No full-text available
To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.
Should all patients who attempt suicide be treated? A reponse to Savulescu
Should all patients who attempt suicide be treated? In the October issue of The Review, Savulescu argues that competent patients who attempt suicide and who refuse treatment should not have such treatment forced upon them [1]. He maintains that there is no ethical distinction to be made between a patient with a longstanding life threatening illness who refuses treatment and a patient who has attempted suicide and refuses treatment. If we are prepared to allow one group of patients to refuse treatment, we must be prepared to allow the other to refuse as well.
Acetaminophen (paracetamol in British literature) is a metabolite of phenacetin which has become increasingly popular as a substitute for salicylates.1 The popularity of acetaminophen has been encouraged by the medical profession because it is allegedly safer than aspirin.2 However, experience in Britain indicates that acute acetaminophen overdosage is both common and significantly more toxic than of salicylates.3-7 Although it is widely used in the United States, only one report describing a single American patient has appeared in the literature.8 This is a puzzling situation. It is axiomatic that if you do not look for something you will not diagnose it. This may provide the answer as there is apparently a general lack of knowledge in the United States concerning the toxicity of acetaminophen. Indeed, one of us (B.H.R.) contacted nine American University poison services in the spring of 1973 and discovered that none had clinical experience or analytical methods in operation. During the past year, however, with a high index of suspicion in Denver, 156 ingestions with four fatalities have been recorded.
Because of the nonspecific initial features of acute overdosage, the lack of coma, the delay in onset of jaundice and the rapid fall in detectable plasma levels of acetaminophen, the cause-and-effect relationship may be missed in even a floridly ill or dying patient. Hepatoxicity is the most remarkable feature and the question must be raised as to how many cases of "jaundice of unknown etiology" are actually due to this drug.
This review is intended to provide an understanding of the current knowledge of this drug. It should be noted that although toxicity and fatalities have occurred in the adolescent age group, only one death in younger children has been recorded.
Decision making for incompetent elderly people is an increasingly serious issue for American society. The decision-making processes we choose will reflect choices among a number of ethical principles--those specifying the purpose of substituted judgment, those guiding the surrogate decision maker, and those used in choosing the surrogate--and depends as well on the way we construe the concept of decision-making competence.