January 2025
·
8 Reads
Journal of Lifestyle and SDGs Review
Objectives: This study examines the legal framework governing the use of state land by cultivators in urban areas and proposes reforms that align with justice. It addresses the legal uncertainty and inequality faced by cultivators who occupy state land without formal land rights. Theoretical Framework: Grounded in the theory of agrarian justice, the study critiques capitalist ideology embedded in the current land laws, particularly the Job Creation Law, which prioritizes developers over cultivators. It advocates for fair access to land resources for marginalized groups. Method: A normative legal approach is employed, analyzing laws and regulations on state land cultivation. Case studies in urban areas, such as Jakarta, where legal conflicts over land rights are prevalent, provide insights into the effects of these laws. Results and Discussion: The study finds significant legal gaps that perpetuate injustice. Cultivators, who have used state land for decades, are denied land rights under the Job Creation Law, which favors business developers. Regional regulations, such as Jakarta’s Governor’s Decree, further hinder cultivators’ access to land certificates, necessitating legal reform for a more just system. Research Implications: Legal reform is essential to grant cultivators fair access to land rights, balancing development with social equity. Urban agrarian reform policies should prioritize justice for cultivators. Originality/Value: This research highlights the tension between capitalist development and social justice, offering a legal reform proposal to resolve conflicts over land rights in Indonesia's urban areas.