Dimiter Toshkov’s research while affiliated with Leiden University and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (59)


The political effects of intra-EU migration: Evidence from national and European elections in seven countries
  • Article

September 2024

·

27 Reads

European Union Politics

Dimiter Toshkov

This article studies the impact of immigration from Central and Eastern Europe on support for Eurosceptic parties. The analysis covers 30 national and European Parliament elections in seven Western, Northern and Southern European countries (2004 to 2019). For each election, I analyse how the local-level share of the vote for right- and left-wing Eurosceptic parties varies as a function of the levels and changes in the local-level share of Central and Eastern European immigrants from the population, controlling for the influence of relevant demographic, social and economic variables. I find that higher levels of immigration from Central and Eastern Europe are systematically related to higher voting shares cast for right-wing Eurosceptic parties at the local level in all of these countries, net of the influence of non-Western immigration, in elections for the European Parliament and in national elections as well. The effects on left-wing Euroscepticism are heterogeneous: positive in the Netherlands, Austria and Portugal, but negative in Italy, Denmark and Sweden. The effects have not diminished significantly over the past 15 years and are most visible in mid-sized localities.


When Should Governments Listen to Social Protests? The Effects of Public Support and Outcome Favorability

May 2024

·

13 Reads

Governments often face social protests contesting their policies and reform plans. In liberal democracies, governments are expected to listen to and consider the demands of the protesters. But in reality, there is often a trade-off between accommodating protesters and enacting timely and effective policies. We study the preferences of citizens for government actions in the context of significant social protests – from canceling and delaying the policies to pushing through with the reforms ignoring protesters to banning protests altogether. To do that, we conduct a survey experiment in the Netherlands in which we manipulate the level of government enacting reforms contested by social protests and whether the reforms are supported or opposed by a majority of the citizens. We also measure whether respondents agree with the substance of the reforms and their trust in government. The results indicate that people are more likely to support governments pushing through with reforms and ignoring social protests when the reforms enjoy majority support and respondents agree with the direction of the reform proposal. Trust in government has a similar effect, but the level of government does not matter. There is very little support for banning protests altogether, and none of the factors we consider predict this attitude. These findings suggest that – even in well-established democracies – citizens’ views on whether governments should listen to, rather than ignore, social protests are contingent on the policy content of the contested government reforms and the existence of majority support for such reforms in society; hence, on a mixture of instrumental and principled reasons, with the principle reflecting a majoritarian view of democracy.


Public Policy Attitudes and Political Polarization in the Netherlands

May 2024

·

11 Reads

While the increasing relevance of political polarization for the well-established multi-party democracies of Western Europe is recognized, we still know relatively little about how the different dimensions of polarization interact in this setting. We focus on the question whether policy attitudes contribute to affective polarization beyond the effects of ideological positions, partisanship and perceptions of polarization levels. To study this question, we run a comprehensive survey of public policy attitudes and political polarization on a quota-representative sample of public opinion in South Holland in the Netherlands. The results provide strong evidence that people having divergent policy preferences are much more likely to show affective polarization towards parties and voters, on top of what ideology and party affiliation predict. Conversely, policy priority incongruence does not have the hypothesized association. While, on average, levels of affective polarization in the Netherlands are relatively low, perceptions of big and increasing polarization are widely shared and significantly associated with affect.


Correction: Information battleground: Conflict perceptions motivate the belief in and sharing of misinformation about the adversary
  • Article
  • Full-text available

April 2024

·

43 Reads

·

1 Citation

Honorata Mazepus

·

Mathias Osmundsen

·

·

[...]

·

[This corrects the article DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0282308.].

Download




Framing international cooperation: citizen support for cooperation with the European Union in Eastern Europe

June 2023

·

35 Reads

·

1 Citation

Comparative European Politics

While there is a large literature studying the determinants of public support for European integration, we know much less about the factors shaping attitudes towards various international cooperation initiatives. In this article, we study the possible influence of framing, a mechanism linking pre-existing values and causal beliefs, on preferences for cooperation with the EU. We develop six thematic frames related to the context of international cooperation: economic benefits, security, shared identity, traditional and liberal values, and rules and norms of governance. We test the effects of these frames using a survey experiment conducted in three countries in Eastern Europe—Belarus, Moldova and Ukraine—that are targeted by the integration projects of both the EU and Russia. We find that thematic framing has only small effects on international cooperation preferences: priming liberal values and governance increases slightly support for cooperation with the EU, but the effects of the remaining frames are too small and heterogeneous to be estimated precisely with our sample. Contrary to expectations, some of these effects are exercised by changing the relevant causal beliefs of citizens, even if the thematic frames were not designed to do so.


Explaining the gender gap in COVID-19 vaccination attitudes

May 2023

·

38 Reads

·

30 Citations

The European Journal of Public Health

Background Women have been significantly more likely than men to express hesitancy toward COVID-19 vaccination and, to a lesser extent, to refuse vaccination altogether. This gender gap is puzzling because women have been more likely to perceive higher risks from COVID-19, to approve more restrictive measures to fight the pandemic and to be more compliant with such measures. Methods This article studies the gender gap in COVID-19 vaccination attitudes using two nationally representative surveys of public opinion fielded in February 2021 and May 2021 in 27 European countries. The data are analyzed using generalized additive models and multivariate logistic regression. Results The data analyses show that hypotheses about (i) pregnancy, fertility and breastfeeding concerns, (ii) higher trust in Internet and social networks as sources of medical information, (iii) lower trust in health authorities and (iv) lower perceived risks of getting infected with COVID-19 cannot account for the gender gap in vaccine hesitancy. One explanation that receives support from the data is that women are more likely to believe that COVID-19 vaccines are unsafe and ineffective and this leads them to perceive the net benefits of vaccination as lower than the associated risks. Conclusions The gender gap in COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy results to a large extent from women perceiving higher risks than benefits of the vaccines. While accounting for this and other factors decreases the gap in vaccine hesitancy, it does not eliminate it completely, which suggests further research is needed.


Fig. 2. Relationship between vaccine hesitancy and vaccination rates in 27 member states of the European Union (ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 country codes). Attitude data: Flash Eurobarometer 494, May 2021. Vaccination data: Our World in Data, as of 19 September 2021.
Fig. 5. Non-linear effects of age (top row) and education (bottom row) on vaccine refusal (left column) and vaccine hesitancy (right column) in each of three regions of Europe. Semi-parametric smooth estimates of the effects based on generalized additive models (GAM). Dotted lines indicate the boundaries of the 95% confidence intervals.
Fig. 7. Odds ratios (exponentiated coefficients) of demographic variables and COVID-19-related beliefs and experiences on vaccine hesitancy in three regions of the Europe (Eastern in red, Western in blue, Southern in black, with 50% and 95% confidence intervals. Models estimated separately for each region. For statistical tests of the cross-region differences, see Model A1 in Table S4 in the Supplementary material. Age and Education have been mean-centered and scaled by 1 s.d. (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.)
What Accounts for the Variation in COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy in Eastern, Southern and Western Europe?

April 2023

·

46 Reads

·

20 Citations

Vaccine

In the wake of mass COVID-19 vaccination campaigns in 2021, significant differences in vaccine skepticism emerged across Europe, with Eastern European countries in particular facing very high levels of vaccine hesitancy and refusal. This study investigates the determinants of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy and refusal, with a focus on these differences across Eastern, Southern and Western Europe. The statistical analyses are based on individual-level survey data comprising quota-based representative samples from 27 European countries from May 2021. The study finds that demographic variables have complex associations with vaccine hesitancy and refusal. The relationships with age and education are non-linear. Trust in different sources of health-related information has significant associations as well, with people who trust the Internet, social networks and 'people around' in particular being much more likely to express vaccine skepticism. Beliefs in the safety and effectiveness of vaccines have large predictive power. Importantly, this study shows that the associations of demographic, belief-related and other individual-level factors with vaccine hesitancy and refusal are context-specific. Yet, explanations of the differences in vaccine hesitancy across Eastern, Southern and Eastern Europe need to focus on why levels of trust and vaccine-relevant beliefs differ across regions, because the effects of these variables appear to be similar. It is the much higher prevalence of factors such as distrust of national governments and medical processionals as sources of relevant medical information in Eastern Europe that are relevant for explaining the higher levels of vaccine skepticism observed in that region.


Citations (41)


... On February 24 th , Russia officially launched its "special military operation" against Ukraine. Subsequently, a large amount of biased and partisan news has been shared online (YarAdua et al. 2022;Osmundsen et al. 2022) , making this an interesting case study. Recent works on Reddit have shed light on the important role of partisan news sharing in analyzing the propagation of political narratives (Hanley, Kumar, and Durumeric 2022) and troll accounts (Saeed et al. 2022). ...

Reference:

A Study of Partisan News Sharing in the Russian Invasion of Ukraine
Correction: Information battleground: Conflict perceptions motivate the belief in and sharing of misinformation about the adversary

... In particular, where courts frequently become the target of recalcitrant leaders, public awareness is more likely to be positively and strongly associated with perceptions of executive influence, despite the inclusion of other well-known correlates of citizens' awareness of courts. In contrast, in environments where interbranch dynamics are more hospitable to courts, 14 For additional insight into the Polish and Hungarian publics' reaction to the EU's enforcement actions and the rule of law crises in these countries, see Stiansen et al. (2024), Cheruvu, Krehbiel, and Mussell (2024), and Toshkov et al. (2024). 15 Subsequent scholarship by Gibson and his coauthors would further suggest this support differential was due to the increased exposures to legitimizing symbols (such as gavels, robes, and distinctive judicial procedures), wherein political sophisticates internalize the ways in which courts are unique, apolitical, and apart from the normal rough and tumble of the standard partisan political process (Gibson and Caldeira 2009b;Gibson, Lodge, and Woodson 2014). ...

Enforcement and public opinion: the perceived legitimacy of rule of law sanctions
  • Citing Article
  • March 2024

... Second, for a long time, popular econometric methods of research on the anti-crisis role of fiscal federalism in crisis periods suddenly began to lose their popularity and practically disappeared from the most cited publications. They give way to methods of comparative and descriptive nature, more understandable to the general public, which both increases the accessibility of scientific recommendations and gives them declarative and insufficient validity in an acute crisis moment (Carroll et al., 2023). ...

Multilevel governance and responses to the COVID-19 pandemic: a systematic literature review
  • Citing Article
  • December 2023

Regional & Federal Studies

... Studies have shown that, on average, females are more risk-averse than males (Byrnes et al., 1999;Harris and Jenkins, 2006). This tendency extends to vaccination decisions, with women being more hesitant compared to their male counterparts (Bish et al., 2011;Morillon and Poder, 2022;Toshkov, 2023). In the context of COVID-19, only one study reported opposite findings (Lazarus et al., 2021). ...

Explaining the gender gap in COVID-19 vaccination attitudes

The European Journal of Public Health

... Among EU member countries, vaccine refusals and hesitancy are highest among former communist countries of Central and Eastern Europe. 2 Yet, vaccine uptake among non-EU member countries of the WHO European region is even lower (Table 1). There are many factors that contribute to vaccine hesitancy. ...

What Accounts for the Variation in COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy in Eastern, Southern and Western Europe?

Vaccine

... Perceptions of Conflict Between EU and Ukraine. To assess this construct, we used one adapted item from previous works (Mazepus et al., 2023): "The European Union and Ukraine have very different interests; what is good for The European Union, is bad for Ukraine". This item was measured on a 5-point Likert scale, where 1 represents "strongly disagree", and 5 represents "strongly agree". ...

Information battleground: Conflict perceptions motivate the belief in and sharing of misinformation about the adversary

... On the other hand, countries considered to have "unbalanced openness," like Moldova (2005)(2006)(2007)(2008) and Georgia (2004Georgia ( -2007, have to a greater extent co-opted EU norms on free and fair elections but have resisted opening up the access to their economic resources to a wider public, since "political winners make sure that their office helps them to weaken competitors for economic rent-seeking" (Ademmer, Langbein, and Börzel 2018). Limited Access Order regimes also limit their science and scientific cooperation with the European Union (Toshkov et al. 2019). ...

Effects of Limited Access Orders on Science Policy and Scientific Cooperation

... Second, we not only apply the winner-loser gap model to an outcome not previously considered by the literature, but even more importantly, to an outcome that is not, properly speaking, a political variable. This entails arguing and empirically showing, in conjunction with some recent work like Toshkov & Mazepus (2022), that electoral processes can influence beyond the political domain and reach important nonpolitical dimensions of social life. Third, and contrary to most previous research that employs cross-sectional data, we follow some recent efforts (Marien & Kern, 2018;van der Eijk & Rose, 2021) and employ pre-post electoral survey panel data and appropriate statistical techniques that strengthen causal inference. ...

Does the Election Winner–Loser Gap Extend to Subjective Health and Well-Being?
  • Citing Article
  • October 2022

Political Studies Review

... Voters are confronted not only with the European integration issue, but with many other issues, thus voting in a multidimensional policy space. This has also been brought forward by Toshkov and Krouwel (2022); the European integration issue cannot be regarded as bundled with other cultural issues, so it should be examined how it relates to other issue dimensions. ...

Beyond the U-curve: Citizen preferences on European integration in multidimensional political space
  • Citing Article
  • February 2022

European Union Politics

... Despite the measurement differences, comparative studies corroborate the general finding that ideological congruence affects evaluations of the judiciary. Several studies examine how a person's ideological congruence with an incumbent ruler affect beliefs in courts' ability to serve as a check on the incumbent; these studies suggest that support for robust separation of powers is contingent on an individual's alignment with the office-holder (Singer 2018;Bartels and Kramon 2020;Mazepus and Toshkov 2022;Magalhães and Garoupa 2023;Böhringer and Boucher 2024;Driscoll, Aydin-Çakır, and Schorpp 2024;Gandur 2024). Similar findings are observed in studies of international courts: in backsliding democracies, support for international tribunals is strongly influenced by whether individuals ideologically align with the incumbents constrained by such tribunals (Cheruvu, Krehbiel, and Mussell 2024). ...

Standing up for Democracy? Explaining Citizens’ Support for Democratic Checks and Balances

Comparative Political Studies