Content uploaded by Dirk Lund Christensen
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Dirk Lund Christensen
Content may be subject to copyright.
Body dimensions, exercise capacity and physical activity level of
adolescent Nandi boys in western Kenya
H.B.Larsen,D.L.Christensen,T.Nolanand H. Sndergaard
The Copenhagen Muscle Research Centre, Rigshospitalet and University of Copenhagen, Denmark
Received 12 May 2003; in revised form 2 December 2003; accepted 9 December 2003
Summary. The aim of this study was to characterize untrained Nandi boys (mean age 16.6
years) from a town (n¼11) and from a rural area (n¼19) in western Kenya (altitude
2000 m.a.s.l.) in regard to their body dimensions, oxygen uptake and physical activity
level. The town boys had a mean maximal oxygen uptake (VO
2max
) of 50 (range: 45–60)
mL kg
1
min
1
, whereas the village boys reached a value of 55 (3763) mL kg
1
min
1
(p<0.01) in VO
2max
. The running economy, determined as the oxygen cost at a given
running speed, was 221 mL kg
1
km
1
(597 mL kg
0.75
km
1
) for town as well as for village
boys. The body mass index (BMI) was very low for town as well as for village boys
(18.6 vs 18.4 kg m
2
). The daily mean time spent working in the field during secondary
school and doing sports were significantly higher in village boys compared to town boys
(working in the field: 44.2 (0–128) vs 1.3 (0–11) min, p<0.01; sports: 32.0 (11–72) vs 12.8 (0–
35) min, p<0.01, respectively). A positive correlation between the daily time spent doing
sports and VO
2max
was found when pooling the data from the town and the village boys
(R¼0.55, p<0.01). It is concluded that the body dimensions of adolescent Nandi town and
village boys corresponds well with findings in Kenyan elite runners. They are very slender
with relatively long legs. In addition, the VO
2max
of the village boys was higher than that of
the town boys, which is probably due to a higher physical activity level of the village boys
during secondary school.
1. Introduction
During the past 35 years, African runners or runners of African ancestry have
produced some of the most remarkable results in athletic events at world-class level.
While the West Africans have excelled in short distance races (100–400 m), the
East Africans, especially Kenyans, have excelled in middle-distance (800–1500 m)
and steeplechase, and also, together with the Ethiopians, in long-distance races
(5000 m—marathon). In fact, >55% of the all-time top 20 lists for men in distances
from 800 m to the marathon are Kenyans. In addition, the majority of the Kenyan
achievements has been produced by a group of eight small tribes called Kalenjin,
which today number only 3.5 million people. Among the Kalenjin tribes, the Nandi
tribe has shown the most profound results. Although this tribe constitutes only 2%
of the Kenyan population, it is the most successful single tribe in Kenya to date
with respect to performance in running. The reasons for this dominance are still
not known, but factors that may play a role are genetic endowment, upbringing and
training.
Success in running events depends on several factors. These include both aerobic
and anaerobic capacities for energy turnover, muscular strength, running economy
as well as biomechanical, psychological and sociological characteristics. So far,
only two studies have examined some physiological differences when comparing
ANNALS OF HUMAN BIOLOGY
MARCH–APRIL 2004, VOL. 31, NO. 2,159–173
Annals of Human Biology ISSN 0301–4460 print/ISSN 1464–5033 online #2004 Taylor & Francis Ltd
http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals
DOI: 10.1080/03014460410001663416
Kenyan athletes with athletes of non-African descent (Saltin et al. 1995a,b).
These studies revealed that Kenyan elite runners have a very high VO
2max
(79.9 mL kg
1
min
1
), but not higher than that observed in Scandinavian elite
runners (79.2 mL kg
1
min
1
). In addition, the studies further demonstrated that
untrained Kenyan boys from a town had a VO
2max
similar to that of untrained
Danish boys described by Andersen et al. (1987). However, Kenyan elite runners
are fostered in small villages and rural areas where physical activity levels are
thought to be higher than in towns. Whether this is true and the degree to which
this may contribute to the development of physiological properties crucial for
performance in middle- and long-distance running is not known. Furthermore, the
studies by Saltin et al. (1995b) revealed that Kenyan elite runners had a highly
proficient running economy compared to Scandinavian elite runners as judged
from oxygen uptake at sub-maximal speeds. Moreover, Kenyan elite runners had
a lower body mass index (BMI) compared to the Scandinavian runners. Dotan et al.
(1983) have demonstrated a moderate relationship between the BMI and marathon
running performance. However, the underlying physiological reasons for this are
not known. Classical studies of human locomotion (Fenn 1930, Cavagna et al.
1964) have indicated that the work of moving the limbs comprises a substantial
part of the metabolic cost of running, just as load-carrying experiments (e.g.
Myers and Steudel 1985) have shown that carrying a few grams of mass on the
feet/ankle evokes an increase in the metabolic rate of running. This indicates that a
low leg mass is advantageous for the running economy. Therefore, it can be specu-
lated whether the low BMI of the Kenyan elite runners implies that these have more
slender limbs than Caucasian elite runners and whether this relates to the observed
superior running economy of the Kenyan runners. In addition, to what degree the
low BMI of Kenyan elite runners compared to Scandinavian elite runners is due
to selection or is a general feature of untrained Kenyans is unknown. Furthermore,
no information is available at present about the running economy of untrained
Kenyans.
In this light the purpose of the present study was to describe body dimensions,
running economy, aerobic power, and related variables and relate them to habitual
daily physical activity level of Nandi town and village boys in western Kenya. The
hypothesis was that the characteristics of east African elite distance runners can be
observed in adolescent Nandi boys regardless of where they live.
2. Methods
2.1. Subjects
Sixty Kenyan boys volunteered for the present study. Before entering the study
all subjects filled in questionnaires encompassing questions related to (a) tribe,
(b) transportation to and from school during childhood, (c) leisure-time activities
and (d) coach-organized training. Based on the questionnaires, 11 town boys and 19
village boys all belonging to the Nandi tribe (verified to the level of grandparents)
not previously engaged in any kind of organized endurance training were selected.
Three Nandi boys were excluded due to illness, while one was excluded due to
insufficient sexual maturation. The remaining 26 boys were excluded due to the
fact that they were not Nandies. All subjects were recruited from two secondary
day schools. The town boys were recruited from Uasin Gishu High School in the
town of Eldoret located in the western part of Kenya, on a plateau at an altitude of
2000 m.a.s.l. Except for two subjects who were raised in a town or city, they were
160 H. B. Larsen et al.
all born and brought up in the rural area around Eldoret. At the age of 14 years,
nine of the subjects had moved to Eldoret in order to begin their studies at secondary
school, while the remaining two subjects continued living in the countryside. The
village boys were recruited from Kamobo Secondary School located in the Nandi
district about 50 km south-west of Eldoret at the same altitude as this town. All
subjects were living in the rural area within a radius of 4 km from the school. Before
entering the study, sexual maturation was assessed by one of the investigators who
evaluated the development of secondary sex characteristics (pubic hair). The method
described by Marshall and Tanner (1970) was employed. The subjects who were
in stage 3 (PH3) or lower were excluded from the study. The vast majority of the
boys who participated were in stage 5 (PH5), while a few boys were in stage 4 (PH4).
The Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Health Sciences at Moi University, Eldoret,
Kenya, approved the study. All subjects and their parents were fully informed orally
as well as in writing of the experimental procedures and possible risks connected with
the study and gave written consent. All subjects were informed that they were free to
withdraw from the study at any time. All subjects were studied at altitude (baro-
metric pressure 595 mmHg). Some physical characteristics, BMI and anthropo-
metric measures (leg length, lower leg length and circumference) of the subjects
are given in table 1.
2.2. Protocol and methods
The date of birth of each subject was assessed by oral information. All subjects
knew in which year they were born. However, one town boy and one village boy
were unaware of their exact date of birth, which was then decided to be 1 July. Body
mass was assessed by using an electronic scale calibrated with known weights. Height
was measured to the nearest millimetre with eye (outer ear orifice being horizontal).
Leg circumference was measured by using a string. Other body dimensions were
measured by using a folding-rule. Lower and total leg length, defined as the distance
from the ground to the middle of the fibula head and the distance from the ground to
the anterior superior iliac spine, respectively, were measured in all boys. In addition,
the distance from the ground to the middle of the lateral malleolus was measured.
All subjects went through sub-maximal and maximal tests on the treadmill. Prior
to these tests, all boys performed two or three (more than 50 min in total) practice
sessions at different days at three different speeds each day to accustom them to
running on a treadmill as well as with the equipment used to determine the respira-
tory variables. The exercise protocol on the treadmill consisted of a 10-min warm-up
Table 1. Some physical characteristics, BMI and anthropometric measures (leg length, lower leg
length and lower leg circumference) of Nandi town and village boys. Mean valuesSD and
ranges are given.
n
Age
(years)
Mass
(kg)
Height
(cm)
BMI
(kg m
2
)
Leg length
(cm)
Lower leg
length (cm)
Lower leg
circumference
(cm)
Town boys 11 16.6 0.7 53.8 8.1 169.5 7.7 18.6 1.5 101.25.3 45.5 2.9 –
15.7–17.5 41.3–64.7 157–183 15.7–20.5 94–113 41–51
Village boys 19 16.6 0.8 53.3 5.3 170.4 7.9 18.4 1.6 101.9 4.9
y
45.4 3.0
y
31.9 1.7
z
15.2–18.4 45.4–63.2 158–187 15.3–20.5 94–111 43–54 29.8–34.9
yn¼15; zn¼12.
Physical characteristics of Kenyan Nandi boys 161
at speeds from 6.0 to 10.0 km h
1
. After 7–10 min of rest, the subjects ran 7 and
6 min, respectively, at two different individual speeds, with 0.5–1.0 min of rest in
between. The two speeds were chosen to demand a heart rate of 150155
(6.0–11.5 km h
1
) and 165–175 (8.0–14.0 km h
1
) beats per minute (b.p.m.),
respectively. In order to be able to calculate exact running economy, body mass
including test equipment was measured immediately before and after the test.
After 10 min of rest, the maximal test was performed at speeds from 13.0 to
17.5 km h
1
. The test started without inclination, and every second minute the
inclination was raised by 2% until exhaustion. During the last 1.5 min at each
sub-maximal speed, the expired air was collected in Douglas bags, while it was
collected continuously during the maximal test. Heart rate was measured continu-
ously during all tests, while a blood sample was taken from a superficial arm vein
at rest and during the last 15 s of each sub-maximal run or immediately after this.
Furthermore, blood samples were taken at rest shortly before the maximal run and 1
and 3 min, respectively, after this test. The oxygen uptake was calculated after meas-
uring the volume of expired air with a gasmeter (London Gasmeter Co.) calibrated
with a Tissot spirometer and the fractions of O
2
and CO
2
using a Servomex S-3 A/I
and a Beckman LB-2, respectively. Heart rate was monitored with a telemetric
system (Polar Accurex Plus, Polar Electro, Finland). The blood samples were
analysed for lactate and ammonia (Kun and Kearney 1974). Haemoglobin was
determined spectrophotometrically on blood taken from a fingertip or from a super-
ficial arm vein after the subjects had been resting in supine position for 5–10 min.
2.3. Physical activity level
To obtain information about the boys’ physical activity level during childhood,
each of them was interviewed by one of the investigators using a standardized
formula encompassing questions related to (a) duties at home involving physical
activity, (b) transportation to and from school, (c) sport activities during a day in
school, and (d) leisure time activities. Furthermore, during secondary school, the
boys filled in questionnaires of their habitual physical activity level from hour to
hour during 6 days on the average. Two different kinds of questionnaires were
employed. In one of these the subjects stated how far they were walking/running
each day to and from school and which kind of physical activities they were doing
during the day. In the other questionnaire the subjects reported how many minutes
they were physically active daily at five different activity levels from lying/sitting to
fast running. Using the initial questionnaires, which the subjects filled in before
entering the study, checked up the information concerning distance between home
and school from the first of these questionnaires. In addition, to obtain more exact
measures of the physical activity level of each subject, heart rate was recorded every
minute during 24 h using telemetric heart rate monitors.
2.4. Statistics
The statistics included the calculations of means, standard deviation and test for
group differences (Siegel 1956). The significance of differences between conditions
was tested using the paired t-test. Differences between conditions were considered
significant at the 95% confidence level.
162 H. B. Larsen et al.
3. Results
3.1. Physical characteristics, BMI and anthropometric measures (table 1)
Both the town and the village boys were small and light, and their BMIs were 18.6
and 18.4 kg m
1
, respectively. Both groups of boys had long and slender legs, with no
difference between groups.
3.2. Exercise data and haemoglobin (tables 2 and 3)
The maximal oxygen uptake of the town boys was 50.2 mL kg
1
min
1
, while the
corresponding value for the village boys was 10% higher (55.1 mL kg
1
min
1
,
p<0.01). Of note is the large range of VO
2max
observed in the village boys. There
were no other differences in the maximal exercise values between the town and
village boys. The values of haemoglobin were low (8.8 vs 8.6 mmol L
1
, respectively),
taking the altitude into consideration. The village boys could run at a slightly higher
sub-maximal speed with given sub-maximal heart rate and blood lactate level com-
pared to the town boys.
3.3. Running economy (table 4)
The oxygen cost of running was the same for the town and village boys when
expressed per kilogram (220.6 vs 221.1 mL kg
1
km
1
) as well as per 0.75 kg (597.4 vs
596.4 mL kg
0.75
km
1
) of body weight.
Table 2. VO
2max
, maximal heart rate (HR
max
) and peak blood lactate (Hla
max
) and ammonia
(NH
3max
) concentration in untrained Nandi town or village boys. Mean values SD and ranges
are given.
VO
2max
n(L min
1
) (mLkg
1
min
1
) (mL kg
0.75
min
1
)
HR
max
(b.p.m.)
Hla
max
(mmol L
1
)
NH
3max
(mmol L
1
)
Town boys 11 2.71 0.51 50.2 4.2 135.9 13.8 196.9 11.0 9.8 2.5
}
226.8 65.9
ô
1.98–3.58 45.4–60.2 121.7–167.3 172–206 7.1–13.9 114–328
Village boys 19 2.94 0.46 55.15.3
y
148.9 15.6
z
197.1 6.4 9.4 1.9** 218.7 54.6**
1.98–3.87 37.4–62.8 100.8–174.9 186–209 6.2–12.8 113–281
Significantly different from town boys: yp<0.01; zp<0.02.
}n¼9; ôn¼8; ** n¼13.
Table 3. Sub-maximal test speeds, heart rate, blood lactate and ammonia concentration for Nandi
town and village boys. Mean values SD and ranges are given.
n
Test speed Heart rate Blood lactate NH
3
(km h
1
) (b.p.m.) (mmol L
1
)(mmol L
1
)
Town boys 10 8.3 1.5 152 7.0 2.0 0.8
y
89.6 17.9
y
6.0–10.5 139–167 1.0–3.4 72.0–128.5
10 10.21.4 171 10.8 2.7 1.1
y
98.0 25.1
y
8.0–12.0 161–179 1.4–4.5 70.0–151.0
Village boys 19 8.7 1.0 153 9.0 1.9 0.4
z
93.4 18.0
z
7.5–11.5 139–169 1.4–2.9 58.5–117.5
19 10.81.0 170 8.2 2.5 0.7
z
101.3 22.7
z
9.5–14.0 152–186 1.2–3.3 66.0–133.0
yn¼8; zn¼15.
Physical characteristics of Kenyan Nandi boys 163
3.4. Habitual physical activity during childhood (table 5)
Except for two town boys who were born and raised in a town/city, all town boys
as well as all village boys reported that they had been living in a village or a rural
area during childhood. The mean distance between home and primary school was 2.5
(0.5–3.5) km and 2.1 (1.0–4.0)km, respectively, for town and village boys. One
town boy reported that he was running to school daily in the morning, two town
boys were running to school if they were late, while two town boys reported that they
walked/ran to and from school. Six town boys reported that they were walking to
school, while nine town boys were walking back home every day. Four village boys
reported that they were walking/running to and from primary school, while 11
village boys reported that they were walking both ways. At the age of 4–12 both
town and village boys reported that they had many duties at home. The main duties
were cattle herding and field work (table 5). Both groups of boys were most active
herding cattle and working in the field before starting primary school. Some of the
fieldwork was made using manual power, while some was made using engine power.
Other duties included washing clothes, shopping and fetching water and firewood.
No differences were observed between the two groups of boys in any physical activity
related to duties at home. In addition, both town and village boys were active doing
sports while at school as well as after school, but no differences were observed
between the two groups (table 5).
3.5. Habitual physical activity level during secondary school (table 6,figure 1)
The mean distance between home and secondary school was 2.5 (1.0–4.0) and
3.0 (1.04.0) km, respectively, for town and village boys. Both groups of boys were
Table 5. Major activities before and during the years at primary school in town and village boys.
The percentage of boys involved in each activity in varying number of days is given. The data are
based on interviews of 11 town boys and 15 village boys.
Cattle herding Fieldwork
Sports activities after
start at primary school
Before start
at primary
school
(%)
After start
at primary
school
(%)
Before start
at primary
school
(%)
After start
at primary
school
(%)
During a day
in school
(%)
After school
time
(%)
Almost
every day
town boys 64 36 55 27 45 27
village boys 73 33 27 27 53 20
3–5 days/week town boys 18 36 36 9 18 18
village boys 13 27 27 40 27 33
<2 days/week town boys 18 27 9 55 27 45
village boys 13 40 47 33 20 40
Table 4. Running economy of Nandi town and village boys measured at 10.15 and 10.79 km h
1
on average, respectively. Mean values SD and ranges are given.
n
Test speed
VO
2
(km h
1
) (mL kg
1
min
1
) (mL kg
1
km
1
) (mL kg
0.75
km
1
)
Town boys 10 10.15 1.4 37.0 3.9 220.6 21.5 597.4 56.0
8.0–12.0 32–45 179–246 509–683
Village boys 14 10.79 1.2 39.6 3.5 221.1 17.9 596.4 39.2
9.5–14.0 35–49 187–237 511–669
164 H. B. Larsen et al.
walking about 3 km on average per day (table 6). Even though the distance covered
daily by running was greater for the village boys compared to the town boys, none of
the two groups of boys did much running (0.3 vs 0.9 km day
1
,p<0.05). The time
spent daily doing sports activities (mainly football and volleyball) was approximately
half an hour for the village boys. This was 150% more than for the town boys
(p<0.02). The village boys were working for about three-quarters of an hour
in the field per day. This was considerably more than the town boys, of whom
only one subject was working in the field ( p<0.01). Of note is also that the time
spent daily herding cattle was very limited for both groups of boys. The 24 h heart-
rate recordings in nine village boys demonstrated a rather low physical activity level
of these boys. Thus, a heart rate above 120 beats min
1
was achieved only during
23 min day (24 h)
1
(figure 1).
4. Discussion
The body proportions of the Nandi boys are indeed much smaller compared to
Caucasian boys of almost the same age (Andersen 1994). The height of the Kenyan
Figure 1. Mean duration (mean SD) of heart rates at different frequencies recorded every minute
during 24 h in nine Nandi village boys.
Table 6. Habitual daily physical activity during six randomly selected days in secondary school for
town and village boys. Mean values SD and ranges are given.
n
Walking Running Sports activities Work (field) Cattle herding
(km day
1
) (km day
1
) (min day
1
) (min day
1
) (min day
1
)
Town boys 9 3.3 2.4 0.3 0.4 12.8 11.8 1.3 3.8 0.0 0.0
0.05.2 0.01.1 0–35 011 00
Village boys 13 2.9 1.7 0.90.9
y
32.0 17.3
z
44.2 41.6
z
9.0 14.9
0.56.5 0.02.8 11–72 0128 047
Significantly different from town boys: yp<0.05; zp<0.01.
Physical characteristics of Kenyan Nandi boys 165
boys is 9 cm lower, while the body mass is 12 kg lower. In addition, the BMI is
2kgm
2
lower compared to the Caucasian boys, which shows that the Nandi boys
have a much more slender body shape than the Caucasian boys (table 7, figure 2). In
addition, except for the Caucasians, the Nandi boys have similar height or tend to be
marginally taller compared to the other ethnic groups presented in table 7, whereas
the body mass of the Nandi boys, except for the Indians (Pathmanathan and
Prakash 1994), is similar to or lower compared to the other groups of boys.
However, the fact that the Nandi boys are relatively high, when taking their low
mass into consideration, implies that they have a very low BMI compared to almost
all the other groups of boys (figure 2). In fact, the only group with a BMI that tends
to be lower than that of the Nandis is the Indian boys. However, these boys are 0.8
years younger than the Nandi boys. The BMI of 17-year-old South African Indian
boys (Walker et al. 1989) actually tends to be higher than the BMI of the Nandi
boys. Three other ethnic groups of boys (Ethiopians (Peters et al. 1987), black South
Africans from the rural area (Walker et al. 1980) and Hong Kong Chinese (Barnett
et al. 1995) (table 7)) tend to have higher BMIs than the Nandi boys. Ethiopians as
well as black South Africans are of interest since both peoples have produced some
remarkable results in distance running. As the number of Ethiopian boys measured
Table 7. Summary table of studies examining height, mass and BMI of adolescent boys of different
ethnic origin.
Study Subject population n
Age
(years)
Height
(cm)
Body mass
(kg)
BMI
(kg m
2
)
Kobayashi et al. 1978 Japanese 43 17.2 168.9 58.2 20.4
Barnett et al. 1995 Hong Kong Chinese 22 16.1 165.7 52.7 19.2
Walker et al. 1989 South African Indian 77 17 169.9 54.8 19.0
Pathmanathan and
Prakash 1994
Indian 20 15.8 164.9 48.8 18.0
Wacharasindhu et al. 2002 Thai 53 16.6 170.8
Andersen 1994 Danish 4511 17 179.6
Danish 4549 17 66.0
Danish 4464 17 20.4
Becker-Christensen 2002 Greenlanders 16 16.9 169.9 63.9 22.1
da Silva and Malina 2000 Brazilian 125 15.0 166.7 55.1 19.7
Sichieri et al. 1995 Brazilian 608 17 167.8 57.4
y
20.4
Spurgeon and Meredith
1979
US blacks 219 15 167.2 56.6 20.2
US whites 186 15 169.4 57.1 19.9
Rosner et al. 1998 US blacks 1417 17 22.8
US whites 1680 17 22.7
US Hispanic 251 17 23.2
Zavaleta and Malina 1980 Mexican–American 55 16.5 168.2 64.3 22.7
Mukhtar et al. 1989 Libyan 44 17 172.4 66.4 22.3
Ibu et al. 1986 Nigerian 26 17 165.6 60.8 22.2
Peters et al. 1987 Ethiopian 7 16–17 167.9 53.9 19.1
Walker et al. 1980 Black South Africans,
rural
148 17 167.0 53.5 19.2
Black South Africans,
urban
151 17 168.2 55.9 19.8
Present study Kenyan Nandi
town boys
11 16.6 169.5 53.8 18.6
Kenyan Nandi
village boys
19 16.6 170.4 53.3 18.4
ycalculated from BMI and height.
166 H. B. Larsen et al.
in the study by Peters et al. (1987) is small (n¼7), and Ethiopian adults (n¼156)
investigated in the same study had BMIs of 18.8 kg m
2
, while Kenyan elite
runners (primarily Nandis) had 19.2 kg m
2
(Saltin et al. 1995b), this indicates
that Ethiopians are at least just as slender as Kenyan Nandis.
The BMIs of several groups of boys of different ethnic origin are in sharp contrast
to the BMIs of the Nandi boys. Thus, the BMIs of Nigerians (Ibu et al. 1986),
Libyans (Mukhtar et al. 1989), US blacks, whites and Hispanic (Rosner 1998),
Mexican–Americans (Zavaleta and Malina 1980) and Greenlanders (Becker-
Christensen 2002) are 4–5 kg m
2
(20–25%) higher compared to the BMIs of the
Nandi boys. It is of note that international results in long-distance running produced
by these people today are very scarce.
The fact that the proportion of leg length to total height changes only marginally
beyond the age of 16 years (Hertel et al. 1995) allows us to compare the percentage of
leg length to stature between the Kenyan boys and Caucasian adults. By subtracting
the distance from the ground to the middle of the lateral malleolus from the leg
length of the Kenyan boys, a direct comparison of leg length between these boys
and Caucasian elite runners described by Svedenhag and Sjo
¨din (1994) becomes
possible. This comparison reveals that the relative leg length of the Nandi town
and village boys is considerably longer compared to the Caucasian elite runners
Figure 2. BMIs of Nandi town and village boys and of adolescent boys of different ethnic origin.
a
and
b
refer to two different investigations of the same people presented in table 7.
Physical characteristics of Kenyan Nandi boys 167
(55.2 and 55.5 vs 52.8%). In addition, the relative leg length of the Nandi boys is
very consistent with findings on Kenyan elite runners (H. B. Larsen et al., unpub-
lished observation). Furthermore, the relatively long legs of the Nandis is in line
with earlier findings in a study comparing tibial length between six different ethnic
minorities of East African origin and Caucasians (Allbrook 1961). This study
revealed that four of these groups had longer tibial length in absolute terms than
the Caucasians despite the fact that their stature was smaller. In addition, the rela-
tive tibial length was longer in the remaining two African groups compared to
Caucasians. Furthermore, the relatively long legs of the Nandi boys is in line with
findings in a study of 15-year-old African boys and adults from a large variety of
African countries (Meredith 1979) as well as findings in a study comparing 15-year-
old black American boys with white American boys (Spurgeon and Meredith 1979).
These investigations have shown a longer lower limb length relative to sitting height
(skelic index) of blacks compared to Caucasian boys (table 8). Additionally, as
the sitting height relative to height seems to be greater in Japanese (Ali et al. 2000),
Thai (Wacharasindhu et al. 2002), and Greenlanders (Becker-Christensen 2002)
boys compared to Caucasian boys (Hertel et al. 1995, table 8), this implies that the
relative leg length of the Nandi boys is considerably longer compared to these groups
of boys. In contrast, however, as many studies of adult Australian aborigines
have shown a very low sitting height relative to total height (Norgan 1994, table 8),
Table 8. Summary table of studies examining sitting height relative to height, skelic index (leg
length relative to sitting height) and leg length (distance from the middle of the lateral malleolus
to the anterior superior iliac spine) relative to height in adolescent boys and adults of different
ethnic origin.
Study Subject population n
Age
(years)
Sitting height/
height ratio
Skelic
index
Leg length/
height ratio
Ali et al. 2000 Japanese 17 0.534
Pathmanathan and
Prakash 1994
Indian 20 15.8 0.515
Wacharasindhu et al.
2002
Thai 53 16.6 0.527
Hertel et al. 1995 Danish 16.5 0.520
Becker-Christensen 2002 Greenlanders 16 16.9 0.531
Norgan 1994, review
based on 17 different
investigations
(1937–1977)
Australian aborigines 917 adults 0.488
Spurgeon and Meredith
1979
US whites 186 15 0.524 91.1
US blacks 219 15 0.506 97.7
Meredith 1979, review,
three studies
Black Africans >75 15 96–105
Five studies US blacks >290 15 98–101
Three studies US blacks 146 17 98–99
14 studies Black Africans 3223 adults 94–115
Two studies US blacks 987 adults 94–99
Svedenhag and Sjo
¨din
1994
Swedish elite runners 26 23.4 0.528
Present study Kenyan Nandi
town boys
11 16.6 0.552
Kenyan Nandi
village boys
19 16.6 0.555
168 H. B. Larsen et al.
this indicates that these people have similar or even longer relative leg length
compared to the Nandis.
Finally, as the study by Spurgeon and Meredith (1979) demonstrated that
the 15-year-old black American as well as Caucasian boys, who were considerably
shorter and lighter than Caucasian boys (Andersen 1994) of almost the same age
as the Nandi boys, had calf circumferences of 33.5 and 34.0 cm, respectively, this
indicates that the Nandi boys (calf circumference of 31.9 cm, table 1) have more
slender limbs in absolute terms compared to black American and Caucasian boys
of the same age.
Since the boys in this study volunteered for the investigation it may be speculated
whether they constitute a representative sample of Nandi boys. However, when
comparing the boys in the present study with an equally large sample of randomly
recruited Nandi boys and boys from other Kalenjin tribes (H. B. Larsen et al.,
unpublished observation) no differences were observed with respect to height,
weight, BMI or leg length.
4.1. Running economy (table 4)
The running economy of the two groups of Kenyan boys seems to be better than
what has been observed previously in untrained Caucasian boys of the same age,
irrespective of whether the oxygen cost is expressed per kilogram or per 0.75 kg
of body mass (A
˚strand 1952, Sjo
¨din and Svedenhag 1992). This indicates that the
superior running economy of the Nandi boys is due to inherent factors. Accordingly,
genetic factors may also partially or fully explain the previously observed superior
running economy of Kenyan world elite runners compared to Caucasian elite run-
ners (Saltin et al. 1995b). In addition, the fact that no difference in running economy
was observed between Nandi town and village boys indicates that the higher physical
activity level of the village boys during secondary school has limited or no effect on
running economy.
4.2. Maximal oxygen uptake and physical activity level (tables 2,5 and 6,
figure 1)
The maximal oxygen consumption of the Nandi town boys is in line with previous
findings on untrained Kenyan boys from the same town (Saltin et al. 1995b), and
also similar to VO
2max
of untrained Caucasian boys (Andersen et al. 1987). However,
it can be argued that the maximal oxygen uptake of the town boys is higher com-
pared to untrained Caucasian boys due to the fact that the VO
2max
of the town boys
is reduced because they were tested at altitude. If measured at sea level, the VO
2max
of these boys would probably have been 3–5% higher (Favier et al. 1995). However,
if the VO
2max
of the Kenyan town boys is adjusted to sea level by adding 3–5% and
thus tends to be higher than VO
2max
of untrained Caucasian boys, this difference
is equalized when normalizing the data for differences in body mass (by using mass
to an exponent of 0.75 instead of 1, since the mass of the Nandi boys is about 12 kg
less than the mass of Caucasian boys of the same age (table 7)). ‘Scaling’ is used
in this relationship because it has proven useful in order to compare humans with
differences in body mass. Here 0.75 has been chosen, because Svedenhag (1995), who
has been studying adolescent runners, their VO
2max
and their running economy,
preferred to use this exponent. The maximal oxygen uptake of the Nandi village
boys was about 10% higher than the VO
2max
of the town boys, which may be due
to the higher physical activity level of the village boys. It is difficult to interpret
Physical characteristics of Kenyan Nandi boys 169
the information concerning the physical activity level during childhood given by the
subjects based on interviews, because no information is available about the duration
or intensity of the different kinds of physical activity (table 5). However, based on
the interviews, there is no indication of a different physical activity pattern between
the two groups of boys until they began their secondary school education. After
starting secondary school, the habitual physical activity level of the village boys was
significantly higher compared to the town boys. The question is therefore whether
the difference in physical activity can explain the observed difference in VO
2max
.It
is true that the duration of the physical activity of the village boys is consider-
ably longer compared to the town boys, but the intensity of the main part of this
activity may be much too low to stimulate VO
2max
for subjects consuming
50–55 mL kg
1
min
1
of oxygen maximally, since the ‘training threshold’ for these
subjects probably is an exercise intensity demanding a heart rate in the range of 135–
145 b.p.m (Larsen 2001). The 24-h heart rate recordings support this assumption,
even though these data must be interpreted with caution due to the low number of
recordings (figure 1). Thus, these recordings indicate that the duration of the period
during which the heart rate is above the necessary level needed to stimulate VO
2max
is
only 10–15 min day
1
. However, although not generally agreed (Milesis et al. 1976),
it has been demonstrated previously (Davies and Knibbs 1971) that only a 10-min
difference in the duration of short (10 min vs 20 min) daily exercise sessions (5 days
per week) can induce a different increase in the VO
2max
in previously untrained
subjects. Therefore, taking both the questionnaires and the heart-rate recordings
into consideration, the observed higher VO
2max
of the village boys compared to
the town boys may be due to the higher physical activity level of the village boys.
This view gets support when studying the relationship between the time spent daily
doing sports and VO
2max
. While no correlation was found for the town boys, a trend
for a relationship was observed for the village boys (R¼0.52, p<0.07). When pool-
ing the data from both groups of boys a moderate correlation was found (R¼0.55,
p<0.01). Somewhat surprisingly, none of the boys in the two groups did much
running between home and school, partially because the main distance was short,
but also because that those who were running reported that they were only doing so
when they wanted to avoid being late for school. The most distinct difference in the
activity pattern between the village and the town boys was expressed through the
games of football and volleyball as well as working in the field after school time
and during the weekends. Even though the maximal oxygen uptake of the village
boys was somewhat higher than the VO
2max
of the town boys, it is much lower than
the level reported previously for Kenyan junior runners who had a level of
64 mL kg
1
min
1
(Saltin et al. 1995b). This means that the daily physical activity
of the boys in the rural area does not give sufficient physiological stimulus in order to
reach the level needed to become an elite runner. However, some of the observed
difference in VO
2max
between the village boys in the present study and the junior
runners studied by Saltin et al. (1995b) is probably due to the fact that the junior
runners were selected.
The observed values of haemoglobin for both groups of Nandi boys are very low
when taking the altitude into consideration. This is probably due to the fact that all
village boys (n¼12) and half of the town boys (n¼4) who were studied with respect
to malaria reported that they had suffered from this disease.
This investigation demonstrated that the principal features with respect to body
dimensions of adolescent Kenyan Nandi town and village boys compares well with
170 H. B. Larsen et al.
findings in Kenyan elite runners. Thus, the Nandi boys have a very low BMI and
thus a slender body shape with relatively long and slender legs. In addition, the
study indicated that the oxygen cost when running is lower in untrained Kenyans
compared to untrained Caucasians and that this may be due to inherent factors.
Furthermore, the study demonstrated that Nandi boys from a rural area have a
higher capacity with respect to some physiological properties needed to become an
elite runner compared to Nandi town boys. Moreover, the study indicated that the
physical activity level of Nandi village boys is higher during secondary school com-
pared to Nandi town boys, which probably explains the observed higher maximal
oxygen uptake of the village boys.
Acknowledgements
The authors are grateful to all participating boys and their parents. We thank
Christian Borch for performing interviews and NIKE Danmark and Johnny Nielsen
for supplying all subjects with running shoes and sports equipment. The study was
supported by grants from TEAM DANMARK Research Foundation and the
Danish Ministry of Culture.
References
Ali, A., Uetake, T., and Ohtsuki, F., 2000, Secular changes in relative leg length in post-war Japan.
American Journal of Human Biology,12, 405–416.
Allbrook, D., 1961, The estimation of stature in British and East African males. Journal of Forensic
Medicine,8, 15–28.
Andersen, L. B., 1994, Blood pressure, physical fitness and physical activity in 17-year-old Danish
adolescents. Journal of Internal Medicine,236, 323–330.
Andersen, L. B., Henckel, P., and Saltin, B., 1987, Maximal oxygen uptake in Danish adolescents
16–19 years of age. European Journal of Applied Physiology,56, 74–82.
A
˚strand, P. O., 1952, Experimental Studies of Physical Working Capacity in Relation to Sex and Age
(Copenhagen: Ejnar Munksgaard).
Barnett, A., Bacon-Shone, J., Tam, K. H., Leung, M., and Armstrong, N., 1995, Peak oxygen uptake
of 12–18-year-old boys living in a densely populated urban environment. Annals of Human Biology,
22, 525–532.
Becker-Christensen, F. G., 2002, Growth in Greenland: development of body proportions and
menarcheal age in Greenlandic children. Ugeskrift for Læger,164, 906–910.
Cavagna, G. A., Saibene, F. P., and Margaria, R., 1964, Mechanical work in running. Journal of
Applied Physiology,19, 249–256.
DaSilva, R. C. R., and Malina, R. M., 2000, Level of physical activity in adolescents from Nitero
´i,
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Cadernos de Sau
´de Pu
´blica,16, 1091–1097.
Davies, C. T. M., and Knibbs, A. V., 1971, The training stimulus. The effects of intensity, duration and
frequency of effort on maximum aerobic power output. Int Z angew Physiology,29, 299–305.
Dotan, R., Rotstein, R., Dlin, R., Inbar, O., Kofman, H., and Kaplansky, Y., 1983, Relationships
of marathon running to physiological, anthropometric and training indices. European Journal of
Applied Physiology,51, 281–293.
Favier, R., Spielvogel, H., Desplanches, D., Ferretti, G., Kayser, B., and Hoppeler, H., 1995,
Maximal exercise performance in cronic hypoxia and acute normoxia in high-altitude natives.
Journal of Applied Physiology,78, 1868–1874.
Fenn, W. O., 1930, Frictional and kinetic factors in the work of sprint running. American Journal of
Physiology,92, 583–611.
Hertel, N. T., Scheike, T., Juul, A., Main, K. M., Holm, K., Bach-Mortensen, N.,
Skakkebk, N. E., and Mu
«ller, J. R., 1995, Body proportions in Danish children. Growth
curves for sitting height, sitting height ratio, subischial leg length and arm span. Ugeskrift for
Læger,157, 6876–6881.
Ibu, J. O., Ofuya, Z. M., Nyong, E. A., and Nwosu, J. O., 1986, Anthropometric estimation of
basal metabolic rate in Nigerian children and adolescents of Niger Delta region of Nigeria.
Scandinavian Journal of Gastroenterology,21, 187–202.
Kobayashi, K., Kitamura, K., Miura, M., Sodeyama, H., Murase, Y., Miyashita, M., and
Matsui, H., 1978, Aerobic power as related to body growth and training in Japanese boys:
a longitudinal study. Journal of Applied Physiology,44, 666–672.
Physical characteristics of Kenyan Nandi boys 171
Kun, E., and Kearney, E. B., 1974, Ammonia. In Methods of Enzymatic Analysis, edited by
H. U. Bergmeyer (New York: Academic Press), pp. 1802–1805.
Larsen, H., 2001, Training principles in distance running. In Running and Science, edited by J. Bangsbo
and H. B. Larsen (Copenhagen: Munksgaard), pp. 125–126.
Marshall, W. A., and Tanner, J. M., 1970, Variations in the pattern of pubertal changes in boys.
Archives of Disease in Childhood,45, 13–23.
Meredith, H. V., 1979, Relationship of lower limb height to sitting height in black populations of Africa
and the United States. American Journal of Physical Anthropology,51, 63–66.
Milesis, C. A., Pollock, M. L., Bah, M. D., Ayres, J. J., Ward, A., and Linnerud, A. C., 1976, Effects
of different duration of physical training on cardiorespiratory function, body composition, and
serum lipids. Research Quarterly,47, 716–725.
Mukhtar, M.-S. R., Rao, G. M., and Morghom, L. O., 1989, Peak expiratory flow rates in Libyan
adolescents. Indian Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology,33, 223–227.
Myers, M. J., and Steudel, K., 1985. Effect of limb mass and its distribution on the energetic cost of
running. Journal of Experimental Biology,116, 363–373.
Norgan, N. G., 1994, Interpretation of low body mass indices: Australian aborigines. American Journal
of Physical Anthropology,94, 229–237.
Pathmanathan, G., and Prakash, S., 1994, Growth of sitting height, subischial leg length and weight in
well-off northwestern Indian children. Annals of Human Biology,21, 325–334.
Peters,W.-H., Keller, E., Abdi, F., Selassie, A. W., and Tadigo, D., 1987, A preliminary anthropo-
metric study (body weight, body height, body-mass index) of Ethiopian schoolchildren and college
students. Die Nahrung,31, 145–148.
Rosner, B., Prineas, R., Loggie, J., and Daniels, S. R., 1998, Percentiles for body mass index in U.S.
children 5 to 17 years of age. Journal of Pediatrics,132, 193–195.
Saltin, B., Kim, C. K., Terrados, N., Larsen, H., Svedenhag, J., and Rolf, C. J., 1995a, Morphology,
enzyme activities and buffer capacity in leg muscles of Kenyan and Scandinavian Runners.
Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports,5, 222–230.
Saltin, B., Larsen, H., Terrados, N., Bangsbo, J., Bak, T., Kim, C. K., Svedenhag, J., and Rolf, C. J.,
1995b, Aerobic exercise capacity at sea level and at altitude in Kenyan boys, junior and senior
runners compared with Scandinavian runners. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in
Sports,5, 209–221.
Sichieri, R., Recine, E., and Everhart, J. E., 1995, Growth and body mass index of Brazilians ages 9
through 17 years. Obesity Research,3, 117s–121s.
Siegel, S., 1956, Nonparametric Statistics for the Behavioural Sciences (New York: McGraw-Hill).
Sjo
«din, B., and Svedenhag, J., 1992, Oxygen uptake during running as related to body mass in circum-
pubertal boys: a longitudinal study. European Journal of Applied Physiology,65, 150–157.
Spurgeon, J. H., and Meredith, H. V., 1979, Body size and form of black and white male youths: South
Carolina youths compared with youths measured at earlier times and other places. Human Biology,
51, 187–200.
Svedenhag, J., 1995, Maximal and submaximal oxygen uptake during running: how should body mass
be accounted for? Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports,5, 175–180.
Svedenhag, J., and Sjo
«din, B., 1994, Body-mass-modified running economy and step length in elite male
middle- and long-distance runners. International Journal of Sports Medicine,15, 305–310.
Wacharasindhu, S., Aroonparkmongkol, S., Supattapisan, S., and Yodvisitsak, W., 2002, Sitting
height and subischial leg length of Thai schoolboys in Bangkok. Journal of the Medical Association
of Thailand,85, S262–S270.
Walker, A. R. P., Walker, B. F., Daya, L., and Ncongwane, J., 1980, Blood pressures of South
African Black adolescents aged 16 to 17 years. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene,74, 595–600.
Walker, A. R. P., Walker, B. F., Jones, J., and Kadwa, M., 1989, Growth of South African Indian
schoolchildren in different social classes. Journal of the Royal Society of Health,2, 54–56.
Zavaleta, A. N., and Malina, R. M., 1980, Growth, fatness, and leanness in Mexican–American
children. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,33, 2008–2020.
Address for correspondence: Henrik B. Larsen, The Copenhagen Muscle Research Centre,
Rigshospitalet, Section 7652, Blegdamsvej 9, DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø, Denmark. e-mail: hboegh@
cmrc.dk
Zusammenfassung. Das Ziel dieser Studie war die Charakterisierung von untrainierten Nandi Knaben
aus einer Stadt (n ¼11) und einer la
¨ndlichen Gegend (n ¼19) im Alter von 16,6 Jahren aus Westkenia
(Ho
¨he 2000 Meter u
¨ber Meeresspiegel) hinsichtlich Ko
¨rpermaße, Sauerstoffaufnahme und sportlicher
Aktivita
¨t. Die Knaben aus der Stadt hatten eine maximale Sauerstoffaufnahme (Vo
2max
) von 50 (45–
60) ml kg min
1
,wa
¨hrend die Dorfknaben einen Wert (Vo
2max
) von 55 (37–63) ml kg min
1
(P <
0,01) aufwiesen. Die Laufo
¨konomie, gemessen am Sauerstoffbedarf bei vorgegebener
Laufgeschwindigkeit, war fu
¨r Stadt- und Dorfknaben jeweils 221 ml kg
1
km
1
(597 ml kg
0.75
km
1
).
172 H. B. Larsen et al.
km
1
). Der Ko
¨rpermasse-Index (body mass index, BMI) war sowohl bei den Stadt- als auch bei den
Dorfknaben sehr niedrig (18,6 bzw. 18,4 kg m
2
). Wa
¨hrend der Schulzeit verbrachten Dorfknaben im
Mittel pro Tag signifikant mehr Zeit bei Arbeiten auf dem Feld und beim Sport im Freien als Stadtknaben
(44,2 (0-128) gegenu
¨ber 1,3 (0-11) min, P<0,01 und 32,0 (11-72) gegenu
¨ber 12,8 (0-35) min, P<0,01). Es
wurde eine positive Korrelation zwischen der Zeit, die ta
¨glich beim Sport verbracht wurde, und Vo
2max
gefunden, wenn die Daten von Stadt- und Dorfknaben gemeinsam betrachtet wurden (R¼0.55, P<0.01).
Zusammenfassend wird festgestellt, dass die Ko
¨rpermaße jugendlicher Nandi Knaben aus sta
¨dtischem und
la
¨ndlichem Umfeld gut mit Befunden u
¨bereinstimmen, die bei Kenianischen Elite-La
¨ufern erhoben wur-
den. Sie sind sehr mager und haben relativ lange Beine. Daru
¨ber hinaus ist die Vo
2max
von Dorfknaben
ho
¨her als die von Stadtknaben, was vermutlich auf die gro
¨ßere sportliche Beta
¨tigung wa
¨hrend der
Schulzeit zuru
¨ckzufu
¨hren ist.
Re
´sume
´.Cette e
´tude a pour but de caracte
´riser des garc¸ ons Nandi citadins (n ¼11) et ruraux (n ¼19) non
entraıˆ ne
´setaˆ ge
´s de 16,6 ans, de l’ouest du Kenya (altitude 2000m) par rapport a
`leurs dimensions
corporelles, leur consommation d’oxyge
`ne et le niveau de leur activite
´physique. Les garc¸ ons citadins
ont une moyenne de consommation d’oxyge
`ne maximale (Vo
2max
) de 50 (45-60) ml kg min
1
alors que
les ruraux atteignent une valeur de 55 (37-63) ml kg min
1
(P<0,01). L’e
´conomie de course de
´termine
´e
comme le cou
ˆt d’oxyge
`ne lors d’une course a
`vitesse donne
´e, est de 221 ml kg
1
km
1
(597 ml kg
0,75
km
1
) aussi bien pour les citadins que pour les ruraux. L’indice de masse corporelle
(IMC) est tre
`s bas chez les citadins comme chez les ruraux (respectivement 18,6 et 18,4 kg m
2
). Le
temps passe
´en moyenne a
`des travaux a
`l’exte
´rieur et a
`des activite
´s sportives dans le cadre de l’e
´cole
secondaire, est significativement plus e
´leve
´chez les ruraux que chez les urbains (respectivement (44,2 (0-
128) contre 1.3 (0-11) min, P<0.01 et 32,0 (11-72) contre 12.8 (0-35) min, P<0.01 ). Apre
`s regroupement
des donne
´es des deux e
´chantillons, on trouve une corre
´lation positive entre le temps passe
´quotidienne-
ment en activite
´sportive et le Vo
2max
(R ¼0,55 P<0.01). On conclut que les dimensions corporelles des
adolescents citadins et ruraux Nandi correspondent bien aux caracte
´ristiques des coureurs d’e
´lite du
Ke
´nya. Ils sont tre
`s minces avec des jambes relativement longues. De surcroıˆ t, le Vo
2max
des garc¸ ons
ruraux est plus e
´leve
´que celui de leurs homologues citadins, ce qui est probablement l’expression d’un
niveau d’activite
´physique plus e
´leve
´chez les ruraux dans le cadre de l’e
´cole secondaire.
Resumen. El objetivo de este estudio fue caracterizar a muchachos Nandi no entrenados, de 16,6 an
˜os de
edad, procedentes de una ciudad (n=11) y de un a
´rea rural (n=19) del oeste de Kenya (altitud 2000
metros sobre el nivel del mar), con respecto a sus dimensiones corporales, consumo de oxı
´geno y nivel de
actividad fı
´sica. Los chicos de ciudad tuvieron una consumo medio ma
´ximo de oxı
´geno (Vo
2max
)de50
(45–60) ml kg min
1
, mientras que los de la aldea alcanzaron un valor de 55 (37–63) ml kgmin
1
(P <
0,01) en Vo
2max
. La economı
´a de carrera determinada como el coste de oxı
´geno a una velocidad de carrera
dada fue de 221 ml kg
1
km
1
(597 ml kg
0,75
km
1
), tanto para los chicos de ciudad como para los
rurales. El ı
´ndice de masa corporal (IMC) fue muy bajo tanto en los chicos de ciudad como en los de la
aldea (18,6 vs. 18,4 kg m
2
). El tiempo medio diario dedicado a trabajar en el campo y a hacer deporte
durante la educacio
´n secundaria fue significativamente mayor en los chicos del a
´rea rural que en los de la
ciudad (44,2 (0–128) vs. 1,3 (0–11) minutos, P<0,01 y 32,0 (11–72) vs. 12,8 (0–35) minutos, P<0,01,
respectivamente). Se encontro
´una correlacio
´n positiva entre el tiempo empleado diariamente en hacer
deporte y el Vo
2max
cuando se agrupaban los datos de los chicos urbanos y rurales (R=0,55, P<0,01). Se
concluye que las dimensiones corporales de los adolescentes Nandi de ciudad y de aldea se corresponden
con los resultados obtenidos en los corredores kenianos de elite, muy delgados y con las piernas relativa-
mente largas. Adema
´s, el Vo
2max
de los chicos rurales es mayor que el de los urbanos, lo que es debido,
probablemente, a un mayor nivel de actividad fı
´sica de los chicos rurales durante la educacio
´n secundaria.
Physical characteristics of Kenyan Nandi boys 173