Anna Rita Scorzini’s research while affiliated with Civil Protection Department of Italy and other places

What is this page?


This page lists works of an author who doesn't have a ResearchGate profile or hasn't added the works to their profile yet. It is automatically generated from public (personal) data to further our legitimate goal of comprehensive and accurate scientific recordkeeping. If you are this author and want this page removed, please let us know.

Publications (58)


Figure 1: Example of traditional damage functions resulting from the application of INSYDE-content for different 265 building types: a) total content damage; b) damage to kitchen and damage setup as well as electric appliances; c) damage to beds, sofas and wardrobes to a detached/semi-detached building; d) as panel c), but for an apartment building.
Figure 2: Variable importance in INSYDE-content. Results obtained with sampling from the two different datasets 290 developed by Di Bacco et al. (2024): a) case for the extended synthetic dataset; b) case for the Po River District synthetic dataset. Variables are ordered according to the median value of the absolute damage difference.
Figure 3a illustrates the results, plotting estimated content damage against building damage for both datasets and comparing them with the equation proposed by Carisi et al. (2018), based on post-event observations from the 2014 Secchia flood in Emilia Romagna, Italy. 330 INSYDE results reveal substantial variability in content damage for same levels of building damage, highlighting the complex, multi-variable nature of damage mechanisms that cannot be fully represented by simple univariate functions. Interestingly, the root function proposed by Carisi et al. (2018) aligns at a median level with INSYDE results, although in a region with lower sample density. Conversely, INSYDE allows discerning distinct patterns in the relationship between building and content damage, shaped by the combined effects of inundation duration thresholds and building characteristics 335 (such as BT and FL) triggering specific damage mechanisms to certain components, as previously described for INSYDE 2.0 by Di Bacco et al. (2024). Furthermore, Figure 3b illustrates the content-to-building damage ratio (CBR) as a function of inundation depth, offering insights into the limitations of using a univariate approach based solely on building damage, especially in case of shallow inundation depths (< 0.5 m), where the higher vulnerability of contents can lead to CBR values exceeding 5. However, as 340 inundation depth increases, overall damage becomes predominantly driven by building damage, leading to a reduction in the differences between the two approaches. Median CBR values for INSYDE across the two datasets range from 0.26 (calculated on inundation durations exceeding 48 hours) to 0.36 and 0.42, respectively for the extended and Po River datasets at shorter durations.
Figure 4. Results of the probabilistic validation of INSYDE-content: a) Caldogno event; b) Lodi event. Median computed damage (dot) and corresponding interquartile range (line) are plotted for each building against observed 380 damage (expressed in 2023 euro).
Building features in INSYDE-content for estimating exposed household items.

+1

INSYDE-content: a synthetic, multi-variable flood damage model to household contents
  • Preprint
  • File available

May 2025

·

48 Reads

·

·

·

Anna Rita Scorzini

This paper introduces INSYDE-content, a novel, probabilistic multi-variable synthetic flood damage model designed to analyze physical damage to household contents on a component-by-component basis. The model addresses a critical gap in current modeling tools, which often overlook the significance of household contents in overall damage assessments. Developed through an expert-based approach and grounded in the scientific and technical literature, INSYDE-content leverages desk-based data to characterize model features, including uncertainty treatment arising from incomplete input data. A sensitivity analysis and a benchmark test against observed losses demonstrate the robust performance of the model and highlight the contribution of different features to damage mechanisms affecting house contents. While in this study INSYDE-content is tailored for illustrative purposes to the hazard, vulnerability and exposure characteristics of Northern Italy, the model is highly adaptable, allowing for its application to different regional contexts through appropriate customization.

Download

Can macro- or meso-scale coping capacity variables improve the classification of building flood losses?

January 2025

·

88 Reads

·

1 Citation

·

·

S. Roucour

·

[...]

·

This study proposes a novel approach to improve the classification of severe building losses caused by river floods (i.e., identification of buildings with high flood damages). In addition to traditional variables reflecting flood hazard and building vulnerability, we investigate the impact of coping capacity variables (i.e., variables accounting for the preparedness and disaster response of the population and management authorities). These coping capacity variables are evaluated at three different scales: the building level (micro-scale), the census tract level (meso-scale), and the municipality level (macro-scale). Specifically, at the macro- and meso-scale these include: (i) the surprise effect (the ratio of the number of flooded buildings to the number of flooded buildings located in an official flood hazard area), (ii) the overwhelming effect (the fraction of flooded buildings compared to the total number of buildings within each census tract or municipalities), and (iii) flood rarity (the ratio of the peak discharge of the considered event to the 100-year flood peak). A binomial logistic regression model is used to classify flood losses based on field survey data from the extreme 2021 flood in eastern Belgium. Each variable is assessed for statistical significance, physical relevance, and multicollinearity. The results show that macro- and meso-scale coping capacity variables are insignificant in classifying building losses using the current dataset, suggesting that data on the building level are needed to reliably estimate building losses. Instead, the variables that contribute most to the classification are water depth, building footprint area, building finishing level and the heating system location. The performance of the classifier, measured by the AUC value, achieves an accuracy of 83%.



Figure 4. (a) Time series of total grape production (tons) in the four Abruzzo provinces. Red dashed line denotes the only wine grape produced in Chieti province. (b) Crop yield (t/h) of the Chieti province grape. (c) Time series of standardized yield residuals for grape yield.
Figure 5. Time series of maximum and minimum daily temperatures and Péguy climate classification in the two considered time ranges, 1952-1982 and 1983-2014, for L'Aquila and Chieti provinces. Dotted lines denote trendlines over about thirty-year time ranges (from [23], modified).
Climate Fluctuations and Growing Sensitivity of Grape Production in Abruzzo (Central Italy) over the Past Sixty Years

December 2024

·

28 Reads

Geographies

The sensitivity of the agricultural production system to short- and long-term climate variations significantly affects the availability and prices of food resources, raising relevant issues of sustainability and food security. Globally, productive systems have adapted to climate change, leading to increased yields over the past century. However, the extent to which these adaptations mitigate the impacts of short-term climate fluctuations, both extreme and ordinary, remains poorly studied. To evaluate the vulnerability of crop yield to short-term climate fluctuations and to determine whether it changes over time, we conducted a statistical analysis focusing on one of the main crops in the Abruzzo region (central Italy) as a case study: grape. The study involves correlation analysis between opportune climatic indices (SPI and SPEI) and grape yield data over the sixty-year period from 1952 to 2014, aimed at evaluating the impact of short-term climatic fluctuations—both extreme and ordinary—on crop yield. Our findings reveal an increasing correlation, mainly in the summer–autumn season, which suggests a rising sensitivity of the productive system over time. The observed increase is indicative of the Abruzzo grape production system’s adaptation to climate change, resulting in higher overall yields but not enhancing the response to short-term climatic fluctuations.


Climate Fluctuations and Growing Sensitivity of Grape Production in Abruzzo (Central Italy) Over the Past Sixty Years

November 2024

·

3 Reads

The sensitivity of the agricultural production system to short- and long-term climate variations significantly affects the availability and prices of food resources, raising relevant issues of sustainability and food security. To evaluate the vulnerability of crop yield to climate fluctuations and to determine whether it changes over time, we conducted a statistical analysis focusing on one of the main crops in the Abruzzo region (central Italy): grape. The study spans the four provinces of Abruzzo and involves the analysis of temperature, precipitation and grape yield over the sixty-year period from 1952 to 2014. Our findings reveal a climatic trend in the region, shifting from temperate to temperate-arid conditions, along with an increasing correlation between crop yield and climatic fluctuations. This suggests a rising sensitivity of the agricultural productive system to climate fluctuations over time. Despite progressively growing yields in the agricultural production system, the increase in sensitivity to climatic fluctuations indicates an inability to maintain high performance under unfavorable climatic conditions. On the other hand, yield fluctuations consistently pose a potential threat to market equilibria.





(a) Land use in the studied provinces of the Abruzzo region, central Italy; (b) comparison between harvested production and cultivated area for the main crops in Abruzzo in 1952 and 2018; and (c) trend of mechanization and fuel use in the studied region between the 1950s and 1990s.
Phases of the illustrated statistical analysis. Residual standardization provides a dimensionless variable for which the correlation with the SPI and SPEI indices of different periods and months of the year is estimated along time windows of thirty years in width, sliding within the time range from 1952 to 2014. The scatterplot illustrates an example of the regression analysis of SYR vs. SPEI3 of March, over the time window 1966–1996. The panel at the bottom summarizes the correlation values estimated for several months of the year (denoted by the column number). The colored cells denote correlation coefficients, in absolute value, above the thresholds of 0.3 and 0.46, which are associated with levels of significance of 10% and 1%, respectively (see main text). The diagram in the bottom right illustrates the correlation values estimated for the dominant SPEI index (here SPEI3 of March) over all time windows.
Wheat crop yield in the studied provinces, with related trends.
Results of the correlation analysis conducted over sliding time windows over the time range 1952–2014. (a) Tables of significant correlation coefficients estimated over five different time windows (see main text). The symbols SPI1, SPI3, and SPI6 denote monthly, quarterly, and semi-annual SPI respectively; the same applies to the SPEI indices. The column number denotes the month in which SPI/SPEI are calculated. (b) Path of the correlation coefficients for the dominant SPEI indices, identified by means of the tables in panel (a).
Forecasting model. In the regression scatterplot each SPEI value is associated with a conditioned probability distribution of SYR (denoted by the shaded area). The comparison between the residual distribution of Res (diagram at the bottom) and the normal model ensures that this latter provides a good approximation for Res distribution. The SYR conditional probability distribution shows the same variance of Res and average given by the expected value associated with each SPEI value.
Measuring Variation of Crop Production Vulnerability to Climate Fluctuations over Time, Illustrated by the Case Study of Wheat from the Abruzzo Region (Italy)

July 2024

·

65 Reads

·

1 Citation

Short-term climate fluctuations can have a significant impact on the stability of food resource prices, thus threatening food security, even in cases where the crop production system shows good adaptation to climate change and/or increasing average yields over time. This paper illustrates, in detail, a statistical approach aimed at verifying whether the variation of the crop production system vulnerability to climate fluctuation exhibits a trend over time. These methods were applied to the case study of wheat grown in the Abruzzo region (Italy). The results show that, although the wheat crop yield still shows ongoing growth, the correlation between climate fluctuations and yield oscillations exhibits a systematic increase over the past sixty years. Such an increase in climate-related production fluctuations may represent a disturbing element for market equilibria and be potentially harmful for the various economic subjects involved at various scales, such as producers, distributors, investors/financial traders, and final consumers. The statistical approach illustrated provides a framework for monitoring climate impacts and also provides the basis for building up statistical forecasting models to support informed decision making in agricultural management and financial planning.


Machine learning and hydrodynamic proxies for enhanced rapid tsunami vulnerability assessment

June 2024

·

128 Reads

·

8 Citations

Coastal communities in various regions of the world are exposed to risk from tsunami inundation, requiring reliable modeling tools for implementing effective disaster preparedness and management strategies. This study advocates for comprehensive multi-variable models and emphasizes the limitations of traditional univariate fragility functions by leveraging a large, detailed dataset of ex-post damage surveys for the 2011 Great East Japan tsunami, hydrodynamic modeling of the event, and advanced machine learning techniques. It investigates the complex interplay of factors influencing building vulnerability to tsunami, with a specific focus on the hydrodynamic effects associated to tsunami propagation on land. Novel synthetic variables representing shielding and debris impact mechanisms prove to be suitable proxies for water velocity, offering a practical solution for rapid damage assessments, especially in post-event scenarios or large-scale analyses. Machine learning then emerges as a promising approach to tackle the complexities of vulnerability assessment, while providing valuable and interpretable insights.


Citations (38)


... In Wallonia, responders and households in 'safe green or unmarked zones' faced the 2021 flood and did not know what to do. Many of the flooded areas directly along the Vesdre river (a tributary of the residents were not aware of the flood risk, and were surprised their houses were flooded up to the second floors (Rodríguez Castro et al., 2025). ...

Reference:

Comparing Flood Forecasting and Early Warning Systems in Transboundary River Basins
Can macro- or meso-scale coping capacity variables improve the classification of building flood losses?

... With the development of big data technology, various data-driven machine learning techniques have been gradually applied to flood disaster research [29]. Di Bacco et al. [30] introduced a machine learning framework to model tropical cyclone-induced compound floods and optimized the prediction results of flood inundation depth. ...

Exploring the compound nature of coastal flooding by tropical cyclones: A machine learning framework
  • Citing Article
  • October 2024

Journal of Hydrology

... We present a framework for multivariate and spatial transfer analysis (Section 2.1) for buildings and road network components. Expanding on existing buildings [26] and road [16] damage data we use remote GIS assessment (Section 2.2), and we develop multivariable models for roads and buildings (Section 2.3). The model is evaluated using relative hit rate in predicting damage level (Section 2.4) and the importance of variables is ranked using permutation importance analysis (Section 2.5). ...

Towards multi-variable tsunami damage modeling for coastal roads: Insights from the application of explainable machine learning to the 2011 Great East Japan Event
  • Citing Article
  • September 2024

Sustainable Cities and Society

... To this end, in the planning processes and development model of the territories, it is necessary to incorporate the disaster risk management component, the United Nations -UN defines as "the application of disaster risk reduction policies and strategies with the purpose of preventing new disaster risks, reducing existing disaster risks and managing residual risk, thereby contributing to the strengthening of resilience and the reduction of disaster losses" (11), this implies working with a comprehensive approach that includes risk analysis and reduction, management of adverse events and recovery; for this, steps such as: delimiting and evaluating areas prone to events (e.g. floods), to draw up hazard or threat maps and to develop risk management plans (12). ...

Unveiling the assessment process behind an integrated flood risk management plan
  • Citing Article
  • August 2024

International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction

... Among the various indices used to describe climatic conditions [13][14][15][16], the Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI) and the Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) are among the most frequently utilized [17]. Recent studies have analyzed the correlations of these indices with anomalies in crop yields in different regions of the world [18][19][20][21][22][23][24]. ...

Measuring Variation of Crop Production Vulnerability to Climate Fluctuations over Time, Illustrated by the Case Study of Wheat from the Abruzzo Region (Italy)

... In this context, Di Bacco et al. 23 implemented different machine learning algorithms on an enhanced version of the building damage dataset compiled by the MLIT (Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism of Japan) for the 2011 Great East Japan event 24,25 . The aim was to capture nonlinear interactions among descriptive variables and analyze the relative importance of the different features on modeling accuracy. ...

Extended MLIT dataset for the 2011 Great East Japan tsunami with inclusion of velocity information

... • Fault Mechanics: Simulating stress accumulation and rupture along submarine faults to predict tsunami triggers [26]. • Wave Propagation: Modeling tsunami wave interactions with bathymetry and coastal topography to estimate inundation zones [30]. • Infrastructure Assessment: Evaluating the impact of tsunami waves on coastal structures, informing resilient design standards [31]. ...

Machine learning and hydrodynamic proxies for enhanced rapid tsunami vulnerability assessment

... Additionally, the lack of well-established 190 criteria defining the threshold for washing away (based on a combination of water height and velocity) makes it challenging to quantify a situation where content damage would be complete. analysis was performed using two synthetic portfolios, each consisting of 250,000 buildings exposed to hypothetical flooding scenarios, as described in Di Bacco et al. (2024). The first dataset represents more general, non-region-specific 200 inundation and building characteristics (referred to as the "extended dataset", hereinafter), while the second focuses on the specificities of northern Italy (Po River District, "Po dataset", hereinafter). ...

The value of multi-source data for improved flood damage modelling with explicit input data uncertainty treatment: INSYDE 2.0

... These parameters are useful tools for assessing the impact of sublethal temperatures and developing strategies to reduce the effects of thermal stress in potato cultivation. Heat stress caused by climate change is a global issue, but its consequences are being experienced at a local level [14], as evidenced by numerous studies on the effects of climate change in Italy on crops such as maize [15], rice [16], and olive trees [15]. ...

Impact of Climate Change on Crop Yields: Insights from the Abruzzo Region, Central Italy

... To this aim, in the tailored INSYDE-content model for Northern Italy (Po River District), empirical data derived from virtual surveys of buildings have been used to establish reliable estimates of content distribution as a function of certain building features. The virtual surveys involve analyzing real estate listings to extract key information from advertised posts, architectural drawings and photos detailing the buildings and 110 their contents (Scorzini et al., 2022). Given the potential inconsistency in data completeness and quality across real estate platforms, only listings with complete information about the building and its contents have to be considered. ...

INSYDE-BE: adaptation of the INSYDE model to the Walloon region (Belgium)