Critical Periods of Suicide Risk in Huntington’s Disease

Department of Psychology, University of Iowa, Roy J. and Lucille A. Carver College of Medicine, 1-305 Medical Education Bldg., Iowa City, IA 52241-1000, USA.
American Journal of Psychiatry (Impact Factor: 12.3). 05/2005; 162(4):725-31. DOI: 10.1176/appi.ajp.162.4.725
Source: PubMed


Contrary to popular belief, receiving a diagnosis of a devastating fatal disease does not exacerbate, and may even alleviate, the risk of suicide. Suicidal ideation was examined in 4,171 individuals in the Huntington Study Group database. Participants were grouped according to a standardized neurological examination from 0 (i.e., normal examination) to 3 (definite Huntington's disease). Patients with an unequivocal diagnosis of Huntington's disease were further divided by stage of disease, from stage 1 (early) to stage 5 (end stage). Findings showed that the frequency of suicidal ideation doubled from 9.1% in at-risk persons with a normal neurological examination to 19.8% in at-risk persons with soft neurological signs and increased to 23.5% in persons with "possible Huntington's disease." In persons with a diagnosis of Huntington's disease, 16.7% had suicidal ideation in stage 1, and 21.6% had suicidal ideation in stage 2, whereas the proportion of Huntington's disease patients with suicidal ideation diminished thereafter. Findings suggest two critical periods for increased risk of suicide in Huntington's disease. The first critical period is immediately before receiving a formal diagnosis of Huntington's disease, and the second is in stage 2 of the disease, when independence diminishes. Although the underlying mechanisms of suicidal ideation in Huntington's disease are poorly understood, it is critical for health care providers to be aware of periods during which patients may be at an increased risk.

Download full-text


Available from: Karin Hoth, Sep 23, 2014
    • "However, the majority of this study's participants did not discuss counseling. The absence of counseling from participant accounts is perhaps most poignant when considering Phyllis' experiences, which appear to reflect many features in the HD research (e.g., Paulsen et al., 2005a; Robins-Wahlin et al., 2000). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Health professionals, researchers, and philosophers have debated extensively about suicide. Some believe suicides result from mental pathology, whereas others argue that individuals are capable of rational suicide. This debate is particularly poignant within illness communities, where individuals may be suffering from chronic and incurable conditions. This article engages with these issues by presenting the accounts of 20 individuals with Huntington disease (HD), a fatal degenerative condition, and 10 informal caregivers (e.g., spouses). Suicide is a leading cause of death amongst people with HD, with an incidence rate many times higher than the general population. In contrast to the majority of the academic literature on HD suicidality, study participants did not connect suicide with mental pathology. Instead, they perceived suicide as a response to the realities of living with HD, such as prolonged physiological degeneration and the need for long-term intensive health care. These findings are subsequently discussed in relation to the rational-pathological suicide binary.
    No preview · Article · Dec 2012 · OMEGA--Journal of Death and Dying
  • Source
    • "Psychological symptoms also are common in persons who are presymptomatic for HD, regardless of their knowledge of gene status. A study of over 4000 persons with HD indicates that high levels of suicidal ideation are found in persons at-risk for the disease, possibly due to uncertainty about disease status and potential future decline (Paulsen et al., 2005a). Longitudinal investigation of frontal executive behaviors in HD groups suggests that apathy, disinhibition, and executive dysfunction are more prevalent in presymptomatic persons than in at-risk but gene negative persons and are associated with worsening motor and cognitive dysfunction (Duff et al., 2010). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In order to broaden knowledge of psychological functioning in Huntington's disease (HD), participants at-risk, prodromal, and symptomatic for HD reported on stress, negative affect, and depressive symptoms as well as life satisfaction, positive affect, and quality of life. Persons with symptomatic HD reported fewer psychological assets and greater stress, depressive symptoms, and negative affect than other groups. Positive affect in symptomatic persons did not significantly differ from other groups, and was higher in persons at-risk for HD than in controls. Greater attention to psychological assets in HD is warranted, particularly positive affect which may not decline early in the disease.
    Full-text · Article · May 2012 · Journal of Health Psychology
  • Source
    • "Although no significant difference in neuropsychological functioning was found between mutation positive and mutation negative asymptomatic carriers prior to testing [Campodonico et al., 1996], after receiving results, those who tested positive had increased risk of major depressive disorders compared to both the general population and to those who tested negative [Codori et al., 2004]. Supporting studies suggest that the incidence of suicide is highest in the prediagnostic phase, decreases for those who have recently been diagnosed, and increases again in later stages of the illness when independence diminishes [Paulsen et al., 2005; Walker, 2007]. Those who tested negative a year after receiving the test result seemed to be somewhat less distressed than they were before test disclosure, but they had not yet developed more optimistic expectations for the future [Tibben, 2007]. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: During the last decade, the field of human genome research has gone through a phase of rapid discovery that has provided scientists and physicians with a wide variety of research tools that are applicable to important medical issues. We describe a true case of familial Huntington disease (HD) in which we modified personal details to protect patient's privacy, where the proband at risk preferred not to know his disease status but wanted to know the status in his unborn child. Once we found the father to be negative, the case raised an important ethical question regarding the management of this as well as future pregnancies. This article discusses the arguments for and against the right not to know of one's carrier status, as well as professional obligations in the context of withholding unwanted information that may have direct implications not only for the patient himself but also for other family members. HD has served as a model for many other adult onset genetic diseases in terms of carrier testing guidelines. Hence, we feel it is time to revisit the issue of prenatal testing for HD and consider updating the current recommendations regarding the patient's right to "genetic ignorance", or the right not to know genetic information.
    Full-text · Article · Jul 2010 · American Journal of Medical Genetics Part A
Show more