Work Group Diversity and Group Performance: An Integrative Model and Research Agenda

Rotterdam School of Management, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Journal of Applied Psychology (Impact Factor: 4.31). 01/2005; 89(6):1008-22. DOI: 10.1037/0021-9010.89.6.1008
Source: PubMed


Research on the relationship between work group diversity and performance has yielded inconsistent results. To address this problem, the authors propose the categorization-elaboration model (CEM), which reconceptualizes and integrates information/decision making and social categorization perspectives on work-group diversity and performance. The CEM incorporates mediator and moderator variables that typically have been ignored in diversity research and incorporates the view that information/decision making and social categorization processes interact such that intergroup biases flowing from social categorization disrupt the elaboration (in-depth processing) of task-relevant information and perspectives. In addition, the authors propose that attempts to link the positive and negative effects of diversity to specific types of diversity should be abandoned in favor of the assumption that all dimensions of diversity may have positive as well as negative effects. The ways in which these propositions may set the agenda for future research in diversity are discussed.

Download full-text


Available from: Astrid C. Homan
  • Source
    • "HOMAN, VAN KLEEF, SANCHEZ-BURKS COGNITION AND EMOTION, 2016, 30 (1)This finding is consistent with the theoretical idea that emotional displays become increasingly relevant in more ambiguous social situations in which interactions are more difficult to predict (VanKleef et al., 2010), as is the case in teams consisting of members with different ethnic backgrounds (vanKnippenberg et al., 2004). In Study 2, we tested a second moderator that should influence the degree to which team members' emotional displays are used to inform inferences about the team's interaction: the degree to which the emotions displayed by team members are likely to reflect the team's experience together. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Emotions are inherent to team life, yet it is unclear how observers use team members’ emotional expressions to make sense of team processes. Drawing on Emotions as Social Information theory, we propose that observers use team members’ emotional displays as a source of information to predict the team’s trajectory. We argue and show that displays of sadness elicit more pessimistic inferences regarding team dynamics (e.g., trust, satisfaction, team effectiveness, conflict) compared to displays of happiness. Moreover, we find that this effect is strengthened when the future interaction between the team members is more ambiguous (i.e., under ethnic dissimilarity; Study 1) and when emotional displays can be clearly linked to the team members’ collective experience (Study 2). These studies shed light on when and how people use others’ emotional expressions to form impressions of teams.
    Full-text · Article · Jan 2016 · Cognition and Emotion
  • Source
    • "Literature on heterogeneity theorizes positive effects from an information/decision-making perspective [16]. The underlying value-in-heterogeneity hypothesis claims that greater heterogeneity may lead to more innovative and creative solutions, enhanced responsiveness and greater flexibility for dynamic requirement adjustments [17]. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: While new organizational offerings, such as product-service systems (PSS), are evolving from adapted strategic decisions, the actors involved in the dynamic implementation of the product-service work system (PSWS) originate from different organizational backgrounds, contribute from various fields of expertise and are familiarized with different working cultures. This built-in heterogeneity is rooted in three distinct compositional sources of the PSWS and it can be classified into a separation, a variety and a disparity type. It gives floor to the successful co-creation of value but also contains numerous challenges as it demands the integration of product and service dominated logics within a heterogeneous, yet collaborative problem-solving working context. This paper aims at eliciting a set of individual competencies that helps workers cope with the demands of PSWS with specific interest in positive and negative effects of different types of built-in heterogeneity.Data presented result from a survey among PSS engineers across branches and organizational entities that were asked to answer a standardized questionnaire in 2012-2013 about competencies as behavioral ad-hoc regulations for unstandardized problem-solving environments. An explorative factor analysis results in a three-dimensional configuration: a) a set of coordinative practices is bundled for improved problem-solving mainly based on positive variety utilization,b) a set of optimistic information filtering activities is bundled to reduce complexity and to benefit from separation and variety, c) a set of reflective in-depth-learning practices supports a high aim at improving and builds on the utilization of variety and separation effects. Based on this configuration positive effects of PSWS built-in heterogeneity can be maximized while negative effects are minimized.
    Full-text · Article · Dec 2015
    • "Diversity management has become a central matter for contemporary social and organizational studies (Harrison and Klein 2007; Jackson, Joshi, and Erhardt 2003; Nielsen and Nielsen 2013; Pieterse, Knippenberg, and Dierendonck 2013; van Knippenberg, De Dreu, and Homan 2004). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The aim of the article is to explore the degree of diversity management implementation in Poland and its relationships with trust in company and its managers and trust among co-workers. To verify hypotheses, we conducted a study involving 335 corporate workers and managers. They were asked to fill in a questionnaire referring to several aspects of diversity management and level of trust in the company at which they work. To explore the relationships between tested variables we used Spearman’s Rho correlation indicator with prior testing of the assumption of normality of data distribution. It turned out that the level of diversity management in participating companies is not high. Its level varies depending on the field in which the given company manages diversity (i.e., age, gender, family status, dis/ability, national and ethnical background, culture, race, religion, etc.). We found significant, positive correlations between the level of diversity management implementation and trust in company, managers, and between co-workers. The research confirmed that diversity management is an important factor related to the building of organizational trust.
    No preview · Article · Dec 2015 · International Journal of Organizational Diversity
Show more