David S. Siroky's research while affiliated with University of Essex and other places

Publications (59)

Article
As an embedded sociocultural code, blood revenge is present in many societies where civil wars occur. Whereas evidence from other social sciences attests to its enduring global significance, security studies scholarship has largely neglected the custom of blood revenge. This article is the first to investigate its relevance for understanding the in...
Preprint
Full-text available
We have read with interest the latest version of Kapoor and Narayanan (KN, 2022), after having responded to an earlier draft that they shared with us in 2021. We are pleased that our research has generated widespread interest across disciplinary boundaries. We believe there is a lot that both Computer Science and Political Science can gain from mut...
Article
Full-text available
Why do states engage in irredentism? Expanding on previous scholarship, this article advances a new theory with rationalist microfoundations that accounts for the incentives of both elites and citizens to support irredentism in democracies and dictatorships. Our model suggests irredentism is more likely when it enables political elites to provide a...
Article
Drawing on original interviews with ex-insurgents and eyewitnesses of the Second Chechen War (1999–2009), this article develops a theory of “kin killing,” defined as the use of lethal violence against insurgents’ relatives as a deliberate counterinsurgency tactic. Family-based targeting works by coercing insurgents to surrender or defect, deterring...
Book
How can researchers obtain reliable responses on sensitive issues in dangerous settings? This Element elucidates ways for researchers to use unobtrusive experimental methods to elicit answers to risky, taboo, and threatening questions in dangerous social environments. The methods discussed in this Element help social scientists to encourage respond...
Preprint
Full-text available
Drawing on original interviews with ex-insurgents and eyewitnesses of the Second Chechen War (1999-2009), this article develops a theory of “kin killing,” defined as the use of lethal violence against the relatives of insurgents as a deliberate counterinsurgency tactic. Family-based targeting works by coercing insurgents to surrender or defect, det...
Article
Full-text available
This forum provides an outlet for an assessment of research on the delegation of war to non-state armed groups in civil wars. Given the significant growth of studies concerned with this phenomenon over the last decade, this forum critically engages with the present state of the field. First, we canvass some of the most important theoretical develop...
Chapter
Full-text available
Secession and secessionists movements have proliferated since the end of the Second World War. The academic literature has extensively explored these movements from different aspects. To begin, scholars have developed several legal approaches to explain when and if so how secession should take place, resulting in debates about the normative basis a...
Article
Full-text available
Islamic law denotes as haram any forbidden behavior, object, beverage, or food. Despite subscribing to a similar Salafi ideology, very few jihadi groups use violence against haram targets (e.g., brothels, casinos, statues, liquor stores, mixed sex schools, and gay clubs). This study argues that haram-centered violence unites ethnically-mixed jihadi...
Article
Full-text available
Most studies of technocratic populism have focused on democracies under stress (e.g., Italy, Czech Republic). This article builds on and extends these studies by analyzing a hybrid regime—post-Soviet Georgia—and argues that technocratic populism in this context is utilized as a façade to cover authoritarian and oligarchic tendencies, while suspendi...
Article
Recognition of aspiring states from established countries is central to becoming a member state of the international system. Previous research suggests that great power recognition decisions regarding aspiring states rapidly converge toward either recognition or non-recognition, yet great power convergence has still not occurred in the case of Koso...
Article
Full-text available
Central governments in multinational states frequently deploy indirect rule to contain peripheral nationalism. Through the exchange of economic resources for political control, local notables are co-opted into cementing loyalty to the central state. Although nationalism often has cultural roots, these can fail to bear fruit because indirect rulers...
Article
How do countries decide whether or not to recognize an aspiring state? We examine such decisions in the context of contested recognition, which we define as a claim to statehood that is recognized by a large number of countries, but remains unrecognized by many others. We suggest that religion—both at the domestic level via religious regulation and...
Article
Social science answers to the essential question of group conflict have focused on two main explanations—their motivating “grievances” and their mobilization “capacity” for collective action. Recent years have seen a renewed focus on grievances in the form of horizontal inequalities (between-group inequality), but the important conceptual and poten...
Article
Full-text available
When do parties respond to their political rivals and when do they ignore them? This article presents a new computational framework to detect, analyze and predict partisan responsiveness by showing when parties on opposite poles of the political spectrum react to each other’s agendas and thereby contribute to polarization. Once spikes in responsive...
Article
Unlike structural realism, neoclassical realism focuses on how the interaction between systemic and unit-level variables influences foreign policy. This article assesses neoclassical realism against two alternative accounts – balance of threat and economic dependence – to explain change in Georgia's foreign policy. While structural realism highligh...
Article
Full-text available
Many scholars have suggested that organized violence in Chechnya has ended, and that Russia’s Chechenization policy and Ramzan Kadyrov’s presidency deserve the credit. We suggest that Putin has created a Frankenstein-like ruler over whom he risks losing control. As a result, the conflict only appears resolved, and we draw attention to both vertical...
Article
Full-text available
Seeing the Forest through the Trees - Volume 27 Issue 1 - David Alan Muchlinski, David Siroky, Jingrui He, Matthew Adam Kocher
Article
Full-text available
Foreign policy alliance formation among small states in the aggregate has been extensively examined in the literature, but mass opinion and preferences on alliance formation in these states remains understudied. To address this gap, this article examines individual alliance preferences in two small states in the South Caucasus region: Georgia and A...
Article
Full-text available
While the efforts of great powers to export their regimes to small states is well studied in the literature, the role of mass opinion in small states where great powers compete for influence remains under-theorized as a factor that can shape small state preferences over foreign alliances and policies. This paper investigates the causes of individua...
Article
Although many countries have ethnic kin on the “wrong side” of their borders, few seek to annex foreign territories on the basis of ethnicity. This article examines why some states pursue irredentism, whereas others exhibit restraint. It focuses on the triadic structure of the kin group in the irredentist state, its coethnic enclave, and the host s...
Article
This paper introduces the key concepts used in this special issue – center, periphery, and vertical bargaining – and inquires why some national groups within democratic states demand outright independence, while others mobilize for regional autonomy and still others settle for even less. It then specifies a theoretical framework that tries to expla...
Article
Does a state's use of indiscriminate violence incite insurgent attacks? The conventional wisdom suggests that it does—Stathis Kalyvas cites dozens of studies and historical cases where collective targeting of the noncombatant population provoked greater insurgent violence. But others have pushed back against this claim. These scholars have made sig...
Article
Recognition from other recognized states is the key to becoming a fully-fledged member state of the international system. Although many new states are quickly and universally recognized, the recognition of other aspiring states remains highly contested. In these cases of contested sovereignty, some countries but not others extend recognition. Howev...
Article
Many scholars have argued that orthodox Muslims harbor attitudes that are more economically communitarian and politically illiberal, since individuals are seen as embedded within a larger community that places a premium on social order. Yet most studies have ignored the potential of Islam as an ideological platform for political reformers. Religion...
Article
Why are some countries prone to ethno-nationalist conflict, whereas others are plagued by class conflict? This is a question that has seldom been raised and rarely been examined empirically. This paper presents a social-structural theory to account for the variable incidence of these two forms of political instability. These two types of conflict r...
Article
Full-text available
The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) is widely regarded as the most important human rights court worldwide. This article investigates the extent to which the court addresses cases from countries with the worst human rights performance. Using a new data set on all ECtHR judgments from 1995–2012, the analysis suggests that the ECtHR does not de...
Article
Nationalism is one of the most powerful forces in the modern world – but why some ethno-national groups mobilize for conflict, while others remain quiescent, remains subject to significant disagreement. This paper argues that domestic politics create the incentives for secession, and international forces make conflict feasible against a sometimes s...
Article
The study of secession generally stresses the causal influence of cultural identities, political preferences, or ecological factors. Whereas these different views are often considered to be mutually exclusive, this paper proposes a two-stage model in which they are complementary. We posit that cultural identities matter for explaining secessionism,...
Article
Full-text available
In multinational states, developing a strong sense of civic nationalism among minorities is critical to creating social order. Countries that fail to cultivate civic nationalism among minorities can face persistent problems of separatism on the periphery. This article investigates the role of three factors that may explain the variable loyalty of i...
Article
Full-text available
The most commonly used statistical models of civil war onset fail to correctly predict most occurrences of this rare event in out-of-sample data. Statistical methods for the analysis of binary data, such as logistic regression, even in their rare event and regularized forms, perform poorly at prediction. We compare the performance of Random Forests...
Article
Objective The literature on indiscriminate violence has emphasized how information shapes state capacity and determines whether and where the government employs collective targeting. This article investigates the conditions that influence the government's ability to obtain intelligence in counterinsurgencies. Specifically, it suggests that the gove...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Internet and social media created a public space for online debate on political and social issues. A debate is defined as a formal discussion on a set of related issues in which opposing perspectives and arguments are put forward. In this paper, we aim to develop automated perspective discovery techniques which would contribute to the understanding...
Article
How do states decide to extend or withhold international recognition in cases of contested sovereignty? We focus on how religion shapes the incentives of states in making this decision, both at the domestic level through religious institutions and at the international level through religious affinities. States with transnational religious ties to t...
Article
Case studies suggest that ethnic groups with autonomous institutional arrangements are more prone to secede, but other evidence indicates that autonomy reduces the likelihood of secession. To address this debate, we disaggregate their autonomy status into three categoriescurrently autonomous, never autonomous, and lost autonomyand then unpack how e...
Article
Full-text available
This article analyzes Rousseau’s political theory of private property, fills a lacuna in the literature, and develops a novel interpretation of Rousseau’s apparently contradictory remarks. Although Rousseau was critical of private property, he did not advocate a clear and easy solution to the problems he discerned. Instead, he put forth a highly di...
Article
While some groups work hard to foster collaborative ties with civilians, others engage in egregious abuses and war crimes. We argue that foreign state funding for rebel organizations greatly reduces the incentives of militant groups to the ‘win the hearts and minds’ of civilians because it diminishes the need to collect resources from the populatio...
Article
Indirect rule is one of the means that central authorities have long employed in hopes of defusing communal conflict and civil war in multicultural societies. Yet very little is known about the appeal of indirect rule among the ruled themselves. Why do people in some places demand more indirect rule and local autonomy, whereas others seem content t...
Article
Full-text available
What explains change and continuity in the foreign policy behavior of small states? Given the proliferation of small states over the past century, this topic has received relatively little systematic attention. When researchers do focus on small states, the emphasis has been on external and international factors, and the primary conclusion has been...
Article
When military alliances are expensive, they naturally raise distributional issues. This article considers two theories to explain how much a state will voluntarily contribute to the economic burdens of defense. Empirical work has relied largely on data from the twentieth century. This article provides an out-of-sample test to evaluate the models. U...
Article
Siroky, David S. (2012) Dissecting Political Violence. International Studies Review, doi: 10.1111/j.1468‐2486.2012.01119.x
Article
Although the 2008 Russian-Georgian war was a military defeat for Georgia, it has only reinforced Georgia's westward trajectory. One noteworthy difference from Georgia's pre-war policy is a new regional strategy – the North Caucasus Initiative – that seeks to create a soft power alternative to Russia's military dominance in the region. We suggest th...
Article
Full-text available
Georgia is the most democratic country in the Caucasus, but arguably its democratization has also been riddled by Huntingtonian developmental crises, resulting in ethnic conflicts and civil wars. We argue that variation in the type of political instability is best understood by focusing on the interaction between nationalism and political instituti...
Article
Why do some secessions produce peace and order, while others lead to violence and instability? Related, why does conflict emerge in some regions and not in others? This essay challenges five prominent explanations and advances an alternative theory. The core argument rests upon a curvilinear conceptualization of ethno-territorial heterogeneity and em...
Article
This article addresses current methodological research on non-parametric Random Forests. It provides a brief intellectual history of Ran-dom Forests that covers CART, boosting and bagging methods. It then introduces the primary methods by which researchers can visualize results, the relationships between covariates and responses, and the out-of-bag...
Article
This paper presents the basic logic of ensemble learning, a special kind of machine learning, and suggests several potentially valuable uses for political scientists. A number of applications to relevant debates in comparative politics and international relations are considered empirically. The paper also offers some guidelines for using ensemble l...

Citations

... Witnessing human rights violations by state agents can alter the political preferences and voting choices of bystanders in post-transition countries and thus reduce the risk of (re-)autocratization. Second, the paper contributes to a burgeoning literature on the short-and longterm attitudinal effects of exposure to political violence and repression (Bauer et al., 2016;Davenport et al., 2019;Walden & Zhukov, 2020). Most of this research has focused on the effects of violence committed by outgroup members, such as civilians' victimization at the hands of rebel groups or minorities' experiences of state repression (Lyall et al., 2013;Siroky et al., 2022). We show how atrocities committed against an outgroup can shift the political preferences of ingroup members. ...
... Among others, this concerns the principal-agent and proxy warfare frameworks (see, e.g. Ahram, 2011;Bar-Siman-Tov, 1984;Karlén et al., 2021;Mumford, 2013;Rauta, 2021aRauta, , 2021bSalehyan, 2009;Salehyan et al., 2014). They are relatively interrelated with the patron-client concept, and, as such, they are likely to provide additional valuable insights. ...
... Other scholars seem to agree. For instance, Siroky et al (2022) find that "haram" (locations where certain behaviors are interpreted as being forbidden by Islam) targeting is a mechanism for overcoming collective action problems among mixed-ethnicity Salafists, while enhancing internal cohesion on the basis of the religion as a superordinate guiding force. This is supported by Braun and Genkin's (2014) finding that collectivist culture reduces the cost of suicide bombing. ...
... To be sure, social science work on slowmotion variables in world politics is not as rooted in rigorous science as structural engineering. But it offers grounds for optimism that experts could do something analogous: (a) identify chronic riskamplifiers and attenuators for nuclear proliferation (Bas & Coe, 2016;Bell, 2015;Carless et al., 2021;Cimbala, 2017;Kaplow & Gartzke, 2016;Solingen, 2007Solingen, , 2018, secession (Black, 2004;Levinson, 2017;Siroky & Abbasov, 2021) and interstate border disputes (Carter & Poast, 2016;Goemans & Schultz, 2016;Huth, 1996); (b) synthesize evidence into causal-propensity assessments for the initial 5 years and convert those assessments into probability judgments on a bounded 0-1.0 scale; (c) adjust their initial probability judgments as time widens to 10 and 25 years; (d) average individual forecasts into composites to further enhance accuracy. ...
... Other factors that can influence states' behaviour regarding their decision to recognize are related to the hierarchy mentioned above and competition among Great Powers. In their study on Kosovo, Siroky et al (2021) found that military and economic ties (arms sales and investments) from the US and Russia were good predictors of recognition (or non-recognition). ...
... Ivanishvili initially become Prime Minister and, though he resigned in 2013, he has remained the dominant force in Georgian politics running the country like a CEO by placing former employees from his companies into key state offices, including three out of four of the Prime Ministers who followed him, all without Ivanishvili holding a formal political role. 89 The result is a parallel informal structure, with high-ranking officials responsible to Ivanishvili and his inner circle rather than to formal institutions. 90 ...
... Here, there is room for exploring an additional dimension -the type of citizen-party linkages characterizing the movement (Kitschelt 2000). Clientelist secessionist parties may be in a better position to control the process of de-escalation than programmatic ones where the linkages between parties and citizens are more fluid and less predictable (Siroky et al. 2021). ...
... This explains why decision-making in national security entails careful management of competing and conflicting interests, and countries with complex and complicated arrangements of identity groups find them challenging to navigate. The relative deprivation theory also posits that national security is vulnerable to competition and conflict among ethnic and religious groups, who often evaluate themselves for traces of inequality, injustice and marginalisation or unfair treatment in comparison with other groups and seek redress through mobilisation that may include instruments of violence (Aaron 2015; Agbiboa 2013; Bauman and Leech 2012; Kunst and Obaidi 2020;Siroky et al. 2020). In similar ways, social conflict theory shows that competition for power and resources of the state, especially by ethnic and religious groups, is likely to undermine national security, especially when their interests and mobilisations are pursued with instruments of violence (Esteban, Mayoral, and Ray 2012;Schlee 2010;Szczecinska-Musielak 2016). ...
... This is in line with earlier findings on the dominance of English corpora in textual research (Pang & Lee, 2008). However, other languages were assessed as well, either as part of multilingual projects (e.g., de Leeuw et al., 2020;Maier et al., 2022) or in single-language studies usually focusing on a specific country or region (Bustikova et al., 2020;El-Masri et al., 2021;Yang & Fang, 2021). ...
... The main strand of literature, informed with constructivist approaches, focuses on so-called small groups of decision-makers and their ideas, values, perceptions, and identities (Davtyan 2021;German 2015;Gvalia et al. 2013;Kakachia and Minesashvili 2015;Kakachia, Minesashvili, and Kakhishvili 2018;Kolstø and Rusetskii 2012;Minesashvili 2021;Naskidashvili and Kakhishvili 2016;Ó Beacháin and Coene 2014). Another strand in the literature, informed with neoclassical realism, focuses more on structural factors, such as perceived relative power capabilities in the international context (Oskanian 2016), and factors such as elite cohesion and state capacity (Gvalia, Lebanidze, and Siroky 2019). More recently, Lebanidze and Kakachia (2023) have argued that, during 2012-2022, elite ideas led Georgia to choose Russia-accommodating policies, but this was limited by overwhelmingly pro-Western public opinion. ...