Christopher W. Wheat’s research while affiliated with Stockholm University and other places

In cases of recurrent colonizations of similar habitats from the same base population, it is commonly expected that repeated phenotypic adaptation is caused by parallel changes in genetic variation. However, it is becoming increasingly clear that similar phenotypic variation may also evolve by alternative genetic pathways. Here, we explore the repeated evolution of photoperiodic plasticity for diapause induction across Swedish populations of the speckled wood butterfly, Pararge aegeria. This species has colonized Scandinavia at least twice, and population genomic results show that one of the candidate regions associated with spatial variation in photoperiodism is situated on the Z-chromosome. Here, we assay hybrid crosses between several populations that differ in photoperiodic plasticity for sex-linked inheritance of the photoperiodic reaction norm. We find that while a cross between more distantly related populations from the two different colonization events shows strong sex-dependent inheritance of photoperiodic plasticity, a cross between two more closely related populations within the oldest colonization range shows no such effect. We conclude that the genotype–phenotype map for photoperiodic plasticity varies across these populations and that similar local phenotypic adaptation has evolved during recurrent colonization events by partly non-parallel genetic changes.

Evolutionary changes in geographic distribution and larval host plants may promote the rapid diversification of montane insects, but this scenario has been rarely investigated. We studied rapid radiation of the butterfly genus Colias, which has diversified in mountain ecosystems in Eurasia, Africa, and the Americas. Based on a dataset of 150 nuclear protein-coding genetic loci and mitochondrial genomes, we constructed a time-calibrated phylogenetic tree of Colias species with broad taxon sampling. We then inferred their ancestral geographic ranges, historical diversification rates, and the evolution of host use. We found that the most recent common ancestor of Colias was likely geographically widespread and originated ~3.5 Ma. The group subsequently diversified in different regions across the world, often in tandem with geographic expansion events. No aspect of elevation was found to have a direct effect on diversification. The genus underwent a burst of diversification soon after the divergence of the Neotropical lineage, followed by an exponential decline in diversification rate toward the present. The ancestral host repertoire included the legume genera Astragalus and Trifolium but later expanded to include a wide range of Fabaceae genera and plants in more distantly related families, punctuated with periods of host range expansion and contraction. We suggest that the widespread distribution of the ancestor of all extant Colias lineages set the stage for diversification by isolation of populations that locally adapted to the various different environments they encountered, including different host plants. In this scenario, elevation is not the main driver but might have accelerated diversification by isolating populations.

Quantifying the tempo and mode via modern phylogenetic comparative methods can provide key insights into how selection and constraints shape trait evolution on a macroevolutionary time scale. Here, we elucidate the evolution of hibernation (winter) diapause, a complex and defining life-history trait that allows temporal escape from harsh winters in temperate regions for many insects, including our model system, butterflies. Butterflies can diapause in all major life stages, and the availability of global-scale phylogenies makes them an ideal model system for studying diapause evolution. First, using a thorough literature survey, we scored the developmental stage of hibernation diapause (egg, larva, pupa, adult) vs. absence of diapause. We find that larval diapause is most common, while pupal, egg, and adult diapause are relatively rare. Next, we determined that the loss of diapause occurred at a much higher rate and that gains primarily occurred from the non-diapause state. While ancestral state estimation at deeper nodes remained uncertain, we found consistent patterns for some families and strong evidence for extensive convergence in diapause evolution. Contrary to expectations, we find no support for increased gain of diapause during the Eocene–Oligocene glaciation (~35 million years ago). Overall, the evolution of diapause in butterflies has a complex history, has evolved convergently, and has likely predated the major glaciation event consistent with the deep history of diapause evolution in insects. This study advances our understanding of the evolution of a complex and important life-history trait and establishes a macroevolutionary foundation for future studies on the ultimate and proximate basis of diapause evolution.

Generalist plant‐feeding insects are characterised by a broad host repertoire that can comprise several families or even different orders of plants. The genetic and physiological mechanisms underlying the use of such a wide host range are still not fully understood. Earlier studies indicate that the consumption of different host plants is associated with host‐specific gene expression profiles. It remained, however, unclear if and how larvae can alter these profiles in the case of a changing host environment. Using the polyphagous comma butterfly ( Polygonia c‐album ) we show that larvae can adjust their transcriptional profiles in response to a new host plant. The switch to some of the host plants, however, resulted in a larger transcriptional response and, thus, seems to be more challenging. At a physiological level, no correspondence for these patterns could be found in larval performance. This suggests that a high transcriptional but also phenotypic flexibility are essential for the use of a broad and diverse host range. We furthermore propose that host switch tests in the laboratory followed by transcriptomic investigations can be a valuable tool to examine not only plasticity in host use but also subtle and/or transient trade‐offs in the evolution of host plant repertoires.

Comparative analyses of gene birth–death dynamics have the potential to reveal gene families that played an important role in the evolution of morphological, behavioral, or physiological variation. Here, we used whole genomes of 30 species of butterflies and moths to identify gene birth–death dynamics among the Lepidoptera that are associated with specialist or generalist feeding strategies. Our work advances this field using a uniform set of annotated proteins for all genomes, investigating associations while correcting for phylogeny, and assessing all gene families rather than a priori subsets. We discovered that the sizes of several important gene families (e.g. those associated with pesticide resistance, xenobiotic detoxification, and/or protein digestion) are significantly correlated with diet breadth. We also found 22 gene families showing significant shifts in gene birth–death dynamics at the butterfly (Papilionoidea) crown node, the most notable of which was a family of pheromone receptors that underwent a contraction potentially linked with a shift to visual-based mate recognition. Our findings highlight the importance of uniform annotations, phylogenetic corrections, and unbiased gene family analyses in generating a list of candidate genes that warrant further exploration.

A bstract The genetic components of the circadian clock have been implicated as involved in photoperiodic regulation of winter diapause across various insect groups, thereby contributing to adaptation to adverse seasonal conditions. So far, the effects of within‐population variation in these genes have not been well explored. Here, we present an experimental test of the effects of within‐population variation at two circadian genes, timeless and period , on photoperiodic responses in the butterfly Pararge aegeria . While nonsynonymous candidate SNPs in both of these genes have previously shown to be associated with diapause induction on a between‐population level, in the present experiment no such effect was found on a within‐population level. In trying to reconcile these results, we examine sequence data, revealing considerable, previously unknown protein‐level variation at both timeless and period across Scandinavian populations, including variants unique to the population studied here. Hence, we hypothesize that these variants may counteract the previously observed diapause‐averting effect of the candidate SNPs, possibly explaining the difference in results between the experiments. Whatever the cause, these results highlight how the effects of candidate SNPs may sometimes vary across genetic backgrounds, which complicates evolutionary interpretations of geographic patterns of genetic variation.

Organisms inhabiting highly seasonal environments must cope with a wide range of environmentally induced challenges. Many seasonal challenges require extensive physiological modification to survive. In winter, to survive extreme cold and limited resources, insects commonly enter diapause, which is an endogenously derived dormant state associated with minimized cellular processes and low energetic expenditure. Due to the high degree of complexity involved in diapause, substantial cellular regulation is required, of which our understanding primarily derives from the transcriptome via messenger RNA expression dynamics. Here we aim to advance our understanding of diapause by investigating microRNA (miRNA) expression in diapausing and direct developing pupae of the butterfly Pieris napi. We identified coordinated patterns of miRNA expression throughout diapause in both head and abdomen tissues of pupae, and via miRNA target identification, found several expression patterns to be enriched for relevant diapause‐related physiological processes. We also identified two candidate miRNAs, miR‐14‐5p and miR‐2a‐3p, that are likely involved in diapause progression through their activity in the ecdysone pathway, a critical regulator of diapause termination. miR‐14‐5p targets phantom , a gene in the ecdysone synthesis pathway, and is upregulated early in diapause. miR‐2a‐3p has been found to be expressed in response to ecdysone, and is upregulated during diapause termination. Together, the expression patterns of these two miRNAs match our current understanding of the timing of hormonal regulation of diapause in P. napi and provide interesting candidates to further explore the mechanistic role of microRNAs in diapause regulation.

Generalist butterflies are characterized by a broad host repertoire that can comprise several families or even different orders of plants. The genetic and physiological mechanisms underlying the use of such a wide host range are still not fully understood. Earlier studies indicate that the consumption of different host plants is associated with host-specific gene expression profiles. It remained, however, unclear if and how larvae can alter these profiles in the case of a changing host environment. Using the polyphagous comma butterfly (Polygonia c-album) we show that larvae can adjust their transcriptional profiles in response to a new host plant. The switch to some of the host plants, however, resulted in a larger transcriptional response and, thus, seems to be more challenging. At a physiological level, no correspondence for these patterns could be found in larval performance. This suggests that a high transcriptional but also phenotypic flexibility are essential for the use of a broad and diverse host range. We furthermore propose that host switch tests in the laboratory followed by transcriptomic investigations can be a valuable tool to examine not only plasticity in host use but also subtle and/or transient trade-offs in the evolution of host plant repertoires. key words: insect-plant association, host plant adaptation, gene expression, phenotypic plasticity

Quantifying the tempo and mode via modern phylogenetic comparative methods can provide crucial insights into the role of selection and constraints in trait evolution. Here we elucidate the evolution of diapause, a complex and defining life-history trait that allows temporal escape from unfavorable conditions in many insects, including our model system, butterflies. Using a thorough literature survey, we first scored the developmental stage of diapause (egg, larva, pupa, adult) vs. absence of diapause. We find that larval diapause is most common in temperate lineages while pupal, egg, and adult diapause are relatively rare. Next, we determined that the loss of diapause occurred at a much higher rate than the gain, and its gain primarily occurred from the non-diapause state. While ancestral state estimation at deeper nodes remained uncertain, we found consistent patterns for some families and strong evidence for the convergent evolution of diapause across butterflies. We found no support for the hypothesis that the rate of the gain of diapause should be higher during the Eocene-Oligocene glacial maximum event (~35 MYA). Overall, the evolution of diapause in butterflies has a complex history, has evolved convergently, and has likely evolved much earlier than the Eocene-Oligocene glaciation event consistent with the deep history of diapause evolution in insects. These findings fill a deep gap in much-needed studies for future comparative research.