Cindy Bessey’s research while affiliated with The Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (39)


Schematic of the OCD (open–close device) eDNA sampler featuring key components, including the sponge capture material and photographs of the manufactured prototype with lid on and lid off.
Photographs showing the installation position of the OCD on the deep‐tow camera system frame, deployment of the combined OCD and camera system, and activation screen of the software that enables the OCD to be opened and closed remotely.
Google Earth map of the sample site locations off the north‐west coast of Western Australia by depth category (white circle = continental shelf, blue circle = mid‐slope, and red circle = abyss), with an inserted photograph of the RV Investigator.
A graphical depiction of the three sample processing methods (filtered 1 L OCD water, sponge pieces as depicted by white rectangles, and rinsed sponge) used to compare fish species detection and a summary of the average number of taxa detected per site by processing method and depth category. Venn diagram depicts the total taxa detected for filtered 1 L samples compared to the taxa detected by the sponge pieces and rinsed sponge combined.
Nonmetric multidimensional scaling plot (NMDS) of the presence/absence of fish families (distance = jaccard, which ignores joint absences and focusses on the proportion of share families) by depth category (black line with open white circle = continental shelf, blue line with solid blue circle = mid‐slope, and red line with solid red circle = abyss). Lines are ellipses based on the standard error for each depth category at a confidence level of 0.9999. Venn diagram depicts the number of taxa detected in each depth category and pie charts show the proportion (in color) of the taxa expected to be found in that depth category, with the gray shaded area showing the proportion of taxa not expected. Data for this figure comes from the 17 sites where all sample processing methods detected fish.
Design and Validation of an Open–Close Device for Integrated Environmental DNA Sampling Detects A Depth Gradient in Indian Ocean Deep‐Sea Fish Assemblages
  • Article
  • Full-text available

January 2025

·

17 Reads

Cindy Bessey

·

Andrew Martini

·

Alasdair Currie

·

[...]

·

Advances in methods for collecting environmental DNA (eDNA) are revolutionizing biomonitoring capabilities. The goal of this study was to leverage existing survey technology to design and test an eDNA sampler that captures an integrated eDNA sample over the length of a deep‐water transect. We manufactured a 300 × 100 × 100 mm mountable, open‐ended box made of high‐density polyethylene that could be attached to the frame of a preexisting deep tow camera system. The box (OCD; open–close device) was equipped with an actuator that attached to hinged doors at both ends, enabling it to be opened and closed remotely at depths up to 6000 m through preexisting communications, thereby exposing the internal chamber to the surrounding water upon activation. A sterile active carbon sponge was inserted into the internal chamber for eDNA capture during each deployment. The OCD sampler was field tested during a voyage to the Gascoyne Marine Park region off northwest Australia. We compared three different methods for processing the captured eDNA from the sampler: filtering OCD water, extracting eDNA from sponge pieces, and filtering sponge rinse water. Using fish as our example organism, we also compared the identities of fishes from eDNA detections with bottom trawl survey data collected during the same survey, and the known regional species pool, to confirm the eDNA identifications were plausible. A large number of fishes (193 taxa, from 87 families) were detected, and the majority were found within their expected depth ranges (> 75%), and in the trawl catches (60%). We discuss design and manufacturing lessons, ideas for increased eDNA capture efficiency for improved methodologies in sample processing, and how to establish appropriate field controls. We also discuss how this technology could advance our scientific understanding in ocean studies in terms of ecological metrics provided and the trade‐offs compared to other sampling tools.

Download

Fig. 1 Seven migration models were used to study the migration levels (M) between three different Indian Ocean populations (GOE = Gulf of Eilat, TAN = Tanzania, WA = Western Australia).
Fig. 2 Haplotype network analysis of all Western Australian Drupella cornus COI haplotypes (n = 53). Circle sizes are proportional to haplotype totals. Crossed lines indicate the number of mutations between
Fig. 3 Maximum likelihood phylogenetic tree (left) and haplotype network analysis (right) for all Indian Ocean Drupella cornus COI sequences (n = 369, 594 bp) and haplotypes (n = 150, 594 bp). One sequence from Ningaloo Reef (NR) was intermediate between the two main haplogroups. GOE refers to sequences from the Gulf of
Group sample sizes (n), number of haplotypes (#H, including number of singleton haplotypes only found in this group) and haplo- type (h) and nucleotide (π) diversities, standard deviations (h SD/ π SD), and neutrality test results for Western Australian (WA; including Rottnest Island [RI], Houtman Abrolhos Islands [HAI] and Ningaloo Reef [NR]) Drupella cornus sequences, and for combined WA group, Tanzanian (TAN) group, and the Gulf of Eilat (GOE) group (Mbije et al. 2019). P-values < 0.05 are marked with [*] and P-values < 0.001 are marked with [**]. Published data for Tanzania and Gulf of Eilat are provided for comparison (Mbije et al. 2019). (Note, data for Tan- zanian haplotypes do not match those provided by (Mbije et al. 2019) (#H 61) due to shorter sequence length used in our assessments)
High levels of genetic connectivity in the corallivorous gastropod Drupella cornus (Rӧding, 1798) in an expanding latitudinal range along Western Australia

January 2025

·

22 Reads

Marine Biodiversity

Understanding connectivity in high impact corallivores is crucial for coral reef management. The obligate corallivorous Drupella cornus (Röding, 1798) has caused extensive damage to some Indian Ocean coral reef areas in the last four decades. This study used novel and previously published Cytochrome Oxidase I ( COI ) sequences to reveal patterns of genetic diversity, phylogeography and connectivity within D. cornus across the Indian Ocean. The genetic compositions of the Western Australian D. cornus groups from Ningaloo Reef, Houtman Abrolhos Islands, and a recently discovered group at Rottnest Island, were analysed and compared to D. cornus groups from the western Indian Ocean (Tanzania and the Gulf of Eilat). The findings indicated that these groups all belong to the same species, except for a few individuals from Rottnest Island, which were excluded from subsequent analyses. No genetically distinct D. cornus groups along the Western Australian coastline were found, whereas molecular population differences were seen between the western Indian Ocean D. cornus groups and the Western Australian D. cornus groups. The molecular differences between the Western Australian and Tanzanian groups were statistically significant; however, there was evidence of historic connections and possibly also occasional long-distance gene flow between these groups. We hypothesise that high-density D. cornus outbreaks have played an important role in the dispersal of this species across Western Australia and, more broadly, the Indian Ocean. This is important as Drupella spp. outbreaks are being reported more frequently in the Indo-Pacific, affecting coral reef health and ecosystem function.




Predicting and assessing the impacts of COVID-19 disruption on marine science and sectors in Australia

October 2024

·

109 Reads

Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries

By March 2020 coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) was anticipated to present a major challenge to the work undertaken by scientists. This pandemic could be considered just one of the shocks that human society has had and will be likely to confront again in the future. As strategic thinking about the future can assist performance and planning of scientific research in the face of change, the pandemic presented an opportunity to evaluate the performance of marine researchers in prediction of future outcomes. In March 2020, two groups of researchers predicted outcomes for the Australian marine research sector, and then evaluated these predictions after 18 months. The self-assessed coping ability of a group experienced in ‘futures studies’ was not higher than the less-experienced group, suggesting that scientists in general may be well placed to cope with shocks. A range of changes to scientific endeavours (e.g., travel, fieldwork) and to marine sectors (e.g., fisheries, biodiversity) were predicted over the first 12–18 months of COVID-19 disruption. The predicted direction of change was generally correct (56%) or neutral (25%) for predictions related to the scientific endeavour, and correct (73%) or mixed (9%) for predictions related to sectors that are the focus of marine research. The success of this foresighting experiment suggests that the collective wisdom of scientists can be used by their organisations to consider the impact of shocks and disruptions and to better prepare for and cope with shocks. Graphical abstract Word cloud analysis of free text responses to questions about expected impact of COVID-19 on the activities associated with marine science



Evidence of corallivorous gastropod Drupella cornus breeding on the higher latitude reefs of Rottnest Island (32°S), Western Australia

December 2023

·

132 Reads

·

1 Citation

Marine Biology

With increasing sea water temperatures, higher latitude temperate and sub-tropical coral reefs are becoming increasingly tropicalised. Although these cooler areas might offer refuge to tropical species escaping the heat, the reshaping of ecosystems can have devastating effects on the biodiversity in these areas, especially when habitat structure is affected. Recently, feeding aggregations of corallivorous gastropod Drupella cornus, a tropical species capable of large-scale reef degradation, were found at Rottnest Island in Western Australia (32°S). We provide evidence that D. cornus spawned at Rottnest Island for 2 consecutive years in 2021 and 2022, and Drupella veligers from an egg case collected at the island hatched and grew at temperatures in the laboratory that were predominantly lower than those at Rottnest Island at the same time. The spawning was possibly triggered by higher than usual La Niña-associated SSTs during the survey period, or the long period of high sea water temperature anomalies recorded around Rottnest Island. A spawning population of D. cornus can greatly affect these higher latitude reef areas, especially when accompanied by increased heat stress. Monitoring and management should be implemented to further understand what effects a breeding population of D. cornus has on Rottnest Island.


Fig. 2. Venn diagram showing how many fish taxa were detected by each survey method for all fish species, as well as for cryptic fish species only.
Fig. 3. The mean number of cryptobenthic fish species detected per site by each survey method (n = 5). Error bars represent standard deviation, and the coefficient of variation is indicated as a percentage above each treatment.
Fig. 4. (a) Nonmetric multidimensional scaling plot of the autotransformed read count data (distance = jaccard) of cryptic fish species by survey method (active = blue circle, passive = pink square) and depth (surface = solid shape, bottom = open shape) and (b) showing species dissimilarities by water depth.
Permutational multivariate ANOVA results (permutations = 10,000). The main test is presented at the top (All), with strong site effects explored below for each of the different methods.
Pairwise comparison results of the permutational multivariate ANOVA to determine which methods differ significantly for cryptobenthic fishes.
Cryptic biodiversity: A portfolio‐approach to coral reef fish surveys

July 2023

·

110 Reads

·

6 Citations

Biodiversity conservation and management requires surveillance that captures the full spectrum of taxa. Here, we showcase the potential for a portfolio of visual, extractive, and molecular methods for detecting previously hidden components of tropical fish biodiversity in an economically and culturally valuable marine site that spans a tropical‐temperate ecotone—the Ningaloo Coast World Heritage Area. With scale and practicality in mind, we demonstrate how environmental DNA (eDNA) methods deployed in a stratified sampling design can yield a more comprehensive monitoring program for species presence than current alternatives (e.g., extractive sampling via anesthetic). eDNA from filtered water samples detected up to six times as many cryptobenthic fish species per site than samples collected with anesthetic, indicating it is a potentially powerful tool for assessing biodiversity of tropical fishes. However, there were also species that were only found when using anesthetic and the contribution of cryptobenthic species to overall diversity of the fish assemblage was unexpectedly low, suggesting not all cryptobenthic fish species have been detected with eDNA. There were also distinct differences in cryptobenthic assemblages both among sites and sample depths (2–3 m) when using eDNA from filtered water, suggesting this technique may be able to identify fine scale spatial differences in cryptobenthic fish assemblage. eDNA collected from water detects the most cryptobenthic species and is therefore an efficient tool for rapidly assessing biodiversity, but extractive techniques may still be required for biological and monitoring studies, and when combined with eDNA sampling provides the most comprehensive assessment of cryptobenthic fishes.


Figure 1
Figure 2
Figure 3
Evidence of corallivorous Drupella cornus breeding on the higher latitude reefs of Rottnest Island (32° S), Western Australia.

May 2023

·

117 Reads

·

1 Citation

With increasing seawater temperatures, higher latitude temperate and sub-tropical reefs are becoming increasingly tropicalised. Although these cooler areas might offer refuge to tropical species escaping the heat, the reshaping of ecosystems can have devastating effects on the biodiversity in these areas, especially when habitat structure is affected. Recently, feeding aggregations of corallivorous gastropod Drupella cornus , a tropical species capable of large-scale reef degradation, were found at Rottnest Island in Western Australia (32 °S). We provide evidence that D. cornus spawned at Rottnest Island for two consecutive years in 2020–2022. Drupella veligers are also shown to hatch and develop successfully at lower temperatures (17.5–23.2°C) in the laboratory, showing high plasticity in the early life stages of D. cornus . The spawning was possibly triggered by higher than usual La Niña-associated SSTs during the survey period, or the long period of high sea water temperature anomalies recorded around Rottnest Island. A spawning population of D. cornus can greatly affect these higher-latitude reef areas, especially when accompanied by increased heat stress. Monitoring and management should be implemented to further understand what effects a breeding, and potentially self-sustaining population of D. cornus has on Rottnest Island.


Production and accumulation of reef framework by calcifying corals and macroalgae on a remote Indian Ocean cay

March 2023

·

145 Reads

·

2 Citations

Coral reefs face increasing pressures in response to unprecedented rates of environmental change at present. The coral reef physical framework is formed through the production of calcium carbonate (CaCO3) and maintained by marine organisms, primarily hermatypic corals, and calcifying algae. The northern part of Western Australia, known as the Kimberley, has largely escaped land-based anthropogenic impacts and this study provides important metabolic data on reef-building organisms from an undisturbed set of marine habitats. From the reef platform of Browse Island, located on the mid-shelf just inside the 200 m isobath off the Kimberley coast, specimens of the dominant coral (six species) and algal (five species) taxa were collected and incubated ex situ in light and dark shipboard experimental mesocosms for 4 h to measure rates of calcification and production patterns of oxygen. During experimental light and dark incubations, all algae were net autotrophic producing 6 to 111 mmolO2m-2d-1. In contrast, most corals were net consumers of O2 with average net fluxes ranging from -42 to 47 mmolO2m-2d-1. The net change in pH was generally negative for corals and calcifying algae (-0.01 to -0.08 h-1). Resulting net calcification rates (1.9 to 9.9 gCaCO3m-2d-1) for corals and calcifying algae (Halimeda and Galaxura) were all positive and were strongly correlated with net O2 production. In intertidal habitats around Browse Island, estimated relative contributions of coral and Halimeda to the reef production of CaCO3 were similar at around 600 to 840 gm-2yr-1. The low reef platform had very low coral cover of < 3 % which made a smaller contribution to calcification of ∼ 240 gCaCO3m-2yr-1. Calcification on the subtidal reef slope was predominantly from corals, producing ∼ 1540 gCaCO3m-2yr-1, twice that of Halimeda. These data provide the first measures of community metabolism from the offshore reef systems of the Kimberley. The relative contributions of the main reef builders, in these undisturbed areas, to net community metabolism and CaCO3 production is important to understand exclusively climate-driven negative effects on tropical reefs.


Citations (24)


... Understanding the interactions between coral reef health and function and associated invertebrate corallivores is becoming increasingly important, especially in view of escalating seawater temperatures (Rice et al. 2019;Haslam et al. 2024a). To develop effective tools for population management and monitoring, information on the levels of connectivity in corallivore species is required (Underwood et al. 2013;Kot et al. 2023). ...

Reference:

High levels of genetic connectivity in the corallivorous gastropod Drupella cornus (Rӧding, 1798) in an expanding latitudinal range along Western Australia
Evidence of corallivorous gastropod Drupella cornus breeding on the higher latitude reefs of Rottnest Island (32°S), Western Australia

Marine Biology

... Specifically, eDNA recovered a majority of both pelagic and demersal species, as well as detected more small crypto-benthic species and large mobile species per site, which resulted in wider phylogenetic signal and diversity as a whole compared to UVC. The same patterns were also observed in other studies where eDNA captures larger number of genera and families, as well as larger fractions of the phylogenetic tree compared to UVC and other methods such as diver-operated video (DOV), baited remote underwater video systems (BRUVs) and extractive sampling via anesthetic (Bessey et al. 2023;Hsu, Chen, and Denis 2023;Juhel et al. 2022;Polanco Fernández et al. 2021;Stat et al. 2019). While the capacity of UVC is limited by different constraints such as underwater visibility, water depth, morphologically similar cryptic species and benthic substrate complexity making it unable to detect diverse type of species, eDNA is less restricted by these barriers and more proficient in revealing a wide range of species across multiple trophic guilds present in the sampling site. ...

Cryptic biodiversity: A portfolio‐approach to coral reef fish surveys

... Climate change could gradually shift the species' suitable habitats to higher latitudes as it seeks optimal environmental conditions. In terms of climatic zone, we expect that tropical fishes may be more resilient to climate change than fishes in other climate zones because large amounts of suitable habitats may arise in temperate or boreal zones (Nakamura et al., 2013;Osland et al., 2021;Haslam et al., 2023). We predicted habitat expansions and northward movements of the distribution center of tropical species, Trachurus japonicus and Scomber japonicus, in the face of climate change. ...

Evidence of corallivorous Drupella cornus breeding on the higher latitude reefs of Rottnest Island (32° S), Western Australia.

... However, both (CCA and calcifying algae) are often not included in Figure 5 Main ecosystem processes (i.e., carbonate dynamics, trophic chain, biogeochemical cycling, microbial loop and chemical mediation) and ecosystem services (i.e., provisioning, regulating, cultural and supporting services) often affected by coral reef benthic changes towards alternative communities (i.e., not dominated by hard corals). (Cornwall et al. 2023, McLaughlin et al. 2023). In addition, shifts towards some non-reef builders, such as bioeroding sponges, further contribute to the degradation of the reef framework, highlighting the need for better understanding the geo-ecological functions of these reefs (Schönberg et al. 2017). ...

Production and accumulation of reef framework by calcifying corals and macroalgae on a remote Indian Ocean cay

... The large size of abalones has turned out to be a threat to the survival of natural populations because this shellfish is an important seafood item that has sustained historical commercial fisheries around the world. Overfishing, disease, ocean warming, and acidification recently led to stock collapse, and a few species are now threatened (Rogers-Bennet et al., 2002;Neuman et al., 2010;Kiyomoto et al., 2013;Li et al., 2018;Rogers-Bennet and Catton, 2019;Wells et al., 2023), including the European green ormer, H. tuberculata (Peters, 2021). ...

Responses of intertidal invertebrates to rising sea surface temperatures in the southeastern Indian Ocean

... However, it should be acknowledged that fish amplification was overall more challenging with the biofilm than with water, as it is common in biofilm samples that fish eDNA is found in low abundance, affecting the success of fish amplification (Rivera et al. 2023). It should also be recognized that water eDNA sampling to measure fish diversity is becoming standard practice (e.g., Takahashi et al. 2023). In contrast, for microalgae and benthic macroinvertebrates, the use of different matrices was found to be complementary. ...

Aquatic environmental DNA: A review of the macro-organismal biomonitoring revolution

The Science of The Total Environment

... The sponge material (Aqua One, Kong's Pty Limited in Australia) was chosen because it is a tightly woven filter pad with 100% active carbon embedded into the fibers that is known to rapidly capture DNA (Figure 1; Bessey et al. 2022). Each sponge insert was approximately 30 × 6 × 0.5 cm. ...

Comparison of materials for rapid passive collection of environmental DNA

Molecular Ecology Resources

... Pyrene bidentata, another species that crashed at the west end was recorded in small numbers at two sites but was abundant at Strickland West (22.3% of total invertebrates) and North Point (32.3%). Similarly, Wells et al. (2021) found the heterobranch gastropod Bursatella hirsuta to be abundant on the platform at Little Armstrong Bay, adjacent to North Point, with an estimated population of >600,000 individuals over the ∼300m long platform (Wells et al., 2021). The Western Australian Museum conducted a detailed survey of Roe Reef, 1 km offshore of the northeastern end of Rottnest Island in 2013 and 2014, recording 287 marine species, including 40 species of molluscs and 16 echinoderms (Richards et al., 2016). ...

A recurring population of the sea hare Bursatella hirsuta (Gastropoda: Aplysiidae) at Rottnest Island, Western Australia

Molluscan Research

... The high-tech robotics being used to sample large volumes of water for aquatic eDNA (e.g., automated underwater vehicles) are expensive to build and operate, are ineffective for inaccessible and/ or complex habitats, and often target a limited set of taxa . Although passive filtration has been explored as an alternative to active filtration using peristaltic or vacuum pumps, they require long submergence times and have saturation limits (Bessey, Gao, et al., 2021;Kirtane et al., 2020). ...

Comparison of materials for rapid passive collection of environmental DNA

... The substrate cover of macroalgae and other environmental variables such as sedimentation, predation, and structural complexity affect the size and distribution of marine life populations; the macroalgae substrate cover was 0.22%. Although the percentage is small and is not considered the main cause, its existence will be a competitor for corals; therefore, the hard corals will be hard to survive (Westlake et al. 2021). ...

Environmental factors and predator abundance predict the distribution and occurrence of two sympatric urchin species at Ningaloo Reef, Western Australia