Carl G. Rosberg’s research while affiliated with University of California System and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (12)


WHY AFRICA'S WEAK STATES PERSIST: The Empirical and the Juridical in Statehood
  • Chapter

December 1986

·

9 Reads

·

24 Citations

Robert H. Jackson

·

Carl G. Rosberg

Sovereignty and Underdevelopment: Juridical Statehood in the African Crisis

March 1986

·

77 Reads

·

120 Citations

The Journal of Modern African Studies

When we speak of ‘the state’ in Tropical Africa today, we are apt to create an illusion. Ordinarily the term denotes an independent political structure of sufficient authority and power to govern a defined territory and its population: empirical statehood. This is the prevailing notion of the state in modern political, legal, and social theory ¹ , and it is a fairly close approximation to historical fact in many parts of the world – not only in Europe and North America, where modern states first developed and are deeply rooted, but also in some countries of South America, the Middle East, and Asia, where they have more recently emerged. The state is an inescapable reality. The military credibility of Argentina during the Falklands war, when it was by no means certain that Britain would prevail against its air force, is an indication of the reality of the state in some parts of the Third World today.



Popular Legitimacy in African MultiEthnic States

June 1984

·

9 Reads

·

53 Citations

The Journal of Modern African Studies

Because colonial boundaries have persisted, self-determination has produced independent ex-colonies rather than independent ethno-nations International legitimacy upholds this pattern but internal legitimacy of governments is not usually so institutionalized. One-party rule has generally replaced polyarchy: it avoids competition between ethno-national groups. But most regimes will continue to rely primarily on 'virtual representation' to secure popular legitimacy while recognizing that in uninstitutionalized multi-ethnic states only the ruling elites can ultimately provide the equity necessary to secure acceptance.-B.W.Beeley





Why Africa's Weak States Persist: The Empirical and the Juridical in Statehood

October 1982

·

1,111 Reads

·

783 Citations

World Politics

State institutions and organizations in Black Africa are less developed than almost anywhere else, and political instability has been prevalent. Yet, these serious empirical weaknesses have not led to enforced jurisdictional change. In order to explain the persistence of some of the weakest states in the world, the authors argue that state jurisdictions in Black Africa have been maintained primarily by the international society of states. Unlike the states that formed in Europe at an earlier period, many Black African states evolved—and survived—in the absence of effective national governments. Whereas state jurisdictions and international society once were consequences of the success and survival of states, today in Black Africa—and perhaps elsewhere, especially in the Third World—they are more likely to be conditions.




Citations (11)


... This is so because personalization of rule often makes politicians assume the feeling of being above the laws of the state. This is why the issue of holding leaders accountable for their actions and inactions has been problematic and this negates the essence of democracy and good governance (Adeyeye, 2006(Adeyeye, , 2011Hyden, 2006;Price, 1974;1975 andJackson &Rosberg, 1982). Unfortunately, the people and political leaders who Van Wyk (2007) asked if they are presidents, patrons, andprofiteers, jointly create what Joseph, (1991;1987) aptly described as prebendalism and neopatrimonialism. ...

Reference:

Desiring Omelette Not Breaking the Egg: Democracy, Elections and Good Governance in Africa Desiring Omelette Not Breaking the Egg: Democracy, Elections and Good Governance in Africa
Personal Rule in Black Africa
  • Citing Book
  • December 1982

... These states only meet the requirements of the state as a territorial entity and not as a formal structure able to provide for or effectively control its citizens. 22 This has resulted in "disengagement" where citizens do not interact with the state due to their skepticism of its effectiveness and legitimacy. 23 Thus, for many, the state in postcolonial Africa is an institution best known for oppressing and exploiting the bulk of its citizens. ...

WHY AFRICA'S WEAK STATES PERSIST: The Empirical and the Juridical in Statehood
  • Citing Chapter
  • December 1986

... The common starting point is the personal nature of the chief executive and personal rule. While civil servants occupy positions with formal job descriptions and are allocated to various agencies, departments, or ministries in accordance with official organograms, scholars emphasize the endurance -from the pre-colonial era -of informal patterns of patrimonial authority, where leaders rule "by dint of personal prestige and power" and according to their personal preferences rather than codified laws (Bratton & van de Walle, 1997;Jackson & Rosberg, 1982a). As a dominant narrative of the post-colonial state, neo-patrimonialism (a hybrid of traditional and modern forms of authority) is characterized as a system in which civil servants, military leaders, and cabinet officials owe their positions as much to their personal connections to the president or prime minister as to their personal expertise and fit with their formal position. ...

Personal Rule in Black Africa: Prince, Autocrat, Prophet, Tyrant
  • Citing Article
  • July 1982

Foreign Affairs

... African socialism needs to be contrasted with the 'Afro-Marxist' type of model that emerged in countries such as Mozambique, Angola and Ethiopia during the 1970s. In these and other countries that formed part of the 'second wave' of socialism in Sub-Saharan Africa (Rosberg and Callaghy, 1979), the distinctiveness of the African situation tended to be rejected in favor of the established principles of scientific socialism (that is, of Marxist-Leninism). This distinction is important because it bears so heavily on the type of technology that the developing country is predisposed to select. ...

Socialism in Sub-Saharan Africa
  • Citing Article
  • January 1979

Foreign Affairs

... Non-democratic rulers introduced new taxes in order to mobilize resources to win wars, and in return, they needed to provide openings for political representation (Schumpeter, 1991;Tilly, 1992). Negotiations over revenue in African countries operate in a post-colonial political context characterized by the absence of inter-state war, hybrid institutions, and economies in which the majority remains employed in low-technology subsistence agriculture (Jackson and Rosberg, 1982;van de Walle, 2001;Moore, 2004;Bräutigam, 2008;North et al., 2013). Thus, revenue pressure and the drive to collect revenue in Africa come from many factors other than interstate war. ...

Personal Rule in Black Africa: Prince, Autocrat, Prophet, Tyrant
  • Citing Article
  • June 1983

Political Science Quarterly

... Call proposes that instead of using the term 'failed state' the literature should differentiate between collapsed states like Somalia, war-torn states like Afghanistan, and authoritarian states like North Korea, etc. For a similar disagreement, see (Jackson & Rosberg, 1982;Manjinkian, 2008;Ayers, 2012). However, (Goldstone, 2008) disagrees by noting that there is no universal definition of fragile or failed states (see also Nay, 2013). ...

Why Africa's Weak States Persist: The Empirical and the Juridical in Statehood
  • Citing Article
  • October 1982

World Politics

... For instances of quite heterogenous comparative assessments of these conceptual approaches to post-independence future seeBenot 1975;Hountondji 1983;Rosberg / Callaghy 1979 7 Koselleck 1986; for Africa, this approach is currently pursued in a sub-project "Narratives of the Future in Modern African History" at the Bayreuth Academy of Advanced African Studies http://www.bayreuth-academy.unibayreuth.de/en/teilprojekt/jenseits_von_europa/index.html (accessed 30th March 2017). ...

Socialism in Sub-Saharan Africa: A New Assessment
  • Citing Article
  • October 1981

African Economic History

... (HAGMANN; PÉCLARD, 2010, HILL, 2005. 6 Ver: FERGUSON, 2008;JACKSON;ROSBERG, 1982ROSBERG, , 1986KAPLAN, 2003. histórica mais ampla, o encontro colonial teria promovido uma série de benefícios aos povos colonizados, como melhorias na infraestrutura pública e a expansão de direitos fundamentais. ...

Sovereignty and Underdevelopment: Juridical Statehood in the African Crisis
  • Citing Article
  • March 1986

The Journal of Modern African Studies

... Developing states have long predicated their legitimacy on the distribution of services and promises of economic development (Young, 1988;Bratton, 1989;Fowler, 1991;Kanyinga 1996, 71;Schatzberg, 2001;Owiti et al., 2004;Johnson, 2014;Osodo & Matsvai, 1997;Jackson & Rosberg, 1984). Studies of sub-Saharan African countries specifically have shown that most people view the state as a parental figure, and as such, expect the state to take care of them by providing services that will allow them to develop (Schatzberg, 2001). ...

Popular Legitimacy in African MultiEthnic States
  • Citing Article
  • June 1984

The Journal of Modern African Studies

... Ghana's winner-takes-all electoral formula is also fueled by the prevalence of clientelistic politics that deepens political divisions and antagonism. The comparative literature shows that electoral politics in Africa is systematically and intrinsically clientelistic (Lemarchand, 1977;Clapham, 1982;93 Eisenstadt and Roniger, 1984;de Walle, 1994, 1997;Jackson and Rosberg, 1982;Hyden, 2006;Joseph, 1987). Politicians or patrons give out gifts, material favors or dispense patronage goods to citizens or clients in return for loyalty and political support at the polls (Wantchekon, 2003: 3). ...

Personal Rule in Black Africa
  • Citing Article
  • January 1984

The International Journal of African Historical Studies