A Pilot Survey of Patient-Initiated Assaults on Medical Students During Clinical Clerkship

Department of Anesthesia, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Academic Psychiatry (Impact Factor: 0.81). 09/2005; 29(4):350-3. DOI: 10.1176/appi.ap.29.4.350
Source: PubMed


To assess the incidents of patient-initiated assault (PIA) against clinical clerks during the first six months of clinical clerkship. To characterise the assaults with respect to service, location, clerk gender, patient gender. To examine the students' perceptions of the reporting process for PIA.
A brief email survey was sent to all third year medical students after six months of clinical clerkship experience. Students were asked to describe assault experiences including: location, service, patient gender and injuries sustained.
Six students reported experiencing physical assault in the first six months of clerkship. Assaults occurred on psychiatry (4) and internal medicine (2) services. Two of the assaults took place during consultations in the emergency department. All students reported having pre-clerkship training in management of violent situations. No students were aware of PIA reporting protocols for their hospital.
Clinical clerks are at risk of PIA during their training. Students experiencing PIA feel that current levels of pre-clerkship training do not adequately inform them of the resources available after such an incident. These findings underline the need for PIA programs in the undergraduate curriculum including preclerkship training and clear, institution-wide reporting guidelines.

8 Reads
  • Source
    • "A 1993 study examining sexual harassment among female physicians in Ontario revealed that 77% of the respondents indicated that they had been sexually harassed at least once in their careers [18] [19]. There are reports of physical abuse toward physicians in training [20], and a family physician from Alberta went public with her experience of being stalked by a patient [21]. Many countries are developing policies to protect physicians from violent patients [22] [23] [24] [25], but Canada does not have a national policy. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Objective. The goal of this study was to examine the monthly incidence rates of abusive encounters for family physicians in Canada. Methods. A 7-page cross-sectional survey. Results. Of the entire study sample (N = 720), 29% of the physicians reported having experienced an abusive event in the last month by a patient or patient family member. Abusive incidents were classified as minor, major, or severe. Of the physician participants who reported having been abused, all reported having experienced a minor event, 26% a major, and 8% a severe event. Of the physicians who experienced an abusive event, 55% were not aware of any policies to protect them, 76% did not seek help, and 64% did not report the abusive event. Conclusion. Family physicians are subjected to significant amounts of abuse in their day-to-day practices. Few physicians are aware of workplace policies that could protect them, and fewer report abusive encounters. Physicians would benefit from increased awareness of institutional policies that can protect them against abusive patients and their families and from the development of a national policy.
    Full-text · Article · Nov 2010

  • No preview · Article · Sep 2005 · Academic Psychiatry
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Anger is a "syndrome" of thoughts, feelings and physiologic reactions. Behavioral responses to anger are influenced by multiple contextual factors. Patients and family members may express anger in response to their own experiences of illness, the healthcare system, or the physician-patient/family relationship. Anger may evoke a variety of clinician responses that while understandable, inadvertently escalate patient and family anger. Clinicians who cultivate personal awareness, practice mindful self-monitoring during their interactions, explore the differential diagnosis of anger, demonstrate specific communication skills, set clear boundaries and seek personal support can overcome the challenges of these difficult conversations, and begin to restore trust in the physician-patient/ family relationship.
    No preview · Article · Feb 2007 · Southern Medical Journal
Show more