John T. Wixted's research while affiliated with University of California and other places
What is this page?
This page lists the scientific contributions of an author, who either does not have a ResearchGate profile, or has not yet added these contributions to their profile.
It was automatically created by ResearchGate to create a record of this author's body of work. We create such pages to advance our goal of creating and maintaining the most comprehensive scientific repository possible. In doing so, we process publicly available (personal) data relating to the author as a member of the scientific community.
If you're a ResearchGate member, you can follow this page to keep up with this author's work.
If you are this author, and you don't want us to display this page anymore, please let us know.
It was automatically created by ResearchGate to create a record of this author's body of work. We create such pages to advance our goal of creating and maintaining the most comprehensive scientific repository possible. In doing so, we process publicly available (personal) data relating to the author as a member of the scientific community.
If you're a ResearchGate member, you can follow this page to keep up with this author's work.
If you are this author, and you don't want us to display this page anymore, please let us know.
Publications (52)
Police investigators worldwide use lineups to test an eyewitness's memory of a perpetrator. A typical lineup consists of one suspect (who is innocent or guilty) plus five or more fillers who resemble the suspect and who are known to be innocent. Although eyewitness identification decisions were once biased by police pressure and poorly constructed...
We argue that critical areas of memory research rely on problematic measurement practices and provide concrete suggestions to improve the situation. In particular, we highlight the prevalence of memory studies that use tasks (like the "old/new" task: "have you seen this item before? yes/no") where quantifying performance is deeply dependent on coun...
Change detection tasks are commonly used to measure and understand the nature of visual working memory capacity. Across three experiments, we examine whether the nature of the memory signals used to perform change detection are continuous or all-or-none and consider the implications for proper measurement of performance. In Experiment 1, we find ev...
Significance
Episodic memories represent the “what,” “when,” and “where” of specific episodes. In epilepsy patients, we detected single-unit activity reflecting episodic memory only in the hippocampus. This neural signal is sparsely coded and pattern-separated, consistent with predictions from neurocomputational models. We also detected single-unit...
A fundamental goal of scientific research is to generate true positives (i.e., authentic discoveries). Statistically, a true positive is a significant finding for which the underlying effect size (δ) is greater than 0, whereas a false positive is a significant finding for which δ equals 0. However, the null hypothesis of no difference (δ = 0) may n...
Change detection tasks are commonly used to measure and understand the nature of visual working memory capacity. Across two experiments, we examine whether the nature of the latent memory signals used to perform change detection are continuous or all-or-none, and consider the implications for proper measurement of performance. In Experiment 1, we f...
The reliability of any type of forensic evidence (e.g., forensic DNA) is assessed by testing its information value when it is not contaminated and is properly tested. Assessing the reliability of forensic memory evidence should be no exception to that rule. Unfortunately, testing a witness's memory irretrievably contaminates it. Thus, only the firs...
Eyewitness misidentifications are almost always made with high confidence in the courtroom. The courtroom is where eyewitnesses make their last identification of defendants suspected of (and charged with) committing a crime. But what did those same eyewitnesses do on the first identification test, conducted early in a police investigation? Despite...
The simultaneous six-pack photo lineup is a standard eyewitness identification procedure, consisting of one police suspect plus five physically similar fillers. The photo lineup is either a target-present array (the suspect is guilty) or a target-absent array (the suspect is innocent). The eyewitness is asked to search the six photos in the array w...
Berkowitz et al. (Berkowitz, S. R., Garrett, B. L., Fenn, K. M., & Loftus, E. F. (2020). Convicting with confidence? Why we should not over-rely on eyewitness confidence. Memory. https://doi.org/10.1080/09658211.2020.1849308) attribute to us the claim that "confidence trumps all", and the few out-of-context quotations they selected can certainly be...
An amendment to this paper has been published and can be accessed via a link at the top of the paper.
We argue there is a ‘crisis of measurement’ in critical areas of memory research and provide concrete suggestions to improve the situation. In particular, we highlight the prevalence of memory studies that use tasks (like the “old/new” task: “have you seen this item before? yes/no”) where quantifying performance is deeply dependent on counterfactua...
The present study examined task order, language, and frequency effects on list memory to investigate how bilingualism affects recognition memory. In Experiment 1, 64 bilinguals completed a recognition memory task including intermixed high and medium frequency words in English and another list in Spanish. In Experiment 2, 64 bilinguals and 64 monoli...
Significance
Eyewitness misidentifications have contributed to many wrongful convictions later overturned by DNA evidence. In response, many useful reforms have been introduced to protect the innocent. However, some police practices designed to protect the innocent also protect the guilty. We investigated a method for selecting fillers in a police...
Eyewitness identification via lineup procedures is an important and widely used source of evidence in criminal cases. However, the scientific literature provides inconsistent guidance on a very basic feature of lineup procedure: lineup size. In two experiments, we examined whether the number of fillers affects diagnostic accuracy in a lineup, as as...
Almost all models of visual memory implicitly assume that errors in mnemonic representations are linearly related to distance in stimulus space. Here we show that neither memory nor perception are appropriately scaled in stimulus space; instead, they are based on a transformed similarity representation that is nonlinearly related to stimulus space....
The relationship between confidence and accuracy in recognition memory is important in real-world settings (e.g., eyewitness identification) and is also important to understand at a theoretical level. Signal detection theory assumes that recognition decisions are based on continuous underlying memory signals and therefore inherently predicts that t...
Encoding activity in the medial temporal lobe, presumably evoked by the presentation of stimuli (postonset activity), is known to predict subsequent memory. However, several independent lines of research suggest that preonset activity also affects subsequent memory. We investigated the role of preonset and postonset single-unit and multiunit activi...
Recent research in the eyewitness identification literature has investigated whether simultaneous or sequential lineups yield better discriminability. In standard eyewitness identification experiments, subjects view a mock-crime video and then are tested only once, requiring large samples for adequate power. However, there is no reason why theories...
The perceived replication crisis and the reforms designed to address it are grounded in the notion that science is a binary signal detection problem. However, contrary to null hypothesis significance testing (NHST) logic, the magnitude of the underlying effect size for a given experiment is best conceptualized as a random draw from a continuous dis...
Objective:
The Executive Committee of the American Psychology-Law Society (Division 41 of the American Psychological Association) appointed a subcommittee to update the influential 1998 scientific review paper on guidelines for eyewitness identification procedures.
Method:
This was a collaborative effort by six senior eyewitness researchers, who...
Objective: The Executive Committee of the American Psychology-Law Society (Division 41 of the American Psychological Association) appointed a subcommittee to update the influential 1998 scientific review paper on guidelines for eyewitness identification procedures. Method: This was a collaborative effort by six senior eyewitness researchers, who al...
The criminal justice system should consider the confidence an eyewitness expresses when making an identification at the time the initial lineup procedure is conducted. High confidence expressed at this time typically indicates high accuracy in the identification. Because the suspect identification – not filler identifications or no identifications...
Signal detection theory is one of psychology's most well-known and influential theoretical frameworks. However, the conceptual hurdles that had to be overcome before the theory could finally emerge in its modern form in the early 1950s seem to have been largely forgotten. Here, I trace the origins of signal detection theory, beginning with Fechner'...
Forensic evidence is often quantified by statisticians in terms of a likelihood ratio. When the evidence consists of a DNA match, the likelihood ratio is equal to the reciprocal of the †random match probability' (p). When p is small (e.g. 1/10 million), the likelihood ratio is large (e.g. 10 million to 1). However, when a single match is obtained...
As part of a criminal investigation, the police often administer a recognition memory task known as a photo lineup. A typical 6-person photo lineup consists of one suspect (who may or may not be guilty) and five physically similar foils (all known to be innocent). The photos can be shown simultaneously (i.e., all at once) or sequentially (i.e., one...
The core functional organization of the primate brain is remarkably conserved across the order, but behavioral differences evident between species likely reflect derived modifications in the underlying neural processes. Here, we performed the first study to directly compare visual recognition memory in two primate species-rhesus macaques and marmos...
ᅟ
Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis was introduced to the field of eyewitness identification 5 years ago. Since that time, it has been both influential and controversial, and the debate has raised an issue about measuring discriminability that is rarely considered. The issue concerns the distinction between empirical discriminability...
Limits on the storage capacity of working memory have been investigated for decades, but the nature of those limits remains elusive. An important but largely overlooked consideration in this research concerns the relationship between the physical properties of stimuli used in visual working memory tasks and their psychological properties. Here, we...
Cognitive psychologists are familiar with how their expertise in understanding human perception, memory, and decision-making is applicable to the justice system. They may be less familiar with how their expertise in statistical decision-making and their comfort working in noisy real-world environments is just as applicable. Here we show how this ex...
Although certain pockets within the broad field of academic psychology have come to appreciate that eyewitness memory is more reliable than was once believed, the prevailing view, by far, is that eyewitness memory is unreliable—a blanket assessment that increasingly pervades the legal system. On the surface, this verdict seems unavoidable: Research...
The available real-world evidence suggests that, on an initial test, eyewitness memory is often reliable. Ironically, even the DNA exoneration cases—which generally involved nonpristine testing conditions and which are usually construed as an indictment of eyewitness memory—show how reliable an initial test of eyewitness memory can be in the real w...
Efforts to increase replication rates in psychology generally consist of recommended improvements to methodology, such as increasing sample sizes to increase power or using a lower alpha level. However, little attention has been paid to how the prior odds (R) that a tested effect is true can affect the probability that a significant result will be...
In vast contrast to the multitude of lineup studies that report on the link between decision time, confidence, and identification accuracy, only a few studies looked at these associations for showups, with results varying widely across studies. We therefore set out to test the individual and combined value of decision time and post-decision confide...
Significance
Neurocomputational models hold that episodic memories are represented by sparse, stimulus-specific neural codes. In tests of episodic memory, single-unit recording studies of the human hippocampus have found neurons that operate as general novelty detectors or general familiarity detectors. Here, we investigated whether neurons can be...
Estimator variables are factors that can affect the accuracy of eyewitness identifications but that are outside of the control of the criminal justice system. Examples include (1) the duration of exposure to the perpetrator, (2) the passage of time between the crime and the identification (retention interval), (3) the distance between the witness a...
Estimator variables are factors that can affect the accuracy of eyewitness identifications but that are outside of the control of the criminal justice system. Examples include (1) the duration of exposure to the perpetrator, (2) the passage of time between the crime and the identification (retention interval), (3) the distance between the witness a...
What law enforcement—and the public—needs to know
Lampinen (2016) suggested that proponents of ROC analysis may prefer that approach to the diagnosticity ratio because they are under the impression that it provides a theoretical measure of underlying discriminability (d′). In truth, we and others prefer ROC analysis for applied purposes because it provides an atheoretical measure of empirical disc...
From the perspective of signal detection theory, different lineup instructions may induce different levels of response bias. If so, then collecting correct and false identification rates across different instructional conditions will trace out the receiver operating characteristic (ROC)—the same ROC that, theoretically, could also be traced out fro...
Citations
... ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.01.04.522746 doi: bioRxiv preprint differ for words encoded during these two sessions as a function of word value. As the standard deviation of the raw ratings of studied words was significantly larger than that of lure words (the average ratio across 63 participants was 1.21 (SD = 0.207) and was significantly greater than 1, t(62) = 8.03, p < 0.001), and to take full advantage of our 6-point recognition confidence scale (which provides more information about memory strength than old/new judgments alone, we conducted a receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis using the unequal-variance signal-detection (UVSD) model (Brady et al., 2022;Mickes et al., 2007). This UVSD model yields memory sensitivity values (sometimes denoted as da) that are analogous to standard d' values that could be derived from the hit rates and false alarm rates alone, but are considered a superior measure because their derivation takes into account the entire distribution of confidence judgements to old and new items (Brady et al., 2022). ...
... Previous studies have often used K values to measure VWM capacity (Vogel et al., 2005;Ye et al., 2018), but other indexes (e.g., d ) have recently been suggested as potentially more valid measures of VWM in change detection tasks (Williams, Robinson, Schurgin, Wixted, & Brady, 2022). Therefore, for the VWM performance measurement, we analyzed both the K value and d (i.e., sensitivity), which can reflect the VWM performance of the participants. ...
... Speech (Supplementary Tables F, J) and music (Supplementary Tables G, K) are two classes of sound particularly important in human communication. A small proportion of hippocampal neurons respond selectively to specific spoken words (Urgolites et al., 2022), and in challenging listening conditions the distinctness of candidate word representations in left hippocampus is positively correlated with speech understanding (Blank et al., 2018;Fig. 4G). ...
Reference: The hearing hippocampus
... Moreover, researchers (Hung et al., 2017;Malbec et al., 2022) have argued that small sample sizes could lead to random outcomes and have even recommended a minimal sample size of 150 for correlational analyses (Hung et al., 2017). On the other hand, Wilson et al. (2022) suggested that theory-focused research should aspire to intermediate sample sizes, as too big sample sizes produce false positives, too. ...
... However, while performing the experiment for multiple trials, multiple traces of similar memory sets are formed in episodic memory. Due to effects of pro-and retroactive interference, this can lead to the result that traces of specific memory sets become inaccessible, even when cued with the presentation of the exact same set over and over again (Wixted, 2021(Wixted, , 2022. If the presentation of the repeated memory set cannot cue the retrieval of a previous episodic trace, no strengthening of that trace occurs; neither explicitly nor implicitly -rather, a new episodic-memory trace is created. ...
... Indeed, as Wixted and Wells highlight, in a dramatic and well-known eyewitness misidentification case in which Jennifer Thompson confidently but incorrectly identified Ronald Cotton as the man who raped her (Thompson-Cannino et al., 2010), Thompson's initial identification was indecisive and expressed with low confidence; it was only after receiving confirmatory feedback from police that Thompson expressed her identification with high confidence (see also Wells, 2020). To avoid the corrupting effect on memory of influences such as confirmatory feedback and misleading suggestions, Wixted et al. (2021) have recommended that a witness's memory should be tested only once. Given the possibly widespread impact of this recommendation on real-world cases, the progress made in this line of research is likely to be among the most consequential recent developments in research on memory sins in applied settings. ...
... Research shows that high eyewitness confidence provided immediately after a suspect identification from a fair lineup is indicative of suspect guilt (given the usual procedural safeguards; Wixted & Wells, 2017; for exceptions see Giacona et al., 2021), but memory for the perpetrator then becomes contaminated over time, resulting in high confidence expressed at trial not being indicative of suspect guilt (Wixted et al., 2022). Recent research also shows that potential jurors are not aware of this critical distinction between immediate and courtroom confidence, and will judge suspects as likely guilty when reading about high eyewitness confidence in a trial transcript, regardless of the timing (Key et al., 2022). ...
... The first challenge researchers face when linking performance across tasks, is measuring key hypothetical constructs. Although this is a well-known challenge for social science researchers in general (e.g., Borsboom et al., 2004;Brady et al., 2021;Kellen et al., 2020;Meehl, 1967;Regenwetter & Robinson, 2017;Rotello et al., 2015), it is also a challenge for researchers who study cognitive control in particular, because the dominant measurement approach called the subtraction method is known to suffer from major limitations. These limitations have been discussed in detail by other researchers and will be reviewed later in this article. ...
... Several recent papers have shown that filler similarity affects eyewitness ID performance (Carlson et al., 2019;Colloff, Wilson, Seale-Carlisle, & Wixted, 2021;Fitzgerald et al., 2013Fitzgerald et al., , 2015. Wells et al. (1993) proposed that lineups should contain a degree of propitious heterogeneity, such that fillers and suspect should not be too similar to each other in physical appearance. ...
... Although it is clear that fair lineups should be preferred, it is less clear exactly how many fillers are needed to maintain this advantage over showups. Only a few studies have examined showups in relation to multiple lineup sizes (e.g., Akan, Robinson, Mickes, Wixted, & Benjamin, 2021;Wooten et al., 2020) and so we will build upon this research by comparing showups, threeperson, and six-person lineups. We will not examine larger lineup sizes for two reasons. ...