ArticlePublisher preview available

Psychophysiology of Aggression, Psychopathy, and Conduct Problems: A Meta-Analysis

Psychological Bulletin
Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract and Figures

A meta-analysis of 95 studies was conducted to investigate the relations of heart rate (HR) and electrodermal activity (EDA) with aggression, psychopathy, and conduct problems. Analyses revealed a complex constellation of interactive effects, with a failure in some cases of autonomic patterns to generalize across antisocial spectrum behavior constructs. Low resting EDA and low task EDA were associated with psychopathy/sociopathy and conduct problems. However, EDA reactivity was positively associated with aggression and negatively associated with psychopathy/sociopathy. Low resting HR and high HR reactivity were associated with aggression and conduct problems. Physiology--behavior relations varied with age and stimulus valence in several cases. Empirical and clinical implications are discussed.
Psychophysiology of Aggression, Psychopathy, and Conduct Problems:
A Meta-Analysis
Michael F. Lorber
State University of New York at Stony Brook
A meta-analysis of 95 studies was conducted to investigate the relations of heart rate (HR) and
electrodermal activity (EDA) with aggression, psychopathy, and conduct problems. Analyses revealed a
complex constellation of interactive effects, with a failure in some cases of autonomic patterns to
generalize across antisocial spectrum behavior constructs. Low resting EDA and low task EDA were
associated with psychopathy/sociopathy and conduct problems. However, EDA reactivity was positively
associated with aggression and negatively associated with psychopathy/sociopathy. Low resting HR and
high HR reactivity were associated with aggression and conduct problems. Physiology–behavior rela-
tions varied with age and stimulus valence in several cases. Empirical and clinical implications are
discussed.
The physiological correlates of antisocial spectrum behavior—
including aggression, psychopathy, conduct problems, and antisocial
personality characteristics—have been the subject of a good deal of
theoretical and empirical attention over the past 45 years (see Scarpa
& Raine, 1997). Understanding possible links between autonomic
physiology and antisocial spectrum behavior may hold special prom-
ise for advancing our understanding of these highly costly behavior
patterns. Autonomic measures move beyond self-reports of psycho-
logical functioning and may be less prone to bias and measure-related
error. They may also be more sensitive indexes of the brain processes
that are ultimately thought to be responsible for the behavior (e.g.,
Fowles, 1980, 1988). Convincingly demonstrating links between an-
tisocial spectrum behavior and autonomic physiology might elucidate
relevant mechanisms and individual differences and potentially lead
to treatment innovations. This is especially important with regard to
antisocial spectrum behavior, because of its enormous cost to society
(e.g., Moffitt, Caspi, Harrington, & Milne, 2002) and its relative
resistance to treatment in many of its forms (e.g., Offord & Bennet,
1994; Richards, Casey, & Lucente, 2003), with the possible exception
of conduct problems in young children (e.g., Brestan & Eyberg,
1998).
Many different theories of antisocial spectrum behavior that in-
volve autonomic psychophysiology have been proposed (Berkowitz,
1994; Eysenck & Gudjonsson, 1989; Fowles, 1980, 1988; Gray,
1987; Hare, 1978a; Quay, 1965; Raine, 1993, 1997; Zillmann, 1994;
Zuckerman & Como, 1983), some with conflicting predictions (e.g.,
Quay, 1965, and Zillmann, 1994). Furthermore, a wide range of
experimental methods and populations have been employed and stud-
ied, respectively. Clear interpretation of the literature has proved
elusive in the face of a mixed pattern of results. In an attempt to clarify
these issues, the present meta-analytic review was designed to quan-
tify the aggregate associations of heart rate (HR) and electrodermal
activity (EDA) with aggression, psychopathy, conduct problems, and
antisocial personality characteristics and to investigate factors that
moderate these relations.
HR and EDA are variables of central interest in many theories
of physiology and antisocial spectrum behavior and have histori-
cally been the most popular measures of psychophysiological
response. Thus, the present analysis was limited to these two
measures. The heart is subject to influence from the sympathetic
(SNS) and parasympathetic (PNS) branches of the autonomic
nervous system, and it is subject to neuroendocrine influences as
well. Chronotropic (i.e., rate-related) cardiac effects are controlled
primarily by the PNS, whereas inotropic effects such as contractile
force and stroke volume are controlled primarily by the SNS. In
contrast, EDA is under exclusive control of the SNS (Blascovich
& Kelsey, 1990; Fowles, 1986). From a perspective dating back to
the seminal work of James and Cannon, HR and EDA are thought
to be tied to emotional responses, with increases reflecting general
emotional arousal, specific emotions, or both (reviewed in Lang,
1994). HR and EDA may also reflect the influence of motivational
systems that control behavior in response to internal and external
cues (e.g., Fowles, 1988; Gray, 1987).
The present meta-analysis focused on three classes of HR and
EDA measures: resting, task, and reactivity. Resting measures
reflect the assessment of autonomic activity in the absence of any
obvious external stimuli. HR and EDA in response to experimental
stimuli are frequently measured in raw form during such presen-
tations (task physiology) or expressed as a change from resting,
baseline, or prestimulus levels (physiological reactivity).
Problems With Interpretation of the Literature
Because of frequent nonreplications and theories that make
competing predictions, the literature on the psychophysiology of
antisocial spectrum behavior is often confusing and seemingly
contradictory. The major thesis of this meta-analytic review is that
these ambiguities are caused in part by two sources: heterogeneity
I would like to thank Theodore Beauchaine, K. Daniel O’Leary, Susan
G. O’Leary, Amy Smith Slep, and Paul Wortman for their helpful com-
ments on earlier versions of this article and Tamara Del Vecchio for her
coding assistance.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Michael
F. Lorber, Department of Psychology, State University of New York,
Stony Brook, NY 11794-2500. E-mail: michael.lorber@stonybrook.edu
Psychological Bulletin Copyright 2004 by the American Psychological Association
2004, Vol. 130, No. 4, 531–552 0033-2909/04/$12.00 DOI: 10.1037/0033-2909.130.4.531
531
This
document
is
copyrighted
by
the
American
Psychological
Association
or
one
of
its
allied
publishers.
This
article
is
intended
solely
for
the
personal
use
of
the
individual
user
and
is
not
to
be
disseminated
broadly.
... Variation in associations between ANS indicators and psychopathy is evident in meta-analyses (de Looff et al., 2021;Lorber, 2004;Portnoy & Farrington, 2015). For example, Lorber (2004) found resting heart rate (RHR) and heart rate reactivity (HRR) were not associated with psychopathy (RHR d = 0.06, p >.05; HRR d = 0.06, p >.05), while resting skin conductance (RSC) and skin conductance reactivity (SCR) were (RSC d = -0.30, ...
... Variation in associations between ANS indicators and psychopathy is evident in meta-analyses (de Looff et al., 2021;Lorber, 2004;Portnoy & Farrington, 2015). For example, Lorber (2004) found resting heart rate (RHR) and heart rate reactivity (HRR) were not associated with psychopathy (RHR d = 0.06, p >.05; HRR d = 0.06, p >.05), while resting skin conductance (RSC) and skin conductance reactivity (SCR) were (RSC d = -0.30, p <.05, SCR d = -0.31, ...
Article
Full-text available
Despite evidence that associations between autonomic nervous system (ANS) responsivity and psychopathic traits vary across stress task only a single study has systematically assessed cross-task differences in associations. To advance this limited literature the current study randomized subjects into either a noise blast (countdown) task or a social stressor speech task (SSST). Analyses tested associations between ANS (heart rate, skin conductance) and measures of psychopathic traits (Self-Report Psychopathy Scale-III (SRP-III), Inventory of Callous-Unemotional (ICU) traits, Levenson Self-Report Psychopathy Scale (LSRP), Sensation Seeking Scale– Form V (SSS-V)). Baseline skin conductance was negatively associated with Erratic Lifestyle (SRP-III) and SSS-V total scores. Heart rate during the SSST had a negative association with Callous Affect (SRP). During the countdown task there was a negative association between skin conductance in anticipation of signaled noise blasts and Interpersonal Manipulation (SRP), and a negative association between change in heart rate after noise blasts in unsignaled trials and Erratic Lifestyle (SRP) and Factor 2 Psychopathy (LSRP).
... This often includes elevated HR, reduced HRV, and elevated electrical conductance of the skin based on sweat gland activity (i.e., skin conductance levels; SCL) [51]. Chronic hyperarousal has been linked to a reduction in social-reciprocity and the emergence of maladaptive and aggressive behaviors, both towards oneself and others [53,54]. Yet, whereas some studies have suggested that alexithymia is associated with hyperarousal [55][56][57], others suggest that individuals with high levels of alexithymia show discrepancies between physiological responses and subjective self-reported experiences [58,59]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Although Ecological Momentary Assessment (EMA) and physiological measurements provide a valuable opportunity to evaluate therapeutic interventions in real time, no study has used this approach to assess Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) in autistic adults with high levels of emotion dysregulation (ED). Methods In this study, 26 autistic adults were evaluated before and after participating in a standard 5-month DBT program, using Ecological Momentary Assessment (EMA). The EMA included: (1) twelve evaluations per day over a 7-day period, measuring alexithymia, emotional states, subjective arousal and emotion control; (2) continuous physiological monitoring with a wristband to record heart-rate (HR), heart-rate variability (HRV) and skin conductance levels (SCL). Results Following DBT, no significant differences were found with respect to negative emotions and higher conflicting emotions, but increased rates of identified emotions, positive emotions and emotion control were found. Baseline autonomic responses remained unchanged, whereas subjective arousal was found to correlate positively with HRV. Overall, these results suggest that participants showed enhanced emotion awareness and emotion regulation capabilities following DBT. Conclusion Our study adds to previous research showing that DBT is efficient in treating ED in autistic adults, using real-time measurements of subjective and physiological markers collected through EMA. Specifically, alexithymia measures decreased post-DBT while positive emotions and emotion control increased. Randomized controlled trials should consider using these methods to improve the assessment of the impact of DBT in the daily life of autistic individuals with ED and/or suicidal behavior.
... Results of several cross-sectional studies, when comparing offenders and non-offenders, indicated a relationship between neurobiological measures and antisocial behavior. For instance, resting heart rate is arguably the best-replicated physiologic correlate of antisocial behaviour (Lorber, 2004;Ortiz & Raine, 2004). This link between the resting autonomic nervous system activity and antisocial behaviour was confirmed a while back even in adolescents. ...
Book
This book seeks to distinguish empirically-based knowledge from widespread misconceptions in the fields of legal and forensic psychology. Across ten chapters, leading scholars contribute different perspectives on their areas of expertise within the fields of legal and forensic psychology, providing a comprehensive overview of the historical context and defining characteristics of these two disciplines. The first section of the book is dedicated to legal psychology, exploring issues such as pseudoscience in lie detection, the use of polygraphs, and the reliability of eyewitness testimony and memory reports in legal settings. The second focuses on forensic psychology, addressing topics such as the relationship between criminal behavior and psychopathology, symptom validity assessment, risk assessment, and the treatment of forensic patients. As such, this vital book will serve as an excellent starting point for those seeking to educate themselves about these disciplines.
Preprint
Full-text available
Despite a wealth of research, the core features of psychopathy remain hotly debated. Using network analysis, an innovative and increasingly popular statistical tool, we mapped the network structure of psychopathy, as operationalized by the Psychopathy Checklist-Revised (PCL-R; Hare, 2003) in two large U.S. offender samples (nNIMH = 1559; nWisconsin = 3954), and one large Dutch forensic psychiatric sample (nTBS = 1937). Centrality indices were highly stable within each sample, and indicated that Callousness/lack of empathy was the most central PCL-R item in the two U.S. samples, which aligns with classic clinical descriptions and prototypicality studies of psychopathy. The similarities across the U.S. samples offer some support regarding generalizability, but there were also striking differences between the U.S. samples and the Dutch sample, wherein the latter Callousnesss/lack of empathy was also fairly central but Irresponsibility and Parasitic Lifestyle were even more central. The findings raise the important possibility that network-structures do not only reflect the structure of the constructs under study, but also the sample from which the data derive. The results further raise the possibility of cross-cultural differences in the phenotypic structure of psychopathy, PCL-R measurement variance, or both. Network analyses may help elucidate the core characteristics of psychopathological constructs, including psychopathy, as well as provide a new tool for assessing measurement invariance across cultures.
Chapter
From a team of leading experts comes a comprehensive, multidisciplinary examination of the most current research including the complex issue of violence and violent behavior. The handbook examines a range of theoretical, policy, and research issues and provides a comprehensive overview of aggressive and violent behavior. The breadth of coverage is impressive, ranging from research on biological factors related to violence and behavior-genetics to research on terrrorism and the impact of violence in different cultures. The authors examine violence from international cross-cultural perspectives, with chapters that examine both quantitative and qualitative research. They also look at violence at multiple levels: individual, family, neighborhood, cultural, and across multiple perspectives and systems, including treatment, justice, education, and public health.
Article
Numerous studies have discussed the connection between social exclusion and prosocial behaviour, yet the conclusions have been inconsistent. We conducted a three‐level meta‐analysis on 83 effect sizes derived from 53 studies ( N = 21,405). Overall, a significant yet weak negative correlation was found between social exclusion and prosocial behaviour ( r = −.10, 95% CI [−0.17, −0.04]). Moderator analysis revealed that individuals in collectivistic cultures may exhibit higher levels of prosocial behaviour following exclusion compared to those in individualistic cultures. The female proportion positively influenced the overall effect size. The type of prosocial behaviour was marginally significant, in that ‘other’ prosocial behaviour yielded the largest effect sizes. However, effects did not differ across age groups, between the inclusion condition and the neutral condition, or between experimental research and correlational research. Our results underscore the crucial roles of culture and gender in the relationship between social exclusion and prosocial behaviour.
Article
Full-text available
To assemble a calibrated set of compassion-eliciting visual stimuli, 60 clinically healthy Mexican volunteers (36 women, 24 men; M age = 27.5 yr., SD = 2.4) assessed 84 pictures selected from the International Affective Picture System catalogue using the dimensions of Valence, Arousal, and Dominance included in the Self-assessment Manikin scale and an additional dimension of Compassion. Pictures showing suffering in social contexts and expressions of sadness elicited similar responses of compassion. The highest compassion response was reported for pictures showing illness and pain. Men and women differed in the intensity but not the quality of the compassionate responses. Compassion included attributes of negative emotions such as displeasure. The quality of the emotional response was not different from that previously reported for samples in the USA, Spain, and Brazil. A set of 28 pictures was selected as high-compassion-evoking images and 28 as null-compassion controls suitable for studies designed to ascertain the neural substrates of this moral emotion.
Chapter
Recidivism, the tendency for individuals to reoffend after release from incarceration or forensic settings, impacts both the individuals themselves and society at large. Managing the risks associated with recidivism requires a thorough understanding of the factors contributing to it and implementing effective risk assessment protocols. It is of utmost significance to reliably conduct risk assessments, because without proper risk assessment, decisions regarding the reintegration of former prisoners and forensic patients into society can be fraught with uncertainty and, in the case of risk to (violent) recidivism, even potential danger to society. By systematically evaluating an individual’s risk factors, professionals can tailor interventions and support mechanisms to mitigate the likelihood of reoffending, ultimately fostering successful reintegration. In this chapter, we will provide a brief overview of the most widely used risk assessment tools for violent recidivism in adults and discuss the potential contribution of neuropsychological findings in this domain.
Article
Introduction Recent evidence suggests that autonomic nervous system functioning can reflect individual differences in sensitivity to the environment, which in turn moderates the effects of family context on psychopathic and antisocial behaviour. Although some preliminary research suggests that the coordination of the sympathetic (SNS) and parasympathetic (PNS) branches of the autonomic nervous system may reflect sensitivity to environmental influences, the majority of research to date has been limited in its focus on just one branch, and little is known about the effects of parental empathy on a child's psychopathic‐like traits. This study aimed to address this gap by examining if the SNS and PNS jointly moderate the prospective contribution of parental empathy to youth psychopathic‐like traits. Methods Male and female children ( n = 340; age = 8–10 years) from the community completed an emotion regulation task during which their skin conductance level (SCL) and respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA) activity were recorded. Parental cognitive, affective, and somatic empathy were reported by the caregivers. The child's psychopathic‐like traits were reported by the caregiver and the child and were reassessed 1 year later. Results Hierarchical regression indicated that after controlling for child sex, age, and concurrent CU traits, low affective empathy in parents predicted higher CU traits 1 year later in youths who exhibited reciprocal sympathetic activation (i.e., SNS activation along with PNS withdrawal), reflecting their enhanced sensitivity to the environment. No such effects were found for other psychopathic‐like traits. Conclusions Findings suggest that reciprocal SNS reactivity may be a biological indicator for sensitivity to environmental influence and highlight the importance of examining the interactions among multiple systems to better understand the aetiology of psychopathic traits.
Article
Full-text available
A significant gap in the psychopathy literature is the lack of studies comparing “successful,” nonconvicted psychopaths with “unsuccessful,” convicted psychopaths. This study tested the hypothesis that successful psychopaths show increased autonomic stress reactivity and better neuropsychological function compared with unsuccessful psychopaths. A total of 26 controls, 16 unsuccessful psychopaths, and 13 successful psychopaths were assessed on psychophysiological measures recorded during an emotional manipulation, the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test (WCST), Wechsler Memory Scale—Revised subtests, and childhood stressors. Compared with controls, unsuccessful psychopaths showed reduced cardiovascular stress reactivity. In contrast, successful psychopaths showed heightened reactivity, better WCST performance, and more parental absence than unsuccessful psychopaths and controls. The implications of these findings and the generalizability of existing psychopathy research are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
T. P. Beauchaine (2001) recently proposed a model of autonomic nervous system functioning that predicts divergent patterns of psychophysiological responding across disorders of disinhibition. This model was tested by comparing groups of male adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder plus conduct disorder (CD/ADHD) with controls while performing a repetitive motor task in which rewards were administered and removed across trials. Participants then watched a videotaped peer conflict. Electrodermal responding (EDR), cardiac pre-ejection period (PEP), and respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA) were monitored. Compared with controls, the ADHD and CD/ADHD participants exhibited reduced EDR. The CD/ADHD group was differentiated from the ADHD and control groups on PEP and from the control group on RSA. Findings are discussed in terms of the motivational and regulational systems indexed. Implications for understanding rates of comorbidity between CD and ADHD are considered.
Article
Full-text available
The present article reports on an attempt to import the concept of psychopathy at the childhood level. Childhood psychopathy was assessed in 430 boys ages 12 and 13 years by using caretaker reports on a translation of an adult psychopathy assessment instrument. A systematic construct validation approach revealed that childhood psychopathy fits into the nomological network surrounding adult psychopathy. Children with psychopathic personalities, like their adult counterparts, were serious and stable offenders, impulsive, and more prone to externalizing than internalizing disorders. Childhood psychopathy also provided incremental validity in predicting serious stable antisocial behavior in adolescence over and above other known predictors and one other classification approach. These results suggest that psychopathy has a childhood manifestation that can be measured reliably. Implications and future directions are outlined.
Article
Full-text available
Boys (average age = 12.1 years) from families with an extensive history of paternal alcoholism differed from controls of similar age and IQ on measures of cognitive function, cardiovascular reactivity, and parent-rated conduct problems. High-risk boys performed most poorly on neuropsychological tests of frontal lobe function. According to tests of temporal organization and conditional-associate learning, control over working memory was the frontal subfunction primarily affected. A mental arithmetic task also elicited greater heart rate increases and peripheral vasoconstriction among high-risk boys than among controls. After controlling for group status, significant correlations remained between frontal lobe test scores and disruptive behavior and between cardiovascular hyperreactivity and anxiety levels. The possible contribution of these findings to alcohol abuse was discussed.
Article
Full-text available
James–Lange theory influenced a century of emotion research. This article traces the theory's origins in philosophical psychology, considers differences in the thinking of James and Lange, and assesses Cannon's early critique and the resulting debate. Research is reviewed evaluating physiological patterns in emotion, the discordance of reported feelings and visceral reactivity, and the role of generalized arousal. NeoJamesian theories of attribution and appraisal—and alternative views based on dynamic psychology—are critically examined. A conception of emotion is presented, on the basis of developments unknown to James in conditioning theory, information processing, and neuroscience. Computational models of mentation are discussed, and implications are drawn for the classical debate on cognition and emotion. In concluding, new paths for emotion research are outlined and homage paid to the inspiration of William James.
Article
Full-text available
One hundred men received one of two levels of mitigating circumstance information either before or after being insulted or not insulted by a co-worker. Participants were then provided with an opportunity ostensibly to deliver aversive noise to the co-worker under either high or low social censure conditions. Physiological data and self-report measures revealed that participants who learned of mitigating circumstance information before being provoked exhibited smaller increases in physiological arousal and reported less annoyance than did those who learned of mitigating circumstance information after insult. Aggression data showed that angered participants evaluated their provoker more favorably and retaliated less when they learned of mitigation before rather than after being insulted. These findings supported attribution theory assumptions that mitigating circumstance information known before the provoking incident influences the individual's interpretation of harm, thereby reducing anger and the instigation to aggression. The reduced impact of information on aggression that is acquired after provocation may reflect the provoked individual's shift of attention from cues surrounding harm to a consideration of inhibitory factors for aggression.
Article
Full-text available
Poorly socialized young adult males have been found to give smaller skin conductance responses (SCRs) to both physical and certain social (i.e., deception) stressors than their more highly socialized counterparts. This study with 30 male undergraduates examined whether these differences are dependent on S's awareness that his physiological responses are being recorded. 15 Ss attempted to deceive a polygraph examiner both before (unaware) and during (aware) a polygraph test. The 15 other Ss made truthful denials to the examiner's questions. All Ss were also asked biographical questions as part of an interview in the unaware condition. Under both aware and unaware conditions, high-socialization (Socialization scale of the California Psychological Inventory) Ss gave larger SCRs when deceiving than did low-socialization Ss. They also gave larger SCRs than low-socialization Ss when disclosing significant personal information but did not differ electrodermally when answering routine information questions. Awareness of physiological monitoring apparently does not mediate the finding that highly socialized Ss are markedly aroused and low socialization Ss little aroused by stress. (10 ref)
Article
Full-text available
In an attempt to replicate the J. M. Gottman et al. (1995) batterer typology, 58 men who had engaged in moderate-to-severe marital violence in the past year were studied. The sample was split into Gottman et al.'s Type 1 men (i.e., whose heart rates decreased, from baseline, during a marital conflict task) and Type 2 men (i.e., whose heart rates increased). The groups did not differ in the manner predicted on measures of marital violence, antisocial or aggressive-sadistic personality, drug dependence, criminality, general violence, childhood exposure to interparental violence, behavior during marital interactions, or relationship stability. Contrary to expectations, wives of Type 1 men rated their husband as more jealous and angry and reported more marital distress. In the only finding consistent with Gottman et al., Type 2 men scored higher on a measure of dependent personality. Implications for future research are discussed.