). ...

Reference:

Bioarchaeological Approaches to African Diasporas in the Twenty-First Century: Intercontinental and Global Legacies of Displacement
Restoring Identity to People and Place: Reanalysis of Human Skeletal Remains from a Cemetery at Catoctin Furnace, Maryland
  • Citing Article
  • December 2019

Historical Archaeology

... They observed few cases of infectious lesions and low rates of dental defects, which suggest good dental health. France et al. (2019) more recently compared stable carbon, nitrogen and oxygen isotope values ( 13 C, δ 15 N, δ 18 O) from Elmina burials to those of enslaved decedents in the United States. The Elmina isotope values were distinct from the United States, suggesting they can be used as a proxy for West African groups forcibly transported to the Americas. ...

Stable isotopes from the African site of Elmina, Ghana and their usefulness in tracking the provenance of enslaved individuals in 18th‐ and 19th‐century North American populations

American Journal of Physical Anthropology

... To demonstrate the DNA extraction process, bone or tooth samples were prepared for extraction as per Fleskes et al. (2019Fleskes et al. ( , 2021. Two sets of DNA extractions were filmed in real time. ...

Ancient DNA and bioarchaeological perspectives on European and African diversity and relationships on the colonial Delaware frontier

American Journal of Physical Anthropology

... R esearch into the health condition of historically known personalities has always attracted the attention of scientists and the professional and general public. [1][2][3] The ideal is to confront demonstrable pathological changes with historical written sources, whether these are changes found on the remains of the body or, for example, in iconography. 4 Therefore, gathering of all possible documents and evidence to create an overall review of the studied case plays a very important role in its interpretation or revision. ...

Unearthing Robert Kennicott: Naturalist, Explorer, Smithsonian Scientist
  • Citing Chapter
  • January 2017

... Within archaeology, the work of post-medieval bioarchaeologists of industrialising England most often produces population-level studies of larger groups, rather than of small communities and individuals. Cases where a fuller historical record is integrated with an analysis of skeletal remains are very rare but have been shown to lead to valuable new knowledge about healthcare, attitudes towards individuals and the role of women (Owsley et al., 2018). The combination of materials which create our archive of embodiment enables us to undertake a holistic treatment not just of elite bodies but those that might be considered 'ordinary' and 'marginalised' bodies -men, women and children of the middling sort and labouring poor, reproducing female bodies, disabled bodies, the old and young, and bodies that were stolen, traded and handled. ...

Lives Lost: What Burial Vault Studies Reveal About Eighteenth-Century Identities
  • Citing Chapter
  • January 2018

... unwillingly (Berger 2021;Blakely 1997;Blakely and Harrington 1997;Byrnes 2017;Crist and Crist 2011;Crist et al. 2017;Dougherty and Sullivan 2017;Garcia-Putnam et al. 2023;Grauer et al. 2017;Halling and Seidemann 2017;Harrington 1997;Lowe 2017;Muller et al. 2020;Nystrom 2011;Nystrom and Mackey 2014;Owsley et al. 2017;Voss 2018). Bioarchaeologists can directly observe the implications of institutionalization and marginalization on human bodies, given that the violence, hardships, and stressors that accompany poverty and otherness may manifest in skeletal and dental tissues (Farmer 2003(Farmer , 2004Gowland 2018;Klaus 2012Klaus , 2014Sofaer 2006). ...

Skeletal Evidence of Anatomical and Surgical Training in Nineteenth-Century Richmond
  • Citing Chapter
  • August 2017

... Amputated limb pits are rarely documented in formal cemetery contexts, and only occasionally are amputated limbs found buried with the deceased (Ragland 1931;Noël Hume 1963;Bruwelheide, Owsley, and Carlson 2008;Owsley and Bruwelheide 2009). On occasion, cut bones are traced to the work of practicing physicians or to 17th-to 19thcentury hospitals and medical schools where surgeons engaged in dissection and training in anatomy and surgery, as well as in performing amputations (Mann et al. 1991;Blakely and Harrington 1997;Bruwelheide, Owsley, Straube et al. 2017;Owsley et al. 2017;Scalise et al. 2018). In this case, bone fragments are discovered on a battlefield where combat took place and surgeries occurred. ...

Evidence for Early Seventeenth-Century Surgery and Dissection at James Fort, Virginia
  • Citing Chapter
  • January 2017

... Most unfortunate for this study, however, it turned out that the death register of Leuk only starts in 1658, which makes it virtually impossible to compare the results of this study to any historical documentation. In similar studies, multiple lines of evidence regarding physical anthropology and costume history were also followed, but, in the end, the name and precise date of birth and death were gained from written documentation, such as cemetery plans or church-register entries (Fingerlin 1992;Owsley et al. 2006;Lösch et al. 2011;Alterauge, Kellinghaus et al. 2017). In contrast, our mummy is from a period in which standardized registration had only just begun, and, due to a lack thereof, the individual remains unidentified. ...

The Man in the Iron Coffin: An Interdisciplinary Effort to Name the Past
  • Citing Article
  • September 2006

Historical Archaeology

... This was the advantage scalps had over a wide array of alternative human trophies popular among Native Americans. Human teeth, fingers, and other hand bones seem to have been particularly widespread but never reached the cultural and social relevance scalps did (Friederici, 2008(Friederici, [1907; Owsley et al., 2007). Unlike the scalp, these are all easy to counterfeit. ...

Reference:

Scalp-taking
Human Finger and Hand Bone Necklaces from the Plains and Great Basin
  • Citing Chapter
  • January 2007