Aram Ziai’s research while affiliated with University of Kassel and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (66)


Neokolonialismus in der globalisierten Ökonomie des 21. Jahrhunderts - Ein Überblick
  • Article
  • Full-text available

October 2020

·

643 Reads

·

10 Citations

Momentum Quarterly - Zeitschrift für sozialen Fortschritt

Aram Ziai

Auf der Grundlage von Kwame Nkrumahs Definition von Neokolonialismus untersucht der Beitrag Praktiken in der globalisierten Ökonomie aus den Bereichen Verschuldung, Strukturanpassung, Entwicklungszusammenarbeit und Landwirtschaft sowie die zentralen Institutionen der globalen politischen Ökonomie (Weltbank, IWF, WTO). Er kommt zu dem Schluss, dass die Kontrolle der Wirtschaft durch ausländische Akteure in der heutigen Wirtschaft ein häufig auftretendes Phänomen ist. Diese Akteure sind aber nicht notwendigerweise identisch mit früheren Kolonialmächten.

Download

Development

December 2019

·

57 Reads

The “development” of “underdeveloped” regions has given rise not only to a huge apparatus of experts and administrators but also to semantic confusion. The latter can only be disentangled if we take into account the critical and linguistic turn in development studies pioneered by the Post-development School.


Gharbzadegi in Iran: A Reactionary Alternative to ‘Development’?

October 2019

·

139 Reads

·

4 Citations

Development

Post-development theory usually engages with examples from Latin America and India and investigates alternative concepts and practices by progressive social movements. This article addresses a post-development concept which originates in Iran, Gharbzadegi or occidentosis, which after the Islamic revolution in 1979 was promoted by the anti-Western Iranian government. It argues that the instrumentalization by right-wing governments should not distract from the emancipatory potential of post-development concepts.


Vertreibung durch Entwicklungsprojekte und ihre Legitimierung: Beispiele von Weltbankprojekten aus Subsahara-AfrikaComparing World Bank Projects in Sub-Saharan Africa

August 2019

·

70 Reads

PERIPHERIE – Politik • Ökonomie • Kultur

Der Artikel untersucht, wie die Vertreibung durch Infrastrukturprojekte im Entwicklungsdiskurs legitimiert wird. Drei typische Legitimationsmuster sind die Unausweichlichkeit des Fortschritts, das Allgemeinwohl und die Eigentumsrechte. Sie sind eng verknüpft mit Elementen des Entwicklungsdiskurses: der Transformation geokultureller Unterschiede in historische Stadien, dem othering vermeintlich rückständiger Gruppen, dem Konzept der Treuhandschaft und der Annahme positiver Effekte von Investitionen.



Towards a More Critical Theory of ‘Development’ in the 21 st Century: Debate: Towards a More Critical Theory of ‘Development’

March 2019

·

319 Reads

·

24 Citations

Development and Change

In response to the article by Horner and Hulme which opens this Debate section, this contribution argues that while the call for a shift from international to global development by Horner and Hulme is justified, their approach is confined to what has been called traditional or problem‐solving theory. On the levels of concepts, theory and metatheory, it fails to transcend orthodox approaches in development theory. Concerning concepts, it employs the traditional concept of ‘development’ without recognizing its ambiguity, referring at different times to social change, positive social change or social change according to the European model. Concerning theory, it is based on the nation state as a unit of analysis, not differentiating between different socio‐economic groups or classes, and neglects questions of power. Concerning metatheory, its knowledge interest, epistemology and methodology also remain within orthodox boundaries, for example reproducing the measurement of aggregate per capita income and its evaluation as progress. In the last section of this article, the author presents an outline sketch for a more critical theory of ‘development’.




Reaktionäre Alternativen zur „Entwicklung“? Zur Rehabilitierung der Post-Development-Konzepte in Thailand und im Iran

July 2018

·

65 Reads

·

4 Citations

PERIPHERIE – Politik • Ökonomie • Kultur

Seit nunmehr einem Vierteljahrhundert geht unter dem Namen „post-development“ ein Gespenst in der Entwicklungstheorie um. Während die klassischen post-development-Texte ihren Fokus primär auf Mexiko, Kolumbien und Indien richteten und die neuere Debatte um buen vivir v.a. Ecuador und Bolivien in den Blick nahm (siehe auch PERIPHERIE Nr. 149), lassen sich alternative, auf nichtwestliche Traditionen Bezug nehmende Vorstellungen einer guten Gesellschaft auch in zahlreichen anderen Ländern finden. Zwei davon möchten wir in unserem Beitrag genauer betrachten. Allerdings möchten wir im Unterschied zu den klassischen Beispielen Fälle untersuchen, in denen die Alternativkonzepte nicht von oft als links angesehenen Basisbewegungen, sondern von politisch rechts stehenden Regierungen vertreten werden: in Thailand und im Iran. Diese Fallauswahl scheint zu der These zu passen, dass post-development letztlich ein reaktionäres, rückwärtsgewandtes Konzept sei. Dieser These möchten wir widersprechen. Unsere Zielsetzung im vorliegende Beitrag ist es, die Instrumentalisierung antiwestlicher, entwicklungskritischer Konzepte in den untersuchten Ländern durch reaktionäre Regierungen zu analysieren, ohne ihren emanzipatorischen Gehalt zu übersehen – letztlich zielen wir auf eine Rehabilitierung von vermeintlich rückwärtsgewandten post-development-Konzepten ab.



Citations (26)


... Cirillo & Taleb, 2016, covering the period from 1500 to the present; see also next section, below) and the "new wars" thesis (cf. Kaldor, 1999, Münkler, 2005 thus seems to be somewhat overstated (see critically Krieger et al., 2018), there seems to be a link between modern statehood, conflict and displacement that has tended to produce more refugees compared to the pre-modern era. ...

Reference:

Refugees
Bewaffnete Konflikte, Neue Kriege und Staatszerfall.
  • Citing Chapter
  • January 2018

... Although the framing of 'development' or modernization 4 as a 'panacea for all ills', as universally desirable, or as a means to an end (for welfare, overcoming poverty and hunger) has been criticized by various post-development scholars for the concept's euro-centric and authoritarian implications (Ziai 2016, p. 54;Ziai 2015;Escobar 2015), the Global North (the EU in this example) operates (once again) as an 'active' agent, determining paths, conditions, and promises for the envisioned transition to the bioeconomy (Vogelpohl and Töller 2021, p. 144;EU 2018, p. 46). The 'passive' 5 peripheral countries in the Global South and semi-periphery are expected to adhere to this model and apply the same logic when designing their own bioeconomy strategies. ...

The concept of ‘development’ and why it should be abandoned
  • Citing Chapter
  • August 2015

... This study adopted theory of neo-colonialism. This theory has been widely attributed to the writings of the former President of Ghana, Nkrumah (1965) in his publication title: Neo-colonialism: the last stage of imperialism, as a follow up to Lenin's Imperialism: the final stage of capitalism (Ziai, 2020). The title of the works of both scholars cited above underscores the nexus between capitalism and neo-colonialism which describes the activities of the Chinese state in African economies. ...

Neokolonialismus in der globalisierten Ökonomie des 21. Jahrhunderts - Ein Überblick

Momentum Quarterly - Zeitschrift für sozialen Fortschritt

... (Bendix, 2013;Jansen, 2019;Langdon, 2013;Sims, 2018 (Mawdsley, , p.2017. 이렇게 급변하는 개발 환경 속에서, 기존 국제개발학 패러다임에 비판적 관점을 견지하고 있는 연구자들은 전통적인 개발 협력 체제와 구분되는 SSC의 차별화된 아이디어, 역사 및 지리적 위치 등에 대한 고민의 필요성이 제기된 것이다 Ruggie, 1983 (Corneliussen, 2021;Dreher & Fuchs, 2015;Naim, 2007 (Bull, 1977;Wight, 1977 동력이 됐다 (Buzan & Little, 2002;Howard, 1984 (Bowden, 2009;Gong, 1984). ...

Beyond the Master's Tools? Decolonizing Knowledge Orders, Research Methods and Teaching
  • Citing Book
  • October 2020

... Iran, for example, opposes modernization and offers a post-development discourse which is better known as the concept of Gharbzadegi. "The Gharbzadegi discourse has been very influential in modern Iranian history and is seen as a 'manifesto of anti-westernization' [33]. ...

Gharbzadegi in Iran: A Reactionary Alternative to ‘Development’?
  • Citing Article
  • October 2019

Development

... Being part of a largely energy-independent collective situated in the Global North, my role is an ambivalent one, as, despite efforts at dismantling it, I am still benefitting from the energy system that I criticize. In this sense, my positionality as a White and queer scholar/activist is motivated by my commitment to practicing ecosocial solidarity and post-development in the Global North, both by securing fundamental aspects of living housing, food production, and energy use (Bendix et al., 2019) and by contributing to decolonizing activities in academia (Ziai et al., 2020). ...

Postdevelopment alternatives in the North

... Muti-lateral organisations such as the World Bank, as well as postdevelopment scholars, have called for the end of such distinctions. 5 However, Horner & Hulme's work was widely criticised for its minimalist definition of development (particularly ignoring structural transformation), data and categories used, as well as their alignment with neoliberal approaches to development theory (Fischer 2019;Ghosh 2019;Sumner 2019;Ziai 2019). Since then, more nuanced arguments for Global Development have focussed on the potential of universalist approaches to encourage 'horizontal learning' between the South and North, avoid infantilising the Global South and argued that since poverty exists everywhere, 'development' must be a focus globally (Leach et al. 2021;Gillespie and Mitlin 2023). ...

Towards a More Critical Theory of ‘Development’ in the 21 st Century: Debate: Towards a More Critical Theory of ‘Development’
  • Citing Article
  • March 2019

Development and Change

... In Thailand, the critique can be pushed even further. While the present military government aspires to link up to the new Chinese high-speed train network, it uses the concept of sufficiency economy to preach modesty to the poor population and silence all political opposition (Schaffar and Ziai, 2018). ...

Reaktionäre Alternativen zur „Entwicklung“? Zur Rehabilitierung der Post-Development-Konzepte in Thailand und im Iran

PERIPHERIE – Politik • Ökonomie • Kultur

... There are calls for a more inclusive engagement with indigenous, communally grounded expertise, such as traditional medicine or agricultural knowledge, and a recognition of pre-colonial scholarly institutions, such as Islamic education in West Africa or Ethiopian monastic schools (de Souza Santos 2015; Abidogun and Falola 2020; Woldegiorgis 2021). Attention is also directed to indigenous notions of development and well-being, including the Latin American concept of 'Buen Vivir,' the Southern African 'Ubuntu,' and the Indian notion of 'Swaraj' (Ziai 2017;Demaria and Kothari 2020;Schoeneberg 2021). ...

Post-development 25 years after The Development Dictionary
  • Citing Article
  • December 2017

... Supported by the assumption that the Global South is "overpopulated" -although people in the Global North consume many times more resources -there is often a disregard for women's rights, under the banner of poverty reduction: through financial incentives to sterilise impoverished women, long-term contraceptives (banned in Europe) with unpredictable side effects, or through the aim of teaching women to have fewer children and branding their desire to have children as backward, irrational or irresponsible. An instrumentalisation of development cooperation through foreign trade is found in the partnerships with the pharmaceutical industry (and conservative nongovernmental organisations [NGOs] like the Deutsche Stiftung Weltbevölkerung [German Foundation for World Population]), which result in development cooperation funds being used to finance contraceptives from BayerHealthCare or Fresenius (Bendix/Schultz 2015Schultz 2006;Bendix/Ziai 2017). ...

Rassismusanalyse in der Entwicklungsforschung am Beispiel deutscher reproduktiver Gesundheitspolitik in Tansania

PERIPHERIE – Politik • Ökonomie • Kultur