Jan Schmitz’s research while affiliated with Radboud University and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (23)


Figure 1. Schematic representation of experimental design and process.
Regression results for treatment effects on intention to order and order rate
How sludge impairs the effectiveness of policy programs: a field experiment with SMEs
  • Article
  • Full-text available

November 2024

·

6 Reads

·

1 Citation

Behavioural Public Policy

·

·

Jan Schmitz

Small and medium-sized enterprises constitute the largest share of companies in most economies. As major resource users and significant contributors to environmental pollution, they are relevant targets for public policy programs aimed at increasing sustainability. We study how ‘sludge’ – small frictions in the choice architecture – can impact the uptake and effectiveness of such public policy programs targeted at SMEs. To this end, we conducted a field experiment within an existing policy program designed to support SMEs in implementing cost-effective environmental management practices. We manipulated the process of receiving free green items intended to support the implementation of those environmentally friendly practices within firms. We find that sludge, in the form of minor additional effort required to order the items, substantially undermined the program’s effectiveness. These results have important implications for policymakers: even minor sludge in the choice architecture can seriously impair the effectiveness of public policy programs targeted at companies.

Download





The Effects of Upward and Downward Social Comparisons on Energy Consumption Behavior: Evidence from a Field Study on Air-Conditioning Usage

June 2021

·

42 Reads

This study aims to (1) disentangle the effects of upward and downward social comparisons on individual electricity consumption behavior and (2) figure out how these effects differ across individuals with heterogeneous electricity consumption. A field study on air-conditioning usage behavior of residents was conducted in a university dormitory. The dormitory residents were randomly allocated to the upward comparison and downward comparison treatment groups and the control group. Those in the treatment groups received weekly feedback about their own electricity consumption for air-conditioning and a distribution of all residents’ consumption, while those in the control group received no feedback. The feedback to the upward comparison (downward comparison) treatment group framed comparisons as upward (downward) by highlighting the proportion of residents who behaved in a more (less) desirable way, i.e., consumed less (more) electricity for air-conditioning than the feedback recipient. The results are twofold: (1) there were no statistically significant consumption differences between any of the treatment groups and the control group and (2) significantly lowered consumption was observed only among the subgroup of the upward comparison group residents whose electricity consumption for air-conditioning was in the lowest 20th percentile. Hence, the feedback had significant effects on certain subgroups of the residents, but no overall effect.


Fig. 3 All subjects: share of endowment contributed to the global public good over time. Notes: Share of endowment contributed to the global public good by all subjects over time. Red line: contributions in the Equal Endowment treatment. Blue line: contributions in the CR treatment. Green line: contribution in the TRR treatment. Panel 1: share of endowment contributed in part 1. Panel 2: share of endowment contributed in part 2. Panel 3: share of endowment contributed in part 3
Table 18 (continued)
Linear regressions: CR and TRR treatment-high and low endowment subjects
Inequality, role reversal and cooperation in multiple group membership settings

March 2021

·

84 Reads

·

11 Citations

Experimental Economics

We investigate the role of endowment inequality in a local and global public goods setting with multiple group membership and examine the effect of temporal role reversal on cooperation decisions. Subjects can contribute to a global public good which benefits all subjects and two local public goods which benefit only subjects of either their own group or the group of the other endowment type. Endowment inequality per-se decreases contributions of subjects with a high endowment to the global public good, but increases cooperation of subjects with a low endowment on their local public good, thereby aggravating income disparities. Exogenously induced role reversal for several periods affects cooperation behavior of subjects with a high endowment positively and induces them to contribute more to the global good. Cooperation in unequal environments thus appears to be more stable when all parties have experienced the public goods game from the disadvantageous perspective. Supplementary information: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s10683-021-09705-y.




The Hidden Benefits of Corporate Social Responsibility

December 2020

·

724 Reads

Environmental activities, for instance actions against climate change, are an important part of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR). This paper studies how an employer's environmental CSR activities affect the pro-environmental behavior of its employees. To do so, we conducted a large-scale field experiment on a crowd-working platform in which the employer's environmental CSR level varied exogenously. We find that employer CSR positively influenced workers' pro-environmental behavior outside the job. Workers who received information that their employer engaged in environmental CSR were more likely to contribute, and contributed higher amounts, to an environmental charity in a private donation decision. Our findings indicate that the impact of CSR may be farther reaching than directly observable by firm activities alone. By using CSR, employers have the potential to influence the behavior of their employees in non-work domains. Our findings have important implications for managers of organizations engaging (or planning to engage) in environmental CSR.


Citations (13)


... Lucerne and Zug are small to mediumsized cities, where SMEs play an important role in the local economy. 3 The consulting consists of a standardized procedure covering four areas (mobility, materials, information and quality, energy and buildings) and is designed to provide a short check-up of an SME's potential to improve its environmental management, and thus to decrease its resource use and increase its environmental sustainability (see also Grieder et al., 2023). This standardized consulting takes around one hour of time during which a consultant is on-site at the consulted SME. ...

Reference:

Not Only for the Money: Nudging SMEs to Promote Environmental Sustainability
How sludge impairs the effectiveness of policy programs: a field experiment with SMEs

Behavioural Public Policy

... implementing environmentally-friendly business practices are often outweighed by the cost. In line with this view, Grieder et al. (2022) find that SMEs' participation in an environmental consulting program is not driven by the potential financial benefits of implementing environmentally-friendly business practices. Instead, especially for smaller firms in the SME spectrum, the motivations and values of managers or owners seem to be crucial companyinternal drivers of the implementation of environmentally-friendly business practices (see also Schrader, 2015, Wickert et al., 2016). ...

Not Only for the Money: Nudging SMEs to Promote Environmental Sustainability
  • Citing Article
  • January 2023

SSRN Electronic Journal

... Simplification of processes to apply for and access programs can help. Grieder et al. (2022) find that small and medium enterprises (SMEs) are more likely to adopt energy-efficiency measures when the benefits of doing so are simplified. As above, simplification could be an individual-level approach such as clearer recycling instructions. ...

How Sludge Impairs the Effectiveness of Policy Programs: A Field Experiment with SMEs

SSRN Electronic Journal

... The second donation is smaller and this decrease is even stronger if both decisions happen within a day instead of having an extended period of one week between the two decisions. Grieder et al. (2021) also document donation behavior in line with moral licensing in two subsequent decisions. However, from an aggregate perspective, additional asks still increase total donations. ...

Asking to Give: Moral Licensing and Pro-Social Behavior in the Aggregate
  • Citing Article
  • January 2021

SSRN Electronic Journal

... Yet, the MLPGG's group structure proves to be well-suited for examining the behavioral consequences not only of vertical but also horizontal inequality. To the best of our knowledge, only Lange, Schmitz, and Schwirplies (2022) addressed horizontal inequality by studying how differences in the initial endowment affect participants' contributions in a MLPGG. Their results suggest that inequality arising from the arbitrary allocation of different initial endowments (i) reduces contributions to the global good from individuals with a high endowment and (ii) enhances cooperation among individuals with a low endowment for their local good. ...

Inequality, role reversal and cooperation in multiple group membership settings

Experimental Economics

... There is a conventional wisdom that people are rational decision-makers, and their choices reflect their underlying values and preferences (Ellsberg 1961); however, there is evidence to suggest that individuals may 'reverse' their preferences depending on alternative descriptions of a problem (Tversky and Kahneman 1981;Shafir 1993;Ledgerwood and Boydstun 2014). This is usually called framing effect, which is at the centre of the debate challenging the significance of rationality principles in decisionmaking (Druckman 2001;Grieder, Kistler, and Schmitz 2020;LeBoeuf and Shafir 2003;Levin, Schneider, and Gaeth 1998). Previous research has used prospect theory to explain how different frames (i.e. ...

Environmental Decision Making in Small Companies: A Behavioral Economics Perspective
  • Citing Chapter
  • December 2020

... Another study found a combination of consistent descriptive and injunctive information on individuals' energy usage to be effective in changing energy usage (Bonan et al., 2020). These messaging tactics are found to be useful for individuals whose energy usage is furthest from the norm, as they are motivated to change to adhere to the consumption standard of their communities (Bonan et al., 2020;Brülisauer et al., 2020). ...

Appliance-specific feedback and social comparisons: Evidence from a field experiment on energy conservation
  • Citing Article
  • October 2020

Energy Policy

... This was supported by a study from the United Nations Economic and Social Communication for Asia and the Pacific (UNESCAP) that examined the rationale for the implementation of the environmental tax in the Asia-Pacific region in achieving Sustainability Development Goals (SDG) (UN, 2017). Many countries, for example the United States of America (UN, 2017), Switzerland (Grieder et al., 2021) and Ireland (Bruin & Yakut, 2018), have successfully changed human behaviour, reduced climate change issues and increased government revenue through an environmental tax policy, particularly from carbon tax. ...

The Behavioral Effects of Carbon Taxes – Experimental Evidence
  • Citing Article
  • January 2020

SSRN Electronic Journal

... Framing interventions may utilize social comparison, goal setting, or commitment and are often evaluated in conjunction with the impact of social norms and norm-based strategies on long-term behavior. Hence, this type of interventions also depends on the individuals' perception on and adherence to norms (Xu et al., 2015;Ghesla et al., 2020;Kacperski et al., 2023;Mäkivierikko et al., 2023;Syropoulos et al., 2023). ...

Pro-environmental incentives and loss aversion: A field experiment on electricity saving behavior
  • Citing Article
  • November 2019

Energy Policy

... Switching individuals' default settings refers to making the "green option" the default choice instead of conventional options, thus creating an anchoring effect. In turn, this is reinforced by consumers' tendency to rely on heuristics, forcing them to consider whether to opt out of the green option rather than join it (Ghesla et al., 2019). In addition, as the default option is reconstructed, framing new information from a loss perspective can further stimulate consumers' loss aversion psychology and promote the target behaviors advocated by low-carbon policies (Kahneman et al., 1991). ...

Nudge for Good? Choice Defaults and Spillover Effects