Worries About Modernity Predict Symptom Complaints After Environmental Pesticide Spraying

Philipps University of Marburg, Marburg, Hesse, Germany
Psychosomatic Medicine (Impact Factor: 3.47). 09/2005; 67(5):778-82. DOI: 10.1097/01.psy.0000181277.48575.a4
Source: PubMed


Concerns about environmental and technological changes affecting health have been shown to be associated with symptom reports in cross-sectional studies. We aimed to investigate how worries about modernity affecting health, negative affectivity, and prior symptom complaints influence health complaints after environmental spraying in a prospective study.
Two hundred ninety-two residents of West Auckland completed questionnaires measuring recent symptoms, negative affect, and concerns about the effects of modernity on health before aerial spraying of their neighborhood with Foray 48B. After spraying, 181 residents (62%) returned a follow-up questionnaire measuring symptoms, spray-avoidance behavior, and the perceived effect of the spray program on health.
The number of symptoms reported after the spray was most closely related to the number of symptoms reported at baseline (beta = 0.40, p = .0001). Higher levels of modern health worries (beta = 0.23, p = .001) and baseline symptoms (beta = 0.17, p < .05) were associated with a higher number of symptoms being attributed to the spray program. Modern health worries also predicted avoidance behavior during the spraying times (beta = 0.32, p = .001) and the belief that the health of participants and the health of their children and pets was affected by the spray (all p < .01).
Worries about aspects of modern life affecting health can strongly influence the attribution of symptoms and beliefs about health effects after environmental incidents.

Download full-text


Available from: Rob Horne
    • "Other studies focus more on the role of personality related variables in reporting symptoms related to the environment. Previous research has for instance suggested negative oriented personality traits (Taylor et al., 2013), high levels of stress (Eek et al., 2010), negative affect (Skovbjerg et al., 2015) and concern about environmental exposures (Petrie et al., 2005) as risk factors for reporting health complaints related to the environment. Our study adds to this body of research that a potential environmental risk event (i.e. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Background: Experimental studies suggest that nocebo responses might occur after exposure to equipment emitting electromagnetic fields such as high voltage power lines (HVPLs) or mobile phone base stations. Objectives: The present study investigates to what extent health responses to a new HVPL can be explained by beliefs of residents regarding the health effects of HVPLs. Methods: We used a quasi-experimental prospective field study design with two pretests during the construction of a new HVPL, and two posttests after it has been put into operation. Residents living near (0-300m, n=229; 300-500m, n=489) and farther away (500-2000m, n=536) filled out questionnaires about their health and their beliefs about the negative health effects of power lines. Longitudinal mediation models were applied to investigate to what extent these beliefs could explain a change in reported symptoms after the new line was put into operation. Results: Significant (p<.01) indirect effects were found for proximity on the increase in reported cognitive (R(2)=0.41) and somatic (R(2)=0.79) symptoms after the power line was put into operation through an increase in the belief that power lines causes health effects. The direct effects of proximity on an increase in reported symptoms were not significant. Conclusions: Our findings suggest that increases in reported health complaints after a new HVPL has been put into operation can be explained by nocebo mechanisms. Future field studies are needed to know whether our findings extend to other environmental health issues in a community.
    No preview · Article · Feb 2016 · Science of The Total Environment
  • Source
    • "In particular, negative oriented personality (NOP) traits such as neuroticism, trait anxiety or trait negative affect are related to symptom reporting [60]. However, evidence of the relationship of these traits with environmental risk perception [61-64] or symptom attribution to environmental factors [65-67] is mixed. NOP traits might also affect health by moderating nocebo effects. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: New high-voltage power transmission lines will be introduced due to increasing demand for reliable and renewable energy supplies. Some residents associate non-specific health complaints with exposure to electromagnetic fields from nearby power lines. This study protocol describes the design and rationale of a prospective study investigating whether the introduction of a new power line triggers health responses in residents living nearby. Methods/design: The study is designed as a quasi-experimental field study with two pretests during the construction of a new power line route, and two posttests after it has been put into operation. Key outcomes are self-reported non-specific somatic and cognitive health complaints, and attribution of these health complaints to a power line. The main determinant is proximity to the new power line route. One member of every household (N = 2379) residing in close proximity (0-500 meters) to the overhead parts of a new power line route in the Netherlands is invited to participate, as well as a sample of household members (N = 2382) residing farther away (500-2000 meters). Multilevel analysis will be employed to test whether an increase in key outcome measures is related to proximity to the line. Longitudinal structural equation models will be applied to test to what extent health responses are mediated by psychosocial health mechanisms and moderated by negative oriented personality traits. This is the first study to investigate health responses to a new power line route in a prospective manner. The results will provide theoretical insight into psychosocial mechanisms operating during the introduction of an environmental health risk, and may offer suggestions to policymakers and other stakeholders for minimizing adverse health responses when introducing new high-voltage power lines.
    Full-text · Article · Mar 2014 · BMC Public Health
  • Source
    • "Another important topic for further study is the influence of remote environmental conditions on personal experiences of stress, coping, and psychological restoration. Even among people living in relatively stable and desirable places, worries about remote and unseen environmental threats such as air pollution, nuclear contamination, tainted food, extreme weather events, random violence, and terrorist attacks are engendering chronic stress and feelings of insecurity (Baum & Fleming, 1993; Lee & Farrall, 2008; McDonald, 2008; Petrie et al., 2005; Stafford et al., 2007; Vaughan, 1993; Wandersman & Hallman, 1993). Increasing worries about remote environmental threats may result in a syndrome of topophobia, or chronic fear associated with particular places (González, 2005; Hipp, 2006)—for instance, scenic coastal areas that have been devastated by hurricanes or tsunamis and downtown areas or transportation depots that have been targeted by terrorists. "

    Full-text · Dataset · Jun 2013
Show more